Hi Coach, according to the show, Zhou Shen sang that low part in the beginning of the song. That’s why he amazed everyone for him to challenge himself. He really dinged in. The other performers in the show with him this season gave him very high compliment on his performance❤❤❤❤❤❤. We’re so glad that you love it too .✌️
Zhou Shen sings with so much texture, layers and emotions. He is so sincere and genuine. You can feel that it is not put on. From your analyses, I've learned to differentiate and appreciate his skills. The way he makes everything sound effortless, yet we know that it is anything but ❤
Bravo Zhou Shen ❤ What a great, unique stage performance by Zhou Shen again. Simple stage, instruction setting, with very complex emotions, artistic vocal skills and strong sense of inner struggle. And Zhou Shen wrote the lyrics of the Chinese opera part himself Great job ❤❤❤
I love seeing Rozette on the edge of her seat listening to Zhou Shen's rendition of this song. You can tell her excitement and even a bit nervousness on her face. I think this is exactly the type of song that she's been longing for Zhou Shen to push the envelope of his vocal technique, range, ability, interpretation, execution. As a frequent listener of Zhou Shen's songs, it's one of the rare moments where your heart beats a little faster not knowing if his voice is going make it through. It's the excitement of hearing he pushes his voice near a breaking point to unfamiliar places that makes the song ultimately such an exquisite journey. As Rozette says, he REALLY digs in this time. In my opinion, he painted a vivid and heartbreaking picture of the song's story with his voice along with the dichotomy of the cello and piano, without putting on some exaggerated acting. This is definitely my favorite Zhou Shen's performance.
Teacher Rozette gets what Zhou Shen was trying to bring out in this song. He explained that he intentionally only have a piano and a cello as instruments in a way to bring out that dialogue of the inner struggle, and the two opposing voices. The Chinese opera lines refer to how one is broken through such inner struggles but managed to pick up all the pieces.
Zhou Shen has the innate for skillfully vocalizing the contents of the song. Zhou Shen mastered in connecting the story of the song to the audience. His artistry in singing let the song enduring to the listener. He a rarify musical genius.
@La-Vita You got it right. A great singer painted you a picture for the story of the song he sang. Zhou Shen sing music in an art form even I don't understand the lyrics for the songs he sing, I still have the emotional connection to the songs I listened to, somehow I generally understand what the song is about.
This is the real artistic. Not just a simple convertion. Many likes. Before today, the comments here were one sided. Glad to see that Zhou Shen's fans are coming back. 🥰🥰
Looking forward to more Charlie Zhou reactions! Definitely love Zhou Shen’s performance! Give the song a new version of life which is a great different from his other songs! Like he can deliver a great performance all the time! ❤
Dear Rozette, I am so glad that you like Shenshen too. About the reason Shenshen chose this song, I think he let out the contradictions within himself, he simply cannot please everyone, so at the end of the song, he just turned and walk away, he has come to term with himself, he will do whatever pleases him from now on! That’s just my interpretation from the lyric and the way he expressed his feelings in the song
Between a singer that has singing prowess vs a singer with singing prowess AND believability factor, i know who I would choose. Someone that has "lived experience" of being subjected to the vagaries of societal norms & expectations. Hence Zhou Shen gets my vote on this one !
I agree this is one of the most artistic performance of Zhou Shen. With only 2 instruments on stage, the dynamic texture of Zhou Shen's vocal presents an operatic scene & deep struggles of one's inner self. He is really an amazing singer, using his angelic voice to tell stories. Support Shen shen always. ❤❤
Zhou Shen sang this song in a really deep human emotionally struggle within yourself. You can feel a very raw of the different emotional stage you're in. Zhou Shen artistry brought the song to live. The Chinese opera felt you're in a calming out moment after you experienced the emotional conflict.
Huahua's version made me deeply fascinated by it for the first time, he has a charming temperament like a demon, I went to search this stage, and found that he was to commemorate the death of Shang Mengdi, the lyricist of this song, which moved me a little, thank you Shang Mengdi for creating the lyrics, giving life power to this song花花的版本讓我第壹次聽就深深的著迷了，他身上有壹種像惡魔壹樣的迷人氣質，我去搜索這個舞台，發現他是爲了紀念這首歌歌詞人尚夢迪的去世，讓我有些感動，謝謝尚夢迪老師創造的歌詞，給予了這首歌生命
Thank you so much to the teachers for another great reaction! I learnt a lot yet again listening to the teacher's review of each stage! A year ago I would not have been able to think about how or why I'd like a certain cover or not, or how to appreciate an artist's techniques and interpreation and effort put into a stage/song. Thanks to the teachers, I've been managing to appreciate music more thoughtfully. Zhou Shen's take was my first time listening to this song, so it left such a deep impression upon me. I'm not sure if it was because after so many songs and covers of him I've listened to yet I still got caught off guard by this stage, or if his interpretation of the song was so dramatically impressionable. The first time I heard it, I didn't quite understand it and only thought it seemed very artistic. Yet there was a nagging feeling of there being something caught and tangled, I felt breathless and almost excited when I listen to him, and I had to go back several more times. The raw emotions he put into the song contrasted with the simple yet gorgeous instruments made it all the more stunning. Personally, it reminded me of the feeling I got when I read Crime and Punishment by Dostoevsky (my absolute favourite book). It was an opressing, overwhelming feeling of breathlessness, a certain sense of raw despair and agony of being torn in between. I'm not sure if this is what the song is conveying since I don't know the lyrics, but it's what I've felt listening to it.
