jazakAllah for clarifiying this issue, i've been memorizing the Quran and suddenly to know that you CAN'T "absolutely" recite the Quran. and i didn't know the second opinion exists, as it was impossible for me to stay away from reciting it even for a single day.
These opinions exist because of the evils of analogy and following other than the Quran and Sunnah. However, "ustadhah" Maryam Amir is of the same methodology as the scholars who supported the first opinion, meaning that her efforts and intentions aren't sincere for salvation or spreading the truth, just pushing an agenda by going against the majority. Specifically, the agenda of modernizing Islam.
Also, it's worth mentioning taking the Rukhsa from the Maliki school to touch a mushaf and recite for the intention of study if you're a teacher/student of knowledge.
the Nabi saw was so comforting to his wives during their period nowadays people are so harsh for women with periods Aisha reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said to me, “Bring me a mat from the mosque.” I said, “I am menstruating.” The Prophet said, “Your menses are not in your hand.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 298 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim
For me personally, the biggest evidence that reciting Quran isn't prohibited during menses is the hadith where the Prophet pbuh says that a woman is deficient in her religion bcoz she can't pray and fast during menses. He didn't say that women can't recite Quran during menses. And recitation is a huge part of our worship. If such a thing was to be prohibited, there would be clear commands about it.
JazaakiAllahu khayra dear shaykha Maryam, thank you so much for this, it's succinct and so, so helpful!! Allahumma baarik!! May Allah bless and reward you and your family and grant you all jannat ul firdaus. Ameeeeen ya Rabb ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Alhamdulliah for the mercy of Allah and being rewarded for the intention, whether you do something or not. SubhanAllah. Thank you for this type of content. Very helpful, Informative and to the point. Please do more videos like this, Sister Maryam. Topics specific to a womans experience. Along this same topic, could you clarify whether or not sisters can attend the masjid on their periods? I read eid is ok, right? For example, could she be in the musalla to attend a lecture or class or even jummuah? Jazaku'Allah khairun and thanks in advance for responding to this comment. Should you not have the time to respond, may Allah reward you for the intention!😊
Ameen to your kind dua! As with this video, it's a difference of opinion amongst scholars on whether or not it's permissible :) most scholars hold it is not, minority of scholars point to the lack of explicit evidence to say it is allowed in addition to the fact that some women did clean/live in the masjid at times and they clearly would have been in menses and yet were not asked to leave during those circumstances. may Allah guide you to what is best!
💖💖💖jee Deedi Aslamalyqum thunkyou so much very good very happy very nice thunkyou 💕 Allah apna haffz Aamaan man Rakha Aameeeeeeeeeeeen ❤Allha ❤Haffaz ❤jee Deedi Aslamalyqum good morning ❤
I simply wouldn't do it. If I'm menstruating, I can listen to it, but it's best if I don't recite it. That makes it easier to avoid confusion. I would not touch it, either. If this is the correct view, I believe Allah's infinite wisdom as to why this ruling in place. XOXO
@@fn4935 I would not do it. The reason given is because during Quran recitation, one must have valid wudu... if you do not, you cannot. However, menstruation is a major state of impurity, so, how can one perform wudu if they wanted to? They can't, which is why they can't.
@@shimmer4771 with all due respect, that is not true. You do not need do have wudhu to read Quran. Touching the Mus’haf requires wudhu however recitation is fine. May Allah guide us to the straight path and grant is firduas Ameen
@@shimmer4771 reciting is allowed. I don’t think there is any evidence from Quran and hadith that says recitation of Wuran is not allowed if once doesn’t have wudhu.
Islam brought many guidelines to protect society from fitan (tribulation and temptation) and moral decline. Undoubtedly women's going out of their homes and mixing with men and speaking softly to them whilst wearing their finest adornments are all among the greatest causes of fitan. Concerning this the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "I have not left behind me any fitnah more harmful to men than women." Narrated by al-Bukhaari (5096). And the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "Beware of this world and beware of women, for the first fitnah (trial) among the Children of Israel had to do with women." Narrated byMuslim (2742). -Copied
Asalamualaykum wrb.What is Sister Maryam said is not entirely true.Most fuquhas said no recitation of Quran in menses or state of Janaba.This is the case unless the person is teacher of Quran needs to teach due to work or the person is taking exam cannot be adjusted to her fee menses days.As the lady is impure cannot pray or fast or go to place of prayer . Doa is different from Quran one can make anytime.Also the lady in menses can touch Quran not total Arabic w translation.Can cross mosque to pick Quran but covered w cloth. Also those w menses the longest period is 15 days after that considered istihadhah can pray fast hold recite Quran. One needs to know properly the Jurists before deciding the fatwa whether majority or only one.Its better the majority though its allowed on one Fuquha only.Mariam needs to refer Fiqh Sunnah book by Sayid Sabiq and Fiqh for Women by Nurhana Ibrahim and Fahmi Mahmoud PhD.
