Who else experienced this: I was all depressed, I had never heard of this brilliant pianist, I started listening and instantly was mesmerized by his agility, clarity and sensitivity, I got all excited and just as I started scrolling through the comments, someone posts he actually passed away. There goes my 5 minutes of happiness, life just ain't fair! :'(
I got this record when I was around 10 and at the time I thought it was pure wizardry. At 55 I still do. I couldn't imagine how anyone could get to these heights. He sure did set some unsurpassable standards in more ways than one.
At first I thought "way too fast" but after a while I changed my mind. These waltzes are brilliantly delivered and I love this performance. Call me a heretic. Fine.
The waltz was intentionally breathless as a dance. Take it from a dancer who also performed in social dancing. The waltz, you see, was INTENDED to be danced/played at such a tempo WITH the emotional variations you hear. THIS is why it was regarded as scandalous , especially by the deluded religious. Chopin was a Romantic, who would tease and improvise humorously, and KNEW he pulled tears, laughter, and every emotion. The stories, history, and observations of those who were privileged to live in his presence, exist, and even some of us miserable music students devoured all this, and as i do here, regurgitate it for you puppies.
I have been fortunate enough to have been taught by some truly amazing teachers including a world leading authority on the interpretation of Chopin and this flies in the face of everything he taught me. And, as Chopin is my favourite composer, it just makes me mad. I'm actually quite a laid back kind of guy.
One of the best interpretation of Chopin's waltzes. This recording haven't many homemade honey-accents, sugar-like melodies... Chopin's music are full of surprises, vigorous harmonical effects, somietimes a weird left-hand sequences, like Kocsis's performance here. Good job!!!
Hm, lets watch a movie today. *wants to open Netflix* *stumbels across UA-cam, clicks on this video* One hour later, I’ve spent my entire Saturday evening listing to Chopin...
Everyone keeps criticizing Kocsis about playing too fast, too loud, with too much impetus and so on. People are so boring. They have listened to Chopin and they just want to keep listening to the same literal interpretations of the oldies. They still steam in their Rubinsteins and square Ashkenazys. This interpretation is fresh, alive and with surprises. Accentuation of hidden melodies here and there. Taking passages in one breath while others would wait, tie their shoelaces and start again. I'm so glad there are pianists like Kocsis and van Oort taking Chopin in different colours.
+Archishman Ghosh You're totally right dude. I absolutely love Rubinstein, but we must give a chance to all different points of view of Chopin's art...
+Archishman Ghosh Particular mention of 19-Waltz Op.posth. B.150. The tempo is perfect, how a Waltz should be danced to. All the other UA-cam videos I've seen tend to drag the music.
+Archishman Ghosh I think is fun, but it breaks the purpose of a waltz, no one could dance to it but on the other hand no one dances waltz anymore anyway so.
Chopin waltzes are characteristic piano pieces and not for dancing. Only the first 4 waltzes are for dancing. He didn't write waltzes like the viennese did. Huneker (critic) mentions this too.
It sounds good, but it isn't how the songs are supposed to be played. For example, in the Waltz Op.64 No.2 it clearly states "tempo giusto" in the score, yet the performer fucks around with tempo like nobody's business.
"L'adieu" is the perfect title for Op. 69 No. 1. It's so melancholy, so longingly beautiful ... the first time I heard it was in the film "The Others" so I can't help but describe it as haunting, too.
Whenever Franzl didn't feel like teaching the piano, Frederic would don a blond wig and stand in for him. To make his friend laugh, Liszt would then play Chopin's waltzes at breakneck speed, and as such this performance is a triumph.
R.I.P Zoltán Kocsis. A great pianist. Two years ago, 2016, 6th November, was the day we pledged to honour his playing once and for all. Goodbye, Zoltán Kocsis!
This was always my favourite interpretation of all and every single one of Chopin's Waltzes. Absolute masterpiece. I had that on vinyl and played it so much that the needle went to the other side.
@@ItalianMappingBestMapper But you do not feel the faster tempo at the same time, it feels to be just right. It is really relaxed due to the technique of Mr. Kocsis
A perfect recording, probably even better than those of Chopin specialists like Rubinstein or Horowitz. All accents, tempos, microtimes, touches as it has to be, not more, not less.
+The Amazing Pootisman Hey, you never know who likes classical music. I mean like, I like the smoky dank may-mays and I can also list 40 something pianistic composers just off the top of my head.
AS confirmed by S.Richter the best performer during his days of enough health. Belongs in the top of Chopins -Walzer performers. Let us never forget Zoltan !!
J'aime Kocsis Zoltan, il interprète si bien Chopin. C'est une mélodie qui me berce, en même temps me passionne. Cette mélodie est aussi mélancolique. J'aime tout simplement 💟
Waltz in E min B.56...the best interpretation I have heard yet! It is not payed enough and is my favourite Chopin waltz! I'm trying to learn it but I can only dream of playing it like that!
