Ningning has the best all-around talent in Aespa to be a true soloist. She is the best overall combination of vocal talent, stage presence, dancing and versatility amongst the Aespa girls. Ningning has no holes in her game. Respect.
@@90slunne Giselle also my bias 🙃 I actually said that because ningning is a little bit better at dancing. But Giselle is improving. I'm sure this perspective will change over time 🤩
@@90slunne Giselle is not the most talented….She’s the best in rap but that’s about it. Her dance skills are average and she’s quite inconsistent vocally. Ningning however always performs at her best. She’s the best vocalist, 3rd best rapper, and debatably almost the second best dancer in aespa.
@@lattethefrappe691 Ningning and Giselle are both mid tier 7 dancers, Giselle is a weak-average vocalist (D+) and her stage presence is improving. We also have to remember that she also has writing credits. Winter is a better dancer than NingNing (energy isn't everything) and her rapping is also more consistent
@@90slunne I do know that they are both mid tier but as a dancer who looks for proper dance technique, skill, and precision, Ningning is definitely the better idol dancer and energy is not what I’m analyzing at all.. She has better lines, slightly better dance technique, she’s more consistent, she has better pops and locks, she’s cleaner and has slightly better stamina, her dynamics are good, and she has good footwork. Have you never watched a fan cam of ningning? I said she’s also almost the 2nd best dancer in Aespa. Winter is the better dancer but not at all by a lot. Ningning has improved so much from Black Mamba era. Her body control, precision, footwork, isolations, chest pops, etc. have improved and she’s only getting better. You can tell in her solo stage. Her extensions have always been good. As far as rapping, Ningning rarely to never gets to rap but in “Wake up”, she proved that she is the better rapper. She has better flow, better tone (in my opinion), better attitude, faster speed, and her vibe is much more fluid. Winter is only more consistent in rap because she gets to rap more than Ningning Ningning is better in rap. Sorry not sorry.
@@TrucPham-nn8cl not really sure which but highly likely the ones who came on that day. I think there was max tvxq, eunhyuk suju, taeyeon snsd, key minho shinee, seulgi wendy rv, kun, xiaojun ten haechan renjun jisung i think hahajjzjzjsjzk
She wasn't trained four years for nothing. Ningning was born to slayy. GOOD VOCAL✅ GOOD DANCER✅ STAGE PRESENCE✅ I know she will become one of the strongest 4th gen kpop artist.
idk what to say i’m speechless this is the best thing i ever heard SHE NEEDS TO RELEASE THIS I WOULD STREAM ASF !!!!! Ningning on this beat??? WAW i need to know who tf produced it bc god damn is fire
Ningning is doig amazing as a solo singer and performer 💯 love her stage presence and expressions, her vocals beautiful and smooth as always. My favorite idol ❤
It's a change from some successful bands that are vocally weaker. With aespa, I've become more demanding about the vocal quality of bands. Ningning does the job with precision and firmness, she's really talented. She started singing in China as a child, her experience and talent immediately put her among the best. And she's only 20!
WAIT WHAT?? NINGNING OK GIRL GO OFFFFF see sm needs to stop hiding her and let her slay like why no ningning in g.o.t. the beat when girlie can serve this???
[Intro] Wake up, Wake up Wake up, wake up You should get up, wake up, ay Wake up, wake up Oh, what you think I said? [Verse 1] 무슨 짓을 해봐도 you can’t see my flaws 소용 없어 달려도 keep it up my road Oh, you look so mad Oh, you look so crazy 땀에 젖은 face, oh, my god so funny So bad, 받아들여 honey 잘 봐, I’m the one top stunner 다 보여, what you thinking 난 네 마음보다 빨라 Keep running, running, running, huh, like [Pre-Chorus] I don’t wanna stop Are you ready, are you ready 어딜 숨어도 거긴 이미 나의 stage 거쳐간 네 상상은 내 놀이터, move, more quickly 잡아 벌써 벌써 벌써 [Chorus] 훅 나타나 휙 낚아채 널 조종할 my finger snap 밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad 커지는 heartbeat 겁먹은 face 거친 네 deep breath 그럼 넌 race You never wake up You woke up to me Now just turn it up [Verse 2] You don’t know what I’m gon’ do 밤새도록 너의 마음을 바꿔놓을 거야 Mess it up, no, no, no, 너를 숨겨도 I gotta Hey, hey, hey, keep it up 심장 끝까지 쫓는 story Oh my, you know I’m the real top stunnеr 안아줄 듯 밀어내고 달래줄 듯 괴롭혀도 날 보는 네 마음은 boom, boom [Pre-Chorus] I don't want to stop Are you ready, are you rеady 눈을 떠봐도 거긴 아직 나의 stage You have to follow it, you gotta know Move so quickly You should get up, wake up, ay [Chorus] 훅 나타나 휙 낚아채 널 조종할 my finger snap 밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad 커지는 heartbeat 겁먹은 face 거친 네 deep breath 그럼 넌 race You never wake up You woke up to me [Bridge] 멀리 아침이 와 구해줄 듯이 but 그마저 결국 날 향하는 시간이야 [Chorus] 훅 나타나 휙 낚아채 널 조종할 my finger snap 밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad No, it’s time to look at, mess it up You into me You can’t run away You never wake up, 내 안에 갇혀
I was surprised, I always thought Winter would get a solo stage like this while Ningning had Winter's ballad but Ningning proved me up and ate this with no crumbs left
Winter can't pull off this concept as well as Ningning. Ningning's stage presence, swagger and facial expressions are way above Winter's right now. Maybe Winter will catch up in the future.
