The Kulture Study: Acid Angels from Asia (tripleS) 'Generation' MV REACTION & REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лис 2022
- Want to help keep the channel alive? Support us on patreon @ patreon.com/formoftherapy
Want to just make a one time donation? You can donate to the channel via PAYPAL: media@formoftherapy.com
Watch the original video here: • 트리플에스(tripleS AAA) ‘Ge...
For business & professional inquiries only:
media@formoftherapy.com
Follow us on social media @formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
#tripleS_AAA #Generation #tripleS
finally someone who's as confused by the song structure as i was. they really gave us one verse and said, you're good, listen to the chorus for the rest of the song
Fr😭it was so repetitive
@@armymydaycaratnctzenatinyaroha yea it was repetitive but the amazing thing is it doesn’t feel repetitive
@@ichigokururin540 fr! Imo the example of a repetitive annoying song is yooa’s selfish 😆
Though I love her songs too
@@ichigokururin540 It's a trick that's very very difficult to pull off, in fact the only song I know that's truly done it is Daft Punk - Around the World.
it’s repetitive ask but doesn’t sound one bit bad 😩 kinda sunil okay to YooAs Selfish
the best way i can describe this new genre thats being formed in kpop is "nostalgia for the modern day"
So true bro, new jeans and now triples are a new change for k-pop and 4th generation also
@@B.B_Yoda0623 lets not forget weeekly's after school !
@@gettingmytherapyfrombangch909 i agree but they didn’t stick to the concept and kind of fell off
"new genre."
@@pinklamborghini5624 ??
a lot of people are confused about the group having "disbanded" due to misleading article headlines from news sites. this is the wrong way to frame how it works, and "disbandment" is language that was introduced by these news sites rather than the company itself. before the members were even revealed, it was established from the beginning that tripleS would not have fixed units and would operate on a rotating basis of subunits and solo groupings. it's similar to how nct u operates in that they rotate through different member combinations for each comeback.
the difference being: the decision of who is grouped together is given to the fans through voting (which is where the nfts come in, votes are displayed on the blockchain for transparency). both the lineups for acid angel from asia and +krystal eyes (the next sub unit) were voted on by fans. every member who had been revealed was included in this voting process, which we expect will be the case forever. fans are given an idea of what the concepts/songs are going to look and sound like and voting is done from there. so it is a controlled voting system where all members are included, and fans are given an idea of what their album rollouts are going to look like for the coming months because the concepts are already somewhat decided.
"disbandment" is an incorrect way to frame the promotions of these subunits ending. no one uses that language for when an nct u subunit finishes promoting. the DEFAULT for this group is NOT repeating lineups. the company later stated that if a unit is able to reach 100k album sales, they will be maintained, but this is an exception vs an expectation. neither the members nor the fans were expecting the lineups to be maintained AT ALL going in, so this is a goal for when they're more established rather than being immediate. simply a motivating goal post for the future, nothing more.
the members have DAILY youtube content called signal which is filmed and uploaded on the same day. the whole process of the members being revealed, concepts and voting being explained, and their daily activities are documented there. i highly recommend watching "Gonna Debut With You | tripleS 트리플에스 : SIGNAL 220916" where the voting process, 100k future goal, and first two subunits are explained to the members.
in conclusion, all members will be active, just not at the same time. there is no disbandment, just regrouping for the next round of albums/concepts/voting. i personally believe this system allows the members to have more work life balance because their promotions will be staggered throughout the year, and they know ahead of time what formation they'll be apart of. the krystal eyes members spent the time generation was being promoted by the AAA members to finish their exams and other school commitments, and vice versa will be possible for the AAA members when krystal eyes starts promoting. it's a rare system in kpop that allows the young people involved to have a life outside of their work.
Your the Man
This should be a top comment
Exception rather than expectation. I think you framed it perfectly!
PD seriously needs to pin this comment it explains tripleS’ concept so well
@@ampr98 unfortunately people prefer reading clickbait poor journalism rather than real information.
1:44 "10/10 immediately"
this is so me haha
The B Sides on this album are so good too. I hope this group and Fifty Fifty get more attention.
I love Fifty Fifty so far I really hope they don’t fall into NUGUdom (their 4 songs are great!)