Is it just me who sometimes feel slightly guilty that we are able to hear the posthumous waltzes? I've only performed B.150 and I felt like I was not supposed to share this with others, only play it by myself. Knowing that this waltz was supposed to be burnt, but Fontana (I think it was) chose to keep them and then after 100 years they got published... Just my opinion though. I mean Chopin was such a perfectionist, so likely these were not as bad as what he thought they were.
Well plenty of amazing posthumous works... Like Mozarts requiem, a whole bunch of Schubert works, and outside of music, the entire works of Franz Kafka.
Életem egyik zenei meghatározója fogta magát és elment... Most mihez kezdjek, amikor olyan jó "haverságban" voltunk? Remélem, Glenn Gould- dal most már együtt játszanak valami Bach kétzongorás versenyművet... Nagyon, nagyon szomorú vagyok. Isten Veled, Zoli!
He taught anyone who could afford his price, which was high, the price of a box seat at the opera. He taught a fifteen year old boy who was a real prodigy. But he died mysteriously, Back then people were dying all the time from all kinds of things. Germs. In Beethoven's time women were not allowed to perform in public, but that was changing, in Paris.
@@aidanguy2182 And yet, it is. His waltzes aren't made for dancing, they are independent pieces of music created only for interpretation. The reason he named them waltzes is because they have waltz elements like the standard waltz accompaniment, 3/4 time etc., but they're *not* made for dancing, that is a fact.
Worth listening to just to get to: Grand Valse Brilliante Op 34, No.2!!! So hauntingly beautiful!💔 And: Waltz, Op 69, No.2!!! So thrillingly poignant💔 Both are deeply moving! Thank you for posting this! ☺️❤️
Interesting you say that. Kocsis had this goal: to keep the works fresh and immediate, so the audience felt they were hearing something for the first time. It seems he achieved that goal.
I love how both Zoltan and Rubenstein bring out the bottom voice in the right hand during the Piu Mosso in 07-Waltz Op.64 No.2 (C# Minor). Zoltan chooses to do it immediately after the Piu Lento (24:10) whereas Rubenstein chooses to do it on the very last time. Interesting choice that doesn't appear to be notated - I wonder if one took it from the other, if it's a coincidence, or if it is in fact notated in certain publications.
You noticed this too!!! When I learned this waltz, I noticed the first notes in the RH of each measure were accented in the score(and as such, it is usually performed this way). However, when I played it myself I found it interesting to emphasize the last note of each measure instead (bottom voice in the RH as you describe). Upon asking my piano teacher about this, he said that doing so didn't quite fit the rhythm of the waltz, as it was emphasizing the wrong pulse and would at best be idiosyncratic. So I'm so glad you pointed this out, that even the world's best do what I wanted to do too!
@@lifestyleastherapyafterstr9423 yeah its really interesting - i think your teacher is mostly correct, though it's often those idiosyncrasies that give each player their own character. i wonder how much of it is truly intentional and how much is maybe because the thumb plays those notes and the tendency is to hit a little harder with that finger. it seems like it's extra prominent in that spot though, and those guys are so intentional with their playing I have to assume it's at least mostly on purpose
@@sziklaszilard8413 Én sajnos soha. 😥 Csak mindig csodálattal hallgattam ahol tudtam. A cisz-moll keringő az Ő előadásában tetszett a legjobban. Olyan nincs még egy...👌♥️
Ever since I heard Valentina Listisa play Op 64 No 2 too fast I thought I would never enjoy this piece unless it were slow. But this guy plays it fast and perfectly.
I'm a great admirer of the late Zoltan Kocsis mainly because he pretty much owned Bartok's highly demanding music. Whether he was a great Chopin waltzes interpreter I am less sure. These performances are brilliant, original, and sometimes provoking, but I can't help finding him impossibly rushed, to the point of being indifferent, in many places. His idiosyncrasies sometimes work well and sometimes don't. To be fair there are many great moments also. It's a mixed bag in my humble opinion. He doesn't seem to have recorded any Chopin apart from the Waltzes, which I find surprising. I had thought the Etudes would have been a more likely candidate.
I'm not an aficionado but I do love Chopin. A waltz is a dance. This performer's insanely rushed passages don't seem to me to be how Chopin would have wanted them played. The dancers would be going nuts trying to keep up and then be hit with unpredictable slow-downs at times. I'm incredulous. Too erratic and unpredictable. Just because you can play something fast doesn't mean that you should.
On the contrary, Chopin stressed to his publishers that neither his waltzes, nor his mazurkas were meant for dancing. Sure, he plays with a little bit too much rubato here and there, or he plays a little too fast on some of the pieces, which Chopin may not have approved of, I still think that Chopin would have appreciated most of these.
