My list would go: 14: Big World Big Adventures 13: Misty Island Rescue 12: Thomas and the Magic Railroad 11: Day of the Diesels 10: Journey Beyond Sodor 9: Calling all Engines 8: The Great Race 7: Hero of the Rails 6: Blue Mountain Mystery 5: King of the Railway 4: Tale of the Brave 3: The Great Discovery 2: The Adventure Begins 1: Sodors Legend of the Lost Treasure
My list(Personal)is: 14:Big world big adventurs: 13:Misty island rescue: 12:Hero of the rails: 11:Thomas and the magic railroad: 10:the great race: 9: Sodor Beyond journey: 8:Blu mountain mistery: 7:Day of the diesels: 6:Adventures Begins: 5:King of the railway 4:Calling on engines 3:The Great discovery 2:Sodor legend of the lost treasure 1:Tale of the brave
@Carmine Lago ah beh allora dillo subito comunque ricorda che anche il Film di Marc Forster(che teoricamente dovrebbe uscire nel 2024)non sarà canonico per il franchise, dato che sarà un ibrido tra live action e CGI(che in teoria dovrebbe essere o buono o addirittura spettacolare, magari tipo SLOTLT).
My First and Top Movie of all is The Great Discovery. I mean in my opinion, everything about it was so GREAT to the sing alongs especially the first one in the beginning, crashes were so phenomenal, and there’s even a fricking rap song in the outro which was really epic and other Great things about The Great Discovery and Stanley was such a GREAT and REMARKABLE Character and everything about him was so GREAT to me including his Theme Song which was really Splendid and that’s why he’s one of my most favourite character in the show, but it’s just sad that he didn’t get a lot of attention nor did he get a lot of screen time in future episodes ever since which makes him such an underrated character, and I really miss Stanley so much. The Title of the movie is also fitting since this is the that movie made me DISCOVER and introduced me to this show that’ll live with me for years and it’s also the first movie I’ve ever watched which is GREAT.
2:19: Wait, but are you sure? I saw a playlist of video clips from the full-movie of The Great Discovery (2008), and I'm pretty sure I only saw, like, 1 or 2 learning segments in them. I also think it would be a great movie because of how much of the majority of engines are shown. This was the final all-model T&F production before Season 12 came out that same year. In fact, both came out back when I was a newborn. So, boy am I glad I grew up along the so-called "hated (2/3: Nitrogen (excluding HOTR (Hero of the Rails) and BMM (Blue Mountain Mystery) & BWBA)" CGI series of Thomas.
Nice little Top 14 list! Honestly, I know that TATMR has its flaws, but ever since T1E2H3 did his review on the movie, I’ve always had a soft spot for it. And I still think it’s better than BWBA or anything Miller could have given us!
Another thing I don't like in The Great Race is how darn long it takes to get to the railway show. It takes literally like, two thirds of the movie just to arrive. And when they get there, every game is rushed in like 5 minutes so they can cut to the chase with Gordon's safety valve, Thomas at the shunting competition, Vinnie's defeat and heading back home again, all in like a rushed 20 minutes.
My favourite is great discovery bc I love how Thomas tumbles down the hill The sad noises when thomas was in the Cave were extraordinary I also like lost treasure tho
Here's my list: 14: Big World Big Adventures (3.5/10) 13: Thomas and the magic railroad (4/10) 12: Misty Island rescue (4.5/10) 11: Day of the diesels (5/10) 10: king of the railway (5.5/10) 9: tale of the brave (6/10) 8: Calling all engines (6.5/10) (guilty pleasure) 7: the great race (7/10) 6: Journey beyond Sodor (7.5/10) 5: Hero of the rails (8/10) 4: Blue Mountain mystery (8.5/10) 3: Sodor's legend of the lost treasure (9/10) 2: the great discovery (9.5/10) 1: the adventure begins (10/10)
@@duckstudios3687 Here’s my list: 14. The Great Discovery 13. Big World! Big Adventures! 12. Journey Beyond Sodor 11. Blue Mountain Mystery 10. Thomas And The Magic Railroad 9. King Of The Railway 8. Day Of The Diesels 7. The Great Race 6. Hero Of The Rails 5. The Adventure Begins 4. Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure 3. Misty Island Rescue 2. Tale Of The Brave 1. Calling All Engines
But This is the reason why I like Blue Mountain Mystery Pros 1. Narrow Gadge Characters Returned 2. Victors Backstory was Good 3. Awesome Writing 4. Diesel was a good choice for a villian 5. Luke's character development during the movie was good 6. Felt Like a improvement for the Thomas and Friends Franchise
Updated ranking 14: Calling all engines 13: Thomas and the magic railroad 12: Journey Beyond Sodor 11: Big World big adventures 10: The great discovery 9: Day of the diesels 8: The adventure begins 7: Sodors legend of the lost treasure 6: The great race 5: Blue Mountain Mystery 4: Misty Island Rescue 3: Hero of the rails 2: Tale of the brave 1: King of the railway
Calling All Engine Pros 1. Return of some old characters from Britt Allcroft era 2. The Music was memorable 3. The Props and sets they used for this film was awesome! 4. The Diesels vs Steamies fighting scene was the best crash scenes 5. Crashes were awesome! Cons 1. Derek Didn't have that much screen time
Yeah, but for me, it’s actually my second favourite on the list, My First and Top Movie of all is The Great Discovery. I mean in my opinion, everything about it was so GREAT to the sing alongs especially the first one in the beginning, crashes were so phenomenal, and there’s even a fricking rap song in the outro which was really epic and other Great things about The Great Discovery and Stanley was such a GREAT and REMARKABLE Character and everything about him was so GREAT to me including his Theme Song which was really Splendid and that’s why he’s one of my most favourite character in the show, but it’s just sad that he didn’t get a lot of attention nor did he get a lot of screen time in future episodes ever since which makes him such an underrated character, and I really miss Stanley. The Title of the movie is also fitting since this is the that movie made me DISCOVER and introduced me to this show that’ll live with me for years and it’s also the first movie I’ve ever watched which is GREAT.
My list would go like this: 14) Big World Big Adventures 13) Journey Beyond Sodor 12) The Great Race 11) Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 10) The Adventure Begins 9) Tale of the Brave 8) King of the Railway 7) Day of the Diesels 6) Blue Mountain Mystery 5) Misty Island Rescue 4) Hero of the Rails 3) The Great Discovery 2) Calling All Engines 1) Thomas and the Magic Railroad
14. Misty Island Rescue 13. Day of the Diesels 12. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 11. Calling All Engines 10. Big World Big Adventures 9. Hero of the Rails 8. The Great Race 7. Journey Beyond Sodor 6. Tale of the Brave 5. King of the Railway 4. Blue Mountain Mystery 3. The Great Discovery 2. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 1. The Adventure Begins
My rankings: 1. Thomas & The Magic Railroad (Number one favourite!) 10/10 2. The Great Race (Really amazing musical!) 10/10 3. The Great Discovery (Awesome model series finale!) 10/10 4. The Adventure Begins (Amazing film!) 10/10 5. King of The Railway (Awesome start to the Brenner-Era) 10/10 6. Tale of the Brave (Great film) 9/10 7. Blue Mountain Mystery (Cool movie) 9/10 8. Hero of The Rails (Rather great movie) 9/10 9. Journey Beyond Sodor (Great series finale movie despise the rushed ending) 9/10 10. Calling All Engines! (Nostalgic film, despise Diesel 10 as a good guy) 8.5/10 11. Day of The Diesels (Guilty Pleasure) 7.5/10 12. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (Great Movie, Bad Topham) 7/10 13. Misty Island Rescue (On the levels of bad, meh and decent) 6.5/10 14. Big World! Big Adventures! (So bad that it's not even funny...) 4/10
Best to worst in MY OPINION: 1. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure 2. The Adventure Begins 3. Tale of the Brave 4. The Great Race 5. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 6. Blue Mountain Mystery 7. King of the Railway 8. Hero of the Rails 9. The Great Discovery 10. Big World! Big Adventures! 11. Journey Beyond Sodor 12. Day of the Diesels 13. Misty Island Rescue 14. Calling All Engines
My ranking: 14: Misty Island Rescue (4/10) 13: Big World Big Adventures (4/10) 12: Day of the Diesels (5/10) 11: Calling All Engines (5/10) 10: The Great Race (6/10) 9: Thomas and the Magic Railroad (6/10) 8: Journey Beyond Sodor (7/10) 7: Hero of the Rails (7/10) 6: The Great Discovery (8/10) 5: King of the Railway (9/10) 4: Tale of the Brave (9/10) 3: The Adventure Begins (9/10) 2: Blue Mountain Mystery (10/10) 1: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (10/10)
14: misty island rescue 13: big world big adventures 12: day of the diesels 11: calling all engines 10: Thomas and the magic railroad 9: the great race 8: king of the railway 7: journey beyond sodor 6: hero of the rails 5: the great discovery 4: tale of the brave 3: the adventure begins 2: blue mountain mystery 1: sodors legend of the lost treasure
My list would be: 14. Big World, Big Adventures 13. Calling All Engines 12. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 11. Day of the Diesels 10. The Great Race 9. King of the Railway 8. Journey Beyond Sodor 7. Misty Island Rescue 6. Hero of the Rails 5. Tale of the Brave 4. The Great Discovery 3. The Adventure Begins 2. SLOTLT 1. Blue Mountain Mystery
14: Misty Island Rescue (mediocre) 13: Day of the Diesels (mediocre) 12: Big World! Big Adventures! (decent) 11: Thomas and the Magic Railroad/Tragic Failroad (decent) 10: Calling All Engines (fine) 9: The Great Race (fine) 8: Journey Beyond Sodor (fine) 7: The Great Discovery (good) 6: King of the Railway (good) 5: Hero of the Rails (good) 4: Tale of the Brave (good) 3: Blue Mountain Mystery (great) 2: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (amazing) 1: The Adventure Begins (entertaining)
Here's My Ranking. If Any Of You Want To Fight Me,Name a Time and Place. Just Kidding Haha,Respect My Opinion. 14.Misty Island Rescue-5/10 13. Day Of the Diesels-5/10 12.Big World,Big Adventures-5.5/10 11.The Great Race-5.5/10 10.Journey Beyond Sodor-7.5/10 9.Calling All Engines-8/10 8.Sodor's Legend Of the Lost Treasure-8.5/10 7.Hero Of the Rails-8.5/10 6.King Of the Railway-9/10 5.Tale Of the Brave-9/10 4.Thomas and the Magic Railroad-9.5/10 3.The Great Discovery-10/10 2. Blue Mountain Mystery-10/10 1.The Adventure Begins-10/10
I'm gonna have to disagree with you on Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure. While I agree there is a lot to like (Sailor John is a menacing antagonists, first time we see Railway Series Characters being brought over since Season 4, Daisy's return), I just can't get over how badly Thomas gets treated in this movie. Sure, he brings on most of it onto himself, but by the time the dynamite scene comes around, it feels like the writers are using any excuse they can think of to have him get into trouble. Personally, my favorite is Thomas and the Magic Railroad. For all of its flaws (and yes, I acknowledge that there are plenty), the story we got is, for the most part, easy to follow and has a lot of good action. My second is King of the Railway for introducing loveable characters and having a low key plot that works.
