What is Civil Disobedience and Is There a Time for It?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- The definition of Civil Disobedience is the refusal to comply with certain laws considered unjust, as a peaceful form of political protest.
Join me as I engage in conversation with highly knowledgeable professionals who share their insights on the concept of Civil Disobedience.
1. Gabriel Moens - Emeritus Professor of Law
2. James Allan - Professor of Law, including Human & Civil Rights
3. David Flint AM - Emeritus Professor of Law
4. Topher Field - Libertarian Political Commentator and Human Rights Activist
5. Dr Augusto Zimmermann - Professor of Law
After listening and becoming aware of the importance and consequences, you decide the answer to my question. Comments welcome.
Everyone should have refused the jabs and then they would have had to back down.
Vaccines save lives cooker.
Hopefully any trust in government at this stage of the game is gone.
Um, yeah, they are deep seeded in denial. @@SecretAgent-p8x
"Hey guys there's a cliff up ahead."
"Yo, we're heading straight over the edge."
"Y'all really determined to keep going this way, huh."
"Welp my whole social network went over the cliff, I'd rather die with them."
Yes totally agree, but how do u get into a brain of MK ultra brainwashed flock
For me Dr Zimmermann was spot on about Australia's governments.
IMO any government that says we have privileges and not right's is totalitarian and not a democracy ,
the so call pandemic proved this.
It's time to remove our corrupt government and the system they put in place that benefits them.
Australia is NOT a Democracy FFS & was never Intended to be a Democracy
Why the eff do the Sheep have this obsession with DuHmOcRaCiEz
Democracy is a terrible system, Democracy is the reason why Individual rights are being eroded. Democracy is Anti Freedom
If Australia is a 'DuHmOcRaCy' why is not Voting a Criminal Offence?
Should I not have the dumbocratic right to chose NOT to vote?
Drain the swamp.
We needed this during covid but everyone was silenced, NEVER FORGET WHAT THEY DID!! We can never give away our rights like that again.
Never will mate👍🏻✌🏻
Never did
Thank you for organizing this panel Robert and thank you for being a man of integrity amongst a pack of wolves.
Love the statement that 'good people break bad laws'. Thank you, Topher. Thank you for all your work, Senator Roberts 🙏
James Allen sounds like Jordan Peterson (I like Jordan)
The answer is in scripture, serve God first and his Commandments, Moses Jesus only
lived because of disobedience to the law, God sent an angel to tell them to flee and
same in other biblical events.
“An Unjust Law is an invalid Law and NOT to be Followed!”
- Thomas Jefferson
“Rebellion to Tyranny is Obedience to God!”
- Thomas Jefferson
When injustice becomes law resistance becomes duty.
Thomas Jefferson.
Abortion, same-sex marriage, and NO SMOKING!
Trump is not the man for the job, alongside Biden, his truely past retirement date.
Jefferson speaks true, however “mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed.” - Declaration of Independence
I was civilly disobedient during convid and I'll do it again.
I'm not allowed to impose myself upon anyone else so by that standard nobody can impose themselves or their BS upon me.
I wasn't but I bloody will be, I have been woken up to the truth
@@brontepetropoulos4755 same here - no more
Yes me too.
Id rather die on my feet than live on my knees as the quote goes.
Didn't pay their unlawful fines so they suspended my driving licence.
Irony was the fine got wiped as unlawful.
The so called govt and their policy enforcers knew what they were doing all along.
Its time for accountability.
@@torifisk9750 A quote often attributed to various rebels from Spain, Mexico and India. But I believe first uttered by George Washington and repeated by Francis Scott Key to the English naval commander in charge of the fleet attempting to destroy fort MacHenry.
I like your profile picture, did you know Israel was the most persecuted people on earth during covid. You could not participate in society at all unless you had all of the vaccines.
I am loving this. Thanks Senator Roberts & all parties involved.
God bless you senator Roberts More like you please and we would have an actual democracy.
We must all stand up and change the broken system. It must be fair for everyone.
My understanding in today's world is simple. It is so evil. Two people in Melbourne Victoria killed themselves publically during COVID. One person burnt themselves alive in their car. With msgs of COVID ruined my life.
