Act from Awareness. As the Self. We don't always need to sit back passively. Sometimes action needs to happen. But still stay as Awareness and then let action happen by itself. Without ego. There is still a measure of responsibility needed sometimes. Awareness is not always a passive state. There is an intelligence that can act through us.
I was calling god for some suffering I was going through . I open UA-cam and find this video . This is how god loves us and responds to our earnest calling . I got my answer from this satsang and there was immediate peace from everything around me . A big thank you for all the insights and with so much clarity . I’m so glad I found you 🌺🌺🌺🌺
Till you reach the state of jhana and thus wake out of Maya you must do social service by relieving suffering whenever you see it. But even then you must do it without ahankara, i.e., without the sense of ' I am the doer ', but with the feeling ' I am the Lord's tool' . -- Ramana Maharshi
Namaskar! Blessings to all! It is important to understand the mind momentum gathered from thousands of years. As Sanjay said, face the consequences! I don't think we should be 'hard on ourselves' in that sense, but we should also not try to control the results from our Sadhana and want moksha on our terms, that is only another desire from ego. Personally I try to practice what Nisargadatta Maharaj once said and that is: " Don't forget to move beyond! " Or what Bruce Lee said: " Be like water! " In early stages our cultivation of compassion for ourselves and therefore for others and 100% honesty is of utter importance. And view any crisis as an inner call from Grace. Thank you deeply. Om Shanti! 🕉🙏
So what I am hearing is doership is free will and doership is ego, and there is no doer. The doer is the illusion. Our doership is dictated by our vasana karma. So by allowing and recognizing the self we can just let the play of the world be as it’s meant to be and be in bliss ❤
I have never had any accomplishments in my life. Everything I have was given to me. My best efforts never work out. I have tried to give up every carnal desire and as soon as I get one thing under control something else pops up. When it comes to living a pure life I am completely powerless. I don't work anymore and I know very few people and I spend my days sitting in my house contemplating God. I have come to understand that the person I am in the depths of my heart is my true nature that is One with God but I still identify with this ego, I feel like I am the ego and that is why I am powerless. There is absolutely nothing I can do for myself so I just sit here. I am not in control of anything at all. My best efforts come to naught.
Thank you deeply Dr Sanjay for your wise guidance 🙏. God is in everything and everywhere, within and without. Look inwards and feel the Self is God. Never mind what the mind will say, judge, criticize, blame, compliment, wish, agree or disagree....it has no impact on you if we have faith in SELF and be just silent 🙏...
Actions happen, deeds are done but there is no doer there of. Life as we know it is a complete whole with its ups and downs. Only problem is we like the ups and not the downs. I can feel the pain of the gentleman asking the question. As Ramesh Balsekar Ji says - do what needs to be done thinking you have all the free will and then have the understanding that whatever is the result is the Gods will. Om tat sat.
Do with ego? Or without? That's the most important part which might be overlooked by many of us.... Does both have different outcomes for the given situation?? These are the things to ponder upon.... 🙏❤️
@@asmallabadi ego as I understand is the sense of ‘I’ which is required to do any action. Using the body and mind as an instrument to do action but understanding that inspiration to do any action is coming from universe/god is the way to go. Definitely pride should not be there. An action done with pride and sense of doership will have a different effect than done otherwise 🌸🙏🏻
@@monikavarma4 it's impossible for one to do what is right in his heart is wrong for someone else... If it is then it's definitely coming from the Ego! There is saying, in order to choose between what's right and being kind, one should always choose being kind which is always right... There is a subtle difference and one has to be very careful as the words might often mislead people if it's not cleared properly... 🙏❤️
We all have ego in action......the key is to be aware of it and to make sure it is not the dominant force in the action. Try to make gratitude and surrender the dominant force in action. I detect my own ego as I type this.
