The Nakba that everyone talk about is a tactic to manipulation the progressive left You will see. This is a self-inflicted outcome. During the Nakba, ARAB armies told the local Arabs to leave the areas where they planned to attack the Jews. The ARAB armies told them leave their homes, and everything behind, because the Arab Armies were planning an attack to destroy Israel. The ARAB armies then lost the war. The Arab countries told the displaced Arab people to settled in refugee camps. Some Arabs stayed and are not Israeli citizens and thriving. But the majority decided to exile themselves. Still 75 years later they never moved on and won’t accept the situation they caused for themselves and still dream of turning the lost into a victory. Meanwhile, many Arabs leaders of the displaced have made billions of dollars from global financial support and almost none of it made it to the people. Only since the 1968 has the displaced Arab started to call themselves, "Palestinians" - which is a name given by Europeans to the region, after they forcibly expelled the Jews, there's no P in Arabic, so why would they name themselves with a name, that doesn't exist in Arabic. justify more violence Ever since the Ottoman Empire the Arab just can't accept the Jews to be free people. Arabs are from the Arabian Peninsula - they speak Arabs. They pray to the Mecca in Saudi Arabia Muslim are not from Jerusalem. They are not from the land of Judea. Arabs are the colonizers and now need to accept co-existence. Islamic education needs to be reformed. Why does anyone think Hamas would stop its ambitions of destroying Israel? In a time of war, Muslim are encouraged to lie and to manipulate infidels. Anyone who is not muslim they do not accept as equal. But they will pretend to accept them until they acquire enough power to kill them. Do they not understand the Islamic “Taqiyya appears in Sura 3:28:" ? “Let not the believers take the unbelievers for friends; and whoever does this, shall have nothing to do with Allâh in any matter; unless you do this to protect yourselves from the unbelievers. Thus Allâh cautions you to have reverence only for him. To Allâh is destiny.” in other words, in a time of war its encouraged to lie; Regarding 3:28, Ibn Kathir writes, “… believers who in some areas or times fear for their safety from the disbelievers… are allowed to show friendship to the disbelievers outwardly, but never inwardly.” Ibn Kafthir quotes Muhammad‘s companion, Abu Ad-Darda’, who said “we smile in the face of some people although our hearts curse them"
@@yakky6052 Palestinian civilian dance and celebrated on the streets during 9/11, 7/07 attacks and Oct 7. There is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians. Their both two sides of the same coin.
Majority of the death of civilians occurred when they order airstrike on the route they were taking to leave where they rescue the hostages. Not the actual location they freed them apparently they broke down and hamas found them but they leveled the whole block they were at.
So all those civilians had to die. Just to get 4 people back. Those people were innocent and not responsible, for the actions of the others. Say you approve of ethnic cleansing, without saying you approve of ethnic cleansing. Colonization at its finest. You people need help.
@@kikibigbangfan3540 A country is supposed to get its citizens back. Hamas didn't have to kidnap anyone, nevermind keep the hostages in a heavily populated area. It's not ethnic cleansing to use the military during a war to rescue hostages. However, disrupting aid trucks, bringing a civilian population to the brink of starvation, killing aid workers, etc, are definitely war crimes. In this case, Israel has four freed hostages to show for it.
@@kikibigbangfan3540 Maybe they shouldn't have voted in Hamas after Israel pulled Jews out of Gaza in 2005 and say nothing as they hide weapons in their schools, homes and hospitals and cheer as they beat women in the back of pickup trucks.
The question to be raised is why did the terrorist group Hamas hold the hostages in a densely populated area? What are they hoping to achieve by inflating the number of civilian deaths? Why did they do the Oct 7th attack in the first place? They're not going to defeat Israel, everyone knows that. Are they hoping to raise money from pro-Hamas groups and countries? Is the Hamas leadership hoping to have nicer homes in Qatar, where some of them currently reside?
All of gaza is densely populated,, specially because Israel keeps razing buildings and it's full of refugees from precious wars already. Inform yourself
Have you considered the live there? Do you know of "where's daddy?" Targeting? Once you know about that you can't take the human shields talking point seriously
Why is American media critically questioning rescue attempts against a terrorist regime (Hamas)? War is ugly. War is unfair. Blame this on the terrorists.
When you take hostages, you take on the repercussions!!! Anyone living in that neighborhood should have assisted in the release and not supported Hamas. When you don't help, you are part of the problem and are an enemy!
OK so the isreali civilians killed on Oct 7 was justified? Because they didn't help end the isreali governments oppression of Palestinian people? Your logic is justifying the deaths of civilains on both sides
@@saadkashaf4820 L take. The civilians that were murdered on the border 10/7 were Palestinian SYMPATHIZERS. Why do you think they lived there? For fun? The booming economy? These civilians were already helping the Palestinians and in return they were raped and butchered. And then they took civilian hostages on top of it. There weren’t any Palestinian hostages being freed by these terrorists so you’re way off on your logic. If you’re going to make comments on this situation the least you could do is research the main issues.
@@Lethalmuffin87 LMAO, how do you know they were sympathizers? Do you really think that any group would kill those who are supporting them? Oh wait, never mind, its Hamas and they are known to use and kill their own people for their benefit. By the way, your logic is way off. The kids at the music event were from all over Israel so were the ones captured. So once again, your logic is off. Palastine is a terrorist state because they elected a terrorist leadership. They are reaping what the sow. They would be a thriving nation if Hamas did not take all the funding from its people. You need to do some real research and come back. You can not try to run with big dogs, young pup. Stay on the porch. Let me know when you want to talk about the history of Palestine and its short existence.
@@saadkashaf4820 No, that’s an obvious extreme that’s unnecessary for the full context of what I said. First off, I was talking about the Kibbutz. Second, those kids at the festival were sympathetic to Palestine and obviously felt like they weren’t enemies otherwise why would they stage their concert right there in the border instead of anywhere else in the country? The main point here is that Hamas went in with the intent of raping. Killing, and abducting civilians. Israel went in last weekend to get those people back, they weren’t going in with the same intent that Hamas had on 10/7. Do you have any proof otherwise?
no according to the idf the civilians that died were in the area they were being chased by Hamas. so they bomb the block with civilian's around that doesn't mean the civilians are holding the hostages. how did you came up with that.