Yes! I hope fifty fifty gets the attention they deserve too!!
LOVIN ME BY FIFTY FIFTY IS ON REPEAT CONSTANTLY
You're so based for liking Fifty Fifty and having an Emil profile photo.
YESSSS!!! Glad to see fellow Fifty Fifty appreciators.
The girl who has a husky lower voice and the one who sings at the start is BIBI's sister Nakyoung!
She's really great and I think it's on their genes. They're so talented!
WHAT BIBIS SISTER
Nakyoung is my bias, alongside Hyerin and Yubin... Acid Angel has them 3... And I'm in heaven lol
BIBI'S SISTER!? OH heck yeah she's gonna kill it.
its literally just an incredible song + debut, I want it coursing through my bloodstream immediately
Reaction fifty fifty please 😢
Acid Angels from Asia is such an amazing group name! I listened to their song because one of the members in this sub unit is Bibi's sister!
True the name is weird but cool
I really loved this debut from tripleS AAA, and it's interesting how both them and NewJeans can approach the same topic yet in completely different ways. 'Generation' focuses upon the restrictions placed upon the youth in Eastern society, with the members only able to express themselves freely (expressed by their dancing) away from the public eye until they're forced to return to acting 'normal', gradually building up through the MV to the point in which they can break free and no longer care about what everyone else around them thinks. It's a complete parallel to NewJeans, that focuses moreso on the existing freedom present in the West, and living your best life.
That's why I once said if they can have a versus or exchange stage, that would be lit. May also starts a big fanwar, but these two are giving off similar vibes but are also different at the same time. Sadly the unit just dissolved right away.
@@greeng6914 Yeah, people are naturally going to draw comparisons between the two, but LOONA was telling a story that's quite mystical and almost removed from reality (excl. 1/3, but even they introduced an android straight away!), whereas it feels more about telling the story of everyday lives here
@@greeng6914 Oh definitely! LOONAs early group work is just completely unmatched sonically, but both the last album (ACCESS) and this one show potential, and I'm really excited for where it's going from here
Sweetie it's not that deep lmao. Asians don't exist simply to be a parallel reality to the west. Shush
your favorite debut EVER!? i am glad we agree
Roxette had this thing "don't bore us, get to the chorus"
tripleS is like "fine, what if the song was like 90% chorus then"
As much as I'm sad that Jaden Jeong left BBC and LOONA, it seems he's doing a great job with this new group! This feels so different and alternative in the k-pop scene
@@calebbb_c ...how did he borderline abuse them and set them up for failure? Didn't he create their entire concept?
@@calebbb_c jinsoul said herself either on fab or a fan call that her scalp never hurt from getting bleached so idk where orbits got that whole thing from. tbh i think some of what you said was jaden’s influence but he was just their creative director, it wasn’t his group to run, at the end of the day loona’s poor promotion (which still hasn’t gotten better btw) is bbc’s fault. especially the diet thing, again not sure where orbits got that, maybe the post of him poking fun at catching yves buying snacks, which i do agree was rude. but at the end of the day that is also up to bbc
@@legalizemarinarawhy you kissing ass. where did you say you get the info that Jinsoul never said it hurted her? i'm a predebut Orbit and one thing i can assure you Jinsoul DID say it was painful, she said it multiple times during fansigns to fans too... 2 and a half years of constant bleach ain't no way that's not painful. also did you know Jaden deleted A WHOLE ALBUM? A WHOLE UNRELEASED ALBUM? put yyxy and especially CHUU ON STRICT DIET? don't kiss ass now. he ain't taking you in as a trainee
FUCK JADEN JEONG! RELEASE THE MAISON
@@calebbb_c dont worry, hes no longer under bbc management so now he can do what he really wants to do. members get paid straight to their pockets, have cards to use whenever they want food and everything. so far so good with triples members.
I believe ADORA provided background vocals for this
Yes, she did
PD needs to react to ADORA, her solo stuff is great!
@@DasVERMiT omg definitely
i love adora she has contributed so much but is so underrated 😢
Yup!
BIBI's sister in this sub-unit
This debut is literally such a 10. Even though I’m sad that this subunit has be dissolved I’m really excited to see what the future subunits will do!!!