@@happypiano4810 yeah the fact that most of chopin's waltzes would just ruin the mood of the dance(XD everyone would get gloomy, wouldn't they lol) so in that sense i completely agree with you that these were fine. In fact, i'd even say I found a lot of them to be the best on youtube.
@@TomCatFromMA no one can dance to a lot of them even if they were played slower lol, i.e. there would naturally be more focus on the pianist than the dancers lol also if one were to dance to that for some reason beyond me, it's actually very much possible with the rubato...although yes it would differ from the traditional waltz where everything seems to be the same all throughtout.
hmm well, from what I've read of the other comments, the general opinion is that it's rushed yet still somewhat good. My opinion, however, is that this style just makes *most*(not all, the last few waltzes did feel rushed at parts, which I don't exactly mind, but the waltz in a minor tho lol) of them sound really nice! I doubt Chopin would want it to be played like that, but who cares, a pianist can have as much freedom as they want...and Zoltan, as you know, has a peculiar interpretation and style so it would feel more forced to him at slower tempi. Also to me, I've never liked recordings of Chopin's waltzes as much as I did listening to these...one might say the emotions got ruined but to me, the musicality and emotions were retained, and even more at certain parts. (now ofc consider waltz in a min posth out of whatever i said XD)
@@owennorth4045 none of those rival him, all of them except rachmaninoff are incompetent, and I wouldn't even say rachmaninoff is romantic, I'd rather say he's early modernist.
The excessive speed of some of these waltzes remind me of the Kentucky Derby race...... And ........They're .........OFF!!! Even Secretariat wouldn't have been able to keep up the speed that I hear in the Minute Waltz!! ;)
lol this comment.. It's an actually funny critique instead of all those dull ones I read. I did think some of them could have been slowed a little bit. but then this is the pianists interpretation so it's gonna be the way he wants.
I'm closing my eyes and trying to picture the dance floor where waltzing couples are trying their level best to keep up with the breakneck changes of tempo in these. . . :-) Fred .
That's because there are two versions of the waltz. One is Chopin's original autographic version, and one is Fontana's edited version. Fontana's versions are usually the ones you can find, so that's why the sheet music in the video has Fontana's version, but the original version is actually played. This is true of (at least) the following waltzes: op. 69, no. 1 op. 69, no. 2 op. 70, no. 1 op. 70, no. 2
@@tigerphantom354 I have the Urtext edition of Chopin's waltzes (G. Henle Verlag). The book has both versions for few waltzes. I'm not sure about where to find them online though. Imslp has a tab called "transcriptions and arrangements" under most pieces and maybe you'll have some luck finding it there. I'll look myself later and update my comment
the pianist is playing the urtext edition, but the video shows the Royal School Edition, BTW thanks for uploading the video as the pianist played beautifully but somehow too strong touch
Mein Lieblingswalzer ist vielleicht die Op. 34 Nr. 3. Es ist besonders interessant, wie die Melodie auf 4/4 während die 2. Spur auf 3/4 ist. Dadurch bildet sich ein 12/4 Takt, da 12 das kgV von 3 und 4 ist.
August 2024.Who's here ? One of the best interpretations of Chopin's waltzes. So beautiful. A great pianist! I've never heard of this pianist ....
Who else experienced this: I was all depressed, I had never heard of this brilliant pianist, I started listening and instantly was mesmerized by his agility, clarity and sensitivity, I got all excited and just as I started scrolling through the comments, someone posts he actually passed away. There goes my 5 minutes of happiness, life just ain't fair! :'(
He was a genius. Listen him, and your happiness will return :)
how can you not know who chopin is
@@deathkiller3671 Pianist, not Composer.
@@jorgeandrade20 Well he didn't even play that well, just speeded through everything tbh
@@deathkiller3671 your opinion. I think it sounds wonderful
I got this record when I was around 10 and at the time I thought it was pure wizardry. At 55 I still do. I couldn't imagine how anyone could get to these heights. He sure did set some unsurpassable standards in more ways than one.
If you can play it slowly, you can play it quickly, but not sacrilegiously. This one is perfect
2set🙌
haha twoset violin😂
Amo Chopin 🎶💌🙏
Piano gaaaang!
@@DrMd-jr3xt YEAH
Chopin’s 19 waltzes
No.1 op.18 0:01
No.2 op.34-1 4:50
No.3 op.34-2 9:54
No.4 op.34-3 15:26
No.5 op.42 17:33
No.6 op.64-1 21:00
No.7 op.64-2 22:35
No.8 op.64-3 25:37
No.9 op.69-1 28:13
No.10 op.69-2 31:46
No.11 op.70-1 34:37
No.12 op.70-2 36:16
No.13 op.70-3 37:50
No.14 op.posth 40:23
No.15 op.posth 43:13
No.16 op.postn 45:14
No.17 op.posth 46:25
No.18 op.posth 49:07
No.19 op.posth 50:19
(自分用)
Thanks a lot!