@angelmendez2211 You do not update yourself on news. 4 Israeli hostages were rescued on Saturday. The male hostages were found in a home that belonged to an Al Jazeera journalist and his father who was a doctor. The female hostage was found in another civilian home. Hamas was paying them to keep the hostages. I no longer believe in the term " innocent civilians" in Gaza. How do these families keep hostages in a close-knit community like Gaza without others knowing about it. Also, some hostages were at Shifa hospital filled with Palestinians, doctors, and nurses. Others were found
It's pretty obvious. Hamas hid them among the women and children using them as human shields so now they can cry about all the civilians that died. It's the same old story over and over. Palestinians are animal savegery defined.
@@angelmendez2211 video is out there literally showing hostages in apartments of civilians. There is even a video of a tunnel that leads to a civilian child's room...how dense can a bot be?
@@ownzuall Way more than whatever you will ever amount to. Even though the IDF keeps bombing their universities. I like Edward Said, maybe read his work.
No mercy to those holding back hostages - This war would have stopped right a week after October 7th if the hostages would have handed back to Israel. Its hamas refusing to lay down the arms and release the hostages. In a romantic view, hamas could drop all hostages at the Egyptian crossing, say good bye to them and the war will end. It would be so romantic easy - but no, hamas prefers to keep them. Result is casualties among militants and civilians. Given the fact that hamas does disguise like civilians, even for US rangers or Navy seals in such a operation, those would be considered as a threat. If it would be 120 US civilians, the rangers would be in place to get them extracted and the death toll would be the same as in Afghanistan or Mogadischu. Reporters, UNRWA employees, and now TV journalists, all have been participating and celebrating October 7th. So, shut up and stop complaining about Israel. Imagine that Mexico shoots rockets at US, day by day, for decades, killing civilians - at some point you need a fierce response if displomacy did not work.
@@joshuamohler2356I have lived in an apartheid state. Israel is not an apartheid state. It has Arabs, Jews and other minorities and a huge proportion of Israelis are jews kicked out of North Africa and the Middle East. Gaza is an apartheid state. No Jew would be permitted to live there
Your telling me as a hostage you wouldn’t want to be in the safety of a journalists home? Are you crazy. I wouldn’t want to be among the civilians and get bombed.
Gaza is literally such a small area itself where over a million people take shelter , what do you mean by keeping the hostages in a densely populated area. Whole Gaza is a densely populated area
It is said that it was mixed in through aid vehicles, and it seems that it was from the temporary dock that cost 320 million US dollars before as the operation base
It's a war crime. You should probably read up on international law. Israel has been committing war crimes for decades though, so I get why you're confused
When hammas took israelis hostages. Muslim says they are heroes. But when israelis fight back. Muslim says genocide. The real problem is in islam teaching.
@@preacherforjesuschrist.3806Jesus is one of the prophets in Islam and he is not God's son. There is one true God which is Allah Subhanallah Wa Taala, obey only to Him and do good. Allah SWT does not have a son and He is no one's father. You read the Al-Quran, Surah Al Baqarah and the verses are there
Tell us about your negotiation attempts with your school bully, enlighten us your strategies, master. P.S On the first cease fire after 7/10 the side that broke cease fire was Hummus. After this Israel stopped negotiating with terrorists.
Why not rejoice over and focus more on hostages freed rather than always emphasizing on civilians death. Hamas started this war when they abducted the hostages and they are responsible for their own people being killed.
Because accountability applies to all. Tell me this, in your mind, what would be crossing a line? What would Israel have to do for you to say, that’s a step too far?
@@Aubz47You are making the assumption that I do not care about accountability. But it is clear to me (a democrat voter for over 20 years) that the media’s emphasis is more on the poor civilians in Gaza rather than condemnation of Hamas who started this tragic change if events.
@@SirRichard94 yes, and the innocent Israel citizens who were brutally killed and abducted from a peaceful music festival are also my brothers and citizens.
@@CC-tu9xb true. So maybe the IDF should stop killing them and accept a peace deal already, like the Israeli protesters have been saying and Hamas proposing since pretty much the first month. How many have the IDF bombed and shot at already?
If only there had been a way to protect the civilians like (1) not attacking Israel, (2) not hiding terrorists like cowards among civilians, (3) not taking hostages, and (4) refusing to release hostages.
Israel had already slaughtered 100,000 civilian Palestinians across the decades before Oct 7. And they have 10,000 hostages too. One day their bubble of impunity burst. Palestinians have equal rights to freedom as any Israeli, despite all the wicked propaganda against them.
There are no civilians in Gaza. If there were they would surrender to the IDF and live free. But they chose to murder,rape and then die for their sins. It's a tragedy of biblical proportion.
Where did you get this narrative? Why do they have to surrender upon a colonialist force? Why do they have to give up their lands? Israel gotta be held accountable for crimes against humanity.
How can you justify killing hundreds of civilians, women and children, to save four people? This is absolute insanity. Palestinians are treated as sub-human!
Religious beliefs caused a lot of pain and suffering in this world. why is it so difficult to come into peace and live together as brothers and sisters where all children can be safe and secure .
@@petma5551 Really!? God made a covenant with Israel (you do this and I'll do that) not an unconditional promise: If you are compassionate to the stranger then you are my people (because that's what my people do/are). I do not think Israel is showing compassion - to anybody - just bombing the bejaysus out of the people who had the cheek to settle for the odd 1700 years in the land they reckoned was theirs (and theirs only,) when they returned in 1948. Serve them right for being born a Palestinian - this should teach them... God's people indeed!
@@TonyCox1351 Thank you- seriously what is wrong with people. One had a mother dying of cancer and probably just made it thanks to the rescue to see her mother one more time.
@@javi3701 there was a ceasefire in effect , then hamas broke it . its not on Israel to except deals with terrorists who rape and murder innocent Israelis .
Right, using human shields, so they can cry about civilians yet again. Same old tactic, and everyone still falls for it. Hamas and their supporters are pure evil.