Well each comeback is supposed to be a different unit right ?
@@spencerhowland6446 preferably, yes + 1 all member comeback
@@juzloopz24 It's a bit challenging to do even a single 24 member song, however JJ must have _something_ planned for it if he decides to attempt it.
Still, that doesn't matter much if the songwriter, composer and producer can't pull it off. 6 minutes bare minimum.
one of the best "La-la la-la la-la" ever like IT'S SO ADDICTING
Watching 'SIGNAL' series on their channel is so fun for better understanding tripleS grouping system. it's a daily reality content episode from Yoon Seoyeon(S1) appear as first member until for now the latest girl Kaede(S9) and it's still going until upcoming member S24.
The content is so fun because they are really don't know who each S's is, so for some S's it is their first time to meet the new S's that coming in 2-4weeks(gap each S's appear/introduce) and before they're appear the company will release a teaser for new S's.
it's loona predebut on crack lmaoo
I love the relative simplicity of the song and choreo. It’s all so satisfying to the senses.
I was blown away by this song and the whole debut ep.
We're all agree that this is an SSS tier debut!
This was also my favorite debut in the last 20 years of Kpop. Ima buy an album just because I liked it so much.
I AM OBSESSED WITH THIS SONG RN, IM SO GLAD YOURE REACTING TO IT AAAAAAAAA
generation is so well constructed, that song don't need a second verse nor bridge but still the flow is crazy
This song just keeps the intensity ON. IT NEVER LETS US OFF THE HOOK. I love it. Definitely one of the best songs I've heard this year.
The song, the sub-unit, the premise of all the future combinations totally slaps.. this song (possibly) is my favourite style of sound this year. Its very fresh, new, current and youthful.
Some amazing rookies coming out with great sounds also include Fifty Fifty. Their "The Fifty" mini album has 4 absolute classic songs on it.
Thanks for reminding me I need to check out the rest of the album
I really think this group could be huge, the sub unit concept is so cool
PD trying to understand the song structure on the first listening was a hilarious throwback look at my own first listening 😂😂
the way he mentioned old loona without even knowing who was behind it sends me lollll
Oh and BIBI's sister is in this sub-unit. It's the girl with bangs. Her name is Nakyoung
For the people who need help knowing who is who
The girl on the thumbnail is Yooyeon who placed 8th on MTG just barely missing the lineup for Class;y she was the 5th member introduced and is currently the oldest
The one with the bangs is Nakyoung she's BIBI's younger sister and a former p-nation trainee she was the 7th member introduced
The one with the heart buns is Yubin she was on the youth cooking show I am chef and was the 8th member introduced
And the one wearing the beanie is Heyrin who is also a former p-nation trainee she was the 2nd member introduced and her introduction teaser included the demo of Dimension
The four girls in the elevator at the end from left to right are Jiwoo, Soomin, Seoyeon, and Chaeyeon they are the other current subunit
+(Kr)ystal eyes
Seoyeon had no previous training and was the first member introduced
Chaeyeon is a former member of Busters and was the 4th member introduced
Jiwoo was also a contestant on MTG and was previously an actress and youth ice hockey player before being on MTG and was the 3rd member introduced
Soomin is also new to the industry but had previous training and was the 6th member introduced she is also currently the youngest
And the lower husky voice is Yooyeon
Basically this it’s a 24 girls group from ModHaus the CEO of this company is Jaden Jong. This group concept it’s around Units, solos and ecc like music career to entertainment career a lot of the members have different backgrounds in music, entertainment and acting. They been introducing the girls 1 by 1 and now they 9.
i LOVE your idea that one of the biggest things that makes kpop music different from other genres is the goal to make every part of the song HIT. you can get something different from the different format-like pulling back in the verses allows for a more serious emotional beat, and makes the chorus stand out-but its easy to see why so many people never go back once they’ve gotten used to the overstimulation of kpop haha
In my opinion, New Jeans kinda opened a new wave in K-pop scene. I wanted to see more groups like them and am so happy to see TripleS.
