Doctor Who The ASHES of Civilisation Review Star Beast 60th Anniversary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Doctor Who The Star Beast Review of the Disney and BBC series from Russell T Davies featuring David Tennant. The Doctor Reunites with Donna Noble played by Catherine Tate and Rose as they face off against The Meep. Can the doctor save Earth in the first episode of BBC's new Doctor Who series, the first on Disney+. Without Billie Piper returning to play Rose. Is Doctor Who the Star Beast 60th anniversary special worth watching?
Join this channel to support and get access to emotes:
/ @disparutoo
Robyn Hood Review Playlist = • Robyn Hood Review The ...
Wheel of Time Review Playlist = • Wheel of Time Episode ...
Ahsoka Star Wars Review Playlist = • Ahsoka Reviews - Disne...
Secret Invasion Review Playlist = • Secret Invasion Review...
Obi-Wan Kenobi Review Playlist = • Obi-Wan Kenobi Review ...
Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power Reviews Playlist = • Lord of the Rings: The...
Velma Review Playlist = • Velma Reviews - HBO Max
She-Hulk Review Playlist = • She-Hulk: Attorney At ...
Subscribe to this channel = / @disparutoo
#doctorwho #Davidtennant #Disney
Doctor Who Review The Star Beast 60th anniversary special. After the video yesterday covering some of the main clips and Russell T Davies reasoning for making the episode like this in the first place. Now it's the full Doctor Who review breakdown, and boy, is there a lot to this one. While there were some good scenes, I couldn't enjoy them because I was always waiting for another sledgehammer of Russell's to hit me in the face and it always came. This was never intended to be entertainment, this was meant to feed you the new morality of Hollywood. The BBC is bad enough but now, it's in combination with Disney+, what a wonderful combination! But what did you think of what you saw? Let me know your thoughts down below and as always, thanks for watching :)
Favorite line was your quip about Billie Piper not having a jaw line better than yours
I haven't watched this show for years.
I let you watch it for me your version is surely better than theirs.
I think I agree with Dave Cullen on this one. Just walk away. Don't watch the show. Don't complain about it. Let it get cancelled, and it will eventually.... and hope someone brings it back in a few years without " THE MESSAGE". Let the ratings speak for themselves. This horse is long dead. Lets stop beating it.
16:06
Did the person who needs a wheelchair just sit cross legged??
How did you miss that?
I suppose this is one way to combat piracy... I wouldent even if it was free.....
Bringing David Tenant back is classic "We killed your favorite character, now love the grotesque meat puppet we made of it". Absolutely appalling!
The Jake Skywalker treatment: "Here's your favourite character, castrated. Having fun yet?"
Reminds me of bringing Han Solo back, just to have him be a deadbeat dad and die lol.
Diversity means no heterosexual white men.
No coincidence after this became a Disney production.
Because he was understanding of Humans changing cultures and treating all people with respect? Oh yes so unlike the Doctor. Wtf are you talking about
At this point this isn't franchise abuse, it's digging up corpses and defiling them.
Just some notes.
1) his annoyance at Donna's husband seems totally manufactured and he's making crap up - a woman not wanting her husband's last name is hardly anything new.
2) "why are UNIT putting out flames" because it was on fire and shot through the sky to the point someone says it was a plane crashing.
I compare it to them beating a corpse with its severed arm.
@@loturzelrestaurantnot new but still uncommon and often viewed as odd.
It's just a demoralisation PsyOp, to destroy everything you once loved
Lol that struck my funny bone!
“Shame you’re not a woman anymore, cause she’d have understood” 🤢🤮 As a woman, I find this statement disgustingly condescending. Can we please stop portraying women as nasty and mean?
No women I associate with would ever say something so mean spirited. It’s yuck.
@@jeremytitus9519 No Lady I know would ever make such a rebuttal as that.
I agree. Its not even a good portrayal of a bitch. It's like these people have ever seen a woman irl.
Chicks are vicious verbally but it's never blunt? On the nose?
We do a lot of body language and tone or wordplay.
Like Michele feifer in hairspray "oh! New clothes? You'll stop traffic!"
Written doesn't look bad but seeing the scene it's bitchy as hell lol.
their goal is to create hate
Womankind have been struggling for centuries to achieve this pinnacle of superiority & now you're complaining? ✊😏
“That” line is literally the worst line in the series’ history and wow, just wow it really damages the character.
This is a man who burned his own planet to save the universe (and then saved it).
This is a man who spent a few billion years in a dial, punching through diamond to save his companion.
I mean, no-one else in the universe can claim to have done more good than The Doctor.
RTD has really misread the room.
This is also a man (literally the SAME man ) who sacrificed himself to save Wilf. Who as the 5th Doctor sacrificed himself to save Peri. Who as the 4th Doctor sacrificed himself to save the universe from the Master. Who as the 3rd Doctor sacrificed himself to save Earth and the universe from the Metabelis spiders.
What has that smug self satisfied little twerp ever done?
Which you'd think Donna, of all people, would know, since they literally had the "Turn Left" episode for her where The Doctor dying under the Thames caused everything to start progressively going to shit, culminating in the stars themselves going out.
She of all people knows how much good he's done, especially with her memories back, cause he saved the entire universe from the Daleks' Reality Bomb in her final episode.
"We never treat something living this horrifically."
The mere existence of "Rose" countermands that.
At this point, I don't know why there isn't an award for "Best character annihilation" and "Best franchise annihilation" (the competition would be insane)
and awards for the UA-camrs who keep making better content than their terrible shows using their own shows... 😁
Yes I would watch this show, the razzies on steroids.
The Despot of Antrim has an award show here on UA-cam for that and it’s great
Nerdrotic had a good video for Top 5 Murdered Franchises a few years ago, Doctor Who was certainly in it though I can't remember if it took first place.
David Tennants 'staring at Donna and Rose' face is actually perfect. It is the perfect 'watching the house burn around you' disbelieving stunned horror meme face.
I expect to see that face pop up in many, many future review videos. If nothing else the episode at least provides excellent fodder for memes.
David Tennant is a good enough actor to KNOW that this is a bad script. And he's a big enough Whovian to KNOW this is the death of his legacy. But he's also woke enough to care more about the message. Truly sad.
@@AliRadicali😂 *Very evidently so..!* 🤣
"This is fine! Plus I have a daughter who is beautiful and gorgeous and if I haven't mentioned recently my daughter is a girl and beautiful and I have a daughter."
as he should. let him get that paper@@ohifonlyx33
"You stupid woman and your weird child!" Meep is surprisignly based.🤣
This confirms that Meep actually turned evil after the daughter asked about his pronouns. He made up the psychedelic sun as an excuse.
Meep for President!
A creature that claims victim hood but turns out to be deceptive monster.
Did RTD mean to do that??
Meep from planet Based Alpha III.
Meep speaks for all of us. 😂 Well her kid _is_ weird, they think they act. 😂
I stand with Meep. Meep did nothing wrong.
You should feel ashamed. Didn’t you learn anything from this episode? It’s THE Meep! He always uses the definitive article.
@@davidgantenbein9362You just called Meep a he and an it. Purge the nonbeliever!
@@davidgantenbein9362OMG! You called The "he".
Meep-meep!