My ranking: 14. Misty Island Rescue (3/10) 13. Big World! Big Adventures! (3/10) 12. Calling All Engines! (4/10) 11. Day of the Diesels(4/10) 10. King of the Railway (5/10) 9. The Great Race (6/10) 8. Thomas and the Magic Railroad (7/10) 7. Hero of the Rails (7/10) 6. Tale of the Brave (8/10) 5. Journey Beyond Sodor (8/10) 4. The Adventure Begins (9/10) 3. The Great Discovery (10/10) 2. Blue Mountain Mystery (10/10) 1. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (10/10)
0:28: Somehow, it works on me. I would presume the majority of you would think otherwise. Also, from viewing a collection of memes on Deviantart, the creator of those memes treat them like the Director's Cut makes SSSSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOO much more sense. I'll put them in the replies in a minute. Once I finish the video viewing.
I love "The Adventure Begins", "Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure" & "Blue Mountain Mystery" so equally(they're objectively equally good too!) that it PAINS me that I have to rank them from #1 to #3! When I watched SLOTLT for the first time I was like "FINALLY some GOOD SHIT of a CINEMATIC piece!!!" but the Fat Controller being a dick in the movie did bother me quite a lot! BMM is the same - I nearly screamed at the return of the narrow gauge engines but the scene where all of them running away from Thomas while yelling that Thomas was not their friend is frankly a CHORE to sit through! I was like "God I've NEVER seen anyone handled a situation so IMMATURELY like this!" TAB is a gift! It instantly brought back all those childhood memories and I didn't care too much about how Henry was handled in the movie! Some other not-as-good but also good Thomas movies include "King of the Railway"(plot is a little dull but I still enjoyed it ; Stephen & the Earl are pure GOLD!), "Tale of the Brave"(heartwarming moments & messages but I really wanted to punch James in his face!) & "Hero of the Rails"(really nice & stylish opening[same applies to BMM] ; the Steam Team was the most united here ; heartwarming story ; Spencer was so flipping EVIL here!)
MY list would go 14: big world big adventure 13: misty island rescue 12: day of the diesels 11: hero of the rails 10: king of the railway 9: Thomas and the magic railroad 8: blue mountain mystery 7: calling all engines 6: journey beyond sodor 5: great discovery 4: great race 3: sodors legend of the lost treasure and tale of the brave 2: tale of the brave and sodors legend and the lost treasure 1: adventure beings
14) Big World Big Adventures Pros: Adventureous, Love the idea of Thomas traveling around the 🌎 and the part where he visits the 🇺🇸 was amazing. Thomas welcomes Nia to Sodor. The songs were great, especially the song Sometimes You Make a Friend as it shows how guilty Thomas truly feels for emotionally hurting Nia. Cons: Thomas was unkind to Nia at first and Ace is selfish. They didn't put Thomas going to India in the special. Although he did go to India as shown in Season 22. 13) Journey Beyond Sodor Pros: The songs were upbeat and catchy. Especially the song I Want To Go Home as it shows that Thomas feels truly homesick. The escape scenes were absolutely EPIC and Thomas found purpose for Merlin, Lexi and Theo. Finally, Thomas and James patch up their quarrel and work together to head back to Sodor. Cons: Thomas is treated like a prisoner by Hurricane and Frankie. Beresford was a bit of a jerk to Thomas. 13) The Great Race Pros: The Great Railway Show reminds me of talent shows that people perform. Thomas got to show his special shunting talent in the shunting challenge. Ashima is left behind as the ⛴ leaves with the other international engines but that's good in a way as she got to know the Sodor engines. Thomas became her best friend. Thomas and Ashima stood up to Vinnie who was bullying Phillip. The songs are awesome with my favorite being Be Who You Are and Go Far. Cons: Thomas' splendid blue paint was messed up at the Steamworks and his front buffer beam was damaged and he remained like that for the rest of the 🎥 with no repair or repaint. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure Pros: Exciting Plot line, Donald and Douglas are back, The Miniature Railway Engines from The Railway Series make their debut, The treasure chase scene is amazing and Sir Topham Hatt is proud of Thomas in the end. Thomas and Ryan become friends in the end and Skiff becomes a new friend of Thomas'. Cons: Gordon is a jerk to Thomas by calling him a silly little tank engine although it doesn't justify Thomas causing an accident with the express coaches, Thomas was severely damaged after falling into a cavern and he was fully repaired when he was back from the works as his paintwork is scratched and dusty and remained like that for most of the film. Daisy who is my most disliked character returns as she's ugly and annoying. Sir Topham Hatt was cross with Thomas too many times. Thomas feeling replaced by Ryan. The Adventure Begins Pros: Edward is a father figure and mentor to Thomas. This is a recreation of the first six season 1 episodes. The movie ends with Thomas receiving his own branchline. Cons: Percy is not in this movie. Thomas' voice changed vut the new voice is somewhat good. Tale of the Brave Pros: Percy is the main character, although Thomas is my favorite but I admire Thomas and Percy equally and both engines are my favorite. Fascinating discoveries are made. Bill and Ben the Tank Engine Twins rescue Thomas from a landslide and Percy rescues James likewise. Thomas, Percy and James are a friendship trio in this film. Cons: James is a jerk to Percy, Percy is 😡 at Thomas and coldly puffs away from him due to not believe him that there is a 'monster' which is a pile of scrap James made to frighten Percy. King of the Railway Pros: A new 🏰 is being built which is Ulfstead 🏰. Thomas and Percy work together and have fun together as good friends should. Stephen is introduced and we learn about him. Gordon and Spencer race each other. The mine is an exciting adventure. Cons: None Day of the Diesels: Thomas is deeply concerned about Percy. Thomas and Percy along with the rest of the steam team fight for the Steamworks. Thomas and Percy help each other. Cons: Percy becomes "friends" with Diesel and Diesel 10 and he gradually spends more time at the DieselWorks. Den and Dart hold Thomas hostage in the back shed. Blue Mountain Mystery Pros: The Narrow Gauge Engines along with Mr Percival the Narrow Guage Controller return. Thomas goes out of his way to help Luke despite a misunderstanding. Recreated flashbacks of the Classic Thomas episodes Come Out Henry, Down the Mine and A Scarf for Percy are referenced. Cons: Diesel is up to no good and the Narrow Guage Engines turn against Thomas over a misunderstanding although it qas temporary. Misty Island Rescue: Thomas is on a new adventure. The Logging Locos are fun and playful. Thomas saves Diesel despite their rivalry. Edward, Gordon and James look for Thomas on Misty Island. Thomas reunites with Percy and the other Sodor engines in the end. Cons: Diesel lost the Jobi Wood and the post credits scene with Diesel 10 is creepy and unwanted. Hero of the Rails Pros: Thomas meeting Hiro and becoming his new friend. All engines setting aside their differences and forming a team for Hiro, especially Gordon and James as they're not their usual boastful selves in the movie. Spencer as the main antagonist. The Steam Team teaming up against Spencer. Spencer's accident at the quarry. Thomas vs Spencer chase where Spencer falls into the muddy marsh. The engines seem Hiro off at the end and him talking to Thomas and Percy. Thomas and Percy helping Hiro to the Steamworks. Cons: None The Great Discovery Pros: Thomas' brass model and facial expressions and the similarity to Season 11, Thomas, You're the Leader rap, Thomas' shade of blue paint and various smiles, The Thomas and James race, Jack and the Pack are in this movie. Thomas and Stanley become friends in the end. Cons: Thomas' accident around the bend and in the tunnel, Thomas being mean to Stanley at first and then going missing. Calling All Engines Pros: The Steamies vs Diesels rivalry and the engines fight, Thomas biffing Arry, Gordon biffing Bert, Emily and Henry biffing Diesel. Thomas talking to Mavis about his idea. Thomas convincing Diesel 10 to help them out. Thomas' dream sequence with Lady in it. Thomas lowering the bridge section into place and gloating that steamies are better than diesels. The songs are catchy. Cons: Diesel, Arry and Bert being mean to the steam engines, Diesel biffing the paint flat beds and the paint cans spilling on Thomas. Arry biffing James, Diesel biffing Toby and Bert biffing Henry. Thomas and the Magic Railroad Pros: The first and only Tjomas theatrical movie. I like Thomas' shade of blue paint and Percy's shade of green paint. The various soundtracks and Thomas being confident in himself by saying "Little engines can do big things, especially when they have nice blue paint like me". Thomas being the first and only engine who traveled through the magic buffers through the Magic Railroad to Muffle 🏔 and back again to Sodor. The chase scene and Diesel 10's defeat. Cons: Edward is not in the movie. James and Percy are voiced by female actors and Gordon being a jerk to Thomas.