But i have seen many acid angel ... ‘s fans said when their idol released this song, that the song recorded and the concept was a long time before the newjeans trend
@@tikasjssID Any fans of any group always argue some topic in their own opinions- and I am not so interested in those kinds of topics. I just hope this trend by these groups can become a main stream in Korea. Hope they can grow together. Thanks.
@@wincup Too late to point this out, but tripleS already dissolved this subunit to make room for new subunits involving these members.
The chance for a comeback was under the condition that the mini reached 100k sales, which it failed to do. Future subunits will be held to the same standard but the members will stay to mix and match at fans' will.
@@nodezsh Oh...too bad... Thank you for the update!
the ceo, creative director and producer of TripleS is Jaden Jeong, who’s behind OnlyOneOf’s concepts and music since their debut, if you listen to their music you’ll notice that he’s been pushing this sound and visual for a couple of years, and if you enjoyed AAA’s debut you’ll probably like Onlyoneof’s discography as well. It’s probably a coincidence that New Jeans debuted with a similar “genre” not long before, or maybe it was the perfect time for it to get popular
i really love this debut so much!! and all their bsides are incredible, especially rolex and charla. i've been replaying the whole album for a month now.
these girls are so pretty and talented i hope they get to shine again in other subunits soon
Best GG debut this year (Billlie was '21, right?)! Fresh, lovely voices, great groove, appropriate for their ages, not male-gaze, they're fabulous! I know this unit's already disbanded, but I super super hope they get a chance to do more songs together as part of the overall group. Also, Bibi's little sister! This is also my favorite GG debut besides Billlie and Aespa.
Z
I'm sure some subunit will have male-gaze eventually.
It is not always a bad thing to sexualize the members of a K-Pop group; that depends entirely on the concept of the group and the song.
But here it was not needed. Doesn't mean it won't happen in the future, though.
"appropriate for their age, not male-gaze" Don't jinx it.... You kinda did already though. 😂
@@zzerutan Male gaze is fine; women do often (read: not always nor the majority) try to appeal to men as part of their identity and sexuality, and I don't think we should erase that.
The first problem comes at the split where young ends and mature begins. People can't decide where the line is.
The second problem comes with the excessive objectification of an idol's body. Some artists will be pushed to do it all the time.
This MV didn't get close to any of these topics. It was all music and TikTok. That's fine by me.
And you also have to take into account this is led by the same man who brought us Kiss Later. (Though admittedly she was extremely young back then.)
YAY PD finally got to hear this awesome song! glad they enjoyed it and hope they love the whole album too
i was like
"yo pd, why did you make me wait? why did *you* wait? didn't anyone tell you to hurry for all our sakes"
regardless of everything i'm very glad they got there and i had fun.
TripleS is a 24 member girl group and this is just a sub-unit that just debuted so technically they are not officially debuting as a "group" and the audition for this girl group is still ongoing!
Late to the party, but you know what this song does? it let's a musical idea breath. And thats rare in (K-)Pop.
AAA is so underrated and I wished they had more success.
This is like my favorite reaction to not only this song but to any song ever.
It just captures my love, reaction and appreciation for this song so well.
I just love it so much.
I feel like at the end of the year, you should do an end-of-year award show type of thing, where you give tell us your fav mv from a boy/girl group, best/fav mv or something cause i would watch
couple of fun facts abt the group:
1. jaden jeong is the A&R behind the group, hence the early LOONA influence
2. LOONA/NCT type debut. This group is planning to have like 24 members i think and theyre debuting indivudally through subunits, what you saw in the end were the next 4 girls from a different sub unit
3. these units will not have a comeback until they hit a particular album sale threshold (if im not wrong)
4. ADORA worked on the background vocals for the song
5. Bibi's younger sister is in the AAA subunit (the one that you reacted to)
6. Yooyeon ranked 8th place in My Teenage Girl, missing her debut in Class:y by one spot
Oh yea 1 question, who's the one who does the high note tho? i can't see anyone doing it on their line distribution
@@sitinorhaleezaarmanshah7803 probably adora
I really enjoyed more this debut than any other this year. This song is catchy and the dance is good. I really hope to see more the girls.
To put it simply they are a subunit of a bigger group (kinda like NCT) the company dissolves the unit if they dont meet the set goal BUT THE GROUP WILL STILL BE ACTIVE, they rotate groups as comebacks and promote them as sub units as well (afaik).
