In my own headcannon, this is their voice actors: Thomas: John Hasler Edward: Keith Wickham Henry: Kevin Frank/Keith Wickham Gordon: Keith Wickham James: Rob Rackstraw Percy: Christopher Ragland/Nigel Pilkington Toby: Colm Feore Duck: Steven Kynman Donald and Douglas: Rob Rackstraw and Joe Mills Oliver: Joe Mills Emily: Teresa Gallagher
Not a bad cast!👍 My cast: Thomas: Eddie Glen Edward: Simon Hepworth Henry: Keith Wickham Gordon: Neil Crone James: Michael Angelis Percy: Linda Ballantyne Toby: Colm Feore Duck: Steven Kynman Donald and Douglas: Ringo Starr Oliver: Joe Mills Toad: Michael Angelis Emily: Teresa Gallagher Bill and Ben: Jonathan Broadbent Bertie: Keith Wickham Trevor: Ringo Starr The Fat Controller: Michael Angelis
here's my cast: (note that it's subject to change & gain more characters at certain points) Thomas: James Buckley Edward: Stephen Fry Henry: Robin Smith Gordon: Colin McFarlane James: Luke Marty Percy: Janet James Toby: Ben Small Duck: Tom Marshall Donald: J P Wright Douglas: Joe Mills Oliver: 10Leigh10 Emily: Elsie Lovelock Bloomer: Tress Macneille Bill: Alec Baldwin Ben: Michael Angelis Stepney: Alec Baldwin Lady: Rebecca Shoichet Harvey: Keith Wickham Arthur: Lee Cornes Murdoch: Keith Wickham Molly: Andrea Libman Neville: Kerry Shale Rosie: Sophie Aldred Stanley: David Menkin Hank: Jeff Bennett Flora: Jo Wyatt Diesel: Michael Brandon Daisy: Tracy Ann Oberman Boco: Kevin Frank Bear: Jim Howick Derek: Colin Moody Diesel 10: Rupert Degas Splatter: John Baddeley Dodge: Nigel Anthony Salty: Clancy Brown Annie: Teresa Gallagher Clarabel: Teresa Gallagher Toad: Michael Brandon Terence: Simon Greenall Bertie: Rupert Degas Trevor: George Carlin Harold: Kevin Frank The fat controller: Keith Wickham
Great ideal cast! As for mine (I also count the narrators as voices, even for the mains): John Hasler as Thomas Simon Hepworth as Edward Kevin Frank as Henry Neil Crone as Gordon Michael Angelis as James Linda Ballantyne as Percy Colm Feore as Toby Steven Kynman as Duck George Carlin as Donald & Douglas, Bill & Ben, and Trevor Joe Mills as Oliver Alec Baldwin as Toad Teresa Gallagher as Emily Keith Wickham as Bertie and The Fat Controller Also, I know this is an unpopular opinion but I find the CGI voice cast to be overrated. I don't dislike them, but people often claim these to be the best interpretations of the characters when really it's not true because most of, if not all, are just manufactured (not to mention the actors themselves are trying to put on a voice to be impressive to kids) and they keep forgetting that there are plenty of other great voices from Magic Railroad and each of the narrators which not only sound natural, but also fits the voices for all eras of Thomas. Granted, there are a few for the main characters that I like such as John Hasler as Thomas (who not only captures his character, but also sounds natural), but still.