Beautiful! Thank you, thank you.🙏 There are laws which govern chaos, there is a powerful beyond this universe. Nothing I do is on my lonesome or it is impossible for One to separate from all that is . Know dear One, you are never alone . 😊 Divine blessings! Love always .
until the Self pulls you in you won't really realise that things happen by themselves. just focus on self realisation. When the Self has pulled you in then you will see thibgs happen by themself. The body will e doing this and that without you thinking or 'doing' which is thinking. 'Thought' comes before and during all 'doing' by ego. when there are no thoughts still the actions go on. But here is the difference, the body won't be doing as much. you will surprised how much uneccasary action the Ego creates. when you are Self you won't even know how this or that is happening you are just enjoting the bliss. really dont think about these things as long as ego is there you will have some sense of doership. this goes with the ego.
Here our friend can also follow the Bhagavad Gita slogan... Anananya chinthantho maam ye jana paryupaasathe theshaam ..... yoga kshemam vahaamyaham which also supports Bhagavan's view
Based on my reading of David Godman's book on Ramana, I've had a few difficulties. If the Self is the Doer of all actions, and we're deluded to think we are the doers, then what Hitler did was prompted by the Self. All of the world's atrocities, then, are the actions of the Self. Now you could say, following Ramana, that the Self is beyond our ethical understanding; it is beyond our notions of "good" and "evil". If so, I'm not sure I see the practical implications of it, because in our daily lives we need to navigate, to discriminate on the basis of ethical conventions. What the Self "does" holds no place, say, in a court of law when criminals must be sentenced. From my understanding of Ramana, our only freedom consists in turning inward and seeing to Whom or What the thoughts appear. The practice of self-inquiry eventually leads to the Self. Along the way we discover that the ego doesn't actually exist; it is a phantom. The notion that the Self is the Doer of all, that we are deluded in thinking we're the doers of anything, is one I don't accept. It leads to insurmountable difficulties. On the contrary, like Jiddu Krishnamurti, I think that our confusion and disorder are a sign that we are very much out of touch with the Ground, or whatever name you choose to give it ("Tao"). In other words, we have no relationship to the Ground insofar as we are in confusion and disorder. So Hitler, in this instance, has no relationship to the Ground. A greedy or envious or violent person has no relationship to It either - and not because he thinks he's the doer of violent actions, but because violence suggests some form of confusion, some sign of self-centered, divisive activity which separates you from me. Clearly, if I see that you and I are one, that we're basically the same notwithstanding superficial differences, I wouldn't act violently toward you, because in doing so, I would be harming myself. So the violent action is a byproduct, or result, of divisive thinking. The confusion lies NOT in my thinking that I am the doer of violent action. Now I'm well aware that some people may question my use of the word "relationship", since, according to Ramana, there is only God or the Self. But my use of the word "relationship" is predicated upon an initial understanding of Ramana's views; it is not based on realization. One must bear in mind that there are practical considerations to weigh in our world. Discrimination, weighing the good and bad, ethical and unethical, is inescapable so long as we live on this planet. That being said, the word "relationship", even if it is not ultimately true, has practical value because we live in a dualistic world. And I feel that much of what we do is OUT of harmony with the cosmic order.
I am really struggling with this. On one hand it has been said that not a leaf moves without God’s will, at the same time in Bhakti Yoga, the establish again and again about right action, and say we have the choice to do bhajan , burn our karmas , and God will then establish himself in our heart, following which any action that comes through us will be God’s actions.
My flight from Toronto to Cleveland was delayed a few months back.. David sat in front seat by the window next to a fat man.. there was no room to move.. He suffers from severe claustrophobia The plane did not take off for 45 minutes.. it was the really hell.. Mind said this is not real, even chanted “Om namo Bhagavate Sree Ramanaya” The words offered no peace.. now I’m terrified to fly again and I must in the near future 😩
My mom took three shots of the poison as well. They pulled a 12-inch long amyloid blood clot out of her after having a stroke. She is now paralyzed on half of her body and my wife and I are taking care of her. Amyloid blood clots only happen with two very specific and rare diseases and the poison shot as well. Sad how many people fell for this.
