they sound realli different in terms of their emotion. the way Jacky sings is like a realli old people who looks back his own love story. eason's sounds the people who is around 30 to 40 age look back to his previous relationship.it gives me a feeling that he still cant forget and try to complain it
A bit pitchy at the beginning and the tempo is slightly too fast. Good interpretation of emotions but the execution of the song feels a bit amateurish. Overall, a good try bear in mind the casual setting of the performance.
完全不同的風格 也非常好聽
Eason的聲音很有劇情
聽了會觸動心弦
啊~就是喜欢eason这种不带太多技巧，不经过多修饰的原始感情滑过的唱法。。
thx for sharing ^^
但其實要滿滿的技巧,,,並且好純熟....先可以唱得咁自然....平時去唱k....只要首歌岩自己音域....就可以唱得幾好....但唱eason歌.....即使首歌音域岩自己....但就是唱不出味道....同eason差十九幾萬條街
第一次聽覺得學友唱得好聽d,但越聽就越覺得eason唱仲有feel,有感情.兩個人都各有各好..........
人家陳奕迅是一把吉他加上隨便一個戶外，
又不是錄音室，也沒有專業設備，
拿張學友的來比較，
不覺得有點苛刻了嗎?
張學友當然很棒!
我也超愛張學友!
兩個都是歌神!
實在沒必要和張學友比較
they sound realli different in terms of their emotion. the way Jacky sings is like a realli old people who looks back his own love story. eason's sounds the people who is around 30 to 40 age look back to his previous relationship.it gives me a feeling that he still cant forget and try to complain it
我個人覺得，Eason嘅唱功一定係非常深厚，但好似被推到唱得好快好急
令我想起國產007 =P
啊～～～～～～～啊的好動人！
正
eason唱出黎既感覺真係好唏噓,再加上其略帶沙啞既聲線........真係好吸引
褪 音： 1)tan3 褪色, 褪去, 褪下
2)teoi3 退, 駾, 螁 「褪tan3」的異讀字
仲話人地讀錯…仲要睇正字，睇左都係錯
所謂歌神 就是給人帶來一種新的感覺
兩個歌神 兩種新的感覺
為何要作比較?
區主播手結他好正!!
very good
喜欢学友的多一点点
好聽？！不只是歌好聽是你唱的也太好聽！！！！！
+1
唱「得」太好聽
錯字😅
@pics4david 星期五930pm有線一台會重播, 應該個個屋企都收到呢個台既 :)
没有整个节目吗？
坐係到喎b-)勁野
@josesekahou 勁..原來褪色喺咁讀..真喺唔知..
褪,行路打倒褪的褪音. 讀成"退"是錯的.
@ycbarton 完全同感
係好聽, 但我鍾意聽周星馳唱多D.
吳國敬黎😂
@MikeYuenn 個個係吳國敬
@MikeYuenn 首歌唔係周星馳唱,係.吳國敬代唱!
@Ki11eRps
同意
A bit pitchy at the beginning and the tempo is slightly too fast.
Good interpretation of emotions but the execution of the song
feels a bit amateurish. Overall, a good try bear in mind the
casual setting of the performance.
是在國產凌凌漆有被用到的
我鍾意梅艷芳唱，真係好好👍❤
好好聽，但我個人覺得，Eason嘅唱功一定係非常深厚，但感覺被推到唱得好快好急
沒有一個唱對褪字, 包括原唱張學友, 除了陳奕迅~~~~
學友是 eason的偶像 －．－ 比什麼．．．．．．．．．．
把聲加首老歌 令我諗起鄭敬基 =D
目前為止 華語歌手只有呂方唱這首歌能跟張學友一較高下
HAHA反而中意睇男主持彈結他
可能除左學友.唱得最好係Eason..
感覺我唱歌而唱
他讀對了褪(吞)色
而張學友卻讀錯了這個字
一定有看最緊要「正」字!!!!!
大佬人地hea唱到咁都要比
唱得好~但真係學友唱得有FEEL D...雖然我係EASON歌迷...但真係...唔係技巧感情...只係一來風格不同~二來聲低聲線都好影響感覺~唔識講...
像花生未紅?
根本就不同風格嘛怎能比較
兩個版本也有不同好處吧
E神係唱歌有技巧, 同埋佢好聰明, 因為佢根本冇法子唱到學友果種澎湃, 就唱個SOFT既
EASON既STYLE我覺得係冇STYLE, 佢唱咩都OK, 都好聽, 但係搵唔到單純只屬於佢既靈魂
而且佢冇餘韻. 單純係好聽卻空洞, 所以通常我係勁耐先聽一次. 因為聽左一次已經開始厭
坦白講, 佢唱SAD歌一個TUNE, 唱HIGH歌一個TUNE, 首首差唔多
好聽, 但好反感
至於學友真係我心中既唯一歌神
也只有學友可以同啊菲合對歌神天后!
觉得eason唱歌词易明d
陳奕迅的版本最忠於原版玉置浩二想表達的
佢d假音開始番黎啦! :)
唱的怪怪的，節奏有些太快
唱到好核突-.-
好似唏噓大叔唱 唔夠靚聲
我都好鍾意想eason d歌，但佢唱呢首歌真心難聽😂，去聽聽呂方唱呢首歌，係目前唱為止，我覺得唱得最好聽的歌手！
我個人覺得，Eason嘅唱功一定係非常深厚，但好似被推到唱得好快好急