@@simonbrehm358 But Disney does not own Doctor Who, the BBC does.
“Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right.”
― George Orwell, 1984
Far as I'm concerned bringing David Tenant back just to have him dressed down by the whamens was the absolute final nail in the franchise's coffin.
Too many final nails to count at this point.
A nail? There are so many in the coffin I think it's become an iron maiden.
If you put an ear to the wood you can hear Dr Who screaming to be let out... Oh, no. Sorry. It's just the Dr Who audience being tortured.
Corpse defiling at this point.
It was a trial.... Not a dress down.
Trials imply fair and impartial judgment.
Darn it. As a Canadian I protest. I was led to believe that Robyn Hood was the worst show of '23, yet here we are about to be bested by this.
I belive even Meep would find the "cookie jar" to much, wouldn't let Robin touch him in fear of getting something from her lol
At least you still made the worst video game of the year. It might even win an award! (Goodbye Volcano High)
Bravo! Not one person on Earth expected Robyn Hood to be good but Russell T Davies crushed the hopes of a large percentant of the planet.
Doctor Who 2023 Special. Raising (lowering) the bar for Worst Show Of The Year.
Robyn Hood is still worse. Nobody stole anything or broke the law on a daily basis, on Dr. Who. Nobody was passing around a condom jar. I could go on, but I digress.
That’s what you get for only being a colony … getting stabbed right before the finishing line 😂
Honestly, watching those scenes with Donna and "Rose" talking down to the Doctor was physically painful...
I'm not even a fan and that hurt me.
I feel for you guys.
I watched a bit during the Tennant run cause my brothers a huge dr who fan and would play it often and beg me to watch.
Yeah and sexist as hell. Also its funny how they both have a dig at men and say women are better. When one of them is a man in a wig. 😂
I'm so tired of seeing shows and movies that do this. It's just making all of us normal, reasonable women look like we're superior, men-hating assholes. It also shows lack of talent in writing if they have to resort to taking cheap shots at men in order to make the female characters look better, for no reason except that they are female. Maybe if they spent less time degrading and tearing men down, they could write some better female characters and more interesting stories to go along with them. Seriously, I'm sick of this pandering bullshit.
@@MahouShoujoTomato We all are. At least Arcane is good.
@SteveyTheEx-Eevee touch grass
Just going to point out: up until this episode, the only ones who ever accused the Doctor of "knowing nothing" were the villains/antagonists. (Or their victims, but with despair). I would only expect companions to say that to the Doctor if he was an imposter and they knew it
Being told you have no idea what it's like to be a woman by Rose who isn't even a woman.
And to a person who was a woman not that long ago. It's ridiculous.
When I heard that “after that I wore a bow tie, after that I was a scotsman, after that I was a woman” I had to think about how Rose Tyler said “you sound like you come from the north” the Eccleston doctor just said “lots of planets have a north”.
It’s just so different in the writing. It’s like now just things are said, expository dialogue delivered, that’s it. There’s no wit, no smirk, no smile, no confidence, no character to be found. It’s like skin walker imitating humans.
_"I'm still dead. Another man gets up and walks away in my place."_ But hey, I can come back whenever I want apparently!
Yeah, the original writing would've had it "I've... been busy. Yourself?" and left it at that.
Maybe a reference to "Well, I got married... to the woman who killed me - Ooh, I was a robot for a moment!" Hide the exposition by making it sound as absurd as possible.
There's also been a good few centuries since The Doctor last said that stuff
@@RathkrynAnd we are talking time travelers here, so there would have been no issue with an older version showing up. But they had to change the rules for regenerations once more, just to make their point, which at this point must be „we hate the fans“.
@@davidgantenbein9362 we literally don't even know why the face came back, lmao. That's literally a plot point that's brought up a few times throughout the episode
Seriously, “Male Presenting Time Lord” makes me wish for another Dalek Invasion of Earth.
I think you'll find Rose has got more bollocks than tenant after they cucked him at the end 😂
I rarely actually scream at my TV, cuz I know the little people in the box can't hear me, but I broke from tradition and spoke in tongues like I was in small town Texas church as I screamed at the screen for a good minute or so when I saw that bit. Needless to say, I've had quite enough of this year's parade of shite.
I actually heard "mal-presenting Time Lord"...
"male-presenting Time Lord" is actually slightly less hateful.
Thing is though, he’s not a timelord anymore so why do they keep calling him that. They made it quite clear he is not from gallifrey.
I agree w Russel. Seeing Darth Vader as a child set me up for a lifetime of resentment towards people w COPD and burn victims. George Lucas is definitely on the wrong side of history.
Don't forget about him being an amputate with four artificial limbs you bigot 😉 !
I applaud your joke here, particularly as an asthmatic. I constantly have to resist The Dark Side any time I use my inhaler.
@@kungfuskullEarthbound Beginnings is also horrible representation, implying that asthmatics have psychic powers and are good at baseball and playing the ocarina.
@@KopperNeoman well 🤔 i've got, like, 1.5/3? I can do ocarina, i somehow just always know what time it is, even in the middle of the night, or flying to a conpletely different continent. So, spooky; but I am *terrible* at sports.
@@kungfuskull Haha your attempt is futile. It is.. Inevitable
David Tennants expression was actually perfect during that smug speech Donna and Rose gave. “You dumbasses are awfully smug considering you just did what I was about to tell you to do.
I'm glad RTD warned us about the real dangers. Now I understand why, every time I use my inhaler for asthma or feel that pain in my bad knee, I have to resist the urge to turn to the Dark Side
People with disabilities only ever became “evil” when they were bullied into it by people treating them different. I guess that says more about how RTD treated the disabled kids in his elementary school.
@@settame1 interesting that you mention that. I was remembering from my early school days (~4th grade?) A new kid showed up who was paralyzed below the waist, and he lashed out constantly, and often literally: hitting anyone ANYONE that came near him. But after a few months of nobody being mean to him, mostly just puzzled; there was a day it was like a switch was flicked and he was all happy and friendly. Since he used to be homeschooled with a neighborhood, well... i think it's sadly safe to assume they weren't good people. But once he got away and discovered kindness: flipped on a dime.
🤔 so, it's interesting that you bring that up...
"You stupid woman with your WEIRD child" ..........legend, couldnt of said it better myself.
Not a Dr Who fan, just here to lend moral support to the fans.
I'm sure this is exact feeling that I had after seeing SW TFA, and then making such a mess of it. The absolute sadness at seeing a great opportunity WASTED. Bringing back iconic characters with their original actors, only to embarrass and destroy them, it's sick. These people are gross.
Thanks mate. My earliest memory of Doctor Who is from 1977, never missed an episode, to see it go the way it has been going for the last few year is 'disheartening'.
As a lifelong Star Wars fan, i can empathize as well. A Dr. Who fan watching this episode must have gone through similiar thoughts and feelings I experienced while I watched helplessly as Disney absolutely desecrated my favorite character, Obi-Wan Kenobi, IN HIS OWN SELF TITLED SERIES..
