A very brave woman. Keep speaking out the truth, please, and God bless you and protect you. Most if not all the campus protesters are completely ignorant and do not understand what they are protesting for.
Always amazed by the high quality of information offered. Vivian, your recalling what happened at Mahalo Oz base.... I am haunted. My kibbutz near Nir Oz miraculously escaped. But the lack of being able to protect otef residents and IDF personnel.... I go nuts a few minutes daily thinking about this.❤
There was widespread violence and civil unrest during the Vietnam War. That was for me the beginning of the divisions in society but we got through it. I think the majority of Americans are deeply appreciative of our country.
Ladies put the blame on the shoulders of the Generals. They are the ones who messed up. They were busy in politics and protest actions. Your PM is one among the greatest of today's statesmen. Stop bashing him on your programmes. It's disrespectful and you are not presenting an unbiased view of him. Shama ...you were excellent, so informative.. I wish you could have been a permanent part of the program. Use your voice to represent the Jewish people and the land of Israel when you return to the USA....
"Conspiracy theories" would gain a lot less traction if so many of them had not proven to be true over the last 5 years. And the Secret Service lapses in protocol and their failure to follow all of the procedures developed over decades shows a degree of incompetence that is very hard to believe. Some of the conspiracy theories make a lot more sense.
Consider that we still do not have access to the Kennedy files! I have watched numerous podcasts examining the Trump shooting and the interviewers are highly skilled and professional investigators and the guests are experts with countless years in the field of security and/or sharpshooting. Those behind this shooting will be routed out specifically because we all have access, we are all interested and we all care! We will no longer be sandbagged and lied to by "authorities". who care only about holding on to power. All of the podcasters resist jumping to conspiracy, but as the woman on the right alludes to, there is a point where so many unthinkable accidents and mistakes add up that you are forced to consider conspiracy.
Takes time to figure things out. The pros look for mistakes and discuss failures. CT is for either the intellectually lazy or attention seekers. Which one are you?
Do the ultra orthodox Jews not know that God required the Levites to lead the battle with praise.... Unless they want to trade their weapons for Psalm books I'd say they to study more cuz they missed that God required them to go to battle and to actually lead it!
They knew and allowed it to play itself out is the sensation that many people feel, because too much of this type of incompetence has occurred for it to be unrelated to some type of planning. Never forget that 150,000,000 Americans died because of gun violence since 2007(2020 Debates). Something is really messed up as Vivian says. Who knows the motivations of an influential individual?
@@478AB92 that is what Joe Biden said during the 2020 debates. As if half of all Americans had been killed in 13 years. It is an example of how the cognitive decline was already evident to those who had not drank the Kool-Aid already.
Emily , typical woman oh i don't like Trump ! , cause i vote with my heart not my head , forget the fact Trump is more pro Israel they any president in decades ..
She said “I will vote Trump”, what are you talking about? She is doing exactly the opposite of what you said, she is voting Trump even though she does not like him. Hating women will not get you anywhere
@@someperson1180 Okay fair enough , i didn't catch her say she would vote for Trump .But since when did criticism be deemed as hate i don't hate women ..
