잘 못 부르더라도 라이브를 해야 실력도 더 늘거고 난 솔직히 안부르는것보다 잘 못불러도 부르려고 노력하는게 더 예뻐보이던데... 아이브 아직 어린 애기들인데 열심히 노력해서 실력이 늘어서 사람들한테 욕 안먹으면 좋겠다. 댓글에 실력이 안되면 데뷔를 하면 안되지, 이게 아이돌이냐 이런 댓글이 달릴까봐 하는 말인데 전 아이브 팬 아닙니다. 저도 실력좋은 아이돌이 뜨고 데뷔하면 좋겠어요. 하지만 이미 데뷔했고 이렇게 많이 주목을 받는데 계속 실력으로 까이니까 안타까워서 댓글을 적습니다. 이왕 데뷔한거 잘 못하더라도 앞으로 열심히 노력해서 잘 하면 좋잖아요. 진짜 아직 어린 아이들인데 안타깝네요..
Okay so whoever was in charge of the technical side for this performance really messed up big time. They forgot to turn on the mics of the girls for the first few moments of the performance. That’s why you can only hear the backing track for Wonyoung, Rei and Gaeul for the first few moments of the performance and Liz’s sudden vocals during the middle of her part. But it seems like they kept messing up with it during the whole performance because the volume keeps going up and down. All groups performing tonight had a backing track playing behind their live vocals so if you’r an IVE hater don’t even try it. It’s unfortunate this happened because people already discredit the girls’ singing, which as an IVE stan I will not sit here and claim that they are the best vocalists out there but they are all at least decent and have Liz and Yujin who can indeed sing very well, you can see that during their recording sessions. I am not a delusional stan and claim what they are not but I also won’t accept haters trying to overexaggerate the truth.
worded perfectly like i don’t even stan ive but I’m so fucking tired of the hate they get for no reason, and this is only going to make it worse when ppl twist it into their own narrative
Bro Everyone Is Saying Ive Is Lip syncing but they aren’t since there are mic problems and there stage got ruined. YALL BEING HATERS SAYING THEY ARENT SINGING LIVE like bro if other groups didn’t sing live most of you wouldn’t care BESIDES WHAT DID IVE DO TO YOU HUH?
They are NOT lipsync I watched fancam that fan took I can hear they're struggling to sing with mic problem😭 poor girls dragged by hater bcs of SBS treated them dirty
@@SsmilingSsmile bro she gets the least attention out of all members. Wonyoung and yujin are known from izone, liz was promoted well in debut and is now popular among the fandom, rei is also known for her rap and vocals, leeseo gets a lot of attention cuz she is the youngest and is appreciated for her achievements. Only recently gaeul is being given enough opportunity to shine.
Although mic have some problem and IVE's voices are unclear but IVE still contribute a beautiful stage,their outfit and visual are so eye-catching,dreamy Christmas vibe❤
@@henriquecjesus you can clearly hear the technical difficulties during the first part of the performance. Even the volume was off, it picked up during Liz’s part. They are not the most stellar vocalists ( besides Liz and Yujin who have the most potential ) but they are not bad as a lot of you want to make them seem like. This performance was screwed over by the technical team.
@@henriquecjesus you should hear their song my satisfaction they all can sing. Are they the best? NO they are not the best but they can improve alot cause everyone is very young but yea try listning their solo live stages they all can sing
i thought they first lip synced and when gaeul started singing they all decided to sing lol like u can hear wy+liz whispering(? at their first two lines
The only group that had problems with the mic and camera working like sh!t SBS the only one to blame is only u My girls as always try their best in their performances 💘
@@LOVEDlVE gaeul fans are just like jisoo fans, always complaining about mistreatment, when theres none, well for gaeul theres some mistreatment actually but not as much as gaeul fans make them to be, ans for jisoo, theres literally no mistreatment and they still say yg is mistreating her
The performance was going okayish until that horrible unnecessary dance break happened ? I mean was it really even necessary to do that dance break and show how messy it was ? 😂
리즈는 무슨 노래든 진짜 너무 잘해
음색요정이 괜히 된게 아니네
애프털라이크까지 발라드 예쁘다
리즈가 라이브 잘한다는게 맞긴했낵
@@user-pl6vc6ff6b 게이야.. 통한의 쉴드치노..
@@user-pl6vc6ff6b 억빠
겁나....저건 아니잖여.....대체 소속사에서는 왜저렇게 준비한거야.....
