Middle Class Ko Kaise Germany Gareeb Bana Dega | How Germany Can Make The Middle Class Poor
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2023
- Middle Class Ko Kaise Germany Bana Dega Gareeb | How Germany Can Make The Middle Class Poor
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Use Our Links For Support:-
Open your BLOCKED ACCOUNT with Fintiba using our link - partner.fintiba.com/flyingabr...
Our Code - flyingabroadyt
Send Fee FREE MONEY Transfer Using Our Wise Link:-
wi.se/flyingabroad
Thank you for the support🙏🏼
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🙏🏻 Swagat hai aapka flying abroad mein 🙏🏻
🙏🏻 स्वागत है आपका फ़्लाइइंग अब्रॉड में 🙏🏻
______________________________________________________________
OUR FAVOURITE EQUIPMENT:
From India 🇮🇳 :
🛸 UDTA JAHAJ (DJI Mavic Mini 2 Drone fly more combo): amzn.to/2LgkHJk
🎥 📸 Vlogging Camera: amzn.to/3rOXChA
💻 Vlogging Editing Setup: amzn.to/2Li3gbe
🎧 Headphones: amzn.to/354ytpF
From Germany 🇩🇪 :
🛸 Humara UDTA JAHAJ (DJI Mini 2 Drone): amzn.to/3ojhyax
🎤 VideoMicro Microphone: amzn.to/2X37GFO
🔌 Microphone Cable: amzn.to/3n6nx0X
🥢 Damdar Tripod : amzn.to/3n6udvG
📱 Mobile Holder: amzn.to/3hLdY6B
⚗️ Dehumidifier (best solution): amzn.to/2JGONFC
🧭 Thermometer, Hygrometer: amzn.to/385tsih
🚿 Very useful in Germany for Indians- (ye toh must buy h for all Indians): amzn.to/39ageAr
______________________________________________________________
→ 📸 Subscribe for more:
Flying Abroad :- / flyingabroad
Flying Abroad Vlogs :- / flyingabroadvlogs
Flying Abroad Shorts :- / @flyingabroadshorts
______________________________________________________________
Previous Videos:
📚 Masters:
• Masters in Germany | M...
🖥 Jobs:
• How to find a job in G...
🇩🇪 ✨ Things To Know About Germany:
• How To Prepare For Ger...
🇩🇪 ✨ Things To Know Before Coming to Germany:
• Watch this before Movi...
👫🏻 Life of an Indian 🇮🇳 in Germany:
• Going back to office a...
🌍 Travel and Vlogs:
• Indian in Oktoberfest ...
________________________________________________________________
FOLLOW US ON:
📸 Instagram: @flying_abroad || / flying_abroad
Facebook: / flyingabroadbyshilpa
📩 Business E-mail: contact@flyingabroad.co.in
#middleclasstrap #povertyingermany #germanykigareebi #howmiddleclasswillbecomepoor #middleclasstopoor #poverty #middleclassinpoverty #middleclassfamily #financesingermany #indianingermany #flyingabroad #flyingabroadgermany #flyingabroadshilpa #flyingabroadsachin #flyingabroadtravel #flyingabroadyoutube
Open your BLOCKED ACCOUNT with Fintiba using our link - partner.fintiba.com/flyingabroadyt
Send Fee FREE MONEY Transfer Using Our Wise Link:- wi.se/flyingabroad
Thank you for the support🙏🏼
POOR
but owns house and car
Old but clean
No noise pollution
No corruption
Clean drinking water
Pure milk
Abundance of fruits n vegetables
No "log kia kaha'en gn"
Rules of Law
Exactly mu thoughts !
Very true...Hope we Indians someday become sensitive towards others, understand priorities in life rather than mere earning money
It’s been more than one year in Germany and I agree with all of your points, Shilpa. Extremely true.
Thank You So Much ☺️🙏🏻
Hello AT,
Will u recommend/advise someone to still come to Germany, if he has offer/job in Germany?
I do hv offer, but watching this video from Shilpa is scary to me
Hello AT,
Will u recommend/advise someone to still come to Germany, if he has offer/job in Germany?
I do hv offer, but watching this video from Shilpa is scary to me
@@manishthadhani2911don't think much bro. Just grab. Don't believe hundred percent whatever this UA-camr posts on UA-cam. They are monetizing from this type of videos
Crony capitalism is at peak in Germany
पर वहाँ के गरीबों के घर भी ठीक-ठाक और साफ हैं 😊
My son is in Germany for the last 6 months. That was his dream. I guess sometimes it's God's Miracle for some and your dream comes true. As a mother I pray for him daily for his dream to come true as his girlfriend is from Germany . I live in Boston for the last 11 years my dream came true. I pray for everyone who is trying to settle abroad and reading this. Pls do pray for my son too. blessings to all❣️
❤
r u out of ur mind bsdk.