Zhou Shen explained that he intentionally only has a piano and a cello as instruments in a way to bring out that dialogue of the inner struggle, and the two opposing voices. The Chinese opera lines refer to how one is broken through such inner struggles but managed to pick up all the pieces.
the traditional Chinese opera lyrics and music part was written by Zhou Shen ( Charlie) : "Seek...that right person Listen...wishing you pick yourself up and make it whole" This feeling of being completed inside and not having to look for self-identity everywhere, not burning or exploding... Whether it's crazy or peaceful, Accept everything about yourself That's the main core of this song Zhou Shen’s understanding and interpretation of songs and lyrics are comprehensive, in-depth and unique.
It's not a track. He really sang live by himself because his range is very wide. If you heard one of his latest songs called 'I'm Star' from Disney then you will know in this performance, he sang the whole song live without the track as you guys think. Thank you for reacting to Zhou Shen.
I reckon they know Zhou Shen was singing live. What they discussed was the double vocal effect in the first verse. They believed Zhou Shen was singing live on his own pre-recorded, rather than using production effect to replicate another track.
Personally Zhoushen presented the best cover for this song Exactly with what you analysed. Just love the way Zhoushen brought in the Very Spirited Art presentation in the torn spirit within. Zhoushen intentionally lowered his voice from the very beginning and added some wild vocal effects at certain stanzas to bring forth the struggle spirit within. The tune and lyrics in the Beijing Opera melody were inspired composed and added by Zhoushen “Seek! The kind man within you Listen! Hope you pick up all you have lost….. (Meaning be your kind self and not being manipulated around) I love Zhoushen covering BEST! From Singapore.
Also he purposely chose to use only the cello and piano for accompaniment so that he could bring forth the life and spirit of the song through his vocal artistry ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Even with just a piano and cello, Zhou Shen can produce so many colours and layers and emotions! Totally different from the original singer, who is good too!
I would say apart from original singer Chen Li, Hua Chenyu has the best performance!!! Not only his adaptation, his articulation, his emotion... I remembered have 2 LIVE performance, one from Singer 2018 and “The Next天籁之战”, is so impressive!!
About the "flammable and explosive", the traditional Chinese opera lyrics and music part was written by Zhou Shen ( Charlie) : "Seek...that right person Listen...wishing you pick yourself up and make it whole" This feeling of being completed inside and not having to look for self-identity everywhere, not burning or exploding... Whether it's crazy or peaceful, Accept everything about yourself That's the main core of this song Zhou Shen’s understanding and interpretation of songs and lyrics are comprehensive, in-depth and unique.
This theatrical rendition brings me chills and inspiration. It’s like watching a musical. Lots of people are pulled between what they want and what others want for them. They struggle with conflicting voices telling them what to do in life. These people can feel shackled, confused, lost, self-doubtful, dejected, despair, and even rage. Zhou Shen Charlie’s message is that we should live life the way we want, not what others want. What we think of ourselves is what really matters. No one is perfect. Accept ourselves and love ourselves as we are. What a powerful, stunning performance by Zhou Shen Charlie!
Thanks for the comments. For the record, Hua Chenyu sang this song on the TV show “The Singer 2018” to show his respect for the passing on of one of the composer. It’s a very sad song during that time.
Your comments about the Zhou Shen’s voice mimic a string instrument is very very very on point. THE MOST UNIQUE characteristic of Chinese operas is that it’s always using human voice to mimic a string instrument in the band, usually a 二胡/板胡/京胡。 go listen to any Beijing opera, then you will find out that the human voice is ALWASY mimic a instrument. This actually goes deep into Chinese music philosophy: 八音克諧， 金聲玉震， 絲竹和鳴。 basically traditional Chinese music is not about tempo or melody, but about creating a simple harmonic sound that using different instruments, including human voice, that has different materials thus different timbre, and let them mix into one single note : harmony, the sound of universe. You could find the same aesthetic from any Guqin music. you have very good ears and music sensitivity! Mimicking instrument is part of ancient Chinese music aesthetic/philosophy
I prefer Zhou Shen's version the most. The simplified rearrangement is very elegant, showcasing various vocal tones and delivering a brilliant interpretation of inner struggles. It's worth mentioning that both the song and lyrics of the Chinese opera part are created by Zhou Shen.
I'm so happy that you love Zhou shen too!! Zhou shen ＆ Liang Long performed “Heartless you”, that is another special and playful performance of Zhou Shen. That performance contains classic Chinese opera and rap and so much fun! Hope that you can do the reaction
Hua Chenyu is amazing. I flew from Germany to China last year to experience 2 of his amazing Mars concerts. It was mindblowing. Best concerts I have ever been too. And I was at many concerts from many different artists in my life. His Mars concerts are on another level. His music, especially his own compositions are awesome, interesting and it never gets boring to listen to his music. I am so happy I found Hua Chenyu 5 years ago.