잘 못 부르더라도 라이브를 해야 실력도 더 늘거고 난 솔직히 안부르는것보다 잘 못불러도 부르려고 노력하는게 더 예뻐보이던데... 아이브 아직 어린 애기들인데 열심히 노력해서 실력이 늘어서 사람들한테 욕 안먹으면 좋겠다.
댓글에 실력이 안되면 데뷔를 하면 안되지, 이게 아이돌이냐 이런 댓글이 달릴까봐 하는 말인데 전 아이브 팬 아닙니다. 저도 실력좋은 아이돌이 뜨고 데뷔하면 좋겠어요. 하지만 이미 데뷔했고 이렇게 많이 주목을 받는데 계속 실력으로 까이니까 안타까워서 댓글을 적습니다. 이왕 데뷔한거 잘 못하더라도 앞으로 열심히 노력해서 잘 하면 좋잖아요. 진짜 아직 어린 아이들인데 안타깝네요..
Okay so whoever was in charge of the technical side for this performance really messed up big time. They forgot to turn on the mics of the girls for the first few moments of the performance. That’s why you can only hear the backing track for Wonyoung, Rei and Gaeul for the first few moments of the performance and Liz’s sudden vocals during the middle of her part. But it seems like they kept messing up with it during the whole performance because the volume keeps going up and down. All groups performing tonight had a backing track playing behind their live vocals so if you’r an IVE hater don’t even try it. It’s unfortunate this happened because people already discredit the girls’ singing, which as an IVE stan I will not sit here and claim that they are the best vocalists out there but they are all at least decent and have Liz and Yujin who can indeed sing very well, you can see that during their recording sessions. I am not a delusional stan and claim what they are not but I also won’t accept haters trying to overexaggerate the truth.
exactly theeir vocals in my satisfaction slayed
Agreed
worded perfectly like i don’t even stan ive but I’m so fucking tired of the hate they get for no reason, and this is only going to make it worse when ppl twist it into their own narrative
Full fancam livevocal good watch gogogo!!
They didn’t forget to turn it on. The rest chose to lipsync, they chose to sing later on.
딴건 모르겠고 편곡 지린다 ㄹㅇ 이 버젼으로 음원 좀 내줘..
yujin so beautiful
gaeul and yujin are the most charismatic dancers wbk
이정도면 마이크 안나온거 아님? 아니 소리가 이렇게 작을 수가 있나 리즈 최고_^^
근데 마이크가 2개나 있음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@하잉-e2r 스텐딩마이크 저거 연출용임 실제로는 안되는거임
와 르세라핌 알바들 열일하노
@@키스를날려쓰러뜨리자 장원영빠가 아직도 있네…
@@키스를날려쓰러뜨리자 릇바인 걸 어디서 알 수가 있음?
Great performance but was there trouble with the audio or something ?
Gaeul being the main SLAYER as always
Their audio is a tragedy....
Always has been
에휴..진짜 악플이 아니라
직업이 가수면 표정연습말고 진짜 라이브 연습좀 했음 좋겠네요..
Bro Everyone Is Saying Ive Is Lip syncing but they aren’t since there are mic problems and there stage got ruined. YALL BEING HATERS SAYING THEY ARENT SINGING LIVE like bro if other groups didn’t sing live most of you wouldn’t care BESIDES WHAT DID IVE DO TO YOU HUH?
They are NOT lipsync I watched fancam that fan took I can hear they're struggling to sing with mic problem😭
poor girls dragged by hater bcs of SBS treated them dirty
Haters gonna hate
This is obvious live but problem audio of sbs
GAEUL SLAYYY
진심 리즈 개잘부르네
They really made After Like sound so Christmassy
Wonyoung and yujin have a very nice ending pose ❤❤
울지원.. 솔로하자..
편곡해서 ar이 준비가 안됐나보다... 원래 실력없고 못부르는건 알지만 그래도 립싱수준으로 무대해서 앵콜 말곤 티 안났는데 너무.... 안타까운 수준이네....ㅜ
그냥 음향사곤데 ㅋㅋ 지능수준
@@미미르 상식적으로 음향사고였음 미안하다고 공지를 띄웠겠지ㅋㅋㅋ그냥 대형사고다 이 실력으로 라이브 해보겠다고 설친 게ㅋㅋ그와중에 쫄려서 ar깔고
みんな可愛すぎる この子達産みたかった🥰🥲 はあーーみんな今年もよく本当に頑張ったよ🥹偉いよ、、、 これからも私の原動力🫶🏻😉 風邪ひかないように沢山美味しいものを食べて休める時は休んで健康に過ごしてくれればそれだけで私は幸せです🐣みんな大好きーーーー‼️‼️‼️
Yujin the gorgeous and most coolest woman you are ♥️🙏🏼🫶🏼
뭔일이야....학교축제에서도 노래 이렇게 부르면 수치사....