We as fans of these works, must band together, offer support to each other to stand up afainst these corporate outsiders who feign appreciation and respect of these properties intent to maliciously usurp the audience and loyalty of these beloved works, retcon the storylines, characters, histories etc., and forcibly inject their tired, uninspired, vapid, cookie cut, propagandish agenda and push "The Message" which, more often than not, outright failed to stand on its own merits or were flat out rejected many times over when pitched at face value, in hopes they will be granted acceptance, given all respect and accolades and garner massively positive viewership once they hijack an established franchise to get their "message" heard/seen.
These people are cancerous and parasitic. Any and all of their attempts, regardless of the property, should be stamped out by fandoms across genres, as a whole.
Yeah, being a former Star Wars fan, all of this has become just another Tuesday. Current year I try to avoid and/or wet anything that involves nostalgia. It’s ultimately better to not have seen something than to get all your nostalgia ruined and abused for some quick bucks.
the worst part is a lot of doctor who fans were also star wars fans, so we had to go through this with star wars as well. it's just so depressing.
in our case, the show was ruined, then we got hope for about a year and then we got it destroyed again in an instant. feel bad for you guys man ❤.
So... did the BBC borrow the Panderstone, or did Disney break a piece of it off?
Disney helped make it.
@@Bootlegdaeternal1Disney had no creative control whatsoever they are just the international publisher
@@db5094 While _technically_ they have "no creative control" they are funding things and when someone who is paying you "makes suggestions" those suggestion have quite a bit of weight.
Russell put it someplace dark
Disney is financing this so they are involved
They did it, they did the meme! The unironically said "Are you assuming pronouns"!
It truly boggles the mind that the fanbase said "Eh, we don't really like the focus on THE MESSAGE, and BBC said "Let's double down on THE MESSAGE, just bring back Tennant, they'll eat up that slop!"
There was no meme, it was just a bloody quote.
@@KopperNeoman A quote can be a meme, genius
I was astonished. I thought the plan was to use Tennant and Tate to rebuild the audience for Gatwa. I can see the sense in that. Giving them a script that’s the equal of Whitakers worst will cause many people to give up. I got through it, then the Special came on. When new Davros came on I just got up and walked out. Had enough.
I'm astonished as to how people don't get that scene was literally meant to piss off bigots. In case you didn't know: no trans person actually says that stuff in their daily life.
@@pirate1876 looks to me like pointlessly dumping his idiot views into a script, and the whole thing was designed to annoy normal people. Giving parts to people who cannot even slightly act because of their made up identity. Repeatedly calling a bloke in a dress beautiful, compared to what ?
I didn’t discover Doctor Who until the 2005 version and I found it to be utterly fantastic. I bogged down a little with Peter Capaldi but on second viewing I appreciated him much more.
Then came Jodie Whittaker. It wasn’t her alone, it was the complete change in the dynamics of the show. For me, that marked the death of Doctor Who. Everything that they do now is just spitting on the grave.
Uwuw can I be next? 🥹
(Be gentle)
Capaldi was a great Doctor, sadly in a time of poor writing and when the agenda was beginning to be shovelled in full force.
Haven't seen Capaldi as the Dr, but he was was good as Cardinal Richelieu in the Three Musketeers
Capaldi was my first doctor change. I started watching in Matt Smiths era. I didnt like the older doctor at first I was used to younger one but Capaldi really won you over. His time was the beginning of the end and the start of this new nonsense. We should have seen it first with Missy but Gomez was such a great actress that it was pretty good. We should have said no to that because that was the beginning of this crap.
@@douglashyslop2209 Missy was a lot of fun...she got really tethered and bland as a character in Season 10, but I found her a delightful villain and a great foil to Capaldi's Doctor.
"You stupid woman with your WEIRD child" is a banger insult tho😂
Donna Noble in my opinion was an abrasive character who in her original stint in the show, had her own personality, and didn’t allow Ten to get away with anything. They had this cute friendship, that spilled chemistry. Now they created this ugly, spiteful character that allowed their kid to do something that should only occur in adulthood, and _only_ after a shite ton of therapy. Having to be told over and over and over how _beautiful_ her kid is. 🙄🤦🏻♀️ This show used to be so much fun to watch. As far as I’m concerned the series is dead, died after Twelve left. No political, gender, identity politics, or gender BS, we just want cheesy, low budget Sci Fi. And if RTD is incapable of doing just that, then he doesn’t deserve a writing career. As I said before, he’s a coward, will always be one. If he’s unwilling to retcon The Timeless Children, because his -boy- his bestie wrote. Then we can’t expect this series to continue. And I’ll enjoy y’all ripping the 15th Doctors stores to shreds. It will be glorious. 😂👍
RTD hated Chibnalls stuff, he got borderline cancelled for it on Twitter a while ago. This is the BBC and Disney, has to be
@@Jiub_SNWell, it's hard to believe that if you watch the interviews and behind the scenes of making this with Davies.... I mean I suppose everything he said could be explained if it's just because he's so terrified of getting canned if he doesn't go along with this crap.
The 10th doctor was my favourite, so while I'm elated they brought David back, I am sad that it was so short and so poorly written. And BTW, we won't be able to criticize 15, because they will make us into racists, just like when we didn't like 13, we were called women hating pigs when all we wanted was a little bit more quality. But tbf after implying that I'm a horrible person for wanting to enjoy the show, I vowed not to watch her until there is a 14th doctor.
"Only adults should be allowed to do this" is a weak position. As soon as you let your society believe that women can be men and men can be women, its over. What did you think was gonna happen when you accepted the gender bender lies being pushed on adults? Did you really think the evil cult would stop at that? Of course they werent gonna do that. They never stop. They always push harder and further. They were always gonna come for the kids.
That’s it. I couldn’t quite suss out what was wrong with Tate, she was always blunt, but not malicious.
I've seen a lot of references to the horrible "The Doctor can't understand because his dangly bits identify as male" but I kept waiting to find out what grand, amazing revelation was hidden from him so well, yet could be easily understood by a person that merely says they're a woman and... it was that they could just let go of the power? Really? REALLY?!?! You don't think they would've tried that the first time? What in the fuck does that have to do with gender identity? Is this some sort of "all men desire power, it's a feature of toxic masculinity, so none could possibly fathom giving up power even if it kills them"? This is so much worse than I thought and they already redefined how low they could just with the setup.
Ah, so that explains it!😮
Sulla became dictator of Rome, purged the Republic of most of his political enemies (creating a host of new ones in the process) and then just _retired._
Like “Okay, job’s done, you can have it back now.”
But yeah okay that’s something _girls_ understand 🤣
@@jeremytitus9519 Sticking with Rome, Diocletian rose to power, became emperor, did everything he could to save the faltering empire, rebuilt the whole thing, was ruthless in many of his edicts. ...and then, stepped down and went back to his family farm in Dalmatia and raised cabbages for the rest of his life.
I thought the male 🐏 part about not letting go was a joke about guys holding it in 😜
While females let it go 💦
Even when the doctor was a women he probably didn't dance much 😎🇺🇸🦅
Because all the power that men have from inventing, building, and maintaining the entire world, needs to be given up and given to vvhamens. That's the insane message.
I'm nearly 66 and I simply don't remember any actual instances of disability being considered evil, but it was a medieval trope, so we've been given a cure for a disease long cured. The issue was always one of not wanting disability visible, because it made the able insecure and uncomfortable, but again that's an issue that I've seen kicked into touch in my own lifetime. Seems to me Mr. Davies wants to put things back to how they were so he can 'solve' the problem all over again and feel relevant once more. It's a mid life crisis mate (like Michael Gove putting penmanship back on the Primary curriculum). Get over yourself.
