Tony McCarroll was great on drums for them. Great feel and attack, and always moving and rocking out back there. The performance was always elevated by his presence on the kit.
So I was 10 when the Beatles broke up and the these guys weren't even born then, they came at least 20 years later. I think that playing this song at the end of their show is a great tribute to the Beatles. It's high energy, loud guitars and Liam signs it well. It's such a shame that people put the two in a contest about which was best. Who cares, they're both good and by performing this song Oasis pay their respects to those that came before them. So leave the contest aside and just listen to the music.
Don't think many people put them in contest, there is no contest it'd be like prime Mike Tyson Vs a new born. Reason they get mentioned together is because Oasis quite clearly took so much from the Beatles because they were their heroes.
It shows that a great song can be covered and still be great. The fact that some people want to argue over which is best proves the point Like Watchtower - Bob vs Jimi. It's a matter of taste.
@@islasim7649 he was doing the basics well but that was about the limit of his abilities. Noel wanted to grow, the next guy Alan White (is that his name?) had more ability. However I think they lost something when Tony left, it had some punk energy that they never got back when he was gone.
I can't believe it ,i was actually there in 94 and i totally missed them and the reason, because the people i went with were total spangles who just wanted to hang round the tent taking mushrooms.With hindsight i should of said right i'm off i'll see you losers in four days when it's time to leave.Oh yeh,one more thing,we went to the cash and carry for supplies just before we left and i said to my mate i have about £120 to spend at the festival,how much you got ?he says £3.£3 for four days at Glastonbury.Well i should of realized it was going to be crap from that moment on.i haven't seen those people for years which i guess is a blessing but they made me miss the mighty Oasis.Enough said.
What I love about Oasis covers is that they always stick to the original and don't improvise a lot vocally. This makes for pleasing homages to the original songs, but given a new twist by Liam's immense voice and Noel's guitar.
5:35 i love what he is doing here. He puts his guitar on a speaker so it creates feedback, but not the one that cuts your ears off. Then he adjusts the roland space echo for this magical sound, wish i had one!
a rare liam falsetto. he also deliberately cracks his voice 03:00 at which he never does. possibly he was overcome with the spirit of john lennon that day
it's one of the best cover versions ever. They literally got their record deal, because of this song. Labels weren't that interested, until they heard them play this
I dunno ..In Alan McGee's own words in this interview , he says he knew he was going to sign Oasis by the second song the played at King Tut's ( which was Up In The Sky , first song was Bring It On Down .)ua-cam.com/video/rpozn3nedMs/v-deo.html
Kind of weird when Oasis were a band that hipsters loved. Playing to a bouncing crowd, on a small stage at about 3pm!! Seems so long ago, but I remember it. They were a real trendy/hipster band. Then they went mainstream about 12 months later.
Cj M yeah I went to 3 oasis gigs, 1995 Earl’s Court, 2000 Wembley and 2005 MK Bowl. Shame the crowd changed from music fans in 95 to virtually an England away match in 2005
No they weren't. They did the hard yards on the toilet circuit. World apart from flashing a shitty promo clip on Instagram and getting yer mates to come to yer first gig. Glastonbury back then wasn't about hipsters.
Hipsters always exsisted. They just morph and changes names. Hippies was another name. People who think they’re hip when all they do is follow dress codes and attitudes. Nothing “hip” about being a follower.
Epic. Look at the crowd, Oasis have driven people in a change of style and they changed even the attitude during gigs. From here we are changing from "Nirvana crowd" (respect) to something different.
huge Nirvana fan and them and Oasis were the only 90s band I dug. And yes it was very refreshing from all theat doom and gloom shite. He comes these fashionable English boys rocking as hard as anything we did. The English gave us rock n roll back in a much better form. Always had. Stopped after Oasis but so did rock. Last rock star LG.
one of the only bands that never people pleased ,God bless them ,nearly as good as the fab 4 ,but that would be hard to do ,bless their little cotton socks .
@tomvallantejr1424 ye ya right mate. Noel apparently said he couldn't play but he seems quality on here doesn't he and on the first album. He even had the image for oasis which alan white didn't. Just mu opinion pal.