Not a bad ideal cast. Here's mine: Thomas: Eddie Glen Edward: Noel MacNeal Henry: Kevin Frank Gordon: Neil Crone James: Luke Marty Percy: Linda Ballantyne Toby: Colm Feore Duck: Steven Kynman Donald and Douglas: George Carlin Oliver & Toad: Joe Mills Bill & Ben: Jonathan Broadbent Emily: Teresa Gallagher Trevor: George Carlin Bertie: Keith Wickham TFC: Keith Wickham
Not a bad cast, here’s mine! Thomas - Simon Nash Edward - William Hope Henry - TheRealTrampy Gordon - Richard Browning or Neil Crone James - Micheal Anglies or Rob Rackstraw Percy - Nigel Pilkington Toby - Colm Feore Duck - Steven Kynman Oliver - Alec Baldwin Donald & Douglas - Joe Mills Emily - Teresa Gallagher
My Cast: Only 1 - 6 Thomas - Eddie Glen Edward - TheRealTrampy Henry - TheRealTramy Gordon - TheRealTrampy James - TheRealTrampy Or Rob Rackstraw Percy - His TATMR Voice, TheRealTrampy Or Me
Not bad! Here's my cast: Thomas - Eddie Glen Edward - Ringo Starr Henry - Kevin Frank Gordon - Neil Crone James - Luke Marty Percy - Linda Ballentine Toby - Colm Feore Duck - Steven Kynman Donald and Douglas - George Carlin and David Tennant Oliver - Joe Mills Emily - Teressa Gallagher Toad - George Carlin Bill and Ben - Alec Baldwin and George Carlin Bertie - Kevin Frank Trevor - George Carlin The Fat Controller - Pierce Brosnan
I'm Sorry, I know this is your idea voice cast, but...Michael Angelis As Emily and George Carlin as Oliver and Toad?! Are you high?! No. Just. No. Terrible, dumb ideas! Neither of those ideas are Great. Look i know you prefer Michael Angelis & George Carlin as those voices because of nostalgia. I get it. But just because the voice is Nostalgia, it doesn't mean Great. Michael Angelis doesn't not work as Emily at all. Same goes to George Carlin as Oliver and Toad. Both are way too high pitched and too corny. Here's how i think the voice cast should go. John Hasler as Thomas (As Much as I'm nostalgic for Eddie Glenn, I gotta be honest: He's not the right fit for Thomas. Like i said, Just because the voice is Nostalgia, it doesn't mean it's Great. Eddie Glenn Is an example. He Sounds way too much like a British mickey mouse and he can get really annoying.) Rowan Atkinson as Edward ( He can work As Edward. Kevin Frank Or Hugh Laurie as Henry Neil Crone as Gordon (No One else can top Neil Crone's Gordon. Rob Rackstraw as James Rupert Grint Or Nigel Pilkington as Percy (Sorry to Linda Ballantyne fans, but she doesn't fit Percy at all.) Colm Feore as Toby Steven Kynman as Duck Craig Ferguson as Donald & Douglas (He has the perfect voice for Them.) Joe Mills as Oliver Eric Idle as Toad Lacey Chabert (US) & Kelly McDonald (UK) as Emily Jonathan Broadbent as Bill & Ben Matt Wilkinson As Trevor Keith Wickham as Bertie and The Fat Controller
In my own headcannon, this is their voice actors:
Thomas: John Hasler
Edward: Keith Wickham
Henry: Kevin Frank/Keith Wickham
Gordon: Keith Wickham
James: Rob Rackstraw
Percy: Christopher Ragland/Nigel Pilkington
Toby: Colm Feore
Duck: Steven Kynman
Donald and Douglas: Rob Rackstraw and Joe Mills
Oliver: Joe Mills
Emily: Teresa Gallagher
Not a bad cast!👍
My cast:
Thomas: Eddie Glen
Edward: Simon Hepworth
Henry: Keith Wickham
Gordon: Neil Crone
James: Michael Angelis
Percy: Linda Ballantyne