The Reshef Plan: The Day After in Gaza and Israel There has never been a state called Palestine and the Arab leadership in the territory of the former Mandate of Palestine has never been interested in a two-state solution. In stating that, I am not denying Arab Muslim descendants of the Mandate the right to a national identity -- just not a "Palestinian" one. Allow me to explain, starting with the “day after” in Gaza. The proposed idea of having the UAE and Saudi Arabia involved in the development of an emirates-like enclave in the Gaza strip led by local Gazan entities that are not wedded to Hamas or the PA -- with Israeli security oversight, Egypt in a supporting role, and the U.S. providing diplomatic cover -- is a step in the right direction. In keeping with the internationally endorsed political framework established in the 1990s by the Oslo Accords that seeks resolution through a bilateral negotiated final status agreement, this would leave it to the Israelis and Arabs to manage Gaza’s reconstruction and development without interference by outsiders, e.g., the UN. Under such a plan, five emirates/governorates could be established in Gaza: North Gaza, Gaza City, Deir Al-Balah, Khan Younis, and Rafah. However, that plan does not fix the wider problem of what to do with the West Bank, Jerusalem, and southern Lebanon. That is why similarly fitting solutions should also be applied for those areas, and -- the game-changer -- extended to all of Israel, using the current conflict in much the same way as the American Civil War was the catalyst for the Reconstructionist Era, during which the U.S. reintegrated into the Union the states that had seceded and determined the legal status of African Americans. It is time for a solution that is not misguidedly focused on “splitting-the-baby” - the two-state solution - but tackles the core issue of Israel's acceptance as a Jewish state in a Muslim region of the world. Such a solution should recognize what the British and League of Nations did when the Mandate was created; that the Mandate’s territory, including the West Bank and East Jerusalem, constituted the heartland of historic and cultural Israel. It is the land that Abraham purchased from Ephron 4,000 years ago, and to which Moses led the Israelites/Jews after their sojourn in Egypt. And it is where they then established two kingdoms and a dominant presence for almost 1,500 years (1,330 BC - 135 AD). If any people meet the criteria for Palestinian indigeneity, it is the Jews. A basic matching of the characteristics of indigeneity listed by the UN in its Factsheet “Who are Indigenous Peoples?” will bear this out. Moreover, in 1948 Israel was the only state to declare independence in the territory, so under the universally applied legal principle of international law, uti possidetis juris, it inherits the pre-existing borders of the Mandate as its internationally recognized sovereign borders. A reconstructionist solution would involve Israel reconstituting itself as a Constitutional Federal Republic (The Federal Republic of Israel), comprised of 27 governorates in Israel’s internationally recognized borders, the Golan Heights, and greater Jerusalem, and seven governorates in Judea and Samaria (Jenin/Tubas, Nablus, Tulkarm/Qalilya/Salfit, Ramallah/Al Bireh, Jericho, Bethlehem, and Hebron). Gaza would become a protectorate of a consortium of states including Israel, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the UAE until such time as the consortium unanimously agrees it is able to self-govern in peaceful coexistence with its neighbors. Southern Lebanon would become an autonomous regional protectorate of a consortium of states including Israel, Saudi Arabia and the UAE until such time as the consortium unanimously agrees Lebanon is able to govern it as a demilitarized autonomous region in peaceful coexistence with Israel. The republic would be guided by a federal constitution granting equal political and civil rights to all its citizens. Each of the republic’s governorates would have a locally elected government with the ability to raise local taxes and manage general administrative affairs. They would also hold specific powers defined in the constitution that would determine which powers belong to the nation (federal), which are shared (concurrent), and which belong only to the governorates, e.g., local police would manage day-to-day policing while national security matters and crimes crossing governorate lines would be handled by a federal authority. The elected Governors would sit in a new deliberative chamber of government. That chamber would also have one representative from each of the faiths representing more than 1% of the total population (Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Druze). While the chamber would not have legislative authority, it would have the mandate to scrutinize legislation, hold the government to account, and consider and report upon public policy. It could also seek to introduce legislation for the Knesset to consider and propose amendments to bills before their final passage into law. It would be able to delay bills though it could not indefinitely block their passage, with the possible exception of bills involving constitutional amendments, religious and minority rights, when a supermajority of 60% would be required to block passage in the Knesset. This would allow for the voices of all residents of the republic to be heard and considered. The Knesset would have legislative power and be much like it is today, though Israel's laws should be revised so that coalition governments cannot be as easily captured by extremist elements, e.g., the election threshold could be raised from 3.5% to 4%. A coalition government could only be formed with 55% of Knesset members, not the current 50%. If a coalition of 55% cannot be formed, then a second round of elections would be