Agr Shia Tareekh or inka Muqadma theek hota Tu ye tu possible nhi ho sakta k itne ziada log Hazrat Abu Bakar, Umar, Usman, Muawiya, Hazrat Ayesha sb k sb Ek Insaan ko piche rakhna chahty hon. Aisa kiya dekh liya tha unho ne Jo ye sb k sb Ali R.A k khilaf baith k sazishe krte rahe? Aisa b tu ho sakta Hai k Hazrat Ali shru se he khalifa banna chahty hon qun k wo samjhty hon k Nabi S.A.W k cousin brother hone k naaty ye asal main unka he haq hai Or sochty hon k ye unke sath ziadti hai Phir dosro k khilaaf ye sb conspiracy banai hon?
ہم احمدی اس تاریخ کو درست نہیں سمجھتے اس لئے اس ان شخصیات پر جج بھی نہیں بنتے صرف اس حد تک جہاں تک قرآن نے بیت رضوان کا ذکر کر کے ان شخصیات کی بزرگی کی گواہی دی ہے اور نبی کریم ص کی بیویوں کو مومنوں کی مائیں کہا ہے۔ اگر کسی سے غلط فہمی کی وجہ سے لغزش ہوئی ہے تو اللہ مغفرت فرمائے۔ اس سے آگے ہم نہیں جاتے کیونکہ قرآن نے واضح ان حضرات کی بزرگی پر مہر ثبت کر دی ہے۔ شکریہ
Bhai kya yeh log Jin ka Aap zikr krrhe ho Aap ko lgta hy ki hmari koi nisbat in wahshi drindo se ho skti he humne kin kngro ko apna aaqa bnaya hua he In drindo ke piche hunne apne bachcho ki jao ko dao par bnaya hua he Gor kre aap bde masum ha
عباس صاحب آپ اپنے چینل پر ختم نبوت اور مرزا صاحب کی نبوت کے دلائل قرآن سے۔ ان دو موضوعات کو ہوسٹ کر سکتے ہئں؟ ان صاحب سے؟ ghost.azrael1 آپ کا مشکور ہوں گا۔ آپ قیصر راجہ اور حارث کی ڈہبیٹ ہوسٹ کر چکے ہیں۔
Finally Abbas came out as a Shia Muslim from Arab lineage. This is the realty of Pakistan we are not a nation but we are divided between multiple faiths and our lives are always divided take example of our housing societies and names we live separately in multiple areas with our own Masjid. Shias don’t marry with Sunnis Sunnis don’t marry with Shias Bohras don’t marry outside Ismailis don’t marry outside Parsis don’t marry outside Christians don’t marry outside as well. Calling Pakistanis as a nation is false in itself we were never a Nation.
'The obvious results of not listening, though it is possible he may be born in a Shia family, we don't know, but nowhere in the video he claimed that he is Shia, all he said was that he is explaining the point of view of Shias'
@@ChefbyMistake "I know many Sunnis by the names apparently of Shias, like Haider, Ghulam Hussain, Ali Rizvi. The 'Shia names' is a total misconception which the Sunnis assign, unfortunately we Sunnis attribute anything we don't like to Shias, although that phenomena might be an Islamic one from the beginning, its just out bias which puts it our as Shia'
@@umayr2935 This is very common Infact there is a Joke in Lebanon it’s either Ali or Muhammad. Ali for Shias and Muhammad for Sunnis so it’s a global thing . Show me a single Ayesha in Shias and a Single Aun or Joan or Nargis in Sunnis ? Well we need to accept our diversity. Ghulam Hussein is a Sufi name not a Shia Nama. Ali Rizvi is a Sunni name because Ali is common and Razavi means different in Sunnis. Show me Baqir Ali Rizvi within any Sunni.
@@ChefbyMistake 'I think you were discussing Abbas Haider as a 'Shia name' and that was my point, how is the name 'Abbas' or 'Haider' not relevant to Sunnis'
عباس بھائی کہیں تو سچ اور جھوٹ ہے ۔ ہم جھوٹ کو Justify نہیں کر سکتے ۔ ہٹلر کی فوج کو ہٹلر کی محبت کا نام دے کر Justify نہیں کر سکتے ۔ آپ نے اہل تشیع بھائیوں کا مقدمہ پیش کیا اب حق تو یہ ہے کہ آپ اہل سنت کا بھی اس موضوع پہ مقدمہ پیش کریں ۔ سب کی سلامتی چاہتے ہیں نفرتوں سے دور بس محبت ہو ۔
@@AliHassan-wc6nbمیرے بھائی میں ان احادیث کو مانتا ہوں ۔ امام مہدی علیہ السلام کی پیروی کرنے کو بھی مانتا ہوں۔ میں مولا علیہ السلام کی شان کو بھی مانتا ہوں ۔ ان کے حق ہونے پر ہونے کو بھی مانتا ہوں۔ لیکن میں یہاں اصحاب کی بات کر رہا ہوں کہ کیس اتنا سادہ نہیں ہے اسے لوگ کسی بھی شکل میں نمایاں کر دیتے ہیں ۔ میرا یہ خیال ہے کہ یہاں اصحاب کا کیس صحیح سے پیش نہیں کیا گیا ۔ دونوں رخ بیان ہونے چاہئیں ۔ جیسے یہاں اہل تشیع کا موقف ہے اسی طرح اہل سنت کا موقف بھی ہوگا ناں میرے بھائی ۔ وہ بھی پیش ہونا چاہیے ۔ بس موقف سامنے رکھ دیں جس کا جو دل چاہے اپنائے مگر ایک طرف کی داستان سنانا انصاف نہیں ۔ باقی سب کی خیر ہو میرے بھائی ۔ سلامتی ہو ۔ اللّٰہ میری اور سب کی اصلاح کرے آمین یارب العالمین
This is not more than a Shia propaganda video. When you describe only one side story you may please your Shia viewers but you can’t touch unbiased viewers.
What unbiased viewers. This is true history. Top sunni scholars have admitted that the second caliph threated Bibi Fatima R.A. Mufti hamdard a Sunni scholar made a video on this.
@@MustafaAli-lb8dq mufti hamdard not a suni he is just another intention seeker like qadri , molana tariq jameel, taqi usmani, saad rizvi show me one video of suni scholar.
Tum harami khudko musalman kahte hoo lanat ho tum par or un logu par jinki tum najaiyiz aulad ko lanat ho tumare ulama para or lanat ho muavia par qki tum sab uski aayashi ka sabab ho jo woh sharab pe ka kara karta tha.
علاج 72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی اسلام = امن و سلامتی فلاحی ریاست اللھم' لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد❤🇵🇰💯🇵🇸
Only one question: Abu Bakar, Fathima, Hazarat Ali, Usman , Aayesha, Rasool and all the characters as mentioned by you, what is link of these characters with Punjab, Sindh, KPK, Balochistan .......Kyu Arabs ke character ko explain karte ho😢❤
@@HistorywithShahrukh my dear brother......it is not about like and dislike. It's about belongings.....it's about identity......it's about who we are, what we are.............? Rest is dependent on your wisdom.,.....
علاج 72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی اسلام = امن و سلامتی فلاحی ریاست اللھم' لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد🇵🇸💯🇵🇰❤
علاج 72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی اسلام = امن و سلامتی فلاحی ریاست اللھم' لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد🇵🇸💯🇵🇰❤
@@vip26970 this incident is narrated in shia books written by Arab authors unlike Persian bukhari and Muslim . of course sunni doesn't accept these narrations as authentic. But what about the bukhari and Muslim where it is narrated that on of the caliphs of sunnis went to the door of Fatima and threatened Fatima ? At least you should accept those narrations
@@rogersimpson2329wo Jews Hai Jo Muslims seh BHI zyadah extremist Hai inki Torah allow karti Hai genocides KO, yeh unka religion Hai jis seh wo age Nahi barh rahee religion ke name per 2 mulk hi bne Hai Israel aur Pakistan aur dono ka Hal dekh ke dukh hota BS
My question is where does it say in Quran that the prophet family deserved khilafat? Why did Ali think Muhammad wanted him to take over? Why did the prophet not say it openly? Why Quran is quiet?
یہ تو نبی ص بتا گئے ہیں میں تمہارے درمیان دو گرانقدر چیزیں چھوڑے جا رہا ہوں قرآن اور میری عترت و اہلیبیت ان دونوں سے جڑے رہنا کسی ایک کو بھی چھوڑ دیا تو گمراہ ہو جاو گے حدیث ثقلین اگر اسلام واقعی سچا مذہب ہے اور اللہ اور اس کے رسول ص حق ہیں تو پھر یہ بھی تو وہی بتائیں گے کہ نبی ص کے بعد آپ ص کا حقیقی جانشین کون ہو گا امت کو تو یہ حق ہی نہیں کہ وہ خود فیصلہ کریں جب موسی علیہ السلام چالیس دن کے لئے طور پر گئے تو ہارون علیہ السلام کو اپنا نائب بنا کر گئے تو نبی ص ہمیشہ کے لئے جا رہے ہیں اور اس کے بعد کوئی نبی بھی نہیں آنا تو ایسے ہی چلے گئے امت کے بیچ جھگڑا چھوڑ کر ؟ یا کسی کو نائب بنا کر گئے ؟ اے علی آپ کا میرے بعد وہی مقام ہے جو موسی کے بعد ہارون کا تھا مگر میرے بعد کوئی نبی نہیں نبی ص تو بتا گئے پر امت نے وہی گمراہی اختیار کی جو قوم موسی علیہ السلام نے کی یعنی سامری کے بچھڑوں کی پوجا
غدیر نہیں پڑھا تم نے٫ اسلام کی پہلی دعوت ٫ دعوت ذالعشیرہ کو نہیں پڑھا تم نے اس لیے بول رہے ہو کہ رسول نے واضع نہیں بتایا۔ تم لوگوں کا مسئلہ ہی یہی ہے کہ جو تمہارے مولویوں نے جھوٹ طوطے کی طرح رٹا دیا ہے۔ اسی کو لیکر چلتے ہو ساری زندگی اپنی کوشش نہیں کرنی۔ قران درسی کتاب نہیں ہے ھدایت کی کتاب ہے اس میں اصول بتاۓ گۓ ہیں کہ مسلمانوں کے خلیفہ میں کونسی خصوصیات ہونی چاہیے۔ مثال کے طور پر عالم ہونا شجاع ہونا متقی ہونا٫ یہ قران کے اصول ہیں ٫ قران کی ان خصوصيات پر کون پورا اترتا ہے وہ رسول اللہ بتائیں گے۔ اور رسول نے اسلام کی پہلی دعوت سے لیکر اسلام کی آخری دعوت تک مولا علی کو اپنا جاننشین بنایا ہے۔
You have done a good job of understanding the usual Shia view and accepted it without doing good critical assessment of your and opposing view. Ali gave Bayah (accepting religious leadership) to Abu Bakr. Ali married Abu Bakr's widow. Ali gave Bayah to Omer, Usman. Ali gave his daughter to Omer in marriage. All this is reported in Shia books which you didn't bother to read. Hussain gave Bayah to Muawiya. Hassan Gave Bayah to Muawiya. Ali, Hussan gave names to omar, usman and abu bakr to their kids. Whan Ali, Hassan and Hussain accepted them, who are you and your shia. Also, whatever you mentioned cannot be proved through any historical or religious books. Hope you open your eyes and expand your critical faculties..... I will definitely be witness in front of Allah that you were made aware of these things....