The Davros trope was also a different one: the genius in a wheelchair not the disabled are evil. Davros is in line with Charles Xavier from the X-Men on the trope scale of things. He was always meant to be the mentally frightening evil as opposed to the physically frightening evil.
Do you not think kids should practice penmanship? Just curious.
@@bethanyjohnson8001It's not a critical issue. Those resources could be put into reducing immigration and removing unwanted immigrants.
RTD must have been a huge Bond fan growing up lol?
RTD is an operative with orders to divide people along imaginary lines and make them fight each others instead of uniting to defeat their oppressors. There you go, some facts.
Bringing David Tennant back just to belittle him is awful. The only thing I liked was the opening title sequence. The episode itself put me through a roller coaster of constant unanswered questions, irritation and boredom. And you're right. The Meep is actually the hero of this story
I would watch a show about the Meep and his zany misadventures as he tries to conquer various planets while insulting people. He could have equally-deranged alien accomplices and everything. Basically, we'd wind up with It's Always Sunny in Space.
Is the pting a shaven meep 😮
"Space is Relatively Void" ??
Rated R or tv 14
Just like a transphobic Invader Zim, it sounds amazing.
Yes! I nominate the junior Dalek who couldn't add up from "The Chase" as the navigator of the Meep's ship.
The "don't judge a book by its cover" plot with the ugly aliens being the good guys and the cute one being evil was done already by the FIRST Doctor. Galaxy 4, Season 3, broadcast in 1965.
Ese no es el problema de este capitulo. Han convertido todo el capitulo en un capitulo político. Han destruido los especiales clásicos de navidad.
it's a trope that is old as the world
Actually, guys, "Beep of the Meeps" was originally published in a Dr. Who magazine in the early 1980's, and reprinted by Marvel Comics for America.
This story followed the comic pretty much beat-for-beat, with no surprises at all ... just a bunch of modern politics.
TBH the Meep being evil was one of the better aspects of the episode, even if it's not all that original anymore.
@@EuroMIX2 as usual in these types of propaganda pieces the character with the best lines that everyones roots for is the bad guy
Imagine landing on an alien planet and the first question the aliens ask is “what are your correct pronouns?”.
The Meep and Doctor should destroy the Earth and go on an adventure together
Plot twist when Meep heard the daughter ask about pronouns instead of 1000 other more interesting things that’s what actually turned Meep evil he just made up the psychedelic sun as an excuse.
Funny they dressed down the doctor for pronouns & then call him a male presenting time lord. did they just assume his pronouns? Just saying...RTD writing is pretty biased.
No sign of intelligent life. Take off again and fly somewhere else.
The Babylon Bee should demand the BBC for royalties because this is a skit the BB did a year ago.
Wait, the bug aliens genocided the meeps, and we're not supposed to sympathize with the last surviving meep? Even if he's crazy/evil, I can't really blame him for trying to escape. 🤨
The doctor especially should sympathize with someone who’s the last of his kind who has turned to evil at times.
My understanding was that the Meeps always fought to the death, refusing to surrender so it turned into an accidental xenocide
So the best part about the wheelchair and Newton's Law is that it wouldn't necessarily affect her... just the chair. So the chair goes flying and she is momentarily seated in the air like a loony toon, before slamming into the ground.
I could imagine this in a spoof like Naked Gun ! 😂
“Shame you’re not a woman anymore” Donna says in front of her trans daughter and Rose agrees! Didnt know you both where so transphobic. What if anyone said that towards your child Donna?! What did the writing team even think here!? You’re so up your own agenda you dont even notice how wrong this part could be seen!
@SteveyTheEx-Eevee that's a good question🤔 Never watched the episode so don't know.
The power of being a Woman and so the Bestist ever. @SteveyTheEx-Eevee
@SteveyTheEx-Eevee Course I'm not serious. I'm making reference to Doomcock.
I am a doctor who nerd. I was excited to see the return of David Tennant. I didn't expect it to be bad. I couldn't bare more than the first 20 minutes.
It’s made me go back and watch the good old days. I didn’t even tune in for this because, deep down, I knew they’d do something like this. I just didn’t think it would be this IN YOUR FACE. My heart broke a bit when I heard him say “Allons-y!”. Like, I know acting is a job, but when you meet countless fans who love your work, how can you not stick up for them?
Yo vi todo con la esperanza que mejorara, pero no paso.
This is how I feel about the new justified season
@@mcnuggetapple they’re still making that show?
What were you baring at the episode? Or did you mean "bear", as in, to carry a burden or to tolerate something? I'm confuse
The only character I care about is the Meep. Not just because he’s cute, but because he’s right.
I'd actually watch the show if this was a setup for a season about Meep going around the galaxy being evil.
Meep did nothing wrong
"We can give up the power because we're so smart and better than you." "You HAVE to give up the power because you'll die because your body can't handle it. Mine can." "That's just what a misogynist would say!"
RTD associating disability with evil says far more about him, than the rest of us who never even had that thought enter our heads.
"If you see a problem where there isn't one, you might be the problem."
I don't think I've ever thought that.
Never ever ever thought of Davros as a wheelchair user.
Wait, does this mean that the Daleks are also disabled because they can't survive outside their enclosures?
See, when I found out about and saw the Doctor (and her costume) regenerating into David Tennant, I knew it stank of desperation because the creators of the show knew they were losing their audience. Hell, they lost me after Kill the Moon. I wasn't going to watch the special, but at the last minute I changed my mind and decided to give it a go. I remembered that Bernard Cribbins died and realized Wilfred Mott, a beloved character played by a wonderful actor, wouldn't be in the show anymore, so I wondered how they were going to acknowledge him. David Tennant's performance in that scene when the Doctor mourns and pays respect to Wilf is superb. It perfectly expresses what the Doctor and a lot of the fans would be feeling. I can't compliment it enough. But then it's ruined when the writer makes it into a joke in which Donna and Sylvia nastily chastize him for having those emotions. In amongst the nonsensical plot and the Luke Skywalker treatment, that scene right there made it clear to me. Russel T. Davies has shown he has no respect for his art, his actors, his fans, or himself. I already knew this show was no longer worth my time, but there was a spark of goodwill left. Now, it's been snuffed out. It stings to feel my investment has ultimately been for nought. No more.
That scene feels like it condenses most of the worst tendencies of woke writing into a single moment. Here's the show building up an expectation and even emotions in the audience, only to slap them in the face and belittle them for having justified expectations and feelings.
The one moment in the entire episode where the audience might have felt anything other than frustration and bitter disappointment, and they just had to subvert it. Because god forbid we give the audience what it wants.
and such an odd way to do it, RTD used to be famous for his soap opera style Doctor Who, bringing in emotions and feelings, but to do that setup and then pay it off like that, was an insult both to the character, to the actor who was a beloved actor in anything he appeared in, and had a long history in Doctor Who, something a 60th anniversary might have wanted to pay tribute to. It felt spiteful and I dont know why RTD would do that.