Thank you very much for this beautiful speech/teaching 🙏 Is it highly possible that the fact of abiding in the Self modifies, in a certain extent, the course of events since the view of the observer on the experience is different? Gratitude 🌺
With predestined we are talking about the life of the body. In the end it doesn't really matter as interest in answers about the body are unimportant. 💕
Babies have no ego sense, how to teach them from starting? How to start spiritual of children in early stage? 🙏😊 Initially they don't understand Gyan (so bhakti marg love is favorable for kids) pls guide
Babies though are born with the capacity for ego, the Ahamkara, which is an inherent part of the mind-body-social environment complex. Indeed, it’s all Maya, but here we are. Don’t we need a healthy ego to navigate the world?
When you play a video game, the character you control on screen has no free will, but this can't be said to imply predetermination or fatalism because I the controller of the character have NO IDEA what the future will bring and that folks is how there can be an absence of free will WITHOUT predetermination.
Sometimes you don’t even understand the sense of doership in situations.. when you are victims of abuse ( physical / sexual / mental) or violence.. when you are at the receiving end of tragedies.. or may be accidental things.. you satisfy yourself with karma theory or may be it was predestined… your faith shakes .. not sure in ego self or even the SELF which chooses to sport the event in your body .. you don’t recognise who is grieving here.. sometimes you won’t understand where are you at.. there are no stages in sadhna .. have you ever seen this world closely .. even Mahakali is dressed up and sold in a temple .. the all pervading consciousness packed in a cage .. there are no stages to achieve here .. can’t be done by mere dry passive observation.. because even that is done by mind.. it can only be done with Love .. and quickly be done with love.. when you are surrounded by temporary situations .. love stronger …allow that ego to only love all pervading and put a reign on it with love.. because it is the only emotion which doesnt seek any proof of validation .. it is selfless and absolute. When you surrender with love your pure self wouldn’t ever get tainted with anything .. allow the drama to happen because you love .. you are love ! And you are loved!
Yes and no. Everything started from intention, thoughts, manifestation, if you act upon it whether is positive or negativity. You are acknowledging it then it will become a cycle whether you like it or not.
No wonder the questioner was so distraught and confused. Sanjay didn’t hep n the least. As Ramesh balsakar says “ there is no free will but act as if there is.” Ps he was the translator for Nisargadatta Maharaj
🎉very true ,higerself stands on its own support ,totaly surrenderd to the one and only one
Act from Awareness. As the Self. We don't always need to sit back passively. Sometimes action needs to happen. But still stay as Awareness and then let action happen by itself. Without ego. There is still a measure of responsibility needed sometimes. Awareness is not always a passive state. There is an intelligence that can act through us.
So well said. Wish you well.
I’m I’m just saying saying it like it
🙏
Thank you so much ❤❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏🙏
I was calling god for some suffering I was going through . I open UA-cam and find this video . This is how god loves us and responds to our earnest calling . I got my answer from this satsang and there was immediate peace from everything around me . A big thank you for all the insights and with so much clarity . I’m so glad I found you 🌺🌺🌺🌺
Not sure about God but definitely the algorithm did it 😅
Till you reach the state of jhana and thus wake out of Maya you must do social service by relieving suffering whenever you see it. But even then you must do it without ahankara, i.e., without the sense of ' I am the doer ', but with the feeling ' I am the Lord's tool' . -- Ramana Maharshi
Divine knowledge..