@@giveusanesirbobholness7199 Tony was incredibly basic and Tony's own words 'lazy.' Alan was classically trained and without him, the next album wouldn't be what it is. Alan didn't just know about drums, but about percussion as well: just listen to the subtle tambourine and maraccas that he puts on the tracks.
Frank Cortes No creo, ya que el quedó en pesimos términos con Noel en incluso saco un libro sobre ella. De todos modos Alan White es mil veces mejor, Tony se la bancó en Definitely Maybe pero era muy repetitiva su forma de tocar.
Si por que el ,what the story morning glory , tenía algunas canciones decentes , pero el definitely maybe era un manantial de rock , y maccarrol calzaria perfecto para el regreso ,eso seria Oasis .
It’s a simple beat and plays really the same beat on everything. I like him tho. He was punky and it fit, he just didn’t have the chops for more intricate stuff. Like the brushes on wonderwall. He couldn’t do that proper.
I might be wrong, but it looks like John Peel at 6m 30s... check and see. Surprised as I assume he wasn't a big fan, but there he is flicking through vinyl. Am I imagining this? ...
2 things.... 6.10 Bonehead is saying "thank god that pair have fucked off" 6.31 I swear that's John Peel behind the amp going through a box of records.
Actually it’s a 1960 given to him by Johnny Marr and it used to belong to Pete Townshend. It was later smashed/broken by Noel after someone ran up onstage.
this performance is almost as old as I am the walrus was at the time. crazy.
holy shit thats true
Terrifying
This performance was when the song was about 28 yrs old. Also this is 24 and a half yrs ago now
And it's older than that wat a mad tune
It a class song, shame I missed out on all of this. I am only 16, but Liam’s new songs are great so at least my generation have that
Tony McCarroll was great on drums for them. Great feel and attack, and always moving and rocking out back there. The performance was always elevated by his presence on the kit.
Tony's beat was sublime. Alan White was a tippy tappy fucker who ruined the 'punk oasis' which was legendary.
@@ginaza9767youre a legend, how did youtube police didnt censore yer comment
@@ginaza9767 You clearly know nothing about drums or drumming. Do be quiet.
@SevenOfNine-7 He could and it sounded miles better.
Liam's voice was so pure then ...
The beatles didnt perform it live...
But oasis do...and thats cool!
Pure *SHIT.*
Check this!
ua-cam.com/video/NXhdLP_nQXA/v-deo.html
@@philsurtees give back ur moms phone kiddo
@@philsurtees Then why are you here?
I love how at the end Noel fucks with the knobs on his amp, gently rests down his guitar and then just walks off stage
He was like 21 y.o. this is a legend.
Check this!
ua-cam.com/video/NXhdLP_nQXA/v-deo.html
23
@@pranavchaware yep
26
Best cover of I am the Walrus hands down. They gave it something else.
1995 Earls court better....
So I was 10 when the Beatles broke up and the these guys weren't even born then, they came at least 20 years later.
I think that playing this song at the end of their show is a great tribute to the Beatles. It's high energy, loud guitars and Liam signs it well. It's such a shame that people put the two in a contest about which was best. Who cares, they're both good and by performing this song Oasis pay their respects to those that came before them. So leave the contest aside and just listen to the music.
Don't think many people put them in contest, there is no contest it'd be like prime Mike Tyson Vs a new born. Reason they get mentioned together is because Oasis quite clearly took so much from the Beatles because they were their heroes.
Noel was born and possibly bonehead.
Would never
It shows that a great song can be covered and still be great. The fact that some people want to argue over which is best proves the point
Like Watchtower - Bob vs Jimi. It's a matter of taste.
@@markkelly3859 Absolutely right
Liam's teeth are perfect ! Not a single filling !
A few years later they have many fillings🤣
Yer kidding right ??
Well he was like 22 at the time so obviously he wouldn’t have any fillings! 🙄
Tonys drumming is so good haha
Lol pretty basic tbf
Yeah I love this drummer
yea idk why he got sacked
@Gael AlPz ‘Themes’? You mean songs?