@@Hariomggn chup pandit😡😡
@@Hariomggn ...chup sala pandit harish larma beta.🤬🤬
Flex flex
These are points that really bother me, especially because I was doing financially fine in India and did not had so many struggles. I am in dilemma whether to go back, but one anxiety I had was to explain to people back in India, when they ask me why I came back? Because they see Germany as perfect and would doubt my capabilities only. You relieved me somewhat from this burden of answering to the people, I would just show them ur video. Thanks. I appreciate all the hustle you and your family are putting in.
My friend take your best decision and don't think about others , nobody is coming to help you out in any demanding situation and you can also say that could not adjust the weather over there !!
Don't go. Stay and try to be better than others living in germany. You will regret soon after you arrive in india
@@15shafique I just rejected the offer from an automobile company of germany and joined the same company in india with good CTC. In bangalore mercedes offering 30LPA with 120% hike while for same position in Germany they are offering 70000 euro Per Year. Why anyone will choose bangalore over Berlin with such low salary.
@@shashank318akgyou wrongly calculate dear 😅
Actually 70000 Euro means
623000 inr ,
So where is the best selary ?
If I mistaking correct me 😊
@@hamidsayed2112 do you have any idea of PPP?
Very very important and informative video specially for those who are planning to settling in Germany.
Thanks a lot Ma'am
Thanks Shilpa ji for this honest sharing. In have not seen any youtuber telling these minutes facts on their channel.
My request is , please make a video on Civil services of Germany and their working. Also try to compare with the Indian IAS officers. Hope you will do it and it will be a viral .
Thanks for providing a realistic view of Germany, I have been living in Berlin for 2 years. Every country has problems even the most developed economies of the world G7 have poverty too, I have lived in the USA, Australia, and now in Germany during the last 11 years of my professional career (Lucky me :) Some would call it).
Just to correct some of these points
1. You can get rich with a job, but you need to do what is needed. For example, I have observed most of the management and high-paying jobs here in Germany asks German as mandatory and they cannot accept non-German speakers which I think is very fair at least in IT because if you are in a management position you are supposed to speak to your bosses who is obviously German national, Some would say it's ridiculous but I say its rule of land where you are living.
2. Salary hike is not always 3 - 5% its very random and depends from company to company (I heard from one of my friends who was on 68k per annum when he started and in 3.5 years his salary is 120k now which is super high according to Germany but banda mehnat kiya aisi hi nahi mil usko)
3. Language is a barrier I agree with you, but how can you expect life to be smooth as butter?
4. Finally, inflation is real and it's eating a lot more money than I expected but I am still able to comfortably live with my wife not even working and the kid going to Kita. But please note it will be like this short term not for 20 years and yes, I am not able to save like 2000 Euros per month but still considerable saving
5. Paperwork yeah this is a pain but once you get used to it you are okay
6.Half of your expenses can be cut down in housing, if you fancy living at center of city like we do (Wife Choice :P) then prepare to shell out 600 - 700 Euros per month extra
Everything looks painful if you feel it, but look on the positive side you get almost free Healthcare, Clean air to breathe, Kid goes to school for free, Govt will support you with some 60-70% of your last drawn salary if you lose job suddenly (if you have a PR of course), and last but not least less traffic and one of the best public transport in the world where you can save money on your travel too :)
Well put.
wow🤩😍😅
Exactly. Skilled hoge to Paisa milega hi, mehnat agar dono country me same krni hai to Germany hi choose kro.
cringe
Is 100k ka good salary in Berlin for a family of 4?
Realistic information, in a very clear way .thanks
Bahut sahi jaankari👌👌👌shilpa
A very different story..Kudos
very informative video 👌
jo apka bolne ka style hai wo bhi magical hai dil karta hai bs sunta hi rahu🎉
Thank you for giving the other side as well😊
Thank you so much for being so honest . You are my favourite youtuber.
Thanks this was very informative!!
I agree on most of the point, lets compare it with india
1. Taxes : paying more than 30% in return getting nothing, private school fees coat your min around 2-3 lakhs per year. Dic visit min 1000 one time , house taxes, water taxes , limited & pathetic public transport , inflated food prices
2 salary hike and job security : check the latest report 90% of employees getting single digit hike in IT, job pressure is on next level.