conducted with minority parties that obtained less than 4% of first-round votes dropped from the roll. Once established, a coalition government could be dissolved with a 50% vote in the Knesset. If the Knesset votes to dissolve a government but a new government coalition cannot be formed, then, like now, an election would be held. This solution would allow Arabs to have local autonomy where they predominate, and secure their property in a national register. It would not allow for Palestinian statehood. Originally proposed in 1937 by the Peel Commission, the idea of a two-state-solution was adopted by the UN in 1947, and after that, repeatedly tried by Israel with the support of the U.S., including as recently as 2000 and 2008. Every time it was rejected by the local Arab leadership, which only ever sought annihilation of the Jewish state. The opportunities for a two-state solution have been squandered, and as the current conflict has laid bare, such a solution would not resolve the real issue, which is Muslim acceptance of a Jewish state in the region. Regarding citizenship; Arabs would be offered citizenship conditional on: 1) completing two (women) to three (men) years of national service (not necessarily military); and 2) renouncing foreign citizenship of states hostile to Israel. Both of these conditions would also be required for Jews to hold citizenship. Those who do not accept these conditions or are beyond the age of national service, would receive full residency with full civil rights, and political rights in the governorates where they are registered. They would be able to vote in local government elections and for their representatives in the new chamber but not in national elections for the Knesset. They would be able to travel, work and live anywhere inside the republic but would not be able to change their residential governorate except by marriage, when they could change their residency to that of their spouse. They would get a special passport for international travel. Children would obtain citizenship status, but would lose it at 18 if they fail to fulfill the requirements of national service. Under penalty of law, organized insurgent activity (defined by law) would be grounds for imprisonment and/or to strip offenders of their citizenship/residency and expel them. This would apply for Arabs and Jews. Acts of terrorism (defined by law) could invoke a death penalty. The solution of a Constitutional Federal Republic of Israel should be supported by all civilized nations. Not only would it offer resolution to the Arab-Jewish conflict in the territory of the former Mandate, it would deal a heavy blow to the pernicious dawa and revivalist ideology of the Muslim Brotherhood that has captured much of Arab and Muslim political thinking around the world.
Yeah he just come totting his ladder and weapon and did what he did. O K. No pictures of anything except a phone recording from the crowd seeing the bullseye as prez said to do to trump
Massive failure from Intel Security & Commanders at the time of Oct7th. Commision insuring full investigation will only be the start to remedy & insure against this happening again.G~d forbid.. kdagPlymouthUK 2024July22nd
please comment about why orthodocs think they have right to not be in IDF...how tjen do they expect to be protected if not willing to be apart of Israel...thanks gals as great report...thank you.
They think so because ben gurion said it was so. If you don't want to protect them banish them.from the land- and keep the Arabs who also don't have to serve in the IDF- See how that works for israel. The talmud says- as the nations hate the jews, so do the jews hate the Torah scholars. How true.
@PaulmySanders-tp1wr My 93 year old mother, with the beginnings of cognitive issues, is all about Harris...she thinks "she is a very intelligent woman". 🤔
A very brave woman. Keep speaking out the truth, please, and God bless you and protect you. Most if not all the campus protesters are completely ignorant and do not understand what they are protesting for.
I would never have expected it? Give me a break. The vitriol from the left the last eight years towards Trump has been abhorrent.
The way Trump has been treated is nothing short of shameful. They’ve projected so much on him.
Trump is a criminal
Social media is a major part of the problem
This show is "social media"! So, actually propaganda is a major part of the problem as is anti-semitism and political/religious extremism.
Yes ! Look at first news. Oh he fell. .no that's biden
MSM They are liars and newspapers all in a nutshell, Liars!
Always amazed by the high quality of information offered. Vivian, your recalling what happened at Mahalo Oz base.... I am haunted. My kibbutz near Nir Oz miraculously escaped. But the lack of being able to protect otef residents and IDF personnel.... I go nuts a few minutes daily thinking about this.❤
Thank you so much amazing ladies ❤
Recovering progressive!!! lol. Good for you.
Yes! I remember being knocked into sanity during Obama 's 1st term.😅
The yes we can song was catchy though
That Egyptian lady is wonderful.
The story of this brave woman from Egypt is shocking. For those still asleep at the wheel wake up
Thank you Dalia Ziada for speaking out. I wish all the best for you ❤
There was widespread violence and civil unrest during the Vietnam War. That was for me the beginning of the divisions in society but we got through it. I think the majority of Americans are deeply appreciative of our country.
Never was a Trump fan but in View of everything going on I hope Trump wins also definitely better for Israel .
I went from hating him to loving him. We need a strong leader.
Trump is a narcissist and sociopath. He is a danger and will do his best to destroy democracy with Project 2025. It’s the Maga manifesto
Let's have Shama Mashtali back. Please...‼️
an Inspiration to this generation.
