Hats off to Mr. Munir for his incredibly balanced, pragmatic, mature, clear, focused and extremely well informed perspectives. Impressive indeed. Wishing well for Bangladesh.
I am an Indian currently in Bangladesh and stayed in whole revolution time. Whatever the facts presented here are totally true ,there is no doubt. Indians most media shows this topic as islamophobic lens.
@@StayAlertfrom786 About communal attacks and responsible group which overthrown the govt. Whatever points justified by Bangladeshi representer are true.
Bangladesh was a gift to ppl of east Pakistan from India! Minorities in Bangladesh m their protection is responsibility of India according to partition clause! If Hindus are attacked, Indian army will enter n rescue them!
@@sarsau Bangladesh was not a gift from anyone!!! Bangladeshi (former East Pakistan which was formed due to partition of British India in 1947) fight with west Pakistan 9 long month, more then 3000000 people sacrificed their lives ! Yes India supported Bangladesh by taking refugees back then and joining the war at the 3rd December 1971 after Pakistan launched preemptive air strikes on northern India, and Bangladesh gained victory 16th December 1971. I am as a Bangladeshi, very grateful for that and always will be. But before you talk hatefully and try to create religious disruption in Bangladesh, I suggest you should learn history first! Not only just hearing from some one but with proper research (about Bangladesh liberation) , and witnessing what’s going on in Bangladesh right now by your own eyes !!!!
@@MituHossain-s4m Yeah we're responsible, for creating religious disruption, in Bangaldesh, and not Hadiths. 😂 And we're also responsible, for reduced percentages of minorities, in Bangladesh. 🤷😅😂 I understand, you might come up with an excuse, of Indian Media being Islamophobic, what about western media though? BBC, Reuters, etc?
At last one refreshing and thoughtful voice from Bangladesh that captures the essence of peaceful and purposeful coexistence. Yes, aggressive rhetorics, cinicysm and conspiracy theories don't heal wounds. Lampoons are there in every society who profess and act on fundamentalist instincts based on religious dogmatism (perhaps religious pervertions) but that should never dominate any society at large. Else, the door to hell is a stone's throw away.
Exactly! Fundamentalists and extremists are everywhere. What people are doing to stop those fundamentalist goons should be one of the crucial things that matters.
We are not accountable to India for attacks on minorities but to our constitution. It is our moral responsibility to protect the minorities. Most attacks on Hindus were due to their association with the former political party in power because in that time they oppressed opposition parties. After an uprising these types of attacks are not uncommon but not expected.
Shameful utterance...if this is the ill-thought in ur mind.. then be ready for the consequences...so this is so-called religion of PEACE! Ur going to become another Afghanistan.. let's see how things evolve around.
@@rizhawk1628 modi should ensure Muslims , Sikhs and Christian’s are safe in India. He needs to sort his own country out first instead of spreading hate and attacking minority religions in India.
India or Induan media’s hyperbole of hindu oppression or for that Awami League as the protector of hindus in Bangladesh are a myth on the contrary history or records if study undertaken will prove that most of Hindu oppression happened mostly whenever Awami Look league were in power
I thought we are the smart people who living in first world country. No I am wrong and there are smarter than me who living in Bangladesh. Wow wow wow!!!! May Allah blessed Bangladesh
Bangladesh was a gift to ppl of east Pakistan from India! Minorities in Bangladesh m their protection is responsibility of India according to partition clause! If Hindus are attacked, Indian army will enter n rescue them!
@@sarsau come with your chai wala army in Bangladesh and we are ready to show you the coffee shop. Be careful build the toilet first and make sure people are not using toilet as their temple.
Excellent job!Munir!! Keep it up. We are human!! We are Bangladeshi! We love humanity, we love our neighbours and we must protect ourselves. Bangladesh is one country one family!! Bangladesh is a free country now!! We must be kind, generous, tolerant,, compassionate and be a model of true democracy. No double standards, no hypocrisy, Let’s start by showing the hard work, let’s educate ourselves and work together with every single nation in this world.
Excellent conversation! Many thanks, Karan, for your continuous efforts of crafting the real picture in this sea of misinformation. Mr. Monir was very loud and clearly described and analysed of the true picture without a single exaggeration of the facts. Would like to see more of these kinds in the coming days.
Absolutely 💯 India must ban Hasina family & her BAL party forever for their own benefits 🚫 Now they must support Bangladeshi people to regain the good relationship again ✅ Indian people should vote I N.D.I.A. alliance party to settle a good political environment in south Asia to bring proper relation with other neighbors as well 🤝🏼 Modi-BJP-RSS-Godi media are causing chaos & spreading racism in this region, because they're based on hindutva extremist ideology 👹
@@falconeagle3655 This is not only bjp policy, congress did the same thing. They gave hasina family more importance than any other political parties in Bangladesh. And that may be due to the ideology what other political parties followed towards India.
I am an Indian and support the people of Bangladesh 🎉 May Allah help you in Peace, Prosperity and Joy. Thanks to my favourite Journalist Karan for this interview with very learned fraind from Bangladesh.
Mr Shafqat Munir brings out the vindictiveness of Sheikh Hasina in the culminating part of the interview which makes him talk of reconciliation of the Bangladesh society on top of bringing Sheikh Hasina to account for excesses and crimes! It was horrendous for Bangladesh to have experienced this for the last 14 years and for India to be an accomplice, unknowingly and unwillingly while I am ready to accept the current Indian leadership to have done the same knowingly and even willingly as our leader can view such actions as acceptable part of governance! The capture of media was total as is the case in India and we in India also need to see where an autocrat goes!
@@cyke1234 Niraj, a true the wire follower. People like you can dream of creating coup against democratically elected govts. These are true autocrats anyone who has a different view are non-democratic.
@@mrinalbiswas2280 Where has one said that the change in Govt, you use the term Coup, of the kind that happened in Bangladesh is likely to happen in India? One has only talked about the shared attributes of the two leaders: Don't you see the capture of media, law & order machinery media, targeting of opposition, and emasculation of institutions here as well? You seem to have blindfolded yourself or decided to wear the glasses of ANDHBHAKTA, if you don't!
Mr. Munir was very HONEST and articulate... I do not believe that Sekh Hasina will ever be welcomed in Banladesh...Hope and pray that New Delhi and Dhaka will create a new authentic relationship..
The real question is if she wants to contest elections, will she be allowed to? What kind of a democracy is it if one party is chased away or killed before calling for 'fair' elections.
@@absdur6320 yeah sure, but that's not the question. The question was if she will be allowed to contest ? There are people in India who contested sitting in jail, and won and are still in jail.