Namaskar! Blessings to all! It is important to understand the mind momentum gathered from thousands of years. As Sanjay said, face the consequences! I don't think we should be 'hard on ourselves' in that sense, but we should also not try to control the results from our Sadhana and want moksha on our terms, that is only another desire from ego. Personally I try to practice what Nisargadatta Maharaj once said and that is: " Don't forget to move beyond! " Or what Bruce Lee said: " Be like water! " In early stages our cultivation of compassion for ourselves and therefore for others and 100% honesty is of utter importance. And view any crisis as an inner call from Grace. Thank you deeply. Om Shanti! 🕉🙏
"Om Shanthi" for the ego 🙂
what a way to spend a Sunday afternoon..pumpkin cake/ tgea/ watching the autumn leaves swirl outside3 my window...and Ramana peace
So what I am hearing is doership is free will and doership is ego, and there is no doer. The doer is the illusion. Our doership is dictated by our vasana karma. So by allowing and recognizing the self we can just let the play of the world be as it’s meant to be and be in bliss ❤
Mind is movement. Soul is stillness
❤️❤️❤️
Eternal blessings
here 🥰
Love and blessings to the questioner....may he be free and happy.🙏 Thank you for the clear and powerful explanation.💗🙏
I have never had any accomplishments in my life. Everything I have was given to me. My best efforts never work out. I have tried to give up every carnal desire and as soon as I get one thing under control something else pops up. When it comes to living a pure life I am completely powerless. I don't work anymore and I know very few people and I spend my days sitting in my house contemplating God. I have come to understand that the person I am in the depths of my heart is my true nature that is One with God but I still identify with this ego, I feel like I am the ego and that is why I am powerless. There is absolutely nothing I can do for myself so I just sit here. I am not in control of anything at all. My best efforts come to naught.
Thank you Sir...may you live long...
Thank you deeply Dr Sanjay for your wise guidance 🙏.
God is in everything and everywhere, within and without. Look inwards and feel the Self is God.
Never mind what the mind will say, judge, criticize, blame, compliment, wish, agree or disagree....it has no impact on you if we have faith in SELF and be just silent 🙏...
Actions happen, deeds are done but there is no doer there of. Life as we know it is a complete whole with its ups and downs. Only problem is we like the ups and not the downs. I can feel the pain of the gentleman asking the question. As Ramesh Balsekar Ji says - do what needs to be done thinking you have all the free will and then have the understanding that whatever is the result is the Gods will. Om tat sat.
Do with ego? Or without? That's the most important part which might be overlooked by many of us.... Does both have different outcomes for the given situation?? These are the things to ponder upon.... 🙏❤️
@@asmallabadi ego as I understand is the sense of ‘I’ which is required to do any action. Using the body and mind as an instrument to do action but understanding that inspiration to do any action is coming from universe/god is the way to go. Definitely pride should not be there. An action done with pride and sense of doership will have a different effect than done otherwise 🌸🙏🏻
@@monikavarma4 it's impossible for one to do what is right in his heart is wrong for someone else... If it is then it's definitely coming from the Ego! There is saying, in order to choose between what's right and being kind, one should always choose being kind which is always right... There is a subtle difference and one has to be very careful as the words might often mislead people if it's not cleared properly... 🙏❤️
So clear, so hard letting go all Stories, Egos doership, a real challenge…thank you for the ending of dreaming…and the path, lets go
I Love this Man
Such a soothing discourse on the Teachings of The Great Master Bhagavan Ramana
No body haha but superhappy to hve found you in this youtube ocean .. thank no one but the One namaste
We all have ego in action......the key is to be aware of it and to make sure it is not the dominant force in the action. Try to make gratitude and surrender the dominant force in action. I detect my own ego as I type this.
🙏🏼💜
Beautiful! Thank you, thank you.🙏
There are laws which govern chaos, there is a powerful beyond this universe.
Nothing I do is on my lonesome or it is impossible for One to separate from all that is .
Know dear One, you are never alone . 😊
Divine blessings!
Love always .
I met true people who work selflessness yogis. What l say true not a lie ஃ❤
Thank you
🙏🏾
Stripping away … not slipping away
Yes! Yes! Yes !