"10 out if 10!!! Immediately!!!" - PD
All of us can relate 😁
I didn't notice the song structure until i watched it again with you now..
the reason its so LOONA similar is because Jaden Jeong is this groups main creative director, who left Loonas company after Butterfly Era due to creative differences. Which is why there's also a lot of similarities such as AAA & YYXY , or the song "Rolex" on the EP which was originally recorded by LOONA
Lol who are you to say Rolex was recorded by loona? Lmao
@@enixcheen5192 the KCA says it LMAO it was OFFICIALLY registered under loons name originally , and then given to TripleS. its common in the industry, calm down.
Thank you for reacting to acid angel 🤗💖
I was waiting for this reaction!!!
Thank you PD
The reaction I've been waiting for. Tysm PD 😌
5:50 yes you are right, this low voice is recognizable in the works of Jaden Jeong - former creative ceo of LOONA
This is literally New Jeans all over again.. Im living for it.
been waiting for 3 weeks in hopes of a reaction to this debut and I got it, thank you PD! visually and vocally they served it up on this song 🤩🤩🤩
I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS SONG and I was waiting for PD s reactionnnn, thank youuuu
we were waiting for this!!
I'm so happy that you enjoy this I recommended this song a while ago
I've been waiting for you to react to this for so long, and I'm glad you enjoyed it as much as I did 😊
Thank you so much PD for reacting! Been waiting for this for so long and your reaction didn't disappoint 😆 Generation is a totally amazing debut can't wait for what's in store for the next subunit!
I was waiting for thattt!! Thank you PD nim for the reaction!!😊
was waiting for this reaction for a while!!! and it did not dissapoint
Haven’t been able to put this song down since I first watched the music video and performance video. It’ll definitely be on my top played songs of the year. Seriously wonderful and genius and the dance is so addicting to watch. I’m so excited for them.
been waiting for this a long timeeee good to see PD reacting to one of the best debuts of all time
i heard about this huge rotating group thing a while ago but didn't see it until it came up as a youtube ad. so i watched it and loved it. didn't realize they were getting bigger and more well known so im glad! hopefully this tripleS thing goes far
Generation is a song you can put on repeat that never come to an end
What actually happened is the sub-unit Acid Angel From Asia (Triple S AAA) had a goal of selling 100,000 albums for this debut EP and that goal was not met, with the unit selling only 20,000 copies of the album “Access”, that's why the sub-unit was disbanded.
It only means that this specific formation for Acid Angel From Asia will no longer exist in the TripleS universe, but the girls will remain part of the group and will participate in future projects and sub-units with other girls in the group. This is part of the concept of TripleS, which is a group "shaped by the fans" and being adjusted as they receive support and grow in popularity. The girls walk around in different concepts and the fanbase decides who fits best in what.
Acid angel from asia can comeback in the future if the fans voted them together! Also the 100k sales is just a opportunity for them since the group will have a rotating units
The 100k sales was never an expectation from their company. It was just an exemption for the units to become permanent when they reach the 100k mark
I was waiting for your reaction to this group! I'm very happy that you like it, the girls are very cute and fun!
Great video K study! TripleS and New Jeans are my new young obsessions. Gotta love the youth.
Such a good analysis and you also verbally said what I was thinking about difference between Kpop and Western pop. I love them crossing and breaking boundaries specially when it results in such a fucking good song!
12:40 "there''s only 4 of them? no there's 4 more of them" PD there's 20 more of them 🤣🤣
BIBI little sister is here!
Also please watch BIBI's new MVs it will BLOW your mind! The production is chef kiss 🔥
i was waiting for your reaction!!!
they didn't disband. it's sub-unit and fans can choose or vote members for the next sub-unit so guys please hold all your DISBANDMENT TRAUMA. they're not iz*one or gfriend. calm down y'all
Its those people who are misinformed who keeps spreading this disbandment bullpoop
@@meimeivaj8334 well of course goal on purpose was unrealistic because they want to experiment more with changing units :) but I think on concerts they will perform again
@@meimeivaj8334 triple S is a group after all and that was subunit what is almost always temporary also in other groups
@@meimeivaj8334 who confirmed it??? Their concept is literally rotating subunit... that 100k wasnt suppose to be met for now... and yes they will still be in other subunit rotatating fan placed members...
