Kya Taurat Musa (AS) par Nazil nahi hui - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 бер 2022
- Kya Taurat Musa (AS) par Nazil nahi hui - Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
ہم کیسے ثابت کریں کہ، تورات حضرت موسیٰء پر نازل ہوئی!
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: ua-cam.com/users/ghamidicil?s...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ UA-cam: / ghamidicil
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #QnAGhamidi #AlMawridUS
Last gem 💎 of Ummah..... 'Raazdan fir naa karay gi koi paida aisa'....... Allah paak aapko Apnay hifzo amaan mai rakhay
حسن بھائی پلیز جس طرح پرویز احمد کو ایکسپوز کیا تھا استاد محترم نے اسی طرح شیخ کے نظریات اور اپنی طرف سے ہی قران کی تاویلات کرنے کے متعلق ایک تفصیلی پروگرام ریکارڈ کروائیں پلیز
Bilkul
These questions are related to a known scholar named Shaikh Muhammad. I will really appreciate if Ghamidi shb will give a detail reply video of the major concepts of Shaikh Muhammad. Allah ghamidi shb ko lambi zindagi de.
اللہ کی رحمت ہو آپ پر ہمیشہ۔ آمین
بہت شکریہ حسن بھی ان موضوعات پر سوال پوچھنے کا۔
اللہ پاک جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب کو لمبی عمر عطا فرمائے
Couldn't help but think about Muhammad Shekih while listening to this.
Alhamdulillah
Very Very clear
Jazak ALLAH khairan
Thank you sir. I understand. It is important. Thanks for clarifying.
Very realistic, authentic education
اللہ تعالیٰ فرماتا ہے کہ و من قبلہ کتاب موسی اماما و رحمہ ۔ ۔
1400 years history is not possible to save except Quran which is saved by allah remaining history is history we cannot say that history is reason for our Hidayat
یہ چودہ سو سالہ تاریخ کی بات نہیں ہو رہی،
جب ایک کتاب نازل ہو رہی ہے اس زمانے کی بات ہو رہی ہے۔
مثال کے طور پر آج کی کسی کتاب کو آپ آج کے دور کے مسلمات کو مد نظر رکھتے ہوئے پڑھتے ہیں۔
Mohammed Sheikh sahab ke pure sawalat ke jawab Kuran ke Roshani Mein gamidiSab de rahe hai
These great thoughts are I think contrary to the thought of shaikh Muhammad....who is continuity of Pervaizi thoughts of school... Nice to hear that scholar like ghamidi sahab beautifully addressed them
Love for ustaz-e-mohtram❤❤
ایک جملے میں شیخ کی شیخی نکال دی آپ نے اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکھے
Hahaha Hahaha yes
متشکرم استاد محترم
Surah Al Maidah.....verse # 46-48 explains Torah and injeel.
للہ پاک ہمیں دین کی بصیرت عطا فرماۓ آمین
Ghamidi Sahab is legend!!!❤️
Salaam. Could you please look into Dr Hany’s work on the Quran. He has done a different translation to the translation what we have. He is an Arabic scholar. He claims he has translated the the Quran according to original Arabic language.
So what’s the key difference?
@@noraiz5105 Salaam. Listen to one of his lecture. You will understand better.
@@jahangirakhtar4651 understand the Qur'an accord Ibrahim locution
@Jahangir Akhtar: Dr Shabbir also made such claim about his translation of the Quran.
Bahut khoobsurat jawab
💕
Mashallah
Al-Ma'idah 5:44
إِنَّآ أَنزَلْنَا ٱلتَّوْرَىٰةَ فِيهَا هُدًى وَنُورٌۚ يَحْكُمُ بِهَا ٱلنَّبِيُّونَ ٱلَّذِينَ أَسْلَمُواۡ لِلَّذِينَ هَادُواۡ وَٱلرَّبَّٰنِيُّونَ وَٱلْأَحْبَارُ بِمَا ٱسْتُحْفِظُواۡ مِن كِتَٰبِ ٱللَّهِ وَكَانُواۡ عَلَيْهِ شُهَدَآءَۚ فَلَا تَخْشَوُاۡ ٱلنَّاسَ وَٱخْشَوْنِ وَلَا تَشْتَرُواۡ بِـَٔايَٰتِى ثَمَنًا قَلِيلًاۚ وَمَن لَّمْ يَحْكُم بِمَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ فَأُوۡلَٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْكَٰفِرُونَ
English - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
Indeed, We revealed the Torah, containing guidance and light, by which the prophets, who submitted themselves to Allah, made judgments for Jews. So too did the rabbis and scholars judge according to Allah’s Book, with which they were entrusted and of which they were made keepers. So do not fear the people; fear Me! Nor trade my revelations for a fleeting gain. And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed are ˹truly˺ the disbelievers.