Rei's hairstyle fit her so much that I thought she was a doll.
Wonyoung ❤️❤️❤️❤️ princess cutie 🥰🥰🥰🥰
리즈 진짜 잘한다..
Honestly I like this version more than their actual holiday remix
아이돌도 가수다
삐쩍 말리고 표정만 짓는 애들보단
통통해도 노래잘하는 리즈가 훨씬 낫지
Wonyoung what a beauty I love you
KIM GAEUL YOU ALWAYS SLAY ME
하나같이 다 똑같네 아니 잘부르는 리즈 냅두고 파트는 누가 다 잡아먹는거지 이정도면 마이크 고장난수준인데
리즈 참 잘해~~^^
마이크 볼륨이 작은 게 맞는 듯.... 들으면 레이고 가을이고 노래 제대로 하고 있음 볼륨이 작아서 그렇지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 사람들이 마음에 미움을 좀 버렸음 좋겠다
뭔 장원영이랑 안유진밖에 안나와 이서 리즈 레이는 뭔 단독샷이 거의 없넼ㅋㅋㅋ
Wonyoung look so cute and pretty in thia hairstyle oh my gosh 😍✨💗
Finally gaeul is getting the hype she deserves!
She is getting the hype the whole year what you talking about?
@@SsmilingSsmile bro she gets the least attention out of all members. Wonyoung and yujin are known from izone, liz was promoted well in debut and is now popular among the fandom, rei is also known for her rap and vocals, leeseo gets a lot of attention cuz she is the youngest and is appreciated for her achievements. Only recently gaeul is being given enough opportunity to shine.
wonyoung it girl
Gaeul really walked away to save the performance
I'm glad starship's showing Gaeul's potential as a dancer these days :)
Stop overhyped gaeul and put down the other ive girls when her dance break isn't great no hate
@@lavienrosewon8811 chill no one is putting down anyone here besides we don't generally see ppl praising gaeul all the time anyways
@@lavienrosewon8811 wtf
gaeul didn't get great dance break tho..we need called out
Starship is suck
리즈 너무 잘한다....🐈⬛❤️
Wonyoung is so beautiful 😍
리즈 잘 부른다
wonyoung looks so stunning omggg 😭😭
They need be praised for singing live WITHOUT MIC WORKING
god I won't forgive SBS for ruined their stage. Why it's always IVE suffer things like this?
Wonyoung gorgeous as always ❤
wonyoung is such a doll 🤍❄ my favorite girl
Gaeul the MAIN SLAYER OMG !!! 🔥
HER DANCE BREAK IS TOO GOOD 😍🙌🏻
Wonyoung the winter Queen👑Her visual,voice,facial expression and dancing movements ruled this stage🤍
Cute wonyoung❤
Although mic have some problem and IVE's voices are unclear but IVE still contribute a beautiful stage,their outfit and visual are so eye-catching,dreamy Christmas vibe❤
the mics have no problem, they can't sing and thats okay
@@henriquecjesus i heard leeseo and liz voice, but its not clear ☠️ wdym lol
@@henriquecjesus you can clearly hear the technical difficulties during the first part of the performance. Even the volume was off, it picked up during Liz’s part. They are not the most stellar vocalists ( besides Liz and Yujin who have the most potential ) but they are not bad as a lot of you want to make them seem like. This performance was screwed over by the technical team.
@@henriquecjesus you should hear their song my satisfaction they all can sing. Are they the best? NO they are not the best but they can improve alot cause everyone is very young but yea try listning their solo live stages they all can sing
i thought they first lip synced and when gaeul started singing they all decided to sing lol
like u can hear wy+liz whispering(? at their first two lines
At least, Gaeul Slayed
このお城とかメイクとかめっちゃiz*one味があってめっちゃ良き😭💞
Gaeul slayed her dance break
Gaeul is the pretty dancer ❤
Wonyoung..so pretty
メリークリスマス♥️アイブちゃん一生懸命歌ってくれて嬉しい😆ありがとう👍️と油断してたらガウル先輩のダンスブレイク⚡
이팀은 가창력이 필요한 노래도 아닌데 리즈 빼면 라이브하면 불안해서 볼수가없다. 유진이마저.끼부리는 연습도 좋지만 노래 연습도 좀해라 어려운 노래 아니잖아. 안유진 팬인데 이번엔 좀..
그런 댓 달 시간에 잠이나자라 ㅉ
여기 초딩밭이라 팩트얘기하면 욕먹음 ㅜㅜㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그럼 니는 얼마나 잘하는데
니가 뭐 국내최초 노래잘하는 사람임?
