Gaza: al-Shifa hospital in ruins as Israeli forces withdraw
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 сер 2024
- Palestinians gathered to inspect the damage to al-Shifa hospital in Gaza after Israeli forces withdrew from the area after a two-week operation.
Subscribe to Guardian News on UA-cam ► bit.ly/guardian...
Israel's military said the raid on what had been the territory’s biggest hospital before the war had been conducted 'while preventing harm to civilians, patients and medical teams'. The World Health Organization said 21 patients had died in al-Shifa in the past two weeks.
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com...
Website ► www.theguardia...
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on UA-cam:
The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardia...
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardia...
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfoot...
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnspor...
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardia...
#Israel #AlShifa #Gaza #Palestine
No mention of the bodies bulldozed and rotting all around the hospital! Many with hands zip tied 😓
@@l-uk3xm go away please
🇵🇸🇵🇸
😔💔
@@zainubumarwhere did you see that?
@@James-9999 al jazeera, middle East eye..many others
I now thoroughly understand why people are antisemitic.
Please explain
Imagine what was happening to Palestinians since 1948
Who could know it was a bad idea to start wars against Israel
in In 1948, Gaza was under the control of Egypt, and the West Bank was under the control of Jordan! Why didn't they give the Palestinians a state? Israel was forced to go to war in 1967 and occupied these territories
Israel promotes that the problem began at 7th October and they forgotten there crimes with Palestinian people before
Israel learned us this word theoretical and practically
Which crimes affected the Jordanian squatters? Occupation? Nope, not since 2005. Prevention of movement? Nope, used Israeli hospitals and were employed in Israel. Denied basic services? Nope. Israel supplied water, sanitation services and electricity. Denied food and water? Nope. 280 trucks a day before Oct 07, more aid now. Is Israel guilty of war crimes? Nope. I suggest you read the third iteration of the Geneva Conventions. Is Hamas guilty of war crimes? Yes - definitely. This continual deflection is simply a ruse to take advantage of people who may not be the sharpest tools in the shed. Tools yes, sharp, not so much.
😂
Cry
This war ofcourse.
If you are talking about 75 years ago, Google 1948 war. Note who started that war. Facts cannot be hidden by lies..
Are they fighting hamas or fighting a hospital building looks like building are antisemitic
They are fighting Hamas in hospital buildings
They are fighting women, children and babies in hospital buildings
Hamas hiding in hospital and attacking idf from emergency rooms.
Same thing.
there was no hamas in hospital, stop laying us usual
Let's all stand for humanity 🇵🇸♥️
You stand with evil
We dont stand with hamas.
@@vjsingh203you aren’t american
Shame on this British government, probably ignoring the legal advice, knowing what is happening. But still supplying weapons!
@TORY-BLUE you should be ashamed of yourself.
Why would we betray our friends in their darkest hour and times of need?
The IDF did nothing wrong.
Blame Hamas for why they use hospitals, schools, civilian homes, UN (UNRWA) buildings or other public facilities for military activities.
@@Van-Cleef-b7msick
@@Van-Cleef-b7m Animals
What is happening to this world 😔💔
Terror is getting destroyed that’s what’s happening
is always been this way, just we didn't know it but from History, we should know better! Time to stop this insanity!😥
😂😂😂
US and UK happened !
Bullets originating from hospital I believe
How can anyone defend these repugnant acts of terror....
From Hamas you mean
They are supremacists.
@@fjm1061 hamas existed only after 1987, the killings & land seizing have been going on since 1948, people like you on the other hand only follow the news only after October 7th
And you side with Hamas?
@@fjm1061 H4m4z that Israel funded and founded? Is that it
War crime !!!
it hurts my stomach that we (our governments) in the West have supported this. Never felt so disappointed and deceived by our media and politicians.
you can leave and go to gaza if u r so hurt
@@uguarte606killer
@@sirinem4470 I am going to say something that WILL sicken you:
womp womp
Y0U D0N'T F€€L TH€ SAM€ AB0UT HAMAS HlDlNG lN H0SPlTALS, AFT€R PR0V0KlNG A WAR?