@@MrE073 - That’s it buddy, you keep deluding yourself by saying that and keep supporting terrorists. Meanwhile, the war would be over in 24h if the Hamas scum would release the hostages. The only reality is that it will never be over, even if Hamas is eliminated because Palestinians cause trouble wherever they go. Read up on Black September
Ms. Saudi Princess, two state solution is NO solution at all because it is a SIN SIN SIN against the LORD GOD of Israel even the LORD JESUS CHRIST himself my Saviour the God that created heaven and earth. You MUST read the BIBLE to know the TRUTH. The root cause of conflict in Israel is that SATAN wants to fight against the LORD GOD of Israel; that is the VERY ROOT CAUSE. Psalm 83:4-5, KJV. Verse 5, ..: they are confederate against THEE. Who is “THEE” here???? THEE is the LORD GOD of Israel. It means fighting against ISRAEL means fighting against the LORD GOD of Israel even the LORD JESUS CHRIST my Saviour.
If you take hostages and compound the issue by hiding them in civilian areas, what do you expect? If you dont want your women and children to get hurt, dont hide behind them and dont resort to terrorism to solve issues.
@@OldFroakydo you have any idea when the conflict between the British and the IRA took place? Long after WW2. The things that happened in WW2 including Dresden are literally why the rules we have today exist. Hur dur civilians were slaughtered back then so it's okay now derp.
“If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.” ~ Malcolm X #FreePalestine
@@galbalut9901Seeing as you're a medical expert perhaps you might look at pictures of hostages released from Israeli prisons. Would like to hear your thoughts on their physical and mental welfare ???
She managed to get her teeth whitened tho… 😂 muscle atrophy 😂😂😂 My perspective as a human being is different than some one who claims to provide health care yet can’t see that there’s nothing at all wrong with her. I thought there was mass rapes going on?🥱
Remember. All civilian death figures are reported by Hamas, a known terrorist organization. CNN and ABC already have retracted false death numbers already. We cannot trust any reported deaths from Hamas.
Also - you must believe the terrorist group hamas who provides the numbers. Even the UN had to walk back the numbers they put out because they realized they were given wrong info by hamas. What do you expect from terrorists.
Have you seen black hawk down? Up to 700 Somalians were killed to rescue the crew. When you have a rescue mission, things can get crazy fast. RPGs were fired from the buildings nearby. Don't make a civilian neighborhood into a hostage hideout and battlefield.
Sadly, Israeli lies, at the moment are embarrassingly frequent and repeated over and over again (without evidence) as if repetition will make them true
At such scale of war started by hanas and backed by Iran who backed by another two big ones, and hostages rescue in such complicated mind-blowing situations, it is unfair and unrealistic to avoid collateral damages. It is not the rescue operation caused so called civilians casualties, but the terrorist caused as the first cause. Put it in this way, a patient had a serious cancer, and a surgeon gave an operation in order to save him, but it ended up with no thanks giving but questioning, complaining and protesting to the surgeon cause the wound and blood loss. Sounds bizza, right? But isn't it exactly what ABC, Channel 9/7/10 and SBS have been doing ?
No matter what Israel does, they will be criticised. Utterly ridiculous, is it not? The Israelis should never have had to rescue Israeli hostages, who should NEVER have been captured and held hostage in the first place! Hamas is totally responsible here Blame hamas for any “ civilians” killed during this heroic IDF rescue. Period!!!!
The UN security council adopted a resolution (today) Monday calling on hamas (arabs in gaza) to accept the proposal for a hostage and ceasefire deal. Let's see if hamas rejects this proposal yet again. Finally, the UN is realizing all the lies hamas has told them.
@@josephineburke3995 Thankfully no other countries have supported that BS except for the three that took in nazis. The point is for the first time the UN is holding hamas responsible and they haven't until this point. I will always be happy that no country in the middle east supports the arabs in gaza except for other terrorist groups- speaks volumes.
"there was 360 degree fighting" why is there not a single video showing them surrounded and fighting for their life but there is so many videos of children being killed.
@@cba4389 the battle of Mogadishu was a full out firefight between US forces and Somalian armies to rescue 100 military personnel from Mogadishu. It lasted an entire night and was pure chaos. Less civilians died in the battle of Mogadishu than during this Israeli "rescue mission" and it was still considered a failure
@@wannenburgg they seem to be very happy sharing video of when they rescued the hostages, why do they never show any videos of the "360 degree fighting" that they use to justify the murder of 200+ people. 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Obviously you didn’t read what the female hostage Noa Argamani said about her captors. She said her captor was bragging to her that she was lucky she was held by a noble man such as himself. He was proud of the task given to him by Hamas. So, no they are not innocent civilians at all…
Rule one of not wanting ur ppl to die
1. Don’t take hostages
💯
2. Don't let your settler kids go to a rave.
@@theoriginalshakil8013 They are called ISRAELIS and they went to a rave within Israel's recognized international borders.
@@theoriginalshakil8013 3. Don't follow a guy who claimed to ride a flying donkey and is found next morning riding his first cousin.
@@theoriginalshakil8013rule no 4. Don't attack a far superior country if you are not ready to suffer heavy casualties
They were rescued from so called civilian homes,to be precise el jaziira journalist! Enough said
They were with Al Jazeera because they paid, al Jizya.
Fake news
This has long been disproven. IDF once again lying through their teeth.
@@TonyNone-yz7xk😂😂😂
Apparently he took part in an op-ed like one time for al-jazira id hardly call that a journalist
Why questions are not raised over KEEPING THEM HOSTAGE FOR NEARLY A YEAR?
shalit was held for 5 and the mastermind was released for him
Israel have kept Palestinian unlawfully for more then years some got released as adult where they were taken as young teens.
Which hostages? The Israeli or the Palestinian ones? Because the Palestinian ones have been hostages for decades.
@@donovan2723 they get arrested for offending in any way while the Israeli hostages were taken for being either Israeli or foreign citizens
Because pro-pals justify Hamas doing whatever they wish
These are not civilians, are these journalists for real? Civilians holding hostages 🤔
The Nakba that everyone talk about is a tactic to manipulation the progressive left
You will see. This is a self-inflicted outcome. During the Nakba, ARAB armies told the local Arabs to leave the areas where they planned to attack the Jews. The ARAB armies told them leave their homes, and everything behind, because the Arab Armies were planning an attack to destroy Israel.
The ARAB armies then lost the war. The Arab countries told the displaced Arab people to settled in refugee camps. Some Arabs stayed and are not Israeli citizens and thriving. But the majority decided to exile themselves. Still 75 years later they never moved on and won’t accept the situation they caused for themselves and still dream of turning the lost into a victory.
