Exactly This video: "It makes people feel relaxed listening to educational tapes, but there's not enough evidence it really works with retaining info." Other videos: "To answer that, we first need to go through the history of tape recorders and education. Then a paid ad about RAID Shadow Legends, followed by another 10 minutes of empty information, before coming to the conclusion we don't know"
@@kurddata5228 Yeah, the results of placebos are interesting but it's a shame the same effects are not achieved without their psychological involvement
I used to watch rap battles before bed and word play schemes that they'd come up with would bounce around my head all the time. I truly believe listening to something before bed at the very least helps store it in memory.
I agree, your conscious mind might not pick it up but people seem to forgot that your subconscious mind never sleeps and can pick things up when your asleep
Seems to leave out the most important aspect to this answer. The subconscious mind never sleeps so it can still pick up what you feed to it when your asleep
I have no conclusive evidence myself either, but I CAN share that by listening to long educational podcasts - e.g. talks on quantum mechanics, that during my sleep I sometimes end up dreaming I'm in a lecture hall asking questions and getting personal answers from the physicist. 😊 I know from studying a bit of neuroscience (while awake) that learning requires *attention*, and subsequently requires *sleep* where we replay the memory of our day in reverse order and solidifies memories into a long-term form. (Interestingly, I've also learned that every time we retrieve a memory stored in long-term storage, it becomes open to becoming altered by the experiences occurring while retrieving that memory.) So e.g. while I've had enough math to understand the basics of category theory, it's been a while since I've actively studied it, so I'm planning on starting over and going through every type of math til I get to the ones I only started to understand (like category theory), or maths I never had a full class in (e.g. statistics). About to play one now while I sleep. 🤓🔉😴
so basically we can learn these things? but we cant retain that information or use it on tests? so basically the doctor is saying I can learn spanish and speak it but cant write the words down or remember every phrase? eh whatever im sure over time it'll stick
@@spcmartin420 no examples come to mind but I’m pretty certain there have been studies that haven’t yielded results but then tested again later another way maybe with better technology and produced results. There’s been money wasted on worse things anyway.
@@spcmartin420 the technology I speak of was hypothetical so your guess would be as good as mine. Also, it actually has been shown to work in the past.
I actually listened to a tape on German and it actually did help over time while I slept. As it said, I cannot write down the words in German. Since I couldn’t do that I decided to learn how to do it. I learnt how to do it at month 5, but I’m a fast learner soooo.... yeah “Hallo wie geht es dir heute”
@@__4654 Mir geht es exzellent, danke für die Nachfrage. Aus welchem Land kommst du denn? Ich würde sagen aus Saudi Arabien, aber bin mir dabei nicht sicher.
Maybe there could be a psychological effect that makes people feel more confident in learning ? But however if the person starts getting over-confident about it but doesn't actually learn during sleep, then that could be another problem
Why would a linguistic expert know the answer? The brain is in a special phase, in which it's sorting out unnecessary informations gather over the course of the day, it just makes sense, that the brain can really process any information between the REM phases of sleep.
@@sad_wrangler8515 there are 5 stages of sleep, the drowsiness,light sleep,moderate sleep,deep sleep and REM,during REM we can also do lucid dreaming which is also connecting a concious part of mind...the only stages where filtering occurs is moderate and deep sleep,the brain is blank..that means the other 3 stages are under conciousness and subconciousness as well,also we dont have clarity on how the brain processes the filtering during those 2 stages either..so isnt it possible that we will be able to learn during those 3 stages?
@@__4654 The problem is that our mind was never meant to learn in these phases of sleep or in general in the phase of sleep. In general, subconsciousness learning is quite inefficient, plus the subconsciousness knowledge of our mind is for most inaccessible, only a few with "Island Talent Syndrome", or people with severe trauma or physical brain damage can access the subconsciousness knowledge. I mean, you can make a selftest, if you really can learn with subconsciousness listening, it could be proofen quite easily. I tried it once, put at least I couldn't remember a single thing, to what I have listened in my sleep.
@@sad_wrangler8515 Hey thanks for replying!also u made a good point tho..well now that u have said,i have extreme amnesia and other blackouts in my memories of certain parts,its prolly cuz of some trauma,i have no memory of it either...maybe that explains something..idk its weird...u have any other ideas to this as well..?pls do tell me if u do..u have really opened my mind tho!
