One problem I see is that Tommy's greed exacerbates Arthur's problems with additional stress. Arthur from the beginning liked to play things safe and live relatively comfortably in the corner the Shelby family established for themselves. He never wanted to rock the boat with Billy Kimber. But ass far as redemption, the rule is that you can't change as a person while doing the same things with the same people. There's a reason that people that quit drinking gradually lose friendships with old drinking buddies. With crime, you have to make a clear break. Even just hanging around your old crew will suck you back in, a point presented in films like Carlito's Way.
Could you do a video on john shelby? He was such an interesting character, he had the capacity of violence Thomas had but it seemed to not effect him at all.
The quality of content and editing is professional and maybe more than that. I can only imagine the pains you took for it . Anyway sublime work brother
These kind of content is 1 of the best i've ever seen, really interesting! It would be nice to do these for others famous char from the like of scarface, goodfellas, donnie brasco, game of thrones, or villains from movies. Keep up the great work!
I just started this video and I like it already. I think the difficulty of arthurs redemption is that he has to, in many ways be a killer regardless so how much can he change from a guy with ptsd that actually kind of enjoys it to the head of a gang that still has to kill.
real talk, you are the best at analyzing these characters of movies on all youtube. Whatever you changed for this video, keep it like that, because this is your best one yet
you know i surprisingly never saw arthur as an evil psychotic man in the earlier seasons even when he did all this fucked up stuff, and it took you straightly saying how he is for me to actually acknowledge him good stuff!
Watched a couple of your videos, great obviously but I didn't really look at the channel but after this one I saw the previous ones I watched and wondered how I wasn't subscribed yet
Tommy actually does have animalistic tendencies and severe PTSD. The thing about him is, he has extreme self control and has found that if he keeps moving, he can keep it down. That’s why when he went on holidays, he started relieving the war with barely any stimuli. We see that he’s also very much prone to violence, when he kills that Irishman in the Garrison and Moss says he looks like he was attacked by a wild animal (Tommy kept going well after the man died) John seems to have the least PTSD of all, especially after his marriage, but he’s also impulsive, and prone to violence.
Congratulations to you, J. Wisdom, for making a video topic, and analysis, about Arthur Shelby, my good friend! Joe Anderson plays Arthur Shelby to an absolute perfection. By the way, do you think that you can do a video topic, and analysis of Raylan Givens from justified?
Dope video man. Arthur most definently had his demons. The editing of this video is top notch. Most definently gonna take some tips. Great video my boy
There are a few things in the video that don't reflect what I remember from the show. I can't remember Tommy needing to use a great deal of violence to maintain his illegal bookies business (at least not on the scale of the show) he could have just had a nice business and stayed where he was. It's not until he expands that there is a need for greater violence. Arthur does fire the machine gun but to me, this seems like an effective use of violence he's under attack he fires and then he's not under attack (they seem to have run off from the lack of return fire) this would be a bonus reason for Johns problem is capacity for violence (probably more so than Tommy) has an advantage for him to fulfill his role and why another character describes him as an attack dog. Also, Tommy doesn't force the business supplying Arthur with drugs to close down he only forces them to stop the drug's side of their business but still allows them to sell things (if I remember correctly it's also a cafe.