عباس آپ نے آخر میں نفرت کا ذکر کیا لیکن کیا شیعہ فکر بھی بحیثیت مجموعی نفرت ہی پر مبنی نہیں؟ یعنی اگر آپ صدیوں پرانے واقعات اور اس دوران سرزد ہونے والی سیاسی غلطیوں کو اگر سیٹل نہیں ہونے دینگے اور آج کی تاریخ میں بھی ہر روز اعلان برأت کرینگے بالخصوص ان ہستیوں کے حوالے سے جنکے لیے مسلمانوں کی اکثریت اپنے اندر نرم گوشہ رکھتی ہے تو یہ نفرت مزید نفرت ہی کو جنم نہیں دے گی؟
اس کے باوجود شیعہ مسلمان کہتے ہیں اور احمدیہ مسلم جماعت غیر مسلم ہے جب دنیا بھر میں احمدیہ مسلم جماعت حضور پاک صلی علیہ وآلہ وسلم کو آخری اور شرعی سچا نبی مانتے ہیں دل کی گہرائیوں ❤ سے اور اسلامی تعلیمات پر دل ❤ کی گہرائیوں سے عمل کرتے ہیں الحمدللہ اور حضور پاک صلی علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے خلفاء راشدین اور سب صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کی دل ❤️ کی گہرائیوں سے عزت احترام کرتے ہیں الحمدللہ
صرف تاریخ کی کتب سے نبی ﷺ کی قریب ترین ساتھیوں جنہوں نے نبیﷺ کے لیے ہر ظلم کا سامنا کیا ان پر اس طرح کے الزام جن کے کوئی متواتر شواہد بھی نا ہو کہا کا انصاف ہے؟؟جب مولا علی علیہ السلام نے خود بالآخر خلاف راشدین کو تسلیم کر لیا تو آج کے مسلمان کیوں تحقیقات کرنے کی مشقت میں مبتلا ہیں؟کیا وہ نبیﷺ کی اشرہ مبشرہ والی حدیث کو بھی نہیں مانتے مولا علی اور حسن رضہ کے فیصلے کے آگے کی سوچ رکھتے ہیں؟؟ آج ہمیں سوشل میڈیا کے دور میں کوئی سالم خبر نہیں میسر اور آپ ہزاروں سال پرانی ان تاریخ کی کتب پر جن کا نا کوئی مقدمہ موجود ہے نا کوئی روایت کا سلسلہ موجود تو ان کی پختگی کے کتنے فیصد چانس بنتے ہیں؟ ؟
یہ دوہرا مقدمہ تو ہرگز نہیں تاریخ وہ بھ تو ہے جو باقی مسلم دنیا نے پڑ ہھی ہے آپ نے ایک طرف کا حال سنایا ہم اہل ِبیت کی محبیت کو اپنے ایمان کا حصہ مانتے ہیں لیکن جن اعلیٰ ہستیوں پے آپ تبرہ کی بات کرتے ہیں اپنی بے مثال قربانیوں کے باعث اللہ پاک کے ہاں ان کا بڑامقام ہے رضی اللہ عنہم علیہم اجمہین
Her jang say bagna wala aur bohat si sazish ma shamil logo ko raziallah banta han un logo na din ka hulya khrab kar dia un ki izat ki gai to ya wo hi kar sakta ha jo din ko sahi nahi janta.
Allah ne iblees ko mohlat de di tu kya us ki b attayat kr ln dajjal ko b dunya ki hukumat Allah ki taraf se mila gi usey b tasleem kr lena kyun k tumhara logic yahi ha hazrat ali ne khalifa ni mana ummat ko us k haal pr chor diya
Shayad yehi saari baaten,qisse,kahaniyan,jinka kuchh pata nahi kya sach hai kya jhoot,insaan ko mazhab se door karne ya atheist banne par majboor karti hain…!?
@@waliullah2391 the holy prophet was in taqiyyah till the age of 40 b4 announcing prophethood... So taqiyah is sunnah of the holy Prophet.... Ameen.....🤣
@@agnostica_x how could you know prophet perform taqiya in age of 40....? You guyz don't even believe in seerah of prophet s.a.w because sahaba describe the seerah of prophet 😂
@@waliullah2391 What was that if that wasn't taqiyah? The holy prophet announced prophethood at the age of 40.... We take Seerah of the prophet from his household, the Ahlulbayt...... Who knows a person better than his household....... Be a man of principle......
So what does it prove? Either the followers were unfaithful/thankless or the leader himself failed to convince his followers with his own messages. Also it indicates Islam does not bring peace from day one.
Abbas with respect, I just want to say that these are disputed facts. You are putting your case from Shia's perspective against Hazrat Abu Baker (RA) and Hazrat Umar (RA), along with Hazrat Ayesha (RA). They are also relatives of Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH). Prophet Muhammad PBUH himself said, if there were a prophet after me, it would be Umar (RA). Moreover, prophet PBUH himself asked ALLAH for Hazrat Umar (RA) acceptance of islam. Likewise, Hazrat Abu Baker (RA) was the friend and first one to accept Islam. Moreover, he is also the father in law of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH. He has given Hazrat Ayesha (RA) to the prophet Muhammad PBUH same as Hazrat Umar (RA) has given Hazrat Hafsa RA to the prophet PBUH. Nothing is cleared in history. Every sahaba (RA) has sacrificed themselves for the prophet PBUH and for Islam. In the same way, Hazrat Usman (RA) is the son in law of the prophet Muhammad PBUH whom the prophet married off his two daughters Hazrat Ruqaiya RA and Hazrat umm e kulsum RA. Moreover, Hazrat Usman RA was the one for whom the prophet Muhammad PBUH has conducted Baith e rizwan. Especially, top ten sahabas i.e. Ashraf e Mubashara have been given high place by the prophet Muhammad PBUH himself. Therefore, categorising one over the other causes dispute. We are no one to judge sahabas with our myopic view and mindset along with distorted facts and history. It is better to pay respect to all sahabas and leave the rest upon Allah (SWT).
i Recommend to All Of You A Book تصفیہ مابین سنی و شیعہ Hazrat Peer Meher Ali Shah Shb RA Is Kitab My Unho Ny Shia Hazrat Ki In Tmam Ilzamat Ka Jawab Daleel Or Quran O Hadees ki Roshni M Diya Hai...... so Tmam Log Lazmi Us Kitab Ko Khud Prhy❤
It is a good start, whether we agree or not. At least it is important to speak about the points of view of others and understand different perspectives of history.
Tell it to Allah and correct the Allah 1st i guess in ur point of u Allah were dumb he didnt allow hazrat usman in mubahila and ayat tatheer and also questioned nabi saw and tell him u gave ur 2 daughtersvto hazrat usman why are u promoting favouritism and prefer Ali and Fatima to all
Prophet did not know how to read and write when Gabriel came in the beginning. How did he then call for something to write on towards the end of his life!? Did he attend evening classes!?😊
extremly exagerated and one sided slanted opinion of this man. he is himself ahlitashi and promote and defend his school of thought and extremly hated vedio against sahaba karam and ahlisunnat wal jamat. we respect ahlibait and all sahaba karam and this is our faith. anyway we expect such disgusting vedio from you. i wanna just say who cheated imam hussain in kufa so kindly listen allama jawad maqvi vedios.
Interview Mr. Javed Ahmad Ghamidi or listen to his talks on the history. See the other side of the picture as well. It's incumbent upon you to put forward the point of view of the other side , dear. Let people decide.
Bhai, the muqaddamah u r presenting is 'all the ppl u hold in reverence were assholes', and then u conclude by saying 'please don't hate'. Humans don't work like that bro.
جب کہ ہم مسلمانوں کی تاریخی کتب نہ ہونے کے برابر ایسی صورت میں یہ کیسے ممکن ہے اج تک ہم لوگوں کیا اپ کی اولاد پر اتفاق نہیں ہے اپ کی تاریخ پیدائش پر اتفاق نہیں ہے ہم کیسے ان روایات پر یقین کریں الحمدللہ قران پاک اور اپ کی سنت جس پر عمل کرکے ہمیں صرف مسلمان کہلوانا چاہیے شکریہ
Let’s say Ali was selected next - only God and people can select the one after not Ali - Even Ali’s father was not Muslim - the idea he married prophets daughter made him family / okay after Ali who is next? If he was selected then God would have helped him - it’s nothing to do with religion it’s to do with power
پہلی بات یہ کہ تاریخ صرف شیعہ کی نہیں اہلسنت کی بھی ہے۔ دوسرا یہ کہ تاریخ کو عقیدہ نہیں بنایا جاتا۔ اگر شیخین یا دیگر صحابہ نے اہلبیت سے ظلم کیا یا کوئی بھی اور غلط کام کیا توقرآن کے مطابق وہ اللہ سے اجر پائیں گے۔ہم سے ان کے بارے میں نہیں پوچھا جائے گا۔ شیعہ مذہب کی بنیاد امامت پر ہے چونکہ وہ اسے قرآن سے ثابت نہیں کرسکتے اس لئے ایسی تاریخ میں لوگوں کو الجھا کر مظلوم بن کر خود کو سچا ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں جس میں وہ سنیوں کی بیوقوفیوں کے باعث خاصے کامیاب رہے ہیں۔
@@ghost.azrael1 میں بفضلہ تعالی حضرت مسیح موعود ع کی نبوت کو قرآن مجید سے بخوبی ثابت کرسکتا ہوں اور ایک عرصے سے علماء کو اس بات کا چیلنج دے رہا ہوں لیکن کوئی بھی ہمت نہیں کرتا۔ آپ ہمت کریں تو میں حاضر ہوں
Why did Allah let all these atrocities happen? he could have made sure that ALi became the first Caliph. No need for centuries worth oof drama, no need for any Mehdi to come back and avenge the injustices. Its all made up anyway.
How can we even obtain an unbiased source, those who wrote history in those times were biased themselves? That's why we have these two versions of history.
Can't understand why people in comment section are so upset. Abbas Haider only presented the views of Ahl-e-Tasheeh. He did not claim that he himself believes them all. He just wanted to let you know the reasons why Shias hate certain personalities in Islam. The truth is that History is ambiguous and ALLAH only took responsibility of Quran, not the history. Historical records can be manipulated by people in any way they like. It has always been the case and will remain as such till eternity. Both Shia and Sunni have different historical records and multiple disagreements. That's just it. A wise person who simply wants to follow Islam will just focus on the present and do as the Quran tells him. That'd be enough to please ALLAH.
Hazrat ali ne apni beti umme kulsum ko hazrat umar ke nikah mein kyu diye fir aur hazrat abubaker umar aur hazrat usman ko humare Nabi AS ne jannat ki basharat kyu di thi
Justification for political gain ,is not a religious way of thinking.Islam is a way of life chosen by Allah for believers to follow, not a way to get political power to rule the masses.As we all are aware, how history is told to serve the wasted interests.We should follow Islam as it is,rather then indulging in the distorted facts of events of centuries,of which truth is known by Allah,only.