This is gut wrenching and utterly sickening. The al-Shifa hospital was a centre of excellence completed in 1946 before Israel was in existence. The name means healing. Not sure the wounds Israel is inflicting will ever heal. What a disaster.
While attacking Israel? Who kept provoking a fight they couldn’t afford?
@@fjm1061 Educate yourself
Another Israeli bot who thinks the war started on Oct 7th@@fjm1061
@@fjm1061 Israel did when they illegally occupied Palestine. Now we are expected to somehow believe the palestians are in the wrong for fighting for their homes?
Intent to destroy a people. Vicious government.
Doctors without Borders said there are no Hamas in the hospital or underground 😢
😂😂😂😂😂
@@naordaniel Why would doctors with national backgrounds from almost every country around the world lie about this?
Why would a Japanese doctor lie about there being no Hamas in their hospital?
@@naordaniel what a sick world we live in 😥
@@Thor.Jorgensen what a sick world we live in 😥
@@naordaniel what a sick world we live in 😥
if you defend this . I hope you see what the victims of the hospital saw .
They saw what innocent people of Israel saw at 7th October
@@HristovVojnikUOtadzbiniDoes what occurred on October 7th make killing civilians, starving babies, blocking medical supplies and destroying hospitals okay?
@@petermcculloch4933 Egypt is blocking Gaza…
And did the "innocent" people of "isreal" saw the 75 years of occupation since 1948?@@HristovVojnikUOtadzbini
@@mo7medjameel632 And did the ''innocent'' Palestinians saw the etnic cleansing of Israel 2000 years ago? By any logic Judea is Israeli land...You can try as much as you can...
Their excuse is like childish.🙄
I remember the war in Bosnia, day after day they shelled Sarajevo, snipers shot at civilians indiscrimately, it culminated in the massacre at Srebrenica. The leaders of those forces were tried and sentenced. The IDF have been doing the exact same thing......we and the US actually supply the weapons with which to do it, I'm ashamed of our politicians.
The IDF have not been doing the exact same thing.
@@NoWindNoSunNoPower Reality calling: "Yes they have".
Hamas is doing the same, how come they're not tried?
You don’t know what you are talking about , do us all a favor and stop talking …..
These are two entirely different situation‘s …. Have a nice day ….
@@l-uk3xm is that what you tell your self so u can sleep at night ? keep lying , people have eyes to see what you"re doing
Isn’t this the same hospital IOF attacked few months ago and pointed to a calendar claiming it is Hamas fighters’ names and made a joke out of themselves!? How is the world watching all this horrors real time and still watch helpless!!
Self defense against children!
20 year children with guns with 5 senior commanders...
no, against their parents
This is a genocide
“Genocide” is Word of the Year. It’s interesting that most people using it, yourself included, haven’t got a clue what it means.
Oh please 🙄
@@NoWindNoSunNoPower israel learned us this word theoretical and practically
@@NoWindNoSunNoPower In the age of the Internet, do you think people don't know how to look for the definition of a word or another?It seems that YOU need to inform yourself.
@marianaalexandru6166 I use the UN definition, as does the ICJ. You know, the ICJ who can’t find any.
War crimes
Committed by the Palestinians
The war crime is Hamas's, using a hospital as a war zone.
"Notwithstanding the lack of an agreed definition, the rationale for a loss of protection is clear. Medical establishments and units enjoy protection because of their function of providing care for the wounded and sick. When they are used to interfere directly or indirectly in military operations, and thereby cause harm to the enemy, the rationale for their specific protection is removed. This would be the case for example if a hospital is used as a base from which to launch an attack; as an observation post to transmit information of military value; as a weapons depot; as a center for liaison with fighting troops; or as a shelter for able-bodied combatants."
- ICRC
Tldr: No
The plan was always to steal Gaza
You geniuses exposed yourselves to the whole world, thank you for helping the Palestinian cause
This is against humanity. Against everything we study at schools and universities. This is nonsense.
Why did the hospital return hit then?
Keep crying mooooohamed.
@@TheRandompainthehe… he heeee.. 😅😅I do not need to answer.
@@mohamadjalalaldin1887 only ones that are crying are the gazans for it to stop 😂
@@TheRandompainthe heeee 😅😅
War crime
Israel will never recover from these horrors.