Meanwhile, many Arabs leaders of the displaced have made billions of dollars from global financial support and almost none of it made it to the people.
Only since the 1968 has the displaced Arab started to call themselves, "Palestinians" - which is a name given by Europeans to the region, after they forcibly expelled the Jews,
there's no P in Arabic, so why would they name themselves with a name, that doesn't exist in Arabic.
justify more violence
Ever since the Ottoman Empire the Arab just can't accept the Jews to be free people.
Arabs are from the Arabian Peninsula - they speak Arabs. They pray to the Mecca in Saudi Arabia
Muslim are not from Jerusalem. They are not from the land of Judea. Arabs are the colonizers and now need to accept co-existence.
Islamic education needs to be reformed.
Why does anyone think Hamas would stop its ambitions of destroying Israel?
In a time of war, Muslim are encouraged to lie and to manipulate infidels. Anyone who is not muslim they do not accept as equal. But they will pretend to accept them until they acquire enough power to kill them. Do they not understand the Islamic “Taqiyya appears in Sura 3:28:" ?
“Let not the believers take the unbelievers for friends; and whoever does this, shall have nothing to do with Allâh in any matter; unless you do this to protect yourselves from the unbelievers. Thus Allâh cautions you to have reverence only for him. To Allâh is destiny.”
in other words, in a time of war its encouraged to lie;
Regarding 3:28, Ibn Kathir writes, “… believers who in some areas or times fear for their safety from the disbelievers… are allowed to show friendship to the disbelievers outwardly, but never inwardly.” Ibn Kafthir quotes Muhammad‘s companion, Abu Ad-Darda’, who said “we smile in the face of some people although our hearts curse them"
Sometimes civilians don’t have a chance to say no
@@yakky6052 Palestinian civilian dance and celebrated on the streets during 9/11, 7/07 attacks and Oct 7. There is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians. Their both two sides of the same coin.
Majority of the death of civilians occurred when they order airstrike on the route they were taking to leave where they rescue the hostages. Not the actual location they freed them apparently they broke down and hamas found them but they leveled the whole block they were at.
They were mainly just shoppers and vendors on a market in the vicinity. You do not need hundreds of people to hold hostages.
Just not forget WHO kidnapped them and WHO held them hostage within civilians!
So all those civilians had to die. Just to get 4 people back. Those people were innocent and not responsible, for the actions of the others. Say you approve of ethnic cleansing, without saying you approve of ethnic cleansing. Colonization at its finest. You people need help.
@@kikibigbangfan3540 A country is supposed to get its citizens back. Hamas didn't have to kidnap anyone, nevermind keep the hostages in a heavily populated area. It's not ethnic cleansing to use the military during a war to rescue hostages. However, disrupting aid trucks, bringing a civilian population to the brink of starvation, killing aid workers, etc, are definitely war crimes. In this case, Israel has four freed hostages to show for it.
You have lost your Humanity.
There are no civilians in gaza.
@@kikibigbangfan3540 Maybe they shouldn't have voted in Hamas after Israel pulled Jews out of Gaza in 2005 and say nothing as they hide weapons in their schools, homes and hospitals and cheer as they beat women in the back of pickup trucks.
Maybe they shouldn’t support Hamas
Maybe you shouldn't pay taxes in support of oppression
@@nasimobeid2945 I don’t want to pay taxes in general. Blame Joe
@@nasimobeid2945 but honestly what did u think was going to happen when u take people.
Maybe those Kidnapped should not support Israel, who daily steals Palestinian land and humiliate them frequently, treat them like non-humans.
@@nasimobeid2945 We don't. We pay taxes to support freedom. Israel is freedom. The Arab world is oppression.
The question to be raised is why did the terrorist group Hamas hold the hostages in a densely populated area? What are they hoping to achieve by inflating the number of civilian deaths? Why did they do the Oct 7th attack in the first place? They're not going to defeat Israel, everyone knows that. Are they hoping to raise money from pro-Hamas groups and countries? Is the Hamas leadership hoping to have nicer homes in Qatar, where some of them currently reside?
All of gaza is densely populated,, specially because Israel keeps razing buildings and it's full of refugees from precious wars already. Inform yourself
You are stating the facts some don't want to hear.
Have you considered the live there? Do you know of "where's daddy?" Targeting? Once you know about that you can't take the human shields talking point seriously
*GAZA:* *_One of the most density populated places ON MOTHER EARTH!_*
@@SirRichard94 You can't take hamas seriously- they don't care about anyone but themselves.
Al Jazeera reporter holding a hostage in his apartment, what a bad day for ABC, NBC, BBC, CNN, MSNBC, Al Jazeera😭
except it's a literal fabricated lie, and yes you are a total m0r0n for believing it.
He wrote 1 article. Doesn't make him a reporter.
These "civilians" are far from innocent and have their hands as dirty as the other terrorists!
Your an idiot
Why do these hostages look so much healthier than the ones being held by the Israelis?
@@FlameHAZE2010 u see what u want to see , its that simple
@user-mg2ip8cr8z You'd know about that wouldn't you?
@@FlameHAZE2010 Your moms face also looks much healthier after I cum on her face and applied it like a cream.
Why is American media critically questioning rescue attempts against a terrorist regime (Hamas)? War is ugly. War is unfair. Blame this on the terrorists.
When you said terrorist immediately comes to my mind the IDF Infanticide Demoniacs Forces. Nothing else
Because they know the Occupation-terrorist-apartheid State (Israel), if you don't know make research.
@@oswaldo66 How's the weather in Rafah, Mohammed?
@@TheCure1. How's the weather in Rafah, Abdullah?
There are no more journalists in the US anymore. Only propagandists and parasites pushing far left wing ideology.
Yeah like why were hostages found in journalists homes?
Debunk that that was a lie😂... Cum'on man🥴
@Gadzonkahow does that change the fact they’re hostages? Involuntarily there, least you can do is take care of them. Are you ignorant?
@@jeremyagosto-santana5280
He isn’t ignorant, he is a supporter of evil.
Fake news, they will say anything to fit their narrative
@Gadzonka oh look, CNN is now reporting how the hostages report being beaten daily and the doctor examining them have confirmed their claims.