Oh dear.. 🙋♂️🙋♀️
Ty
日本人見っけ！
日本人意外とおるやん
At first I thought "way too fast" but after a while I changed my mind. These waltzes are brilliantly delivered and I love this performance.
Call me a heretic. Fine.
The waltz was intentionally breathless as a dance. Take it from a dancer who also performed in social dancing. The waltz, you see, was INTENDED to be danced/played at such a tempo WITH the emotional variations you hear. THIS is why it was regarded as scandalous , especially by the deluded religious.
Chopin was a Romantic, who would tease and improvise humorously, and KNEW he pulled tears, laughter, and every emotion.
The stories, history, and observations of those who were privileged to live in his presence, exist, and even some of us miserable music students devoured all this, and as i do here, regurgitate it for you puppies.
R.I.P. Zoltán Kocsis he passed away today.
yes he is my favorite chopin waltz pianist ! :(
R.I.P. Kocsis Zoltán! He was a great pianist.
Marcus Jones no
Thank fuck for that. His playing is just absolutely disgraceful!
I have been fortunate enough to have been taught by some truly amazing teachers including a world leading authority on the interpretation of Chopin and this flies in the face of everything he taught me. And, as Chopin is my favourite composer, it just makes me mad. I'm actually quite a laid back kind of guy.
The interpration is breathtaking...I think that it is the best. Bravo Maestro Kocsis!
One of the best interpretation of Chopin's waltzes. This recording haven't many homemade honey-accents, sugar-like melodies... Chopin's music are full of surprises, vigorous harmonical effects, somietimes a weird left-hand sequences, like Kocsis's performance here. Good job!!!
Yes.
I think he plays it too fast
welcome back
this is not your first time here
This is, for me, the definitive recording of Chopin's waltzes. Sure, he plays some of them quickly, but it is music to dance to.
I'd have a heart attack trying to keep up with this tempo.
@@sharonsalisbury7334 I'd risk it 😄
Hm, lets watch a movie today.
*wants to open Netflix*
*stumbels across UA-cam, clicks on this video*
One hour later, I’ve spent my entire Saturday evening listing to Chopin...
Corbis Vids
Time well spent :)
*You made the right choice*
Pootis
Just the entirely same situation right here.
Pootis
Everyone keeps criticizing Kocsis about playing too fast, too loud, with too much impetus and so on. People are so boring. They have listened to Chopin and they just want to keep listening to the same literal interpretations of the oldies. They still steam in their Rubinsteins and square Ashkenazys.
This interpretation is fresh, alive and with surprises. Accentuation of hidden melodies here and there. Taking passages in one breath while others would wait, tie their shoelaces and start again.
I'm so glad there are pianists like Kocsis and van Oort taking Chopin in different colours.
+Archishman Ghosh This is exactly what I think.
+Archishman Ghosh You're totally right dude. I absolutely love Rubinstein, but we must give a chance to all different points of view of Chopin's art...
+Archishman Ghosh Particular mention of 19-Waltz Op.posth. B.150. The tempo is perfect, how a Waltz should be danced to. All the other UA-cam videos I've seen tend to drag the music.
+Archishman Ghosh I think is fun, but it breaks the purpose of a waltz, no one could dance to it but on the other hand no one dances waltz anymore anyway so.
Chopin waltzes are characteristic piano pieces and not for dancing. Only the first 4 waltzes are for dancing. He didn't write waltzes like the viennese did. Huneker (critic) mentions this too.
Nobody plays Chopin's waltzes better. When Kocsis is your first introduction to them and you listen to the others, there is no comparison.
+Agustín Barrios Mangoré Kissin is terrible, I'll pass.
Rubinstein does it 1000x better
+Gijs Wolfs I think they are both amazing pianists. The style is only personal taste... their level of playing Chopin is definitely equal.
+nicholas72611 Kissin is definitely not terrible, if anything, I think I prefer his style of playing to Chopin's Waltzes compared to anyone else.
It sounds good, but it isn't how the songs are supposed to be played. For example, in the Waltz Op.64 No.2 it clearly states "tempo giusto" in the score, yet the performer fucks around with tempo like nobody's business.
-Grande Valse Brillante Op.34 No.2
My god, what a sound..
Well aren't you a little too sure of yourself! :D
He took it back to it's rustic roots.
Kocsis will be missed.
"L'adieu" is the perfect title for Op. 69 No. 1. It's so melancholy, so longingly beautiful ... the first time I heard it was in the film "The Others" so I can't help but describe it as haunting, too.
Ugh, his playing his elegant and smooth...I hope to be able to play music so elegantly one day...
same...