@awavey
I have to admit that I lost my respect for RTD as a writer when I read his collected emails book. He seemed to treat writing as just a necessary duty. There didn't seem to be any care taken, he was ok with cobbling together endings just because they were an easy way to resolve the plot. Jack Warner used to tell his wroters, It doesn't matter how good a movie is, if the end is crap, so is the movie. And so many RTD stories seemed to turn crap in the last 5 minutes.
Claiming Wilf is alive as well when the Actor has passed felt wrong too, They did not do that with The Brigadier thank god, Moffatt had some decency there.
@@RomanHistoryFan476AD I agree. Although they did dig up the Brigadier's corpse and turn him into a Cyberman. Bstds.
Let’s stop giving Tenant a free pass. Just like Harrison Ford. They knew what they were doing.
Word.
..... Ewan McGregor, Haden Christiansen, and Mark Hammill as well.
I don't fault people for getting the "bag" as the kids say these days, but damn, wait until a finished script or have a contract with full creative control over your character or something. Seriously. Do these people know they could have died as legends, but are now gonna die as middling hacks?
Fans often make the mistake and confuse the actor with the character. David Tenant isn’t Dr Who, he just plays him. Maybe he is in for the money, maybe he thought the script is great, maybe he doesn’t care and wants to play Shakespeare instead or maybe he just loves The Message. Who knows, I don’t know the guy.
Mark Hammil is legit a evil dude. He went to the ukraine and was crowned their " drone ambassador" .
@@davidgantenbein9362 very true. Could be Tenant just wanted to resume a role he enjoyed playing regardless of the script. I think his legacy though won't be tarnished because over time this abomination will fade from memory just like many bad sequels to popular films are.
Russell T. Davies actively going along with this ruination after his acclaimed run on _Doctor Who_ is the equivalent of Chris Claremont coming back to writing the X-Men, not retconning all the mistakes that have been taking place after his run, embracing those mistakes, and saying that we need to give Mojo a spine because we can't associate deformities with evil. That's the best example that I can give for those who aren't _Doctor Who_ fans for how bad that franchise has become.
It makes sense when you realize Chibnall's job was to destroy Dr. Who, and Davies' job was to urinate on its grave.
RTD wrote some good episodes like Bad Wolf, Left Turn, Midnight, Tooth and Claw etc but the 60th anniversary was appalling and he should be ashamed. I have packed my nu-Who (2005 onwards) DVDs away and I will never watch them again.
Disney is going to find a way to massacre X-men 92 😢
@@s3any1977 Why not? They're actually good! RTD doesn't get a nickel every time you watch an old episode.
Claremont did ruin his "legacy" with his godawful run on Exiles though.
The best part of the show is the unintentional bit - trans ideology as an allegory for Donna’s memory loss. As long as we never recognize reality, everything is fine….
He has lived a thousand lifetimes and given up so much to save the Universe, the Earth and his homeworld. He has lost more than any person will ever know, but he is "Male presidenting" so give up your power you hero!
Real fans that use a wheelchair would know that Davros’s life support system floats off the ground by modifying gravity in the lore. Should I feel like everyone sees me as evil when I’m riding around on my zero turn lawnmower?
Zero Turn? Burn the witch!
Sit on lawnmowers are EEEEVVVIIILLL!!!
Lawn mower?!?!
.
You are evil, everyone knows scythes are the way to go. It adds character and resilience to ones soul and especially ones lawn.
.
☠️ Lol jk do what u want
@@dandywaysofliving Scythes are cool :D
Thank you for taking the time to put your hysterical and honest review.
I am an American mom who hasn't been to a movie in four years. I just watch the new garbage through the filter of your perception, which makes it palatable and enjoyable.
It's amusing everything they try to "fix" characters in shows they accidentally make them the most evil horrible people imaginable 😂
I genuinely believe that they think people like that are good people
Yeah, since Peter Capaldi said, “Doctor, I let you go.”, this is just weird Tumblr fanfic we’re getting. So fine, Doctor, as lifetime fan since 1973, I let you go.
When Donna had her mind wiped she resisted because she didn't want to forget her time with the Doctor - her best friend - and lose the life of travelling with him. It had nothing to do with not wanting to let go of the power of the metacrisis...
So the daughter is a trans, and I was right at first glance. Imagine that.
The end of this 'episode' was the most sexist, bigoted experience I've ever had watching a television show or a movie. it was an entirely repulsive and disgusting end to a repulsive and disgusting episode.
For folks supposedly against stereotypes yet they have no problem using them
What they really desire is not equality, but Power, the left want one sided power in their favour, allowed to be hypocrites and their enemies locked up. Tolerance is a lie for them since tolerance only means for their beliefs. @@pheunithpsychic-watertype9881
In the BBC’s own review of the show, it was described as “nothing more than a vehicle to deliver The Message”!!
I feel bad for the old school fans, their last chance of a few good episodes of Dr. Who turned into this…
I don't feel bad for the fans, they enable this garbage. It's just like people who wine about loot boxes in video games, but still buy the games. I know it's not a perfect analogy, but it is similar. If you're not willing to dip out when it's headed south to send a message, then you're part of the problem imo. Whining on Twitter doesn't mean crap, they just ignore it. You need to send a message that hits them in the bank account.
@@Cman04092 The ratings are the lowest ever recorded. It wasn't the fans.
@@readhistory2023 yes now they are, now that it's absolutely destroyed. My point is, people could have made a stand ages ago, and didn't. I can't be too upset or suprised consider most people are weak and/or stupid these days.
Out of all the franchises that have been destroyed this one hit the hardest for me.
@@readhistory2023 Not as low as many of Jodies, sadly. But it will probably get there in time.
Russell T Davies falls to Roald Dahl Evil Grownup Syndrome - "I'm smart, you're dumb, I'm big, you're little, I'm right, you're wrong, and there's nothing you can do about it."
Were they expecting the audience to be thinking of Rose Tyler when Donna was calling out for 'Rose'? Because they have announced this new Rose for over a year and there is no surprise at all
I can't believe they couldn't let Rose be her own original character. They had to taint her with this smug B. First, River replaced her importance as the first and rare love of the Doctor, now this one is taking her name. Couldn't Rose just have one thing to herself?
Jason had to steal her name.
At least he didn't call himself Sarah.
presumably she has the human doctor "clone" all to herself.
Just wait until Susan comes back to see how grandad's getting on in 2023. 😱
@@Lorkanthal The clone is not the Doctor. He sounds more like Donna.
Has anyone else made the observation that they changed the Meep from its original bluish black colour to... White? It might seem like a stupid thing to point out, but this episode was so on-the-nose, simplistic and clumsily obvious with its ideological messaging that I honestly wouldn't be surprised if it was a deliberate, politically motivated decision.
Also got to give Meep some sharp teeth to really drive the message home.
The Meep has ben all sorts of colours in various reprints and reissues. In various reissues _he_ was blue grey, purple, greyish pink, royal blue and a quite nice teal. *he* always had little pointy teeth (but we only saw them after *HE* came out as evil). Of course, hhhheeeee looked white originally because the comic strip was black and white in Dr Who Weekly. Very binary, how soooo 20th century.
What they did unquestionably change was that _HE_ and *_his_* race turned evil when their planet was affected by The Black Sun.
Edited for duplucation.