If election was rigged why students did not agitate. Why opposition did not agitate. Hasina became PM after winning elections. If her 1st term was bad why she was elected again. Bangladeshis want India' help but they don't want hindus in Bangladesh.
@@rajeevashetty8395 Bro the ruling party almost always has total control over the police and military. Protests in Bangldesh isn't anything and has been going on for over a decades. Most people didn't join in bfr because there is a high chance of them being killed or jailed. This time everything became too big and the military refused to shoot.
I am an Indian Christian. Christians and Muslims have special minority rights. There is even quota system for Muslim students. The only issue BJP has with us is Christian missionary activity. There are three Christian-majority North East Indian states through missionary activity. As a Christian, I am totally against conversion by giving incentives to poor people. Muslims should also stop Dawa/Conversion in a pluralist country like India. If you think you only reach heaven through Jesus or by accepting Muhammed as Prophet, that in itself is a starting point of intolerance toward other faiths. Muslim clergy has to say, " Small Jihad (Employing violence) - Concentrate on Big Jihad which is inside your mind, Kafir (Unbeliever), Murdath (Ex Muslim - Death sentence) and Ummah (Muslim brotherhood - Focus on Universal brotherhood) don´t apply in a pluralistic country like India. I have a question: Can a good Hindu or a good Christian reach heaven, without accepting PM as Prophet? According to Islam - NO
Had they not been protected in the last 75 yrs their number wouldn't have trebled..... Contrary to yours... Where the% of hindus has decreased from 16% to 2%
One day, people will read about the Bangladesh Revolution in books the way they read about the French Revolution. Hats off to the brave students and people of Bangladesh.
Well done, Shafquat munir. You proved to be the right Spokesperson and voice of the August 5th revolution ! You have very aptly cleared the clutters around our hard earned revolution to an important foreign media. Keep up the good job. I am proud of you !
Great interview. Kudos to both the interviewer and the guest for keeping to the point and respecting each other’s views. Bangladesh is a nation that is 80% akin to India in terms of cultures and values. We never had any Pakistani or Afghan like mentalities and never will. Please don’t politicise this movement
That’s a joke. The only reason that you don’t have that is because neither Pakistan or Afghanistan would accept you that way. What did west Pakistan do to east Pakistan. otherwise you are more akin to Pakistan than India. hell you were Pakistan Till 1971 because you wanted separation from India. it’s all good just don’t pretend otherwise. Own up
@@mohammedmurtaza3257 We are already living in an environment marked by hatred and violence _within_ India 😅😅 I mean, watch any mainstream news channel....they spew communal hatred day and night
because it's Bangladesh internal matter.keep your nose somewhere else.perhaps reducing poverty in India.after decades of coma Bangladesh has woken up with full of energy.everyone wants to contribute to rebuilding Bangladesh now.🎉🎉🎉🎉
This chap would make an excellent spokesperson for the Interim government or any future government. Articulate, knowledgeable, composed & well spoken 👍
We know how to ensure the safety of our minorities, and we will do that definitely as we have been doing this so far. It's better if India focuses on the safety of their minorities.
No you donot. Data over the last 75 years prove that. We focus on our borders, self interest of our people which includes both minorities and majorities. You do not do that.
Islamists will hardy know the reality. The issue is Bangladesh govts other than Hasina has been encouraging terrorism in North Eastern states and harboring radical elements. India will stay on the side of humanity and also with the people who are not in constantly into radicalism and terrorism.
He is absolutely correct.I contact with my hindu friend.They are all fine.The past government of Hasina regime who are behind this minorities attack.Like modi je.
That's absolutely right! The student wing of Hasina's party was behind the attack on our Hindu brothers. The leaked Whatsapp conversation of their central committee is the prove!
Outstanding interview And discussion.. this is the best indian discussion i have seen so far.. most others are crappy and doesn't look at things objectively
Excellent, he became emotional at the end of his interview. God help rebuild Bangladesh. You did it, you are free. My prayers for Bangladeshi people. From Pakistan 💌🤟
Thank you Mr Shafqat Munir for rightly ventilating the feelings of the people of all walks of life! Now, the ball is in the court of India whether or not to make friendship with the people of Bangladesh based on equality, honour and trust!
Indian media personalities must evaluate the situation properly. Hindus or any other minorities in Bangladesh are more safe compared to the Dalits and other minorites in India.
Hasina was an autocrat ,but that autocrat was steadfastly supported by India ,India got only one friend ,that is autocrat Hasina .Jamat is wrongly portrayed in India.
Hasina was the only one who protected minorities to small extent. Without her , Bangladesh would become more radical Islamic nation. India should cut ties with bangladesh
Yes JAMAT is wrongly portrayed in India?!😮 stealing undergarments ( Bra & Blouse) & made it to be auctioned in public of a 77 years old lady ex-PM? whole world have seen it.. even Taliban of Afghanistan never did it.. So this is JAMAT.. this is so-called Student's movement?! Shame shame.. it's a dirty slap on all Bangladeshi's.
@@nafimking6529 I don't recall talking to you. First, learn manners. Second, I see loads of you talking about our internal matters. Your media stays busy with whatever is happening on this side of the border. Toder to dekhi sob kichu tei India ke dosh dite. To UA-cam e ekhon boro boro kotha na bole, ja giye nijeder desh samla. Jodi bochor dhore, India India na kore nijeder desh samlatis aj ke ei dosha hoto na. 🤫🤫🤫🤫
Rightly presented Bangladesh situation by Mr. Munir. India should not brand people secular revolution as Islamist, and this will hamper regional peace. They should avoid play game on this and not to use Bangladesh situation as so called toolkit.
I appreciate both guys having such prolific discussions and sharing with us. I am from Bangladesh, I feel proud of how Mr Munir explained the position we have now. Please, please, please, stop seeing BD contingent upon Hasina’s eyes. It would be foolhardy to keep doing it anymore. Last but not least, good questions from the other side. Keep up the good work.
Bangladesh must ensure safety of your Minorities in your country. Both are independent countries no one should used word must to another countries stand that is not acceptable by Indians at any cost. For India it is better wait and watch no investment until peace and democracy settle by Bangladeshi people.
He is speaking of Bangladesh, that is wat they are saying India must do this, India must support otherwise there will be problems for India. Threat under the guise of help.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu He edited his reply. Earlier he was talking about treating minorities right and it wasn't clear if he was talking about Bangladesh or India
The more and more we delve into the last 15 years of autocracy in BD, it is becoming clear the Modi-Hasina duo were using each other for their own personal gains, without considering the welfare of the people of their respective countries.
when will you topple your own dictatorial regime. the common people of bangladesh will always support the common people of pakistan. we are united by religion and many other factors. but we know that even you know the reason for hatred between the two nations is your military who wanted to rule our country with an iron fist and is doing the same in yours aswell.