She's ready to do solo, but the label don't. What I see is Ningning actually able to hype the crowd, but SM always have the tendencies to make everything so perfect. Like this performance; her mic is off, and she needs to focus on dance only. I'll wait for the time SM let her really 'shine' as she actually is
![[HD] aespa KARINA "Menagerie" Solo Stage Performance (Concert Ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SsO6rTJZGvg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HD] aespa KARINA "Menagerie" Solo Stage Performance (Concert Ver.)](/img/tr.png)
NingNing is a rising star. She knows her charisma and she knew as well her appeal to be a soloist.
But shes lovely as she was shy after solo performance at the concert lol
@@l6k007 p⁰o⁰
I really hope Ningning does some more solo, she's incredible.
100% vocalist 100% dancer 100% rapper 100% visual
Ningning has the best all-around talent in Aespa to be a true soloist. She is the best overall combination of vocal talent, stage presence, dancing and versatility amongst the Aespa girls. Ningning has no holes in her game. Respect.
She can change her voice to match the song, it's impressive.
this is the best solo stage for me ningning has everything in her vocals rap dance visual she fking nailed it god real 4th gen ace
Most badass solo stage from 4th gen
_she has one of the most perfect vocals in kpop_
omg Ningning. She's crazy. She really is the top stunner.
This new side of Ning is shocking, I love her duality ❤
Ningning's stage presence here is absolutely amazing! her future as soloist is so clear!
Ningning really looks like a senior idol. She really is the most talented member. I'm proud of her!!
Ningning is my bias, but personally I think Giselle is the most talented
@@90slunne Giselle also my bias 🙃 I actually said that because ningning is a little bit better at dancing. But Giselle is improving. I'm sure this perspective will change over time 🤩
@@90slunne Giselle is not the most talented….She’s the best in rap but that’s about it. Her dance skills are average and she’s quite inconsistent vocally. Ningning however always performs at her best. She’s the best vocalist, 3rd best rapper, and debatably almost the second best dancer in aespa.
@@lattethefrappe691 Ningning and Giselle are both mid tier 7 dancers, Giselle is a weak-average vocalist (D+) and her stage presence is improving. We also have to remember that she also has writing credits.
Winter is a better dancer than NingNing (energy isn't everything) and her rapping is also more consistent
@@90slunne I do know that they are both mid tier but as a dancer who looks for proper dance technique, skill, and precision, Ningning is definitely the better idol dancer and energy is not what I’m analyzing at all.. She has better lines, slightly better dance technique, she’s more consistent, she has better pops and locks, she’s cleaner and has slightly better stamina, her dynamics are good, and she has good footwork. Have you never watched a fan cam of ningning?
I said she’s also almost the 2nd best dancer in Aespa. Winter is the better dancer but not at all by a lot. Ningning has improved so much from Black Mamba era. Her body control, precision, footwork, isolations, chest pops, etc. have improved and she’s only getting better. You can tell in her solo stage. Her extensions have always been good.
As far as rapping, Ningning rarely to never gets to rap but in “Wake up”, she proved that she is the better rapper. She has better flow, better tone (in my opinion), better attitude, faster speed, and her vibe is much more fluid. Winter is only more consistent in rap because she gets to rap more than Ningning Ningning is better in rap. Sorry not sorry.
Man... I know she can sing, but daaaaaaang, she can dance and "rap" extremely well too. She is going places for sure!
ningning is the most beautiful member of aespa
Ningning can be an amazing vocalist, a rapper, and a dancer and she is very beautiful ❤️ She's a queen 👑 😎
It took me a long time to chose a bias but her stage presence made me chose her
NINGNING IS A FULL PACKAGE! 100% VOCAL, 100% VISUAL, 100% DANCE!