因為周深才聽到這首歌，在這個視頻有幸看了5位歌手對這首歌的演繹，陳粒是原唱，除了周深的我最喜歡她的演繹，她唱出了這首歌的靈魂，而翻唱我比較喜歡周深的，他的舞台音樂配置簡單，全首歌就靠他的歌聲演唱支撐，這是一個很有藝術性的舞台，讓我著迷了。
青菜蘿蔔各有所好！
我喜歡周深的版本，簡單高雅的樂音，不需大聲嘶吼，或誇張的肢體，以一個人多變的嗓音及紮實的唱功就撐起全部表演，完美詮釋原著想要表達的意境。音域極寬，挑戰自我極限，自己加上的戲腔及歌詞，更收畫龍點睛之效，絕美！❤❤❤
周深唱出了自己的理解，表达的淋漓尽致👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
認同
优美又有深度的演绎🤩💖
是的，大声嘶吼，其实是摇滚曲风的演唱方式
我是一位不太懂藝術音樂的老人(雖然我是深深的粉絲)，從他第一次唱時我是不太懂為何要唱成那麼低音，但老師的觧說讓我懂很多歌唱的技巧舆表現。謝謝橘子老師的解說讓我這個老人懂的很多。
周深紮實的唱功、頂級的歌唱技巧 融入了完整的情緒表達，賦予這首歌靈魂和音樂劇般的故事性，周深果然唱的最好最動聽最感人。
這首歌第一次聽，最後周深的演繹令人印象深刻，整个改編編排很好,初聽感覺有多重人物在爭出來說話,一个人的音樂劇!喜歡周深永遠有新嘗試，總帶給人驚奇!
深深是音樂界中我的最愛
@@cecilialee7215蜜免，我只聽深聲。😂😂😂❤❤❤。
ua-cam.com/video/uLl1ewWh3Gk/v-deo.htmlsi=24tzrzjuvB6f8CT4
這是訪問周深為何選此曲，也包含了他為什麼這樣設計，前面的超低八度是無奈無力的表達，是他本人的真唱，片內的rehearsal 片段令我知道的。既然老師這麼喜歡，了解多一點就更能提升欣賞的層次了。還有他為什麼加上劇曲在間奏和他填上這兩句辭的含意，太有意思了！❤鼓勵喜歡此曲的人去看看這短短的訪問。
up
顶，真的觉得他好有音乐想法，也很开心看到他现在越来越不被其他人的看法所左右
👍
陈粒在演唱这首歌的时候，是以女性的视角，一个独立女性看到对方把戏。这首歌述说的是男性对女性矛盾的要求，歌词每一句都是矛盾的，要我怎么样，又要我怎么样。比如赐我梦境，却要我很快清醒。其实是一个女性已经把另一半的要求看得很清楚了，一切了然的心境。因为歌词太过矛盾，所以很暗黑与戏剧。从周深的角度，他唱了三个角色，第一个最低的声音就像我们心里住的恶魔，还有一个女性的视角，一个男性的视角。因为歌曲本身的矛盾性，所以周深唱成了这样。戏曲的部分是最出彩的部分，不仅是因为周深唱得很好，更重要的是歌词是对前面所有歌词的回答。最后说：寻，良人，听，拾起你内心的全部，是说找到自己的良配，通俗一些的说是找到彼此相爱与适合的人，拾起内心的全部，意思找回内心自正的自我。这是一种思考，一种顿悟，一种洒脱。陈粒是中国民谣第一女歌手，是特立独行的唱作人，但她并不是最流行的歌手。她的歌以歌词内容见长，喜欢她的人，都是喜欢她歌词所讲的故事，表达的情绪，情感共鸣。
同频人我是
Hi Coach, according to the show, Zhou Shen sang that low part in the beginning of the song. That’s why he amazed everyone for him to challenge himself. He really dinged in. The other performers in the show with him this season gave him very high compliment on his performance❤❤❤❤❤❤. We’re so glad that you love it too .✌️
周深易燃易爆炸是說出每個人的內心存在矛盾，用歌曲表達出來，他真真正正是一個音樂人！😍😍😍
音樂家💯💯💯
Zhou Shen sings with so much texture, layers and emotions. He is so sincere and genuine. You can feel that it is not put on. From your analyses, I've learned to differentiate and appreciate his skills. The way he makes everything sound effortless, yet we know that it is anything but ❤
他有多努力才让这些看起来毫不费力啊
是的，他看上去的 effortless 都是透過他的努力和熱情去做就的，喜歡周深唱歌，更喜歡他的人品修養努力堅持不計得失的態度 ❤❤
喜歡周深!!非常有藝術性和突破的一次演唱，好喜歡第一段低音和戲腔，中間的一些尾音的加重處理也好帥。只能說，整首歌的編排和演唱的真的是懾人心魄。永遠支持周深深!有實力又努力~
Unbeatable. Highly preferred
Bravo Zhou Shen ❤ What a great, unique stage performance by Zhou Shen again. Simple stage, instruction setting, with very complex emotions, artistic vocal skills and strong sense of inner struggle. And Zhou Shen wrote the lyrics of the Chinese opera part himself
Great job ❤❤❤
I love seeing Rozette on the edge of her seat listening to Zhou Shen's rendition of this song. You can tell her excitement and even a bit nervousness on her face. I think this is exactly the type of song that she's been longing for Zhou Shen to push the envelope of his vocal technique, range, ability, interpretation, execution. As a frequent listener of Zhou Shen's songs, it's one of the rare moments where your heart beats a little faster not knowing if his voice is going make it through. It's the excitement of hearing he pushes his voice near a breaking point to unfamiliar places that makes the song ultimately such an exquisite journey. As Rozette says, he REALLY digs in this time. In my opinion, he painted a vivid and heartbreaking picture of the song's story with his voice along with the dichotomy of the cello and piano, without putting on some exaggerated acting. This is definitely my favorite Zhou Shen's performance.
