This song was written for Beyond 10 yr anniversary. It ended up a signature song for Beyond. Everyone could feel their pain when they sing this song even without knowing the story. For those who know story, can't stop crying!
the fact that this was written over 20 years ago by all members of beyond they can all get in and sing their hearts out every time they are all good muscians
The solo was better than the one in 2003. But nothing can beat 1996 version! 1996 version was the most genuine expression. Could hear they were crying. That is how powerful music is and what music is about!
man i cant stop listening to this song. ive been replaying this song since i was 12. theres some curse lolol. my friends got influence by me after singing this song everyday now and then. LOL
Can’t move on everytime listening this song in any version they sing.. Of course Ka Kui version is the best.. But the feel is deep everytime i listen to this song..
@funnyjoke23 of course ka kui is 100%. still, there's no reason to diss his bandmates. they've always insisted they are a 4 person band and they deserve respect coz they still play the old songs even though they can't match ka kui's original vocals.
音樂的最高境界，就是能夠引起多數人的共鳴，beyond真的做到了⋯⋯👍👍⋯⋯👍👍了不起的樂團👏👏👏👏😎😄😀
一個樂隊能夠每位都唱得，又懂作曲填詞玩樂器，又帥氣十足，真是難得！Beyond，您是最强勁的！
This song was written for Beyond 10 yr anniversary. It ended up a signature song for Beyond. Everyone could feel their pain when they sing this song even without knowing the story. For those who know story, can't stop crying!
家駒真係福薄命薄，天才早逝，不然嘅話，他会極開心同佢哋一齊開Beyond演唱會，一直到老
96&05 兩次阿Paul支結他都哭了，96係我聽阿Paul最淒厲最哀怨嘅演奏，05阿Paul懷著不捨去演奏，兩次都感受到堅強嘅佢哭了，結他都哭了！beyond......不論會否重組，香港人一定會記得曾經有一隊令我地值得自豪嘅樂隊存在過！家駒......多謝你為香港樂壇帶嚟過一個光輝歲月！
阿PAUL唱的 今天我 寒夜裡看雪飄過 是除了家駒以外 唱的最有感覺的人了
再加上最後的SOLO 真的是絕配
除了家駒 沒有人比的上了
kaiyou chang
05這個版本的solo恐怕連家駒也比不上
@@lammichael1732 真的 05年的SOLO整個超越03年
我想家駒也是很高興Paul能把這首歌能再次昇華
the fact that this was written over 20 years ago by all members of beyond they can all get in and sing their hearts out every time
they are all good muscians
最后的solo 简直封神，太牛逼了
05年的时候还在高中。。。没钱看现场版，看的重播，激动到掉眼泪。。。beyond还有ka kui在我记忆中永不退色！
最後一段solo,在那一刻,paul就是吉他,吉他就是paul.. .
guitar solo 間直繞樑三日
96的吉他像在哭泣 伤感中带着对家驹无尽的思念
05的吉他像在道别 伤感中带着坚毅和走下去勇气 这就是beyond精神！
Wong Ka Kui will always be with them in spirit.But Beyond is incomplete without Ka Kui we miss you so much Wong Ka Kui.
Solo的部分太棒了
一聽這首歌, 令我懷念黃家駒，他的歌無人可以代替，想念他
永遠懷念家駒
最喜欢这种又有音乐又有节奏的歌曲 , 尤其是深深的歌聲，永遠都能打動人心。太好聽了
太晚出生...沒機會....這首歌 經典 我台灣人 也很愛
8年前第一次聽05年版 8年後再聽 solo最後一個音下去 真得快哭出來
阿PAUL SOLO. 永遠都好好. 而且比其他人都特別
貫中真帥....
我有个梦想就是能够看一场BEYOND的演唱会
香港樂壇既傳奇!!!!
再唔會有好似佢地咁既樂隊,,
beyond!!!!
The solo was better than the one in 2003. But nothing can beat 1996 version! 1996 version was the most genuine expression. Could hear they were crying. That is how powerful music is and what music is about!
