Just amazing... Can't believe the tonal quality of both the singers... And am shocked to see some ignorant people have engaged themselves in comparing Ustad Rashid Khan to Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty.... One of them commented Ustad Rashid Khan is the king of music.... Let me make it very clear... Neither Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty nor Ustad Rashid Khan nor Pandit Anindo Chatterjee nor Pandit Tejendra Narayan Majumder nor Pandit Bhawani Shankar nor Gopal Barman is the God of Music.... Nobody can be the God of Music... They all are worshippers of Music... Critics please make their conception very very clear....
You are absolutely right. They all worship the "Nad Bramha" metamorphosed in their voice and "Talbaddya". Yes, one has to be careful in choosing the "metaphors" without knowing the dimension of "Nad Bramha", which is not only infinite but incomprehensible without the GURU, the Master in whom knowledge is the reposite. Thank you again for your incisive and unbaised clinical approach.
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster : ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
Ajoy& daughter Kaushiky will be Remembered for Ever more& more ! They are Bless Soul ! Cosmic energy is always realised in Prayers & Allap ! OSHO !!!!!
This is the combined effort of three geniuses in the world of Indian music… such divine music! Ustad Rashid will be missed for his exceptional renditions of Hindustani Classical Music…. His jugalbandis with various artists like Ustad Shahid Parvez , Hariharanji and other artists will be remembered forever! Pranam to all these artists!🙏🙏🙏
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster : ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
A kind request. Now whoever has more clips of this magnificent evening, i believe has a duty to share with other listeners of this magnificent realm of music. Such high calibre musicians creating music with one another, which is extremely rare. Imagine the amount of sheer joy it could bring to your fellow brothers and sisters? This is true testimony to the various gifts that God has bestowed upon his creations. We are also gifted to be on the receiving end of it all. So pls pls pls share if you have more
Of course Panditji's feeling is different..One would have to be deaf, dead or daft not to respond to it. It too is haunting and full of majesty and serene mastery, like that of Ustadji's superb sur and sargam and the Sarod maestro's gliding swooping swarataan. All of them are gifted masters. Bless them all for giving us this wonderful presentation!
oh yes. stay a few years in Santiniketan first and get a hold of the intactness of rabindrasangeet that is maintained by the singers here before commenting these. Tagore had prohibited any further improvisation in is songs. In case of a doubt, get a Full Volume of Geetabitan and do actually read the last pages where Tagore himself wrote about his songs being hampered by other singers as they've been improvising them in their ways, and how it has "pained" Tagore. He had compared his pain of having his songs changed to losing his own daughters to "ineligible" matches. Please do a basic research while commenting (and influencing) in a public platform.
Among the "people" you refer to are individuals for whom Rabindrasangeet goes beyond just music. It is part of their consciousness and being. Rabindrasangeet in its pure and unadulterated form is bliss for them whereas musical soirees (circus) featuring this mongrelization is a blow to them! Best of luck to the venerable ones for 'fooling' around Rabindrasangeet. Same hold true for classical music. Mixing oil with water may make great visuals but it renders both oil and water useless.
We must have the ability to appreciate beauty in each of these artists. They are all extremely talented and have their own typical nuances when they present their music! All of them are geniuses, have their individual qualities… really appreciate their range of voice and lyrical ability! Each one compliments the other’s performance! I salute them with equal reverence! 🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
Excellent & commendable effort..... before making comments here on these great maestros, we must assess our own abilities! Lets not talk just to defame someone who has proved himself & doesn't need our qualitative assessment!
I thoroughly enjoyed the refreshing variation and contrasting singing styles; hope that (some day) people stop comparing legends, and stick to pure listening for what their music has to offer. Also saw some earlier comments from Rabindrasangeet fans - I hope they broaden their minds to greater creativity. I heard duets from Ustadji with several other singers - he leaves little room for others, contrary to the spirit of duets. I am a great fan of his singing, though!
Wowwww...You both are the ones who i wanted to listen together for a very long time.Dream come true indeed.Thankyou so much uploader.You both are amazingly fantastic.I jst wanna take both of your blessings.🙌🙏🙏🙏🙏
behag raag er duti flavour dekhano hoeche there is a beautiful meeting of the two different forms of music and rabindranath perhaps wanted meeting of different emotions and forms of life
A kind request. Now whoever has more clips of this magnificent evening, i believe has a duty to share with other listeners of this magnificent realm of music. Such high calibre musicians creating music with one another, which is extremely rare. Imagine the amount of sheer joy it could bring to your fellow brothers and sisters? This is true testimony to the various gifts that God has bestowed upon his creations. We are also gifted to be on the receiving end of it all. So pls pls pls share if you have more. Peace. - NN
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster : ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
I am a student of Carnatic music for a number of years, and a lot of Ragas are shared between the two schools of music (Carnatic and Hindustani)...I have to concede that the Hindustani rendition of Behag is much more aesthetically pleasing and divine to my ear than the Carnatic version...it's absolutely lovely :D
Lot of thoughts involved in my opinion , Pt Ajay Chakraborty is the best classical artiste at this point of time in India. With great respect to Ustad Rashid Khan.
