I've listened to this performance for many times now. Wow, how great! Not only this M&O organ sounds great, but the way mr. Marshall plays this piece is truly amazing!
Unbelievable authentic sound! Of course, I'm not sitting in the room where this organ is being played, but I"ve listened to many of M&O organs on here and I think the best attribute of such authentic sound is that, unlike the many [very good] electronic organs made by others, one never tires of the sound from a M&O organ.....because...one forgets he's listening to an electronic organ. That's amazing.
Brilliant, the reg in the 1st movement was wonderful, such intricate sounds were produced. The duet in the 2nd movement was sublime. 3rd movement showed Bach out-Beethovened Beethoven. Such a banal theme turned into a masterwork then done upside down, such a showoff he was! There are some fugues in the WTC with themes like this, herky jerky that he just toys with and spins into music. The sound of this organ is amazing, my orchestral ears are just buzzing with new sounds. Performance was just as Bach should be played, sometimes tenderness, sometimes with momentum. Bach doesn't need all this rubato performers are doing. I just loved this, thanks.
What a superb performance. I agree with other posters: the registration is definitive, and the performance brings out the subtle interactions among the three voices. Wonderful. Need to hear more!
I love this work. It's one of my favorites from Bach. My favorite thing is by far the registration used in the first movement. It has a sort of sparkle to it that most north German organs seem to have about them.
A delightful work, beautifully and confidently played. And wonderful technique, Mr. Marshall! Makes me wish I had started piano in grade school instead of high school.
Have a look at their website: they not only build new organs with AGO consoles, they also do additions to exisitng pipe organs and complete rebuilds of electronic organs. However, from what I recall, not only dimensions and standards used by Royal College of Organists were only slightly different, but were pretty much abandoned in favor of AGO specs. If the stoptabs are an issue, have a look at their first instrument (Opus 1) at Trinity Wallstreet.
Very nice pedal-work in movt 1 and I love the embellishments in the 3rd...one gets so used to hearing this played 'clean' and with no improvised ornaments...nice! I still hesitate to believe that this isn't a genuine pipe organ..even listening on headphones! :-)
@BigOrganPipes Yes, it has four Trinity subs. The only organ, so far, with rotary woofers is our Opus 4 at Middle Collegiate Church. The specs are available on our web site.
great playing! very difficult, as are all the others - beautiful registration! alexander Brown - Composer of "Fuga in tempore cprpnae" [among others, also here on YT. 👏👏👏
Electronic is more accurate. 'Electric' organ could mean an organ with a motor for air prodcution for an electrostatic reed organ, or a motor for tone wheels...'electronic' is a exclusively non moving parts and operates from tubes,transistors, IC's, and of course digital. This organ sounds very good. And I'm not big on digital. Excellent playing too!
bonne interprétation mais ma préférence va à une interprétation très peu connu et pourtant, selon moi, sans équivalent, celle de Kei Keito (enregistrement rarissime à trouver)
Is is fine to use Romantic registration in a Baroque work these days? Sounds like a Clarinet (LH) in the second movement or is it the Krumhorn or Seskwalter?
I think the idea is to sell electronic-pipe organs with the Rodgers name. Tempi are way too fast and historically uninformed, but notes are there and repertoire is vast unlike for most salespeople.
M&O electronic organs only sound good because they use recorded samples of real pipe organs. Same goes for pretty much all modern electronic organs. If forced to produce their own sounds, they would fail to sound convincing.
Computational fluid dynamics are starting to get good enough that, for example, the makers or Organteq might disagree. I have no relationship with them, but their audio clips sound pretty good to me. www.modartt.com/organteq
The first and second movements are well measured,sober and lightly registered, alas the last movement does not belong to the same performance, loud, flashy and bombastic finishes the work more like a romantic concerto. Shame.
He plays this so well. Bach would be impressed.
yes
The intricate delicacy of which Bach was such a master. Amazing and beautiful.
This music "separates the men from the boys".
Great job.
I've listened to this performance for many times now. Wow, how great! Not only this M&O organ sounds great, but the way mr. Marshall plays this piece is truly amazing!
agree
0:00-Allegro moderato 3:05-Adagio 9:06-Allegro
Unbelievable authentic sound! Of course, I'm not sitting in the room where this organ is being played, but I"ve listened to many of M&O organs on here and I think the best attribute of such authentic sound is that, unlike the many [very good] electronic organs made by others, one never tires of the sound from a M&O organ.....because...one forgets he's listening to an electronic organ. That's amazing.
Brilliant, the reg in the 1st movement was wonderful, such intricate sounds were produced. The duet in the 2nd movement was sublime. 3rd movement showed Bach out-Beethovened Beethoven. Such a banal theme turned into a masterwork then done upside down, such a showoff he was! There are some fugues in the WTC with themes like this, herky jerky that he just toys with and spins into music. The sound of this organ is amazing, my orchestral ears are just buzzing with new sounds. Performance was just as Bach should be played, sometimes tenderness, sometimes with momentum. Bach doesn't need all this rubato performers are doing. I just loved this, thanks.
What a superb performance. I agree with other posters: the registration is definitive, and the performance brings out the subtle interactions among the three voices. Wonderful. Need to hear more!