Why is India so concerned about Hindus in Bangladesh? Bangladeshi Hindus have always lived their lives as they wish without any significant issues. Why doesn't India address how the Indian army and Hindus have demolished mosques and killed Indian Muslims within their own territory?
Bangladeshi citizens seem to be doing more to protect the minority people in their country than the Indian establishment does in its own country. In India the citizens, instead of trying to protect fellow minority citizens, would join in to attack them instead. That the sad reality of India today. So this is a bit rich coming from India. (Waiting for the right wing trolls to come and spew more hatered in the replies. Aao bhakton, aao)
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@paranoah8550 in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@adityabanerjee7145 in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
Very inciteful & touchful (towards the end). A much needed antidote to the Islamist paranoia & ignorance that is coming out of the Indian capital, media & netizens. Thank you Karan Thapar. Thank you Shafqat Munir.
I am stunned and overwhelmed by the answers given by Mr.Munir. It is completely unexplainable that the change in power or the situation that we as Bangladeshi are going through at this point of time, we want India as a neighbour must accept, apprehend and appreciate this movement as a movement led by people, to be specific the vast majority of people who were to accept oppression and threat by the Autocratic Government that we were in till the 5th August 2024.
Then why there was no one to protect you musicians Rahul Ananda and why were you able to protect the Indian culture centre in which you have burnt the whole history of your liberation war, the ISKCON temple; I am just listing a few, the list is endless. But those protection photos should win you a fake image of the year award.
We are trying to save as much as possible. If attacks were on hindus only it wouldn’t be a problem we could save everyone but attacks happening everywhere as some people did awami league their houses being burnt also by BNP JAMAT. Situation is unrest due to lack of police as people don’t have trust on police anymore. But you’re complaining about my country how much you guys saved your minorities ?… i never saw a hindu guarding our mosque during riots very rare .I agree attacks are happening but it’s not only to targeted to hindus only it’s happening everywhere. And majority people don’t support vandalism .
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu Our law enforcement force already start investigation about Rahul Ananda, Iscon temple and other attacks. Some people did this intentionally. Sometime It may not be possible to save individual quickly. You have to understand we are at post-revolutionary states. If you demand a complete law and order in this stage, it's just a day dreaming i think. However, we are trying to make everything normal ASAP. My request to your news Channels stop spreading false news. (Remember, Here no one or no party attack any temple in an organised way, like BJP attack on Babri Mosque.)
I can’t help crying. We are free! Karan is trying his best to portray the real picture in Bangladesh… Thank you Karan, our love and respect for your bold journalism ❤🙏.
So this govt that has come in now should the Indian Govt support and deal with it or should the Indian govt support and deal with each and every individual Bangladeshi people by letting them in India without a visa.
just don't be too stupid. Your 4th largest remittance comes from Bangladesh. Over 10 lakhs indian works in Bangladesh. Also huge number of Bangladeshi go to india for healthcare. You're acting in a way that they go to india for free treatment.@@AjitKumar-lo9yu
@@AjitKumar-lo9yuactually ..now is early..keep as it is for now. In future, a person who could do it is PM Modi.. Trying develop a SAARC ID where members can visit countries without a visa. Economists should work out the maths and money..
Brilliant responses by Mr. Shafqat Munir. This is absolutely grounded on the truth and should serve as a wake up call for Indian policy makers that the old hackneyed policies in establishing relationship with Bangladesh are not going to work.
When BNP was in power they pursued anti-India policies and allowed atrocities on Hindus. Sheikh Hasina reversed that, whom should we trust. He is talking as though they will be in power soon. What is the guarantee?
Speaker convsys sentiments of Bangladeshis. Mr Shjib Joy has nothing but to mischief make. He is a decrepid man, and Indian gov is very smart and should not lend its ears to a deposed corrupt regime.
Mr Thapar,your hate for Mr Modi is very clear from your statement made during the interview. As an Indian journalist you should be equally worried about what is happening with the hindus in Bangladesh. Instead you are stating that the anguish expressed by our PM about the fate of the minorities is unfounded and an over reaction. Absolutely irritating.
Y r people so bothered about minorities only in Bangladesh? Minorities are treated equally in all aspect here. What about India? The Muslims are treated like 2nd class citizens there. Nobody is talking about the perpetrator Modi.
Yes it is peoples revolution in Bangladesh against Govt and minorities including Hindus should be kept safe fully. It is the duty of people of Bangladesh and military to protect all minorities. They are also the citizens of Bangladesh.
This is a people's revolution.Indias some media & political leader trying to narrate it as the revolution of extremist which is totally bogus. India should respect the will of Bangladeshi people. India had supported a autocratic govt for last 15 years which made annoyed Bangladeshi people. It is time for India to rebuild ties with the people of Bangladesh.
You elected a govt. Indian govt had ties with the government of banngladesh. When the new government will be formed we will have ties with them too. Don’t talk like India proped up this government. It would have been nice not to have any relation with Bangladesh in any capacity. That’s would have been best for both side. An average Bangladeshi supports Pakistani more than Indian it’s they identify has Muslims that’s it.
@@StayAlertfrom786you've no idea how india helped her to stay in power. Even in january she was in huge pressure from UN, EU & USA to held a free & fair election. She got enough help from india to calm down USA & EU. You may see a huge anti indian mentality among Bangladeshi, but you've never tried to focus on the root cause. Yes, I accept there a small group of extremist, but main anger was the unconditional & unethical support from indian govt to a dictator. I hope Delhi should reconsider their foreign policy about Bangladesh in a way that relationship between two neighbours don't get affected even after regime change. We can't change our neighbours, nor can we help a dictator and get unpopular among neighbour country.
Thank You Karan for the interview with the leader of Bangladesh as for us in Meghalaya having relatives in Bangladesh and as Christians our pastors have Bangladeshi Passport to attend Synods and Presbyteries of all Bengalee Khasi Pnar Faithfuls And we in Meghalaya have many MBBS students in Bangladesh many has Passed Test of MCI Medical Council Of India and are serving as doctors. All the best To You Sir
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@adityabanerjee7145 in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
None of the student leaders had given out any instructions to the protesters- asking them to have patience and not show any vengeance. Why were they mum when the destruction was going on? These leaders had access to every communication system
@@nandinichanda3599 Actually they did, multiple times. On 5th August, that was the first thing they did through television media. They also formed local committees who are patrolling through different neighbourhoods to prevent the attacks.