To all the dudes who say rashid khan saab is better than pandit ji...just listen to the old videos of pandit ji...he's almost 70 now...Rashid khan saab is in his prime...you can't compare them both right now...but pandit ji is definitely higher than Rashid khan saab...the command which Ajay ji has is unbeatable by anyone ...
What a grand tribute to Gurudev by RENOWNED Maestro. The song has been sung at the Maestro's own composition, meaning that Gurudev had less knowledge of music. Tagore emphasised that his songs are to be sung according to the laid down notation with no variations. This is a befitting tribute for 22 se Srabon with reason for his demise.
You cannot recompose Tagore's song. It has to be sung according to the notation laid down by Tagore. Pt A Chakraborty's rendition of Tagore's song is an example. No one doubts the knowledge of the Panditji but he should have shown some reverence to Tagore.
Bipin Mishra Where did that come from? I'm asking which of the vocalists composed this. It's a question not a judgement or criticism. To answer your question those are two completely separate fields. The composer has the greater talent usually in filmy music because the vocalist is not classically trained but in classical vocal/instrumental it is different since the roles are equal but different.
In order to continue the debate you must have some conception of Tagore and his works specially his songs. The question here is the point of rendition from an untrained singer or a person who can't sing. Pt A C is no doubt a knowledgeable and an expert in classical music, no question about this. The point is that he should have followed Tagore's notation. Tagore has left no liberty for the singer and the essence of the rendition is in his notation.
কোথায় চলে গেলি রে হতভাগা, লক্ষ লক্ষ মানুষ কে ছেড়ে? আবার আয় আমার প্রানের রাসিদ? আমি দেখতে পারছি না, চোখের জলের জন্য, কিন্তু শুনছি তুই গাইছিস শুধুই আমার জন্য। হে ঈশ্বর এমন অন্যায় করলে আমাদের সাথে?
Any raga , if performed in its finest form will sound heavenly. The sheer quality of these two legendary artists made this raga sound it's TRUE essence
Some fools comparing a 60 years old Ajoy sir to Rashid 35 around. Obviously Ajoy sir will find it difficult to manage breath, but his voice quality and modulation still second to none
Wow! I mean all of them are legends. Rashid Khan sahab, Pandit Ajay jee, Tejendra Majumdar, Anindo Da, Bhavani Shankar. Pakhawaj ka sound thorha aur hota tou performance aur khil jaati. Nevertheless, just wow man. A feast to remember.
Just amazing... Can't believe the tonal quality of both the singers... And am shocked to see some ignorant people have engaged themselves in comparing Ustad Rashid Khan to Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty.... One of them commented Ustad Rashid Khan is the king of music.... Let me make it very clear... Neither Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty nor Ustad Rashid Khan nor Pandit Anindo Chatterjee nor Pandit Tejendra Narayan Majumder nor Pandit Bhawani Shankar nor Gopal Barman is the God of Music.... Nobody can be the God of Music... They all are worshippers of Music... Critics please make their conception very very clear....
♥️
You are absolutely right. They all worship the "Nad Bramha" metamorphosed in their voice and "Talbaddya".
Yes, one has to be careful in choosing the "metaphors" without knowing the dimension of "Nad Bramha", which is not only infinite but incomprehensible without the GURU, the Master in whom knowledge is the reposite.
Thank you again for your incisive and unbaised clinical approach.
00000000000⁰000000000000000⁰000000000000⁰0⁰00⁰0⁰00⁰⁰⁰⁰0⁰00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000⁰00000⁰0000⁰0000000
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster :
ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html
Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
@@apoorv219that 1.13 minute video is a fast forwarded one. I won't say anything more!
Sat sat naman Pt. Ajoy chakrabarty ji and Ustad Rashid Khan saab🙏
Kya Range hai, Khan Saab... Pranaam aapko janam janam tak...
Exactly, sister.
Aum Shanti
Plz talk me sis
Ajoy& daughter Kaushiky will be Remembered for Ever more& more ! They are Bless Soul ! Cosmic energy is always realised in Prayers & Allap ! OSHO !!!!!
Are you a follower of bhagwan Rajneesh,?