The diva of 4th gen .. and i would like to say she is the goddess of photoshoots and teasers
THIS SONG IS AMAZING! I never expected NINGNING to do a concept like this 😳❤️ she slay this !!
Saw somewhere that said this is the performance that her seniors are most awed at. Good job impressing your seniors Ningning! Love you!!
Do you remember which seniors exactly?
@@TrucPham-nn8cl not really sure which but highly likely the ones who came on that day. I think there was max tvxq, eunhyuk suju, taeyeon snsd, key minho shinee, seulgi wendy rv, kun, xiaojun ten haechan renjun jisung i think hahajjzjzjsjzk
she's so talented
Woh...ningning has got that freestyle dance perfect and wonder if she will have an album some day
aespa should have a concept like this because ningning slaysssss
She wasn't trained four years for nothing. Ningning was born to slayy.
GOOD VOCAL✅
GOOD DANCER✅
STAGE PRESENCE✅
I know she will become one of the strongest 4th gen kpop artist.
And she can actually like rap 😮
you missed the rap. ALL ROUNDER MAKNAE ✨✨✨✨✨✨
에스파님들의 메인보컬 닝닝님다운 카리스마 넘치는 wake up.. 좋아요!😊
this is my favorite choreography ever and it’s not even released 😭
I need this song to be official so bad
idk what to say i’m speechless this is the best thing i ever heard SHE NEEDS TO RELEASE THIS I WOULD STREAM ASF !!!!! Ningning on this beat??? WAW i need to know who tf produced it bc god damn is fire
This is a Hyolyn/BoA level performance wowww
Ningning is doig amazing as a solo singer and performer 💯 love her stage presence and expressions, her vocals beautiful and smooth as always. My favorite idol ❤
It's a change from some successful bands that are vocally weaker. With aespa, I've become more demanding about the vocal quality of bands. Ningning does the job with precision and firmness, she's really talented. She started singing in China as a child, her experience and talent immediately put her among the best. And she's only 20!
WAIT WHAT?? NINGNING OK GIRL GO OFFFFF see sm needs to stop hiding her and let her slay like why no ningning in g.o.t. the beat when girlie can serve this???
Imagine her in GOT 🔥🔥🔥🔥🥹
Cause she is the WHOLE of g.o.t the beat. She checks of all the criteria and roles
ここ最近のドルの皆様が清楚コンセプトが多い中こういう魅力爆発セクシーコンセプトをお届けしてくれるニン様に大感謝😭✨まぢかわいい😭✨
she shined so much!! 😭🤍
Imagine a main vocal who dance like main dancer ❤
Baekyhun exo
BTS jungkook
twice jihyo
@@whenibuyacaricallitjiminso1808 not for me
@@ptmachenel9928 yess ❤
@@whenibuyacaricallitjiminso1808 mmmm no
Her stage presence is insane 😎
Best performance of the year!!
Dengar dia nyanyi sampai merinding , ningning emang nggak pernah mengecewakan suaranya
0:55 I'm replaying this part for about 20x now
😻😻😻😻me too
What a Queen, this song slayyyys
She really is the best performer of the group 🥵🥵🥵
I am still so obsessed with this performance. I wish SM has released the song officially
She slayed as damn
0:58 this part! Slay Queen! 😊🫰
[Intro]
Wake up, Wake up
Wake up, wake up
You should get up, wake up, ay
Wake up, wake up
Oh, what you think I said?
[Verse 1]
무슨 짓을 해봐도 you can’t see my flaws
소용 없어 달려도 keep it up my road
Oh, you look so mad
Oh, you look so crazy
땀에 젖은 face, oh, my god so funny
So bad, 받아들여 honey
잘 봐, I’m the one top stunner
다 보여, what you thinking
난 네 마음보다 빨라
Keep running, running, running, huh, like
[Pre-Chorus]
I don’t wanna stop
Are you ready, are you ready
어딜 숨어도 거긴 이미 나의 stage
거쳐간 네 상상은 내 놀이터, move, more quickly
잡아 벌써 벌써 벌써
[Chorus]
훅 나타나 휙 낚아채
널 조종할 my finger snap
밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome
Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad
커지는 heartbeat 겁먹은 face
거친 네 deep breath 그럼 넌 race
You never wake up
You woke up to me
Now just turn it up
[Verse 2]
You don’t know what I’m gon’ do
밤새도록 너의 마음을 바꿔놓을 거야
Mess it up, no, no, no, 너를 숨겨도 I gotta
Hey, hey, hey, keep it up
심장 끝까지 쫓는 story
Oh my, you know I’m the real top stunnеr
안아줄 듯 밀어내고 달래줄 듯 괴롭혀도
날 보는 네 마음은 boom, boom
[Pre-Chorus]
I don't want to stop
Are you ready, are you rеady
눈을 떠봐도 거긴 아직 나의 stage
You have to follow it, you gotta know
Move so quickly
You should get up, wake up, ay
[Chorus]
훅 나타나 휙 낚아채
널 조종할 my finger snap
밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome
Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad
커지는 heartbeat 겁먹은 face
거친 네 deep breath 그럼 넌 race
You never wake up
You woke up to me
[Bridge]
멀리 아침이 와
구해줄 듯이 but 그마저 결국
날 향하는 시간이야
[Chorus]
훅 나타나 휙 낚아채
널 조종할 my finger snap
밤은 길고 이 꿈은 awesome
Run for more chase, bad, bad, bad, bad
No, it’s time to look at, mess it up
You into me
You can’t run away
You never wake up, 내 안에 갇혀
I CANNOT WAIT FOR THIS MEW ALBUM, May can't come fast enough!