They don't care. It will take years to rebuild from here.
@@nauxsi Building concrete is easier than building a state, and the occupier entity is destroying itself
What horrors, Ahmed?
With Biden's support for a Palestinian state, it seems he's allowing Iran to gain leverage and paving the way for its dominance over the West.
Nothing like hospital in Gaza
dam. everything looks like in crumble there.
Had been flat
Free the kidnapped innocent civilians!
@@isaccrosenthal "Free the kidnapped innocent civilians!"
Meh I wouldn't.
I like the idf. It sure is keeping the promise of making Ga-za a parking lot
War criminals
Any person with 1 ounce of moral fiber in their body is outraged by what is happening to the Palestinians.
You can take your "outrage" and shove it.
@@whiterose-kb9lk lol exactly. Don't use a hospital as a terror base, how bout that??
Hamas using a hospital as a base of operations and its inhabitants as shields is outrageous indeed. Hamas couldn’t care less for Palestinian civilians.
Hamas is notorious for hiding their troops under hospitals for comments like this one.
Exactly
This is a terrorism.
Meanwhile, Israel calls 10-year-old kids who throw rocks against soldiders "terrorists".
Absolutely evil.
What is israels end game for doing this?
Gread
They want the land for a new canal so they can make millions and don't have to use the Suez anymore.
beachfront houses
@@pinkcloud8182 you mean poland 🇵🇱 🤣
Ben Gurieon Canal Project... Netenyahoo was discussing it with the Saudis before this war started and also this is why you have seen flare ups in the Red Sea.
Palestinians will not be allowed back in Gaza.
Where's the 'command and control' bunker'???????
هذا المجمع الطبي اقدم من إسرائيل الكيان المحتل
😂😂
Stop lying about occupation when you know it's legally not true. You encourage hate and war over nothing
What have they done when given Gaza, turned it into a battle field wasting billions in aid money, instead of a paradise. They break every peace deal!!
And now it dosent exist cry more sandman
Troll @@Vlad-si9xs
@@CaptHC weak nancy
Israel is staying on Palestine place...no shame Israel....
Stop talking rubbish when it's absolute lies!!
@@veenacriddle1207 shame shame
What happened to the international law?
Civilized people
Now do you still consider Hamas the terrorist one
Yes
al lado de Israel son bebés de pecho
Isrl is the terrorist , and the only one in the region. Hms was elected and is defending its land that was occupied in 1948
@@Nov-5062 go seek mental health. You case is not any easy one
@@serranaferrer3343 we’re talking about a genocide committed by isrl. Open your brain
Distraction of the Alshifa complex was the main goal
Al Shifa was a major hub of Hamas's operation.
@@janetprice85No, that was an excuse to destroy it
@@JamesBalmforth Why would Israel destroy a hospital unless Hamas who were videoed firing from the doors of the hospital not have been there? The weapons, documents and Hamas soldiers have been seen and captured operating there disguised as medics and patients in the hospital. Are you not aware of facts or just assuming Oct 7th was a myth too?
@@JamesBalmforth💯
@janetprice85 Al Shifa was older than the state of Israel as it was built in 1946. That is why Israel destroyed it. To remove traces of Palestinian history. Don't drink the koolaid. Go read ilan Pappe, Miko Peled, Zachary Foster, Avi Shlaim, Rashid Khalidi...
Shame on USA and European countries
Absolute disgrace what they have done
american terror
I have no idea what antisemitism means anymore!
The term "antisemitism" is nothing but a social construct and an instrument to silence any critics.
It means do not question the book or my interpretation of the book
Hello West, Is it a war crime to destroy over crowded hospital? Would like to hear your opinions please.
No, it's not, if it's used for military purposes you're allowed to destroy it. Clear and simple. Read the international law you so clearly try to hide behind.
It’s a war crime to turn a hospital into a military base, which is exactly what Hamas did.
I stand with Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸
From Indian 👍👍
@@Shaji-wh9dlI stand with Palestine. From Malaysia 👍👍
Gross 😂
Me too. Free Palestine!
If this is not in breach of international law , i dont know what is. You cannot tell me that this was not a wanton act of destruction by the IDF.