Mind-blowing concept!!!🙏
সংগীতের মহান দিকপাল সব এক সঙ্গে । সরাসরি নাই বা দেখতে পেলাম । শুধু মুগ্ধ হয়ে শুনলাম ।
This is the combined effort of three geniuses in the world of Indian music… such divine music! Ustad Rashid will be missed for his exceptional renditions of Hindustani Classical Music…. His jugalbandis with various artists like Ustad Shahid Parvez , Hariharanji and other artists will be remembered forever! Pranam to all these artists!🙏🙏🙏
Maharajo eki saaje ele hridoyopuromaajhe !
Charonotale koti shoshi surjyo mare laaje.
Garbo sabo tutiya murchhi pare lutiya,
Sakolo mamo deho mono binasamo baaje.
Eki pulakobedona bohichhe modhubaaye !
Kaanone jato pushpo chhilo mililo tabo paaye
Palok naahi nayone, heri na kichhu bhubane -
Nirokhi shudhu antare sundaro biraje.
This is divinity...
संगीत के इन महान हस्तियों को कोटी कोटि प्रणाम।
Enjoyed excellent deliverance of Ajoy & Rashid.
Ustad Rashid Khan proved, what is classical music and how to perform? Salute ustadji.....
Pt Chakroborty also.
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster :
ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html
Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
A kind request. Now whoever has more clips of this magnificent evening, i believe has a duty to share with other listeners of this magnificent realm of music. Such high calibre musicians creating music with one another, which is extremely rare. Imagine the amount of sheer joy it could bring to your fellow brothers and sisters? This is true testimony to the various gifts that God has bestowed upon his creations. We are also gifted to be on the receiving end of it all. So pls pls pls share if you have more
Wow Rashid Khan, you are truly something else!!!!!!!
Of course Panditji's feeling is different..One would have to be deaf, dead or daft not to respond to it. It too is haunting and full of majesty and serene mastery, like that of Ustadji's superb sur and sargam and the Sarod maestro's gliding swooping swarataan. All of them are gifted masters. Bless them all for giving us this wonderful presentation!
Yes it's an awesome performance...
A brilliant attempt to put Rabindra Sangeet in different horizon, dimension & perspective. Great to.listen.
And people are out there "disliking" this masterpiece!!
Are they human being?
oh yes. stay a few years in Santiniketan first and get a hold of the intactness of rabindrasangeet that is maintained by the singers here before commenting these. Tagore had prohibited any further improvisation in is songs. In case of a doubt, get a Full Volume of Geetabitan and do actually read the last pages where Tagore himself wrote about his songs being hampered by other singers as they've been improvising them in their ways, and how it has "pained" Tagore. He had compared his pain of having his songs changed to losing his own daughters to "ineligible" matches. Please do a basic research while commenting (and influencing) in a public platform.
Among the "people" you refer to are individuals for whom Rabindrasangeet goes beyond just music. It is part of their consciousness and being. Rabindrasangeet in its pure and unadulterated form is bliss for them whereas musical soirees (circus) featuring this mongrelization is a blow to them! Best of luck to the venerable ones for 'fooling' around Rabindrasangeet. Same hold true for classical music. Mixing oil with water may make great visuals but it renders both oil and water useless.
If Pt Ajoy Chakraborty is "Bhav" Ustad Rashid Khan is "Aatma"
আমার সৌভাগ্য, এঁদের তিনজনকেই, পৃথকভাবে দেখা ও অনুষ্ঠান শোনার সুযোগ হয়েছে l
We must have the ability to appreciate beauty in each of these artists. They are all extremely talented and have their own typical nuances when they present their music! All of them are geniuses, have their individual qualities… really appreciate their range of voice and lyrical ability! Each one compliments the other’s performance! I salute them with equal reverence! 🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
My goodness, all of the people I pray to learn from in one video. Thanks a million for posting.
Excellent & commendable effort..... before making comments here on these great maestros, we must assess our own abilities! Lets not talk just to defame someone who has proved himself & doesn't need our qualitative assessment!
Truly said.
I think that is first time ever we saw them together in a concert.Just speechless.
Ustad ji what a voice wow and taan! Both are great.
I thoroughly enjoyed the refreshing variation and contrasting singing styles; hope that (some day) people stop comparing legends, and stick to pure listening for what their music has to offer. Also saw some earlier comments from Rabindrasangeet fans - I hope they broaden their minds to greater creativity. I heard duets from Ustadji with several other singers - he leaves little room for others, contrary to the spirit of duets. I am a great fan of his singing, though!
Well said
Rashid we miss you! You were the true angel of God!