❤❤
Great scholar Ghamdi sab
Asslam o alakum.. Hassan ilyas sahib palz aik program sirf Muhammad sheikh k mutaliq krain .. plz
Good reply to mohammad sheikh
Asslamo alaikum ghamdi sahib quraan main hai k nabiyoon ne toraat se hukam kia is ki tafeel kar dain meherbani hogi
Afreen afreen ♥️♥️
Sir plzzzzzz. Shaikh Muhammad sab ka rad karo plzzzz
Ustad ❤️
Audio quality aaj kal kharab Hoti he, please iss ka Kuch kare
Asalam o Alikum, Sir mera aik important sawal hay,
Torat main Life after death ya jannat jahanam Qayamat akhrat ka zikar kyu nahi hay?
jab k sara quran es baat par base karta hay...
This is not the only issue with Muhammad Shaikh. Sb. There are quite a few things in his ideology.
1: Quran is the only book. Not the last /final book of Islam.
2: Quranic text was present even before prophet Muhammad bin Abdullah PBUH.
3: he uses Al kitaab word to explain things.
4: when was quran revealed?, answer is “ no time given”. Evidence: NONE. just translations of ayas , taken out of context, based on his questionable assumptions.
5: masjid nabwi IS ACTUALLY masjid e aqsa and Masjid e aqsa is ACTUALLY masjid e Zarrar.
6: quran is the ONLY source of deen.
7: method of salat is from Moqaam e Ibraheem, not transferred to us through sahaba as sunnah.
These are a few things that l could remember at this time and this is based on my understanding. May Allah SWT forgive me if I made a mistake.
In the end, Alhamdolillah for a teacher like Ghamidi. May Allah SWT bless you with long life. Amen.
Also. according to my understanding, even after spending decades on only quran, Muhammad Shaikh Sb. is not able to provide translation of even a single complete major surah of quran, based on his ideologies. I am not sure if anyone can even confirm that he is working on any at this time. To me, that’s a red flag. What I noticed is that he would quote ayas, translate them based on his principles and mostly ayas are quotes out of context, then join those ayas from different parts of quran and come up with an idea that is different from 99.99. % Muslims. May Allah SWT forgive me if I said something that’s isn’t true . Salam.
As Salam O Alaikum,
Dear brother we are accountable on what we have with us right now,and our deeds in such parameters,so we couldn't charged about the previous circumstances which was faced by olders,
As we seen the newly changes in all across tradition, education, (science)linguists and various trends of superbly designed life structure,
So you can struggle with present and available current values,
So as we have Al hamd o lillah Quran e Kareem, since last 1400 years with all principles and guidance of current affairs, upcoming warnings and previous destructions,(details of nations with signs)
So it's not worth to raise that it's early connected features, Ruling principles are the matter according to occurance, that is based on Right (Haqq)
@@umairsheikh2283 , brother I am not sure about the point you are trying to make here. Salam.
Excellent explainations
❤❤❤
salam Mujhe ap se aek sawal puchna he rahnumai fermaen.
This question was raised by Muhammad Sheikh
Kon hai yea sheikh...