my top favorite movies are: Blue Mountain Mystery, King Of The Railway, Hero Of The Rails, The Adventure Begins and Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure.
Thomas and the magic railroad: 10/10 Calling All Engines: 7.5/10 The Great Discovery: 8.5/10 Hero Of The Rails: 10/10 Mistery Island Rescue: 10/10 Day Of The Diesels: 10/10 Blue Mountain Mystery: 10/10 King Of The Railway: 10/10 Tale Of The Brave: 7.5/10 The Adventures Begins: 10/10 Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure: 8/10 The Great Race: 8.5/10 Journey Beyond Sodor: 9/10 Big Word Big Adventures: 10/10
For me, my list would go: 14. Big World! Big Adventures 13. Misty Island Rescue 12. Calling All Engines! 11. Journey Beyond Sodor 10. Day of the Diesels 9. The Great Discovery 8. Hero of the Rails 7. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure 6. Tale of the Brave 5. The Great Race 4. King of the Railway 3. Blue Mountain Mystery 2. The Adventure Begins 1. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
You forgot to mention "Bad Acting" under the cons for Thomas and the Magic Railroad. Also, I personally thought Day of the Diesels was actually a movie about cults and how they love bomb the isolated, which is why Percy acts like an idiot the whole time.
My list: 14 = Bad 13-12 = Neutral 11-4 = Good 3-1 = The Best! 14. Big World! Big Adventures! 13. Blue Mountain Mystery 12. Tale of the Brave 11. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure 10. Day of the Diesels 9. Misty Island Rescue 8. The Great Race 7. King of the Railway 6. Calling All Engines 5. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 4. The Adventure Begins 3. Journey Beyond Sodor 2. Hero of the Rails 1. The Great Discovery
My list would be 14.big world big adventures 13.misty island rescue 12.day of the diesels 11.calling all engines 10.Thomas and the magic railroad 9.king of the railway 8.the great race 7.journey beyond sodor 6.the great discovery 5.blue mountain mystery 4.Tale of the brave 3.the adventure begins 2.hiro of the rails 1.sodors legend of the lost treasure
My opinion: 14. Big World! Big Adventures! 13. Misty Island Rescue 12. Day of the Diesels 11. Thomas and the Magic Railroad 10. Calling All Engines 9. King of the Railway 8. The Great Race 7. Journey Beyond Sodor 6. The Great Discovery 5. Tale of the Brave 4. Hero of the Rails 3. Blue Mountain Mystery 2. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure 1. The Adventure Begins
To me, Misty Island Rescue is the worst Thomas movie and the 4th worst movie I have ever seen and the best movie to me is also Sodor's Legend of The Lost Treasure
My list from worst to best movie on my opinion: 14. Tale of the brave: -It was boring, Thomas wasn't trying enough to find out what are the footprints on the rocks. And the T-rex fossil was a waste of potential and not the main idea to the title. 13. Journey beyond sodor: -I like the new characters and I Never know there were experimental engines. -I don't like how they make the train characters able to move, like come on this isn't chuggington. 12. Big world! big adventures!: -The music is decent. 👍 -Again don't like moving body physics on trains. It didn't show other great places and ace....OMG where do i start, he's a awful character. Cars with faces doesn't look good (except for trucks and buses). 11. The great race: -I like how Gordon has a brother and both talk eachother. -It only have 3 races and ended quick. Also the best decorated challenge is pointless and not a race. 10. King of the railway: -liked medieval stuff and royal liked engines. I obviously don't hate the movie at all. -The title didn't stand out the movie, their is no "king" of the railway. When I saw the trailer to this, it was weird cause the faces of Thomas and etc were bright. 9. Calling all engines: -I liked the steamies and diesels battle eachother cause of their differences. Rarely Don't see that all the time. 8. Misty island rescue: -Interesting loging loco's character's and new island area to see. Unexpected diesel 10's return. 7. The adventure begins. -It give me nostalgic to the classic series. I like it how they give Thomas a backstory on how he arrived to sodor. Good movie and great times to my childhood. 6. Hero of the rails. -The story is original and fascinating. 5. Day of the diesels. -I like it when all diesels come like a army to take over the steam work same as the steam engines form an army. -I don't like the new voice for diesel 10 but I understand bringing OG diesel 10 voice would scare new young audience. I'm ok with that. 4. Blue mountain mystery. -Good story, music, and the return of narrow gauge engines (well most of them). -Scarloie's voice is way to deep but alright then no problem. 3. Sodor's legend of the lost treasure. -Great story telling and way more enjoyable to watch. Perfect.👌 2. The great discovery. -great quality and I love "Thomas your the leader" song, best song than every other song. Hands down. 1. Thomas and the magic railroad. -I liked it cause it was my first movie that I ever watch and I don't give a damn what people say. Still the number one movie. Lady forever.
