I agree. I wish they’d made two smaller palettes. I just want the cool toned side and that palette is huge! I think they could have made it much smaller.
I am 100% with you that these would have been much, much better and appealing as TWO SEPARATE palettes, Amanda. If so, I only would have wanted the cool, grungy side, as I already not only have ND's Sunrise Midi palette, but quite a motherlode of pink/red/warm type palettes. I do love the vivid matte blushes, not all the glittery cheek stuff, though. However, I do have Nars Exhibit A and UD Quiver for the red, and many a bright peach and coral blush (like; TOO many!).
I like both sides, especially the cooler side, but I wish it were either smaller with less dead space or two separate palletes. I would have bought both! I just hate giant palletes. I like seeing more cheek products but not loving these for me. Your looks are beautiful as always! ❤ Thanks for the video!
Wow, I love the cool toned side! 🥰. I wish they were two palettes or at least that the pans were uniform and condensed. Same as your critiques Amanda. 🙂
Oden's Eye, what happened?!? Your highlighters in the Solmane 2 collection were lovely. A little hint of glitter, but mainly a lit from within glow. These recent releases are like 87% glitter and that silver one is topping 99% glitter 🥲
I know that in the past it looked like they had two formulas. One that was really sparkly glitter, and one that was very reflective but glow from within. I’m hoping someone with all the highlighters will show a comparison.
The packaging is giving me Sarah J Maas ACOTAR vibes ❤ the whole palette isn’t for me, but I love the packaging and I love the dark side! It would be interesting if they just realised each side as a separate palette.
I don't understand the highlight with sparkles, why?? The gunmetal and navy shimmers though, love! It's a hard pass for me, sorry Oden but thank you Amanda for the video and your honesty.
When I got the email about this I thought it looked too bright for me, but if you cover the bright coral matte and bright purple/pink shimmer, it actually looks really wearable.
I totally agree with everyone else. It would have been better as two palettes. It also looks slightly uninspired. I've gone off OE. The last thing I purchased from them was a Angelica's green collab palette. Ever since then, nothing has spoken to me.
I don't know. I think your idea for the two separate palettes is much better than one big palette. Aside from the size, the color story feels... I don't know, boring? uninspired? Idk, it feels very much done before and not even that good of a version. It reminds me a lot of the Nomad Love & Death palette but the bright side being more like that coral 9-pan palette from Colourpop with the square pans and transparent packaging. Also for a palette with 'shadow' in its name you'd think it would have more depth
They kinda put all of their creativity into the packaging and artwork than in the actual product itself 🤷🏻♀️ I’m so annoyed that this isn’t two separate collections and all that dead space in the pallet.
Have to agree, at least 4 of the palest shimmers would look the same on the eye from anyone standing a few feet back. I would rather have seen either more colour in the palette, or curate it down to a smaller size. That said, I'd totally buy a few of the other shimmer shades if they were sold as singles.
As a mythology fan I’m on board with the palette concept. But like some others have noted, I think I would have preferred two separate palette Reminds me of Nomad Romeo and Juliet themed Love and Death palette and I only wanted the cool side of that palette also😅😅. The matte blushes have my attention. I have Nars Exhibit A and yes it’s similar but definitely more tomato red
I’m over huge pallets that can’t be stored easily in my makeup drawer. This seems off to me as far as how things are trending. If this was 2 separate pallets, I might buy one or both- but such a large pallets doesn’t interest me.
I think it’s probably a typo in the palette which makes sense since O.E. isn’t from an English speaking country 😬 or they just made up their own cool word 🤣
This palette just…. isn’t for me. I agree it would have worked better as separate palettes, but also, I find a lot of the tones/colors too similar. I would have changed escape and daylight for instance. And am I the only one thinking it looks a lot like Nomad’s Verona Love & Death? I’m not suggesting anything but….
It is screaming to fold in half. They should have made it like the saga of freja or done 2 separate palettes. Odens eye is getting quite boring recently. I'm not seeing anything original with their colour stories.
They recently started a sister company. Maybe dividing their attention/creativity between the two is actually hurting the brand? I like many aspects of this release but feel like it's just not thought through as well.
I wish they would have done it in 2 palettes, also. I really like the cool tone Shadow side.
Yeah I'm not digging this palette at all, not just the size but how the pans don't match up in line. Should've been 2 separate palettes
Just like the Nomad Verona palette, I wish they had divided it. I love the aesthetic, but I won't be purchasing this one.
I agree. I wish they’d made two smaller palettes. I just want the cool toned side and that palette is huge! I think they could have made it much smaller.
The double sided “book” style would have been a better choice for packaging
I am 100% with you that these would have been much, much better and appealing as TWO SEPARATE palettes, Amanda. If so, I only would have wanted the cool, grungy side, as I already not only have ND's Sunrise Midi palette, but quite a motherlode of pink/red/warm type palettes. I do love the vivid matte blushes, not all the glittery cheek stuff, though. However, I do have Nars Exhibit A and UD Quiver for the red, and many a bright peach and coral blush (like; TOO many!).
I like both sides, especially the cooler side, but I wish it were either smaller with less dead space or two separate palletes. I would have bought both! I just hate giant palletes. I like seeing more cheek products but not loving these for me. Your looks are beautiful as always! ❤ Thanks for the video!
Wow, I love the cool toned side! 🥰. I wish they were two palettes or at least that the pans were uniform and condensed. Same as your critiques Amanda. 🙂
MY JAW DROPPED AT THE SWATCHES OF THE RIGHT SIDE
Same. I'm not a cool toned person but that right side is DIVINE.