You illiterate prick.
@@islasim7649 he was doing the basics well but that was about the limit of his abilities. Noel wanted to grow, the next guy Alan White (is that his name?) had more ability. However I think they lost something when Tony left, it had some punk energy that they never got back when he was gone.
I can't believe it ,i was actually there in 94 and i totally missed them and the reason, because the people i went with were total spangles who just wanted to hang round the tent taking mushrooms.With hindsight i should of said right i'm off i'll see you losers in four days when it's time to leave.Oh yeh,one more thing,we went to the cash and carry for supplies just before we left and i said to my mate i have about £120 to spend at the festival,how much you got ?he says £3.£3 for four days at Glastonbury.Well i should of realized it was going to be crap from that moment on.i haven't seen those people for years which i guess is a blessing but they made me miss the mighty Oasis.Enough said.
Quite the textbook detour.
said,,,yo!
There was a lot of that gong on in those days.
pricks
you missed a treat ,no more mushies for you .
Liam Lennon
기안 his son's lennon gallagher
Noel McCartney
John Gallagher
@@zdreinje8100 nAaaaaa a aaAA
@@richardsylvanus2717 sounds very uncool
His voice... so clean, powerful and energic
Not a camera or mobile in sight just people living in the moment. Beautiful.
I like how Liam just sits there while the song goes on on and on and on and...on 😂
Liam looked freaking awesome! 😍
What I love about Oasis covers is that they always stick to the original and don't improvise a lot vocally. This makes for pleasing homages to the original songs, but given a new twist by Liam's immense voice and Noel's guitar.
I love Liam's outfit here, might have to get something like it lol.
Yeah but you’re not as good looking as he is.
@@TheMusicalElitist sad reality 😔
5:35 i love what he is doing here. He puts his guitar on a speaker so it creates feedback, but not the one that cuts your ears off. Then he adjusts the roland space echo for this magical sound, wish i had one!
6:08 funny how Liam went away like that🤣🤣🤣
IKR, he’s like yeh my job here is done, I’m out! Hilarious
1:09 Liam doing the “I’m crying” bit 😮
a rare liam falsetto. he also deliberately cracks his voice 03:00 at which he never does. possibly he was overcome with the spirit of john lennon that day
Sean u all ways together if I don't see u not like that all ways love u like a bro❤🤠
You can see the whole band is having fun with this one. Even tony.
i love the way tony drums in this what an icon
don’t know why he got sacked
@@islasim7649 his drumming on whatever was good to like he was getting there
@@islasim7649 He was shite.
@@shredder9536 No he wasn’t.
@@TheMusicalElitist noel thought he was shite. Hah?
Voice of a generation. Impeccable
They were something else from the begining☺
Yes a band who turned super successful
0:52 Jorah Mormont
HelterSkelter is that jorah mormont?
HelterSkelter he found the Cure!
JAJAJAJJJAJAJAJAJAJJAJA
Hahahah
🤣🤣🤣
Now this performance is as old as I Am The Walrus was at the time
The voice a of Generatio.. oasis the Best....simplemente Genial...😙🎵🎶🎙
Love how Liam and Noel are just still singing/playing music while a bunch of people are just getting taken out of the crowd
Back in 90s when there is no fucking phone no taking pic or vid just enjoy fucking GIG
Best performance ever!
Since Liam's career is going off right now I would love to hear him cover this again now.
5:19 When the music is so good you just stand still and listen
Great band cover greatest band's song.
The drummer is playing great!!! I prefer that Definitely maybe drum sound than the Morning Glory drum sound
Who asked you?
@@TheMusicalElitist Eggman
@@TheMusicalElitist👈 noel is in the room. 😂
@@giveusanesirbobholness7199 No, he isn't. But I certainly know about drums and drumming.
The best bloody band in the world 🌎....bedsides the Beatles
Tony was the pergect drumer for oasis
No he wasn’t.
You’re also an illiterate prick.
Lol, no.
I dig the way the crowd was really into it, right from the start.