3. Buying house: do you think a middle class person can buy a house in cities like banglore, pune ,hydrabad without bank loan
so true no one is considering these things
Also, I guess she compared "best of India" to "worst of Germany"
I mean, about 70-80% Indians work for 3-5 LPA in some service based IT company, that too, in some IT hub like Bangalore, Noida, New Delhi and Gurugram. I receive a minimum of 25k as rent for a 2 BHK flat in a gated society in a middle-class area like Dwarka, New Delhi.
How can anyone even survive with a 3 or 5 LPA job if he/she don't have their own house? They HAVE to rely on someone (most probably parents). And a health crisis is something unaffordable. That's not even barely surviving
Who pays 30% tax in India hardly few
Comparison is not about Germany vs India. It is about people who are leaving India for better jobs and salaries. With good skill sets in IT one can get high jobs in India as well and enjoy chaotic life in India (which I love). In India you get everything at finger tips. Earlier Indian IT job were known for support roles only but now we have job roles from design to development.
@@GolbalEduVentures Realise what you're saying.
People are not paying taxes NOT because India has a lenient taxation policy, but because the majority don't even earn enough to survive. How would the government tax them?
That being said, it doesn't mean Indians don't pay taxes at all. GST on most articles is around 12-18%, fuels are taxed beyond 100%.
Because of this you would end up paying more tax (in return of no healthcare or educational benefits), if you fall in that 30% direct tax bracket.
Of course you can continue to live like a lower/lower-middle class dude without paying taxes and congratulate yourself for saving it. But if you want to upgrade your economic class, Germany or any Western nation is way better option
Thank you sharing very important information first … but let see first comments 👍🏼🤗💐❤️
Thanks. You gave us a realistic picture of survival in Germany.
It's the real side of every country 😢
Acha let's see the unemployment And poverty rate after this year. Agree.. dude they aren't researchers and truth seekers just youtuber. Waha ka bhikari bhi sir mam bolta hai 😂😂😅
@@largefan1 theek hai bhia humare yaha ke bhikari ko bodete hai sir/madam bolne ko woh ameer hojayenge ? Tum jaise khud ko goro ke gulamo ke bajah se humara desh piche hai samay hai swabhimani bno
@@spidy-qv4rb abey champu pehle context samajh..aur jhandu ghulam soch kiski kitni kya hai dikh gaya.. whataboutery ke badhir baat English nahi vocabulary attitude ki hai.chood nibbe tu toh apne ghar ke jhagde bhi padosi karwata hai maanta hoga. Jai ho tum jaise lampat chupad deshbhakt ki 👍🤣😡🤬🤬
In fact there is poverty in every corner of the world but in India even a beggar has family. The 5 eyes countries do not enjoy that. No family and also poor
No, not every country
Very Nice video Shilpa ji. Content bahot badhiya tha. Lots of best wishes to you three.👍👍🙏
आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद भगवान आपको लंबी उम्र दे और अच्छी समृद्धि दे जो आप भारत के लोगों के ऊपर ऊपर उपकार कर रहे हो
Thanks for reality description .After long break watching video, sound change noticed.👌❤👍GBU Di!!
Great effort and keep it up thanks for guidance.
Wow, eye opener!, Thanks.
बेटे अच्छा लगा, आपने ये रूप भी दिखाया। थैंक्यू।
NICELY DESCRIBED. ... EXCELLENT. ...REAL STORY......TKS FOR CALL A SPADE
Very informative, many thanks.
Highly calculated vlog, Shilpa you are perfect analyst. Very hardworking.
Bohat helpful hy
The question is Would you leave Germany then? I have been living in Berlin since more than one year - although i agree with a lot of your points regarding rentals, language, etc however i think the quality of life you get in return (for the taxes you pay) is worthwhile - some examples include world class public transport which actually provides you last mile connectivity; brilliant quality of food and lifestyle products; access to entire europe for travel; i think in what i have seen, a great work culture where personal boundaries are respected, leaves are never questioned, you are not asked to work late, overtime is compensated via flex hours and at-least in berlin and in startups you get a decent pay rise, incentives, and benefits(although this maybe debatable). I agree with you on high deductions but we also have to see that these deductions include social security elements like health insurance, care insurance, unemployment insurance, etc. I think every country or city around the world has limitations and i think circumventing those limitations only make you a better and a more resilient individual. Overall infra including roads, Public schools and Healthcare facilities are world class in Germany as well. Also lets look inflation as macro factor currently - globally inflation is high in almost all countries (historically Germany has had a very low and stable inflation). I am not gonna discuss poverty a lot here but we know how well off Germany is in that regard globally (comparatively speaking). Look forward to your comment and your answer on “if you would leave Germany if you see a lot of challenges in the country”?