我覺得一首歌好不好听在于代入感和共鸣感，每個人都有聽歌的个別喜好。像我喜歡听歌剧，古典音樂，不是很喜歡流行曲！ 但我听了四首下來，讓我有感觉想聽完的只有第四首！像老師說的前奏好美，整首歌的編排像我愛的歌剧只用了簡單的樂器，主角是vocal . 而且很有层次和张力的表演！我一向來都很颀賞老师的点評，因她的評語每次都一針見血，很直接，𣎴像其它reaction 。支持老師！❤❤為她点贊
周深的舞台是最簡單的，只有鋼琴及大提琴及他自己，没有大隊樂隊及和音，出來的感覺就是動聽及藝術性，真棒👍👍👍
+1 周深真的很棒，我也很喜欢周深唱这首歌💕💕💕
+1❤
周深清唱也十分棒❤
周深就一台钢琴和一个大提琴就靠自己的唱功创造出迷幻、撕扯和歌剧的高级效果，周深永远在进步，不断尝试，不断突破，不断更新，确实当得上内娱新生代第一人
+1
+1
唱商高、情商高、人品又好
非常贊同
同感
Teacher Rozette gets what Zhou Shen was trying to bring out in this song. He explained that he intentionally only have a piano and a cello as instruments in a way to bring out that dialogue of the inner struggle, and the two opposing voices. The Chinese opera lines refer to how one is broken through such inner struggles but managed to pick up all the pieces.
Hope Rozette read your comment.
Thank you for explaining the opera lines which I don’t understand 🙏👍💕
周深的大膽改編讓這首歌升上另一層次，是一個十分完美的舞台演出、不可替代的藝術品。
人耳喜歡聽高音的華麗，因爲讓人輸導情緒；也喜歡低音的節奏，因它能讓人鎮定！周深突破自我限定，練就超低音，從音樂性而言，周深的技能是頂級的，從藝術性而言，更是無以倫比的完美！周深實在是難能可貴的音樂人啊🎶💖👍💜
我最愛周深的版本，但我也同意其他版本唱得很棒。 Rozette老師很專業，但對中國京劇風格不太熟悉，較難體會周深加入戲腔之後的魅力，類似的還有如光亮、算你狠、蘭亭序......等，稍微可惜了些。
我最喜欢周深的版本🥰🥰🥰，很好听但是有一点短没听够🫣。 老师看周深唱都坐直了🤭，很兴奋的👀。我中间的Chinese opera 不懂，不过很好听我喜欢💕💕💕
感謝 周深 加入戲腔，讓整首歌曲有了回饋；回歸和諧平衡的自己！ 祝福大家 元宵節愉快！
周深是用全身的细胞去感受一首歌，通过他自己的理解，结合制作团队的共同努力，放大一首歌原本的意境和立意，是一个真诚的歌者，可以演绎一个人的舞台剧。 他总能挖掘塑造一首歌更深层的内涵，编排出其他歌手达不到的意境， 让听者和他一起升华。深深，赶快来北美开演唱会啊 ❤😂
+1
不，要來香港開演唱會先😊
中国都开不起了，北美就算了吧
說得好，希望周深也快來香港開演唱會
@@ft4352去香港开我也会去看😊
為周深而來🥰
喜歡原唱"陳粒"和翻唱"周深"的版本
但老師有句話說得不錯-->"每個人都是粉絲眼中的神"👍
以前从来没有注意过这首歌， 因为周深，我在听他唱之前就把以前所有的版本都听了一遍，最后周深的改编非常惊艳，这首歌是一件艺术品，很成功的表达， 很棒的舞台，完美的演绎~~~我看到了一个人的挣扎， 以及歌者的进步，加油周深💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
周深版本全都是他自己編排的，包括選這兩種樂器編曲，中間的戲曲跟歌詞都是周深寫的
我們家深寶寶是最優秀的唱將。😂😂😂❤❤❤。
厲害
周深工作室刚刚官宣@卡布叻_周深 全新个人专辑即将推出，惊喜总是来得很突然啊，一把子期待住了！
听周深的演唱常感觉自己忘记了呼吸，他的声音有种力量把人带入音乐里，是位难得的艺术家❤
同意
Zhou Shen has the innate for skillfully vocalizing the contents of the song. Zhou Shen mastered in connecting the story of the song to the audience. His artistry in singing let the song enduring to the listener. He a rarify musical genius.
但最特别的是每首歌里都有治愈或者温暖 的感觉。他表达情感的方式很特别，总可以能让我开心地笑，或者泪流满面时幸福笑。无论歌词如何让我心碎，我总能感受到一丝希望， 学习到东西。这是情绪和艺术沉积吗？！
@La-Vita You got it right. A great singer painted you a picture for the story of the song he sang. Zhou Shen sing music in an art form even I don't understand the lyrics for the songs he sing, I still have the emotional connection to the songs I listened to, somehow I generally understand what the song is about.
@@victorhuynh4031 我比你幸运一点，因为我的母语与中文非常接近，所以学习起来就没呢么难。我真的不得不承认生米们说是对的。如果你能听懂他唱的每一个词、每句话，你的感受会更深刻。如果你听他的英文歌的时，你一定会更清楚地理解到这一点。我学中文越多，我就越意识到他的努力🥹
周深的每一次翻唱都会带给每首歌新的生命力❤❤❤喜欢老师们真诚的点评👍
My favorite musician ! He is one of a kind. Amazing performance ! ❤ Zhou Shen ❤
虽然老师是周深的粉丝(well, 有人认为可能有滤镜)，虽然有语言的隔阂, 但是, 老师通过这个几分钟的舞台, 能读懂了周深在这首歌想要表达的意境(周深在节目中有说), 太厉害了❤👍
周深太厉害了，整个舞台整个音乐人声的配合，短短几分钟就呈现了一种电影质感和意境, 把这首歌多维度地演绎得更有艺术张力👍❤️🌹
佩服老师！听不懂中文却get到周深要表达！厉害👍🏻
周深版本賦予這首歌新的生命，非常有藝術性，老師的鑑賞力真的一流
老師感受力好強
This is the real artistic. Not just a simple convertion. Many likes.