My list God awful 14 misty island rescue Bad 13 big world big adventures 12 day of the diesels Why 11 magic railroad 10 the great race Okay 9 calling all engines 8 king of the railway Good 7 journey beyond sodor 6 hero of the rails 5 tale of the brave Amazing 4 the great discovery 3 blue mountain mystery 2 lost treasure Perfect 1 the adventure begins
I all do respect, I do think TATMR isn't as great as some others, the best one for me is Hero of The Rails becuase it brought me back to the series when it came out. I jsur don't think it's the worst one. BWBA was just bad and some plot point were never used. I watched the whole thing and the only thing that was good was when Thomas saw a dead engine. Also, TATMR is on UA-cam with Boomer if you want to rewatch it. I loved TATMR and is definitely my second favorite movie
But to Be Reasonable 10 Reason why I like Sharon Miller era! (And some things I don't like.) Pros. 1. The Animation is realistic and detailed also pretty nosltalgic 2. Excellent Writing and character ideas! 3. Merchandising was good at the time. 4. The Songs were awesome and puts me in the happy mood! 5. The Voice Actors are professional and give the characters more personality Cons 1. Too Much 3 strike formula 2. Charlie's Jokes are stale 3. Ferdinand needs to stop saying "That's Right!" 4. Too Much Ryming 5. The Camera frames could of improved
For me I don’t rank these movies. Only I either like them or hate them and I like 8 of them. I like: Thomas And The Magic Railroad The Great Discovery Hero Of The Rails Blue Mountain Mystery King Of The Railway Tale Of The Brave The Adventure Begins Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure The rest are bad: Calling All Engines Misty Island Rescue Day Of The Diesels The Great Race Journey Beyond Sodor Big World Big Adventures
My rankings 11: Misty Island Rescue (The worst there is Bash and Dash are terrible the dialogue is terrible and Thomas is just as horrible) 10: Day Of The Diesels (Also pretty bad with so much rhyming and alliteration and Percy is a complete idiot) 9: Thomas And The Magic Railroad (A mess of a movie with good music and a good villain but it has little to do with Thomas the human characters are dull and the test auidences just made the film that much worse by tampering with the voices for the characters. It's plot is also way too hard to understand and is ever so convoluted.) 8: Calling All Engines (A dull experience with little going on and there's too many learning segments just to pad out the runtime and just feels generic as all it's just a movie about settling differences and the steam and diesel rivalry just feels like a race war it's got good songs and I am a bit nostalgic for it but for something in the HiT era it's rathe weak compared to the rest of the series.) 7: Hero Of The Rails (A very dated film with questionable CGI animation and the dialouge is once again terrible and it creates a huge plothole about Hiro being the first engine on sodor. Although it is miles better than everything above.) 6. The Great Discovery (A nice film with a beautiful visual look and it has a really well written message about Thomas not feeling apperciated the things that hold it back is a bit of Sharon Miller writing and Pierce Brosnan's tiresome narration that would put any kid to sleep.) 5. King Of The Railway (A very decent film with a lot going for it. I like the story about Godred's crown and Stephen is a cool character but it just feels much slower compared to other Brenner specials) 4. The Adventure Begins (Pretty overrated and not as good as Season 1 but for what is it's a nice tribute to the Railway Series it just has some things that I don't personally enjoy.) 3. Tale Of The Brave (A very well written film with a lot going for it I enjoyed Gator and the story about him and Percy and the ending is just amazing.) 2. Blue Mountain Mystery (A movie that is so well written that it would fit perfectly with the Brenner specials and the rhyming and alliteration from the previous movies has now been completely removed! Luke is adorable the mystery is great Victor's backstory being revealed was such a treat.) 1. Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure (This is THE Thomas movie that feels the most cinematic. Sailor John's a fantastic villain it has great songs. Godlike orchestral soundtrack. A thrilling chase scene and a good message.) Haven't Seen: The Great Race (Looks very generic like Calling All Engines and just a gimmicky movie trying to shove in all these international engines that no one gives two craps about.) Journey Beyond Sodor (All the bad characters and horribly unrealistic moments just doesn't sell with me.) Big World! Big Adventures! (I never will watch this movie in my entire lifetime and for good reason)
#16-15: the 2 all engines go specials 0/10 Actually #14 Misty island rescue 1/10 #13 Day of the diesels 3/10 #12 Big world big adventures 3/10 #11 Calling all engines 4/10 #10 Journey beyond sodor 6/10 #09 The great race 6/10 #08 Thomas and the magic railroad 7.5/10 #07 Hiro of the rails 8/10 #06 King of the railway 8/10 #05 Tale of the brave 8/10 #04 The great discovery 8/10 #03 Blue Mountain Mistery 9/10 #02 The adventure begins 9/10 #01 Sodor's legend of the lost treasure 10/10
14:Calling All Engines -2/10 Pros:Steamies Vs Diesels is Very Epic Cons:89% of it is Filler Doesn’t focus on a few points Bland as That Girl from the Lorax 13.Day at the Diesels 3/10 Pros:The Exact same as Dennis’s Cons:Forgettable Percy is not Percy I can’t take seriously at all 12.Misty Island Rescue 5/10 Pros:It’s Very Nostalgic I watched it when I was 4 And I love the animations at the start Cons:If this movie was anything but a movie it would be a mosquito bite 11.Big World! Big Adventures 5/10 Pros:Where in the World is Thomas is Hilarious,Nia is very Good Cons:Other than WITWIT Horrible songs,They didn’t go all around the world 10.Journey Beyond Sodor Pros:None Cons:None
Nitrogen Studios animation is good and kinda in my options better then Arc Animation also the logging Locos cause me excitement but no offense if I like things ya hate
Journey Beyond Sodor Pros 1. Animation is Decent 2. Theo and Hurricane are interesting characters 3. I wanna go home song was a masterpiece Cons 1. Too Cartoony and Wired 2. Lexi is uninteresting characters and is annoying 3. The plot with Thomas trapped in the steelworks was stupid and lazy even my brother hated it too 4. Frankie and Hurricane are the worst villains 5. The Bouncing Characters 6. Beresford was a dumb character
Mine is Tale of the brave 5/10 Pros the new characters are good The scene where bill and ben save thomas is good The moral is good The songs were great Oliver returned Cons percy is a idiot for the entire film The scene where cranky stops the ship is pointless Gator states his real name is garold but his nameplate says otherwise Misty island rescue 6/10 Pros I like the new characters The songs are good Whiff returned Cons Thomas is a jerk What does hicklty pility mean Calling all engines 6⅙/10 Pros the songs are good The fight scene was epic Cons diesel 10 is boxed up Derek's role is small The great discovery 7/10 Pros Stanley's a good character There are no learning segments The songs are great Pierce Brosnan is a good narrator Cons thomas is a jerk King of the railway 7⅓/10 Pros the new characters are great The intro is fantastic Jack returned Cons the scene where they made it 1 hour long The great race 7¼/10 Pros the new characters are good The songs are fantastic The flying scotchman is in it Cons the bridge jump scene The title is bad Big world big adventures 7⅖/10 Pros nia and ace are good characters Yong bao gets a speaking role Cons sir topham hatt nearly died 3 times Thomas is a jerk Journey beyond sodor 7⅚/10 Pros the new characters are good The songs are fantastic Cons the first 10 minutes Day of the diesel's7⅝/10 Pros diesel 10 is a villain again The new characters are good Cons percy is a idiot Thomas and the magic railroad 7⅞/10 Pros the new characters are fantastic It's the first movie Cons the test audience screwed up the film James is voiced by a woman in the movie Blue mountain mystery 8/10 Pros luke and Winston are fantastic character It had a plot twist Cons the scene where the narrow gauge engines run away from Thomas is bad The adventure begins 8/⅚/10 Pros it shows what happened when Thomas arrived Cons Henry is in his new shape Hiro of the rails 9/10 Pros the new characters are awesome The plot is good Cons the animation Sodors legend of the lost treasure 10/10 Pros the new characters are fantastic Donald Douglas rex mike bert daisy Alfie max montyand Oliver return Cons ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmeR1
Wow, Diesel 10 is the kiss of death for Thomas movies, huh?
My list would go:
14: Big World Big Adventures
13: Misty Island Rescue
12: Thomas and the Magic Railroad
11: Day of the Diesels
10: Journey Beyond Sodor
9: Calling all Engines
8: The Great Race
7: Hero of the Rails
6: Blue Mountain Mystery
5: King of the Railway
4: Tale of the Brave
3: The Great Discovery
2: The Adventure Begins
1: Sodors Legend of the Lost Treasure
GREAT LIST
My list(Personal)is:
14:Big world big adventurs:
13:Misty island rescue:
12:Hero of the rails:
11:Thomas and the magic railroad:
10:the great race:
9: Sodor Beyond journey:
8:Blu mountain mistery:
7:Day of the diesels:
6:Adventures Begins:
5:King of the railway
4:Calling on engines
3:The Great discovery
2:Sodor legend of the lost treasure
1:Tale of the brave
Of course Big World Big adventures is at the bottom
@Carmine Lago e TATMR che fine fa??
@Carmine Lago ah beh allora dillo subito comunque ricorda che anche il Film di Marc Forster(che teoricamente dovrebbe uscire nel 2024)non sarà canonico per il franchise, dato che sarà un ibrido tra live action e CGI(che in teoria dovrebbe essere o buono o addirittura spettacolare, magari tipo SLOTLT).
I think that Calling all engines felt more like an episode, than a movie.
ThomasFan261 says that the movie would barely suffice as a 2-parter.
Frrr
My First and Top Movie of all is The Great Discovery. I mean in my opinion, everything about it was so GREAT to the sing alongs especially the first one in the beginning, crashes were so phenomenal, and there’s even a fricking rap song in the outro which was really epic and other Great things about The Great Discovery and Stanley was such a GREAT and REMARKABLE Character and everything about him was so GREAT to me including his Theme Song which was really Splendid and that’s why he’s one of my most favourite character in the show, but it’s just sad that he didn’t get a lot of attention nor did he get a lot of screen time in future episodes ever since which makes him such an underrated character, and I really miss Stanley so much. The Title of the movie is also fitting since this is the that movie made me DISCOVER and introduced me to this show that’ll live with me for years and it’s also the first movie I’ve ever watched which is GREAT.
Same Yea I’m lazy 2 reply
I don’t understand why BWBA was not on the very bottom.