Amazing artist, very sorry to hear about his death :( RIP Kocsis Zoltán!
Oh man! every time i just hear about someone, Domenico, Fred, EVERYBODY, I find out they are dead!
@@briseboy still, we can celebrate their life and artistry by listening to their music 🎶
21:00 never seen someone play Minute Valse so freaking fast
CreepyRed Somebody's trying to play Minute Waltz in a minute lol
Same lol
BUT HE CAN'T!!!!XDXDXD
@@nurdvpn not as bad as some people trying to play 15 notes a second lol #twoset
@@clarayu5409 he did it really really clean for that tempo. Applaud for that
Ah......perfect music for a lazy Monday afternoon here in LA. Thank you for uploading this delight.
Zoltán Kocsis RIP. A great master pianist !
Such a beautiful composition.....and with what magnificence,dexterity,rawness and exquisiteness kocsis zoltan played....RIP K.Zoltan.
Whenever Franzl didn't feel like teaching the piano, Frederic would don a blond wig and stand in for him. To make his friend laugh, Liszt would then play Chopin's waltzes at breakneck speed, and as such this performance is a triumph.
Honestly hilarious, where did you learn about this?
Whether Frederic would make Liszt's female students faint is another question. It would be a nice change of pace if they didn't after all....
probably my favorite interpretation of the minute waltz.
R.I.P Zoltán Kocsis. A great pianist. Two years ago, 2016, 6th November, was the day we pledged to honour his playing once and for all. Goodbye, Zoltán Kocsis!
This was always my favourite interpretation of all and every single one of Chopin's Waltzes. Absolute masterpiece. I had that on vinyl and played it so much that the needle went to the other side.
I absolutely agree, I find the faster than normal tempo to be great and also really like the rubato. All the colors fit just right.
@@ItalianMappingBestMapper But you do not feel the faster tempo at the same time, it feels to be just right. It is really relaxed due to the technique of Mr. Kocsis
@@gliderfan6196 Exactly, it carries you forward with vitality but it doesn't feel rushed in the slightest
Thanks for the synchronized score!
A perfect recording, probably even better than those of Chopin specialists like Rubinstein or Horowitz. All accents, tempos, microtimes, touches as it has to be, not more, not less.
Chopin to najpiękniejsza spuścizna dla ludzkości. Dziękuję.
I love how the uploader has a tf2 meme profile picture. And then uploads sophisticated music. It's just hard to think of the two going like that. ;D
+Zac Clark I always thought that there was no one in the world that likes these two things both at the same time.But it seems you do! :D
Lol, your hoovy face goes perfectly with that comment.
+Zac Clark Of course it does! :P
+The Amazing Pootisman Hey, you never know who likes classical music. I mean like, I like the smoky dank may-mays and I can also list 40 something pianistic composers just off the top of my head.
+Zac Clark that's the spirit!!
AS confirmed by S.Richter the best performer during his days of enough health. Belongs in the top of Chopins -Walzer performers. Let us never forget Zoltan !!
I think i just found the best video on UA-cam ever
J'aime Kocsis Zoltan, il interprète si bien Chopin. C'est une mélodie qui me berce, en même temps me passionne. Cette mélodie est aussi mélancolique. J'aime tout simplement 💟
Waltz in E min B.56...the best interpretation I have heard yet! It is not payed enough and is my favourite Chopin waltz! I'm trying to learn it but I can only dream of playing it like that!
+Wayne Threadgate I can't even play it normally.But plannig to try waltz b.150 and b.44 . They are amazing too!
the refrain of this one sounds a lot like a minor key version of the refrain from Grande Valse Brilliante Op. 18
Is it just me who sometimes feel slightly guilty that we are able to hear the posthumous waltzes? I've only performed B.150 and I felt like I was not supposed to share this with others, only play it by myself. Knowing that this waltz was supposed to be burnt, but Fontana (I think it was) chose to keep them and then after 100 years they got published... Just my opinion though. I mean Chopin was such a perfectionist, so likely these were not as bad as what he thought they were.
Well plenty of amazing posthumous works... Like Mozarts requiem, a whole bunch of Schubert works, and outside of music, the entire works of Franz Kafka.
chopin doesnt know what he's talking about then, b. 150 is beautiful
My condolences for the passing of this great pianist. Such delicacy and brilliance in these Waltzes.
Love the ending of Op. 34 No. 1, it gives such a playful vibe, amazing job!
Poland is an amazing and special country blessed with the genius of its many artists. Much respect. Will always have a special place in my heart.
Chopins waltzes are some of my favorite music
42:50: Wow so pretty, so organisned so...
42:56: AAHHHHHH!
LMAO I laughed hahaha
@@amj.composer
wow 3 years ago, brings me back ;)
@@alexismiller2349 Recently a lot of my older comments have been resurfacing its fun to see them.