The UN and ICJ should investigate this act and takd action against Israel
Who enforces it?
@@nauxsi the UN , look who enforces the peace treaty in Cyprus. Let's not forget the UN tried the leaders of the Bosnian Serbs for atrocities they carried out in the civil war
I think the Israel country is no human rights law😢
So called civilised world is responsible
Hamas is responsible
@@jahlove44that's why IDF r@ped women in al shifa hospital right?
The uncivilised need to stop blaming others for their barbaric behaviour!!
@@MohammadHuzaifa-dz9tsyou mean what yall have done on the 7th october 2023 ?
And the world is just staying and watching
Yeah they are mostly brain dead from all that sand anyway
satanyahu should get his surgery done in this hospital
You know that Hamas operated within this hospital right?
Please show the evidence ..
This all is Israel's false claims...
Don't be inhuman ..
Sinwar did his heart surgery in Israel!!!!
Why Natanyahu should go to that place which is full of terrorists?
Long live Israel
@@tonyjakson5934 True, true, don't mess w/the nation of David
IDF soldiers committed a war crime😢
They are not soldier. Just monsters
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Free Tibet Free Kurdistan
Free Israel of Palestinians (whatever that is)
It's being freed from existence
@@TheRandompaint so you are proudly talking about genocide. 😅 very hurt person.
@@ragnarulrichson778 it is apartheid. Because there is no difference between humans.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸✌️✌️
Shame on world as they watch this genocide
this isn't geno. not even close
You mean the genocide always against Israel!!!!!!
কী হিংসা। তাদের বিশ্রী নিকৃষ্ট মানসিকতা দেখা যাচ্ছে চারদিকে।
i don’t care what anyone says. nothing justifies this.
Free Palestine 🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Free Tibet Free Kurdistan
Israeli terror🤬
Israeli defense 🔯
@@SloaneLasers keep telling yourself that so it's easier for you to sleep at night.
In which country in the world do terrorists hide inside hospitals, and use ambulances as private cars during wartime.
i wonder how they write this title making it like it happens naturally ....such level of hypocrisy ...
Apartheid Israel is doing that.. still the champions of human rights and democracy are silent.. very shame on you and your human rights and your so called international law.. shame on you
many of us in the West are ashamed of our complicity
This is horrific. The most moral army in the world ! What a joke 😂
You are immoral and expect others to be moral?
Edit:Al shifa hospital in ruins because of israel.
How is it Israel’s fault? Hamas were using it as battleground. It’s all on Hamas
Edit: (since you have 1 brain cell) AL Shifa Hospital in ruins because of Hamas.
@@rd123. And the Austrian painter was a saint...The easter bunny came yesterday...Santa gave me a lot of gift on christmas.😇
@@perrottaroberthat is exactly how it is
Isreali bots just took this comment section huh
It seems same like what happened on oct 7 when israeli forces opened fire on their own citizens
Delusional.
war crime 😢
And of course the Guardian always believes Hamas.
Israel lies.
@@user-pf7tf3rf1usiempre lo hizo
And still palestinian support hamas which still holds the hostages which started this conflict
Google Naqba ❤
😢😢😢😢😢Свободу Палестине😢😢😢
Free palestine INSALLAH
Insalata mista
Absolutely terrible what Israel done. No words to say anything.
Dont start a war and then cry about it
This is not terrible, the terrible will start on April 9th when the UN ceasefire resolution expires and IDF will have to go get the hostages from Rafah. Protest against Hamas if you want a chance to prevent this from happening.
@@user-fz8hq4tv7n you mean who start in 1948 Nakbah masacre?
@@user-fz8hq4tv7n Said the guy who promote genocide.
@@ZONE-fj8ly genocide of a terror. Yes
Remember Oct 7th ? NEVER AGAIN!
😂😂😂😂
Exactly never again !
Hamas, do not start a war and when the opponent humiliates you do not hide among innocent people in a hospital. 🤷♂️
This is disgraceful, what year is this meant to be?
You know that Hamas operated within this hospital right?
@@Naomi1 No evidence provided. If there is no evidence, international law says assume there isn't.