1: thomas and the magic railway
Naw jbs
Big facts
No
I like king of the railway best
What the film should've been called in the UK
2:09 yes, ace is practically lightning McQueen
2:19: Wait, but are you sure? I saw a playlist of video clips from the full-movie of The Great Discovery (2008), and I'm pretty sure I only saw, like, 1 or 2 learning segments in them. I also think it would be a great movie because of how much of the majority of engines are shown. This was the final all-model T&F production before Season 12 came out that same year. In fact, both came out back when I was a newborn. So, boy am I glad I grew up along the so-called "hated (2/3: Nitrogen (excluding HOTR (Hero of the Rails) and BMM (Blue Mountain Mystery) & BWBA)" CGI series of Thomas.
Nice little Top 14 list! Honestly, I know that TATMR has its flaws, but ever since T1E2H3 did his review on the movie, I’ve always had a soft spot for it. And I still think it’s better than BWBA or anything Miller could have given us!
Another thing I don't like in The Great Race is how darn long it takes to get to the railway show. It takes literally like, two thirds of the movie just to arrive.
And when they get there, every game is rushed in like 5 minutes so they can cut to the chase with Gordon's safety valve, Thomas at the shunting competition, Vinnie's defeat and heading back home again, all in like a rushed 20 minutes.
When CGI better than the models movies
My favourite is great discovery bc I love how Thomas tumbles down the hill
The sad noises when thomas was in the Cave were extraordinary I also like lost treasure tho
Here's my list:
14: Big World Big Adventures (3.5/10)
13: Thomas and the magic railroad (4/10)
12: Misty Island rescue (4.5/10)
11: Day of the diesels (5/10)
10: king of the railway (5.5/10)
9: tale of the brave (6/10)
8: Calling all engines (6.5/10) (guilty pleasure)
7: the great race (7/10)
6: Journey beyond Sodor (7.5/10)
5: Hero of the rails (8/10)
4: Blue Mountain mystery (8.5/10)
3: Sodor's legend of the lost treasure (9/10)
2: the great discovery (9.5/10)
1: the adventure begins (10/10)
2:22 actually there are learning segments but weren't in the final cut
@@duckstudios3687 Here’s my list:
14. The Great Discovery
13. Big World! Big Adventures!
12. Journey Beyond Sodor
11. Blue Mountain Mystery
10. Thomas And The Magic Railroad
9. King Of The Railway
8. Day Of The Diesels
7. The Great Race
6. Hero Of The Rails
5. The Adventure Begins
4. Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure
3. Misty Island Rescue
2. Tale Of The Brave
1. Calling All Engines
Thanks for doing my request
But This is the reason why I like Blue Mountain Mystery
Pros
1. Narrow Gadge Characters Returned
2. Victors Backstory was Good
3. Awesome Writing
4. Diesel was a good choice for a villian
5. Luke's character development during the movie was good
6. Felt Like a improvement for the Thomas and Friends Franchise
Um wheres the cons?
Updated ranking
14: Calling all engines
13: Thomas and the magic railroad
12: Journey Beyond Sodor
11: Big World big adventures
10: The great discovery
9: Day of the diesels
8: The adventure begins
7: Sodors legend of the lost treasure
6: The great race
5: Blue Mountain Mystery
4: Misty Island Rescue
3: Hero of the rails
2: Tale of the brave
1: King of the railway
I think we can all agree that 2015 was a great year for Thomas.
Fun fact: according to a trackmaster collection poster thingy-ish, misty island rescue released on dvd somewhere exactly six days before i was born
That is cool. The great race was released on my birthday in 2016
Legends noticed they played a big world big adventures song instrumental from when thomas meets nia
Great job. I love your videos by the way. Also i agree with most of this
Calling All Engine
Pros
1. Return of some old characters from Britt Allcroft era
2. The Music was memorable
3. The Props and sets they used for this film was awesome!
4. The Diesels vs Steamies fighting scene was the best crash scenes
5. Crashes were awesome!
Cons
1. Derek Didn't have that much screen time
I would but Thomas and the Magic Railroad in 1st place it was such a good movie.
It really is
Yeah, but for me, it’s actually my second favourite on the list, My First and Top Movie of all is The Great Discovery. I mean in my opinion, everything about it was so GREAT to the sing alongs especially the first one in the beginning, crashes were so phenomenal, and there’s even a fricking rap song in the outro which was really epic and other Great things about The Great Discovery and Stanley was such a GREAT and REMARKABLE Character and everything about him was so GREAT to me including his Theme Song which was really Splendid and that’s why he’s one of my most favourite character in the show, but it’s just sad that he didn’t get a lot of attention nor did he get a lot of screen time in future episodes ever since which makes him such an underrated character, and I really miss Stanley. The Title of the movie is also fitting since this is the that movie made me DISCOVER and introduced me to this show that’ll live with me for years and it’s also the first movie I’ve ever watched which is GREAT.
I think it was just ok
My list would go like this:
14) Big World Big Adventures
13) Journey Beyond Sodor
12) The Great Race
11) Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure
10) The Adventure Begins
9) Tale of the Brave
8) King of the Railway
7) Day of the Diesels
6) Blue Mountain Mystery
5) Misty Island Rescue
4) Hero of the Rails
3) The Great Discovery
2) Calling All Engines
1) Thomas and the Magic Railroad
what's the song at 3:49?
14. Misty Island Rescue
13. Day of the Diesels
12. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
11. Calling All Engines
10. Big World Big Adventures
9. Hero of the Rails
8. The Great Race
7. Journey Beyond Sodor
6. Tale of the Brave
5. King of the Railway
4. Blue Mountain Mystery
3. The Great Discovery
2. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure
1. The Adventure Begins
I think 1 and 2 are Magic Railroad and SLOTLT because I grew up with the Model era of Thomas and the treasure Movie was so Badass
2:27 thomas is in his 100% true persona. and in the great discovery there are two learning segments, but they are skipable
Blue mountain mystery is the nostalgic to me
My rankings:
1. Thomas & The Magic Railroad (Number one favourite!) 10/10
2. The Great Race (Really amazing musical!) 10/10
3. The Great Discovery (Awesome model series finale!) 10/10
4. The Adventure Begins (Amazing film!) 10/10
5. King of The Railway (Awesome start to the Brenner-Era) 10/10
6. Tale of the Brave (Great film) 9/10
7. Blue Mountain Mystery (Cool movie) 9/10
8. Hero of The Rails (Rather great movie) 9/10
9. Journey Beyond Sodor (Great series finale movie despise the rushed ending) 9/10
10. Calling All Engines! (Nostalgic film, despise Diesel 10 as a good guy) 8.5/10
11. Day of The Diesels (Guilty Pleasure) 7.5/10
12. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (Great Movie, Bad Topham) 7/10
13. Misty Island Rescue (On the levels of bad, meh and decent) 6.5/10
14. Big World! Big Adventures! (So bad that it's not even funny...) 4/10
Best to worst in MY OPINION:
1. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure
2. The Adventure Begins
3. Tale of the Brave
4. The Great Race
5. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
6. Blue Mountain Mystery
7. King of the Railway
8. Hero of the Rails
9. The Great Discovery
10. Big World! Big Adventures!
11. Journey Beyond Sodor
12. Day of the Diesels
13. Misty Island Rescue
14. Calling All Engines
My ranking:
14: Misty Island Rescue (4/10)
13: Big World Big Adventures (4/10)
12: Day of the Diesels (5/10)
11: Calling All Engines (5/10)
10: The Great Race (6/10)
9: Thomas and the Magic Railroad (6/10)
8: Journey Beyond Sodor (7/10)
7: Hero of the Rails (7/10)
6: The Great Discovery (8/10)
5: King of the Railway (9/10)
4: Tale of the Brave (9/10)
3: The Adventure Begins (9/10)
2: Blue Mountain Mystery (10/10)
1: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (10/10)
Lets go!!!
Like if you want boco and duke to return
14: misty island rescue
13: big world big adventures
12: day of the diesels
11: calling all engines
10: Thomas and the magic railroad
9: the great race
8: king of the railway
7: journey beyond sodor
6: hero of the rails
5: the great discovery
4: tale of the brave
3: the adventure begins
2: blue mountain mystery
1: sodors legend of the lost treasure
That’s the same thing as the unlucky tug tier list you can’t copy him
@@tugsfan1617 i don't copy him a just have the same opinion
My list would be:
14. Big World, Big Adventures
13. Calling All Engines
12. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
11. Day of the Diesels
10. The Great Race
9. King of the Railway
8. Journey Beyond Sodor
7. Misty Island Rescue
6. Hero of the Rails
5. Tale of the Brave
4. The Great Discovery
3. The Adventure Begins
2. SLOTLT
1. Blue Mountain Mystery
Thank you someone who knows that bmm is the best movie
@@milton7955 it really is. It does everything right
14: Misty Island Rescue (mediocre)
13: Day of the Diesels (mediocre)
12: Big World! Big Adventures! (decent)
11: Thomas and the Magic Railroad/Tragic Failroad (decent)
10: Calling All Engines (fine)
9: The Great Race (fine)
8: Journey Beyond Sodor (fine)
7: The Great Discovery (good)
6: King of the Railway (good)
5: Hero of the Rails (good)
4: Tale of the Brave (good)
3: Blue Mountain Mystery (great)
2: Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (amazing)
1: The Adventure Begins (entertaining)
0:56 i see you think calling all engines is even worse than misty island rescue. i have a defence video on it in productions. perfect for you
Can you do worst episode(s) from each season?