Your govt agencies have reported that in your Madrasas child abuse is rampant and mullahs are involved in the abusive acts , you should discuss such issues also.
علاج 72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی اسلام = امن و سلامتی فلاحی ریاست اللھم' لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد❤🇵🇸🇵🇰💯
Islam has two parts- Religious & Political The religious side is copied from Persian, Jewish, Christian, Aramaic, Hebrew, Greek texts including Torah & Gospels The political side is very violent during the Islamic Arabic Prophet’s time itself with war, raids, k!££!NG etc This violence continued even after the Arabic Prophet’s death. We see how the family members including his daughter, grandchildren, son-in-law were treated and had violent d€@ths. Then the 3 out of first 4 Sahabas had violent d€@ths These violence continue even today when we see terrorism , most of these are Islamic. Compare this with Jesus, his disciples spread across the world (without any army/sword) after his death & resurrection to spread and preach the teachings of Gospels. Near and dear ones including family on earth of Jesus had peaceful life … Jesus’ family and disciples didn’t scheme, conspire and hatred against each other unlike the Sahabas & others.
You are describing such a sensitive subject so carelessly, so this is not good journalism, you should have done it with references in more episodes. This is bad journalism that can create more rift and hate
I want to address some allegations very briefly The word Maula was used for Hazrat Zaid too, is he also a caliph?. The Prohphet PBUH said 'OH Zayd, you are our brother and Maula. Maula word was also used for Quresh and Ansar and some other people. (Muslim) The main dispute between shia and sunni is not caliphate, its the concept of Imamat. According to numerous Shia sources (including Haqqul Yaqeen, Imams are superior to Propheths. And Al-kafi goes on to saying that every imam has all the knowledge and miracles of ALL the past prophets a.s and the imam is directly guided by Allah, like Prophets a.s (Then there is no point in arguing if non-prophet people are superior to Hazrat Ali or other Imams.) Firstly you provided the wrong translation of the word (Yahjur, it means "to leave", pointing to the the Prophet's (PBUH) leaving the world, and then he went on saying "istafemuhu, meaning ask him... YOu don't ask a person if he is delusional or not). Ali was the scribe of the Prophet (PBUH) it was Ali's duty to hand over the pen and paper. No report says Hazrat Umar stopped Ali from doing that. Ali had four more days to hand over the pen and paper (Qirtas) Fadak was treated as a public trust by Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman and Even Ali and it was not handed over to Ahlul Bayt during the Caliphate of Ali and Imam Hasan. (Sheikh Asif Mohsini a famous shia writer said that Fadak's income was given to Ahlul Bayt by All four caliphs. (Ali followed the Sunnah of the previous caliphs on Fadak). If people poisoned the Prophet (PBUH) then wasn't it Hazrat ALi's duty to punish the people when he became the Caliph and return Fadak? It is a duty of caliph to protect people's lives and property and Ali somehow failed to do it.
Please don't exaggerate the situation. There are always some ppl in less numbers and others in large. What's the situation in Iran, only 9% are Sunni and others. Sunni ppl are more tolerant as they listen to tabra and move on. Never seen any Sunni, so blatantly disrespecting any Ahl e Bait. There could be but they won't dare if they were in Iran. Here inter sectarian harmony is exploited in Moharram. Isn't that a point to ponder and be pragmatic
Allah ne kuch logo ko zameen pe Bheja lekin Bheje mein bheja Nahi bheja isliye kuch Anpad log Samjha ne ke baad bhi nahi samjhte Are Bewakoof jaao Aur Apni khud ki likhi hui kitab padhlo mat suno kisi aur ki baat Apna khud ka bheja istemal toh kar sakte hona Ahlebet Zindabad Haq pe hai Maula Ali
@AbbasHaidar Jung e Jamal ke baad hui thi Jung e Siffin. Aapne isko Ulta bata diya hai. Aapne apni Taraf se kafi koshish kari cheezon ko rakhne ki bahut si jagahon per ghaliban aapke sources ki kami rah gai hain ya time ki Wallahu Alam. Per Koshish achi hai aapki.
Abbas Haidar Bhai, Baagh-e-Fadak ko lekar, Hazrat Abbas(RA) aur Hazrat Ali(RA) ke darmyaan shadeed ikhtelaaf aur jhhagdaa kyuñ thhaa...?? Aur, Jab ikhtelaaf had se zyaada badhhaa to ye donoñ Hazraat, Hazrat Umar(RA) ke paas kyuñ gaye thhe...???????
ان کی تاریخ کو بتانے کا انداز جیسے آپ سچ سمجھ کر بیان کر رہے ہیں ۔آپ نے یقین پہلے کر لیا اور بیان کر دہے ہیں ۔ آپ کے پاس دوسری طرف کی آرا نہیں۔ بد دیانتی یا متعصب رویہ۔
Ap ki presentation bohat decent ha, ap ne is video ma sirf shia aqaed batae hain jo already hum jante hain, lekin in aqaed or waqiat k references & authenticity nahi batai
Agr Shia Tareekh or inka Muqadma theek hota Tu ye tu possible nhi ho sakta k itne ziada log Hazrat Abu Bakar, Umar, Usman, Muawiya, Hazrat Ayesha sb k sb Ek Insaan ko piche rakhna chahty hon. Aisa kiya dekh liya tha unho ne Jo ye sb k sb Ali R.A k khilaf baith k sazishe krte rahe? Aisa b tu ho sakta Hai k Hazrat Ali shru se he khalifa banna chahty hon qun k wo samjhty hon k Nabi S.A.W k cousin brother hone k naaty ye asal main unka he haq hai Or sochty hon k ye unke sath ziadti hai Phir dosro k khilaaf ye sb conspiracy banai hon?
@@AliHassan-wc6nbKoi tu baat hogi Ye sb k sb tu batil parsat nhi ho sakty Tareekh main inka b bara muqaam hai bohat c conspiracy hain isme Allah Tallah bhtr janta hai wohi inka faisla kry ga Hum log nhi kr sakty.
Very important to reply to your biased knowledge briefly 1-you told about ghadeer khum that prophet saw appointed Syedona Ali rz as first caliph the valid question is that y Ali rz didn't fight against abu bakr and umar and usman for hos caliphate as he fought three battles against his legitimate caliphate against moavia rz, 2-you said abu bakr rz didn't give fidak to syeda Fatima rz , the question that y Ali rz didn't give fadak to his family if that was not justice in era of abu bakr, Umar and usman, how it was justified in caliphate of Ali rz. 3-you said umer rz burned the door of syeda Fatima rz and insulted Ali rz, the question is that was Ali rz so coward that he saw all that and then he stood up with these three caliphs who are murderers of his wife for 25 years respectfully . I think it will take so long so enough for now. Will elaborate your other false and fabricated propaganda any other time...
Jhote rafzi jhoot(taqqiya) inke iman ka 1 rukan hain Ahle Bait(r.a) aur Sahaba(r.a) ke aapas mein mohabbatein thin. 1.Hazrat Ali(r.a) ki beti Umme Kulsum jo ke Hazrat Fatima(r.a) se thin unka rishta Hazrat Umar(r.a) se huwa. 2.Hazrat Ali(r.a) ke beton ke name Abu Bakr o Usman thay jo ke Karbala mein shaheed huwe Hazrat Usman Hazrat Abbas ke bhai thay aur barri bahaduri se lar ker shaheed huwe unka name nahein liya jaata nahein toh dhanda band hojayega. 3.Hazrat Ameer Muavia(r.a) Hazrat Ali Akbar ki maa Ke Sagge mamu thay Umme Laila Abu Sufyan nawasi thin. 4.Hazrat Fatima(r.a) ka janaza Hazrat Abu Bakr(r.a) ne parhaya. 5.Hazrat Zain Ul Abidin, Hazrat Jafar Sadiq hamesha rahe madeene mein aur unke name se kutab kufe se chapti rahin. 4.Agar Hazrat Umar(r.a) ne Hazrat Bibi Fatima(r.a) per darwaza giraya toh kiya Sher Khuda(r.a) ko nahein pta ke jisne Fatima ko takleef di guya Nabi Pak ko takleef di mumkin nahein ke Sher E Khuda khomosh rehte aaj agar aap ker ghar per koi hamla kare aap khomosh rahenge?? 5.11 Imamo ke bachon ke name Abu Bakr, Usman, Aysha Aur bahot Sahaba per milte hain agar aapko unse piyar hai toh aap unki pairwi kiyun nahein karte??. 6.shimr malon aur ibn muljim malon dono shia thay. 7.Hazrat Fatima(r.a) ka ek baal dikh raha tha sooraj nahein nikla tha maazAllah yeh unki betiyon per tohmat lagate hain ke beparda bazaron mein ghumaya gaya unhein mumkin hai ke Ali ke betiyan beparda hoon?? Aur dunya qaim rahe?? Dalail bahot milenge aapko aur bhi haqeeqat mein sabse barre dushman Ahle Bait ke rawafiz hain koi 1 kam bata dein jo Hazrat Ali(r.a) ne kiya ho aur yeh karte hoon? Hazrat Ali ne bachon ke name Abu Bkr aur digar Sahaba per rakhe yeh nahein rakhte Hazrat Ali(r.a) ki darhi Mubarak thi yeh jahan darhi wala dekhein aag bagola hojayenge Hazrat Ali sache thay yeh jhoot(taqqiya) to apne iman ka rukan samajte hain. Yeh sab dalail jo diye hain ooper sab aapko inki kitabon mein mil jayega.
persian (Koofi) zamana jahlyait m b pervaiz ko bht oncha maqam dete thay jhoti kahanyain us ki azmat m, phr jb islam un py aya aur hazrat ali r.a ka wahan maqam howa tb b un ki yahi adat rahi jhoti kahanyian bana bana, agr ap tarikh ki book parho to pehli books m sirf hazrat fatima hazrat abubakar sy kafa tha, phr next book m hazrat umar ka b zikr aa giya ab hazrat abubakr r.a k sath fadak wali story thi to hazrat umar k sath ikhtalfat ki waja banai inhon ny wo door wale waqie ki warning ko inhon ny books m execute b kr diya tb tk mohsin ya bacha ni tha phr wo thora masla add krne k liye bacha mar b diya phr us ki waja sy moat b likh di next books m ab ye bhai shb ny lohe ki silakh b dal di us m, ye waqt k sath sath shia alem ny in k demagho m ghater bhar diya ha jo ab koi shia hi nikal sakta ha masla ye ha k shia lrkon ki perwarish aisi hoti ha k wo intellectual soch ni pate, jis din unhen ye relize ho giya k mohsiin (fake baby) marne py agr hazrat ali r.a bad m khuch ni kia to wo dunia k darpok insan tha q k muslman ki kamzor tareen alamat ye k apni zaban sy b na awaz utha sake , us din shia m sy koi uth k ye sb in ko samjhaye ga aur qoam ko akhata kre ga tb na to hazrat ali ko shan chupai jaye gi na hazrat umar ko yazidi sunat k tehat galyain di jayen gi
10:30-10:45 Abbas Haidar Bhai, Aapko kis tarah ye pataa lagaa ki Faatima(RA) ke batan ka bachchaa (jo abhi paidaa bhi naa huaa thhaa) ladka thhaa, ya ladki thhee,,, aur uss bachche ka naam MOHSIN thhaa..??? How can you ensure that the foetus was that of a MALE-CHILD. ??? And that, His name was MOHSIN..????