There was not one report publically and most Aussies didn't even know.Most Aussies didn't even know nor witness the brutality of police nor witness the carnage. I hold the media responsible. In tinamin square we saw that Chinaman in front of tank. The world saw it. The world saw us being mutilated by police till we were called BY the world " The traditional prison colony.
Jesus is coming back soon mate to judge the evil and reward the good. Hang in there as their is real hope!
I was proud to be civilly disobedient. Unjabbed, unmuzzled, no QR BS, even made playground qr bs disappear. It felt good and I had no hesitation to stand my ground. I lived my life the way I wanted, while around me people lived in fear behind their muzzles in their houses. I did not and will NEVER comply. 🇦🇺❤️
Bless you Senator roberts, take care of yourself and stay strong. My prayers go out to you for the strength to continue your work.
Only 88 views !
Come on Australia …. Wake up
PLEASE
Did you share it to FB and sites there. If not why not.
8.3k now
@@TheCharger18911k plus now it is a must to Watch
@@TheCharger189 Heading for 12,000 now... Hopefully people are catching on! Spread the word!
The UA-cam algorithm does not make make this easily available that’s why
Thank Senator Roberts and Guest 🙏!
Much appreciated !
Thank you Senator
Thank you senator Roberts, for giving a platform to these remarkable humans, this is what Australia needs to hear...
Excellent discussion gentlemen.
This podcast needs to be on mainstream media. Thankyou for this brilliant presentaion.
If our Governor General was doing his job properly he would have stepped in and said it unconstitutional. Precious governments have done a good job of not teaching our constitution to us .
What we need - and what they fear - is citizen initiated referenda- then the citizens would have control over the laws and constitutions of their countries, and elections would not matter so much as we could restrict pretty much everything they could do.
GG won't, cannot, he is one of them
Obviously GG was not doing his job honourably and sincerely. He chose to play politics and that should not be allowed. GG job lacks a compelling mechanism to be deployed to protect the constitution and the people from bad laws, rogue government. GG duties are fundamentally flawed
And now the GG is going to get pay rise of 400.000 $
Bro THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA PTY LTD doesn't have to abide by the Constitution lol
Roberts won't tell you that, because he's paid by the same Corporation who pays the rest of the Parasites in the Parliament
Thank you Senator Roberts for this very informative forum
Fascinating and thought provoking...thanks to Senator Roberts
So illuminating! Thank you Senator Roberts. I do wish some form of accountability is brought down in those who manipulated and lied - and still continue with the lies. Such a wonderful assembly of interesting speakers.
Thankyou Malcolm,
We the people TELL our representatives what we expect, They do not tell us!
I thank you for this valuable information and hope Australians can come together to stand up to political corruption.
Take the OA awards off McGowan, Andrews and Dr Norman Swan.
Yes please. These honours have deleted the honour they were meant to bestow on the decent recipients.
Free Assange now
He is getting out tomorrow.
He is out
IS FREE NOW,,FINALLY
Just pray he comes home safely.
Ok. Done. 🙏
Thank you to such knowledgeable and inspiring people! You should all go on tour together to inspire this nation because this information needs to be out there for all to hear. Government needs to work FOR THE PEOPLE again! We need the ability to have freedom of speech in order to have self respect again. Freedom of speech teaches us how to engage with each other in a respectful manner as we debate issues that need to be raised.
Thanks for this senator. Encouraging to hear we still have some wise men among us.
Sadly so many Aussies decided to go against their true feelings and beliefs so that they could work and provide for their families. Now they cannot do that because they’re too sick and injured or no longer with us. Trust in government and the institutions has gone completely
The majority of Australians took the vaccines willingly and berated those of us who refused. Only now they act like they did it against their beliefs. There is no sign that trust in Government has gone anywhere. The Majority went back to life as normal and still get their regular Covid Booster and Flu jabs.
Wonderful watch and listen. Thank you very much Senator Roberts and also thank you very much to your excellent guests.
NOW! Before is too late
The Australian Constitution which cannot be changed without referendums clearly states what we, the people have to comply with, and it does not contain States of Emergency, does not contain wearing masks that have been purposely contaminated with dangerous chemicals, does not insist that children should be imprisoned inside of masks, does not force injections into anyone, et., etc., etc.