👍🏼👍🏼
But it's not the IDF it's the ex-generals that did not want the IDF to be alarmed , caroline Click always has so unmasced good sharing
Ladies put the blame on the shoulders of the Generals. They are the ones who messed up. They were busy in politics and protest actions. Your PM is one among the greatest of today's statesmen. Stop bashing him on your programmes. It's disrespectful and you are not presenting an unbiased view of him. Shama ...you were excellent, so informative.. I wish you could have been a permanent part of the program. Use your voice to represent the Jewish people and the land of Israel when you return to the USA....
"Conspiracy theories" would gain a lot less traction if so many of them had not proven to be true over the last 5 years. And the Secret Service lapses in protocol and their failure to follow all of the procedures developed over decades shows a degree of incompetence that is very hard to believe. Some of the conspiracy theories make a lot more sense.
שלום from New England
Hello from the nutmeg state.
Shalom 💙❤️💙❤️💙
@@RationalityPersonality-w7v
I had no idea there was a "Nutmeg state" until you mentioned it here, so I looked it up on Google.
Hello, Connecticut!
OMG it's just like so totally incredible.
Where is Ashira? Have you mentioned where she is/has been?
Consider that we still do not have access to the Kennedy files! I have watched numerous podcasts examining the Trump shooting and the interviewers are highly skilled and professional investigators and the guests are experts with countless years in the field of security and/or sharpshooting. Those behind this shooting will be routed out specifically because we all have access, we are all interested and we all care! We will no longer be sandbagged and lied to by "authorities". who care only about holding on to power. All of the podcasters resist jumping to conspiracy, but as the woman on the right alludes to, there is a point where so many unthinkable accidents and mistakes add up that you are forced to consider conspiracy.
Takes time to figure things out. The pros look for mistakes and discuss failures. CT is for either the intellectually lazy or attention seekers. Which one are you?
God rules in spite of what ANYONE thinks
Hi everyone of you people
free speech is about audience right to hear different things
Good exchange of views on this program. I was pleasantly surprised.
Praise Yeshua, Buden is out of the run , it's official now
I can't believe it--that woman just said that we didn’t expect violence from anti Trump people!
Definitely if you live in Israel you have to do your part Don’t expect other peoples sons and daughters to need to protect you. Do your part
The Jewish picture was of somebody completely different that sort of looked like the shooter from a certain angle
Do the ultra orthodox Jews not know that God required the Levites to lead the battle with praise.... Unless they want to trade their weapons for Psalm books I'd say they to study more cuz they missed that God required them to go to battle and to actually lead it!
They knew and allowed it to play itself out is the sensation that many people feel, because too much of this type of incompetence has occurred for it to be unrelated to some type of planning.
Never forget that 150,000,000 Americans died because of gun violence since 2007(2020 Debates).
Something is really messed up as Vivian says. Who knows the motivations of an influential individual?
Is it really 150 million?
President Biden misspoke. He meant to say 150,000. Per the CDC ~600,000 have died via guns (violence + suicide + accidents) from 2007 to 2024.
The USA has more guns than citizens
@@478AB92 that is what Joe Biden said during the 2020 debates. As if half of all Americans had been killed in 13 years. It is an example of how the cognitive decline was already evident to those who had not drank the Kool-Aid already.
I'm very concerned for Netanyahu 's safely in the RAT'S HANDS WITH THE PRESENCE OF THE MOSLEMS
Emily , typical woman oh i don't like Trump ! , cause i vote with my heart not my head , forget the fact Trump is more pro Israel they any president in decades ..
Trump is gaslighting. He loves only himself.
She said “I will vote Trump”, what are you talking about? She is doing exactly the opposite of what you said, she is voting Trump even though she does not like him. Hating women will not get you anywhere
@@someperson1180 Okay fair enough , i didn't catch her say she would vote for Trump .But since when did criticism be deemed as hate i don't hate women ..
The Reshef Plan: The Day After in Gaza and Israel
There has never been a state called Palestine and the Arab leadership in the territory of the former Mandate of Palestine has never been interested in a two-state solution. In stating that, I am not denying Arab Muslim descendants of the Mandate the right to a national identity -- just not a "Palestinian" one. Allow me to explain, starting with the “day after” in Gaza.