Your position is wrong. Fiqh as Sunnah is unreliable. She is quoting sunni ulemas with the schools of fiqh which comprise of thousand upon thousands of scholar whom have research the issue with all the main proofs going back to the source. We are not abandoning the majority for fiqh Sunnah that is simply intellectual suicide. There is ikhtilaf so you can follow one or the other. No need to argue about an issue that has been decided for centuries.
@@fn4935 When Imam Malik says so ??...plse check.Many Muslims supposed to be teachers of Islam or Dakwah guys in the west are quoting Imam Malik wrongly abt many issues.May Allah punish them as Imam Malik RAH sticks to the truth was tortured incessantly by the Khalifah for not changing his fatwa according to what the Khalfahs suffered in prison and urine incontinence due to damage to bladder caused by non stop beatings enforced by the zalim Khalifah.Allahualam.
Assalaamu alaikum, during periods take rest. Do some good deeds. I don't recite Quran, I won't touch Quran and I don't do namaz. What's wrong with these woke culture Muslims. Take s rest ladies. These you tubers are so annoying and find happiness in confusing people.
jazakAllah for clarifiying this issue, i've been memorizing the Quran and suddenly to know that you CAN'T "absolutely" recite the Quran. and i didn't know the second opinion exists, as it was impossible for me to stay away from reciting it even for a single day.
These opinions exist because of the evils of analogy and following other than the Quran and Sunnah. However, "ustadhah" Maryam Amir is of the same methodology as the scholars who supported the first opinion, meaning that her efforts and intentions aren't sincere for salvation or spreading the truth, just pushing an agenda by going against the majority. Specifically, the agenda of modernizing Islam.
That's must be the best solution. Second solution don't exist!!
Don't touch the book and don't pray the Salah in your period.
Shes not talking about touching the mushaf or praying.@@coolyellowtransport5147
There are different of opinions, I follow the one in which you can recite it as long as you are holding it with a piece of cloth 👍🏼
Wow! Such a concise, brilliant, comprehensive and thoughtful answer!!! ❤❤❤❤
What's wow...she hardly knows the basics abt Islam.Check facts please.
@@nurhanaibrahim162 I have from multiple traditional sources. Alhamdulillah! She checks out. 💯
Also, it's worth mentioning taking the Rukhsa from the Maliki school to touch a mushaf and recite for the intention of study if you're a teacher/student of knowledge.
May Allah bless you and reward you for your blessed efforts
the Nabi saw was so comforting to his wives during their period nowadays people are so harsh for women with periods Aisha reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said to me, “Bring me a mat from the mosque.” I said, “I am menstruating.” The Prophet said, “Your menses are not in your hand.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 298
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim
For me personally, the biggest evidence that reciting Quran isn't prohibited during menses is the hadith where the Prophet pbuh says that a woman is deficient in her religion bcoz she can't pray and fast during menses. He didn't say that women can't recite Quran during menses. And recitation is a huge part of our worship. If such a thing was to be prohibited, there would be clear commands about it.
JazaakiAllahu khayra dear shaykha Maryam, thank you so much for this, it's succinct and so, so helpful!! Allahumma baarik!! May Allah bless and reward you and your family and grant you all jannat ul firdaus. Ameeeeen ya Rabb ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
We are enjoying our Ramadan!Thank you.
May Allah bless you dear sister! Amen
U explained that very good
I knew that you study Quran but this is the first time that I know that you also study fiqh 👑
Alhamdulliah for the mercy of Allah and being rewarded for the intention, whether you do something or not. SubhanAllah.
Thank you for this type of content. Very helpful, Informative and to the point. Please do more videos like this, Sister Maryam. Topics specific to a womans experience. Along this same topic, could you clarify whether or not sisters can attend the masjid on their periods? I read eid is ok, right? For example, could she be in the musalla to attend a lecture or class or even jummuah?
Jazaku'Allah khairun and thanks in advance for responding to this comment. Should you not have the time to respond, may Allah reward you for the intention!😊
Ameen to your kind dua! As with this video, it's a difference of opinion amongst scholars on whether or not it's permissible :) most scholars hold it is not, minority of scholars point to the lack of explicit evidence to say it is allowed in addition to the fact that some women did clean/live in the masjid at times and they clearly would have been in menses and yet were not asked to leave during those circumstances. may Allah guide you to what is best!
Thank you so much for this!
Alhamduliallah ❤❤
Assalamualaikum. UR knowledge is appreciable.
اسلام علیکم 🇵🇰🇯🇴
by recitation do you mean reading Quran from a Quranic App with Arabic Text? So is it permissible?