@@SentaiYamanekowtf you clearly dont check your own side social media account nor real footage from there 🤦♂️
@@Vlad-si9xs None of which showed any evidence of Hamas operating within the hospital. Going to a hospital does not count under international law. Besides, it's on Israel to present evidence (as the one assaulting the hospital and making the claim that it's being used as a base) and they provided nothing but 'trust me, bro'.
Women and children can't leave, like other war zones, crimes against humanity...😢
That title is a disgrace to journalism, as if the hospital was destroyed by someone we don’t know!
Wicked an evil.
😢😢😢
Bunch of bot accounts starting with user defending terrorism
*Now it looks like an Ex-hamas stronghold.*
Бойкот израилю😢😢😢
Israel must be held to account for the war crimes being conducted in Gaza.
And who is going to hold Hamas accountable? YOU?
let people know that they also found 500+ hammas operatives in the hospital, along with new weapons they been transferred after IDF left it the first time.
How do you know ' because they always say the truth hahah
Keep trolling. You are complicit to war crimes. There will be a day. Maybe 30 years from now. It comes faster then you think.
Liar
How is that ?
give us your source
@@brunocauz7383 Hamas 'health' said 800 people died in a hospital car park hahaha...LIARS
They are coward they can fight with innocent children and women shame on u
😢
Coward army fear from children 😂😂😂
The last thing you can say about idf. And you are lier.
Why u have not mentioned about the bodies of civilians rotting outside the hospital?
Imagine how wonderful living in here as an Ottoman Empire citizen.
Pray for the world peace❤❤❤
Lesson: Do not use hospitals as a base for fighters.
Lesson: if you are strong enough you can steal lands.
@@faontastik You cannot steal what belongs to you. Stealing is prohibited in Judaism. Do you have stronger argumentation than this?
No one believes your lies anymore
@@politicas3361 Palestinian land belongs to ... palestinian people.
So easy.
@@JamesBalmforth Maimonides said "Something is not more true if everyone believes it or less true if no one believes it"
We know what is true and that's stands independent of world opinion.
Got anything better than that ?
Why its a bad idea to support terrorists.
Shame on all the world 🌎 can you see!👀
Nah shame on those sandman 🤦♂️
Crimes against humanity !
😂😂😂
Hamas operated from inside the hospital, so it lost its protection under the laws of war.
Right , all that says idf is true.where are the tunnels
"Laws" of war of Vlad Tepes, not current international law
@@brunocauz7383 that's a very brilliant question we need someone to show us the tunnels but also we need proof that these tunnels are under al shifa hospital
You must watch only Aljerzzra where they don't show the tunnels.
@@brunocauz7383Stop watching Aljazira and you see those tunnels I promise you
This is tragic 😢. So so wrong. I can't believe most leaders around the world are allowing this to happen 😭💔
So its ok for hamas to hide in hospitals bringing the fight to the sick. Than saying ya cant fight back It's a hospital
Two weeks of fighting demonstrate that Hamas occupied the hospital and its grounds and yet the usual cohort of apologists only blame Israel. Using a protected place as a base for military operations is a war crime. But, of course, no one will mention that here!
Se los culpa de genocidio.
They have the RIGHT to defend their hospitals
@@MoHi-cx8pyyou mean from their own missile because exept this case where they literaly took it as their base with hostage even they did it themself with their 0 cell brain that swim
Google Naqba please ❤
Why should Hamas seek shelter in hospitals, when the international law granting special protection for these localities are violated consequently for half a year now?
next time don't use hospital as a terror base ,
Alright Mr genocide bot
Six months of war crimes, chronic military failure, and attempts to create victory were all a result of their failure. All of Israel's allies suffer from the humiliation of defeat, a shameful reality that will be remembered in history. 1:16 1:16
"hamas denies that it used the hospital " thats funny
IDF are looking for a terrorist named Monday. Now that is the real joke.
President Erdogan of Turkey called the Israelis "a people without honour".
A dictator should watch his mouth,,,
@@charlesayache6801los genocidas también
@@charlesayache6801 You're missing the point. Dictators are just as capable of telling the truth as anyone else. Please learn how to think.
Israel already lost the war
It was never a war.
It was not us