How about you interview the families of the Palestinian victims?
When you take hostages, you take on the repercussions!!! Anyone living in that neighborhood should have assisted in the release and not supported Hamas. When you don't help, you are part of the problem and are an enemy!
OK so the isreali civilians killed on Oct 7 was justified? Because they didn't help end the isreali governments oppression of Palestinian people? Your logic is justifying the deaths of civilains on both sides
@@saadkashaf4820 L take. The civilians that were murdered on the border 10/7 were Palestinian SYMPATHIZERS. Why do you think they lived there? For fun? The booming economy?
These civilians were already helping the Palestinians and in return they were raped and butchered. And then they took civilian hostages on top of it. There weren’t any Palestinian hostages being freed by these terrorists so you’re way off on your logic.
If you’re going to make comments on this situation the least you could do is research the main issues.
@@Lethalmuffin87 LMAO, how do you know they were sympathizers? Do you really think that any group would kill those who are supporting them? Oh wait, never mind, its Hamas and they are known to use and kill their own people for their benefit. By the way, your logic is way off. The kids at the music event were from all over Israel so were the ones captured. So once again, your logic is off. Palastine is a terrorist state because they elected a terrorist leadership. They are reaping what the sow. They would be a thriving nation if Hamas did not take all the funding from its people. You need to do some real research and come back. You can not try to run with big dogs, young pup. Stay on the porch. Let me know when you want to talk about the history of Palestine and its short existence.
@@Lethalmuffin87 yeah the people at the music festival were dancing in support of the Palestinians?
@@saadkashaf4820 No, that’s an obvious extreme that’s unnecessary for the full context of what I said. First off, I was talking about the Kibbutz.
Second, those kids at the festival were sympathetic to Palestine and obviously felt like they weren’t enemies otherwise why would they stage their concert right there in the border instead of anywhere else in the country?
The main point here is that Hamas went in with the intent of raping. Killing, and abducting civilians. Israel went in last weekend to get those people back, they weren’t going in with the same intent that Hamas had on 10/7.
Do you have any proof otherwise?
Civilians were holding the hostages!
no according to the idf the civilians that died were in the area they were being chased by Hamas. so they bomb the block with civilian's around that doesn't mean the civilians are holding the hostages. how did you came up with that.
@angelmendez2211 You do not update yourself on news. 4 Israeli hostages were rescued on Saturday. The male hostages were found in a home that belonged to an Al Jazeera journalist and his father who was a doctor. The female hostage was found in another civilian home. Hamas was paying them to keep the hostages. I no longer believe in the term " innocent civilians" in Gaza. How do these families keep hostages in a close-knit community like Gaza without others knowing about it. Also, some hostages were at Shifa hospital filled with Palestinians, doctors, and nurses. Others were found
It's pretty obvious. Hamas hid them among the women and children using them as human shields so now they can cry about all the civilians that died. It's the same old story over and over. Palestinians are animal savegery defined.
yeah kids and babies who died were holding them(!)
@@angelmendez2211 video is out there literally showing hostages in apartments of civilians. There is even a video of a tunnel that leads to a civilian child's room...how dense can a bot be?
War is tragic
Shame on Hamas not Israel
Shame on your mama for birthing an idiot.
How many palestinians died before October 7th?
Shame on Israel and the US, who keep on helping with the land theft and killing of Palestinians
@@SirRichard94 How many Palestinians contributed to this world and how many Israelis? Science, medicine, etc.
@@ownzuall Way more than whatever you will ever amount to. Even though the IDF keeps bombing their universities. I like Edward Said, maybe read his work.
ABC, you have lost respectability with me. This guy George is a laughing stock liberal. Shame on you.
Why does the media entertain Hamas propaganda? It's so goofy.
why was there no comment about the fact that an aljezeera journalist was the one holding some of them ???
Because the media is leftist.
@@Lukejb2Butterworth Correction. Qatar's Official Government media outlet, Al Jazeera.
Because the mainstream media are evil.
You should know owns the media if not OIL 💸
No mercy to those holding back hostages - This war would have stopped right a week after October 7th if the hostages would have handed back to Israel. Its hamas refusing to lay down the arms and release the hostages. In a romantic view, hamas could drop all hostages at the Egyptian crossing, say good bye to them and the war will end. It would be so romantic easy - but no, hamas prefers to keep them. Result is casualties among militants and civilians. Given the fact that hamas does disguise like civilians, even for US rangers or Navy seals in such a operation, those would be considered as a threat. If it would be 120 US civilians, the rangers would be in place to get them extracted and the death toll would be the same as in Afghanistan or Mogadischu. Reporters, UNRWA employees, and now TV journalists, all have been participating and celebrating October 7th. So, shut up and stop complaining about Israel. Imagine that Mexico shoots rockets at US, day by day, for decades, killing civilians - at some point you need a fierce response if displomacy did not work.
Cope + typed out like a bot
It definitely would not have stopped. Because Palestinians would still be treated as sub humans living in an apartheid military state.
Your view on the Palestinian issue is utterly distorted!
@@joshuamohler2356I have lived in an apartheid state. Israel is not an apartheid state. It has Arabs, Jews and other minorities and a huge proportion of Israelis are jews kicked out of North Africa and the Middle East. Gaza is an apartheid state. No Jew would be permitted to live there
@@joshuamohler2356 It might not have stopped because hamas doesn't want a cease fire because they want Israel.
And why no comment about the aljazeera journalist who was holding some of the hostages ???
And Al Jazeera has the guts to complain that there channel was banned in Israel.
He was a independent journalist, and his father was a doctor so.
@@ovictor1472 who was holding people hostage in his house , not a good person
@@ovictor1472 lovely family
Your telling me as a hostage you wouldn’t want to be in the safety of a journalists home? Are you crazy. I wouldn’t want to be among the civilians and get bombed.
Gaza is literally such a small area itself where over a million people take shelter , what do you mean by keeping the hostages in a densely populated area. Whole Gaza is a densely populated area
Disguised as civilians? Are you serious
Exactly- they are gaza arabs that participated in this.