Yes but touch the Quran with a cloth! Not with your hands because you wouldn't be in wuzu
💖💖💖jee Deedi Aslamalyqum thunkyou so much very good very happy very nice thunkyou 💕 Allah apna haffz Aamaan man Rakha Aameeeeeeeeeeeen ❤Allha ❤Haffaz ❤jee Deedi Aslamalyqum good morning ❤
Masha Allah
Can I read my Athkar? Like the three Quls and Dua.
Yup 😊
❤❤❤❤❤
Assalamualaikum, dari mana kamu berasal?
Is she saying you can recite the quran it means you can touch it?
Can a women go to the mosque while on her period?
yes but do not pray
I simply wouldn't do it. If I'm menstruating, I can listen to it, but it's best if I don't recite it. That makes it easier to avoid confusion. I would not touch it, either. If this is the correct view, I believe Allah's infinite wisdom as to why this ruling in place. XOXO
For women who memorise Quran, it will be more difficult for them.
Following either opinion is fine as there is evidence on both sides.
@@fn4935 I would not do it. The reason given is because during Quran recitation, one must have valid wudu... if you do not, you cannot. However, menstruation is a major state of impurity, so, how can one perform wudu if they wanted to? They can't, which is why they can't.
@@shimmer4771 with all due respect, that is not true. You do not need do have wudhu to read Quran. Touching the Mus’haf requires wudhu however recitation is fine. May Allah guide us to the straight path and grant is firduas Ameen
@@fn4935 I said recite, not read.
@@shimmer4771 reciting is allowed. I don’t think there is any evidence from Quran and hadith that says recitation of Wuran is not allowed if once doesn’t have wudhu.
How are you sister
Finally welcome to critical thinking on the domination of male scholarship in Islam.
No she's not talking about "male scholarship" she's talking about fiqh and madhahib with knowledge & understanding not with whims & desires
Love you
Islam brought many guidelines to protect society from fitan (tribulation and temptation) and moral decline. Undoubtedly women's going out of their homes and mixing with men and speaking softly to them whilst wearing their finest adornments are all among the greatest causes of fitan. Concerning this the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "I have not left behind me any fitnah more harmful to men than women." Narrated by al-Bukhaari (5096). And the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "Beware of this world and beware of women, for the first fitnah (trial) among the Children of Israel had to do with women." Narrated byMuslim (2742). -Copied
Asalamualaykum wrb.What is Sister Maryam said is not entirely true.Most fuquhas said no recitation of Quran in menses or state of Janaba.This is the case unless the person is teacher of Quran needs to teach due to work or the person is taking exam cannot be adjusted to her fee menses days.As the lady is impure cannot pray or fast or go to place of prayer . Doa is different from Quran one can make anytime.Also the lady in menses can touch Quran not total Arabic w translation.Can cross mosque to pick Quran but covered w cloth. Also those w menses the longest period is 15 days after that considered istihadhah can pray fast hold recite Quran.
One needs to know properly the Jurists before deciding the fatwa whether majority or only one.Its better the majority though its allowed on one Fuquha only.Mariam needs to refer Fiqh Sunnah book by Sayid Sabiq and Fiqh for Women by Nurhana Ibrahim and Fahmi Mahmoud PhD.
Your position is wrong. Fiqh as Sunnah is unreliable. She is quoting sunni ulemas with the schools of fiqh which comprise of thousand upon thousands of scholar whom have research the issue with all the main proofs going back to the source. We are not abandoning the majority for fiqh Sunnah that is simply intellectual suicide. There is ikhtilaf so you can follow one or the other. No need to argue about an issue that has been decided for centuries.
This is the opinion of imam Mailik (Rahimullah) if I’m not mistaken.
Following either imam is fine
@@fn4935 When Imam Malik says so ??...plse check.Many Muslims supposed to be teachers of Islam or Dakwah guys in the west are quoting Imam Malik wrongly abt many issues.May Allah punish them as Imam Malik RAH sticks to the truth was tortured incessantly by the Khalifah for not changing his fatwa according to what the Khalfahs suffered in prison and urine incontinence due to damage to bladder caused by non stop beatings enforced by the zalim Khalifah.Allahualam.
Assalaamu alaikum, during periods take rest. Do some good deeds. I don't recite Quran, I won't touch Quran and I don't do namaz. What's wrong with these woke culture Muslims. Take s rest ladies. These you tubers are so annoying and find happiness in confusing people.
There's literally nothing "woke" about this. It's just an analysis of the rulings of different madhaahib.
You need to stop taking rests and learn your religion instead of being a jaahil and writing jaahil comments
She literally mentioned the greatest scholars in our history saying it is permissible and you come and make this about being "woke"