Liam vocal so good he do the backup singging too
The good old days!
it's one of the best cover versions ever. They literally got their record deal, because of this song. Labels weren't that interested, until they heard them play this
I dunno ..In Alan McGee's own words in this interview , he says he knew he was going to sign Oasis by the second song the played at King Tut's ( which was Up In The Sky , first song was Bring It On Down .)ua-cam.com/video/rpozn3nedMs/v-deo.html
Kind of weird when Oasis were a band that hipsters loved. Playing to a bouncing crowd, on a small stage at about 3pm!! Seems so long ago, but I remember it. They were a real trendy/hipster band. Then they went mainstream about 12 months later.
Cj M yeah I went to 3 oasis gigs, 1995 Earl’s Court, 2000 Wembley and 2005 MK Bowl. Shame the crowd changed from music fans in 95 to virtually an England away match in 2005
Everyone loved oasis
They were never hipsters and hipsters didn't exist then
No they weren't. They did the hard yards on the toilet circuit. World apart from flashing a shitty promo clip on Instagram and getting yer mates to come to yer first gig. Glastonbury back then wasn't about hipsters.
Hipsters always exsisted. They just morph and changes names. Hippies was another name. People who think they’re hip when all they do is follow dress codes and attitudes. Nothing “hip” about being a follower.
Une grand groupe avec de bonnes références !!!!!!!
I was there first and last time at glasto didnt see Oasis didnt know where I was let alone seeing a great rock n roll band 22 to not be again
We were there ❤
Go to 6:00 and 6:26. Guigsy's doing some pretty interesting things on the bass. Wish it was turned up.
Underrated
THAT FALSETTOSSS
Sublime. Especially the second higher one.
In Glasgow 94 was better
fucking good band!! This lenno's master sounds excellent Nice concert!
Epic. Look at the crowd, Oasis have driven people in a change of style and they changed even the attitude during gigs. From here we are changing from "Nirvana crowd" (respect) to something different.
huge Nirvana fan and them and Oasis were the only 90s band I dug. And yes it was very refreshing from all theat doom and gloom shite. He comes these fashionable English boys rocking as hard as anything we did. The English gave us rock n roll back in a much better form. Always had. Stopped after Oasis but so did rock. Last rock star LG.
I am the walrus, n' then I'm gettin' off
Sounded just as good the other night at the Co Op 👍👌
I can't get enough
one of the only bands that never people pleased ,God bless them ,nearly as good as the fab 4 ,but that would be hard to do ,bless their little cotton socks .
The instrumental makes the Oasis version perfect! Gallagher has a better voice too plus sound quality is way better now days.
Better than what the Beatles version? Come on man. They wouldn’t even say that. Lennon’s voice is sublime. Even LG knows that.
amazing !!!
Christ a real young Liam, I thought it was Jarvis Cocker at first lol
Tony playing his heart out here!! I thought he was a great drummer😕
the best
Tonys drumming on here was better than Alan whites
So much more feel
@tomvallantejr1424 ye ya right mate.
Noel apparently said he couldn't play but he seems quality on here doesn't he and on the first album.
He even had the image for oasis which alan white didn't.
Just mu opinion pal.
No it isn't.
@@giveusanesirbobholness7199 Tony was incredibly basic and Tony's own words 'lazy.' Alan was classically trained and without him, the next album wouldn't be what it is. Alan didn't just know about drums, but about percussion as well: just listen to the subtle tambourine and maraccas that he puts on the tracks.
We were there Reggie god bless seen them before anyone I Swansea city I'm the egg man who the poler bear
Guigsys bass line is great
He always sounds great playing a Fender Jass Bass.
Si Oasis regresa debería ser con esta formación,inclusive con Tony Mccarroll
Frank Cortes No creo, ya que el quedó en pesimos términos con Noel en incluso saco un libro sobre ella. De todos modos Alan White es mil veces mejor, Tony se la bancó en Definitely Maybe pero era muy repetitiva su forma de tocar.
Fernando Rossi También Alan Withe salió en malos términos. Noel lo sacó para meter a Zak
Ya reckon. No chance that Noel would be up for that.