And where did you fund this particular piece of information? In your Republic TV? Student leaders promptly instructed all the people in the country to help people in minority from Awami goons who wanted o create chaos in the country by disturbing the minority.
Scenes witnessed from Dhaka or not sure of the venue - where Sheikh Mujibur’s statue is being vandalised - do you want me to believe that those were fake images. Honestly speaking- I would have loved to believe that.
@@nandinichanda3599 no, the image is correct. It reflects the pent up anger suppressed for 15 years. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman who is the founding father of the nation is the first autocrat of Bangladesh. Sheikh Hasina reestablished his one party state system again which lead to her fall. The act of vandalism was condemned by the students and the civil society. The other side of the coin is missing in international news is that almost 80% of the looted/vandalised property was restored by the students. They are the one controlling traffic on the street, cleaning and restoring vandalized properties, patrolling neighbourhoods to prevent any sort of attacks, and collecting the looted properties.
Valuable lives, blood & sweat.. Dreams would have been shattered.. For Freedom.. Hope the NEW FOUND FREEDOM.. Bring Bright & Promising Future for the Citizens of Bangladesh.. & it's Neighborhood.. 🙏🙏
Well done Mr Shafqat Munir. You spoke well on behalf of overwhelming majority of Bangladeshi people.
@@awaazuthabd Couldn't agree more.
Taqiqa in full flow
Population exchange with westbengal is the solution.
1.2 crore from there and 2.6 crore from here.
You mean majority Islamists
@@pradipray1251 mamatadi vetoes it
He portrays a real and honest picture of dictator Hasina.
Wire shows the real picture of Islamists
@@sarsau wire is clearly funded by outside power its a shame maulana modi never took action against foreign funded media houses
@@sarsau why u guys so afraid of a certain religion? Why bro? The east India company really brainwashed this region.
@@sarsau and you shown the real picture of biased radicalist Indian mentality
Hats off to Mr. Munir for his incredibly balanced, pragmatic, mature, clear, focused and extremely well informed perspectives. Impressive indeed. Wishing well for Bangladesh.
I wish Bangla Desh the very best having with such educated and civilized leaders.
Hats off to students and common man of Bangladesh whi so spectacularly overthrew an autocratic goverment and saved their country. Love from India.
I am an Indian currently in Bangladesh and stayed in whole revolution time. Whatever the facts presented here are totally true ,there is no doubt. Indians most media shows this topic as islamophobic lens.
What facts are true elaborate ?
@@StayAlertfrom786 About communal attacks and responsible group which overthrown the govt. Whatever points justified by Bangladeshi representer are true.
Bangladesh was a gift to ppl of east Pakistan from India! Minorities in Bangladesh m their protection is responsibility of India according to partition clause! If Hindus are attacked, Indian army will enter n rescue them!
@@sarsau Bangladesh was not a gift from anyone!!! Bangladeshi (former East Pakistan which was formed due to partition of British India in 1947) fight with west Pakistan 9 long month, more then 3000000 people sacrificed their lives ! Yes India supported Bangladesh by taking refugees back then and joining the war at the 3rd December 1971 after Pakistan launched preemptive air strikes on northern India, and Bangladesh gained victory 16th December 1971. I am as a Bangladeshi, very grateful for that and always will be. But before you talk hatefully and try to create religious disruption in Bangladesh, I suggest you should learn history first! Not only just hearing from some one but with proper research (about Bangladesh liberation) , and witnessing what’s going on in Bangladesh right now by your own eyes !!!!
@@MituHossain-s4m Yeah we're responsible, for creating religious disruption, in Bangaldesh, and not Hadiths. 😂 And we're also responsible, for reduced percentages of minorities, in Bangladesh. 🤷😅😂
I understand, you might come up with an excuse, of Indian Media being Islamophobic, what about western media though? BBC, Reuters, etc?
At last one refreshing and thoughtful voice from Bangladesh that captures the essence of peaceful and purposeful coexistence. Yes, aggressive rhetorics, cinicysm and conspiracy theories don't heal wounds. Lampoons are there in every society who profess and act on fundamentalist instincts based on religious dogmatism (perhaps religious pervertions) but that should never dominate any society at large. Else, the door to hell is a stone's throw away.
Exactly! Fundamentalists and extremists are everywhere. What people are doing to stop those fundamentalist goons should be one of the crucial things that matters.
That's the view of the entire nation. A few uncultured people have caused some damage, but we will not tolerate such behaviours
We are not accountable to India for attacks on minorities but to our constitution. It is our moral responsibility to protect the minorities. Most attacks on Hindus were due to their association with the former political party in power because in that time they oppressed opposition parties. After an uprising these types of attacks are not uncommon but not expected.
Shameful utterance...if this is the ill-thought in ur mind.. then be ready for the consequences...so this is so-called religion of PEACE! Ur going to become another Afghanistan.. let's see how things evolve around.
@@rizhawk1628 modi should ensure Muslims , Sikhs and Christian’s are safe in India. He needs to sort his own country out first instead of spreading hate and attacking minority religions in India.
They are safe over here. It is only in the Islamic countries the minorities are castigated
India or Induan media’s hyperbole of hindu oppression or for that Awami League as the protector of hindus in Bangladesh are a myth on the contrary history or records if study undertaken will prove that most of Hindu oppression happened mostly whenever Awami Look league were in power
The attacks were happening during Awami League rule as well every year and Hasina did nothing.
I thought we are the smart people who living in first world country. No I am wrong and there are smarter than me who living in Bangladesh. Wow wow wow!!!! May Allah blessed Bangladesh
Bangladesh was a gift to ppl of east Pakistan from India! Minorities in Bangladesh m their protection is responsibility of India according to partition clause! If Hindus are attacked, Indian army will enter n rescue them!
@@sarsau come with your chai wala army in Bangladesh and we are ready to show you the coffee shop. Be careful build the toilet first and make sure people are not using toilet as their temple.
Excellent job!Munir!!
Keep it up. We are human!!
We are Bangladeshi!
We love humanity, we love our neighbours and we must protect ourselves. Bangladesh is one country one family!!
Bangladesh is a free country now!!
We must be kind, generous, tolerant,, compassionate and be a model of true democracy.
No double standards, no hypocrisy,
Let’s start by showing the hard work, let’s educate ourselves and work together with every single nation in this world.