Arthur shelby is a typical borderline personality. I was diagnosed with BPD 6 years ago ( after 2 years of therapy have been told that I dont meet the criteria to be diagnosed anymore 🎉), let me try give my reasoning about this as follows.. 1) his emotions are erratic and can be set off over slights to his character. 2) He tries to kill himself and constantly suffers with depressive episode, psycopaths have so much love for themselves they rarely try to off themselves. 3) His affinity to violent impulsivity and constant need to numb himself with substance abuse, and it all comes from a place of pain. For example the scene where he killed the boy is a classic Borderline rage moment, as he feels remorse straight away. There is a massive overlap between PTSD and BPD and he might experience both. 4) His mother actually killed herself which is a trauma that he or tommy never fully acknowledged or dealt with. 5) Tommy and John both exhibit Anti social tendancies, which are cold and impulsive, but where that differs from Arthur is that he is in Constant pain. The emotional centre of the brain in borderlines is about 3 times the size of the average population, so when something hurts it hurts 3 times as much. This is different from psycopathy because they actually have an emotional centre which is about half as much as the average population. 6) he shows signs when with Linda that he was a changed man and definitely has the capability of recovery, however his evil Borderline side comes out and ruins that. Without treatment this condition is actually more common among prisoners these days because they can't keep their emotions under control. Still, amazing video and incredible work fella! Really informative and good to deep dive into the struggles of strong male characters in TV
War is not the only ptsd you can get from the military .....you dont need a war to have to fight fires, hydralic bursts high pressure air bursts and to see people die from it ....to fight but not be able to save and to be saved in kind ....you dont need war in the military to be put under enormous stress ...sleep deprivation and constant drills and being held to the highest standards can do that to you ....just making a point that will go over most peoples heads
0:38 it was life or death there and he didn't have a weapon. He was defending himself. More or less, Arthur is a sociopath, not a psychopath because a psychopath doesn't have any emotions or loyality to no one. If he was a psychopath he could've try to kill Tommy to take his place in the gang and familly but we found out he defended his familly in his teenage years by fighting cops who raided them with a pitchfork, I think. A psychopath is born, a sociopath is made.
Can we all just take a moment to sincerily appreciate how well Paul Andersen has actually portrayed the character of Arthur Shelby? Simply amazing.
One problem I see is that Tommy's greed exacerbates Arthur's problems with additional stress. Arthur from the beginning liked to play things safe and live relatively comfortably in the corner the Shelby family established for themselves. He never wanted to rock the boat with Billy Kimber.
But ass far as redemption, the rule is that you can't change as a person while doing the same things with the same people. There's a reason that people that quit drinking gradually lose friendships with old drinking buddies. With crime, you have to make a clear break. Even just hanging around your old crew will suck you back in, a point presented in films like Carlito's Way.
Could you do a video on john shelby? He was such an interesting character, he had the capacity of violence Thomas had but it seemed to not effect him at all.
Interesting, I'll consider him for the future thank you🤝
And Thomas Shelby to
He's done it again, HE DOES NOT MISS!
Thank you bro, I always appreciate the support 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@JWisdom It's all my pleasure man, you're a brother🙏
The quality of content and editing is professional and maybe more than that. I can only imagine the pains you took for it . Anyway sublime work brother
Thank you brother 🙏much appreciated. Editing was definitely a pain at times but I try to enjoy it as much as I can🤝
The actor did an amazing job. Arthur was convincingly unhinged
These kind of content is 1 of the best i've ever seen, really interesting! It would be nice to do these for others famous char from the like of scarface, goodfellas, donnie brasco, game of thrones, or villains from movies. Keep up the great work!
Thanks for the ideas🙏I appreciate it
I'm absolutely blown away by your compassionate and well thought out insights into your character analyses. Seriously, first class.
Bro, I call a spade a spade, and you are one, analysing characters like this is just spectacular..... You're intelligent bro🙌
Thank you so much bro🙏🏼
Damn, you're underrated ngl...Why is this better than a Netflix Documentary?
Ah thank you 🙏I try my best
Just come across your channel about 4 videos deep. Great content man gonna be good seeing u grow!
I just started this video and I like it already. I think the difficulty of arthurs redemption is that he has to, in many ways be a killer regardless so how much can he change from a guy with ptsd that actually kind of enjoys it to the head of a gang that still has to kill.
This is a great series your putting together!
This is incredibly well made. Bravo.
Thank you 🙏🏼
These videos are so impressive bro, you’re actually really underrated!🔥
Thank you🙏🏼🙏🏼
These videos are awesome.. you should do one on Jax Teller from SOA
Amazing video!! Great amount of quality work went into it. Subscribed
Thank you brother 🙏🏼🙏🏼
The editing is on an other level, wel done!!