Comparison of what the Shia say about the high level sahaba to what is said about Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani is inappropriate and based in ignorance. You just offended a bunch of sunni Muslims, but I am assuming that is what you were looking to achieve. I didn't really understand the point of the video. Are you Shia, Qadiani?
حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہہ کی غیرت،ہمت ، شجاعت اور ایمان پر اس سے بڑی تہمت نہی ہوسکتی۔ جو شیعہ حضرات اور موصوف آپ لگاتے ہیں ۔ بڑی عجیب توجیہہ پیش کرتے ہیں کہ چھ مہینے بعد انھوں نے نہ صرف بیعت کی بلکہ شیخین کے مشیر اور قاضی بن گئے
What a stupid vlog there are more than 7 crore shia innpakistan minority ni ha shia ahle sunat or minorities mila kr 65% hn jab k shia alone 35% of population hn
I like your VIDEOS befire. But here while presenting history you are mistakended... 01 abu bkr was appointed as Khalifa, after six months Ali just asked that hadn't we had right in khilafa, so abu bakr cried a the moment and Ali a.s said i have got my answer we are satisfied with you that you accepted your guilt. Mola Ali a.s married with wife of abu barkr. 02. Umar was appointed in order to save ummah from anarchy, and while he was on his death bed he appointed Six members committee to choose amongst them. Mola Ali was Chief justice during khilafat of Umar ra. And Umar ra married with daughter of Mola Ali as. During that time Fatima R.a was not injured by door, because at that time there were no doors as it was tribal system still in most villages there are no door or gates just a heavy cloth is hanging... Umar ra could nerve think of Hurting daughter of prophet Muhammad SAW.. 03. Mola Ali as defended Usman r.a during riots of outsider along with Hassan and Hussain a.s... Overall when Mola Ali never abused any of them how could they do it. Mola Ali supported Each khalifa for greater cause of Ummah, so why can't you do...
Shiaism is a religion and they have no case. Ali was power hungry so were his sons, and please tell people you were present when prophet asked for writing material. How mean was Ali who asked his wife to go and make claim for Fidak.
SAbse pehile aysha ne rasool allha ko zeher diya 2. Abubakar or umer ne hzt ali kee khilaft cheen lee 3 .umer ne.janabe Fatema zehra or hzt Mohsin ka katl kiya 4.mavia or aysha ne hzt ali ko sauun se nhi rehne Diya 5. Mavia ne hzt hasan ko zeher dilwya 5. Yazeed ne hzt imam Hussain ko sheed karya... ( Ab in behan k tano kee kaise tareef kare)😊
Well Needed CLIP. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Secularism & Mangolism. May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!! My Salute for all the ULAMA Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل !!!!
Bhai ap na sirf Shia tareekh sekhi hai or woi beyan ki hai, or jis tarha apna bughaz k sth sahaba Ka nam use Kia ap KO sharam ani chahea , is trha ap shia KO khud hi badnam kr rhy ho , is sa bhtr hai ap apna nazariya apna pas hi Rakho ,
Let bygone be bygone and we need to open our hearts and minds to all denominations of faiths. If our own faith is strong then we shouldn't be afraid of what other believe or practice. There are those who don't say it but by through their actions, God forbid, they are committing shirk when they lay judgment as if they are God. Let God decide the matters of faith.
Abbas you are nice young man and great thoughts. But never show leaning on one side irrespective of authentication of tales. Neither Shia nor Sunni who hate each other never been truthful. They are not capable to undetstand phelosphy of Islam , selflessness and priorities.
Is Pakistan not for Ahmadis:
ua-cam.com/video/T075Bt83cW0/v-deo.html
Agr Shia Tareekh or inka Muqadma theek hota Tu ye tu possible nhi ho sakta k itne ziada log Hazrat Abu Bakar, Umar, Usman, Muawiya, Hazrat Ayesha sb k sb Ek Insaan ko piche rakhna chahty hon. Aisa kiya dekh liya tha unho ne Jo ye sb k sb Ali R.A k khilaf baith k sazishe krte rahe? Aisa b tu ho sakta Hai k Hazrat Ali shru se he khalifa banna chahty hon qun k wo samjhty hon k Nabi S.A.W k cousin brother hone k naaty ye asal main unka he haq hai Or sochty hon k ye unke sath ziadti hai Phir dosro k khilaaf ye sb conspiracy banai hon?
ہم احمدی اس تاریخ کو درست نہیں سمجھتے اس لئے اس ان شخصیات پر جج بھی نہیں بنتے صرف اس حد تک جہاں تک قرآن نے بیت رضوان کا ذکر کر کے ان شخصیات کی بزرگی کی گواہی دی ہے اور نبی کریم ص کی بیویوں کو مومنوں کی مائیں کہا ہے۔ اگر کسی سے غلط فہمی کی وجہ سے لغزش ہوئی ہے تو اللہ مغفرت فرمائے۔ اس سے آگے ہم نہیں جاتے کیونکہ قرآن نے واضح ان حضرات کی بزرگی پر مہر ثبت کر دی ہے۔ شکریہ
Suggest me a good book to know about shia version of islam
Bhai kya yeh log Jin ka Aap zikr krrhe ho Aap ko lgta hy ki hmari koi nisbat in wahshi drindo se ho skti he humne kin kngro ko apna aaqa bnaya hua he
In drindo ke piche hunne apne bachcho ki jao ko dao par bnaya hua he
Gor kre aap bde masum ha
عباس صاحب آپ اپنے چینل پر ختم نبوت اور مرزا صاحب کی نبوت کے دلائل قرآن سے۔ ان دو موضوعات کو ہوسٹ کر سکتے ہئں؟
ان صاحب سے؟
ghost.azrael1
آپ کا مشکور ہوں گا۔ آپ قیصر راجہ اور حارث کی ڈہبیٹ ہوسٹ کر چکے ہیں۔
Finally Abbas came out as a Shia Muslim from Arab lineage.
This is the realty of Pakistan we are not a nation but we are divided between multiple faiths and our lives are always divided take example of our housing societies and names we live separately in multiple areas with our own Masjid.
Shias don’t marry with Sunnis
Sunnis don’t marry with Shias
Bohras don’t marry outside
Ismailis don’t marry outside
Parsis don’t marry outside
Christians don’t marry outside as well.
Calling Pakistanis as a nation is false in itself we were never a Nation.
'The obvious results of not listening, though it is possible he may be born in a Shia family, we don't know, but nowhere in the video he claimed that he is Shia, all he said was that he is explaining the point of view of Shias'
@@umayr2935 Abbas Haider is a Shia Name our names are based on our religious affiliations.
@@ChefbyMistake "I know many Sunnis by the names apparently of Shias, like Haider, Ghulam Hussain, Ali Rizvi. The 'Shia names' is a total misconception which the Sunnis assign, unfortunately we Sunnis attribute anything we don't like to Shias, although that phenomena might be an Islamic one from the beginning, its just out bias which puts it our as Shia'
@@umayr2935 This is very common Infact there is a Joke in Lebanon it’s either Ali or Muhammad. Ali for Shias and Muhammad for Sunnis so it’s a global thing . Show me a single Ayesha in Shias and a Single Aun or Joan or Nargis in Sunnis ? Well we need to accept our diversity.
Ghulam Hussein is a Sufi name not a Shia Nama.
Ali Rizvi is a Sunni name because Ali is common and Razavi means different in Sunnis.
Show me Baqir Ali Rizvi within any Sunni.
@@ChefbyMistake 'I think you were discussing Abbas Haider as a 'Shia name' and that was my point, how is the name 'Abbas' or 'Haider' not relevant to Sunnis'
عباس بھائی کہیں تو سچ اور جھوٹ ہے ۔ ہم جھوٹ کو Justify نہیں کر سکتے ۔ ہٹلر کی فوج کو ہٹلر کی محبت کا نام دے کر Justify نہیں کر سکتے ۔
آپ نے اہل تشیع بھائیوں کا مقدمہ پیش کیا اب حق تو یہ ہے کہ آپ اہل سنت کا بھی اس موضوع پہ مقدمہ پیش کریں ۔
سب کی سلامتی چاہتے ہیں نفرتوں سے دور بس محبت ہو ۔
Bhai, aapke Haan imamat ka concept he nhi hai.
Bani Israeel 71, 77
Baqarah 30,124,247
Aale Imran 61
Furqaan 27-30
Ahzaab 33,62
Hadees e nisbat like Musa(as) aur Harun(as).
Hadees e Saqalain
Hadees Mankuntu Maula.
Imam Ali(as) se le ker Imam Mahdi(as) tak. Yeh koi political issue bhi hai. Deeni issue hai.
Imam Mahdi aur Hazrat Esa ko support kerna zaruuri hsi aakhri daur mein, isi Tarah pichle daur mein Ali(as) ki itaat ferz Hai unko support kerna ferz Hai.
Jese Rasuul(saww) ko support kerna zaruuri Tha. Kyon jiske Rasuul (saww) Maula, Ali(as) unke maula.
@@AliHassan-wc6nbمیرے بھائی میں ان احادیث کو مانتا ہوں ۔ امام مہدی علیہ السلام کی پیروی کرنے کو بھی مانتا ہوں۔ میں مولا علیہ السلام کی شان کو بھی مانتا ہوں ۔ ان کے حق ہونے پر ہونے کو بھی مانتا ہوں۔ لیکن میں یہاں اصحاب کی بات کر رہا ہوں کہ کیس اتنا سادہ نہیں ہے اسے لوگ کسی بھی شکل میں نمایاں کر دیتے ہیں ۔ میرا یہ خیال ہے کہ یہاں اصحاب کا کیس صحیح سے پیش نہیں کیا گیا ۔ دونوں رخ بیان ہونے چاہئیں ۔ جیسے یہاں اہل تشیع کا موقف ہے اسی طرح اہل سنت کا موقف بھی ہوگا ناں میرے بھائی ۔ وہ بھی پیش ہونا چاہیے ۔ بس موقف سامنے رکھ دیں جس کا جو دل چاہے اپنائے مگر ایک طرف کی داستان سنانا انصاف نہیں ۔
باقی سب کی خیر ہو میرے بھائی ۔ سلامتی ہو ۔ اللّٰہ میری اور سب کی اصلاح کرے آمین یارب العالمین
If umar killed Fatima then why Ali and aale rasool put his son name on umar r.a
Exactly
Because it’s all lie they rafzia’s r liar
Qatilo k naam beto k naam nhi rkhy jaty. Banu umya ki purani chal h
Any reference?
There is no name of Umar in Ali's son. This is fabricated story
Case of sunni factor should also be presented with same detail
This is not more than a Shia propaganda video. When you describe only one side story you may please your Shia viewers but you can’t touch unbiased viewers.
What unbiased viewers. This is true history.
Top sunni scholars have admitted that the second caliph threated Bibi Fatima R.A. Mufti hamdard a Sunni scholar made a video on this.
First of all go and read your own sunni books If this is a shia propaganda they why is if written in your sunni sahe books other sunni books
Ok... Kindly u tell us the right one plz...😂
@@MustafaAli-lb8dq mufti hamdard not a suni he is just another intention seeker like qadri , molana tariq jameel, taqi usmani, saad rizvi show me one video of suni scholar.