Luv the Arianafication of this song. Yaasss ning work iiittt
she was born to be a performer. look at her
Something about the way she pronounces 0:56 just sounds so pleasantly satisfying to me
She ate…like👑❤️
카리나 윈터에 가려져서 그렇지 닝닝이 진짜 정통 미인상이네 진짜 이쁘당
A main vocalist who raps so satisfying
Awesome!!! Love Ningning so much. 😍❤️
Why isn’t this on spotify yet? Please I want thhis so bad. Ningning
I LOVE ningnings solo, I hope she debuts as a soloist she has so much potential. Hopefully in the future 🙏
Omg first she did this. The vocals. The dancing. AND she did an English version too? I love her.
I was surprised, I always thought Winter would get a solo stage like this while Ningning had Winter's ballad but Ningning proved me up and ate this with no crumbs left
this fit more ningning style, she's a baddie. Winter is my bias but she fits more simple, preppy style of songs, her stage was empty tho...
Winter can't pull off this concept as well as Ningning. Ningning's stage presence, swagger and facial expressions are way above Winter's right now. Maybe Winter will catch up in the future.
2:21 the moment that made my wig fly straight to the Kwangya💔💔💔
She’s so good. I didn’t expect to be wrecked by her. ❤
How many times have you watched this?
Me: Yes
SM get yo ass UP and WORK damn.. is it that hard to release a song
She's ready to do solo, but the label don't. What I see is Ningning actually able to hype the crowd, but SM always have the tendencies to make everything so perfect. Like this performance; her mic is off, and she needs to focus on dance only. I'll wait for the time SM let her really 'shine' as she actually is
She definitely knows what 4 + 4 is.....
Ate ❤
Woow NingNing la rompiste Mujer!! Cada día más impactada 😘
My gurl's a stunnah
Ningning Grande 💋💋‼️
Wake Up and Up are officially my fav aespa solo songs 🔥
Wow superstar ningning
I love you Ningning
NINGNING SLAYY
I’ll never get over this song
Her dance,vocal,rap,visual 💯
Ningning, you are so cool, this performance was out of the box. So gorgeous.
And somehow it reminded me of Agnezmo. I really missed Agnezmo too tho.
I have two words to describe this: sexy and powerful.
0:53 The dancer looks like Seulgi
Why is that true-
thought it was just me!
Apenas BRILHE Ningning, você nasceu pra ser uma estrela!!! 💖💫
she holds so much power honestly
I always come back to this, she ate so bad
Ningning hasn't changed. peoples reactions to her have. Slayning is epic 😀
After watching the video Ningning is definitely my bais
id love to see her do more solo stages shes such an amazing performer
2:20 obsessedddddd
Ningning slay❤
OMG NINGINING
Straight 🔥! I hope they release all these solos - I need to blast them 24/7!
My baby SLAAAAY
This song is so good😍 ningning stage performance ate, she born to be star❤
I can really see her slaying solo. However I wish she would showcase her live singing more
and that's queenqueen!
Ningning you are a super star 💋
And we have to wake up from this dream, you drive us crazy
👑QUEEN NING NING
Charisma overflowing, my queen burn the stage again and again
Slaaayyyyyy 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Suka sekali Dengerin ini lagu sama dance nya keren bgt, tidak bosen bosen..
Ningning u are the best
Her stage presence💣💣she looks like jennie from blackpink especialy her side face
This is such a fcking SERVE Ningning will forever be my aespa bias. I can’t wait for her solo promotions too 🥳
Ning, you slay without them! bravoning~
02:19 slay
Her laugh at the start took my heart.
Aespa has so much potential to become a huge group. But SM just needs to WAKE UP bc currently they’re ruining the group