Here's My Ranking. If Any Of You Want To Fight Me,Name a Time and Place. Just Kidding Haha,Respect My Opinion.
14.Misty Island Rescue-5/10
13. Day Of the Diesels-5/10
12.Big World,Big Adventures-5.5/10
11.The Great Race-5.5/10
10.Journey Beyond Sodor-7.5/10
9.Calling All Engines-8/10
8.Sodor's Legend Of the Lost Treasure-8.5/10
7.Hero Of the Rails-8.5/10
6.King Of the Railway-9/10
5.Tale Of the Brave-9/10
4.Thomas and the Magic Railroad-9.5/10
3.The Great Discovery-10/10
2. Blue Mountain Mystery-10/10
1.The Adventure Begins-10/10
I'm gonna have to disagree with you on Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure. While I agree there is a lot to like (Sailor John is a menacing antagonists, first time we see Railway Series Characters being brought over since Season 4, Daisy's return), I just can't get over how badly Thomas gets treated in this movie. Sure, he brings on most of it onto himself, but by the time the dynamite scene comes around, it feels like the writers are using any excuse they can think of to have him get into trouble.
Personally, my favorite is Thomas and the Magic Railroad. For all of its flaws (and yes, I acknowledge that there are plenty), the story we got is, for the most part, easy to follow and has a lot of good action. My second is King of the Railway for introducing loveable characters and having a low key plot that works.
My ranking:
14. Misty Island Rescue (3/10)
13. Big World! Big Adventures! (3/10)
12. Calling All Engines! (4/10)
11. Day of the Diesels(4/10)
10. King of the Railway (5/10)
9. The Great Race (6/10)
8. Thomas and the Magic Railroad (7/10)
7. Hero of the Rails (7/10)
6. Tale of the Brave (8/10)
5. Journey Beyond Sodor (8/10)
4. The Adventure Begins (9/10)
3. The Great Discovery (10/10)
2. Blue Mountain Mystery (10/10)
1. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (10/10)
I’m surprised you put big world big adventures so high
0:28: Somehow, it works on me. I would presume the majority of you would think otherwise. Also, from viewing a collection of memes on Deviantart, the creator of those memes treat them like the Director's Cut makes SSSSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOO much more sense. I'll put them in the replies in a minute. Once I finish the video viewing.
Nice
I love "The Adventure Begins", "Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure" & "Blue Mountain Mystery" so equally(they're objectively equally good too!) that it PAINS me that I have to rank them from #1 to #3! When I watched SLOTLT for the first time I was like "FINALLY some GOOD SHIT of a CINEMATIC piece!!!" but the Fat Controller being a dick in the movie did bother me quite a lot! BMM is the same - I nearly screamed at the return of the narrow gauge engines but the scene where all of them running away from Thomas while yelling that Thomas was not their friend is frankly a CHORE to sit through! I was like "God I've NEVER seen anyone handled a situation so IMMATURELY like this!" TAB is a gift! It instantly brought back all those childhood memories and I didn't care too much about how Henry was handled in the movie!
Some other not-as-good but also good Thomas movies include "King of the Railway"(plot is a little dull but I still enjoyed it ; Stephen & the Earl are pure GOLD!), "Tale of the Brave"(heartwarming moments & messages but I really wanted to punch James in his face!) & "Hero of the Rails"(really nice & stylish opening[same applies to BMM] ; the Steam Team was the most united here ; heartwarming story ; Spencer was so flipping EVIL here!)
BWBA
Cons: just... just look at it...
Pros:
(insert wind whistling through trees sound effect here)
MY list would go
14: big world big adventure
13: misty island rescue
12: day of the diesels
11: hero of the rails
10: king of the railway
9: Thomas and the magic railroad
8: blue mountain mystery
7: calling all engines
6: journey beyond sodor
5: great discovery
4: great race
3: sodors legend of the lost treasure and tale of the brave
2: tale of the brave and sodors legend and the lost treasure
1: adventure beings
14) Big World Big Adventures
Pros: Adventureous, Love the idea of Thomas traveling around the 🌎 and the part where he visits the 🇺🇸 was amazing. Thomas welcomes Nia to Sodor. The songs were great, especially the song Sometimes You Make a Friend as it shows how guilty Thomas truly feels for emotionally hurting Nia.
Cons: Thomas was unkind to Nia at first and Ace is selfish. They didn't put Thomas going to India in the special. Although he did go to India as shown in Season 22.
13) Journey Beyond Sodor
Pros: The songs were upbeat and catchy. Especially the song I Want To Go Home as it shows that Thomas feels truly homesick. The escape scenes were absolutely EPIC and Thomas found purpose for Merlin, Lexi and Theo. Finally, Thomas and James patch up their quarrel and work together to head back to Sodor.
Cons: Thomas is treated like a prisoner by Hurricane and Frankie. Beresford was a bit of a jerk to Thomas.
13) The Great Race
Pros: The Great Railway Show reminds me of talent shows that people perform. Thomas got to show his special shunting talent in the shunting challenge. Ashima is left behind as the ⛴ leaves with the other international engines but that's good in a way as she got to know the Sodor engines. Thomas became her best friend. Thomas and Ashima stood up to Vinnie who was bullying Phillip. The songs are awesome with my favorite being Be Who You Are and Go Far.
Cons: Thomas' splendid blue paint was messed up at the Steamworks and his front buffer beam was damaged and he remained like that for the rest of the 🎥 with no repair or repaint.
Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure
Pros: Exciting Plot line, Donald and Douglas are back, The Miniature Railway Engines from The Railway Series make their debut, The treasure chase scene is amazing and Sir Topham Hatt is proud of Thomas in the end. Thomas and Ryan become friends in the end and Skiff becomes a new friend of Thomas'.
Cons: Gordon is a jerk to Thomas by calling him a silly little tank engine although it doesn't justify Thomas causing an accident with the express coaches, Thomas was severely damaged after falling into a cavern and he was fully repaired when he was back from the works as his paintwork is scratched and dusty and remained like that for most of the film. Daisy who is my most disliked character returns as she's ugly and annoying. Sir Topham Hatt was cross with Thomas too many times. Thomas feeling replaced by Ryan.
The Adventure Begins
Pros: Edward is a father figure and mentor to Thomas. This is a recreation of the first six season 1 episodes. The movie ends with Thomas receiving his own branchline.
Cons: Percy is not in this movie. Thomas' voice changed vut the new voice is somewhat good.
Tale of the Brave
Pros: Percy is the main character, although Thomas is my favorite but I admire Thomas and Percy equally and both engines are my favorite. Fascinating discoveries are made. Bill and Ben the Tank Engine Twins rescue Thomas from a landslide and Percy rescues James likewise. Thomas, Percy and James are a friendship trio in this film.
Cons: James is a jerk to Percy, Percy is 😡 at Thomas and coldly puffs away from him due to not believe him that there is a 'monster' which is a pile of scrap James made to frighten Percy.
King of the Railway
Pros: A new 🏰 is being built which is Ulfstead 🏰. Thomas and Percy work together and have fun together as good friends should. Stephen is introduced and we learn about him. Gordon and Spencer race each other. The mine is an exciting adventure.
Cons: None
Day of the Diesels: Thomas is deeply concerned about Percy. Thomas and Percy along with the rest of the steam team fight for the Steamworks. Thomas and Percy help each other.
Cons: Percy becomes "friends" with Diesel and Diesel 10 and he gradually spends more time at the DieselWorks. Den and Dart hold Thomas hostage in the back shed.
Blue Mountain Mystery
Pros: The Narrow Gauge Engines along with Mr Percival the Narrow Guage Controller return. Thomas goes out of his way to help Luke despite a misunderstanding. Recreated flashbacks of the Classic Thomas episodes Come Out Henry, Down the Mine and A Scarf for Percy are referenced.
Cons: Diesel is up to no good and the Narrow Guage Engines turn against Thomas over a misunderstanding although it qas temporary.
Misty Island Rescue: Thomas is on a new adventure. The Logging Locos are fun and playful. Thomas saves Diesel despite their rivalry. Edward, Gordon and James look for Thomas on Misty Island. Thomas reunites with Percy and the other Sodor engines in the end.
Cons: Diesel lost the Jobi Wood and the post credits scene with Diesel 10 is creepy and unwanted.