Lajawabbbbbbbbbbbbb sir
بہت عرصہ سے یہ سوالات تھے جو سوشل میڈیا پر بلخصوص محمد شیخ کی مجلسوں میں اٹھاۓ جاتے تھے آج الحمدللہ استاذ محترم نے انکے جوابات دے کر یہ گراہ کھول دی ھے
Taurat, Zaboor, Injeel, Quran, Furqan, Zikar etc. These all are the attributes of one Book/ Kalam of Allah
I agreed with you 100% dear same like rahman , Rahim , karim is tribute of Allah , and second if these books are diffrent books then how allah can say us you people verify what ever these nonmuslims are saying because these non Muslims written books by his hands and if they are saying froM kitab Of allah so it will be same , like kitab in my hom and other Muslims are same no change
seren dipitous dear injeel means good news , tuarat means law , about good news allah told give good news to momin , and we know quran is qanon also in chapter Imran allah told this book having to type of verses one is hokom means qanon law , so brother this all are same no change , if you read chemistry in class 10 and after 20 years you got PHD in chemistry what ever you read in class 10 that is same no diffrece ,
seren dipitous and brother in chapter Imran ayat number 23 you can check plz in that ayat allah mention from main book I given part to them so from that ayat we can understand that main book is one and previous generations they got parts from it , for example I am PhD student in chemistry so from main chemistry knowledge I got one small portion in 10 class + 11 + 12 classes so on and finally I got full book , what I am thinking book 📖 is same no change
Many things brother I can share with you but typing and writing is difficult, did you seen that allah told that I given to musa a book which is furqan and allah also told this this book Quran is also furqan , this is also evidence that book are same no change
Ghamdi Sahib we were expecting little bit more strong and knowledge able explanation of the Issue. The answer is very lame. You need to explain it the light of Quranic ayat.
Sir.... Sari zindagi anadze hi lgane h ya amal bhi karna h
محمد شیخ صاحب کہتے ہیں کہ ایمان آیت پر ھونا چاھئے ،غامدی صاحب فرما رہے کہ قرآن میں ھر چیز کا ھونا ضروری نہیں تو پھر فرقان کس کو بنائیں گے فیصلے کے لئے 🤔
Bilkul sahi kaha quran ko furqan na samajhna bhi gunah hai
Sabit krne ki zroorat nahi.. understood hai
Ustad e Muhtaram ❤❤
Maharbani kar ke 1 aur program Karen aur tafseel se bataen with qurani aayat
اگر اس دلیل کو مانا جائے تو اس کی ضرورت کیا تھی کہ زبور کے متعلق وضاحت کی گئی کہ یہ حضرت داؤد ء پر نازل ہوئی تھی
Torah means the law, not necessarily a book.
Salik means the traveller and not the name of a person. Can you see the problem with this approach?
Torah is book jisme allah ki batayi law v h hidayat aur noor v
Sirf torat ki meaning par mat jao .means se sirf law nikalta h
Lekin allah quran me ho farmata h
Isme hidayat h aur noor v jis tarah quraan ke liye aur injil ke liye v kaha h
Great reply to Mohammed Sheikh, very unfortunate that Mohammed Sheikh despite giving lectures for over 30 years didn't put effort in to learning the Arabic language. Trying to understand the true meanings of Allama Iqbals poetry through an English or Chinese translation will no doubt lead to mistakes. The quran is a master piece in Arabic literature and the naunces of a language can only be understood when one has a good grasp of that language. That's where in many places Mohammed Sheikh in places makes errors.
Why did Allah wrote " We gave Musa the Book" , why did not a single time He wrote taurat with Musa AS name? If its obvious then why Allah mentioned that we gave Musa the book? It was also not needed.
Sorry to say but Such an illogical explanation Ghamidi Sahab. And the truth is that you can't show a single ayat mentioning MUSA AS name with the word Taurat!
Infact it's given with EEsa AS, both taurat and injeel! You can't give a logical explanation from a single Ayat as Muhammad Sheikh does ! May Allah bless him and his family, Ameen.
@@bushraumair3234 great ur right
Please ask javaid ahmad sb to explain what Quran says about toraat.
Ya log KIA btaay ga
nuyark aur lahor ko to proof kiya ja skta hai ki vo aaj hai .ye dunya hai.din me kaie sabit krge ki musa ko torat di.aur vo kha hai ya use utha liya gya.usme kya likha tha.
According to your logic, why was there a need to introduce Zaboor that was given to Dawood (p) it was already known, why was Taurat/ Injeel introduced with Eesa (p) when it was already known and examples can go on an on.