Before today, the comments here were one sided. Glad to see that Zhou Shen's fans are coming back. 🥰🥰
Looking forward to more Charlie Zhou reactions! Definitely love Zhou Shen’s performance! Give the song a new version of life which is a great different from his other songs! Like he can deliver a great performance all the time! ❤
Zhou Shen is always the best! added 'colour' to the song, showing his superb voice control in presenting this song in his unique way...superb!!
最喜歡周深的版本，四兩撥千斤，提琴，鋼琴，歌聲，融為一體，令人感同身受，靈魂深陷其中！
周深版本是最精彩🎉🎉，他在聲生不息說要用此歌曲唱出內心的拉扯，是真正的藝術家👏👏👏👍👍👍
周深的版本，人和樂器搭配的非常好，整首聽下來音樂性非常的豐富，非常喜歡這種像一齣音樂劇且有極佳唱功支撐的歌曲。
周深真得实在能力太强，还喜欢挑战自己，太有追求了。喜欢到不行了。能和他在一个时代，真是太棒了。
Dear Rozette, I am so glad that you like Shenshen too. About the reason Shenshen chose this song, I think he let out the contradictions within himself, he simply cannot please everyone, so at the end of the song, he just turned and walk away, he has come to term with himself, he will do whatever pleases him from now on! That’s just my interpretation from the lyric and the way he expressed his feelings in the song
不知道會不會出一集周深合唱大比較😂😅😊
覺得「算你狠」,「末日飛船」，「聽那片海」，「她是黯淡星」，「自由行走的花」，「彩色的黑」，「愛情轉移」，「星際列車」⋯⋯⋯
一堆合唱歌都值得老師點評賞析❤😊🎉
每个歌手都会有粉丝。周深已经远远超越了歌手本身，他的艺术性、表现力、戏剧性、创造性、娱乐性、vocal的高超技艺、个人修养，是这个时代的最强音，可以说是中国乐坛的代表！很多国外的音乐人，只从周深的声音就能给出很多很多艺术层面的分析和赞赏，他唱的英语、日语、印度语、意大利语、俄语、乌克兰语、波兰语，都没有违和感。我们祝福周深吧！
❤❤💯
是！💖周深💖很棒👍💯
能走向世界的中國歌手，非周深莫屬❤️❤️❤️❤️
因为周深我才听华语歌，平时都听英语歌。Totally agree 周深可以代表中国乐坛走向全世界👍👍👍 期待周深开国外的演唱会🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
说得好❤
周深唱的最後一句 “还怨我徒...有泪流”， “徒”和“有”中间那个要耳机才听得见的哽咽 (37:30)，已经把这首歌升华到另一个層次。是最刺到心里的音符， 完美！
這裡真是神來一筆，很拉扯。
真牛
抽泣聲 好一點音響也可以聽到
I really enjoyed all CZ Media reaction videos. So true, yet natural. Of course, I like 周深’s reactions the most. 😍
This was the stage that Zhou Shen suggested, with simple two instruments and him, to show what the inner world is....great, touching performance!
Zhou Shen's performance is rated higher than the original singer. Coach Rozette reads most of the crucial things Zhou Shen has tried to deliver. 🎉🎉🎉
周深說過：原唱是無法超越的！
周深是非常尊重原唱，原唱陳粒是以女性角度去創作這首歌曲，很棒！而周課是以每個人會對外界不同的人的指點無所適從的茫然、不知所措，甚至遺失自己的本性為出發點去創作改編，兩者不同，所以我喜歡原唱陳粒和周深！
簡簡單單的配器，周深的歌聲和樂器的呼吸一致，讓聽的人一秒入戲~陳粒又酷又颯，風格明顯，酷爆!
很多音樂人都對周深的翻唱給予高度評價，真的很讚
Between a singer that has singing prowess vs a singer with singing prowess AND believability factor, i know who I would choose. Someone that has "lived experience" of being subjected to the vagaries of societal norms & expectations. Hence Zhou Shen gets my vote on this one !
这老师很可爱，一看到周深就眉开眼笑的，就跟学校老师看到了高考状元学霸一样怎么看怎么顺眼，没什么好多说的，反正就是心头好
Love Zhou Shen, great performance👍👍❤❤
I agree this is one of the most artistic performance of Zhou Shen. With only 2 instruments on stage, the dynamic texture of Zhou Shen's vocal presents an operatic scene & deep struggles of one's inner self. He is really an amazing singer, using his angelic voice to tell stories. Support Shen shen always. ❤❤
看到最後好有趣，老師現在完全成了周深粉絲了😂😂😂，看得出來是有多愛
木耳罷了
@@Huamazing你都是🦃️了，還管人家什麼耳？
哈哈哈 评论里都看到酸鸡😂😂😂
@@Huamazing 跳大神粉丝来了😅
@@马丽-v9c 你們可以不要把你們飯圈低俗的互撕文化帶到國外丟臉嗎？
Zhou Shen sang this song in a really deep human emotionally struggle within yourself. You can feel a very raw of the different emotional stage you're in. Zhou Shen artistry brought the song to live. The Chinese opera felt you're in a calming out moment after you experienced the emotional conflict.