I only want the cool half 😩😩😩
Me too!!! 💚🖤💜🩶💙
@@nancytipton7602 give us the grungy moody cool tones 🖤
Interested in the 2 blushes only. I wish that these were 2 different pallets. I love the warm side. Thank you for your in depth review.
Oden's Eye, what happened?!? Your highlighters in the Solmane 2 collection were lovely. A little hint of glitter, but mainly a lit from within glow. These recent releases are like 87% glitter and that silver one is topping 99% glitter 🥲
I know that in the past it looked like they had two formulas. One that was really sparkly glitter, and one that was very reflective but glow from within. I’m hoping someone with all the highlighters will show a comparison.
So pretty but I’m gonna have to wait and do a big haul for Black Friday, cause my wallet. Plus your collab is calling to me 😂❤
The more I look at this the more I really like it.
I like the matte blushes! I'm not to sure about the highlighters. Both of your eye looks turned out so pretty!
I looooove glittery highlighters so these are right up my alley 😍
I'm not into OE, but I Love to watch your videos! 😊
The packaging is giving me Sarah J Maas ACOTAR vibes ❤ the whole palette isn’t for me, but I love the packaging and I love the dark side! It would be interesting if they just realised each side as a separate palette.
I don't understand the highlight with sparkles, why?? The gunmetal and navy shimmers though, love!
It's a hard pass for me, sorry Oden but thank you Amanda for the video and your honesty.
is there an overspray on their highlighters?
Nope they are just super glittery 🤣
These blushes and highlighters look amazing!!!
Not related, but I was wondering if you'd do reviews on cp transfer proof lipstick? 😉 curious whether the shades are purty and comfy
When I got the email about this I thought it looked too bright for me, but if you cover the bright coral matte and bright purple/pink shimmer, it actually looks really wearable.
Gentle firefly 💜
I don't even wear highlighter, but yowza!
I really like the blue tone eye look best. The pallette is very beautiful and the two matte blushes. Thanks for making this video.💙🍂🤎🏵️👍✔️✔️❤️❗🍁⭐
I totally agree with everyone else. It would have been better as two palettes. It also looks slightly uninspired. I've gone off OE. The last thing I purchased from them was a Angelica's green collab palette. Ever since then, nothing has spoken to me.
The warm colors look gorgeous on you ♡
I don't know. I think your idea for the two separate palettes is much better than one big palette. Aside from the size, the color story feels... I don't know, boring? uninspired? Idk, it feels very much done before and not even that good of a version. It reminds me a lot of the Nomad Love & Death palette but the bright side being more like that coral 9-pan palette from Colourpop with the square pans and transparent packaging. Also for a palette with 'shadow' in its name you'd think it would have more depth
Bf upcoming, got my eye on the matte blushers.
The packaging is beautiful! I think I finally talked myself out of it. I like your idea if it was 2 separate palettes and they could fit together.
I was eyeing that Subtle Radiance highlighter but I didn’t expect it to be a glitter bomb on the cheeks 😔
They kinda put all of their creativity into the packaging and artwork than in the actual product itself 🤷🏻♀️ I’m so annoyed that this isn’t two separate collections and all that dead space in the pallet.
Have to agree, at least 4 of the palest shimmers would look the same on the eye from anyone standing a few feet back. I would rather have seen either more colour in the palette, or curate it down to a smaller size. That said, I'd totally buy a few of the other shimmer shades if they were sold as singles.
I feel OE aid trying to set a trend with the extra sparkly highlighters rather then follow tends. I’m not drawn to the extra pizzaz
As a mythology fan I’m on board with the palette concept. But like some others have noted, I think I would have preferred two separate palette Reminds me of Nomad Romeo and Juliet themed Love and Death palette and I only wanted the cool side of that palette also😅😅. The matte blushes have my attention. I have Nars Exhibit A and yes it’s similar but definitely more tomato red
Definitely wish this was 2 palettes, the warm side does nothing for me
I’m over huge pallets that can’t be stored easily in my makeup drawer. This seems off to me as far as how things are trending. If this was 2 separate pallets, I might buy one or both- but such a large pallets doesn’t interest me.
Is luminosity spelled Liminosity? Or i can't read?
I think it’s probably a typo in the palette which makes sense since O.E. isn’t from an English speaking country 😬 or they just made up their own cool word 🤣
@@MakeupJustForFun thanks for confirming.
This palette just…. isn’t for me. I agree it would have worked better as separate palettes, but also, I find a lot of the tones/colors too similar. I would have changed escape and daylight for instance.
And am I the only one thinking it looks a lot like Nomad’s Verona Love & Death? I’m not suggesting anything but….
I thought of the Nomad palette too.
The packaging is beautiful as expected. The size and half warm tone just doesn't do it for me. The looks you did are pretty.
Ugh. Why sparkly, glittery highlighters? I just don’t understand this collection
It is screaming to fold in half. They should have made it like the saga of freja or done 2 separate palettes. Odens eye is getting quite boring recently. I'm not seeing anything original with their colour stories.
Yes! Not to shade anyone but tbh I think the perfect world collection was their last good release. Everything after that just hasn't been very good :/
They recently started a sister company. Maybe dividing their attention/creativity between the two is actually hurting the brand? I like many aspects of this release but feel like it's just not thought through as well.
@@pauwula yes that was my last palette I bought from them. They really fell flat after their first Xmas collection