The original Meep was in a black and white comic strip. No colour. He looked white to me, in the original. I bought the Weekly during it's original run. I'm still wondering why they chose this classic comic strip to destroy.
Don't worry Mr Davis we understand exactly how you feel about the wheelchair situation because most of us mistakenly associated new Who, with it's amazing early episodes, directly with your own intelligence, common sense and sanity.
We all have the opportunity to course correct and don't worry most of us have.
As for RTD being the Avenger of the Disabled, I believe it was Az who pointed out at least SIX disabled heroes: Professor Charles Xavier, Oracle / Barbara Gordon, Daredevil, Cyborg, Geordi LaForge, LUKE FUCKING SKYWALKER…
Take a swan dive into a black hole, Russel.
Batgirl is no longer disabled. She fixed her back just like Batman did. Through the power of writing.
Kentaro Miura laughing in his grave
@@jeremytitus9519Based observation. Guts kicks ass while missing a hand AND an eye. Badass representation that's older than I am.
Starts even in children’s media with how to train your dragon. Kid has a prothetic leg
And Hawkeye, he's deaf.
(I know not in movie but still)
"""Rose""" has five o'clock shadow...
They got Luke Skywalker, Indiana Jones, and now the dear old Doc. Somebody warn Batman; they’re coming for him
They got him decades ago
I’m surprised they didn’t notice how hypocritical it is that the person with identity dysmorphia gets it fixed by having it replaced with someone’s else’s identity.
They also missed the extreme irony of having someone who’s still biologically male and always will be, lecturing someone who’s been biologically female in the very recent past and still retains those memories about womanhood. I, as a woman, would be significantly less offended if the roles were reversed in that conversation. In fact, I might have had my opinion of this episode drastically flipped if the doctor had given that manlet a good dressing down.
This is the best part about these people. They are so deep up their asses trying to teach others how to live that they would not hear anyone say they are up their asses.
@@DannyDevitoOffical-TrustMeBro If the Doctor had dared to correct "Rose" on anything he'd be on suicide risk before the first complete sentence.
You know because people suffering from psychosis that everyone wants to say is totally normal and not psychosis despite being the definition of psychosis are EXTREMELY mentally stable.
we have to keep shoving perversion and insanity in peoples faces to "normalize" it.
@@DannyDevitoOffical-TrustMeBro Never happen. The thing is for all their talk about trans identity and such, they funny enough as soon as the Doctor someone who can transition between the sexes turns Male, they treat him not as Trans but as another white male punching bag, because he is Male. These people are so indoctrinated their own believes ad logic falter as soon as Male enters the equation.
They only reason they 'like' Rose is because he is a male who became Female, they only like them due to becoming Female.
I'd like to thank shill David Tennant for making this possible. They couldn't have done it without him...
Hey tennants a great dude and he did great as the doc, I highly doubt he's actually fully on board with this given how conservative and anti modern he is
@@Jiub_SN- He read the script....he did the show..... he took the check.
@@Jiub_SN David Tennant is 100% complicit
@@Jiub_SN Additionally, he also went on to publicly support and enthusiastically endorse this nonsense.
I actually liked it, thought it was a bit cringe in some parts mostly just one but I can let it slide. Everything else was enjoyable. Idk why everyone says it's dead now. Thought it was a bit better than 13, only cause I wasn't falling asleep while watching an episode, I'd force myself to stay up or nap before continuing(sorry 13) .
.
I also didn't realize the daughter was trans.
.
At first I thought she identified as male but being on UA-cam for bit, I learned she's actually a bruh in a skirt. Had me fooled, so maybe I'm not the best in judging things for what they are dx
Like it legit took me awhile and I'm still confused if that's actually a girl or a guy 😮 can someone tell me?😊
The Doctor never regenerated in Twice Upon a Time. It was tragic to see him die after meeting the First Doctor again and having his touching "reunion" with Clara and Nardole, but that was where Doctor Who ended. Yup. Nothing happens after that.
Man, imagine how cool it would have been to have Doctor Donna come back and gamble everything on figuring out how to regenerate?
If she eventually managed to transplant the Doctor's DNA into her body and regenerate with it, sacrificing her very existence to give the Doctor 11 more regenerations? Damn.
My ending to Doctor Who:
At the conclusion of ‘The Time of the Doctor,’ the 11th Doctor mistakenly thought that the Time Lords were granting him a completely new regeneration cycle. They weren’t. They granted him *one more* life to enable him to complete his work on Trenzalore and defeat the Daleks.
During ‘Twice Upon A Time,’ the 12th Doctor is struggling with the decision of whether to regenerate or to refuse, unaware that this was his final incarnation. Ultimately, this decision is taken out of his hands. As he regenerates, the artron energy dissipates into the heart of the TARDIS. The Doctor has passed away. The TARDIS travels on and reconstitutes the Doctor’s personality and memories to create the being known in ‘The Day of the Doctor’ as ‘The Curator,’ an artificially generated being that is able to shape itself into different forms of the Doctor’s past faces (ie an older fourth doctor, maybe a younger first doctor, younger seventh doctor, older ninth doctor etc). It remains as a monument to the Doctor’s history and ensures that his work lives on.
@@KopperNeoman its ironic that they ended up using this type of idea except worse with the "bi-generation" thing
"The luckiest man in the world, would have a sandwich!" Hahahaha.
"You Stupid woman! With your weird child!"
He got to know them well.😆😆
Of all the Doctor Who episodes, let alone anniversary episode, this was Painful to watch, embarrassing to watch.
Peter Capaldi was the very last Doctor.
I do find it rather hilarious that everyone treats. Donna's husband like he doesn't even exist. Because really he doesn't. His literal ONLY PURPOSE, is so that Donna can have a mixed race child.
Also the whole lets be over inclusive yet treat people with disabilities with special attention/ treatment, which is exactly what they don't want!!!! They want to be treated like everyone else. Which means YES YOU CAN HAVE DISABLED VILAINS! and actually they usually turn out pretty fkn bad ass when done right and not through wokeness.
They also talk about rose like she just appeared out of thin air. What is so wrong with reality?
“They called me Mister Glass”
@@jeremytitus9519damnit! You beat me to it 😂
@mrbeans2425
Prime example of your "pretty fkn bad ass" comment is the main man himself, Darth Vader. He's a walking torso with prosthetic limbs and a portable iron lung. And he is (before Kenobi, shudder) one of the most iconic, recognizable, and badass villains in pop culture.
@@dragonmaster1360 facts
Yeah, I was extremely confused by the Rose character. Did Rose have to become "female presenting" (as RTD would have it) on purpose or was there a sudden inexplicable change from boy to girl that they don't really want to talk about? And how is Rose different now that the power's been let go?
These sort of shows are like Eclipses, and you are my box with a pinhole in it, allowing me to see them without going blind. Thank you. :)
Excellent way of putting it. If I actually watched this stuff first hand, I would probably be in a padded room like the end of In the Mouth of Madness.