@@meimeivaj8334 You really need to research about how the group works. Selling 100k is never the goal. The whole concept of the group are subunits that have rotating members. Regardless if they sell 100k or not they will still be split up into other subunits. The "permanent" subunit will be able to comeback in the future but it doesn't mean that they won't be paired with other girls anymore.
I'm so happy you checked this out, PD! I was a bit "concerned" you wouldn't get to it since it has been a few weeks since they debuted-I was honestly hoping you'd watch the MV since I had a feeling it'd be right up your alley. It's my favorite debut of this year (for both GGs and BGs), and the EP is so dope (Charla is probably one of my favorite b-sides EVER). I'm really excited for what's in store with +(KR)ystal Eyes if +(82) is anything to go by. tripleS as a whole is a group that I'm definitely keeping on my radar. So glad you enjoyed it, and I hope you react to the upcoming sub-units as well
loved this reaction ❤
Been waiting for so long for this
I've been waiting for this song's reaction!
Modhaus the company responsible of them is backed by some very big sponsors which explains the large budget in production and the mv. It’s also very apparent in their daily signals in which they all have meal cards and luxurious houses.
It was an incredible debut !! I can't wait for the next sub unit of TripleS
I think they were 24 members. Did you know Yooyeon(the girl in black vest) almost debuted with class:y she was a fan favorite if not with the ridiculous final challenge bonus pts like 40% of the individual votes and more with the other finalists which is miscalculated imo. Jiwoo the tall girl in the end is also a finalist if i remember correctly.
Glad she didn’t debut with classsy
Jiwoo sadly isn't a finalist, she was eliminated before the final 🥲 but anyway so happy both of them ended up in tripleS hahaha
Thanks again from great professional insights. Song and MV, amazing groovy masterpiece.
This song gets better the more u hear
TripleS new mv rising is out…. I think you’ll like it.
I love pd's facial reactions so much. They're always so good haha
I knew you'd love it, the dance is awesome it's going to be legendary
oh ive been waiting for this 😁
I was waiting for you to react to this because I just knew you'd love it when I first heard it 😂
one of the idols in this group yooyeon was in a survival show called mtg which formed class:y
Watching this again can’t wait for there next song😭😭❤️
I WAS WAITING FOR YOU HUHUHUHUH
This song is so amazing!! Can't wait for what Triple S is going to have further!!! It's nostalgic and listening to this song is so easy to vibe to it!!
Ohh I was waiting for this reaction
the melody and the one verse!!??!?!!?! i fell in love immediately!!!
loved your reaction! 9 members have been revealed so far. the first 8 were voted into the first 2 units. The 4 girls in the elevator at the end are the next subunit krystal eyes. and the 9th member kaede will participate in a future voting to see which unit she will be in when more members are revealed.
they are one of the subunits of tripleS. they are acid angel from asia. the girls at the end are (KR)ystal Eyes. they are completely different girls. fans got to choose the subunits for the members. KE will debut later. they are still new member reveals. it’s kinda like NCT / japanese groups that use this kinda formation style. I LITERALLY HAD THE SAME REACTION AS YOU WHEN I HEARD THEIR DEBUT!
Ive been waiting this
I knew you would like their debut 😂❣️
I BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
I love this new vibe that the newer gen of kpop has been trying, I know not ALL 4th gen kpop grps do this but I rly dig it
It’s definitely more learning towards western kinda vibes but that’s ok I think it’s great
I think this is the start of the 5th gen era. Their vibes doesn't scream 4th gen AT ALL and I'm absolutely here for it!
I loved it, insta bought the albums (bummed i didnt get pre-order bonus)
Started watching their youtube channel, they upload daily: vlogs, bts and such.
And revealing new members each month, debuting in sub-units (I think that that sub-unit becomes a group if they sell 100.000 albums in that comeback/debut)
Can't wait to see all 24 members and participate in the votes.
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS REACTION. 😭🤣BEST REACTION BY FAR. I haven't been getting too into girl groups lately and then this came and caught my absolute attention