A very insightful comment! Thanks for sharing your thoughts Shrey!
@@Raasta01 These are the same people who run first when their is a recession. He is indirectly blaming india.
Waiting for her reply if she would leave Germany.
Germany turning into Islamic country save your life leave Germany as soon as possible
I would just like to respond here that after looking at a lot of pros and cons, opportunities booming in India, I recently moved back from Germany to India.
So informative video…..
Different countries have different definitions of poverty. In India, healthcare is not supportive to the poors but Germany takes care even the poorest when it comes to health. The German educational institutions provide quality education free of cost. In India, everyone knows the condition of the public schools and hospitals. What benefits do the Indian Govt provide if someone goes broke after getting laid off? Nothing, even if the person pays 30% tax during his job tenure. At least people don't have to think about these basic things in Germany.
Boss in india edu and food is cheap, And even you are broke you can sleep with some food in your stomach. Poor minds blames govt for their conditions. Get out of this mentality.
So you mean to say this girl is lying?.... Only you are Mahatma Gandhi?.... Others are Rahul Gandhi?....
@@INCREDIBLE-INDIANS I am not saying that she is lying. What I am stating here is a fact and also another way to see this topic. If you have a better counter point please share here, only abusing will not work.
I am not sure who is Rahul or Mahatma here, but I am pretty sure that you are an uneducated moron who doesn't have his own point of view. People like you are known as 'Gadha'.
Dude.... I have seen the video of an indian lady living in germany. And the harsh reality she said is Germany is too expensive to live. Both husband and wife have to work to enable them to live a standard life. There is no high pay raise like in india. 1 to 5% pay hike only if you perform exceptionally well. House rent and tax structure is very high too.... And Germany population is nearly 85 millions and india population is 1400 millions. So dude its easy to downgrade our own country majority of whom i blame congress party policies which ruled india for quite a long time..... Under Narendra Modi govt india has taken a leap and its growing steadily fast... I know majority of people may not like my opinion but its a fact. Just wait for another 5 years and you'll see the diffetent result. And its easy for a well to do person to criticize our own country where they are born. I wont say much but will wait for a right time.....
@@INCREDIBLE-INDIANS wow, you can express your points sensibly, Good. Though I agree with couple of points mentioned in the video but I also stated few more facts. Do you even live in Germany? If yes, then you should know that the high tax rates have various components and it's not only income tax but social securities are there which will help you in your bad times. Compared to india, where I used to pay similar taxes(33% including the cess) but didn't get any help from the govt. If you add PF contribution, optional medical insurance then the effective tax rate in India is almost same as Germany plus India has high GST. These are also other aspects you have to consider. income tax in India vs income tax, pension, medical, unemployment contribution in Germany is not a fair comparison.
My comment didn't have any political references but you brought political agenda, not sure why. If you are so much in love with what is going on in India, then why don't you go back and contribute to India's growth. Why staying here and whining? Also, why so intolerant if someone criticises some aspects of their country? why are you considering some hard facts about your country as an insult to your leader? India is not him and he is not India. So stop taking offence on behalf of him. I am not here to discuss Congress vs BJP, you don't need to drag politics everywhere. Your first comment is not decent, perhaps you thought you would be spared after commenting crass and no one will give a reply.
Very pleasant presentation.
Thanks for nice video, your presentation skills is great. Short and sweet. Ok thanks
Nice informative video
If a person do this much hustle in India he will live more comfortable & happy life. reasons:- Family support, no language barrier, Grocery & daily needs at your door step e.g:- bigbasket, country delight etc, digitalisation, house help easily available. If i miss any you can add. Thanks
Very informative
Very very very informatics information regarding Germany students.
So very very nice video shilpa mam kamaldeep India Rajasthan Hanumangarh
Watching your videos since while
Start of ur videos was abt ur struggle finally success in getting jobs in germany
Expenses,Visa, shopping, parents, hapiness etc etc all accumulated over 3yrs
Suddenly now this video, really wondering if i should make a move to Germany (yes saw abt 3-5yrs citizenship too)
But with this official recession
Will u still encourage people to come to Germany (i have offer)
✔️We really appreciate your work and you are really honest and clear about whatever you are saying.
Your channel is extremely awesome!
💎
Thanks a ton
Informative post
Maine socha tha ki Germany mein Sab Amir hota hai aapane yah achcha information Diya main Jahan hun vahan Khush hun 😊 aapko video bahut achcha hai
I saw your many of your videos and i I liked them all ...its nice how honestly you make videos .... Very informative!