Excellent conversation! Many thanks, Karan, for your continuous efforts of crafting the real picture in this sea of misinformation. Mr. Monir was very loud and clearly described and analysed of the true picture without a single exaggeration of the facts. Would like to see more of these kinds in the coming days.
Let’s start new chapter between Bangladesh 🇧🇩 & India 🇮🇳
Never.
@@jayanthisrinivasan9055 OMG! Mr.Minister of External Affairs of India! what are you doing here?
East pakistan
These Katuwas will always be loyal to their religion!! Not to their nation!!! Ambedkar was damn right
It seems to me highly irresponsible to tie the relationship with a sovereign nation to any single person (Sheikh Hasina) or her family.
@@leonardobear5487 That is exactly what BJP did.
Absolutely 💯 India must ban Hasina family & her BAL party forever for their own benefits 🚫 Now they must support Bangladeshi people to regain the good relationship again ✅ Indian people should vote I N.D.I.A. alliance party to settle a good political environment in south Asia to bring proper relation with other neighbors as well 🤝🏼 Modi-BJP-RSS-Godi media are causing chaos & spreading racism in this region, because they're based on hindutva extremist ideology 👹
@@leonardobear5487 it's OK for you fools and ambani
@@falconeagle3655You are exactly correct .
@@falconeagle3655 This is not only bjp policy, congress did the same thing. They gave hasina family more importance than any other political parties in Bangladesh. And that may be due to the ideology what other political parties followed towards India.
I am an Indian and support the people of Bangladesh 🎉 May Allah help you in Peace, Prosperity and Joy. Thanks to my favourite Journalist Karan for this interview with very learned fraind from Bangladesh.
You are not supporting them as a indian you are supporting them as fellow kaumi so sit down.
@@gauravsaini8375 🐮 gang spotted!
@@DrZubairulIslam Your name is Bangladeshi. Either you are lying through your teeth or you must had illegally come to India.
@@abusasha478 why momad had consumed 6 yr kid Aisha
@@tseringangchuk5420, who would go as an illegal in India? Do you think India is Europe or North America?
Mr Shafqat Munir brings out the vindictiveness of Sheikh Hasina in the culminating part of the interview which makes him talk of reconciliation of the Bangladesh society on top of bringing Sheikh Hasina to account for excesses and crimes!
It was horrendous for Bangladesh to have experienced this for the last 14 years and for India to be an accomplice, unknowingly and unwillingly while I am ready to accept the current Indian leadership to have done the same knowingly and even willingly as our leader can view such actions as acceptable part of governance!
The capture of media was total as is the case in India and we in India also need to see where an autocrat goes!
India would never have this sort of coup. People in India by large are civil
@@cyke1234 Niraj, a true the wire follower. People like you can dream of creating coup against democratically elected govts. These are true autocrats anyone who has a different view are non-democratic.
@@mrinalbiswas2280 Where has one said that the change in Govt, you use the term Coup, of the kind that happened in Bangladesh is likely to happen in India?
One has only talked about the shared attributes of the two leaders: Don't you see the capture of media, law & order machinery media, targeting of opposition, and emasculation of institutions here as well?
You seem to have blindfolded yourself or decided to wear the glasses of ANDHBHAKTA, if you don't!
@@alokkadam4416 Good Luck, a Harebrained Bhakta and Nut!
@@NirajPant2 Dynast slaves propaganda
Mr. Munir was very HONEST and articulate... I do not believe that Sekh Hasina will ever be welcomed in Banladesh...Hope and pray that New Delhi and Dhaka will create a new authentic relationship..
I don't think it's possible under Modi government
Well done Shafqat, you are spot on!
You have spoken the truth straightaway. Your talk portrays absolutely the true scenario.
Bravo!
Hasina's political career is over. You can hope but people of this country won't accept her. If she comes back, she would be handcuffed first.
The real question is if she wants to contest elections, will she be allowed to? What kind of a democracy is it if one party is chased away or killed before calling for 'fair' elections.
@@ambat7960 If she comes back, wont she be trialed for the massecares that she gave to the orders to execute???
@@absdur6320 yeah sure, but that's not the question. The question was if she will be allowed to contest ? There are people in India who contested sitting in jail, and won and are still in jail.
If election was rigged why students did not agitate. Why opposition did not agitate. Hasina became PM after winning elections. If her 1st term was bad why she was elected again. Bangladeshis want India' help but they don't want hindus in Bangladesh.
@@rajeevashetty8395 Bro the ruling party almost always has total control over the police and military. Protests in Bangldesh isn't anything and has been going on for over a decades. Most people didn't join in bfr because there is a high chance of them being killed or jailed. This time everything became too big and the military refused to shoot.
We also want India to protect minorities of their country.
you are protected
Or you can invite oppressed minorities from India t Bangladesh....like India does (CAA)
I am an Indian Christian. Christians and Muslims have special minority rights. There is even quota system for Muslim students. The only issue BJP has with us is Christian missionary activity. There are three Christian-majority North East Indian states through missionary activity. As a Christian, I am totally against conversion by giving incentives to poor people. Muslims should also stop Dawa/Conversion in a pluralist country like India. If you think you only reach heaven through Jesus or by accepting Muhammed as Prophet, that in itself is a starting point of intolerance toward other faiths. Muslim clergy has to say, " Small Jihad (Employing violence) - Concentrate on Big Jihad which is inside your mind, Kafir (Unbeliever), Murdath (Ex Muslim - Death sentence) and Ummah (Muslim brotherhood - Focus on Universal brotherhood) don´t apply in a pluralistic country like India. I have a question: Can a good Hindu or a good Christian reach heaven, without accepting PM as Prophet? According to Islam - NO
Had they not been protected in the last 75 yrs their number wouldn't have trebled..... Contrary to yours... Where the% of hindus has decreased from 16% to 2%
Completely agree with you @@thomasthomasphilp4393
Excellent interview, Mr. Munir. nicely put. Impressive indeed.
Did Hindu students try to protect Babri masjid when it was being attacked?
You are asking the wrong question; why was the Ram temple 🚩 attacked and destroyed first should be you question.
😛😛😛
Correct your grammar, then we will answer you.
@@Rousseau123beef burger 🍔
@@abusasha478 Thanks, but I like beef steak more. What about you tasting pork pie.
Well done Mr. Munir!
One day, people will read about the Bangladesh Revolution in books the way they read about the French Revolution. Hats off to the brave students and people of Bangladesh.
Well done, Shafquat munir. You proved to be the right Spokesperson and voice of the August 5th revolution ! You have very aptly cleared the clutters around our hard earned revolution to an important foreign media. Keep up the good job. I am proud of you !