Toby: Colm Feore
Duck: Steven Kynman
Donald and Douglas: Ringo Starr
Oliver: Joe Mills
Toad: Michael Angelis
Emily: Teresa Gallagher
Bill and Ben: Jonathan Broadbent
Bertie: Keith Wickham
Trevor: Ringo Starr
The Fat Controller: Michael Angelis
here's my cast:
(note that it's subject to change & gain more characters at certain points)
Thomas: James Buckley
Edward: Stephen Fry
Henry: Robin Smith
Gordon: Colin McFarlane
James: Luke Marty
Percy: Janet James
Toby: Ben Small
Duck: Tom Marshall
Donald: J P Wright
Douglas: Joe Mills
Oliver: 10Leigh10
Emily: Elsie Lovelock
Bloomer: Tress Macneille
Bill: Alec Baldwin
Ben: Michael Angelis
Stepney: Alec Baldwin
Lady: Rebecca Shoichet
Harvey: Keith Wickham
Arthur: Lee Cornes
Murdoch: Keith Wickham
Molly: Andrea Libman
Neville: Kerry Shale
Rosie: Sophie Aldred
Stanley: David Menkin
Hank: Jeff Bennett
Flora: Jo Wyatt
Diesel: Michael Brandon
Daisy: Tracy Ann Oberman
Boco: Kevin Frank
Bear: Jim Howick
Derek: Colin Moody
Diesel 10: Rupert Degas
Splatter: John Baddeley
Dodge: Nigel Anthony
Salty: Clancy Brown
Annie: Teresa Gallagher
Clarabel: Teresa Gallagher
Toad: Michael Brandon
Terence: Simon Greenall
Bertie: Rupert Degas
Trevor: George Carlin
Harold: Kevin Frank
The fat controller: Keith Wickham
Great ideal cast!
As for mine (I also count the narrators as voices, even for the mains):
John Hasler as Thomas
Simon Hepworth as Edward
Kevin Frank as Henry
Neil Crone as Gordon
Michael Angelis as James
Linda Ballantyne as Percy
Colm Feore as Toby
Steven Kynman as Duck
George Carlin as Donald & Douglas, Bill & Ben, and Trevor
Joe Mills as Oliver
Alec Baldwin as Toad
Teresa Gallagher as Emily
Keith Wickham as Bertie and The Fat Controller
Also, I know this is an unpopular opinion but I find the CGI voice cast to be overrated. I don't dislike them, but people often claim these to be the best interpretations of the characters when really it's not true because most of, if not all, are just manufactured (not to mention the actors themselves are trying to put on a voice to be impressive to kids) and they keep forgetting that there are plenty of other great voices from Magic Railroad and each of the narrators which not only sound natural, but also fits the voices for all eras of Thomas. Granted, there are a few for the main characters that I like such as John Hasler as Thomas (who not only captures his character, but also sounds natural), but still.
quite a nice cast here's mine
Thomas:John Hasler
Edward:Keith Wickam
Henry:Hugh Laurie (Even Hugh Laurie isn't a Thomas actor)
Gordon:Keith Scott
James:Luke Marty
Percy:Nigel Pilkington
Toby:Colm Feore
Duck:Steve Kynman
Donald and Douglas:Joe Mills
Oliver:Joe Mills
Hugh Laurie as Henry: Perfect Choice. Another choice for Edward can be Rowan Atkinson.
Not a bad ideal cast.
Here's mine:
Thomas: Eddie Glen
Edward: Noel MacNeal
Henry: Kevin Frank
Gordon: Neil Crone
James: Luke Marty
Percy: Linda Ballantyne
Toby: Colm Feore
Duck: Steven Kynman
Donald and Douglas: George Carlin
Oliver & Toad: Joe Mills
Bill & Ben: Jonathan Broadbent
Emily: Teresa Gallagher
Trevor: George Carlin
Bertie: Keith Wickham
TFC: Keith Wickham
I agree with your picks, Omeed. :)
@@wiktoriazootar3241 Thanks, princess. 😘
Not a bad cast, here’s mine!