Leave everything and dissolve In Pure Silence
🙏💜🙏
👌👌🌺🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🌺❤️❤️
until the Self pulls you in you won't really realise that things happen by themselves. just focus on self realisation. When the Self has pulled you in then you will see thibgs happen by themself. The body will e doing this and that without you thinking or 'doing' which is thinking. 'Thought' comes before and during all 'doing' by ego. when there are no thoughts still the actions go on. But here is the difference, the body won't be doing as much. you will surprised how much uneccasary action the Ego creates. when you are Self you won't even know how this or that is happening you are just enjoting the bliss. really dont think about these things as long as ego is there you will have some sense of doership. this goes with the ego.
Amazing 🙏
Ultimate knowledge as always..
Here our friend can also follow the Bhagavad Gita slogan... Anananya chinthantho maam ye jana paryupaasathe theshaam ..... yoga kshemam vahaamyaham which also supports Bhagavan's view
When our mind is surrendered at the feet of the Guru , we do not fear the tsunami.
We stay still and untouched.
particularly apropos -- thank you
This is your best video Sanjay
Thank you 🙏🏻
💚🙏🌹
🙏🙏🙏
🌊💙🙏💙🌊
I wonder that if every thing is predetermined then we can’t do nothing to stop the war between Israel and Hamas?
💜
Based on my reading of David Godman's book on Ramana, I've had a few difficulties. If the Self is the Doer of all actions, and we're deluded to think we are the doers, then what Hitler did was prompted by the Self. All of the world's atrocities, then, are the actions of the Self. Now you could say, following Ramana, that the Self is beyond our ethical understanding; it is beyond our notions of "good" and "evil". If so, I'm not sure I see the practical implications of it, because in our daily lives we need to navigate, to discriminate on the basis of ethical conventions. What the Self "does" holds no place, say, in a court of law when criminals must be sentenced. From my understanding of Ramana, our only freedom consists in turning inward and seeing to Whom or What the thoughts appear. The practice of self-inquiry eventually leads to the Self. Along the way we discover that the ego doesn't actually exist; it is a phantom.
The notion that the Self is the Doer of all, that we are deluded in thinking we're the doers of anything, is one I don't accept. It leads to insurmountable difficulties. On the contrary, like Jiddu Krishnamurti, I think that our confusion and disorder are a sign that we are very much out of touch with the Ground, or whatever name you choose to give it ("Tao"). In other words, we have no relationship to the Ground insofar as we are in confusion and disorder. So Hitler, in this instance, has no relationship to the Ground. A greedy or envious or violent person has no relationship to It either - and not because he thinks he's the doer of violent actions, but because violence suggests some form of confusion, some sign of self-centered, divisive activity which separates you from me. Clearly, if I see that you and I are one, that we're basically the same notwithstanding superficial differences, I wouldn't act violently toward you, because in doing so, I would be harming myself. So the violent action is a byproduct, or result, of divisive thinking. The confusion lies NOT in my thinking that I am the doer of violent action.
Now I'm well aware that some people may question my use of the word "relationship", since, according to Ramana, there is only God or the Self. But my use of the word "relationship" is predicated upon an initial understanding of Ramana's views; it is not based on realization. One must bear in mind that there are practical considerations to weigh in our world. Discrimination, weighing the good and bad, ethical and unethical, is inescapable so long as we live on this planet. That being said, the word "relationship", even if it is not ultimately true, has practical value because we live in a dualistic world. And I feel that much of what we do is OUT of harmony with the cosmic order.
I am really struggling with this. On one hand it has been said that not a leaf moves without God’s will, at the same time in Bhakti Yoga, the establish again and again about right action, and say we have the choice to do bhajan , burn our karmas , and God will then establish himself in our heart, following which any action that comes through us will be God’s actions.
My flight from
Toronto to
Cleveland was
delayed a few
months back..
David sat
in front seat
by the window
next to a fat
man.. there
was no room
to move..