Yep
I just admired Zoltan Kocsis.s performance, I think he was a great one.
46:25 Omg I love this waltz, that simple melody is so beautiful
Composed 1826 / 1827 , the manuscript being lost during Second World War.
yes agree is one of most beautiful things i never listened to
Életem egyik zenei meghatározója fogta magát és elment...
Most mihez kezdjek, amikor olyan jó "haverságban" voltunk?
Remélem, Glenn Gould- dal most már együtt játszanak valami
Bach kétzongorás versenyművet...
Nagyon, nagyon szomorú vagyok.
Isten Veled, Zoli!
R.I.P. Kocsis Zoltán
I love these songs forever and ever and ever. Anyone just learning how to play piano, stick with Chopin. He will be good to you forever and always!
Like those waltzes, Kocsis lived his life so fast...I still miss him.
Some of Waltzes are too fast I think but it's Kocsis Zoltán's interpretation !! I love !
@Arjun Sharma :)
I have known these so superficial treasures for ages and I can't decide forget them to listen to deeper pièces. Dear master, who learns me everything.
+Ludwig Van Beethoven The salon temper.
I'm reading the Chopin biography now by Jeremy Nicholas. A great composer and a great teacher. His music teaches from beyond the grave.
Chopin would only teach girls i was told .
He taught anyone who could afford his price, which was high, the price of a box seat at the opera. He taught a fifteen year old boy who was a real prodigy. But he died mysteriously, Back then people were dying all the time from all kinds of things. Germs. In Beethoven's time women were not allowed to perform in public, but that was changing, in Paris.
+Ken Nickels But girls was the first of his priorities, and maybe they should pay less than boys !
That boy's name? Albert Einstein.
@@oOpumpkinheadOo 2070 paradigm shift?
The speed he is using is ungodly.
I think I kind of like it.
With a dance I think the tempo should stay reasonably consistent. His changes in tempo are terribly annoying. How can one dance to such seeming chaos?
@@TomCatFromMA these waltzes werent written to be danced to, rather to be performed in concerts and such
@@aidanguy2182 And yet, it is. His waltzes aren't made for dancing, they are independent pieces of music created only for interpretation. The reason he named them waltzes is because they have waltz elements like the standard waltz accompaniment, 3/4 time etc., but they're *not* made for dancing, that is a fact.
I love his interpretation of op 64 no 2 ! So beautiful !
My favourite performance of minute waltz
Breaking: Zoltán Kocsis is dead. Tremendous loss.
it's really nice to hear pianist play the warsaw autograph of op 69 -1
sublime, gentle yet energetic,,, rich in texture and subtexture,,
Elbűvölő. Koszönöm ezt a csodálatos előadást.
prob best interpretation of op 18 ive heard
¡Qué preciosura de interpretación de la esencia noble del vals! Regocijo con el nº 3 en concreto. Disfruten del legado de este gran artista.
Best Chopin performance ever. Minute waltz is the best option for a hotline in Polish Courts
Beautiful performance. Thanks
Worth listening to just to get to:
Grand Valse Brilliante Op 34, No.2!!!
So hauntingly beautiful!💔
And: Waltz, Op 69, No.2!!!
So thrillingly poignant💔
Both are deeply moving!
Thank you for posting this! ☺️❤️
Amazing performance some of them its like a hear them first time.
Interesting you say that. Kocsis had this goal: to keep the works fresh and immediate, so the audience felt they were hearing something for the first time. It seems he achieved that goal.
The E-major posth., 5th from last in this video, at around 43:13 - I have the Schirmer edition of Chopin waltzes (©1894, 1915; renewed 1922, 1943). It has 15, fingered by Rafael Joseffy.
This is the final one of the 15, and Joseffy, doubting its authenticity, declined to edit it; editing was done by Carl Mikuli. A note in a box at the top left states:
"This Valse, the authenticity of which is questioned, is inserted by the publisher, however, without Mr. Joseffy's editorial revision."
And at upper right, it is attributed: F. Chopin (1829).
My own impression, on playing it as written, was that it sounded too simplistic to be Chopin; or perhaps it was an idea he had sketched out, intending to return later to flesh out, but never got around to doing. Later collections of Chopin waltzes, both sheet music and recordings, contain this one without singling it out in any way, and seem to comprise typically 19 to 21 waltzes.
Anyone have any idea how this set of circumstances came about? Was this E major waltz questioned by anyone besides Rafael Joseffy? What was the basis of his doubt? How & when did its authenticity become established?
And why the varying number of "complete Chopin waltzes"? Were there some pieces being switched between being labeled Waltz vs Mazurka (both being 3/4)? [The 15 in the Schirmer collection are the first 15 of these 19.]
I'm aware that there are 6 lost waltzes, for which we have only the first 4 bars, due to a fire at his sister's house, where she had kept his effects after his death. I've seen those "thematic index" type entries, and none match any complete waltzes (as expected).