I must say I am surprised that there has not been more pushback and emphasis on the shot taken at "Male Presenting" in the special. Yes, it has been pointed out how this is "The Message" but I think it has been missed entirely that this is not "The Message" as many think. This has gone way past just targeting natural born men and male energy as is common in "the message" but now is attacking Maleness at all, even from just those who present as male (i.e. those born woman who wish to transition to or who identify as men). I thought this surely would have made a much bigger splash than it did. This is all involved saying unequivocally, "Oh your trans? You identify as female? We got your back. What? Your Identify as male? Get out of here, women are better." This is a whole new level of hypocrisy - They will advocate for trans rights and acceptance and have your back but only if you are male identifying as female apparently. Men, and all things identifying as men or presenting as men (those mannequins, anatomically correct puppets, some fire hydrants...) suck and are stupid in their eyes. This is not Diversity, Equity, or Representation, this is pure, unadulterated, Sexism and Hatred on open display. Sadly, these people also do not seem to get that you can not fight hatred with hatred, and you can not force acceptance, trying to do so only breeds bitterness, hostility, frustration, and forces all sides to draw battle lines. The ONLY successful way to dispel hatred is with patience, education, compassion, discussion, and compromises over time.
I think the reason is simple, So many people just gave up now and are not angry but just feel indifferent to the show, empathy has now filtered in and no one cares for Dr Who anymore. After this episodes that 5 million viewership number will likely begin to fall and then plummet when the 15th Doctor takes over.
Attacking all maleness is nothing new. Trans men were only ever tolerated by being ignored.
It's also insulting to male presenting nonbinary people.
I think RTD forgot the Doctor is nonbinary now and wrote that line still thinking he's a just man. If Russel can't be bothered to keep track of the terrible retcons, why should we? 🤦🏽♀️
You can't 'identify' as a man. It is not an identity, it is a biological characteristic. I get what you're trying to do, but you're using all their ideological language.
Such a greatly written character her daughter, seeing as she is;
Beautiful. And shes beautiful. Simply gorgeus. very beautiful. Did i mention beautiful? just gorgeous.
her journey from beautiful to beautiful, is just beautiful. Gorgeous.
Delusion is not beautiful, it is an illness
The fact that Donna's son ends up so messed up and thinking he's a chick is rather in line with how overbearing her character is. Her son must have *SO* many mommy issues, especially with how she demeans her husband.
Do you go out of your way to say the wrong gender for the character? If so, that's a lot more hate crime-y than simply disagreeing with the idea of trans folk. Deliberately disrespecting someone because you don't like the way that THEY are living their life. Yikes.
@sn0wfal676 I was referring to the character's biological sex and obvious mental illness, i.e gender dismorphia but sure, call me a hater. Whatever floats your woke boat.
@@sn0wfal676 These kids have issues with reality and this is your take on it?
@@MarieAnne. Not sure if you mean the trans folk or transphobic folk. Transphobic folk definitely have issues with reality.
@@sarasunshinemt4444 You don't even know what "Woke" is. It's just a silly buzzword for you because you don't understand change. Trans isn't a mental illness. There are studies from Cambridge (could be another one of the big schools) showing evidence of a biological connection that influences trans folk. The tldr of the study is that men and women have certain elements of their brain that is common to their biological makeup. Men have men brain, women have women brain, etc. The study showed that in every trans brain studied, if it was a female-born person then they would have the male's brain. Other way around if it was someone biologically male but wanting to transition into being female. It isn't an illness, it's just how some folk are born.
And before you preach horse shit anywhere, please know your stuff. The pseudo-term is "dysphoria" not "dismorphia" ya goof.
Even if you don't agree with it for whatever odd reason, why hate? Why poke fun of? Why disrespect? Like trans folk don't kill anyone by being trans, they just tryna live their life the happiest they can. What's so bad about that?
I am disabled and often require the use of a wheelchair. As such, I find it highly insulting that RTD would underestimate my capacity for evil.
Russel T drank the kool aid so bad he forgot not only the Doctor previous life was a woman but that the Timeless Child that he did not retconed was a bunch of minority women before regenerating into William Hartnell's original Doctor.
Meaning that whole "you wouldnt understand because you are a male timelord" from Donna and "Rose" was a complete BS.
I think Gary mentioned it in his review that scene is all about telling the male fans, classic or nu, you dont understand because youre men, its not Donna and Rose really dissin the Doctor, its RTD using the show as the vehicle for the message again
Especially since Rose is a dude too.
@@awavey Yeah, I know, The Message was more important than making sense, might as well make Donna look right at the screen and adress the male audience instead of breaking their own continuity.
Relooking at the older RTD episodes, I did notice that some of their plots and writing are not as great as I remembered. Maybe overrated is the better word. RTD is just another establishment hack now, rather push the message and ruin a show, than create a memorable show.
@@RomanHistoryFan476AD True, RTD worked fine probably because he had restrictions back then, in this clown era though he had free reign to do whatever he wanted.
People used to hide behind the sofa because of the monsters in Dr Who, now they're hiding because of the writers.
From apocryphal media we know that TARDISes are living creatures that are normally basically mind controlled by timelords, except the Doctor figured out that was very unethical and stuff and fixed his TARDIS up with just manual controls. She just tossed a cup of tea into the control chip analogue that is basically stuck right into its brain.
That's a great way to end an episode.
My head canon is that the Doctor died at the end of Twice Upon a Time and everything since has been Dalek propaganda.
I'll go with that!
I am glad that we are still 100% associating disability with EVIL.
Cause that was the aim of the show? Right?
It's the one tradition this show isn't trying to subvert, bless them.
Yup I'm now convinced wheelies are evil
basically Bran was the evil one in Game of Thrones, it all makes total sense now, the white walkers were just misunderstood
Jokes aside, Bran does come off as a villain when you put some thought into it, he let so many people die, let Jon be exiled, kept so many secrets to himself, let theon be killed, made himself King by manipulation, had a link to the White Walkers their king. @@awavey
When talking about associating disability with evil Russell says: "Trust me, there's a very long tradition of this".
If it's such a commonplace thing why do we need to trust him? Either it should be blatantly obvious or he should be telling us "Trust me, that's what _you_ think".
Honestly he's not wrong though, giving the villains some sort of imperfection to use as a visual cue that they're bad is a very old trope. Of course, subverting this convention by having the "ugliest" people turn out to be the nicest ones is also a very old trope (even Dr Who did this with Galaxy 4), so why RTD thinks this is still some kind of issue in 2023 is beyond me.
The Trans character is listed as being 15 years old, which is younger than the age of consent in the UK... this feels wrong... should we really having this conversation?? Especially coming from the organisation that brought us Jimmy Saville... ????
That "You know nothing" scene is going to go down in TV history as some of the worst dialog ever put on paper.
Sorry, it still has some pretty stiff competition from "they'll never know what you sacrificed"... ah, but you said "some of", so it still counts!
Bringing David back to play Dr Who is same as Marvel bringing back RDJ
If Disney Marvel did that, I'd pray RDJ would laugh in their faces.
Yay! Disparu is about to lay down his eloquent and witty dis track!
EDIT: I'm disabled and reserve the right to be evil in a wheelchair if I want to... although at this point I am merely incorrigible with an occasional limp and cane 😂
After this I and Husband are never having anything to do with DW anymore beyond enjoying videos like yours. BTW, you skewer things like this with superlative skill and ALWAYS entertain!! TY to you Disparu!!
I don't know why that Donna lady is so cool with trashing men, her daughter is one.