我最愛周深的版本，太有創意了~兼具藝術性😍
I like Zhou Shen’s singing the most, thank you for reacting to this song, I have been waiting this for a long time~~~~ He is artist❤❤❤❤
陈粒在演唱这首歌的时候，是以女性的视角，一个独立女性看到对方把戏。这首歌述说的是男性对女性矛盾的要求，歌词每一句都是矛盾的，要我怎么样，又要我怎么样。比如赐我梦境，却要我很快清醒。其实是一个女性已经把另一半的要求看得很清楚了，一切了然的心境。因为歌词太过矛盾，所以很暗黑与戏剧。从周深的角度，他唱了三个角色，第一个最低的声音就像我们心里住的恶魔，还有一个女性的视角，一个男性的视角。因为歌曲本身的矛盾性，所以周深唱成了这样。戏曲的部分是最出彩的部分，不仅是因为周深唱得很好，更重要的是歌词是对前面所有歌词的回答。最后说：寻，良人，听，拾起你内心的全部，是说找到自己的良配，通俗一些的说是找到彼此相爱与适合的人，拾起内心的全部，意思找回内心自正的自我。这是一种思考，一种顿悟，一种洒脱。陈粒是中国民谣第一女歌手，是特立独行的唱作人，但她并不是最流行的歌手。她的歌以歌词内容见长，喜欢她的人，都是喜欢她歌词所讲的故事，表达的情绪，情感共鸣。
周深的很cool, 有自己的元素, 他的vocal很厲害,簡單琴音加上他純vocal便能撐起整首歌
Really better than the original
Huahua's version made me deeply fascinated by it for the first time, he has a charming temperament like a demon, I went to search this stage, and found that he was to commemorate the death of Shang Mengdi, the lyricist of this song, which moved me a little, thank you Shang Mengdi for creating the lyrics, giving life power to this song花花的版本讓我第壹次聽就深深的著迷了，他身上有壹種像惡魔壹樣的迷人氣質，我去搜索這個舞台，發現他是爲了紀念這首歌歌詞人尚夢迪的去世，讓我有些感動，謝謝尚夢迪老師創造的歌詞，給予了這首歌生命
华晨宇是一个优秀的艺术家
Good to see that there are so many support here
still.
Huahua is not real artist. His song called as cancer 癌 demonstrate that actually he is a psycho.
I love Hua hua's version
Love Huahua's version
Thank you so much to the teachers for another great reaction! I learnt a lot yet again listening to the teacher's review of each stage!
A year ago I would not have been able to think about how or why I'd like a certain cover or not, or how to appreciate an artist's techniques and interpreation and effort put into a stage/song. Thanks to the teachers, I've been managing to appreciate music more thoughtfully.
Zhou Shen's take was my first time listening to this song, so it left such a deep impression upon me. I'm not sure if it was because after so many songs and covers of him I've listened to yet I still got caught off guard by this stage, or if his interpretation of the song was so dramatically impressionable.
The first time I heard it, I didn't quite understand it and only thought it seemed very artistic. Yet there was a nagging feeling of there being something caught and tangled, I felt breathless and almost excited when I listen to him, and I had to go back several more times.
The raw emotions he put into the song contrasted with the simple yet gorgeous instruments made it all the more stunning.
Personally, it reminded me of the feeling I got when I read Crime and Punishment by Dostoevsky (my absolute favourite book). It was an opressing, overwhelming feeling of breathlessness, a certain sense of raw despair and agony of being torn in between. I'm not sure if this is what the song is conveying since I don't know the lyrics, but it's what I've felt listening to it.
Zhou Shen explained that he intentionally only has a piano and a cello as instruments in a way to bring out that dialogue of the inner struggle, and the two opposing voices. The Chinese opera lines refer to how one is broken through such inner struggles but managed to pick up all the pieces.
the traditional Chinese opera lyrics and music part
was written by Zhou Shen ( Charlie) :
"Seek...that right person
Listen...wishing you pick yourself up and make it whole"
This feeling of being completed inside
and not having to look for self-identity everywhere,
not burning or exploding...
Whether it's crazy or peaceful,
Accept everything about yourself
That's the main core of this song
Zhou Shen’s understanding and interpretation of songs and lyrics are comprehensive, in-depth and unique.
周深令我喜愛這首歌，他的版本簡直是一場舞台盛宴
😊 I'm maybe a bit bias but I will always choose Zhou Shen because I dunno well the other singers 😅 like i dunno if i've heard them
周深把這首歌唱的與原唱完全不同~~周深對這首歌的詮釋我喜愛❤❤❤
Zhou Shen’s performance absolutely brings this song to another level!
這個表演完全是周深自己的編排，展現了他個人的音樂审美與對歌曲歌詞的領悟，對人性的領悟。
Can’t agree with you more on this! Somehow Zhou Shen’s singing just touch my soul! Thank you for sharing your opinions! ❤ Love and respect 🫡
It's not a track. He really sang live by himself because his range is very wide. If you heard one of his latest songs called 'I'm Star' from Disney then you will know in this performance, he sang the whole song live without the track as you guys think. Thank you for reacting to Zhou Shen.
I reckon they know Zhou Shen was singing live. What they discussed was the double vocal effect in the first verse. They believed Zhou Shen was singing live on his own pre-recorded, rather than using production effect to replicate another track.
@@vivianwong754我也以為是說開始的低音部份，也是周深現場唱的呀
Personally
Zhoushen presented the best cover for this song
Exactly with what you analysed.