Fred
.
Woah. Fresh takes on the score. Some tempos are very quick, but adds liveliness to the piece.
i love this so much, every time i write papers for college i listen to this first
I love how both Zoltan and Rubenstein bring out the bottom voice in the right hand during the Piu Mosso in 07-Waltz Op.64 No.2 (C# Minor). Zoltan chooses to do it immediately after the Piu Lento (24:10) whereas Rubenstein chooses to do it on the very last time. Interesting choice that doesn't appear to be notated - I wonder if one took it from the other, if it's a coincidence, or if it is in fact notated in certain publications.
You noticed this too!!!
When I learned this waltz, I noticed the first notes in the RH of each measure were accented in the score(and as such, it is usually performed this way). However, when I played it myself I found it interesting to emphasize the last note of each measure instead (bottom voice in the RH as you describe).
Upon asking my piano teacher about this, he said that doing so didn't quite fit the rhythm of the waltz, as it was emphasizing the wrong pulse and would at best be idiosyncratic. So I'm so glad you pointed this out, that even the world's best do what I wanted to do too!
@@lifestyleastherapyafterstr9423 yeah its really interesting - i think your teacher is mostly correct, though it's often those idiosyncrasies that give each player their own character. i wonder how much of it is truly intentional and how much is maybe because the thumb plays those notes and the tendency is to hit a little harder with that finger. it seems like it's extra prominent in that spot though, and those guys are so intentional with their playing I have to assume it's at least mostly on purpose
Thanks to posting it. Very good. I love so much Chopin's Piano Pieces.
Halhatatlan Kocsis Zoltán ❤️🌹
@@sziklaszilard8413 Számomra Ő egy minden tekintetben nagy művész, nem is szoktam múlt időben fogalmazni. Nincs olyan, hogy Ő volt...
@@sziklaszilard8413 😔
@@sziklaszilard8413 jó lett volna személyesen ismerni...
@@sziklaszilard8413 Én sajnos soha. 😥 Csak mindig csodálattal hallgattam ahol tudtam. A cisz-moll keringő az Ő előadásában tetszett a legjobban. Olyan nincs még egy...👌♥️
This is pure gold dude, thanks.
Ever since I heard Valentina Listisa play Op 64 No 2 too fast I thought I would never enjoy this piece unless it were slow. But this guy plays it fast and perfectly.
Awesome really full of energy huge round of applause
17:33 very difficulte but very beautiful
I'm a great admirer of the late Zoltan Kocsis mainly because he pretty much owned Bartok's highly demanding music. Whether he was a great Chopin waltzes interpreter I am less sure. These performances are brilliant, original, and sometimes provoking, but I can't help finding him impossibly rushed, to the point of being indifferent, in many places. His idiosyncrasies sometimes work well and sometimes don't. To be fair there are many great moments also. It's a mixed bag in my humble opinion. He doesn't seem to have recorded any Chopin apart from the Waltzes, which I find surprising. I had thought the Etudes would have been a more likely candidate.
I'm not an aficionado but I do love Chopin. A waltz is a dance. This performer's insanely rushed passages don't seem to me to be how Chopin would have wanted them played. The dancers would be going nuts trying to keep up and then be hit with unpredictable slow-downs at times. I'm incredulous. Too erratic and unpredictable. Just because you can play something fast doesn't mean that you should.
On the contrary, Chopin stressed to his publishers that neither his waltzes, nor his mazurkas were meant for dancing. Sure, he plays with a little bit too much rubato here and there, or he plays a little too fast on some of the pieces, which Chopin may not have approved of, I still think that Chopin would have appreciated most of these.
@@happypiano4810 yeah the fact that most of chopin's waltzes would just ruin the mood of the dance(XD everyone would get gloomy, wouldn't they lol) so in that sense i completely agree with you that these were fine. In fact, i'd even say I found a lot of them to be the best on youtube.
@@TomCatFromMA no one can dance to a lot of them even if they were played slower lol, i.e. there would naturally be more focus on the pianist than the dancers lol also if one were to dance to that for some reason beyond me, it's actually very much possible with the rubato...although yes it would differ from the traditional waltz where everything seems to be the same all throughtout.
hmm well, from what I've read of the other comments, the general opinion is that it's rushed yet still somewhat good. My opinion, however, is that this style just makes *most*(not all, the last few waltzes did feel rushed at parts, which I don't exactly mind, but the waltz in a minor tho lol) of them sound really nice! I doubt Chopin would want it to be played like that, but who cares, a pianist can have as much freedom as they want...and Zoltan, as you know, has a peculiar interpretation and style so it would feel more forced to him at slower tempi. Also to me, I've never liked recordings of Chopin's waltzes as much as I did listening to these...one might say the emotions got ruined but to me, the musicality and emotions were retained, and even more at certain parts. (now ofc consider waltz in a min posth out of whatever i said XD)
Stravinsky's orchestral arrangement of this work is great as well!