He suffers
from severe
claustrophobia
The plane did
not take off
for 45 minutes..
it was the
really hell..
Mind said
this is not real,
even chanted
“Om namo
Bhagavate
Sree Ramanaya”
The words
offered no
peace.. now
I’m terrified to
fly again and
I must in the
near future 😩
My mom took three shots of the poison as well. They pulled a 12-inch long amyloid blood clot out of her after having a stroke. She is now paralyzed on half of her body and my wife and I are taking care of her. Amyloid blood clots only happen with two very specific and rare diseases and the poison shot as well. Sad how many people fell for this.
💖💖💖
Intellectually David
knows Bhagavan
speaks the Truth..
still there is fear..
will there be
suffering in
another body
after death of
this one..
Thank you very much for this beautiful speech/teaching 🙏 Is it highly possible that the fact of abiding in the Self modifies, in a certain extent, the course of events since the view of the observer on the experience is different? Gratitude 🌺
Dear guru ji,
Have you met any people after death please explain me ஃ❤
Ego just disappeared after noticing its trap in doership
With predestined we are talking about the life of the body. In the end it doesn't really matter as interest in answers about the body are unimportant. 💕
🙏🕯️❤️🕉️☮️☮️☮️
Let it be as it is, any word is a trap Nhamasta
As David I was
banished from my
family for not
taking C o v i d
v a c c i n e . .
am curious
how many
people refused
it in India
To be a Bhagavan devotee, what do I need to do ? Thank you for your advice 🙏🏼
What our guru ji concept after death
who founded advaita philosophy 6-700 years before Buddha's time?
Babies have no ego sense, how to teach them from starting? How to start spiritual of children in early stage? 🙏😊 Initially they don't understand Gyan (so bhakti marg love is favorable for kids) pls guide
Krishna Das ji says.. You don't teach by teaching. It's basically transmission.
Babies though are born with the capacity for ego, the Ahamkara, which is an inherent part of the mind-body-social environment complex. Indeed, it’s all Maya, but here we are. Don’t we need a healthy ego to navigate the world?
When you play a video game, the character you control on screen has no free will, but this can't be said to imply predetermination or fatalism because I the controller of the character have NO IDEA what the future will bring and that folks is how there can be an absence of free will WITHOUT predetermination.
Sometimes you don’t even understand the sense of doership in situations.. when you are victims of abuse ( physical / sexual / mental) or violence.. when you are at the receiving end of tragedies.. or may be accidental things.. you satisfy yourself with karma theory or may be it was predestined… your faith shakes .. not sure in ego self or even the SELF which chooses to sport the event in your body .. you don’t recognise who is grieving here.. sometimes you won’t understand where are you at.. there are no stages in sadhna .. have you ever seen this world closely .. even Mahakali is dressed up and sold in a temple .. the all pervading consciousness packed in a cage .. there are no stages to achieve here .. can’t be done by mere dry passive observation.. because even that is done by mind.. it can only be done with Love .. and quickly be done with love.. when you are surrounded by temporary situations .. love stronger …allow that ego to only love all pervading and put a reign on it with love.. because it is the only emotion which doesnt seek any proof of validation .. it is selfless and absolute. When you surrender with love your pure self wouldn’t ever get tainted with anything .. allow the drama to happen because you love .. you are love ! And you are loved!
NOTHING.... BE AS IT IS
🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍
Can anyone please tell me why it says Ramana Das on the images ?
Please Google it.
Yes and no. Everything started from intention, thoughts, manifestation, if you act upon it whether is positive or negativity. You are acknowledging it then it will become a cycle whether you like it or not.
No wonder the questioner was so distraught and confused. Sanjay didn’t hep n the least. As Ramesh balsakar says “ there is no free will but act as if there is.”
Ps he was the translator for Nisargadatta Maharaj
Krishna das said Ma said its all grace,but act as its free will.
Ppl and their storys😂😂😂
🙏❤