Rare combinations of Artists!!! Thanks for upload!
excellant combination of all artists,thanks for uploading.
Wowwww...You both are the ones who i wanted to listen together for a very long time.Dream come true indeed.Thankyou so much uploader.You both are amazingly fantastic.I jst wanna take both of your blessings.🙌🙏🙏🙏🙏
behag raag er duti flavour dekhano hoeche
there is a beautiful meeting of the two different forms of music and rabindranath perhaps wanted meeting of different emotions and forms of life
fantastic to see both on stage together. what a treat!
Awesome combination of great singers and performance
BIG FAN OF PT AJOY CHKRABORTY Ji!
A kind request. Now whoever has more clips of this magnificent evening, i believe has a duty to share with other listeners of this magnificent realm of music. Such high calibre musicians creating music with one another, which is extremely rare. Imagine the amount of sheer joy it could bring to your fellow brothers and sisters? This is true testimony to the various gifts that God has bestowed upon his creations. We are also gifted to be on the receiving end of it all. So pls pls pls share if you have more. Peace. - NN
অনন্য মেলবন্ধন ,,,,সকল কে জানাই প্রণাম ,,,,🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
आप दोनो महत कलाकार भगवान को पुजारी हैॅ।मेरा प्रणाम स्वीकार करिये।
Surer murchonay abhibhuto ei praan. Adbhut shundor ei sonbedon!
The very much awaited jugalbandi of the great maestros..loved it
Wonderful musical experiece by two of.great musical geniuses of this generation.
What a wonderful Ghazal sung by so great singers And accompanied by very nice musicians.
JasiMagon
The Big Trio in stage performing is one of the best treat to hear along with other happy hearing best musicians of Bengal we are blessed.
Because of these people our classical music save Today
Waaa wa kamal. Anhad nadka dilpe parbah karna ,our swar me sur ko sing karna har kisiki baski bat nahi hai.🙏🙏🙏
Unparalleled and Unmatched Tankari, of Ustad Rashid Khan Saheb along with his golden voice .
UA-cam don't have many videos of pt ji in his prime but I found one in which taan speed was atleast as fast as ustad rashid if not faster :
ua-cam.com/video/ja6Ab_MwuIM/v-deo.html
Those who underestimated pt ji based on his 60 year old self in this video were ignorant guys.
thanks for this very rare treat, a treasure to all of us.
bless you all.
Thank you up loder together with You Tube.
Oshadharon!
Rashid Khan the god of classical music
Absolutely right 💯
Memorable music.My deep regards to Pdt.Ajay Chakraborty and other ustadji.
Rabindrasangeet in new light, vry refreshing from pt ajay c against the pure classical bandish of ud rashid ji
Truly a pleasure have such rave and sage comments and such detailed comparisons.
Dodh ka dodh aur pani ka pani hogaya bhajan gane wali awaz
I am a student of Carnatic music for a number of years, and a lot of Ragas are shared between the two schools of music (Carnatic and Hindustani)...I have to concede that the Hindustani rendition of Behag is much more aesthetically pleasing and divine to my ear than the Carnatic version...it's absolutely lovely :D
where we can hear these all great Artist combo other than you tube? thanks to up loader as well as You tube
Very rare to see so many greats performing together thank you 🙏
i can't stop my tears after listening these beautiful and heart touching voices together 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
ustad Rashid Khan have a ineffable Voice
So wonderful 💐
Beautiful sentiment of Rashid and Ajay some of my favorite vocalist…what a lovely ensemble too!
Raag behag e eto valo rabindra songit... osadharon
Excellent! Excellent! Excellent! Thank you, Masters!!!
Aap Dono ko mera Bahut Bahut Naman... Jai ho
Lot of thoughts involved in my opinion , Pt Ajay Chakraborty is the best classical artiste at this point of time in India. With great respect to Ustad Rashid Khan.
Sougata Bagchi what a great joke!
15:00 what was that.samhaj me nahi aaya.
Rashid khan is amazing in Bistar of taan using delicate notes
Excellent rendering of Bihag by the trio
Marvelous presentation
good to see both on sharing stage
wah kya baat hai.... great performance pt and ustad ji
Hats off...Out of this world
This great ones carry you to another level where there is only joy.
wonderful music leads to divinity
A most delightful ensemble Truly pleasing and exalting in many ways Thanks for this access N K Singh
To all the dudes who say rashid khan saab is better than pandit ji...just listen to the old videos of pandit ji...he's almost 70 now...Rashid khan saab is in his prime...you can't compare them both right now...but pandit ji is definitely higher than Rashid khan saab...the command which Ajay ji has is unbeatable by anyone ...