Very disappointed to hear your point of view. Al Kitab is Furqaan and we need to judge it from it. Very weak argument and examples of cities, that way we all know who Abrahim is but Quran tells us who the real Abrahim is, so is Moosa and others. 🥲
بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم
السلام علیکم الیاس اچھا کیا آپ نے اس زبان و بیان کے قواعد سے منحرف شخص محمد شیخ کا نام لیے بغیر آپ نے ردّ کردیا ۔
I think Muhammad sheikh K uthaye gaye Sawal Hain ye me ne Uska Session dekha hua hai;
حسن بھائی پلیزملوا دیں جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب سے ایک دفعہ
Aajka Ilmo hikmet suna tha Fb per, Ghamidi sahib aap nay wo sub chezun ko mozoh banaya jo Imran Khan sahib say mutahliq hain. Main ummeed ker raha tha k aap say munharag arkaam k baaray main b raiy le jaiuge k unka amal kesa tha? Kiya unain astefaah day ker dobara aa ker oppositoon kerni chahyay thee ya abhi pti voters ka vote lay ker opposition k sath milna chahyay tha?
شیخ محمد کا نظریہ ہے یہ
very logical and technical answers by a giant SCHOLAR OF ISLAM!
یہ ایک لطیفہ ھے ۔ ۔
ایک بیبی اپنے شوہر سے ہر روز مار کھاتی تھی ۔ پڑوسن اس کو ایک میا جی کے پاس لے گئ مزاجی ذہین انسان تھا پورا ماجرا سن کر اسنے ایک شیشی بھر کردم کیا ھوا پانی یہ کہ کر دیا کہ جیسے ھی شوہر کے آنے کا وقت ھو فلفور شیشی کا ایک چمچ پانی اپنے منہ میں رکھ لے دھیان رھے نہ نگل نا ھے نہ تھوکنا ھے ۔ بیوی نے عمل کیا اس کی پٹائی بند ھو گئ ۔ دراصل وہ زبان دراز عورت تھی ۔
دنیآں میں زبان دراز مرد بھی کم نہیں
Aslam o Alaikum
sir apke swal ki smjh he nhi i
pehle to ap bolte han k torah ka quran man ziqr nhi phir ap ne kaha k Hazrat MUSA A.S ka ziqr nhi
meherbani farma k agaahi farma den
kyuki surah Al ahraaf man to wazeh ziqr ha toraat injeel or Hazrat MUSA A. S ka
Slam bhai , Bhai aik dusray scholer haih nauzbillah jin ka yeh akeda ha k Torat Musa AS ko d gai ha ya wo Quran k ilawa koi dusri book ha yeh kaha likha ha Quran may Ghamidi saab nay btaya k yeh likhnay ki zarurat e nai q k Looog phlay say e wakif thay k Torat Mosa AS ko d gai , dusra wo khtay haih taorat ka by word mean Kanoon ha Quran may murad musa as ki book nai blkay qanoon ha iska rad karnay k liay ghamidi saab nay jawab dia k koi b jab word bola jata us ka ilam pehlay say mojood hota yani k agar may usman bolu to is say murad aap aik Male e logay na k Aik saanp q k by word to usman ka matlab aik saanp hota yeh phaki k toor pay misaal d
قرآن میں لکھا ہے کہ اس سے پہلے کوئی کتاب نہیں اور نہ ہی علم کے کوئی آثار.
قرآن ہی فرقان اور ھماری ھدایت اور جنت و دوزخ کا معیار نہ کہ تاریخ وغیرہ.
محمد شیخ نے تورات کا موسی علیہ السلام کے ساتھ ذکر سورہ مائدہ 5 کی آیت 44 میں سب انبیاء کے ساتھ بتایا کیوں کہ موسی علیہ السلام رسول نبی تھے. جبکہ ان کے نام کے ساتھ لفظ تورات نہیں آیا. یہ سچائی کیوں چھپا رہے غامدی صاحب؟
The Only man who puts forward the #BookOfAllah in your hands and when he reads from it - the Arabic words of God with translation & essence, he clarifies the topic.
His 80*2 topics from #Quran and explanation shown within from the #Quran itself is matchless in the present day world.
His direct comparison with Bible highlights the perversion & misrepresentation, and fake news propagated in the world against the #BookOfAllah.
Besides, he himself is the first and true follower of the #Quran and its spirit after his dedication to this cause of Allah 30 plus years ago. He has been living through the Eternal words of God.