Hero of the Rails
Pros: Thomas meeting Hiro and becoming his new friend. All engines setting aside their differences and forming a team for Hiro, especially Gordon and James as they're not their usual boastful selves in the movie. Spencer as the main antagonist. The Steam Team teaming up against Spencer. Spencer's accident at the quarry. Thomas vs Spencer chase where Spencer falls into the muddy marsh. The engines seem Hiro off at the end and him talking to Thomas and Percy. Thomas and Percy helping Hiro to the Steamworks.
Cons: None
The Great Discovery
Pros: Thomas' brass model and facial expressions and the similarity to Season 11, Thomas, You're the Leader rap, Thomas' shade of blue paint and various smiles, The Thomas and James race, Jack and the Pack are in this movie. Thomas and Stanley become friends in the end.
Cons: Thomas' accident around the bend and in the tunnel, Thomas being mean to Stanley at first and then going missing.
Calling All Engines
Pros: The Steamies vs Diesels rivalry and the engines fight, Thomas biffing Arry, Gordon biffing Bert, Emily and Henry biffing Diesel. Thomas talking to Mavis about his idea. Thomas convincing Diesel 10 to help them out. Thomas' dream sequence with Lady in it. Thomas lowering the bridge section into place and gloating that steamies are better than diesels. The songs are catchy.
Cons: Diesel, Arry and Bert being mean to the steam engines, Diesel biffing the paint flat beds and the paint cans spilling on Thomas. Arry biffing James, Diesel biffing Toby and Bert biffing Henry.
Thomas and the Magic Railroad
Pros: The first and only Tjomas theatrical movie. I like Thomas' shade of blue paint and Percy's shade of green paint. The various soundtracks and Thomas being confident in himself by saying "Little engines can do big things, especially when they have nice blue paint like me". Thomas being the first and only engine who traveled through the magic buffers through the Magic Railroad to Muffle 🏔 and back again to Sodor. The chase scene and Diesel 10's defeat.
Cons: Edward is not in the movie. James and Percy are voiced by female actors and Gordon being a jerk to Thomas.
Finally somebody who sees day of the diesels sucks more than misty island rescue
my top favorite movies are:
Blue Mountain Mystery, King Of The Railway, Hero Of The Rails, The Adventure Begins and Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure.
Thomas and the magic railroad: 10/10
Calling All Engines: 7.5/10
The Great Discovery: 8.5/10
Hero Of The Rails: 10/10
Mistery Island Rescue: 10/10
Day Of The Diesels: 10/10
Blue Mountain Mystery: 10/10
King Of The Railway: 10/10
Tale Of The Brave: 7.5/10
The Adventures Begins: 10/10
Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure: 8/10
The Great Race: 8.5/10
Journey Beyond Sodor: 9/10
Big Word Big Adventures: 10/10
I don’t understand why everyone hates yellow rheneas
I completely agree with the top three.
Well Diesel 10’s Probably Gonna Be Arrested For His Crimes
For me, my list would go:
14. Big World! Big Adventures
13. Misty Island Rescue
12. Calling All Engines!
11. Journey Beyond Sodor
10. Day of the Diesels
9. The Great Discovery
8. Hero of the Rails
7. Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure
6. Tale of the Brave
5. The Great Race
4. King of the Railway
3. Blue Mountain Mystery
2. The Adventure Begins
1. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
How can bwba not on the last spot
Idk maybe because that it has some hard competion in the worst category (DOD and MIR
You forgot to mention "Bad Acting" under the cons for Thomas and the Magic Railroad. Also, I personally thought Day of the Diesels was actually a movie about cults and how they love bomb the isolated, which is why Percy acts like an idiot the whole time.
Pls do seasons worst to best
My list:
14 = Bad
13-12 = Neutral
11-4 = Good
3-1 = The Best!
14. Big World! Big Adventures!
13. Blue Mountain Mystery
12. Tale of the Brave
11. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure
10. Day of the Diesels
9. Misty Island Rescue
8. The Great Race
7. King of the Railway
6. Calling All Engines
5. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
4. The Adventure Begins
3. Journey Beyond Sodor
2. Hero of the Rails
1. The Great Discovery
@Michael Butler Because they just don’t feel as good as the others in my opinion.
@Michael Butler Cool! :)
My list would be 14.big world big adventures
13.misty island rescue
12.day of the diesels
11.calling all engines
10.Thomas and the magic railroad
9.king of the railway
8.the great race
7.journey beyond sodor
6.the great discovery
5.blue mountain mystery
4.Tale of the brave
3.the adventure begins
2.hiro of the rails
1.sodors legend of the lost treasure
Misty Island should not be placed so high. "Some parts are unrealistic" ALL of it is unrealistic, convoluted and horrible.
1.Great discovery
My opinion:
14. Big World! Big Adventures!
13. Misty Island Rescue
12. Day of the Diesels
11. Thomas and the Magic Railroad
10. Calling All Engines
9. King of the Railway
8. The Great Race
7. Journey Beyond Sodor
6. The Great Discovery
5. Tale of the Brave
4. Hero of the Rails
3. Blue Mountain Mystery
2. Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure
1. The Adventure Begins
I will say swap the top 2, but it doesn't matter at the bottom 7. You can mix the bottom seven, and it still makes sense.
Misty island rescue is not last how dare you
I just don't get how BWBAcgot so high
calling all engines wasnt even that bad, no way it should be lower than many of the movies you ranked higher
3:32 only thomas and henry are out of character, i think that adventure closer to be mid than to be the best. everyone has hot takes
My top 3 movies are:
3: SLOTLT.
Ryan is just Stanley and Henry is a bit of a wimp.
2: TATMR.
The tone is great.
1: TAB.
It's perfect.
I love Thomas and magic ✨ railroad and others my childhood is Hit era
1:29
WAIT YOU LIKE MISTY ISLAND Dude
i agree with everything
How was mir 11 not 14 what the heck!
To me, Misty Island Rescue is the worst Thomas movie and the 4th worst movie I have ever seen and the best movie to me is also Sodor's Legend of The Lost Treasure
My list from worst to best movie on my opinion:
14. Tale of the brave:
-It was boring, Thomas wasn't trying enough to find out what are the footprints on the rocks. And the T-rex fossil was a waste of potential and not the main idea to the title.
13. Journey beyond sodor:
-I like the new characters and I Never know there were experimental engines.
-I don't like how they make the train characters able to move, like come on this isn't chuggington.
12. Big world! big adventures!:
-The music is decent. 👍
-Again don't like moving body physics on trains. It didn't show other great places and ace....OMG where do i start, he's a awful character. Cars with faces doesn't look good (except for trucks and buses).
11. The great race:
-I like how Gordon has a brother and both talk eachother.
-It only have 3 races and ended quick. Also the best decorated challenge is pointless and not a race.
10. King of the railway:
-liked medieval stuff and royal liked engines. I obviously don't hate the movie at all.
-The title didn't stand out the movie, their is no "king" of the railway. When I saw the trailer to this, it was weird cause the faces of Thomas and etc were bright.
9. Calling all engines:
-I liked the steamies and diesels battle eachother cause of their differences. Rarely Don't see that all the time.
8. Misty island rescue:
-Interesting loging loco's character's and new island area to see. Unexpected diesel 10's return.
7. The adventure begins.
-It give me nostalgic to the classic series. I like it how they give Thomas a backstory on how he arrived to sodor. Good movie and great times to my childhood.
6. Hero of the rails.
-The story is original and fascinating.
5. Day of the diesels.
-I like it when all diesels come like a army to take over the steam work same as the steam engines form an army.
-I don't like the new voice for diesel 10 but I understand bringing OG diesel 10 voice would scare new young audience. I'm ok with that.
4. Blue mountain mystery.
-Good story, music, and the return of narrow gauge engines (well most of them).
-Scarloie's voice is way to deep but alright then no problem.
3. Sodor's legend of the lost treasure.
-Great story telling and way more enjoyable to watch. Perfect.👌
2. The great discovery.
-great quality and I love "Thomas your the leader" song, best song than every other song. Hands down.
1. Thomas and the magic railroad.
-I liked it cause it was my first movie that I ever watch and I don't give a damn what people say. Still the number one movie. Lady forever.
Magic Railroad will always be #1 in my book!
My list
God awful
14 misty island rescue
Bad
13 big world big adventures
12 day of the diesels
Why
11 magic railroad
10 the great race
Okay
9 calling all engines
8 king of the railway
Good
7 journey beyond sodor
6 hero of the rails
5 tale of the brave
Amazing
4 the great discovery
3 blue mountain mystery
2 lost treasure
Perfect
1 the adventure begins
I all do respect, I do think TATMR isn't as great as some others, the best one for me is Hero of The Rails becuase it brought me back to the series when it came out. I jsur don't think it's the worst one. BWBA was just bad and some plot point were never used. I watched the whole thing and the only thing that was good was when Thomas saw a dead engine. Also, TATMR is on UA-cam with Boomer if you want to rewatch it. I loved TATMR and is definitely my second favorite movie
But to Be Reasonable 10 Reason why I like Sharon Miller era! (And some things I don't like.)