@@Javed-d4m which book according to suni books shia are not muslim, you want me to believe these books or only some parts.
Very limited and conservative knowledge to present complex issue.
کون سی تاریخ/ متعصب
"When you play the game of thrones, you win or you die. There is no middle ground."Cerci Lancaster
Stark family wala scene hogya ah e bait k sath 😂
@@xMoominimam mahdi shayd jhon snow ban k aye
Tum harami khudko musalman kahte hoo lanat ho tum par or un logu par jinki tum najaiyiz aulad ko lanat ho tumare ulama para or lanat ho muavia par qki tum sab uski aayashi ka sabab ho jo woh sharab pe ka kara karta tha.
Okay where is the rebuttal to all these claims ? So I am expecting a counter claim to all these claims by you only for you to be unbaised
He is not giving his point of view...he is describing shia point of view to understand why shia do what they do
@@saadraees09 get well soon
علاج
72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے
ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو
خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے
علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی
اسلام = امن و سلامتی
فلاحی ریاست
اللھم' لبیک
پاکستان زندہ باد❤🇵🇰💯🇵🇸
Only one question: Abu Bakar, Fathima, Hazarat Ali, Usman , Aayesha, Rasool and all the characters as mentioned by you, what is link of these characters with Punjab, Sindh, KPK, Balochistan .......Kyu Arabs ke character ko explain karte ho😢❤
Adat se majboor 😂
Bhai this is an islam related video nhe pasand to mat dekho
@@HistorywithShahrukh Bas yehi jawab hain 😁
@@HistorywithShahrukh my dear brother......it is not about like and dislike. It's about belongings.....it's about identity......it's about who we are, what we are.............? Rest is dependent on your wisdom.,.....
These people were stupid arabs while indians were far superior
عقیدت سے نکل کر ریسرچ کی جائے تو منظر واضع طور پر سامنے آ جائے گا
علاج
72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے
ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو
خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے
علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی
اسلام = امن و سلامتی
فلاحی ریاست
اللھم' لبیک
پاکستان زندہ باد🇵🇸💯🇵🇰❤
Already bohat research huwa hai or still it is underway.
Basically a Muslim killed another Muslim Ali just for power
shuru sey aysa hay inka.. nabi ki deadbody side may.. aur ye apas may larhna shuru 😂
Basically 1 gang fought against another gang. They were all criminals
علاج
72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے
ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو
خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے
علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی
اسلام = امن و سلامتی
فلاحی ریاست
اللھم' لبیک
پاکستان زندہ باد🇵🇸💯🇵🇰❤
Tuj jassay sabai kuttay aisay hi sahaba ikraam R.A per bhonktay hain
@@theenlightenedone1283.
Just fake Persian stories..
Bukhari , Muslim were Persian
Shia sources are from kulaini , mufeed and sadooq who were Arab ...
@@hammadhussain4422 give me reference where do these books refer to " door breaking " incident.
@@vip26970 this incident is narrated in shia books written by Arab authors unlike Persian bukhari and Muslim . of course sunni doesn't accept these narrations as authentic.
But what about the bukhari and Muslim where it is narrated that on of the caliphs of sunnis went to the door of Fatima and threatened Fatima ? At least you should accept those narrations
@@hammadhussain4422 give references
@@vip26970 1)read the book " AL FAROOQ" by shibli naumani .
2)Tareekj yaqoobi
3) kitab sulaim ibn Qais
Apka bht bht shukriya aap ne haq ko represent kya. Allah pak apko hamesha khosh aur abaad rkhe aameen 🤲🏻💖🥰
Waqt aagaya hy k dunya mazahib aur qoomiaton se aage barhe ~ Yoval Noah Harere
Absolutely 💯
Yuval khud tou apney Zionism se aage nahin barh saka as exemplified by his stance in the Falasteen genoc1de.
@@rogersimpson2329wo Jews Hai Jo Muslims seh BHI zyadah extremist Hai inki Torah allow karti Hai genocides KO, yeh unka religion Hai jis seh wo age Nahi barh rahee religion ke name per 2 mulk hi bne Hai Israel aur Pakistan aur dono ka Hal dekh ke dukh hota BS
Bhai sahih kah raha hai. No nabi, no islam... Only human.
@@rogersimpson2329 palestine genocide? loll next joke please
My question is where does it say in Quran that the prophet family deserved khilafat? Why did Ali think Muhammad wanted him to take over? Why did the prophet not say it openly? Why Quran is quiet?
Qur'aan is not quite at all.
Bhai, aapke Haan imamat ka concept he nhi hai.
Bani Israeel 71, 77
Baqarah 30,124,247
Aale Imran 61
Furqaan 27-30
Ahzaab 33,62
Hadees e nisbat like Musa(as) aur Harun(as).
Hadees e Saqalain
Hadees Mankuntu Maula.
Imam Ali(as) se le ker Imam Mahdi(as) tak. Yeh koi political issue bhi hai. Deeni issue hai.
Imam Mahdi aur Hazrat Esa ko support kerna zaruuri hsi aakhri daur mein, isi Tarah pichle daur mein Ali(as) ki itaat ferz Hai unko support kerna ferz Hai.
Jese Rasuul(saww) ko support kerna zaruuri Tha. Kyon jiske Rasuul (saww) Maula, Ali(as) unke maula.
یہ تو نبی ص بتا گئے ہیں
میں تمہارے درمیان دو گرانقدر چیزیں چھوڑے جا رہا ہوں قرآن اور میری عترت و اہلیبیت ان دونوں سے جڑے رہنا کسی ایک کو بھی چھوڑ دیا تو گمراہ ہو جاو گے
حدیث ثقلین
اگر اسلام واقعی سچا مذہب ہے اور اللہ اور اس کے رسول ص حق ہیں تو پھر یہ بھی تو وہی بتائیں گے کہ نبی ص کے بعد آپ ص کا حقیقی جانشین کون ہو گا امت کو تو یہ حق ہی نہیں کہ وہ خود فیصلہ کریں
جب موسی علیہ السلام چالیس دن کے لئے طور پر گئے تو ہارون علیہ السلام کو اپنا نائب بنا کر گئے تو نبی ص ہمیشہ کے لئے جا رہے ہیں اور اس کے بعد کوئی نبی بھی نہیں آنا تو ایسے ہی چلے گئے امت کے بیچ جھگڑا چھوڑ کر ؟ یا کسی کو نائب بنا کر گئے ؟
اے علی آپ کا میرے بعد وہی مقام ہے جو موسی کے بعد ہارون کا تھا مگر میرے بعد کوئی نبی نہیں
نبی ص تو بتا گئے پر امت نے وہی گمراہی اختیار کی جو قوم موسی علیہ السلام نے کی یعنی سامری کے بچھڑوں کی پوجا
غدیر نہیں پڑھا تم نے٫ اسلام کی پہلی دعوت ٫ دعوت ذالعشیرہ کو نہیں پڑھا تم نے اس لیے بول رہے ہو کہ رسول نے واضع نہیں بتایا۔
تم لوگوں کا مسئلہ ہی یہی ہے کہ جو تمہارے مولویوں نے جھوٹ طوطے کی طرح رٹا دیا ہے۔ اسی کو لیکر چلتے ہو ساری زندگی اپنی کوشش نہیں کرنی۔
قران درسی کتاب نہیں ہے ھدایت کی کتاب ہے اس میں اصول بتاۓ گۓ ہیں کہ مسلمانوں کے خلیفہ میں کونسی خصوصیات ہونی چاہیے۔ مثال کے طور پر عالم ہونا شجاع ہونا متقی ہونا٫ یہ قران کے اصول ہیں ٫ قران کی ان خصوصيات پر کون پورا اترتا ہے وہ رسول اللہ بتائیں گے۔ اور رسول نے اسلام کی پہلی دعوت سے لیکر اسلام کی آخری دعوت تک مولا علی کو اپنا جاننشین بنایا ہے۔
It was fake story created by kafir Shia
You have done a good job of understanding the usual Shia view and accepted it without doing good critical assessment of your and opposing view. Ali gave Bayah (accepting religious leadership) to Abu Bakr. Ali married Abu Bakr's widow. Ali gave Bayah to Omer, Usman. Ali gave his daughter to Omer in marriage. All this is reported in Shia books which you didn't bother to read. Hussain gave Bayah to Muawiya. Hassan Gave Bayah to Muawiya. Ali, Hussan gave names to omar, usman and abu bakr to their kids. Whan Ali, Hassan and Hussain accepted them, who are you and your shia. Also, whatever you mentioned cannot be proved through any historical or religious books. Hope you open your eyes and expand your critical faculties..... I will definitely be witness in front of Allah that you were made aware of these things....
Jo sb Apne likha hy UN sab ka link de sakty hain source authentic chahie Ali a s ke nisbat Jo bhi Apne likha hy uska source please share krien
R imam Hussain ne bayah ni ki thy
You are funny
This filth that you have written is published by Banu Umayyad pigs... We have researched deeply and everyone knows so you guys also open your eyes..
عباس آپ نے آخر میں نفرت کا ذکر کیا لیکن کیا شیعہ فکر بھی بحیثیت مجموعی نفرت ہی پر مبنی نہیں؟ یعنی اگر آپ صدیوں پرانے واقعات اور اس دوران سرزد ہونے والی سیاسی غلطیوں کو اگر سیٹل نہیں ہونے دینگے اور آج کی تاریخ میں بھی ہر روز اعلان برأت کرینگے بالخصوص ان ہستیوں کے حوالے سے جنکے لیے مسلمانوں کی اکثریت اپنے اندر نرم گوشہ رکھتی ہے تو یہ نفرت مزید نفرت ہی کو جنم نہیں دے گی؟
Proper and nice
Bhai, aapke Haan imamat ka concept he nhi hai.
Bani Israeel 71, 77
Baqarah 30,124,247
Aale Imran 61
Furqaan 27-30
Ahzaab 33,62
Hadees e nisbat like Musa(as) aur Harun(as).
Hadees e Saqalain
Hadees Mankuntu Maula.
Imam Ali(as) se le ker Imam Mahdi(as) tak. Yeh koi political issue bhi hai. Deeni issue hai.
Imam Mahdi aur Hazrat Esa ko support kerna zaruuri hsi aakhri daur mein, isi Tarah pichle daur mein Ali(as) ki itaat ferz Hai unko support kerna ferz Hai.
Jese Rasuul(saww) ko support kerna zaruuri Tha. Kyon jiske Rasuul (saww) Maula, Ali(as) unke maula.
Naram gosha tu awam vegina or mastardbation k liye b rakhti ha tu kya usey b sahi maan ln
اس کے باوجود شیعہ مسلمان کہتے ہیں اور احمدیہ مسلم جماعت غیر مسلم ہے جب دنیا بھر میں احمدیہ مسلم جماعت حضور پاک صلی علیہ وآلہ وسلم کو آخری اور شرعی سچا نبی مانتے ہیں دل کی گہرائیوں ❤ سے اور اسلامی تعلیمات پر دل ❤ کی گہرائیوں سے عمل کرتے ہیں الحمدللہ
اور حضور پاک صلی علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے خلفاء راشدین اور سب صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کی دل ❤️ کی گہرائیوں سے عزت احترام کرتے ہیں الحمدللہ
Matlab arzi dal rahay ho shiun ko kafir r ahmadiun ko musalman kahnay ki.