Just love the way Zhoushen brought in the
Very Spirited Art presentation in the torn spirit within.
Zhoushen intentionally lowered his voice from the very beginning
and added some wild vocal effects at certain stanzas to bring forth
the struggle spirit within.
The tune and lyrics in the Beijing Opera melody were inspired composed and added
by Zhoushen
“Seek! The kind man within you
Listen! Hope you pick up all you have lost…..
(Meaning be your kind self and not being manipulated around)
I love Zhoushen covering BEST!
From Singapore.
Also he purposely chose to use only the cello and piano for accompaniment
so that he could bring forth the life and spirit of the song
through his vocal artistry ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
百变周深！ 还记得听周深唱这首歌的第一句时，内心的那种震撼！周深永远不会令人失望❤
Even with just a piano and cello, Zhou Shen can produce so many colours and layers and emotions! Totally different from the original singer, who is good too!
周深唱的版本令我爱上这首歌❤循环听到今天，欲罢不能！每字每句，吐气和音都有周深想表达的东西，入迷！就像看了场短的歌剧音乐剧的感觉，舞台盛宴❤❤
I would say apart from original singer Chen Li, Hua Chenyu has the best performance!!! Not only his adaptation, his articulation, his emotion... I remembered have 2 LIVE performance, one from Singer 2018 and “The Next天籁之战”, is so impressive!!
Unfortunately all three hosts do not rate him high!
You're right, he's really great!!
I love hua hua' performance
There is another version from his Mars Concert on 2/7 /2016 at Beijing. Total 3 versions
@@Truth2011sgrather than showcase the skill, there is nothing to appraise.
陳粒這場很有意思，比起MV更好；另外就是周深很有層次感，覺得戲腔很絕，個人而言最喜歡這兩個
［資訊補充與更正］
感謝老師的點評！易燃影爆炸是個人十分喜歡的歌曲，能看到老師的點評十分高興！
然而看到老師在聽到原曲時有說到：「相信前面翻唱的兩位（加入歌劇部分）應該有受到原曲的啟發」，這點是錯誤的，所以在此想作出補充，並希望頻道能把背景資訊告知老師。
易燃易爆炸是陳粒老師在2015年發布的歌曲，原曲並沒有歌劇的部份；而加入歌劇改編的第一人，其實是老師看的第一位歌手--華晨宇加入的。
相比起老師選取的2018歌手版本，華晨宇的首次改編是在2016年［天賴之戰］中發表的。節目中，參與節目的歌手僅僅只有一晚時間可以改編抽選到的歌曲，所以參演的歌手們全也十分厲害呢！
而當中，華在節目中「首次」為易燃易爆炸加入了歌劇式的唱法，令歌曲變得更有戲劇性--而戲劇性及畫面感，也是華的歌曲中的拿手好戲。
點評中選取的原唱影片是4年前（YT上傳時間）陳粒老師的現場影片，同時本人也有找到陳粒老師在4年前有發布的MV，相信是一個翻新的版本呢。此外，本人在網上找到及粒老師有加入歌劇演繹部份的版本，最早是在2018年歌手時發布的。
以上、如果資訊有誤還請各位指出！謝謝！
,聽完這幾個版本，華的比較戲劇，黃玲的妖魅又炸，很喜歡原唱的作曲，深深的版本集合了以上版本所有優點，還把前面三個版本的中間吟唱補的那麼淒美，客觀的說，我最愛深深的版本。❤❤❤
周深❤
周深❤
❤️Zhou Shen performance from Malaysia! He is such a great singing artist!!!
Bravo 周深❤ 他一直不断在尝试和突破。惊艳的舞台💐
About the "flammable and explosive",
the traditional Chinese opera lyrics and music part
was written by Zhou Shen ( Charlie) :
"Seek...that right person
Listen...wishing you pick yourself up and make it whole"
This feeling of being completed inside
and not having to look for self-identity everywhere,
not burning or exploding...
Whether it's crazy or peaceful,
Accept everything about yourself
That's the main core of this song
Zhou Shen’s understanding and interpretation of songs and lyrics are comprehensive, in-depth and unique.
This theatrical rendition brings me chills and inspiration.
It’s like watching a musical.
Lots of people are pulled between what they want and what others want for them. They struggle with conflicting voices telling them what to do in life. These people can feel shackled, confused, lost, self-doubtful, dejected, despair, and even rage.
Zhou Shen Charlie’s message is that we should live life the way we want, not what others want. What we think of ourselves is what really matters. No one is perfect. Accept ourselves and love ourselves as we are.
What a powerful, stunning performance by Zhou Shen Charlie!
终于等到这期周深的版本reaction。我就知道老师喜欢！
很多專業音樂人士都喜歡周深版❤
Yes, she always has those emotion when listening to Shen Shen”s song😂 I believe she loves this
Hahaha Ms Rozette, your face really brightened and smiled happily when reacting to Zhou Shen. Can see the love you have for his performances
Thanks for the comments. For the record, Hua Chenyu sang this song on the TV show “The Singer 2018” to show his respect for the passing on of one of the composer. It’s a very sad song during that time.