Pros.
1. The Animation is realistic and detailed also pretty nosltalgic
2. Excellent Writing and character ideas!
3. Merchandising was good at the time.
4. The Songs were awesome and puts me in the happy mood!
5. The Voice Actors are professional and give the characters more personality
Cons
1. Too Much 3 strike formula
2. Charlie's Jokes are stale
3. Ferdinand needs to stop saying "That's Right!"
4. Too Much Ryming
5. The Camera frames could of improved
Excellent writing? Hmmmmm no
Realistic animation? Hmmmm maybe
u read my mind
For me I don’t rank these movies. Only I either like them or hate them and I like 8 of them.
I like:
Thomas And The Magic Railroad
The Great Discovery
Hero Of The Rails
Blue Mountain Mystery
King Of The Railway
Tale Of The Brave
The Adventure Begins
Sodor’s Legend Of The Lost Treasure
The rest are bad:
Calling All Engines
Misty Island Rescue
Day Of The Diesels
The Great Race
Journey Beyond Sodor
Big World Big Adventures
Here's my TTTE movies list:
1 SLOTLT
2 TAB
3 BMM
4 TGD
5 TOTB
6 KOTR
7 HOTR
8 JBS
9 TGR
10 TATMR
11 CAE
12 DOTD
13 BWBA
14 MIR
Well Even Though Diesel 10 Lost And He’s Not Gonna Win Again
My favourite is either tale of the brave or king of the railway
my i like the great discovery
magic railroad
calling all engines
They're the only 3 films with models, man if fans would be able to use model trains for a movie that'd be cool and more realistic than CGI
Be free to hate me‚ but I like TAB more than SLOTLT
The best will alway be blue mountain mystery
My rankings
11: Misty Island Rescue (The worst there is Bash and Dash are terrible the dialogue is terrible and Thomas is just as horrible)
10: Day Of The Diesels (Also pretty bad with so much rhyming and alliteration and Percy is a complete idiot)
9: Thomas And The Magic Railroad (A mess of a movie with good music and a good villain but it has little to do with Thomas the human characters are dull and the test auidences just made the film that much worse by tampering with the voices for the characters. It's plot is also way too hard to understand and is ever so convoluted.)
8: Calling All Engines (A dull experience with little going on and there's too many learning segments just to pad out the runtime and just feels generic as all it's just a movie about settling differences and the steam and diesel rivalry just feels like a race war it's got good songs and I am a bit nostalgic for it but for something in the HiT era it's rathe weak compared to the rest of the series.)
7: Hero Of The Rails (A very dated film with questionable CGI animation and the dialouge is once again terrible and it creates a huge plothole about Hiro being the first engine on sodor. Although it is miles better than everything above.)
6. The Great Discovery (A nice film with a beautiful visual look and it has a really well written message about Thomas not feeling apperciated the things that hold it back is a bit of Sharon Miller writing and Pierce Brosnan's tiresome narration that would put any kid to sleep.)
5. King Of The Railway (A very decent film with a lot going for it. I like the story about Godred's crown and Stephen is a cool character but it just feels much slower compared to other Brenner specials)
4. The Adventure Begins (Pretty overrated and not as good as Season 1 but for what is it's a nice tribute to the Railway Series it just has some things that I don't personally enjoy.)
3. Tale Of The Brave (A very well written film with a lot going for it I enjoyed Gator and the story about him and Percy and the ending is just amazing.)
2. Blue Mountain Mystery (A movie that is so well written that it would fit perfectly with the Brenner specials and the rhyming and alliteration from the previous movies has now been completely removed! Luke is adorable the mystery is great Victor's backstory being revealed was such a treat.)
1. Sodor's Legend Of The Lost Treasure (This is THE Thomas movie that feels the most cinematic. Sailor John's a fantastic villain it has great songs. Godlike orchestral soundtrack. A thrilling chase scene and a good message.)
Haven't Seen:
The Great Race (Looks very generic like Calling All Engines and just a gimmicky movie trying to shove in all these international engines that no one gives two craps about.)
Journey Beyond Sodor (All the bad characters and horribly unrealistic moments just doesn't sell with me.)
Big World! Big Adventures! (I never will watch this movie in my entire lifetime and for good reason)
#16-15: the 2 all engines go specials 0/10
Actually
#14 Misty island rescue 1/10
#13 Day of the diesels 3/10
#12 Big world big adventures 3/10
#11 Calling all engines 4/10
#10 Journey beyond sodor 6/10
#09 The great race 6/10
#08 Thomas and the magic railroad 7.5/10
#07 Hiro of the rails 8/10
#06 King of the railway 8/10
#05 Tale of the brave 8/10
#04 The great discovery 8/10
#03 Blue Mountain Mistery 9/10
#02 The adventure begins 9/10
#01 Sodor's legend of the lost treasure 10/10
14:Calling All Engines -2/10
Pros:Steamies Vs Diesels is Very Epic
Cons:89% of it is Filler Doesn’t focus on a few points Bland as That Girl from the Lorax
13.Day at the Diesels 3/10
Pros:The Exact same as Dennis’s
Cons:Forgettable Percy is not Percy I can’t take seriously at all
12.Misty Island Rescue 5/10
Pros:It’s Very Nostalgic I watched it when I was 4 And I love the animations at the start
Cons:If this movie was anything but a movie it would be a mosquito bite
11.Big World! Big Adventures 5/10
Pros:Where in the World is Thomas is Hilarious,Nia is very Good
Cons:Other than WITWIT Horrible songs,They didn’t go all around the world
10.Journey Beyond Sodor
Pros:None
Cons:None
I love it too man Ryan was gesat
Great
My favorite is hero of the rails and James is vain all the time
Nitrogen Studios animation is good and kinda in my options better then Arc Animation also the logging Locos cause me excitement but no offense if I like things ya hate
Um ok
Journey Beyond Sodor
Pros
1. Animation is Decent
2. Theo and Hurricane are interesting characters
3. I wanna go home song was a masterpiece
Cons
1. Too Cartoony and Wired
2. Lexi is uninteresting characters and is annoying
3. The plot with Thomas trapped in the steelworks was stupid and lazy even my brother hated it too
4. Frankie and Hurricane are the worst villains
5. The Bouncing Characters
6. Beresford was a dumb character
My favorite Thomas movie is thomas and the magical railroad
Mine is
Tale of the brave 5/10
Pros the new characters are good
The scene where bill and ben save thomas is good
The moral is good
The songs were great
Oliver returned
Cons percy is a idiot for the entire film
The scene where cranky stops the ship is pointless
Gator states his real name is garold but his nameplate says otherwise
Misty island rescue 6/10
Pros I like the new characters
The songs are good
Whiff returned
Cons
Thomas is a jerk
What does hicklty pility mean
Calling all engines 6⅙/10
Pros the songs are good
The fight scene was epic
Cons diesel 10 is boxed up
Derek's role is small
The great discovery 7/10
Pros Stanley's a good character
There are no learning segments
The songs are great
Pierce Brosnan is a good narrator
Cons thomas is a jerk
King of the railway 7⅓/10
Pros the new characters are great
The intro is fantastic
Jack returned
Cons the scene where they made it 1 hour long
The great race 7¼/10
Pros the new characters are good
The songs are fantastic
The flying scotchman is in it
Cons the bridge jump scene
The title is bad
Big world big adventures 7⅖/10
Pros nia and ace are good characters
Yong bao gets a speaking role
Cons sir topham hatt nearly died 3 times
Thomas is a jerk
Journey beyond sodor 7⅚/10
Pros the new characters are good
The songs are fantastic
Cons the first 10 minutes
Day of the diesel's7⅝/10
Pros diesel 10 is a villain again
The new characters are good
Cons percy is a idiot
Thomas and the magic railroad 7⅞/10
Pros the new characters are fantastic
It's the first movie
Cons the test audience screwed up the film
James is voiced by a woman in the movie
Blue mountain mystery 8/10
Pros luke and Winston are fantastic character
It had a plot twist
Cons the scene where the narrow gauge engines run away from Thomas is bad
The adventure begins 8/⅚/10
Pros it shows what happened when Thomas arrived
Cons Henry is in his new shape
Hiro of the rails 9/10
Pros the new characters are awesome
The plot is good
Cons the animation
Sodors legend of the lost treasure 10/10
Pros the new characters are fantastic
Donald Douglas rex mike bert daisy Alfie max montyand Oliver return
Cons ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmeR1
swap TATMRR with BWBA
I dont like how you put tatmr belowmisty island
seeing journey beyond sodor AND BWBA in a higher spot than Hero of the Rails causes me pain
TATMR 2018 as 2000
CAE 2019 as 2005
TGD 2020 as 2008