Great interview. Kudos to both the interviewer and the guest for keeping to the point and respecting each other’s views. Bangladesh is a nation that is 80% akin to India in terms of cultures and values. We never had any Pakistani or Afghan like mentalities and never will. Please don’t politicise this movement
That’s a joke. The only reason that you don’t have that is because neither Pakistan or Afghanistan would accept you that way. What did west Pakistan do to east Pakistan. otherwise you are more akin to Pakistan than India. hell you were Pakistan Till 1971 because you wanted separation from India. it’s all good just don’t pretend otherwise. Own up
Mr Munir is the voice of Bangladesh...He explained everything correctly..
Well said brother.there is no place of communal hatred in Bangladesh 2.0❤❤
So why target the minorities every time.
I am worried about the minorities of India. The discrimination they are facing for over 4 dacades.
@@lokeshkrishna4534 Ask them who are targeting
Why peddling pathogical lies ?
@@YaseerAta As expected from radical islamists.
Why should? India must not do anything. Only save borders from them . Let them do what they do , they are not idiots they are smarter than India .
Would you prefer to live in an environment marked by violence, or in a peaceful, progressive community? Your surroundings are crucial.
If India really does that, that would be really nice of them.
@@mohammedmurtaza3257 We are already living in an environment marked by hatred and violence _within_ India 😅😅
I mean, watch any mainstream news channel....they spew communal hatred day and night
because it's Bangladesh internal matter.keep your nose somewhere else.perhaps reducing poverty in India.after decades of coma Bangladesh has woken up with full of energy.everyone wants to contribute to rebuilding Bangladesh now.🎉🎉🎉🎉
Why the massmadurer Sheikh Hasina is in India ?
Indian media should also give more airtime to people like this guy and give people's views
Excellent interview!
the interview is excellent ..feel informed and educated on a very urgent South-Asia issue ..thank you.
Please widen your sources to educate yourself. The wire has some strange tilt towards extremists.
This chap would make an excellent spokesperson for the Interim government or any future government.
Articulate, knowledgeable, composed & well spoken 👍
We know how to ensure the safety of our minorities, and we will do that definitely as we have been doing this so far. It's better if India focuses on the safety of their minorities.
No you donot. Data over the last 75 years prove that. We focus on our borders, self interest of our people which includes both minorities and majorities. You do not do that.
We Bangladeshi people want friendship with people to people not with corrupt politicians to corrupt politicians
We have had enough people to people of yours here in India. Now you do your people to people among yourselves.
Yes india should stand with Bangladeshi peoples not with murderer sheik Hasina
Islamists will hardy know the reality. The issue is Bangladesh govts other than Hasina has been encouraging terrorism in North Eastern states and harboring radical elements. India will stay on the side of humanity and also with the people who are not in constantly into radicalism and terrorism.
@@mrinalbiswas2280 not anymore, times have changed, this new generation will not tolerate such extremism.
@SohanaHaider 😂😂 Don't have a choice when 99 percent are extremists
@@shobhitdagur1086 not really
Karan and Munir, you did well.
He is absolutely correct.I contact with my hindu friend.They are all fine.The past government of Hasina regime who are behind this minorities attack.Like modi je.
That's absolutely right! The student wing of Hasina's party was behind the attack on our Hindu brothers. The leaked Whatsapp conversation of their central committee is the prove!
MODI JI is not past government - he is the present....and the future - get used to it
modi jee dangal party.
He has put it across with great eloquence & clarity. There is no doubt that such people as leaders can make a matured society.
Outstanding interview And discussion.. this is the best indian discussion i have seen so far.. most others are crappy and doesn't look at things objectively
Excellent, he became emotional at the end of his interview. God help rebuild Bangladesh. You did it, you are free. My prayers for Bangladeshi people. From Pakistan 💌🤟
'A leopard can't change its spots"
Thank you Mr Shafqat Munir for rightly ventilating the feelings of the people of all walks of life! Now, the ball is in the court of India whether or not to make friendship with the people of Bangladesh based on equality, honour and trust!
Now I can relate why no bangladeshi had ever appeared for any interview
Because of dictator Hasina..if we tell the truth the next day we r vanish from the world..now we r free & we can talk freely. 😊
Mr. Munir, very candid interview indeed. Thank you for sharing your honest feelings. We wish Bangladesh the very best now that you are free again.
Indian media personalities must evaluate the situation properly. Hindus or any other minorities in Bangladesh are more safe compared to the Dalits and other minorites in India.
If that is so, then how many Muslim or dalit refugee from India you have? None
Eye opener and wishing this good beginning leads to peace prosperity of Bangladesh & the region.
Thankyou Karan for your truisim
Hasina was an autocrat ,but that autocrat was steadfastly supported by India ,India got only one friend ,that is autocrat Hasina .Jamat is wrongly portrayed in India.
Hasina was the only one who protected minorities to small extent. Without her , Bangladesh would become more radical Islamic nation. India should cut ties with bangladesh
Yes JAMAT is wrongly portrayed in India?!😮 stealing undergarments ( Bra & Blouse) & made it to be auctioned in public of a 77 years old lady ex-PM? whole world have seen it.. even Taliban of Afghanistan never did it.. So this is JAMAT.. this is so-called Student's movement?! Shame shame.. it's a dirty slap on all Bangladeshi's.
@@cyke1234rightly said Sir 💯💪🔥
Very civilised, honorable & intelligent discourse by both individuals.
There is no place for shiekh haseena and awami league in Bangladesh
Kick all your existing parties out.
@@NoEndForUs well that's none of ur business.whom we will keep & whom we kick from country that's out business none of ur.
@@nafimking6529 I don't recall talking to you. First, learn manners. Second, I see loads of you talking about our internal matters. Your media stays busy with whatever is happening on this side of the border.
Toder to dekhi sob kichu tei India ke dosh dite. To UA-cam e ekhon boro boro kotha na bole, ja giye nijeder desh samla. Jodi bochor dhore, India India na kore nijeder desh samlatis aj ke ei dosha hoto na. 🤫🤫🤫🤫
What he said is very true. Indians need to understand.
Rightly presented Bangladesh situation by Mr. Munir. India should not brand people secular revolution as Islamist, and this will hamper regional peace. They should avoid play game on this and not to use Bangladesh situation as so called toolkit.
I appreciate both guys having such prolific discussions and sharing with us. I am from Bangladesh, I feel proud of how Mr Munir explained the position we have now. Please, please, please, stop seeing BD contingent upon Hasina’s eyes. It would be foolhardy to keep doing it anymore.