In this video you look a bit ill...are you okay? Please take care 😊💐
Wah kya battery hai g good exploration
Thank a lot Shilpa Ji
Very good information.
Very Informative, I am workings here in Delhi in German MNC and sometime think to move to Gemany but this video is eye opener
Good information didi ☘️
Good one .
Very good information, great
Very informative and good Analycis
Thanks 😀
अति सुन्दर प्रस्तुति
Thanks
Boss garib log to har jagah dikhenge chahe desh kitna bhi amir kyu na ho...🙏
You were really good!
Excellent presentation
Acha vlog he jankari ke li thanks from tanzania 🇹🇿
I left Germany 5 months before to Bangladesh. Corruption made us poor here and environmental problems too high.
Bro I am plaing to go Germany with my gf , it is ok can we survive in Germany
Nice ! Lots of info about Germany ( but kal hi aapka india se vapas aane ka vdo dekha 😁toh kuch connect nahi ho pa raha - kuch time laga ke - kuch link karte hue vdos banao )
Both channels are different and timeline will not match 😀
@@FlyingAbroad you are the best shilpa di 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
Excellent
Good one
God bless you Beti from palwal haryana
Good informative videos.
I luv the tone of ur voice. It's very soothing and so easy on d ears. Nicely presented too.👍
Thank you
It is her own personal experience. The title of video can sound harsh and demotivating . It has to be your own personal decision if you have capability, conviction , believe you can manage than atleast one can try for few months and then can take his own life decision. I have been to germany two times recently, everything is normal there .
She is doing well as she mentioned in her previous video that one can earn 1 cr and everyone knows in abroad you have to manage on own.
I was happy when i saw her previous video she travel to Europe countries, bought bmw , showed amazon office and appartments.
Kehne ka matlab yeh hai ke Germany mat jao India me hi koi business Karo aur khush raho
nah
This video is the biggest eye opener for people planning to move there.. good job 👍
And its sad for a middle class person to think about it..
Great information
Nice sister'Ji love from Rajasthan India God bless you
Thanks a lot…..
good info
200% reality , As an Indian-German each and every word is absolutely true :( :( :(
Your every video is very informative for my family
Plz make a detail video on business related in hindi
Not english
Very nice information
Very Very super information thanks madam
Actually it is worse than she mentions. Cost to company is relatively high and companies expect you to perform as per your CTC. However, CTC includes your income tax as well as social insurance and payroll tax, which the company pays directly to the government (without you getting to see it on your salary slip). So effectively for a single earner (Tax class 1), a CTC of 6000€ would translate to less than 3000€ take home net salary. For the asset prices in Germany, that salary is abysmally low. Even high skilled individual struggle to afford anything more than one single apartment in their entire lifetime.
Very nice❤
Nice !
Thanks!
Ohh…it’s unbelievable.
I am lucky to be here in India 👍
dark part of the country it's good u discribed all with true manner....
Best informative videos. Kindly mention the place of videos in your vlogs.
Very nice and honest video. Das ist die Wahrheit :(
👍👍
Good video
Maam, Is it possible to work in Germany till Retirement and come back to India? Whether we will get German Pension in India or whether we can transfer German Pension in India?
High tax tho yaha pe bi ha. Above 15-20l package you pay 20-30% tax. Here you have to pay taxes in everything in name of gst.
Interest rates on loan are very high in India. Best thing about paying tax in Germany is that you get back in return from govt in form of education, healthcare, facilities.
Absolutely right ...
Wrong absolutely wrong than why they are charging for health insurance so much .
Abe chutiye gst to germany me bhi hai
what faciities? Healthcare is in decline, rents are high. Australia is better in persent time.
Abe bhaoike saale 15 -20 lakhs salary saale kitne logo ko milte hai jaantu 😂😂😂
I live in Berlin, Germany...I have to agree with all the points said here.
Thank You So Much ☺️🙏🏻
Thanks this was very informative
Thanks for the Information . Germany can come back from Recession. We find poor people in every part of world or even opposite streets of Billionaire Residents. But Germany system is unique.
Nice through well
i really like ur content. i have two opportunities, first that I will start my business in dubai the second I will come to germany for my masters degree. and I am computer science student. whiich u think is the best option?
Good information
Thanks 😊
Itni deeply knowledge ,,, itni to mje apni city @delhi ki b nahi hai ji 😅🎉
Live in India, never leave your motherland. Learn to live in challenges ❤
acha 🤣
Superb amazing wonderful and unbelievable. India is the best.
dear sachin sir and shilpha mam make a video on medicine course please
waha ke garrebo ke ghar yaha ke middleclass se bhi achha hai
Thanks for giving a correct perspective about Germany.