Lovely instrument! Great registration and performance. I love these Trio Sonatas!
Thank you, Les!
Yes, this organ is digital, built by Doug Marshall and David Ogletree of M&O. Cameron Carpenter designed the stop list and the layout of the console.
I love this work. It's one of my favorites from Bach. My favorite thing is by far the registration used in the first movement. It has a sort of sparkle to it that most north German organs seem to have about them.
Love the sound of this organ, has such a beautiful sound!!
What an amazing performance! Wonderful phrasing, articulation, and registration. And a lovely instrument. Simply Wow!
I love the way you play the third mov!
Die beste Interpretation, die ich je gehört habe: Glückwunsch! The best interpretation, i ever have heard! Congratulations!
A delightful work, beautifully and confidently played.
And wonderful technique, Mr. Marshall! Makes me wish I had started piano in grade school instead of high school.
Indesputable masterpiece. Perfomance was terrrific. Enjoyed very much. Thank you.
Very clear palying! The execution is so clear and nice!
Greetings from Italy
Wonderful performance by *Doug Marshall* ! Also nice views. Thank you.
He makes it look so easy
Beautiful sound, great technique! Amazing interpretation!
love this mans style and the organ is grouse
I love your playing on all the recordings I've watched.
Have a look at their website: they not only build new organs with AGO consoles, they also do additions to exisitng pipe organs and complete rebuilds of electronic organs. However, from what I recall, not only dimensions and standards used by Royal College of Organists were only slightly different, but were pretty much abandoned in favor of AGO specs. If the stoptabs are an issue, have a look at their first instrument (Opus 1) at Trinity Wallstreet.
Wonderful, well done teacher, your art is inspiring!.
Douglas, that was just fabulous!
I have watched this video about 300 times
Wonderful performance!
バッハのトリオソナタ難しいのですよね、素晴らしい魂のこもった演奏です。
BWV525は一番好まれていますが私は526や528も好きです😂
Very nice pedal-work in movt 1 and I love the embellishments in the 3rd...one gets so used to hearing this played 'clean' and with no improvised ornaments...nice! I still hesitate to believe that this isn't a genuine pipe organ..even listening on headphones! :-)
This is an old comment but: checkout the videos under the "Proof of Concept" on their website. They're a mindblowing experience.
Wonderful!!! I really enjoyed this performance, it makes very positive vibs. Congrats!
Very good
nice...I like the phrasing...awesome..!
@BigOrganPipes Yes, it has four Trinity subs. The only organ, so far, with rotary woofers is our Opus 4 at Middle Collegiate Church. The specs are available on our web site.
EXCELLENT!, in every way!
nádherné, excelentné.....
Stupenda!!
great playing! very difficult, as are all the others - beautiful registration!
alexander Brown - Composer of "Fuga in tempore cprpnae" [among others, also here on YT. 👏👏👏
Great Playing! Hello from Ft. Myers!
thanks for uploading! Love the trio sonatas, I'm even transcribing some to violin so I can play them (badly)
Very nice!
excelentná hra...
fantastická hra...
3:04 Adagio
9:05 Allegro
DIESE STÜCKE VON JOHANN SEBASTIAN BACH SIND DIE BESTEN
@BigOrganPipes Yes, mostly.
🎹👌🏼
how do you reach the top manuals and lowest ped notes with a short height
Oh cool. Does it also use the Def Tech Trinity subwoofers? What about rotary woofers? I'd love to see the full specs of everything.
How much does an organ like this cost? I'm guessing at least four or five hundred grand on the console alone plus the brains speakers subs and amps
Super !Vous êtes un élève de qui ?est-ce que vous venez donner des récital en France ?
Hi. Does this organ use Definitive Technology speakers like the Trinity Wall Street organ?
wow xd
Electronic is more accurate. 'Electric' organ could mean an organ with a motor for air prodcution for an electrostatic reed organ, or a motor for tone wheels...'electronic' is a exclusively non moving parts and operates from tubes,transistors, IC's, and of course digital.
This organ sounds very good. And I'm not big on digital. Excellent playing too!
bonne interprétation mais ma préférence va à une interprétation très peu connu et pourtant, selon moi, sans équivalent, celle de Kei Keito (enregistrement rarissime à trouver)
Is is fine to use Romantic registration in a Baroque work these days? Sounds like a Clarinet (LH) in the second movement or is it the Krumhorn or Seskwalter?
Skøn orgelmusik det er lige noget, jeg kan lide.
I think the idea is to sell electronic-pipe organs with the Rodgers name. Tempi are way too fast and historically uninformed, but notes are there and repertoire is vast unlike for most salespeople.
M&O electronic organs only sound good because they use recorded samples of real pipe organs. Same goes for pretty much all modern electronic organs. If forced to produce their own sounds, they would fail to sound convincing.
Computational fluid dynamics are starting to get good enough that, for example, the makers or Organteq might disagree. I have no relationship with them, but their audio clips sound pretty good to me. www.modartt.com/organteq
little fast E Flat Major one.
What a small portion of this instrument Bach needed! The rest is excess.
+Rick Marti Spot on.
The first and second movements are well measured,sober and lightly registered, alas the last movement does not belong to the same performance, loud, flashy and bombastic finishes the work more like a romantic concerto. Shame.