Thomas - Simon Nash
Edward - William Hope
Henry - TheRealTrampy
Gordon - Richard Browning or Neil Crone
James - Micheal Anglies or Rob Rackstraw
Percy - Nigel Pilkington
Toby - Colm Feore
Duck - Steven Kynman
Oliver - Alec Baldwin
Donald & Douglas - Joe Mills
Emily - Teresa Gallagher
My Cast: Only 1 - 6
Thomas - Eddie Glen
Edward - TheRealTrampy
Henry - TheRealTramy
Gordon - TheRealTrampy
James - TheRealTrampy Or Rob Rackstraw
Percy - His TATMR Voice, TheRealTrampy Or Me
Not bad! Here's my cast:
Thomas - Eddie Glen
Edward - Ringo Starr
Henry - Kevin Frank
Gordon - Neil Crone
James - Luke Marty
Percy - Linda Ballentine
Toby - Colm Feore
Duck - Steven Kynman
Donald and Douglas - George Carlin and David Tennant
Oliver - Joe Mills
Emily - Teressa Gallagher
Toad - George Carlin
Bill and Ben - Alec Baldwin and George Carlin
Bertie - Kevin Frank
Trevor - George Carlin
The Fat Controller - Pierce Brosnan
Too late to have George Carlin in the cast because..well, he's dead.
Neil crone as gordon
Michael E. Rodgers should voice the Scottish Twins.
I agree with you on d&d
1:58 Henry’s cgi Voice is terrible. The Uk one is good, but Casper philipson is the goat!
I honestly didn’t mind it. I thought it was a nice choice.
Nigel pilkington as percy
That's cool man
Fantastic video but where is Terrence?
He might be there in part 2 if it comes
@@wariopercy1896 Oh alright
Me personally I think George Carlin as Bill and Ben is perfect to me in my opinion and also for toad Alec Baldwin is the best.
Joe mill and rob rackshaw as Donald and Douglas.
Micheal Angelis as duck
Colin theore as toby
I would have George carinas james
Ringo as henry
Hi thomas voice in the u s is I like martin sherman
Pierce broson
Carlin
As edward
Eddie Glenn as thomas
I'm Sorry, I know this is your idea voice cast, but...Michael Angelis As Emily and George Carlin as Oliver and Toad?! Are you high?! No. Just. No. Terrible, dumb ideas! Neither of those ideas are Great. Look i know you prefer Michael Angelis & George Carlin as those voices because of nostalgia. I get it. But just because the voice is Nostalgia, it doesn't mean Great. Michael Angelis doesn't not work as Emily at all. Same goes to George Carlin as Oliver and Toad. Both are way too high pitched and too corny.
Here's how i think the voice cast should go.
John Hasler as Thomas (As Much as I'm nostalgic for Eddie Glenn, I gotta be honest: He's not the right fit for Thomas. Like i said, Just because the voice is Nostalgia, it doesn't mean it's Great. Eddie Glenn Is an example. He Sounds way too much like a British mickey mouse and he can get really annoying.)
Rowan Atkinson as Edward ( He can work As Edward.
Kevin Frank Or Hugh Laurie as Henry
Neil Crone as Gordon (No One else can top Neil Crone's Gordon.
Rob Rackstraw as James
Rupert Grint Or Nigel Pilkington as Percy (Sorry to Linda Ballantyne fans, but she doesn't fit Percy at all.)
Colm Feore as Toby
Steven Kynman as Duck
Craig Ferguson as Donald & Douglas (He has the perfect voice for Them.)
Joe Mills as Oliver
Eric Idle as Toad
Lacey Chabert (US) & Kelly McDonald (UK) as Emily
Jonathan Broadbent as Bill & Ben
Matt Wilkinson As Trevor
Keith Wickham as Bertie and The Fat Controller
Ok nice voice cast but remember it’s my opinion and it’s not that deep man, it was just a video for fun
@@wariopercy1896 I'm aware its your opinion, but it's not a good one. Especially Michael Angelis As Emily. Sorry but this is not a good idea,
At least just respect my own opinion, we are allowed to have our own opinions
@@wariopercy1896 I'm just calling like like i see it.
@@JellytoyProductionsAtleast he knows that Eddie glen is the perfect Thomas voice