三字的演唱呆着悲怆，令人感动，Beyond精神永驻
我系90後，我真系好想去現場聽
我人生中第一首聽到的廣東歌！
最後一段solo 太感動了
beyond 的歌特別好聽
希望在估中這件事裏Beyond能走出來用歌聲鼓勵學生
96 和 05年的SOLO是最好聽的
最後阿Paul的solo是經典
我聽過最好的版本
1999年仲正啵
96最有feel
05最震慑
家駒、生日快樂
he's not crying anymore i am crying while singing this with them
黃貫中好帥
相信黃家駒仍在世既話，Beyond一定唔會散！
這麼多年了 大家都不同了 但家駒永遠都會年輕
这首歌唱的没觉得特别特别好但这段solo太有感觉了 FOREVER BEYOND
beyond就是beyond,每个团员都能唱。还越唱越好。
家駒絕對是香港人的驕傲！
听了那么多种版本。。真的。。听了那么多年。。。还是家驹的最棒。。最好。。
哎唷~~!!...可不可以不要解散啊!!!好捨不得喔！..
@Samuel08052 BEYOND迷也不捨啊！不管以後還會不會再重組或在音樂路上有更多的做為、作品，BEYOND迷永遠支持！永遠的BEYOND....
ejsionan 永遠嘅等待永遠既等待
我好想去聽演唱會......希望今生有機會聽到3太子在度合體......他們ㄝ都老了！
開首便動容
往昔重重 悉現眼前
2003也不錯
they sing with different tone in this concert...very nice...beyond forever!!!
2005年的尾奏最好，吉他聲就像在哭泣一樣，阿Paul現在老了，海闊天空的尾奏都無法彈完了
paul支吉他流眼淚...
伤感却坚定的声音！
I return keeping this song, I feel like I am on a loop
man i cant stop listening to this song. ive been replaying this song since i was 12. theres some curse lolol. my friends got influence by me after singing this song everyday now and then. LOL
陳雲自由自我 永遠高唱我歌 走遍千里
gives me such a complicated feeling everytime when i listen to this wonderful song...a mix feeling of 喜,怒,哀,樂
BAND仔生涯真的不易走
ka kui：我一世都不會忘記您！
聽到有少少想喊,太感人
第一段既和音好好聽,係咁repeat中~
三字的演唱呆着悲怆，感动
這一版有一種激勵上進的感覺~~
有共鳴。
別人是因為家駒愛上吉他而我是因為啊paul愛上吉他
好歌！
2.44的音乐 我脑海里突然出现他们四子一起的片段画面，好想哭T^T
Excellent voice. Make me feel so free.
能聽得出最後一段solo奏出paul對beyond依依不捨之情,paul是不捨得的
贯中最后的solo真係超正
不想你別去.....家駒
Can’t move on everytime listening this song in any version they sing.. Of course Ka Kui version is the best.. But the feel is deep everytime i listen to this song..
Really heart touching song....
wing can hit the high notes quite well
Beyond's magic lives forever!
Good
海闊天空 先係最能夠代表香港既歌
加油!!
I love u
beyond memang mantap👍
@Samuel08052 感情很复杂。有恋恋不舍，但是结束音又让人感觉已经很满足了。这个尾音和以往的尾奏都不一样。感觉是个完整的句号。
说的好
经典中的经典
音響超好
他们都不舍得 家駒。。。不舍得舞台。。。。不舍得BEYOND。。。。
不舍得歌迷。。。。
家强和世荣的二重唱很好听
@xusiduo2u 如果你说的CD原版是指家驹的版本，那尾奏应该是无限延长然后渐渐消失的。我说的稳定是指最后结束的时候，96和03的尾奏结束音应该是F调的G,05版本结束音就是F调的C了，显然C比G稳定多了。G尾音很容易让人产生没有完成的感觉。你仔细想想这3个版本最后的结束部分就知道了。
Paul重新编噶Solo都唔错~
love this song
👍❤️
啊Paul D solo 簡直係結他中傳奇
這才是夾BAND嘛，成員中人人都會唱，歌詞又有意思
BAND SOUND NEVER LEFT HK!
海阔天空。粤语歌曲beyond
Indeed
:') It was so touching
I miss ka kui.....................
年少無知結尾段ＳＯＬＯ有呢段ＳＯＬＯ既ＦＥＥＬ
@funnyjoke23 of course ka kui is 100%. still, there's no reason to diss his bandmates. they've always insisted they are a 4 person band and they deserve respect coz they still play the old songs even though they can't match ka kui's original vocals.
為什麼KTV裡沒有這個版本......
2018 6.10 家驹生日快乐
我聽到家駒把声!!!!
Turelove222 三个人合唱时候是可以感觉到有家驹声音
搞不好那個家駒的聲音是黃家強的 因為親兄弟 聲音會很像
this is good stuff
4:25 百聽不厭