Again you are Making illogical comparison here. Both are greats . There is no difference between u and the people ur speaking against.
এসব ফালতু তুলনা করে দুই মহামানব কে ছোট করছেন কেন - দুজন ই মহান ও ক্ষণজন্মা
sotti opurbo... mugdho hoya galam. Ami apnadar k koti koti proman kor6i 🙏
Splendid!!!! what a combination!!!!
What a grand tribute to Gurudev by RENOWNED Maestro. The song has been sung at the Maestro's own composition, meaning that Gurudev had less knowledge of music. Tagore emphasised that his songs are to be sung according to the laid down notation with no variations. This is a befitting tribute for 22 se Srabon with reason for his demise.
Sunil Gomes Which Maestro are you speaking of? There are two vocalists here. Which composed this piece? Ajoy or Rashid?
You cannot recompose Tagore's song. It has to be sung according to the notation laid down by Tagore. Pt A Chakraborty's rendition of Tagore's song is an example. No one doubts the knowledge of the Panditji but he should have shown some reverence to Tagore.
Would you redraw the Monalisa? Or recompose Beethoven? If that is nonsense then I doubt your sanity.
Bipin Mishra Where did that come from? I'm asking which of the vocalists composed this. It's a question not a judgement or criticism.
To answer your question those are two completely separate fields. The composer has the greater talent usually in filmy music because the vocalist is not classically trained but in classical vocal/instrumental it is different since the roles are equal but different.
In order to continue the debate you must have some conception of Tagore and his works specially his songs. The question here is the point of rendition from an untrained singer or a person who can't sing. Pt A C is no doubt a knowledgeable and an expert in classical music, no question about this. The point is that he should have followed Tagore's notation. Tagore has left no liberty for the singer and the essence of the rendition is in his notation.
মুগ্ধতার সঙ্গে উপভোগ করলাম
Oh god what a performance of pt ajoy chakroborty and rasid khan ji legendary singer
Apurbo rager melbondhon.
Aahha.. Resonates with ur heart. Bound to make u emotional.
কোথায় চলে গেলি রে হতভাগা, লক্ষ লক্ষ মানুষ কে ছেড়ে? আবার আয় আমার প্রানের রাসিদ? আমি দেখতে পারছি না, চোখের জলের জন্য, কিন্তু শুনছি তুই গাইছিস শুধুই আমার জন্য।
হে ঈশ্বর এমন অন্যায় করলে আমাদের সাথে?
Priceless and speechless awesome art form
Thank you very much for uploading.
Aap ne is saaz ke jarie 😊ekdam saama bandh dia. Is ke alabe mere pas aur koi labz nahi hai! Jee o hajar saal. Subbo khair.😅
হয়তো প্রশংসা করলেও খাটো হবে গুরূজী তবুও বলি এটা আমার হৃদয় স্পর্শ করল
very well said. comparisons are the scourge of humanity
It is not appropriate to compare the two. Each has his own style. No doubt Ustad RK Shahib has a deep voice & versatility.
Wow what's feel Ajoy Chakraborty sir
মনটা ভরে গেল 👌
Behaag is such a perfect raag
Any raga , if performed in its finest form will sound heavenly. The sheer quality of these two legendary artists made this raga sound it's TRUE essence
... amar sab kaaj pondo, just chhere uthte parchhi na....
সব কাজ পণ্ড হলো?!
তা হবে না ? এমন অনুষ্ঠান ছাড়া যায় ?
WONDERFUL WONDERFUL WORLD MUSIC.
Khub sundor
these stuffs keep me alive..really! :))
Dui dikpal aksathe ,asadharan👌💅🙏
pt A Chakraborty and R Khan duet song is outstanding unique.
Very good combination. Enjoyed
Remained spellbound...this is unearthly!!..all the stars under one umbrella...
Can spend the whole life for this type of classics..
Regards,
Khub Sundar...
..
Simply mesmerising music after cancelling all criticism by all so called learned music lovers.
Some fools comparing a 60 years old Ajoy sir to Rashid 35 around. Obviously Ajoy sir will find it difficult to manage breath, but his voice quality and modulation still second to none
35 h Rashid Khan?😂 Thanks for your valuable knowledge 😂
@@Skhatik2001 this is a 15 years old concert man
Two legends!!!
Aaha,mon kore galo
Excellent, both are genius....
Wow! I mean all of them are legends. Rashid Khan sahab, Pandit Ajay jee, Tejendra Majumdar, Anindo Da, Bhavani Shankar.
Pakhawaj ka sound thorha aur hota tou performance aur khil jaati. Nevertheless, just wow man. A feast to remember.