Did the two tanks escorting the vans not give you a hint?😂😂
It is said that it was mixed in through aid vehicles, and it seems that it was from the temporary dock that cost 320 million US dollars before as the operation base
It's a war crime. You should probably read up on international law. Israel has been committing war crimes for decades though, so I get why you're confused
@@sherylgreenberg3540 For your knowledge, Palestinians are not Arabs, but surely part of Umm@. 🤮
When hammas took israelis hostages. Muslim says they are heroes.
But when israelis fight back. Muslim says genocide.
The real problem is in islam teaching.
God has a Son. Jesus is His name. Praise Jesus, Father, Holy Spirit. Repent Muslims. Submit to the one and only God
Islam is a religion of hatred. What can you expect
When thieves come from Europe, they call themselves 'settlers'. unforgetable quote of an American settler, "If I don't steal, someone else will"
@@preacherforjesuschrist.3806Jesus is one of the prophets in Islam and he is not God's son. There is one true God which is Allah Subhanallah Wa Taala, obey only to Him and do good. Allah SWT does not have a son and He is no one's father. You read the Al-Quran, Surah Al Baqarah and the verses are there
Why those "Innocent Palestians" had the hostages ?
Why do Israeli Bots always have latin names?
@@nigelsmith3719 at least I put my name… While cowards hide behind fake names
The were paid by Hamas to hold the hostages in their homes.
Hamas has money while the unemployment rate is 47% and 80% of Gaza lives in poverty. 🙄
Because they aren't innocents
Why is it the most idiotic remarks always come from people with latin names? I suspect you're an Israeli BOT. No?
Great news of the rescue . Divine Protection for Israel 🇮🇱 & its people.
LONG LIVE ISRAEL
This could have been successfully accomplished through negotiation instead of bloodshed. The images are truly horrible.
Tell us about your negotiation attempts with your school bully, enlighten us your strategies, master. P.S On the first cease fire after 7/10 the side that broke cease fire was Hummus. After this Israel stopped negotiating with terrorists.
This could not have happened if hamas didn't kidnap those Isrealis. Sad
You don’t negotiate with the devil
Ah yes, let’s just assume the reports from the Hamas controlled Gaza health ministry are entirely factual. No chance of bias there at all huh?
No no no, I got a better idea let’s all just believe what the IDF says, as if they haven’t been lying since day 1. What a sick joke.
How dare you question Islamic narrative? You Islamophobic Kafir!! ..... don't call us Kafirphobic though.
The numbers from the Gaza Health Ministry have been independently verified and were even confirmed by the Pentagon.
Why not rejoice over and focus more on hostages freed rather than always emphasizing on civilians death. Hamas started this war when they abducted the hostages and they are responsible for their own people being killed.
Because accountability applies to all. Tell me this, in your mind, what would be crossing a line? What would Israel have to do for you to say, that’s a step too far?
Imagine 250 persons. Probably more than your whole school generation gone. They are human just like your brothers and sisters.
@@Aubz47You are making the assumption that I do not care about accountability. But it is clear to me (a democrat voter for over 20 years) that the media’s emphasis is more on the poor civilians in Gaza rather than condemnation of Hamas who started this tragic change if events.
@@SirRichard94 yes, and the innocent Israel citizens who were brutally killed and abducted from a peaceful music festival are also my brothers and citizens.
@@CC-tu9xb true. So maybe the IDF should stop killing them and accept a peace deal already, like the Israeli protesters have been saying and Hamas proposing since pretty much the first month. How many have the IDF bombed and shot at already?
If it’s not apartheid and not an occupation what is it?
If only there had been a way to protect the civilians like (1) not attacking Israel, (2) not hiding terrorists like cowards among civilians, (3) not taking hostages, and (4) refusing to release hostages.
Israel had already slaughtered 100,000 civilian Palestinians across the decades before Oct 7. And they have 10,000 hostages too. One day their bubble of impunity burst. Palestinians have equal rights to freedom as any Israeli, despite all the wicked propaganda against them.
play stupid games win stupid prizes..
Next time maybe don't hide hostages in your bedroom.
There are no civilians in Gaza. If there were they would surrender to the IDF and live free. But they chose to murder,rape and then die for their sins. It's a tragedy of biblical proportion.
Congratulations, your idiotic commentary goes so well with your name. Go smoke some more.
Where did you get this narrative? Why do they have to surrender upon a colonialist force? Why do they have to give up their lands? Israel gotta be held accountable for crimes against humanity.
I will assume that English is your second language because those statements made absolutely no sense.
So toddlers are not civilians?? Do you mean the Israeli reported MASS RAPE and 40 beheaded babies lie?
@@jkmatt1 As the name indicates, he probably is smoking crack, lot's of it. Or he's a member of the Israeli Internet Goon Squad.
Who exactly is Civilian here?? 🧐
See the images in front of your eyes.
100% of Hamas terrorists are palestinese civilians. So when they say “civilian deaths” well you know what information they are omitting
@@SirRichard94 we see terrorists
It is encrypted word for Terrorist.
None of them look ill treated and obviously well fed.
You are not a smart person
So that justified being held hostage against their will for eight months by a terrorist organization?
So it’s okay as long as they feed them?
Really you got that by just Looks?? In the Video she was Crying
How can you justify killing hundreds of civilians, women and children, to save four people? This is absolute insanity. Palestinians are treated as sub-human!
Religious beliefs caused a lot of pain and suffering in this world. why is it so difficult to come into peace and live together as brothers and sisters where all children can be safe and secure .
Rule number 1:
Don't start wars if you won't accept the consequences.
Don't occupy Palestinian territory for over 50 years if you won't accept violent revolt
@@rachelbarlow9382 Gaza not occupied since 2005
@rachelbarlow9382 the whole land belong to Israel, the whole land, from the sea to Euprhates.
they were already dying since 1948..
@@petma5551 Really!? God made a covenant with Israel (you do this and I'll do that) not an unconditional promise: If you are compassionate to the stranger then you are my people (because that's what my people do/are). I do not think Israel is showing compassion - to anybody - just bombing the bejaysus out of the people who had the cheek to settle for the odd 1700 years in the land they reckoned was theirs (and theirs only,) when they returned in 1948. Serve them right for being born a Palestinian - this should teach them... God's people indeed!
Immense trauma when they physicality as fat as they were before being hostage and smiling and laughing.... so traumatized... so true😂😅😂
Look at how healthy and well nurised they are,can you say the same for the Palestinians? CAN YOU?