I am starting my own independent 30 day trial on this subject tonight. I will be playing French language lessons all night, every night, from 30 seconds before I get into bed until I wake up for the next month. I'll let you know how I go.
You’re trusting a doctor who will turn around and shove all types of medication down your throat so he can continue making more money instead of telling all the natural free to low cost ways you can heal?
new research shows though it won't have any long term effects but it might help you to understand somethings better tomorrow just don't hear it too loud and not with a Bluetooth headphones
Seems like he’s just saying there’s not enough data and it might be difficult to retain, I’m still gonna test it and make my own data so hopefully someday I’ll be one of the smartest people on earth without having to read everything and not consciously have to pay attention
@@jass7755 after listening to this and the night after an audio of rocket science I don’t recall a thing about it, best thing is probably to listen to them when awake a few times
@@DD99654 try to watch and be alert about the info before u go to sleep..also tell to urself that u would like to learn this while sleeping somehow..first u try with setting ur brain as an alarm clock..set a time u would like to wake or set a limit on how much hours to sleep...then see if brain tries to make u wake up during that time...this all works for me uk
I’m not a doctor. But this is false. I learned my times tables when I was 7 by playing them 1x1 through 10x10 before I went to bed and falling asleep through it. I might leave this school now because he’s lying to us
That is what he said? Are you too thick to watch the full video and actually listen? I am not legally an adult yet I can muster up the attention span to watch this video and get a solid answer. Imbecile.
@@jimtsap04 Placebo effects would be something like telling a perfectly fine person that they're sick then they start sneezing out of nowhere right? There's really no outside source that caused them to be sick.. But if a person did something like.. learn the entire pi while they slept because of something that actually TAUGHT them, then that wouldn't count as a placebo? Idk I'm bad at explaining my jumbled thought process. I guess a better wording of what I'm talking about would be "Person listens to pi while they sleep, wakes up and consciously knows pi, number by number"🤷🏽♀️
Placebo effects, to me, are more like affirmations. Imagine telling a person, with one dollar to their name, that they'll be rich within a month then suddenly, they know all the keys to becoming a CEO without ever searching for it😂. But with this, it would be an outside force telling them all the tricks.
@@AlanaeImontae I think I'm picking up what you're putting down, if it's not placebo the it would be a little less direct that straight up memorising information, it would be more like your subconscious consuming information without consciously analyzing it, kinda like passively scrolling social media, more consuming than actually learning, any knowledge you'd get would be at most a foggy mess if you haven't done any further study on the subject.
I tried to learn a language SOLELY by only listening as I slept as an experiment and I learned quite a few common phrases. Still can't read it though(Portugese)😂😂 (Edit: I actually have quite a few cases to prove this is possible because that's really how I learned/started off learning a lot of things Ik right now. I'm bad at explaining how I think it works though.)
@@setrakianabraham8706 Thank you for bringing me back. Portugués is so easy to read now. I breeze through Portugués, German, Spanish & even a bit of French(I promised myself that I’d never try French😵💫).. I guess I’m trying Japanese, Russian, Thai or Vietnamese after French!!
I have done this experiment, and here are the outcomes 1. If you listen and while listening if you sleep then it won't help the moment you felt sleep after that nothing will go in your mind it's completely blank you won't remember a thing after you reach to first cycle of sleep which is 15-30 minutes from the instance of closing eyes and starting listening, 2. when you start listening while closing your eyes after few minutes you will definitely sleep , bit what will happen with final outcome , ...ummm it's just nothing you will get a good nap of 15minutes to 1hr and afterwords you will start studying with eyes open , sitting on your study desk with 100% concentration
![[Try Listening for 3 Minutes] FALL ASLEEP FAST | DEEP SLEEP RELAXING MUSIC](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rCSCPujLs14/mqdefault.jpg)
Why cant all videos be like this?, quick and to the point, no bullshit.
Money
Watch time
Nice avatar
Don’t forget to subscribe , hit the like button, and follow on twitter
I suppose this was not for the money. I am pretty sure dragging a video out gives people more money so they just add fake stuff for the money.
I wish every channel would give a quick answer without sellout
Yeah
UA-cam isn’t about being informational anymore it’s about the money, more view time equals higher chance of being recommended and shit like that
Exactly
This video: "It makes people feel relaxed listening to educational tapes, but there's not enough evidence it really works with retaining info."