#MuhammadShaikh #AllahKaBanda #QuranKaBashar at
ua-cam.com/users/MUHAMMADSHAIKH
ua-cam.com/video/6XtpNg6fvvM/v-deo.html
Aap ne sahi tarike se jawab nahi deeya, tawrat ki history nhi batai, AAp se details mein ansure ki ummid thee
Tum engineer se sawal pucho...yaha waqt barbaad mat karo
Taurat, Zaboor, Injeel, Quran, Furqan, Zikar, Kalam etc. These all are the attributes of One Book of Allah
Hahaha…seems like you have seen Muhammad Sheikh lecture. Holy Quran 2:139
------------------
قُلْ أَتُحَاجُّونَنَا فِي اللَّهِ وَهُوَ رَبُّنَا وَرَبُّكُمْ وَلَنَا أَعْمَالُنَا وَلَكُمْ أَعْمَالُكُمْ وَنَحْنُ لَهُ مُخْلِصُونَ
Say: Will ye dispute with us about Allah, seeing that He is our Lord and your Lord; that we are responsible for our doings and ye for yours; and that We are sincere (in our faith) in Him?
🤔🤔🤔 laiken hamko aisa sabat krnay ke zarurat kyun aa gyee
Israel is one of the companion of Prophet Noah PBUH. His progeny is Bani Israel.
Assalam Alekum, Ghamdi Saheb aur aapkay sathi, ab time yeh bataain karnay ka nahin hai. Aaj duniya bhar kay Musliman har qism ki parasyhani main giraya hain. Inko theek karnay kay liyay maidan main utarin. Sirf waaz say kutch nahin honay ka.
Waa Alaikum As Salam,
True correction make the change,
First human being then society and then finally Humanity,
Musalman means to surrender under the light of divine education,
That was naive ghulam khusro aka Muhammad sheikh.
Javed ghamidi:1
Muhammad sheikh:0
Baghwhat Geeta is book of Hindus which Is not written in Quran so can we deny that Geeta is not Hindus book
This is a very strange explanation from such a big scholar ...Ok Then why in the Quran "Tarah" was not even called a Book? and to Moses ES Allah said he give Him Book and Furqan...Surah 2 ayat 53 ".And ˹remember˺ when We gave Moses the Book -the standard ˹to distinguish between right and wrong˺ that perhaps you would be ˹rightly˺ guided. and which book the same book Surah 2 ayat 2 ".This is the Book! There is no doubt about it1-a guide for those mindful ˹of Allah˺,
After long time I did not agreed with you about tourat, tourat is qanoon and allah ka qanoon is included in Quran , but kitab which is with jews about that book allah told they wrote this book by his own handes and they are telling this is from allah , tuarat is name of Quran , furqan is name Of Quran , sultan is name is quran , injil is name of Quran , al wahee is name of Quran same like allah is name and rahman is name of allah , Rahim is name of Allah .
sorry to say but that is not a very logical answer by GHamidi.
So in other words, Allah does not mention something because everybody already knows it from before??? really??
Then why in the world did Allah mention that He gave Injeel to Isa(as) ? 5:46
Didnt people already know this?
Then why in the world did Allah mention that He gave Dawood(as) the Zaboor? 4:163, 17:55
Didnt people already know this???
Remember, there is no change in Allah’s sunnah/practice (33:62, 35:43), so the same principle should be applied here.
Does Ghamidi’s reply even make sense?? In other words, in 620 AD, Allah mentions about Injeel , which is 600 years ago but not Torah which is 3500 years old!
Like seriously????
People need to be reminded about older things, not recent things.
Sorry Mr. Ghamidi, your answer does not make sense.
If Physicists discover a new law of physics, they will be forced to update an existing text book of Physics. Does this mean they wont include the Newtons Laws in it just because everybody already knows it??? Of Course not.
Everybody knows that the symbol of water is H2O. If chemists discover a new element and need to update the periodic table and hence come up with an updated text book, do you think they wont mention H2O because everybody already knows it from before???? What kind of logic is that???
Hence Ghamidi’s principle falls flat on its face. I am absolutely baffled at his response and further baffled at how people are actually liking his response!