Abu bakr se lekar unar, Yazeed se lekar aj k tm , sab kafir hn
صرف تاریخ کی کتب سے نبی ﷺ کی قریب ترین ساتھیوں جنہوں نے نبیﷺ کے لیے ہر ظلم کا سامنا کیا ان پر اس طرح کے الزام جن کے کوئی متواتر شواہد بھی نا ہو کہا کا انصاف ہے؟؟جب مولا علی علیہ السلام نے خود بالآخر خلاف راشدین کو تسلیم کر لیا تو آج کے مسلمان کیوں تحقیقات کرنے کی مشقت میں مبتلا ہیں؟کیا وہ نبیﷺ کی اشرہ مبشرہ والی حدیث کو بھی نہیں مانتے مولا علی اور حسن رضہ کے فیصلے کے آگے کی سوچ رکھتے ہیں؟؟
آج ہمیں سوشل میڈیا کے دور میں کوئی سالم خبر نہیں میسر اور آپ ہزاروں سال پرانی ان تاریخ کی کتب پر جن کا نا کوئی مقدمہ موجود ہے نا کوئی روایت کا سلسلہ موجود تو ان کی پختگی کے کتنے فیصد چانس بنتے ہیں؟ ؟
یہ دوہرا مقدمہ تو ہرگز نہیں تاریخ وہ بھ تو ہے جو باقی مسلم دنیا نے پڑ ہھی ہے آپ نے ایک طرف کا حال سنایا ہم اہل ِبیت کی محبیت کو اپنے ایمان کا حصہ مانتے ہیں لیکن جن اعلیٰ ہستیوں پے آپ تبرہ کی بات کرتے ہیں اپنی بے مثال قربانیوں کے باعث اللہ پاک کے ہاں ان کا بڑامقام ہے رضی اللہ عنہم علیہم اجمہین
Her jang say bagna wala aur bohat si sazish ma shamil logo ko raziallah banta han un logo na din ka hulya khrab kar dia un ki izat ki gai to ya wo hi kar sakta ha jo din ko sahi nahi janta.
Allah ne iblees ko mohlat de di tu kya us ki b attayat kr ln dajjal ko b dunya ki hukumat Allah ki taraf se mila gi usey b tasleem kr lena kyun k tumhara logic yahi ha hazrat ali ne khalifa ni mana ummat ko us k haal pr chor diya
Allah saved me. From all fitnas
I am converted Shia
Shayad yehi saari baaten,qisse,kahaniyan,jinka kuchh pata nahi kya sach hai kya jhoot,insaan ko mazhab se door karne ya atheist banne par majboor karti hain…!?
In another video, he had mentioned that one of his parents was Shia and the other Sunni, if I am not mistaken.
Mufti hamdadrd a sunni scholar has exposed the second caliph in his videos.
First of All He Is Not Suniii he Is Your Brother Taqayyah Wala Shia Rafzi😂😂😂😂@@MustafaAli-lb8dq
@@absf1229
He is Ahl-e-Sunnat, so go to this area and find out for yourself... You are the only one who has gone astray.
@@syedmali. If he is ahlesunnat then go to a medical Dr for your mental health check up🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ahl e Bait ❎
House Stark ✅
Abbas Haider.. very nice guy. Soft spoken but knowledgeable.
For u Haris sultan is just like your brother when it comes to Umar r.a you claim that he killed daughter of prophet such a hypocrite 😊
Accept the reality .... Hypocrisy is in Sunni Islam
@@agnostica_x lol u guyz talking
about hypocrisy your whole religion revolving around 9/10 "takiya"😂
@@waliullah2391 the holy prophet was in taqiyyah till the age of 40 b4 announcing prophethood... So taqiyah is sunnah of the holy Prophet.... Ameen.....🤣
@@agnostica_x how could you know prophet perform taqiya in age of 40....? You guyz don't even believe in seerah of prophet s.a.w because sahaba describe the seerah of prophet 😂
@@waliullah2391 What was that if that wasn't taqiyah? The holy prophet announced prophethood at the age of 40.... We take Seerah of the prophet from his household, the Ahlulbayt...... Who knows a person better than his household.......
Be a man of principle......
Only Shia stories Phao😂😂😂😂
There is no doubt that the Family of Prophet was betrayed and very badly treated after the Prophet’s demise.
😂@@mv0112012
منے میاں کہاں سے آئے ہو
Didn't
Mohammad forsaw this? When he can get massages from God about his sex life?
Nabi bhi tou zalim tha
So what does it prove?
Either the followers were unfaithful/thankless or the leader himself failed to convince his followers with his own messages.
Also it indicates Islam does not bring peace from day one.
1400 years from now, people will be fighting if 2018 election was fixed or 2013 😂.
Abbas with respect, I just want to say that these are disputed facts. You are putting your case from Shia's perspective against Hazrat Abu Baker (RA) and Hazrat Umar (RA), along with Hazrat Ayesha (RA). They are also relatives of Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH). Prophet Muhammad PBUH himself said, if there were a prophet after me, it would be Umar (RA). Moreover, prophet PBUH himself asked ALLAH for Hazrat Umar (RA) acceptance of islam. Likewise, Hazrat Abu Baker (RA) was the friend and first one to accept Islam. Moreover, he is also the father in law of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH. He has given Hazrat Ayesha (RA) to the prophet Muhammad PBUH same as Hazrat Umar (RA) has given Hazrat Hafsa RA to the prophet PBUH. Nothing is cleared in history. Every sahaba (RA) has sacrificed themselves for the prophet PBUH and for Islam. In the same way, Hazrat Usman (RA) is the son in law of the prophet Muhammad PBUH whom the prophet married off his two daughters Hazrat Ruqaiya RA and Hazrat umm e kulsum RA. Moreover, Hazrat Usman RA was the one for whom the prophet Muhammad PBUH has conducted Baith e rizwan. Especially, top ten sahabas i.e. Ashraf e Mubashara have been given high place by the prophet Muhammad PBUH himself. Therefore, categorising one over the other causes dispute. We are no one to judge sahabas with our myopic view and mindset along with distorted facts and history. It is better to pay respect to all sahabas and leave the rest upon Allah (SWT).
THIS!
i Recommend to All Of You A Book تصفیہ مابین سنی و شیعہ Hazrat Peer Meher Ali Shah Shb RA Is Kitab My Unho Ny Shia Hazrat Ki In Tmam Ilzamat Ka Jawab Daleel Or Quran O Hadees ki Roshni M Diya Hai...... so Tmam Log Lazmi Us Kitab Ko Khud Prhy❤
It is a good start, whether we agree or not. At least it is important to speak about the points of view of others and understand different perspectives of history.
Huzur ki do betion ka niakah hazrat usman se hua .... to wo jayada haqdar the hazrat ali se ..
Absolutely
Huzoor ki biwiyaan bhi Ahle Bayt thi, un ke haq ke baare me Shia kyoon nahin bhonkte hai?
@@BatMan-m6u
Shia ka baarwa Mahdi, al qayim, Sahib al-Zaman: Gandu darpok bhagoda.
Tell it to Allah and correct the Allah 1st i guess in ur point of u Allah were dumb he didnt allow hazrat usman in mubahila and ayat tatheer and also questioned nabi saw and tell him u gave ur 2 daughtersvto hazrat usman why are u promoting favouritism and prefer Ali and Fatima to all
@@wisedome3433 kisne bata deya ke Nabi ke biwiya bhi ahle bait me hai
@@ifhamhaider7295
Quran shariff padho, Surah Ahzab (33) Aayat 28 se 34 tak. Ghaor se padho.
Prophet did not know how to read and write when Gabriel came in the beginning. How did he then call for something to write on towards the end of his life!?
Did he attend evening classes!?😊
Nabi saw can write and read but u are hindu i guess and this is ahle sunnat view not the view of shia
Why is he not telling us the Sunni side of the story? He is himself Shia and trying to be smart by promoting the lies
extremly exagerated and one sided slanted opinion of this man. he is himself ahlitashi and promote and defend his school of thought and extremly hated vedio against sahaba karam and ahlisunnat wal jamat. we respect ahlibait and all sahaba karam and this is our faith. anyway we expect such disgusting vedio from you.
i wanna just say who cheated imam hussain in kufa so kindly listen allama jawad maqvi vedios.
Aisha is wife actual family not Ali he was son in law - what a joke?
Interview Mr. Javed Ahmad Ghamidi or listen to his talks on the history. See the other side of the picture as well. It's incumbent upon you to put forward the point of view of the other side , dear. Let people decide.
Bhai, the muqaddamah u r presenting is 'all the ppl u hold in reverence were assholes', and then u conclude by saying 'please don't hate'. Humans don't work like that bro.
What a stupid logic he is trying to give in defense of Shia's
As he is Imam bargain. Very disappointing , prejudice and irrational.
نالائق آدمی نبی کا جنازہ نہیں پڑھایا جاتا انہیں نماز جنازہ کی ضرورت نہیں ہوتی
جب کہ ہم مسلمانوں کی تاریخی کتب نہ ہونے کے برابر ایسی صورت میں یہ کیسے ممکن ہے اج تک ہم لوگوں کیا اپ کی اولاد پر اتفاق نہیں ہے اپ کی تاریخ پیدائش پر اتفاق نہیں ہے ہم کیسے ان روایات پر یقین کریں الحمدللہ قران پاک اور اپ کی سنت جس پر عمل کرکے ہمیں صرف مسلمان کہلوانا چاہیے شکریہ
Qareeeb mein agar pani ka glass rakha hai to wo khud par phaink dye ta k apko HOSH ajaye :) Thanda ho to ziada behtar hai.
It’s a great show.
Thank you Abbas.
Let’s say Ali was selected next - only God and people can select the one after not Ali - Even Ali’s father was not Muslim - the idea he married prophets daughter made him family / okay after Ali who is next? If he was selected then God would have helped him - it’s nothing to do with religion it’s to do with power
Explosive topic 🧨
There is a grave difference between religion and politics.