Other videos: "To answer that, we first need to go through the history of tape recorders and education. Then a paid ad about RAID Shadow Legends, followed by another 10 minutes of empty information, before coming to the conclusion we don't know"
Normally they have 1 minute intro and 1 minute outro
That's the first thing I thought while watching this. But making video too short can be a loss to the youtubers
Answer: well yes but no
I experienced while learning German. It does help!
@@kurddata5228 It's possible you'r6 experiencing a placbo effect
@@wizardoftrees8424 I am overwhelmed with gratitude for placebo. Luckily I can trick my brain
@@kurddata5228 Yeah, the results of placebos are interesting but it's a shame the same effects are not achieved without their psychological involvement
@@wizardoftrees8424 you mean placebo
I used to watch rap battles before bed and word play schemes that they'd come up with would bounce around my head all the time. I truly believe listening to something before bed at the very least helps store it in memory.
Practice with sleep makes perfect
Not practice and practice
Yes there has been studyies on this
Google -practice with sleep makes perfect.
I agree, your conscious mind might not pick it up but people seem to forgot that your subconscious mind never sleeps and can pick things up when your asleep
rap music promotes anxiety and ADD.
Studying before sleeping strengthens memory of it.
Seems to leave out the most important aspect to this answer. The subconscious mind never sleeps so it can still pick up what you feed to it when your asleep
I have no conclusive evidence myself either, but I CAN share that by listening to long educational podcasts - e.g. talks on quantum mechanics, that during my sleep I sometimes end up dreaming I'm in a lecture hall asking questions and getting personal answers from the physicist. 😊
I know from studying a bit of neuroscience (while awake) that learning requires *attention*, and subsequently requires *sleep* where we replay the memory of our day in reverse order and solidifies memories into a long-term form.
(Interestingly, I've also learned that every time we retrieve a memory stored in long-term storage, it becomes open to becoming altered by the experiences occurring while retrieving that memory.)
So e.g. while I've had enough math to understand the basics of category theory, it's been a while since I've actively studied it, so I'm planning on starting over and going through every type of math til I get to the ones I only started to understand (like category theory), or maths I never had a full class in (e.g. statistics).
About to play one now while I sleep. 🤓🔉😴
so basically we can learn these things? but we cant retain that information or use it on tests? so basically the doctor is saying I can learn spanish and speak it but cant write the words down or remember every phrase? eh whatever im sure over time it'll stick
School flashbacks.
Dude written spanish is easy. It's easier than English. For the most part how it's written is how it sounds
@@supermonk3y07 learning langugage flashbacks.
@@supermonk3y07 once u can write it its easy to speak it too! imagine the words in ur head:)
No? He's saying that listening to things might relax your brain and make you feel better but you don't learn anything from it
They should do more scientific studies on this
@@toothless.warrior that’s why I said “more”. Have a quick reading lesson.
@@sigmazeta8 if it’s never been shown to work in the past why waste more money studying it?
@@spcmartin420 no examples come to mind but I’m pretty certain there have been studies that haven’t yielded results but then tested again later another way maybe with better technology and produced results. There’s been money wasted on worse things anyway.
@@sigmazeta8 What new technology could yield different results? Our brains just aren’t active enough during sleep.
@@spcmartin420 the technology I speak of was hypothetical so your guess would be as good as mine. Also, it actually has been shown to work in the past.
I actually listened to a tape on German and it actually did help over time while I slept. As it said, I cannot write down the words in German. Since I couldn’t do that I decided to learn how to do it. I learnt how to do it at month 5, but I’m a fast learner soooo.... yeah
“Hallo wie geht es dir heute”
Es geht mir gut und dir?
Sehr gut
es geht und du?
@@__4654 Mir geht es exzellent, danke für die Nachfrage. Aus welchem Land kommst du denn? Ich würde sagen aus Saudi Arabien, aber bin mir dabei nicht sicher.
Holy crap I read these comments fluently. I know more German than I thought I did😂😂
Video: So you want to know if you can learn by listening to tape while sleeping??
Also video: *WELL WE DON'T KNOW EITHER*
Lol
At least they only used 37 seconds of our time to say that as opposed to 37 minutes
So basically "not quite, but if it makes you feel better... do it."
Maybe there could be a psychological effect that makes people feel more confident in learning ?