The government does not have Constitutional authority to make laws, that authority rests with we, the people, and THAT IS THE PEOPLE's SAFEGUARD FROM ROGUE GOVERNMENT.
Since we do not have a lawfully appointed and installed Monarch, and have not since Queen Victoria died, we have NO PROTECTION from ROGUE GOVERNMENT.
I very much appreciate these men that can eloquently speak in english. I admire you
This is a brilliant idea! Keep it up. Providing us with the knowledge, ideas and wisdom to think for ourselves and act independently of the mainstream narrative. Thank you for organising this, and thank you to the guests
Prof Moens speaks the most sense of the panel.
It's time Australians get rights and not privileges. Until that day, Australians are subjects, not citizens.
The cultural institutions are too far gone. Isolate them and build new ones.
Brilliant discussion. Thank you so much Senator Roberts and thank you to all your guests. I’d like to share my favourite quote which doesn’t refer to any of your guests but to the majority of Australians ‘Learning that even intelligent people can be cowards and that courage is a much rarer attribute than intelligence.’ Julian Assange.
From kindergarten there should be a module taught on our constitution until graduation! These days, most people don't know when their rights are being trampled on.
The Constitution is Anti State, do you think the Government who controls education (because the sheep don't want to educate their own Children) really wants to teach Anti State lol?
They wont do that . They dont want the people to know what their rights are
Have you read our constitution? We'd do well to rip ours up and replace it with the USA constitution. USA constitution: all about individual rights, liberties, rights to self defence, right to bear arms, right to not incriminate oneself by refusing to answer a question"plead the 5th". Their constitution is for the individual. The AUSTRALIAN constitution is a terms of trade document from a newly minted country/colony its just a bunch of crap that amounts to states may do what they want but the Feds over the states and none of you states get to take 100% dibs on any mineral reserves you find. Try finding anything about your rights in there
@@thomasc9370100 per cent
or how their money is pissed against a wall by the wastrels in government. If they taught students how our banking cartels work there would be a revolution tomorrow.
The risk of insult is the price of clarity
A Public Forum 'Think Tank' Is the BASIS for ALL Government Procedures, Beginning's !
It is all down to TRUST LAW and
The WORD above everything and everyone.
Citizens driven referendum is needed to return power to the people
It's called "direct democracy" and restores the power back to the people.
@@GazGuitarz If Australia is a 'DuHmOcRaCy' why is not Voting a Criminal Offence?
Should I not have the dumbocratic right to chose NOT to vote?
So the same 'people' that have voted me into Higher Taxes & Less Freedom's, should have even more power?
Wow the sheep really are delusional
Absolutely there is NO political accountability in Australian states and federal government, parliamentary privilege, political exemptions, making laws to protect themselves, above the law, NO Rule of Law for politicians, corruption means ambassador, fraud means cover up for deaths of people Robodebt, the list goes on, on, on
The penalty for those in authority breaking the law needs to be much harsher than it is for the general public. They even knew this back in the time of Hammurabi's code 1755-1750 BC.
Bro you realise they ALL are employed by the COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA PTY LTD including Roberts
Look up the Definition of Australia in the Legislation. Roberts & the rest of them are administering a Corporation & you are unwillingly consenting to it
@@andrewkerr5296 Where are you are you lost at
Mr Roberts what a wonderful program you Put together I have to say that your guests were inspirational to say the least, Thank you 🇦🇺
Thanks beautiful people, for heal the human cognition.
Ghandi also said... It is better to do violence if it is in your heart than to wear the cloak of peace to hide your impotence.
YT has removed this twice.
Thank you for this podcast Senator Roberts. This is possibly the best panel discussion/debate I have seen on this topic (especially regarding Australia) on video social media.
Keep the insightful and genuine episodes coming!
Excellent discussion ✅
Nuremberg
There's a lot of digging through bs in front of you, mate. Before you realise that the victims and perpetrators of heinous crimes against humanity were totally reversed in nuremberg
Quality topics, and some interesting information to ponder.
Thanks for sharing and helping with freedom.
Great news today on Julian Assanges freedom. Let's celebrate.