Thank you bro 🙏🏼
How do you only have 30k, with the quality of the video and length of videos I fully thought you had a couple mil. Keep it up
real talk, you are the best at analyzing these characters of movies on all youtube. Whatever you changed for this video, keep it like that, because this is your best one yet
Thank you brother 🙏will do
Bru wtf
I stubbled onto banger of a video
110% coming back again to this chanel
Great video cuz 👌👌👌👏
Thank you bro glad you could enjoy 🙏🏼
you know i surprisingly never saw arthur as an evil psychotic man in the earlier seasons even when he did all this fucked up stuff, and it took you straightly saying how he is for me to actually acknowledge him
good stuff!
This video is extremely well made! Left very satisfied
i love this one bro! coming like Netflix documentary style : keep it up🖤
Much love bro🙏🏼🙏🏼
Another banger brother 🐐
Appreciate it brother 🙏
Yes broo! Been waiting for this one 💪🏽🖤
Hope you enjoyed bro🙏🏼
I shed tears when his father betrayed him again and he attempted suicide
Watched a couple of your videos, great obviously but I didn't really look at the channel but after this one I saw the previous ones I watched and wondered how I wasn't subscribed yet
Thank you bro, I hope you stay for more🤝
Good job, Amazing amazing work🙌💘
Thank you 🙌
Hey, I'm new here. Love that you've covered characters from Peaky Blinders, an awesome but underrated show. 👏🏽
Nice work bro. I will like to do a video with you someday. Cheers
Damn this is actually really good. Nice work man.
Thank you Mr Corleone 🙏🏼
@@JWisdom Hahaha thanks man
Amazing editing bro
Thank you brother🙏
Luv your videos. You should do one on Joe Goldberg from You
Tommy actually does have animalistic tendencies and severe PTSD. The thing about him is, he has extreme self control and has found that if he keeps moving, he can keep it down. That’s why when he went on holidays, he started relieving the war with barely any stimuli. We see that he’s also very much prone to violence, when he kills that Irishman in the Garrison and Moss says he looks like he was attacked by a wild animal (Tommy kept going well after the man died)
John seems to have the least PTSD of all, especially after his marriage, but he’s also impulsive, and prone to violence.
These small channels are getting better
Congratulations to you, J. Wisdom, for making a video topic, and analysis, about Arthur Shelby, my good friend! Joe Anderson plays Arthur Shelby to an absolute perfection. By the way, do you think that you can do a video topic, and analysis of Raylan Givens from justified?
Very good bro. Please make a video on EHTAN HUNT character in Mission Impossible.
beautifully explained 👏🏽
Glad it was helpful🤝
Dope video man. Arthur most definently had his demons. The editing of this video is top notch. Most definently gonna take some tips. Great video my boy
Appreciate it man! Thanks a lot🙏
@@JWisdom Amazes me this don't have more views.. gonna hit you up soon dog
I like how every enemy of the peaky Blinders is scared of him
There are a few things in the video that don't reflect what I remember from the show. I can't remember Tommy needing to use a great deal of violence to maintain his illegal bookies business (at least not on the scale of the show) he could have just had a nice business and stayed where he was. It's not until he expands that there is a need for greater violence. Arthur does fire the machine gun but to me, this seems like an effective use of violence he's under attack he fires and then he's not under attack (they seem to have run off from the lack of return fire) this would be a bonus reason for Johns problem is capacity for violence (probably more so than Tommy) has an advantage for him to fulfill his role and why another character describes him as an attack dog. Also, Tommy doesn't force the business supplying Arthur with drugs to close down he only forces them to stop the drug's side of their business but still allows them to sell things (if I remember correctly it's also a cafe.
Man amazing analysis.
Thank you bro!