Last but not least, good questions from the other side. Keep up the good work.
Bangladesh must ensure safety of your Minorities in your country. Both are independent countries no one should used word must to another countries stand that is not acceptable by Indians at any cost. For India it is better wait and watch no investment until peace and democracy settle by Bangladeshi people.
Wait, are you talking to India or Bangladesh?
😂😂❤@@paranoah8550
He is speaking of Bangladesh, that is wat they are saying India must do this, India must support otherwise there will be problems for India. Threat under the guise of help.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu He edited his reply. Earlier he was talking about treating minorities right and it wasn't clear if he was talking about Bangladesh or India
The more and more we delve into the last 15 years of autocracy in BD, it is becoming clear the Modi-Hasina duo were using each other for their own personal gains, without considering the welfare of the people of their respective countries.
Pakistan stands with the people of Bangladesh brother
Hahaha! Don't worry no Islamists coming back there.
when will you topple your own dictatorial regime. the common people of bangladesh will always support the common people of pakistan. we are united by religion and many other factors. but we know that even you know the reason for hatred between the two nations is your military who wanted to rule our country with an iron fist and is doing the same in yours aswell.
One beggar always stands with another
@@merlingaming6541If you’re so united by religion then why aren’t you still part of Pakistan 🇵🇰?🤔
@@subhendumandal2857😂🤣
Its so so so so accurately replied off......each one was exact situation that been stated perfectly ❤❤❤❤❤
Why is India so concerned about Hindus in Bangladesh? Bangladeshi Hindus have always lived their lives as they wish without any significant issues. Why doesn't India address how the Indian army and Hindus have demolished mosques and killed Indian Muslims within their own territory?
Two very eloquent gentleman having a fact based interaction on a serious crisis affecting both countries unlike other Indian platforms.
1:16 Same should be applied in India , Indian minorities should must be protected
Indian minority far safer than Bangladesh
Converted # correction.
@@SankarDas-nz4nh common sense not conversion
Where they are getting killed ??
@@User-ce4zu recent maharashtra case
Well done mr. Munir...u have said what indians should know...
It's the duty of the new Bangladesh's government to ensure safety of it's minorities.
Such a brilliant message! Thanks Karan Sir.
Bangladeshi citizens seem to be doing more to protect the minority people in their country than the Indian establishment does in its own country.
In India the citizens, instead of trying to protect fellow minority citizens, would join in to attack them instead. That the sad reality of India today.
So this is a bit rich coming from India.
(Waiting for the right wing trolls to come and spew more hatered in the replies. Aao bhakton, aao)
Yes it is the reality at different times and different parts of India - but don't use the word SAD with it... be a bit unbiased
@@adityabanerjee7145 Why do you think it is not sad
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@paranoah8550
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@adityabanerjee7145
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
Very inciteful & touchful (towards the end). A much needed antidote to the Islamist paranoia & ignorance that is coming out of the Indian capital, media & netizens. Thank you Karan Thapar. Thank you Shafqat Munir.
Do not worry about Bangladesh as a neighboring country. Our country will be managed by a Nobel winner, not a tea seller!
That tea seller is more popular leader than your about to die Nobel prize winner
@@cyke1234 So you don't know Yunus. He is famous all over the world and Bangladeshi people respect him that is why he was selected as a chief adviser.
@@SoikatAhamed-e7f never heard of him. Let’s see how well he does to control radical islamists
@@cyke1234 that statement just proves how literate you lot are 😂
Please don't beg from India by threating minorities.
I am stunned and overwhelmed by the answers given by Mr.Munir. It is completely unexplainable that the change in power or the situation that we as Bangladeshi are going through at this point of time, we want India as a neighbour must accept, apprehend and appreciate this movement as a movement led by people, to be specific the vast majority of people who were to accept oppression and threat by the Autocratic Government that we were in till the 5th August 2024.
Well said sir you spoke on behalf of all the Bangladeshis
Mind blowing!!!!! Proud of you @Shaqat Munir
Sir is completely right. We protect our hindu neighbours all night. It was 3 day, our boys sleep less then 4hr.
But Indian media spreading wrong news.
India doesn't need to protect there minorities and Indians don't loot theirs win citizen.
Then why there was no one to protect you musicians Rahul Ananda and why were you able to protect the Indian culture centre in which you have burnt the whole history of your liberation war, the ISKCON temple; I am just listing a few, the list is endless.
But those protection photos should win you a fake image of the year award.
We are trying to save as much as possible. If attacks were on hindus only it wouldn’t be a problem we could save everyone but attacks happening everywhere as some people did awami league their houses being burnt also by BNP JAMAT. Situation is unrest due to lack of police as people don’t have trust on police anymore. But you’re complaining about my country how much you guys saved your minorities ?… i never saw a hindu guarding our mosque during riots very rare .I agree attacks are happening but it’s not only to targeted to hindus only it’s happening everywhere. And majority people don’t support vandalism .
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu Our law enforcement force already start investigation about Rahul Ananda, Iscon temple and other attacks. Some people did this intentionally. Sometime It may not be possible to save individual quickly. You have to understand we are at post-revolutionary states. If you demand a complete law and order in this stage, it's just a day dreaming i think. However, we are trying to make everything normal ASAP. My request to your news Channels stop spreading false news.
(Remember, Here no one or no party attack any temple in an organised way, like BJP attack on Babri Mosque.)
Who r you to protest them and why? If I am right you were protesting against your government, was minorities was governing you?
Munir came across as a fine speaker and a clear articulator.
India cannot rule out the role of America, China and Pakistan in this , for their strategic interests.
I can’t help crying. We are free! Karan is trying his best to portray the real picture in Bangladesh… Thank you Karan, our love and respect for your bold journalism ❤🙏.
India will learn from Students revolution
Acha tu hame batariya hai😂😂😂
Mr.Munir spoke with outstanding clarity. Everything he said reflects the views and wishes of our people in Bangladesh.
India made great mistake by supporting Hasina, the killer., India need to show support only to Bangladeshi people , not any particular regime
So this govt that has come in now should the Indian Govt support and deal with it or should the Indian govt support and deal with each and every individual Bangladeshi people by letting them in India without a visa.
just don't be too stupid. Your 4th largest remittance comes from Bangladesh. Over 10 lakhs indian works in Bangladesh. Also huge number of Bangladeshi go to india for healthcare. You're acting in a way that they go to india for free treatment.@@AjitKumar-lo9yu
@@AjitKumar-lo9yuactually ..now is early..keep as it is for now.