Allah’s book is for guidance (2:2, 17:9) , hence by definition it should contain the necessary points for guidance. It cannot happen that important information be left out, specially when Allah Himself wrote that He doesnt omit anything from The Book (6:38)
--------
Musa(as) is the most mentioned prophet in the quran , 136 times. The word Tawrat comes 18 times and there is not a single ayat in the quran which connects the both.
Can you imagine!!!
Instead of pondering and thinking as to why this information is missing, Ghamidi tries to rationalize with an answer which doesnt make any sense.
Fact is that there is nowhere that Allah says that He gave Musa(as) a book by the name of Tawrat.
3:84 says that We have to believe what was given to Musa(as).
So lets ask Allah Himself, what He gave to Musa(as).
Allah says He gave Musa(as) the following:
The Furqan 2:53
Sultan 4:153
Nine clear signs 17:101
Guidance 40:53
Tablets 7:145
Zia 21:48
Zikar 21:48
Al-Kitab (written 8 times 2:53, 2:87, 6:154, 17:2, 23:49, 25:35, 28:43, 41:45)
Now look at this, look at this…….what are the odds that in 6236 verses, not once….not once Allah says that He gave Musa(as) the Tawart???
Like seriously…….Allah says 8 times that He gave Al-Kitab to Musa(as)....8 times. Why couldnt He have said once that it was Tawrat?
Irony is that for centuries, we are being taught what Allah has not mentioned or written in His book.
And what Allah mentions……………nobody is teaching us. Can you imagine?
Like, i bet, nobody has heard that Allah gave Musa(as) Zia!....what is Zia? Has anyone heard it?
--------
Fact is that the jews have hijacked this word
Yes, Allah says that He revealed/Anzalna the Tawrat 5:44, but every word which has the word NAZIL (and its derivatives) connected to it does not become a book by default.
Allah revealed/anzalna the Meezan/balance (57:25). Meezan is not a separate book.
Allah revealed/Nazil Hadid/Iron (57:25), Iron is not a book
Allah revealed/Nazil Water from the sky (50:9) Rain is not a book.
By the way, there are many people in Africa who do not know where Lahore is and many in the world who do ot know where New York is.
Quran is for whole mankind for guidance 2:185, not only for the elite highly educated who have more knowledge than an average person.
A very poor reply by Ghamidi.
1st book taurat
2nd zaboor
3rd injeel
4th quran
Go backwards
Quran on Mohammad s
Before mohammad the era of esa Ebn e mariyam was there yani bible was there. More over surah jin also states the when they said we have heard something similar when they heard quran from mohammad s .
In another surah it is clearly mention zaboor was given to daud and when he use to recite the mountains us to tasbee along. So we are left with one book. That is torah. If you read quran and read musa as story which is mentioned several times was prepared for 40 days and he was called over to the mountain . When he came back and saw the cow was being worshipped he lost his mind and threw the plates he was carrying. Basically it was TAURAT.
Quran ko ahista parha karo
Taakay samjh sako
Jawed sb,,lakin agr aap Gujrat/hydrabad kahenge to aap ko batana hoga ke ye India wala h ya Pakistan wala.,,mtlb ye ke aap ka logic thoda illogical sa lga.Mazerat
Sir Ghamdi sb.plz be factual,don't depend upon perception.like your type and scholars,it is sad that instead of proving from Quran,u r coating only n only perception.When Quran is not proving that tourah was given to Moosa?
While Quran syas about tourait not tourah.
Quran is clearly declaring in writing by name that Al Kitab was given to Moosa.So,plz don't suppose,its the matter of Quran?Your views r totally not convincing at all.
مفید گُفتگو۔۔۔۔۔
ایسے سوالات تو پوچھنے کے قابل بھی نہیں ہوتے ہیں۔یہ سوالات کس بیوقوف انسان کے دماغ میں آئے؟
bakwas ki ha
Why did Allah wrote " We gave Musa the Book" , why did not a single time He wrote taurat with Musa AS name? If its obvious then why Allah mentioned that we gave Musa the book? It was also not needed.
Sorry to say but Such an illogical explanation Ghamidi Sahab. And the truth is that you can't show a single ayat mentioning MUSA AS name with the word Taurat!
Infact it's given with EEsa AS, both taurat and injeel! You can't give a logical explanation from a single Ayat as Muhammad Sheikh does ! May Allah bless him and his family, Ameen.
Miner.ahdees.zandeq