果然這首歌的改編還是得看華晨宇，前幾天剛聽到我家旁邊的工地在放，真的好多人喜歡欸😮看了留言才知道當時歌手舞台上的演唱華是因為作詞人的離世臨時換歌，怪不得身著全黑演唱，致敬作詞者的同時也造就這一場堪稱經典的舞台，花花真是有實力也很有情誼的人❤
令人尊敬的
我觉得华晨宇做到很多人可能都无法做到的事，就是尊敬每一位不管同行也好，不同行也好，是台前台后的。只要是对待人，都是以尊重为出发点。
@@shanlynchew373Lo mismo pienso👍
可是我更喜欢华晨宇在天籁之战翻唱的那版，更有感染力，歌词也没被篡改
Your comments about the Zhou Shen’s voice mimic a string instrument is very very very on point. THE MOST UNIQUE characteristic of Chinese operas is that it’s always using human voice to mimic a string instrument in the band, usually a 二胡/板胡/京胡。 go listen to any Beijing opera, then you will find out that the human voice is ALWASY mimic a instrument. This actually goes deep into Chinese music philosophy: 八音克諧， 金聲玉震， 絲竹和鳴。 basically traditional Chinese music is not about tempo or melody, but about creating a simple harmonic sound that using different instruments, including human voice, that has different materials thus different timbre, and let them mix into one single note : harmony, the sound of universe. You could find the same aesthetic from any Guqin music.
you have very good ears and music sensitivity! Mimicking instrument is part of ancient Chinese music aesthetic/philosophy
周深的艺术性很高，独树一帜，简化乐器，很喜欢他有思想的歌者👍👍
🤝
除了原唱, 周深才是最能表達這首歌的意境, 老師道出樂曲應有的意義, 並非一味放聲大喊就是好的
真的难得。说真的，在没遇见周深之前，我听不得高音。太吵了！！！哈哈哈，周深唱高音，我却佩服~好听十好美！哈哈哈偏心😅
You said it well. I really can't stand unnecessary screaming during singing.
I prefer Zhou Shen's version the most. The simplified rearrangement is very elegant, showcasing various vocal tones and delivering a brilliant interpretation of inner struggles. It's worth mentioning that both the song and lyrics of the Chinese opera part are created by Zhou Shen.
For Shen Zhou’s performance, there is unedited rehearsal version. I am interested in seeing you guys to review that one.
老師咁鍾意歌手追求變化和敢於冒險挑戰，尤其是周深，可以聴concerto pour une voix，應該又會有另一個驚喜。
对对 Jack 可以考虑选这首让老师欣赏哦
总是被周深的音乐审美打动！
曲终仍意犹未尽！
周深版的，聽完感覺他只唱了一小段，看時間才發現原來不是😂實在太好聽了!!!!無限聽❤❤
听了好多遍了，还和你有同感，感觉刚开始唱就结束了
每天循環迄今。。。
我循环到今天，欲罢不能❤❤总觉得听不够😂
绕梁三日💞
周深是個寶藏男孩，永遠都可為我們帶來驚喜！老師也好厲害👍
周深把這首歌詮釋出它的生命力，是用“心”來唱出的，不是炫技。
只能说华晨宇的炫技恰到好处。易燃易爆炸最好听的版本
@@zezhengong7632disagree
Zhou Shen's 2nd album is coming soon! Just announced officially...too excited !!! 😍😍😍
2016天籟第一次聽到這首歌就愛上了! 連續好久每天都跟唱，尤其開車開長途的時候跟著唱都覺得旅途變短了，太好聽了! 沒想到都已經八年過去了，去年飛去北京、廣州聽現場好滿足! 期待2024現場演唱之歌王的日出場!
我也很喜欢华晨宇天籁版的易燃易爆炸
Huahua's concert is the best
Love Hua Chenyu
喜欢华晨宇的台风
2016年 华晨宇给这首歌赋予了新的生命，改编后的易燃易爆炸从此大放異彩，不愧为当代乐坛的音乐魔法师。
完全認同橘老師的說法，周深這個舞台是最捧的🥳🥳🥳
老師沒有比較，只是說她覺得是周深目前排前三而已，不要給老師拉仇恨值了～🙏
周深的部分 老師給了好多我沒發現的部分 越來越欣賞老師了
最喜欢深宝板本，橫跨40多個音符，5個八度。咋舌!他的低音部份很低，很少听到他用這種声線。他這首曲真是個藝術品。我相信很少人能翻唱這首曲。太難了!
周深我总觉得他是在把这首歌的情绪，像歌剧一般唱了出来。
我并不觉得难听，反而感受到了歌剧般美妙的舞台剧场。
现在歌手很少人能办得到。
I'm so happy that you love Zhou shen too!! Zhou shen ＆ Liang Long performed “Heartless you”, that is another special and playful performance of Zhou Shen. That performance contains classic Chinese opera and rap and so much fun! Hope that you can do the reaction
ua-cam.com/video/MlGn6ifnXg4/v-deo.htmlsi=1r4r_5gsvjEsqlP9
不斷.... 重覆再看，多謝小編對周深的改觀，也多謝老師 變了深深迷😂❤
Hua Chenyu is amazing. I flew from Germany to China last year to experience 2 of his amazing Mars concerts. It was mindblowing. Best concerts I have ever been too. And I was at many concerts from many different artists in my life. His Mars concerts are on another level. His music, especially his own compositions are awesome, interesting and it never gets boring to listen to his music. I am so happy I found Hua Chenyu 5 years ago.
喜歡周深的版本！周深把他想表達的完整的呈現出來，周深真的很棒！
OMG who is the last singer, blows me away! Love it! ❤
ZhouShen ~ the top singer in China
@@ZhouShen_Global_Fans_Family 容易引起部分歌星粉丝的不悦，咱还是少招惹些头脑发热的吧。