리즈는 파트 더 올려주는게 맞다니까ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아이브에 노래 잘하는 애가 리즈,유진 말고는 막 좋다 할 음색이 없는데 리즈 파트 너무 적은것같음 그리고 에프터 라이크 발라드 버전으면 느릴텐데 그걸 음정을 그대로 놓는게 맞냐..유진이 힘들어보이는데..
그건 니 생각이고 ㅇㅇ
Wonyoung yujin double center...wonyoung jjang👍
Liz is the best
gaeul and yujin main dancers
Gaeul has been getting the attention she deserves!!!!
쇼츠로 본 게 mr 제거가 아니었구나 얘네 진짜 어떡하냐…
레이 너무 백설공주 같다ㅠㅠ❤️
Wonyoung’s hairstyle is cute but her charisma is unparalleled,she is winter queen and dominate this performance🤍👑
She did't even sang her lines so nice domination XDD
@@tonymontana7195 she sing 1:25
@@tonymontana7195 there is headset mic...tho they didn't used their mic..front them
아이브 최애는 안유진님!
그냥 너무 좋음 ㄷㄷㄷㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌ
The only group that had problems with the mic and camera working like sh!t SBS the only one to blame is only u
My girls as always try their best in their performances 💘
nmixx also had mic problems
가을 선배 개지린다
FINALLY. Finally Starship treating Gaeul like a member of IVE. She got solo dance break!!! And she killed it
she’s had a center part/dance break for almost every show this award season wdym
@@alsowishimura6824 gaeul fans have victim complexes
@@LOVEDlVE gaeul fans are just like jisoo fans, always complaining about mistreatment, when theres none, well for gaeul theres some mistreatment actually but not as much as gaeul fans make them to be, ans for jisoo, theres literally no mistreatment and they still say yg is mistreating her
Gaeul é linda demais, a Princesa perfeita lol
oh my... wtf was that after like performance
There ending pose >>
Gaeul dance>>>
Gaeul did great! Why the performance so short though.
So glad Gaeul is getting more screentime
Wonyoung is such underappreciated
what🧍♀🧍♀🧍♀
aren’t you the same person who said gaeuls dance break wasn’t good 💀
because WY cares only her visual,not skill.
@@j0slyn702 yes starship give shit dance breat at ive..we need hire other
Didn’t you just tell us that we should stop overhyping a single member?
Yujin jugando con su corbata 🔥🥵🌈❤️🔥❤️💘💓💖💖😍🙈🔥😌🥰🚨🔝
The performance was going okayish until that horrible unnecessary dance break happened ? I mean was it really even necessary to do that dance break and show how messy it was ? 😂
라이브는큰일다 ~
レイちゃんにアリエッティのコスプレしてほしい
キキも似合う
못부르는걸 못부른다 얘기하지 이게 악플이냐? 대중들의 관심으로 먹고 사는 직업인한테 현실을 얘기하는 게 뭔 잘못인가. 당연히 일반인보단 잘부르겠지만 대상 탄 그룹인데 기대치 높은게 당연한거 아닌가?
대중의평가로 먹고사는애들보고 평가하면 악플이라니 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 별게다 악플이라네
GAEULLL U KILLED IT GIRL
리즈 빼고 다들 노래는 좀 많이 부족한듯 ㅠㅠ 리즈 파트 좀 많이줘라..
the camerawork 😭
Liz best girl
Wonyoug the doll a beauty will goes down in history for sure 😍😍
YUJIN SLAYS
She deserves so much more than what Starship is doing with this group.
@@lastsliceoflife true
Gaeul slays those dances eveytime
i love Wonyoung sm!! ❤️
아니 진짴ㅋㅋㅋ 레코딩 영상 올릴때부터 느낀거지만 소속사 무슨 자신감으로 이걸 계획한거냐고 목소리 하나도 안 들려서 방송사고 인줄 알았음…
Let's talk about Liz
My girl
Whoever their sound person is, they need to raise their mic's volume to match the music.
Great performance, bad audio
IVE Amazing！Our perfect girls♡
yujin i'm crazy for you
리즈 귀엽다아♡♡
Gaeul main slayer
Why is the sound so bad in performances of multiple groups? Anyways they slayed and look
beautiful
the cameraman destroyed a great performance
카메라맨은 훌륭한 성능을 파괴
Sucks they always show wonyoung and yujin in thumbnail ..
ガウル姉さん！！凄すぎます✨♥️最高
Iveは本当に最高だーー✴️