Thank you Senator Roberts
With a Government to corrupt so draconian we only have blind compliance or civil disobedience. PS thank you so much for your incredible efforts on our behalf
"CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE IS SACRED WHEN USED AGAINST A CORRUPT GOVERNMENT" MAHATMA GANDHI
and that was against the UK "CORRUPT GOVERNMENT"
Thanks Malcolm, please keep informing us
Thanks Senator much respect👍🙏🇭🇲
To live justly & bravely, daring to make a difference one day at a time.
I WILL STOP BEING A CONSPIRACIST WHEN THE GOVERNMENTS STOP CONSPIRING
Totally agree with your thinking Malcolm.
The fact that the Govt could blatantly break vaccine coercion laws and the Nuremberg code, (not to mention the constitution and their own Party manifesto) under the guise of "an emergency" has me questioning the point of having protection laws?
Tyrannical Govt overstep is the very reason these laws were introduced! 🤷
thank you Senator 😊
Excellent podcast! I don't have enough words to praise the information provided here.
The problem really is the amount of sheep amongst us.
There is a time for everything to occur.
we're are close, very close.
Close to WW3, mobilization and the draft.
Yes Malcolm .
Yep - consequences - give them a criminal records and ban them from public office permanently - Australia needs leaders not sheep in charge
Thank you for your tireless efforts.
WHEN iN jUSTICE becomes Law Resistance becomes Duty
There are times and situations where violence is justified. That's part of the foundation of society.
Well said Dr Zimmermann
And to all ❤
Thank you to all for their wonderful contributions. God bless you all ❤️
I think that the influence of Post-Kantian ideology particularly Hegel's Dialectical Methodology needs to be addressed. Our Tertiary Institutions are deeply rooted in it.
Australian's love giving up the freedom to FEEL safe.
Yes yes definitely
Excellent thank you all.
IT IS TIME TO SAY NO ON MASS
We did voting NO. It hasn't changed a thing. But what have the NO voters done. It is difficult having a dictatorship for a government
Just stop paying Taxes
😂😂😂 no chance of that in a country where pusillanimity persists
Thank you sir Allan
AMAZING SPEAKERS THANK YOU
Basic law should be put on the schools carriculum. If you want social change
Thank you Malcom Roberts and to all your guests.
What a champion bloke! 🫡👍🙏🇦🇺
I agree with what that’s a gentleman said about the government thinking they’re above the law he’s right
Great Discussion!
Right here, Rght now!
No notification. Thank you YT.
Thank you Malcom as always very happy to hear from you .
Your the best
An excellent and timely discussion. Thank you Senator Roberts for bringing such knowlegable people together. Is there any other political party doing this?
No
THANKU
Augusto is accurate you must support and strengthen the non compliance of police to unjust laws… that is key
Dan Andrews consequences? A better paid job, massive pension and an award from his king. Rewarded for tyranny and social destruction. Our laws are pathetic and not worth following by his example.
Well he did what he was told
100% agree mate...
I'm in my pod
You vill eat ze bugs.
The Job of a Legitimate Legislature is to make laws pursuant to the Constitution Act 1901 by the will of the people who are the Government, remember the first 3 words of the Above Constitution. (WHEREAS THE PEOPLE) Not the politicians. Quick and Garran define this, not me. and for the people and not over them.
They breach these sentiments continually and they all should stand down and face Criminal Charges of Treason, Treachery, Sabotage and Fraud.
You Stand up to the global misanthropists. Thnx Malcolm.
Malcolm, what is the name of the current bill Labor are trying to put through that will allow and provide greater access for foreign overseas asset management companies such as BlackRock to purchase own and then rent out Australian properties to Australian citizens.
Is it part of the Housing Australia Future Fund where they will also provide taxpayers funded grants and tax cuts to superannuation fund companies to assist in them purchasing and building properties for them to own and rent out?
Don't worry .. every one will get a free tent.
I agree with Direct Democracy which takes the decisions away from the Govt
Why don't you ask the 2018 health ministers that all signed up for it.
Bet they never had the jab
What the government did to the people of Australia was unjust and the mandatory rules that the government's put in place was criminal. They need to be held to account
Andrews needs to be in gaol.
That's intetesting what you where saying Malcom...so the pompous nature of these criminal politicians getting to a position where they think they can't be prosecuted for a crime. Have to start holding those who have committed political crimes as liable as any other crook