In future, a person who could do it is PM Modi..
Trying develop a SAARC ID where members can visit countries without a visa.
Economists should work out the maths and money..
Brilliant responses by Mr. Shafqat Munir. This is absolutely grounded on the truth and should serve as a wake up call for Indian policy makers that the old hackneyed policies in establishing relationship with Bangladesh are not going to work.
Mr. Thapar Dosti Bani Rahe 😂❤❤
Thanks Both of you 🎉🎉❤❤
When BNP was in power they pursued anti-India policies and allowed atrocities on Hindus. Sheikh Hasina reversed that, whom should we trust. He is talking as though they will be in power soon. What is the guarantee?
Like anti Bangladesh people. By current govt ..
Go to root of the problem.
Excellent interview.
Speaker convsys sentiments of Bangladeshis. Mr Shjib Joy has nothing but to mischief make. He is a decrepid man, and Indian gov is very smart and should not lend its ears to a deposed corrupt regime.
Excellent journalism as usual by KARAN THAPAR !! Hats off !!
Mr Thapar,your hate for Mr Modi is very clear from your statement made during the interview. As an Indian journalist you should be equally worried about what is happening with the hindus in Bangladesh. Instead you are stating that the anguish expressed by our PM about the fate of the minorities is unfounded and an over reaction. Absolutely irritating.
Thapar #😊😊
Great interview with a scholar who speaks with knowledge, professionalism and mutual respect.
Now I hope Modi would run and hide like a coward that he is, we have our own Leader of Opposition and he can form a government as well 👍👍
Do you mean...PAPPPPOOOOOO
Modi?...a coward?....😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@angelbaybi997 ask him to face Rahul ji in parliament? He will do toilet in his dhoti
@@adityabanerjee7145 yes Modi is the New Pappu
Why run and hide? Do you even understand democracy?
Shafakat Munir, love the clarity brother.
Y r people so bothered about minorities only in Bangladesh? Minorities are treated equally in all aspect here.
What about India? The Muslims are treated like 2nd class citizens there. Nobody is talking about the perpetrator Modi.
Wow !!! Perhaps you don't know the history of Bangladesh and why only 1 crore hindu Bengalis are left in Bangladesh.
Yes it is peoples revolution in Bangladesh against Govt and minorities including Hindus should be kept safe fully. It is the duty of people of Bangladesh and military to protect all minorities. They are also the citizens of Bangladesh.
This is a people's revolution.Indias some media & political leader trying to narrate it as the revolution of extremist which is totally bogus. India should respect the will of Bangladeshi people. India had supported a autocratic govt for last 15 years which made annoyed Bangladeshi people. It is time for India to rebuild ties with the people of Bangladesh.
You elected a govt. Indian govt had ties with the government of banngladesh. When the new government will be formed we will have ties with them too. Don’t talk like India proped up this government. It would have been nice not to have any relation with Bangladesh in any capacity. That’s would have been best for both side. An average Bangladeshi supports Pakistani more than Indian it’s they identify has Muslims that’s it.
@@StayAlertfrom786you've no idea how india helped her to stay in power. Even in january she was in huge pressure from UN, EU & USA to held a free & fair election. She got enough help from india to calm down USA & EU. You may see a huge anti indian mentality among Bangladeshi, but you've never tried to focus on the root cause. Yes, I accept there a small group of extremist, but main anger was the unconditional & unethical support from indian govt to a dictator. I hope Delhi should reconsider their foreign policy about Bangladesh in a way that relationship between two neighbours don't get affected even after regime change. We can't change our neighbours, nor can we help a dictator and get unpopular among neighbour country.
@@habiburrahman-tg7rm so are you saying Indians rigged Bangladeshi elections and have been doing it since the 90s as she is as pm 90s as well.
Well done, Shafqat Munir....excellent
We need to give benefit of doubt to the ppl of our neghbour to bring peace and order there as fast as possible....ppl are saying.
Good analysis
Excellent massage to India.
message*
Thank You Karan for the interview with the leader of Bangladesh as for us in Meghalaya having relatives in Bangladesh and as Christians our pastors have Bangladeshi Passport to attend Synods and Presbyteries of all Bengalee Khasi Pnar Faithfuls
And we in Meghalaya have many MBBS students in Bangladesh many has Passed Test of MCI Medical Council Of India and are serving as doctors.
All the best To You Sir
All over the world same issue. Doesnt take a genious to understand why. Just ask AI to find root cause
Modi’s disinformation IT cell and raw.
What about safety of minorities in india?
They feel threatened by MODI JI'S 56 INCH CHEST - no solution for that...
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been in power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@adityabanerjee7145
in india its the hindus who are persecuted since the day of independence to this very day...they preplanned every major riot since modi has been power n did far worse before then...🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
Ask Dalai Lama why he chosed India & not any islamic country
Very well said . We are with the people of Bangladeshi who support justice and free and fair democracy in the country
None of the student leaders had given out any instructions to the protesters- asking them to have patience and not show any vengeance. Why were they mum when the destruction was going on?
These leaders had access to every communication system
@@nandinichanda3599 Actually they did, multiple times. On 5th August, that was the first thing they did through television media. They also formed local committees who are patrolling through different neighbourhoods to prevent the attacks.
And where did you fund this particular piece of information? In your Republic TV? Student leaders promptly instructed all the people in the country to help people in minority from Awami goons who wanted o create chaos in the country by disturbing the minority.
@@neyazahmed309 UA-cam channels showing pictures of vandalism are all fake news?
Scenes witnessed from Dhaka or not sure of the venue - where Sheikh Mujibur’s statue is being vandalised - do you want me to believe that those were fake images.
Honestly speaking- I would have loved to believe that.
@@nandinichanda3599 no, the image is correct. It reflects the pent up anger suppressed for 15 years. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman who is the founding father of the nation is the first autocrat of Bangladesh. Sheikh Hasina reestablished his one party state system again which lead to her fall. The act of vandalism was condemned by the students and the civil society. The other side of the coin is missing in international news is that almost 80% of the looted/vandalised property was restored by the students. They are the one controlling traffic on the street, cleaning and restoring vandalized properties, patrolling neighbourhoods to prevent any sort of attacks, and collecting the looted properties.
Valuable lives, blood & sweat.. Dreams would have been shattered.. For Freedom.. Hope the NEW FOUND FREEDOM.. Bring Bright & Promising Future for the Citizens of Bangladesh.. & it's Neighborhood.. 🙏🙏
howmany Muslims been killed in India
Far less than Hindus killed in Bangladesh. And in India, Muslims also kill in equal measure