Ur hadith were written in Persia 200-300years after Mo died.. religion=politics😛
پہلی بات یہ کہ تاریخ صرف شیعہ کی نہیں اہلسنت کی بھی ہے۔ دوسرا یہ کہ تاریخ کو عقیدہ نہیں بنایا جاتا۔ اگر شیخین یا دیگر صحابہ نے اہلبیت سے ظلم کیا یا کوئی بھی اور غلط کام کیا توقرآن کے مطابق وہ اللہ سے اجر پائیں گے۔ہم سے ان کے بارے میں نہیں پوچھا جائے گا۔ شیعہ مذہب کی بنیاد امامت پر ہے چونکہ وہ اسے قرآن سے ثابت نہیں کرسکتے اس لئے ایسی تاریخ میں لوگوں کو الجھا کر مظلوم بن کر خود کو سچا ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں جس میں وہ سنیوں کی بیوقوفیوں کے باعث خاصے کامیاب رہے ہیں۔
Ap Bi Mirza Sb Ki Nabwat Ko Kabi Quran Sa Sabit Ni Kar Sakta Ansar Sb
@@ghost.azrael1 میں بفضلہ تعالی حضرت مسیح موعود ع کی نبوت کو قرآن مجید سے بخوبی ثابت کرسکتا ہوں اور ایک عرصے سے علماء کو اس بات کا چیلنج دے رہا ہوں لیکن کوئی بھی ہمت نہیں کرتا۔ آپ ہمت کریں تو میں حاضر ہوں
@@ansar58 Ap Wo Hi Ha Na X Pa Post Karta Ha K Miraz Sb Ka Reference Ni Dana
@@ansar58 Nabi To Door Ki Bat Ha Ek Fair Insan Sabit Kar Da To Bari Bat Ha Janab
@@ghost.azrael1 دیکھا! جیسے ہی قرآن کا نام لیا آپ بھاگ گئے
Why did Allah let all these atrocities happen? he could have made sure that ALi became the first Caliph. No need for centuries worth oof drama, no need for any Mehdi to come back and avenge the injustices. Its all made up anyway.
AJJ KA SHIA BHI KHASSI HAY OR AJJ KA SUNNI BHI KHASSI HAY. DONO SAY BUK CHODIYA KERWA LOOO.
How can some one come now and take revenge from people who died 1400 year ago - are you serious?
SHIA KI ZINDAGI BUS HALEEM ROTI KAY PECCHAY GUZAR JAYE GEE.
Aur tum lanti nasibi ke terrorism may guzar jaate hai. Ajay saaray sunni yahudi say pit rahay hain 😂
قاتلین عُثمان سب کے سب حضرت علی کے کیمپ میں تھے، کیا یہ درست ہے؟
they ya nhe they lekin history batati ha k Ali k followers humesha sy haq pe thy i think agar kia ho ga to sahi kia ho ga
قاتلین عثمان سارے کے سارے صحابہ تھے۔ اس پر بھی غور کرو ذرہ
Han Ali b kum rami nhn tha
Bilkul @@xMoomin
History is cruel. It will be good to get these details from some unbiased source. Source should not be from Sunni or Shia side or scholars or persons.
Par ye Banda to Sirf aur Sirf shia books ka reference de Raha he ...
Bhai, aapke Haan imamat ka concept he nhi hai.
Bani Israeel 71, 77
Baqarah 30,124,247
Aale Imran 61
Furqaan 27-30
Ahzaab 33,62
Hadees e nisbat like Musa(as) aur Harun(as).
Hadees e Saqalain
Hadees Mankuntu Maula.
Imam Ali(as) se le ker Imam Mahdi(as) tak. Yeh koi political issue bhi hai. Deeni issue hai.
Imam Mahdi aur Hazrat Esa ko support kerna zaruuri hsi aakhri daur mein, isi Tarah pichle daur mein Ali(as) ki itaat ferz Hai unko support kerna ferz Hai.
Jese Rasuul(saww) ko support kerna zaruuri Tha. Kyon jiske Rasuul (saww) Maula, Ali(as) unke maula.
How can we even obtain an unbiased source, those who wrote history in those times were biased themselves? That's why we have these two versions of history.
Very true! Shia source of History presented.
Can't understand why people in comment section are so upset. Abbas Haider only presented the views of Ahl-e-Tasheeh. He did not claim that he himself believes them all. He just wanted to let you know the reasons why Shias hate certain personalities in Islam.
The truth is that History is ambiguous and ALLAH only took responsibility of Quran, not the history. Historical records can be manipulated by people in any way they like. It has always been the case and will remain as such till eternity.
Both Shia and Sunni have different historical records and multiple disagreements. That's just it. A wise person who simply wants to follow Islam will just focus on the present and do as the Quran tells him. That'd be enough to please ALLAH.
A wise person will not follow Islam or any other religion. Quran is man made and there is no Allah.
One sided fake story. Hazrat Ali ne bhi Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddique ki Bayt ki thi.
Never... kbi b nhii kii.
Hazrat ali ne apni beti umme kulsum ko hazrat umar ke nikah mein kyu diye fir aur hazrat abubaker umar aur hazrat usman ko humare Nabi AS ne jannat ki basharat kyu di thi
I am interested in knowing if you are Shia. Your name is a big clue
Justification for political gain ,is not a religious way of thinking.Islam is a way of life chosen by Allah for believers to follow, not a way to get political power to rule the masses.As we all are aware, how history is told to serve the wasted interests.We should follow Islam as it is,rather then indulging in the distorted facts of events of centuries,of which truth is known by Allah,only.
You are absolutely right jis cheez ka pata na ho us par baat nhi karni chahiye
Your govt agencies have reported that in your Madrasas child abuse is rampant and mullahs are involved in the abusive acts , you should discuss such issues also.
Ali sahaba ka qatil tha lekin ap shia ho ke honest ho
علاج
72 فرقوں سے نکل کر 1 جماعت بن جانے کا وقت آگیا ہے
ملت/امت میں شامل ہو جاو
خلیفہ وقت کی اطاعت میں ہی برکت ہے اور پاکستان/ اسلامی ممالک کی بقا ہے
علماء سو سے بچیے/ نام نہاد لیڈروں سے بھی
اسلام = امن و سلامتی
فلاحی ریاست
اللھم' لبیک
پاکستان زندہ باد❤🇵🇸🇵🇰💯
Islam has two parts- Religious & Political
The religious side is copied from Persian, Jewish, Christian, Aramaic, Hebrew, Greek texts including Torah & Gospels
The political side is very violent during the Islamic Arabic Prophet’s time itself with war, raids, k!££!NG etc
This violence continued even after the Arabic Prophet’s death. We see how the family members including his daughter, grandchildren, son-in-law were treated and had violent d€@ths.
Then the 3 out of first 4 Sahabas had violent d€@ths
These violence continue even today when we see terrorism , most of these are Islamic.
Compare this with Jesus, his disciples spread across the world (without any army/sword) after his death & resurrection to spread and preach the teachings of Gospels.
Near and dear ones including family on earth of Jesus had peaceful life …
Jesus’ family and disciples didn’t scheme, conspire and hatred against each other unlike the Sahabas & others.
You are describing such a sensitive subject so carelessly, so this is not good journalism, you should have done it with references in more episodes. This is bad journalism that can create more rift and hate
I want to address some allegations very briefly
The word Maula was used for Hazrat Zaid too, is he also a caliph?. The Prohphet PBUH said 'OH Zayd, you are our brother and Maula. Maula word was also used for Quresh and Ansar and some other people. (Muslim)
The main dispute between shia and sunni is not caliphate, its the concept of Imamat. According to numerous Shia sources (including Haqqul Yaqeen, Imams are superior to Propheths. And Al-kafi goes on to saying that every imam has all the knowledge and miracles of ALL the past prophets a.s and the imam is directly guided by Allah, like Prophets a.s (Then there is no point in arguing if non-prophet people are superior to Hazrat Ali or other Imams.)
Firstly you provided the wrong translation of the word (Yahjur, it means "to leave", pointing to the the Prophet's (PBUH) leaving the world, and then he went on saying "istafemuhu, meaning ask him... YOu don't ask a person if he is delusional or not). Ali was the scribe of the Prophet (PBUH) it was Ali's duty to hand over the pen and paper. No report says Hazrat Umar stopped Ali from doing that. Ali had four more days to hand over the pen and paper (Qirtas)
Fadak was treated as a public trust by Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman and Even Ali and it was not handed over to Ahlul Bayt during the Caliphate of Ali and Imam Hasan. (Sheikh Asif Mohsini a famous shia writer said that Fadak's income was given to Ahlul Bayt by All four caliphs. (Ali followed the Sunnah of the previous caliphs on Fadak).
If people poisoned the Prophet (PBUH) then wasn't it Hazrat ALi's duty to punish the people when he became the Caliph and return Fadak? It is a duty of caliph to protect people's lives and property and Ali somehow failed to do it.
attempted to understand the difference between both sects several times, this is the first time I got a clearer understanding, thanks
Please don't exaggerate the situation. There are always some ppl in less numbers and others in large. What's the situation in Iran, only 9% are Sunni and others. Sunni ppl are more tolerant as they listen to tabra and move on. Never seen any Sunni, so blatantly disrespecting any Ahl e Bait. There could be but they won't dare if they were in Iran. Here inter sectarian harmony is exploited in Moharram. Isn't that a point to ponder and be pragmatic
Sunni are black spot on islam every terrorism organization belongs to sunni
Allah ne kuch logo ko zameen pe Bheja lekin Bheje mein bheja Nahi bheja isliye kuch Anpad log Samjha ne ke baad bhi nahi samjhte Are Bewakoof jaao Aur Apni khud ki likhi hui kitab padhlo mat suno kisi aur ki baat Apna khud ka bheja istemal toh kar sakte hona Ahlebet Zindabad Haq pe hai Maula Ali
@AbbasHaidar Jung e Jamal ke baad hui thi Jung e Siffin. Aapne isko Ulta bata diya hai. Aapne apni Taraf se kafi koshish kari cheezon ko rakhne ki bahut si jagahon per ghaliban aapke sources ki kami rah gai hain ya time ki Wallahu Alam. Per Koshish achi hai aapki.
Abbas Haidar Bhai,
Baagh-e-Fadak ko lekar,
Hazrat Abbas(RA) aur Hazrat Ali(RA) ke darmyaan shadeed ikhtelaaf aur jhhagdaa kyuñ thhaa...??
Aur,
Jab ikhtelaaf had se zyaada badhhaa to ye donoñ Hazraat, Hazrat Umar(RA) ke paas kyuñ gaye thhe...???????
ان کی تاریخ کو بتانے کا انداز جیسے آپ سچ سمجھ کر بیان کر رہے ہیں ۔آپ نے یقین پہلے کر لیا اور بیان کر دہے ہیں ۔ آپ کے پاس دوسری طرف کی آرا نہیں۔ بد دیانتی یا متعصب رویہ۔
Ap ki presentation bohat decent ha, ap ne is video ma sirf shia aqaed batae hain jo already hum jante hain, lekin in aqaed or waqiat k references & authenticity nahi batai
jab hazrat Ali a.s ny didn't fight with hazrat abu bakar r.a and hazrat omer r.a but you dont want to see that .. 🙄
This is one sided story according to this story you shows hazrat ali ra nawz u billah not a brave man.where is sword zulfqar
على اكبر اور علی اصغر کا اصل نام ابو بکر اور عمر تھا۔
رسول اللہ کے لاشہ کے الفاظ
سے بہتر تھا کہ آپ جسد مبارک کا لفظ استعمال کرتے؛؛؛؛
Agr Shia Tareekh or inka Muqadma theek hota Tu ye tu possible nhi ho sakta k itne ziada log Hazrat Abu Bakar, Umar, Usman, Muawiya, Hazrat Ayesha sb k sb Ek Insaan ko piche rakhna chahty hon. Aisa kiya dekh liya tha unho ne Jo ye sb k sb Ali R.A k khilaf baith k sazishe krte rahe? Aisa b tu ho sakta Hai k Hazrat Ali shru se he khalifa banna chahty hon qun k wo samjhty hon k Nabi S.A.W k cousin brother hone k naaty ye asal main unka he haq hai Or sochty hon k ye unke sath ziadti hai Phir dosro k khilaaf ye sb conspiracy banai hon?