I’m just confused. What did it mean when they said “a male presenting time lord wouldn’t understand”? Is this some kind of concept of letting go of power that only women can understand? Well, ok, but if we go to the next part - what’s woman enough to understand that concept (if indeed women are the only ones capable of it) - the Doctor has literally been a woman. That’s in his memory surely. Does this mean that Rose didn’t understand this until they became a woman? But if they’re non-binary, are they a woman? Or is Rose a she? Are Donna and Rose both women in literally the same way? Or does it mean that all gender types and none can comprehend relinquishing power other than those who male present? What about masculine lesbians or female to male trans? I mean I just sit here and find my head spinning out of control trying to understand - why I couldn’t understand - if we can all be anything, then why does anything stand in the way of understanding? And what even are we supposed to understand…? I just… I just don’t understand. I’m not even angry. I’m just confused.
“A person who LOOKS like you do, wouldn’t understand”
Like, forget your identity-self constructed or otherwise. Forget men and women, masculinity and femininity.
_Someone with your surface appearance_ wouldn’t understand.
Such a deranged thing to write, then to green light, then to film, then to release. How do you hear something like that and not ask yourself
“Are we the baddies?”
@@jeremytitus9519 that’s it, that’s it exactly. It’s so surface that it removes all meaning from it entirely. And shows a complete misunderstanding of the entire idea they’re trying to convey. I mean, I don’t have any skin in the game here either way (I’m very live and let live) but this whole thing felt nonsensical and impossible to comprehend. So - I guess I’m not crazy then, it is just completely shallow nonsense.
@@shadesofslayshallow nonsense? Absolutely.
It feels like metacommentary from the writers that ACTUALLY the doctor is a woman FOR REAL and just "presenting" as male at the moment, or maybe they're just picking on Dave for refusing to wear Jodi's clown suit for the regeneration.
You're confused because you're trying to make sense of the story and the show was focused on the message, story be damned.
Imagine being FORCED to fund this crap by way of the outdated 'TV Licence'. Paying for the BBC should be optional.
If you're not over 60 what's the point of paying it, streaming exists and is even cheaper if you don't bother with the licence and use the money for that
it is optional. They are probably going to turn it into a tax eventually but for now you can refuse
@SteveyTheEx-Eevee Stand firm. Revolutions have been fought over less. (Hi, from the US!)
@@archstanton9073In that case, the colonies actually DID owe money. They foisted separatism on their subjects to welch on it.
Revolutions happen when the government is disgruntled. Restorations happen when the people are disgruntled.
According to the BBC, its ok to like 7-15 year olds. There's a very long tradition of this.
At Disney too.
That line about Wilf being in sheltered accommodation really should’ve been cut. It serves no purpose other than to make The Doctor look like an idiot again and it’s disrespectful after Cribbins’s passing to leave it in.
"Sheltered accommodation" sounds dystopian as hell. "Nursing home" isn't great either but it's better than that.
And if in two remaining episodes we won't see Wilf (ther is a chance they recorded something with him), then it should be removed for way more reasons than just bad script writing
"I have a daughter"
Proceeds to show image of a male. Who is dressed as women have a preference to dress.
"Daughter" is a title applied to a female child, yet they show a male and call that person a daughter.
Yet they apply said title upon a male.
Nope, no denial of basic reality there..............
edit: I've never called myself a "Dr Who Fan", but i can easily say i have enjoyed it a great deal. As a child Tom Baker was "The Doctor" and i enjoyed the early 2000s resurgence of the character.
But even i can easily see the complete betrayal of the character known as "The Doctor" displayed by the 'current year/the message' enacted by the Zealots who sadly hold control of such stories.
The motivation of usurpation and control displayed by said Zealots should be easy to identify by anybody with enough neurons to form a synapse.
I grew up with this doctor and it a shame he was treated like this.
He signed up for this crap. This isn't the first job he has followed up with woke bullsh1t
The bearded UNIT soldier is only ever sent out on Sikh & destroy missions...
I have not watched Dr. Who but I can see how important and loved it is by it’s beloved fans. I would hate to see my favorite tv show get destroyed by political correctness and left wing ideologies.
Appreciate the sentiment, but this was not destroyed, it was torn to shreds, urinated on and the remains burned in a ditch.
destroyed is underselling it
it was captured, tied up, raped, then left to die on the streets for everyone as an example to see how the woke mafia operates
The fans are not beloved. If they were, the show runners would create something decent. Those fans are hated now and that's clear
@@garethmorgan8326
Bit of an overreaction. I mean, Game of Thrones was torn to shreds, urinated on and thrown in a ditch. This just has some mediocre dialogue and a message you don’t agree with.
@@realdaggerman105 say, what. Game of thrones was just rushed bad writing. It didn't shit all over itself, then smear it on the screen.
"Shame you're not a woman anymore." She said, lacking zero awareness. Standing next to a troon.
Surely, "The Gorgeous Disparu" will inevitably catch on. Like wildfire.
The fact that *Rose* is meant to be 15 as well. Disgusting. I hope no one watches this crap anymore. And yes the writers and show runners deserve to get crap for this awful writing. But David and Catherine shouldn't get a pass. They were happy to ruin their characters for money
*Jason
As soon as you let your society believe that women can be men and men can be women, its over. What did you think was gonna happen when you accepted the gender bender lies being pushed on adults? Did you really think the evil cult would stop at that? Of course they werent gonna do that. They never stop. They always push harder and further. They were always gonna come for the kids.
Wouldn't Rose be at most 14? Regardless, I think it's hilarious that they got someone who looks 23 to play a 9th grader.
16:06 Jestem przekonana że ta scena absolutnie spodoba się wszystkim osobom na wózkach inwalidzkich którzy NIE MOGĄ poruszać nogami bez pomocy swoich rąk... w przeciwieństwie do tej pani która dosłownie założyła nogę na nogę bez większego wysiłku. Cudowna wrażliwość na jakże ważne tematy dla osób głównie SPARALIŻOWANYCH.
How the _fuck_ did they miss that.
@@grandarkfang_1482Arrogance
@@grandarkfang_1482cause they don't think.
She is committing disability fraud. Someone contact the government!😅
🐸☕ *YOU DO REALIZE THAT NOT ALL DISABLED♿ PEOPLE ARE COMPLETELY PARALYZED/NUMB!?*
I can confirm that I can’t reverse park to save my life, but I can do science 😂
I actually had the smallest bit of hope that we could start watching Doctor Who as a family again, like I did with my parents. Not a chance I’m letting them watch this propaganda.
Embarrassing character. Kate Stewart was a convincing leader. Osgood a convincing smart Alec scientist. Just came over as arrogant
12th doctors final words were.. I let you go.
But yeh a male presenting timelord doesn't know how to do that
The early scenes with Meep are actually quite extraordinary in how poorly they're written. He meets a "woman" who disembowels his friend, gets poked in the eye by another woman, witnesses another woman punch out a man who later goes on to give medical aid, and suggests profiting off his capture. Either Russel is retarded, or he.... actually despises women and chooses to portray them in this way. Astonishing either way.
Who the fuck associates disability with evil!!? First time I heard of that...
Ask RTD. Then again, I think RTD has participated one too many times in using narcotics.