The proposed idea of having the UAE and Saudi Arabia involved in the development of an emirates-like enclave in the Gaza strip led by local Gazan entities that are not wedded to Hamas or the PA -- with Israeli security oversight, Egypt in a supporting role, and the U.S. providing diplomatic cover -- is a step in the right direction. In keeping with the internationally endorsed political framework established in the 1990s by the Oslo Accords that seeks resolution through a bilateral negotiated final status agreement, this would leave it to the Israelis and Arabs to manage Gaza’s reconstruction and development without interference by outsiders, e.g., the UN. Under such a plan, five emirates/governorates could be established in Gaza: North Gaza, Gaza City, Deir Al-Balah, Khan Younis, and Rafah.
However, that plan does not fix the wider problem of what to do with the West Bank, Jerusalem, and southern Lebanon. That is why similarly fitting solutions should also be applied for those areas, and -- the game-changer -- extended to all of Israel, using the current conflict in much the same way as the American Civil War was the catalyst for the Reconstructionist Era, during which the U.S. reintegrated into the Union the states that had seceded and determined the legal status of African Americans.
It is time for a solution that is not misguidedly focused on “splitting-the-baby” - the two-state solution - but tackles the core issue of Israel's acceptance as a Jewish state in a Muslim region of the world. Such a solution should recognize what the British and League of Nations did when the Mandate was created; that the Mandate’s territory, including the West Bank and East Jerusalem, constituted the heartland of historic and cultural Israel. It is the land that Abraham purchased from Ephron 4,000 years ago, and to which Moses led the Israelites/Jews after their sojourn in Egypt. And it is where they then established two kingdoms and a dominant presence for almost 1,500 years (1,330 BC - 135 AD). If any people meet the criteria for Palestinian indigeneity, it is the Jews. A basic matching of the characteristics of indigeneity listed by the UN in its Factsheet “Who are Indigenous Peoples?” will bear this out. Moreover, in 1948 Israel was the only state to declare independence in the territory, so under the universally applied legal principle of international law, uti possidetis juris, it inherits the pre-existing borders of the Mandate as its internationally recognized sovereign borders.
A reconstructionist solution would involve Israel reconstituting itself as a Constitutional Federal Republic (The Federal Republic of Israel), comprised of 27 governorates in Israel’s internationally recognized borders, the Golan Heights, and greater Jerusalem, and seven governorates in Judea and Samaria (Jenin/Tubas, Nablus, Tulkarm/Qalilya/Salfit, Ramallah/Al Bireh, Jericho, Bethlehem, and Hebron). Gaza would become a protectorate of a consortium of states including Israel, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the UAE until such time as the consortium unanimously agrees it is able to self-govern in peaceful coexistence with its neighbors. Southern Lebanon would become an autonomous regional protectorate of a consortium of states including Israel, Saudi Arabia and the UAE until such time as the consortium unanimously agrees Lebanon is able to govern it as a demilitarized autonomous region in peaceful coexistence with Israel. The republic would be guided by a federal constitution granting equal political and civil rights to all its citizens.
Each of the republic’s governorates would have a locally elected government with the ability to raise local taxes and manage general administrative affairs. They would also hold specific powers defined in the constitution that would determine which powers belong to the nation (federal), which are shared (concurrent), and which belong only to the governorates, e.g., local police would manage day-to-day policing while national security matters and crimes crossing governorate lines would be handled by a federal authority.
The elected Governors would sit in a new deliberative chamber of government. That chamber would also have one representative from each of the faiths representing more than 1% of the total population (Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Druze). While the chamber would not have legislative authority, it would have the mandate to scrutinize legislation, hold the government to account, and consider and report upon public policy. It could also seek to introduce legislation for the Knesset to consider and propose amendments to bills before their final passage into law. It would be able to delay bills though it could not indefinitely block their passage, with the possible exception of bills involving constitutional amendments, religious and minority rights, when a supermajority of 60% would be required to block passage in the Knesset. This would allow for the voices of all residents of the republic to be heard and considered.