But however if the person starts getting over-confident about it but doesn't actually learn during sleep, then that could be another problem
I'm trying to figure why an internal medicine doctor is answering this question and not a linguistics expert
Why would a linguistic expert know the answer? The brain is in a special phase, in which it's sorting out unnecessary informations gather over the course of the day, it just makes sense, that the brain can really process any information between the REM phases of sleep.
@@sad_wrangler8515 there are 5 stages of sleep, the drowsiness,light sleep,moderate sleep,deep sleep and REM,during REM we can also do lucid dreaming which is also connecting a concious part of mind...the only stages where filtering occurs is moderate and deep sleep,the brain is blank..that means the other 3 stages are under conciousness and subconciousness as well,also we dont have clarity on how the brain processes the filtering during those 2 stages either..so isnt it possible that we will be able to learn during those 3 stages?
@@__4654 The problem is that our mind was never meant to learn in these phases of
sleep or in general in the phase of sleep. In general, subconsciousness learning
is quite inefficient, plus the subconsciousness knowledge of our mind is for
most inaccessible, only a few with "Island Talent Syndrome", or people with severe trauma
or physical brain damage can access the subconsciousness knowledge. I mean, you can make
a selftest, if you really can learn with subconsciousness listening, it could be proofen
quite easily. I tried it once, put at least I couldn't remember a single thing, to what
I have listened in my sleep.
@@sad_wrangler8515 Hey thanks for replying!also u made a good point tho..well now that u have said,i have extreme amnesia and other blackouts in my memories of certain parts,its prolly cuz of some trauma,i have no memory of it either...maybe that explains something..idk its weird...u have any other ideas to this as well..?pls do tell me if u do..u have really opened my mind tho!
Dr. : But there's not a lot of scientific evidence
My brain : turn off the WiFi
Best video ever without any drama
I am starting my own independent 30 day trial on this subject tonight. I will be playing French language lessons all night, every night, from 30 seconds before I get into bed until I wake up for the next month. I'll let you know how I go.
Ok same
Any updates?
Results?
shiii
How did it go
They feel better because they beleive it's working, but language learning is different
By looking at the duration of this video I thought it’s gonna be a joke and the doctor will just say “no” as a reply. 😆
Thank you Doctor!
Asem Eljahmi - (Bane snaps neck of doctor)
@@arealgoodguy nice
You’re trusting a doctor who will turn around and shove all types of medication down your throat so he can continue making more money instead of telling all the natural free to low cost ways you can heal?
Dr. Huberman at Stanford talked about playing audio during a certain stage of sleep that does work.
new research shows though it won't have any long term effects
but it might help you to understand somethings better tomorrow
just don't hear it too loud and not with a Bluetooth headphones
It's conscious vs subconscious mind. If the former is asleep, very little learning.
Helpful
thank you for your short answer..
IS IT Y E S OR N O ! ! ? ? ? W H A T THE H E L L.
Ikr.. Talk about vague
That's a no.
It doesn't matter, this video is from 2010.We now know it's possible, we just don't specifically know how to perfect it.
It’s yes and no
@@robynyoumans2366 🤣
Disliked because it wasn't the answer I wanted! 😂
RACHEL IS NOW 40
A better night's sleep is due to the certain wavelengths in the songs
is it a yes or no or *yesn't* or "noys*
Just try yourself for a couple of days, then drop your comment here.
Seems like he’s just saying there’s not enough data and it might be difficult to retain, I’m still gonna test it and make my own data so hopefully someday I’ll be one of the smartest people on earth without having to read everything and not consciously have to pay attention
Can you update please?
@@jass7755 after listening to this and the night after an audio of rocket science I don’t recall a thing about it, best thing is probably to listen to them when awake a few times
@@DD99654 try to watch and be alert about the info before u go to sleep..also tell to urself that u would like to learn this while sleeping somehow..first u try with setting ur brain as an alarm clock..set a time u would like to wake or set a limit on how much hours to sleep...then see if brain tries to make u wake up during that time...this all works for me uk
@@DD99654 hi give me your experience please
@@DD99654 hiiiii
So you're saying it won't hurt 🤔
I learned c++ while sleeping
For real?
@@mr.nutella1745 no lol
@@sethamoto9061 oh
@@mr.nutella1745 if you believed that I got a closet full of snake oil I want to sell you in a pyramid scheme.