Desire to rule is prohibited in Islam.
Baatil parast mil ker Haq per hamla kerte hain. Tamaam twwron ka nishana Ali(as) he rahay even when he got hukumat.
@@AliHassan-wc6nbKoi tu baat hogi Ye sb k sb tu batil parsat nhi ho sakty Tareekh main inka b bara muqaam hai bohat c conspiracy hain isme Allah Tallah bhtr janta hai wohi inka faisla kry ga Hum log nhi kr sakty.
Yahi to bat Ha dono sides ko dekhen to smjh main ata ha
Very important to reply to your biased knowledge briefly
1-you told about ghadeer khum that prophet saw appointed Syedona Ali rz as first caliph the valid question is that y Ali rz didn't fight against abu bakr and umar and usman for hos caliphate as he fought three battles against his legitimate caliphate against moavia rz,
2-you said abu bakr rz didn't give fidak to syeda Fatima rz , the question that y Ali rz didn't give fadak to his family if that was not justice in era of abu bakr, Umar and usman, how it was justified in caliphate of Ali rz.
3-you said umer rz burned the door of syeda Fatima rz and insulted Ali rz, the question is that was Ali rz so coward that he saw all that and then he stood up with these three caliphs who are murderers of his wife for 25 years respectfully .
I think it will take so long so enough for now.
Will elaborate your other false and fabricated propaganda any other time...
Start hi ghalat comparision se kia ha. Qadiyano Shia se relate nahi hoty kisi b soorat. Qadiyanon ko Shia Sunni dono Kafir smjhty.
Allah Aapko Salamat Rakhe aapne Sach kaha
Yahi sach hain
Hazrat usman ko Sahabao ne Shahed kiya es liye sunni Aalim bhole bhale sunniyo ko nahi batate
Aap k mutabiq agar Ali sy khilafat cheen li thi tu btao phr ali ny abu bkr o umer ki bait kyu ki ???
Jhote rafzi jhoot(taqqiya) inke iman ka 1 rukan hain Ahle Bait(r.a) aur Sahaba(r.a) ke aapas mein mohabbatein thin.
1.Hazrat Ali(r.a) ki beti Umme Kulsum jo ke Hazrat Fatima(r.a) se thin unka rishta Hazrat Umar(r.a) se huwa.
2.Hazrat Ali(r.a) ke beton ke name Abu Bakr o Usman thay jo ke Karbala mein shaheed huwe Hazrat Usman Hazrat Abbas ke bhai thay aur barri bahaduri se lar ker shaheed huwe unka name nahein liya jaata nahein toh dhanda band hojayega.
3.Hazrat Ameer Muavia(r.a) Hazrat Ali Akbar ki maa Ke Sagge mamu thay Umme Laila Abu Sufyan nawasi thin.
4.Hazrat Fatima(r.a) ka janaza Hazrat Abu Bakr(r.a) ne parhaya.
5.Hazrat Zain Ul Abidin, Hazrat Jafar Sadiq hamesha rahe madeene mein aur unke name se kutab kufe se chapti rahin.
4.Agar Hazrat Umar(r.a) ne Hazrat Bibi Fatima(r.a) per darwaza giraya toh kiya Sher Khuda(r.a) ko nahein pta ke jisne Fatima ko takleef di guya Nabi Pak ko takleef di mumkin nahein ke Sher E Khuda khomosh rehte aaj agar aap ker ghar per koi hamla kare aap khomosh rahenge??
5.11 Imamo ke bachon ke name Abu Bakr, Usman, Aysha Aur bahot Sahaba per milte hain agar aapko unse piyar hai toh aap unki pairwi kiyun nahein karte??.
6.shimr malon aur ibn muljim malon dono shia thay.
7.Hazrat Fatima(r.a) ka ek baal dikh raha tha sooraj nahein nikla tha maazAllah yeh unki betiyon per tohmat lagate hain ke beparda bazaron mein ghumaya gaya unhein mumkin hai ke Ali ke betiyan beparda hoon?? Aur dunya qaim rahe??
Dalail bahot milenge aapko aur bhi haqeeqat mein sabse barre dushman Ahle Bait ke rawafiz hain koi 1 kam bata dein jo Hazrat Ali(r.a) ne kiya ho aur yeh karte hoon?
Hazrat Ali ne bachon ke name Abu Bkr aur digar Sahaba per rakhe yeh nahein rakhte Hazrat Ali(r.a) ki darhi Mubarak thi yeh jahan darhi wala dekhein aag bagola hojayenge Hazrat Ali sache thay yeh jhoot(taqqiya) to apne iman ka rukan samajte hain.
Yeh sab dalail jo diye hain ooper sab aapko inki kitabon mein mil jayega.
persian (Koofi) zamana jahlyait m b pervaiz ko bht oncha maqam dete thay jhoti kahanyain us ki azmat m, phr jb islam un py aya aur hazrat ali r.a ka wahan maqam howa tb b un ki yahi adat rahi jhoti kahanyian bana bana, agr ap tarikh ki book parho to pehli books m sirf hazrat fatima hazrat abubakar sy kafa tha, phr next book m hazrat umar ka b zikr aa giya ab hazrat abubakr r.a k sath fadak wali story thi to hazrat umar k sath ikhtalfat ki waja banai inhon ny wo door wale waqie ki warning ko inhon ny books m execute b kr diya tb tk mohsin ya bacha ni tha phr wo thora masla add krne k liye bacha mar b diya phr us ki waja sy moat b likh di next books m ab ye bhai shb ny lohe ki silakh b dal di us m, ye waqt k sath sath shia alem ny in k demagho m ghater bhar diya ha jo ab koi shia hi nikal sakta ha masla ye ha k shia lrkon ki perwarish aisi hoti ha k wo intellectual soch ni pate, jis din unhen ye relize ho giya k mohsiin (fake baby) marne py agr hazrat ali r.a bad m khuch ni kia to wo dunia k darpok insan tha q k muslman ki kamzor tareen alamat ye k apni zaban sy b na awaz utha sake , us din shia m sy koi uth k ye sb in ko samjhaye ga aur qoam ko akhata kre ga tb na to hazrat ali ko shan chupai jaye gi na hazrat umar ko yazidi sunat k tehat galyain di jayen gi
10:30-10:45
Abbas Haidar Bhai,
Aapko kis tarah ye pataa lagaa ki Faatima(RA) ke batan ka bachchaa (jo abhi paidaa bhi naa huaa thhaa) ladka thhaa, ya ladki thhee,,, aur uss bachche ka naam MOHSIN thhaa..???
How can you ensure that the foetus was that of a MALE-CHILD. ???
And that,
His name was MOHSIN..????
Comparison of what the Shia say about the high level sahaba to what is said about Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani is inappropriate and based in ignorance. You just offended a bunch of sunni Muslims, but I am assuming that is what you were looking to achieve. I didn't really understand the point of the video. Are you Shia, Qadiani?
Kyu hussain ny tu yazeed ki bait nhi ki tu phr ali ny abu bkr o umer ki bait kesay krli agar wo haq pr nhi thy ..?????
حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہہ کی غیرت،ہمت ، شجاعت اور ایمان پر اس سے بڑی تہمت نہی ہوسکتی۔ جو شیعہ حضرات اور موصوف آپ لگاتے ہیں ۔
بڑی عجیب توجیہہ پیش کرتے ہیں کہ چھ مہینے بعد انھوں نے نہ صرف بیعت کی بلکہ شیخین کے مشیر اور قاضی بن گئے
Thank you for providing Shia perspective❤.
What a stupid vlog there are more than 7 crore shia innpakistan minority ni ha shia ahle sunat or minorities mila kr 65% hn jab k shia alone 35% of population hn
You are not putting Shia’s view but you are expressing your own views too
I like your VIDEOS befire. But here while presenting history you are mistakended...
01 abu bkr was appointed as Khalifa, after six months Ali just asked that hadn't we had right in khilafa, so abu bakr cried a the moment and Ali a.s said i have got my answer we are satisfied with you that you accepted your guilt. Mola Ali a.s married with wife of abu barkr.
02. Umar was appointed in order to save ummah from anarchy, and while he was on his death bed he appointed Six members committee to choose amongst them. Mola Ali was Chief justice during khilafat of Umar ra. And Umar ra married with daughter of Mola Ali as.
During that time Fatima R.a was not injured by door, because at that time there were no doors as it was tribal system still in most villages there are no door or gates just a heavy cloth is hanging...
Umar ra could nerve think of Hurting daughter of prophet Muhammad SAW..
03. Mola Ali as defended Usman r.a during riots of outsider along with Hassan and Hussain a.s...
Overall when Mola Ali never abused any of them how could they do it.
Mola Ali supported Each khalifa for greater cause of Ummah, so why can't you do...
Shiaism is a religion and they have no case. Ali was power hungry so were his sons, and please tell people you were present when prophet asked for writing material.
How mean was Ali who asked his wife to go and make claim for Fidak.
U must b an extreme level of illiterate person… U hv neither idea of religion not history…
Ali, Ayesha, Momo sare barbaric monsters the bhai... Aur power hungry the.. Noone is innocent... Wake up. Embrace humanity
When someone kill your mother in front of you then praise him because you are not a monster.
@@muhammadarsalanghouri3693 Momo is worse than Monster bhai...how can he be Prophet??? Come on...
SAbse pehile aysha ne rasool allha ko zeher diya
2. Abubakar or umer ne hzt ali kee khilaft cheen lee
3 .umer ne.janabe Fatema zehra or hzt Mohsin ka katl kiya
4.mavia or aysha ne hzt ali ko sauun se nhi rehne Diya
5. Mavia ne hzt hasan ko zeher dilwya
5. Yazeed ne hzt imam Hussain ko sheed karya...
( Ab in behan k tano kee kaise tareef kare)😊
Well Needed CLIP. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Secularism & Mangolism. May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!! My Salute for all the ULAMA Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل !!!!
Engineer Sahab Real ID se ao
😂😂😂@@HistorywithShahrukh
Bhai ap na sirf Shia tareekh sekhi hai or woi beyan ki hai, or jis tarha apna bughaz k sth sahaba Ka nam use Kia ap KO sharam ani chahea , is trha ap shia KO khud hi badnam kr rhy ho , is sa bhtr hai ap apna nazariya apna pas hi Rakho ,
Now please present Suni view about each of the point you mentioned and what other side thinks about Ahle-bait.
Rasool SAW ke liey Bister Marg Lafz nahi istimal karna chahiey, aap yeh keh saktey hein , aakhri waqt mien they,
Thanks Abbas, very clearly and carefully explained, filled in a lot of gaps in my knowledge.
Let bygone be bygone and we need to open our hearts and minds to all denominations of faiths. If our own faith is strong then we shouldn't be afraid of what other believe or practice. There are those who don't say it but by through their actions, God forbid, they are committing shirk when they lay judgment as if they are God. Let God decide the matters of faith.
Abbas you are nice young man and great thoughts. But never show leaning on one side irrespective of authentication of tales.
Neither Shia nor Sunni who hate each other never been truthful. They are not capable to undetstand phelosphy of Islam , selflessness and priorities.