It's also mentioned that he fought at Gallipoli, which was an extremely brutal battle even during WW1
Actually Arthur isn't a psychopath AT ALL, psychopaths lack empathy and especially remorse, Arthur has alot of remorse
great video. May i ask what do you use to edit this?
Thank you, I use Adobe After Effects for all the animations, Premier Pro to put it all together with the music, voiceover, b-roll etc
YOU’RE THE BEST!
❤️❤️
create one for Sully from Top Boy
Arthur shelby is a typical borderline personality. I was diagnosed with BPD 6 years ago ( after 2 years of therapy have been told that I dont meet the criteria to be diagnosed anymore 🎉), let me try give my reasoning about this as follows.. 1) his emotions are erratic and can be set off over slights to his character. 2) He tries to kill himself and constantly suffers with depressive episode, psycopaths have so much love for themselves they rarely try to off themselves. 3) His affinity to violent impulsivity and constant need to numb himself with substance abuse, and it all comes from a place of pain. For example the scene where he killed the boy is a classic Borderline rage moment, as he feels remorse straight away. There is a massive overlap between PTSD and BPD and he might experience both. 4) His mother actually killed herself which is a trauma that he or tommy never fully acknowledged or dealt with. 5) Tommy and John both exhibit Anti social tendancies, which are cold and impulsive, but where that differs from Arthur is that he is in Constant pain. The emotional centre of the brain in borderlines is about 3 times the size of the average population, so when something hurts it hurts 3 times as much. This is different from psycopathy because they actually have an emotional centre which is about half as much as the average population. 6) he shows signs when with Linda that he was a changed man and definitely has the capability of recovery, however his evil Borderline side comes out and ruins that. Without treatment this condition is actually more common among prisoners these days because they can't keep their emotions under control.
Still, amazing video and incredible work fella! Really informative and good to deep dive into the struggles of strong male characters in TV
on the punisher would be a cold vid
I like how you get into the tunnel rat and personal history
could you do tom hardy in the movie lawless next?
Please make a video on Frank Underwood
I cant understand why this doesnt have 100k views
It’s age restricted unfortunately, really limits it’s reach
War is not the only ptsd you can get from the military .....you dont need a war to have to fight fires, hydralic bursts high pressure air bursts and to see people die from it ....to fight but not be able to save and to be saved in kind ....you dont need war in the military to be put under enormous stress ...sleep deprivation and constant drills and being held to the highest standards can do that to you ....just making a point that will go over most peoples heads
Damn. I shed tears
🙏🏼🙏🏼
this is made really well with only 9k views
Could look at Micheal Grey too
The p.t.s.d. Aspect is what I like most about the show
Can you do one on Ragnar lothbrook
Already done 🤝
Yo how’s this vid only got 29k views
do amander waller
He must have served in the middle east too. He knew exactly which tobacco the Turks used to smoke in the third season when meeting the russian
That’s why Tommy was a sergeant major
Arthur clearly has ptsd. From both the Great War, and the life he was brought up in.
Arthur was ABSOLUTELY close to THE best cast member on peaky blinders
Arthur Shelby felt like such a real character real nice 🍔😎🥵🥶🤠.
0:38 it was life or death there and he didn't have a weapon. He was defending himself. More or less, Arthur is a sociopath, not a psychopath because a psychopath doesn't have any emotions or loyality to no one. If he was a psychopath he could've try to kill Tommy to take his place in the gang and familly but we found out he defended his familly in his teenage years by fighting cops who raided them with a pitchfork, I think. A psychopath is born, a sociopath is made.
Different bro, different
Love my brother 🙏🏼
Reminds me of Jax Teller from Sons Of Anarchy
Brilliant
🐐
psychos don't love, Arthur loves
Do pablo Escobar
Back to 17k BY ORDER OF THE PEAKY BLINDERS
🙏🏼🙏🏼
Whooo the f*** is next?😈
This man has talent. He needs more roles
Arthur is more a sociopath
AWWWWRRRRRFAAARRR
I STILL LOVE WHEN HE SHOUTS LEENDA