Si por que el ,what the story morning glory , tenía algunas canciones decentes , pero el definitely maybe era un manantial de rock , y maccarrol calzaria perfecto para el regreso ,eso seria Oasis .
Las canciones de Definitely Maybe jamás volvieron a sonar igual desde la partida de Tony , el tenía ese punk maravilloso
3:25 good shit
I wish john can see it 🙁
BIBLICAL
lame.
C M Not Hazed = Shit
Your not hazed
yeet boi daly Daly do ah give a fuck
Eu estou chorando
I love Oasis, but why Tony McCarroll got fired I'll never know.
Yes you do. Now be quiet.
@@TheMusicalElitist ha ha is that you Noel?!
Because he was rubbish.
@@Johnny1Reggae YYYYAAAWWWNN!!! That your attempt at a comeback?
Funny Liam messing up the lyrics.
can you blame him? the lyrics seem impossible to remember lol
@@rayk9598 jooba jooba joobah
Great cover. Only Oasis, Siouxsie and Joe Cocker well covered The Beatles. It's very difficult.
They really are hard to emulate. This is such a complex song to sing... Liam does it justice
This is better than the version on The Masterplan
Yeah it is
This versión is in glasgow
Tony Carroll wasn't too bad after all
@lee turton He was very solid. It being youtube I am duty bound to make some sort of Lars Ulrich joke...I'll get back to you.
It’s a simple beat and plays really the same beat on everything. I like him tho. He was punky and it fit, he just didn’t have the chops for more intricate stuff. Like the brushes on wonderwall. He couldn’t do that proper.
Amazing!
Check this!
ua-cam.com/video/NXhdLP_nQXA/v-deo.html
I might be wrong, but it looks like John Peel at 6m 30s... check and see. Surprised as I assume he wasn't a big fan, but there he is flicking through vinyl. Am I imagining this? ...
Poor Tony getting sacked. He was great on the drums. I don’t know what Noel wanted better out of him.
“Walroos”
this fuckin rocks
🙌❤ I love Oasis version
5:03
The two greatest rock songs - I am the Walrus and Gimme Shelter.
and MY GENERATION!!!
Hard one but - *"Rock 'n Roll"* Led Zep, *"Kashmir"* Led Zep, *"Stay with Me"* - The Faces - Oh...so fucking many!
You think I am the Walrus is a rock song?...I think it's got more to do with Alice in Wonderland.
Peter Cifuentes The beatles version has more to do with Alice in Wonderland.
Your opinion and not shared by many others
1:09 Just... Marry me 🥺💔😻
Semolina Pilchard climbinla mmh mh...
Tomorrow at 0800 Glastonbury opens 2024 they have Cyndia Lauper yippeee for the youngsters , 94 Oasis , say no more.
His voice......
Check this!
ua-cam.com/video/NXhdLP_nQXA/v-deo.html
0:52 whos da is that
coner Macolum that`s jorah mormont my friend
Mark heap?
The Walrus
2 things....
6.10 Bonehead is saying "thank god that pair have fucked off"
6.31 I swear that's John Peel behind the amp going through a box of records.
It absolutely is!!! Great spot!!!
Sounds like I am hearing this of The Masterplan
Wow Noel with a '59 Les Paul?
It could be the one that Johnny Marr gave him which he promptly smashed over the head of some guy who tried to fight Liam on stage
Actually it’s a 1960 given to him by Johnny Marr and it used to belong to Pete Townshend. It was later smashed/broken by Noel after someone ran up onstage.
this to me, is another example of the fact that Alan is an awesome drummer; but he never nails the ragged feel of Walrus, and Columbia.
Yeah Alan could actually play them.
1:08
BIBLICAL
1:30 no one gonna mention that he completely fucked it 😂
00:52
3:25 cool bass guigs
I think this band could go on to bigger things.
Forgets the words 1:31
gigs bass is sick here
Great song but know need to keep it going 4eva??¿????
💔👏
最高
Check this!
ua-cam.com/video/NXhdLP_nQXA/v-deo.html
6:10 🥰
I am a eggman to