How about asking why Al Jazeera was holding three of the hostages
There is no evidence of that. Even cnn refused to support on that. They nonstop lie
No this lie from IDF
Don't get me wrong, but these hostages look especially well cared for. Glad they are out of the situation.
I would say that kidnapping someone against their will is by definition not caring for them well
@@TonyCox1351 Thank you- seriously what is wrong with people. One had a mother dying of cancer and probably just made it thanks to the rescue to see her mother one more time.
@@sherylgreenberg3540 she would have been released quicker if Israel accepted the ceasefire deal.
@@javi3701 Where do you get your info from hamas- they rejected 5 offers-not Israel.
@@javi3701 there was a ceasefire in effect , then hamas broke it . its not on Israel to except deals with terrorists who rape and murder innocent Israelis .
Free Palestine ( from world map 🌎)
"Hostages in trauma" *Proceeds to show the hostages happy and smiling*
Wow how traumatic hostages.
Crazy how the amount of people stayed in areas of effect after being warned, they started the war .
You don’t get to choose how the hostages will be rescued. They were brutally abducted from a music festival.
You call that brutality look up how Palestinian are being treated.
Blame hamas. Collateral damages.
Blame incompetent IDF solders.
Blame Hamas. Why starting it at the first place.
The hostages weren’t being held by Hamas, but by Palestinian civilians. Could your reporter be any more biased
Right, using human shields, so they can cry about civilians yet again. Same old tactic, and everyone still falls for it. Hamas and their supporters are pure evil.
That’s convenient for Israel, it justifies all the civilian deaths they have caused.
You must think we were born yesterday.
False
@@MrE073 - That’s it buddy, you keep deluding yourself by saying that and keep supporting terrorists. Meanwhile, the war would be over in 24h if the Hamas scum would release the hostages. The only reality is that it will never be over, even if Hamas is eliminated because Palestinians cause trouble wherever they go. Read up on Black September
And The civilans weren't killed as casualties, but were purposely targeted and murdered by the IDF. Could you be any more blind😊
You can never understand under Western civilisation, military and civilians are one in hamas!
Ms. Saudi Princess, two state solution is NO solution at all because it is a SIN SIN SIN against the LORD GOD of Israel even the LORD JESUS CHRIST himself my Saviour the God that created heaven and earth.
You MUST read the BIBLE to know the TRUTH. The root cause of conflict in Israel is that SATAN wants to fight against the LORD GOD of Israel; that is the VERY ROOT CAUSE.
Psalm 83:4-5, KJV.
Verse 5, ..: they are confederate against THEE.
Who is “THEE” here????
THEE is the LORD GOD of Israel.
It means fighting against ISRAEL means fighting against the LORD GOD of Israel even the LORD JESUS CHRIST my Saviour.
If you take hostages and compound the issue by hiding them in civilian areas, what do you expect? If you dont want your women and children to get hurt, dont hide behind them and dont resort to terrorism to solve issues.
The British did not kill large numbers of innocents when going after the Irish Republican Army.
@@xijinbling2373they did during WWII Ever heard of Dresden?😂
Now people understands.dobt go to Rafah
@@OldFroakydo you have any idea when the conflict between the British and the IRA took place? Long after WW2. The things that happened in WW2 including Dresden are literally why the rules we have today exist. Hur dur civilians were slaughtered back then so it's okay now derp.
Spoken like a total child.
One hostage apparently held in the home of an Al Jazeera journalist
Pride parade in Gaza this year
“If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.” ~ Malcolm X #FreePalestine
JEWS ARE THE VICTIMS HERE.2,000 YEARS PLUS 80 OF REPEATED BIGOTTED VIOLENT ATTACKS BY HER ANTISEMETIC NEIGHBORS.CAN THE LIES!
At least we know how many palestinians every Israeli is worth. 60 people.
She looks very healthy for a just released hostage as do the other 3. But apparently this issue isn’t “news”. Give me a break.
@@galbalut9901Seeing as you're a medical expert perhaps you might look at pictures of hostages released from Israeli prisons.
Would like to hear your thoughts on their physical and mental welfare ???
If the hostages are in great shape, their captors must be in greater shape. So you are you whining about hunger in Gaza?
She managed to get her teeth whitened tho… 😂 muscle atrophy 😂😂😂
My perspective as a human being is different than some one who claims to provide health care yet can’t see that there’s nothing at all wrong with her.
I thought there was mass rapes going on?🥱
How many idf, hostages and civilians got killed during the rescue?
Over 250 at least for this operation. Yet they're celebrating about it. Kind of f*cked up...
And some 700 injured…
@@nasimobeid2945 You believe the info provided by hamas- wow
Remember. All civilian death figures are reported by Hamas, a known terrorist organization. CNN and ABC already have retracted false death numbers already. We cannot trust any reported deaths from Hamas.
Is that a military successful operation? In other times that was called a disaster
God says he blesses the people that bless Israel, and he who dishonors them he will curse. Genesis 12:3 Pretty simple.
How did they rescued 4 hostages but kill3d over 270 lives and flattened buildings ?😔
Can you show me Evidence of 270
Absolutely insane that our tax dollars are funding this genocide.
Also - you must believe the terrorist group hamas who provides the numbers. Even the UN had to walk back the numbers they put out because they realized they were given wrong info by hamas. What do you expect from terrorists.
@@sunnymitra6372 It's in the video. If you don't like the source, give us YOUR
evidence.
@@sunnymitra6372oh yeah you eVÌĽĚ.
Looking like someone just came back from vacation
If Hamas cared about Palestinian people they would free the hostages!! How can the world expect Israel to forget their citizens?!
One thing for sure is the world will not forget the atrocities committed by Israel.
The world will not forget the atrocities committed by Israel.
@@xijinbling2373 You mean the atrocities committed by Hamas.
2:16: " they were sitting at home (letting an Israeli hostage clean their dirt!)"
Oh yeah that’s really believable.
The word is colateral damage.
Pallywood!
270 killed to save 4??
What rubbish are you talking. Noone said wars should have equal number of deaths. This is just an excuse to save Hamas
They will breed 10x than that in no time. Don't worry. Fastest breeding religion 🤣
Have you seen black hawk down? Up to 700 Somalians were killed to rescue the crew. When you have a rescue mission, things can get crazy fast. RPGs were fired from the buildings nearby. Don't make a civilian neighborhood into a hostage hideout and battlefield.