The Knesset would have legislative power and be much like it is today, though Israel's laws should be revised so that coalition governments cannot be as easily captured by extremist elements, e.g., the election threshold could be raised from 3.5% to 4%. A coalition government could only be formed with 55% of Knesset members, not the current 50%. If a coalition of 55% cannot be formed, then a second round of elections would be conducted with minority parties that obtained less than 4% of first-round votes dropped from the roll. Once established, a coalition government could be dissolved with a 50% vote in the Knesset. If the Knesset votes to dissolve a government but a new government coalition cannot be formed, then, like now, an election would be held.
This solution would allow Arabs to have local autonomy where they predominate, and secure their property in a national register. It would not allow for Palestinian statehood. Originally proposed in 1937 by the Peel Commission, the idea of a two-state-solution was adopted by the UN in 1947, and after that, repeatedly tried by Israel with the support of the U.S., including as recently as 2000 and 2008. Every time it was rejected by the local Arab leadership, which only ever sought annihilation of the Jewish state. The opportunities for a two-state solution have been squandered, and as the current conflict has laid bare, such a solution would not resolve the real issue, which is Muslim acceptance of a Jewish state in the region.
Regarding citizenship; Arabs would be offered citizenship conditional on: 1) completing two (women) to three (men) years of national service (not necessarily military); and 2) renouncing foreign citizenship of states hostile to Israel. Both of these conditions would also be required for Jews to hold citizenship. Those who do not accept these conditions or are beyond the age of national service, would receive full residency with full civil rights, and political rights in the governorates where they are registered. They would be able to vote in local government elections and for their representatives in the new chamber but not in national elections for the Knesset. They would be able to travel, work and live anywhere inside the republic but would not be able to change their residential governorate except by marriage, when they could change their residency to that of their spouse. They would get a special passport for international travel. Children would obtain citizenship status, but would lose it at 18 if they fail to fulfill the requirements of national service. Under penalty of law, organized insurgent activity (defined by law) would be grounds for imprisonment and/or to strip offenders of their citizenship/residency and expel them. This would apply for Arabs and Jews. Acts of terrorism (defined by law) could invoke a death penalty.
The solution of a Constitutional Federal Republic of Israel should be supported by all civilized nations. Not only would it offer resolution to the Arab-Jewish conflict in the territory of the former Mandate, it would deal a heavy blow to the pernicious dawa and revivalist ideology of the Muslim Brotherhood that has captured much of Arab and Muslim political thinking around the world.
Yeah he just come totting his ladder and weapon and did what he did. O K. No pictures of anything except a phone recording from the crowd seeing the bullseye as prez said to do to trump
4:07 Zionist dolphins reference??? 😅🐬
They do make mistakes. Kennedy anyone?😒
Massive failure from Intel Security & Commanders at the time of Oct7th. Commision insuring full investigation will only be the start to remedy & insure against this happening again.G~d forbid.. kdagPlymouthUK
2024July22nd
Caroline glick ❤❤❤
please comment about why orthodocs think they have right to not be in IDF...how tjen do they expect to be protected if not willing to be apart of Israel...thanks gals as great report...thank you.
They think so because ben gurion said it was so. If you don't want to protect them banish them.from the land- and keep the Arabs who also don't have to serve in the IDF- See how that works for israel.
The talmud says- as the nations hate the jews, so do the jews hate the Torah scholars. How true.
Umm.. he dropped out
To answer the thumbnail, no
You've seen it from Trump? Any examples?
Well planned with ignorance then saying opps sorry. Well planned!
The secret service is secret
Jd Vance is a sellout.
I thnk you miss alot when talking why the right doesnt trust the narrative creators in media i used narrative creators for a reason.
Not my favorite show at all
Impossible for Harris to "win"? see 2020
Still can’t find an Israeli to host this ??😂
Thank you President Biden for stepping down. Kamala Harris will do a excellent job both for the USA and for Democracies around the world. FDT.
Rational I think not,illrationial is more like it.
😂😂😂
@PaulmySanders-tp1wr My 93 year old mother, with the beginnings of cognitive issues, is all about Harris...she thinks "she is a very intelligent woman". 🤔
Please tell us you’re joking 😂
Definitely. She has imagined what can be unburdened by what has been 😅
So secret that they will turn against those whom they suppose to protect.
Oct 7 was not a security failure. It was deliberate as Hannibal directive was implemented.
see ABC News " IsraeliObservation >>> "