"Chopin is the greatest of them all, for with the piano alone he discovered everything."
- Claude Debussy
! nagyON jó verzió / very good versiON :) szép dal / nice sONg !
Meggyőző / cONvincing
Chopin is absolutely unrivaled in the romantic period.
Uhhhh Liszt? Brahms? Rach? Tchaikovsky?
@@owennorth4045 none of those rival him, all of them except rachmaninoff are incompetent, and I wouldn't even say rachmaninoff is romantic, I'd rather say he's early modernist.
WOW Chopin would be proud of these performances...GREATNESS!!!
I love the Grande Valse Brilliante Opus 18 ♥♥♥
Kocsis Zoltan is the best in waltz ..
I do love his opus 64, No. 3 in A flat Major. It's light and whimsical.....very nice!
No. 1 is the best interpretation I've ever heard.
Waltz Op.posth. B.46 is heavenly, never heard it before!
Same feeling when I found this video.
Passei a adolescência ouvindo Chopin por Guiomar Novaes, todos os dias. Toquei algumas peças.
I never thought of playing it so fast, but in my opinion it doesn't lose quality after all. However, the tempo changes make them kinda interesting.
Didn’t expect to see the Heavy having uploaded the Chopin’s Waltzes
Bass Aufstieg/Abstieg:
(10:24)
(21:12) Minute Waltz Op.64 No.1
(40:29)
(40:40) walzer e moll
staccato tonrepition:
43:48
45:52
Nachschlagnoten:
44:09
Idee verziert:
50:36
23:11
(typisch Chopin)
The excessive speed of some of these waltzes remind me of the Kentucky Derby race...... And ........They're .........OFF!!! Even Secretariat wouldn't have been able to keep up the speed that I hear in the Minute Waltz!! ;)
Which makes them great for those dumb ballet stretches I used to do. It's kinda like Zumba Chopin
Zumba Chopin, this made my year sir. Thanks
lol this comment.. It's an actually funny critique instead of all those dull ones I read. I did think some of them could have been slowed a little bit. but then this is the pianists interpretation so it's gonna be the way he wants.
I'm closing my eyes and trying to picture the dance floor where waltzing couples are trying their level best to keep up with the breakneck changes of tempo in these. . . :-)
Fred
.
I thought that way at first. But his playing has grown on me (and is far better than what I can do).
Several subtle differences between Zoltan and the score.
That's because there are two versions of the waltz. One is Chopin's original autographic version, and one is Fontana's edited version. Fontana's versions are usually the ones you can find, so that's why the sheet music in the video has Fontana's version, but the original version is actually played. This is true of (at least) the following waltzes:
op. 69, no. 1
op. 69, no. 2
op. 70, no. 1
op. 70, no. 2
@@karolakkolo123 where can I get the sheet music?
@@tigerphantom354 I have the Urtext edition of Chopin's waltzes (G. Henle Verlag). The book has both versions for few waltzes. I'm not sure about where to find them online though. Imslp has a tab called "transcriptions and arrangements" under most pieces and maybe you'll have some luck finding it there. I'll look myself later and update my comment
@@karolakkolo123 thank u can you please scan the book?
I would really appreciate it if u can scan it and send it to tigerzha66@gmail.com
J'aime bien le mi bécarre ajouté par l'interprétation dans la valse de l'adieu.
+Nicolas Messina j'aime peu son interprétation...
Globalement moi non plus mais j'ai l'oeil de l'amateur.
C'est tellement beau ♡.♡
HOW IS CHOPIN SUCH A GENIUS ?
Marvellous how many waltzes Chopin wrote after he was dead!
They were published after his death. He didn't rise from his grave to compose them. LOL
@Michael Gouda yeah! :D
It could still happen some day. "Newly found manuscript by Chopin dated 2017 in his own hand?"
I love this sound so much
Air After b6
the pianist is playing the urtext edition, but the video shows the Royal School Edition,
BTW thanks for uploading the video as the pianist played beautifully but somehow too strong touch
+Aaron Chan So those things that he is doing differently is written down and not improvised?
+Archishman Ghosh yes, he played with urtext edition, but shown with Royal School edition
Mein Lieblingswalzer ist vielleicht die Op. 34 Nr. 3. Es ist besonders interessant, wie die Melodie auf 4/4 während die 2. Spur auf 3/4 ist. Dadurch bildet sich ein 12/4 Takt, da 12 das kgV von 3 und 4 ist.
I think I just broke an eyeball trying to follow these...👀
It would be nice to have the same edition as the pianist!
Imagine dedicating so much time to playing the waltzes but blazing through it as if he had to make the last train home