That's exactly what the media wants you to believe.
So glad they are free. Heartbroken for the other hostages and the innocent people and children who have died in this war.
They are all Hamas
The Civilians were all having riffles
Killing hundreds to save 4... Life is tough!
His Father passed with out knowing his fate 😢💔..
Palastenians reep the seeds they sowed !!!!!!!! 🤷🤔🇮🇱🇺🇸✊😉
Neither Israelis nor Palestinians will live in peace without a two-state solution
You can say what you want to say against Netanyahu but definitely hes making concrete results...
Netanyahu is a cowardly liar - yes concrete results to keep himself in power anf therefore out of jail (for corruption) - despicable man.
If the Jews gave up all their lands except Tel Aviv. Would the Hamas accept peace or attack Tel Aviv?
Fk tel aviv
Why do Palestinian lies and exaggerations get to take precedence over Israel's narrative?
Your talking about Israelis
Sadly, Israeli lies, at the moment are embarrassingly frequent and repeated over and over again (without evidence) as if repetition will make them true
Israelis have had a lot of practice! - statements without evidence swallowed whole by the West
What about the 6500 Palestinians who were kept hostages before October 7th even if I don't mention about the killings and imprisonment done after??
1000 had to get hurt to saved these 2. Good luck on these survivors living from guilt
1:30 _”fighting for days in a refugee camp”_ ??😭
They disguise as humanitarian aid workers
So the Al Jazeera journalist is civilian. 🤮🤮🤮🤮
How does one "mismanages" the war? Is this according to hamas?
How is this bollock of questions allowed
Innocent civilians don’t keep hostages captive in their homes
💪🇺🇸🇮🇱👑
*🙏✡️✝️☪️🙏*
*_Abrahamic Religions_*
There is only *ONE KING.* *_Get your act together._*
The good God comes to save all humans and not to capture and cause misery to all humans. Evil humans must learn to be like the good God.
You forgot the part where they hid in humanitarian aid trucks. Guess we wont hear about it from you until next week once you found a good spin on it.
You're talking about the Israelis right? Yeah they dumped all the aid before going into Gaza.
@@nasimobeid2945 you must be hamas
@@nasimobeid2945 yes. They are always out doing themselves.
They were in umarked vans bud. And didn't the two tanks escorting them not give you any hints? 😂
@@TheRandompaint "they committed war crimes and killed a bunch of civilians and fight like cowards 😂"
DIY: How to prevent army strikes on your home and ppl?
Don't take hostages
At such scale of war started by hanas and backed by Iran who backed by another two big ones, and hostages rescue in such complicated mind-blowing situations, it is unfair and unrealistic to avoid collateral damages. It is not the rescue operation caused so called civilians casualties, but the terrorist caused as the first cause.
Put it in this way, a patient had a serious cancer, and a surgeon gave an operation in order to save him, but it ended up with no thanks giving but questioning, complaining and protesting to the surgeon cause the wound and blood loss.
Sounds bizza, right? But isn't it exactly what ABC, Channel 9/7/10 and SBS have been doing ?
No matter what Israel does, they will be criticised. Utterly ridiculous, is it not? The Israelis should never have had to rescue Israeli hostages, who should NEVER have been captured and held hostage in the first place! Hamas is totally responsible here Blame hamas for any “ civilians” killed during this heroic IDF rescue. Period!!!!
Why are the Palestinians being called Hamas, is that a new name for their country? It doesn't make sense. Are the Hamas Palestinian or now just Hamas?
They are called Arabs. There is no such place called Palestine
They are involved in the 7th October. They know everything. Every person looks very healthy
Even the dead look healthy, don't you think, Israeli Bot?
ABC should be so ashamed
Here is the cease fire deal , Israel wil govern Gaza , deal or no deal bye
Netanyahu is better than Jesus
@@azharghulamhussein6930Jesus was not a war criminal
@@the_orthodox_historian You mean Netanyahu is?
@@azharghulamhussein6930 yes
Questions raised by fascists and their allies in the west
Notice how you don't hear the released hostage talking? This channel is propaganda
There is no civilian in Gaza
Why they kept hostages that only causes civilians prob. Both has to maintain Peace
The UN security council adopted a resolution (today) Monday calling on hamas (arabs in gaza) to accept the proposal for a hostage and ceasefire deal. Let's see if hamas rejects this proposal yet again. Finally, the UN is realizing all the lies hamas has told them.
The UN have also sanctioned the IOF for crimes against humanity in Gaza
@@josephineburke3995 Thankfully no other countries have supported that BS except for the three that took in nazis. The point is for the first time the UN is holding hamas responsible and they haven't until this point. I will always be happy that no country in the middle east supports the arabs in gaza except for other terrorist groups- speaks volumes.
They all look healthy and fine?? Am I wrong?
Then their captors must be even healthier? So why you complain of hunger in Gaza?
You can't see mental trauma and rape by appearances.
they didn’t commit any sin but they are guarding the hostages thos dead are hamas
"there was 360 degree fighting" why is there not a single video showing them surrounded and fighting for their life but there is so many videos of children being killed.
Is this sarcasm or is it suppose to be a serious question? Hamas is 100% responsible for all deaths since October 7.
@@cba4389Didn't know Hamas murdered 36,000 + civilians ???
@@cba4389 the battle of Mogadishu was a full out firefight between US forces and Somalian armies to rescue 100 military personnel from Mogadishu. It lasted an entire night and was pure chaos. Less civilians died in the battle of Mogadishu than during this Israeli "rescue mission" and it was still considered a failure
Why should Israel alert anyone to their operations? Why should they videotape this for you during a continuing operation. 🤔
@@wannenburgg they seem to be very happy sharing video of when they rescued the hostages, why do they never show any videos of the "360 degree fighting" that they use to justify the murder of 200+ people. 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
All eyes on REASI (india)😢😢😢😢
Obviously you didn’t read what the female hostage Noa Argamani said about her captors.
She said her captor was bragging to her that she was lucky she was held by a noble man such as himself.
He was proud of the task given to him by Hamas.
So, no they are not innocent civilians at all…