Boi! I wish 🤣
Remember this little saying that you put whatever you wanted to learn under your pillow and sleep on it
Wouldn’t a psychiatrist or psychologist be a better doctor to ask these kinds of questions too
Actually.. yes. A very good one is hard to come by though😬
Seeing only the length of video, it was obvious that the answer would be no. A yes answer would need more explanation.
Fair, yet gray area answer
Did anyone of the people in the comments reasearched the subconscious mind before.
Y
Short answer: maybe but probably not
I’m not a doctor. But this is false. I learned my times tables when I was 7 by playing them 1x1 through 10x10 before I went to bed and falling asleep through it. I might leave this school now because he’s lying to us
what about audiobooks like fight club
@Slyz Fel but seriously tho did you read the 2 and 3 book
so, he doesn't know
As simple as that
All he had to say was yes or no and why it was that answer...
That is what he said? Are you too thick to watch the full video and actually listen? I am not legally an adult yet I can muster up the attention span to watch this video and get a solid answer. Imbecile.
So is that a yes or a no?
Spypals no
There's no real evidence of it working, but it's worth trying
yesn't
Haha xD the guy up there is correct xD it's a yesen't xD
Ion even know
pog
Listen to mantras as u sleep
I think its a placebo effect more often than not
That wouldn't make sense
@@AlanaeImontae how?
@@jimtsap04 Placebo effects would be something like telling a perfectly fine person that they're sick then they start sneezing out of nowhere right? There's really no outside source that caused them to be sick.. But if a person did something like.. learn the entire pi while they slept because of something that actually TAUGHT them, then that wouldn't count as a placebo? Idk I'm bad at explaining my jumbled thought process. I guess a better wording of what I'm talking about would be "Person listens to pi while they sleep, wakes up and consciously knows pi, number by number"🤷🏽♀️
Placebo effects, to me, are more like affirmations. Imagine telling a person, with one dollar to their name, that they'll be rich within a month then suddenly, they know all the keys to becoming a CEO without ever searching for it😂. But with this, it would be an outside force telling them all the tricks.
@@AlanaeImontae I think I'm picking up what you're putting down, if it's not placebo the it would be a little less direct that straight up memorising information, it would be more like your subconscious consuming information without consciously analyzing it, kinda like passively scrolling social media, more consuming than actually learning, any knowledge you'd get would be at most a foggy mess if you haven't done any further study on the subject.
They've been has scientific research and shit on this. This man lied.
"They've been has scientific research?" Perhaps you should try listening to one of those tapes on proper grammar when you go to bed tonight.
I got you an answer it's a No.
I tried to learn a language SOLELY by only listening as I slept as an experiment and I learned quite a few common phrases. Still can't read it though(Portugese)😂😂
(Edit: I actually have quite a few cases to prove this is possible because that's really how I learned/started off learning a lot of things Ik right now. I'm bad at explaining how I think it works though.)
any update?
@@setrakianabraham8706 Thank you for bringing me back. Portugués is so easy to read now. I breeze through Portugués, German, Spanish & even a bit of French(I promised myself that I’d never try French😵💫)..
I guess I’m trying Japanese, Russian, Thai or Vietnamese after French!!
@@AlanaeImontae wow you are uch a talented person! Does solely listening to recordings during sleep work or not?
Answer: unknown, due to lack of evidence.
Luckily we have evidence now. This video is ten years old.
@@NottherealLucifer And, what was the verdict on that, if you don't mind?
in other words, yesn't
Thats a no
Huh?
That is right..just a load of nonsense. you canot learn while you sleep....I tried many timea and it dont work...who created tz thought is a Lie.
At least I know now it’s a waste of money
The answer is no.
well that didnt really answer anything lmao
Yes it dis
Answer at 0:27 thank me later
I have done this experiment, and here are the outcomes
1. If you listen and while listening if you sleep then it won't help the moment you felt sleep after that nothing will go in your mind it's completely blank you won't remember a thing after you reach to first cycle of sleep which is 15-30 minutes from the instance of closing eyes and starting listening,
2. when you start listening while closing your eyes after few minutes you will definitely sleep , bit what will happen with final outcome , ...ummm it's just nothing you will get a good nap of 15minutes to 1hr and afterwords you will start studying with eyes open , sitting on your study desk with 100% concentration
Nope