I saw a documentary about this last summer. The evidence points towards the settlement relocating further up into the bay. There is an island with a similar name to Croatoan according to local tribes and the theory is that the clue to where they relocated was marked wrong since the map they used was upside down. Archeologists have found evidence of a settlement further into the bay and are convinced that this is what remains after the Roanoke settlement. I find it all very confusing the be honest.
@@LOCKHIMUP2024 could most definitely have happened too. From the very beginning of the settlement one of them killed a native, which hardly is the best way to impress people when moving into someone else’s neighborhood 😂
@@LOCKHIMUP2024The natives could have came in at night and killed them in their sleep which would be why their was no trace. Or they could have gone andvlived with the Natives thinking White wasn't coming back.
I mean honestly, it just shows that the descendants of the tribe had any english people. Which probably is the case with almost every tribe. This isn't really showing us any indication, that it was those english settlers specificaly. It could be literally anyone, as I doubt we've got ANY native tribes left, that don't have any genetic variance in terms of settlers from Europe
@@austinh953 That’s quite exuberant. Thank you for continuing this American tradition in which we can enlighten our youth in to better understand our culture.
Im a Native American in Rob Co NC. They have now put out paperwork saying that our Tribe, The Lumbee Tribe of NC is the possible decendants of the colony mixing with the Croatians.
Except when he returned he saw lots of young native Americans that had blond hair and blue eyes. They intergreted Instead of starving over a cold winter
People with Grey eyes , this is a important subject with this occurrence.. but still doesn't explain where they went or what happened . No bodies not a single shred of evidence was left behind. Still intriguing today.
They obviously integrated with Native Americans nearby- whether by choice or force (or both). The only other possibility would've been mass drowning, which is highly unlikely.
That's a pretty big statement to say that it's the "only other possibility" There's literally infinite ammount of possibilities. Spanish / French ship coming along and taking them, them settling somewhere else by themselfes, fear of attack of natives and fleeing, supersticion leading to that decision, etc. etc. There's literally an inifinite number of possibilities
@@ThatGuy-rdokidnapped, at bow point maybe? Or at least threats of violence. But a load of white people left behind in a new foreign land? Quite frankly, anything could have happened to them.
Clearly what happened is that some spooky HP Lovecraft stuff when down. They all went to the bottom on the sea to live with Dagon as fish people. Croatan was probably the minion of Dagon that recruited them.
I'm not sure what you mean when you say "no sign of relocation" Thiers one glaring plot hole in that theory...... Theirs nobody their! That's literally what relocation is, if somebody is on one place then another...... they have relocated. As for what happened the logical explanation is they ran out of resources such as food, as stated the lead was on a supply run via ship..... so it's most likely scenario that they relocated. (Only conspiracy nuts would say "no sign of relocation" despite the literal meaning of it being aparrent) Education wasn't common practice so spelling wasn't good I'm surprised letter where even formed by settlers. Most brutal way.... they where killed by natives while sleeping and relocated, the notices took back the land and carved up, but it's most likely the former than the latter.
They simply moved to Virginia on interstate I-81. Been there several times, it's a pretty quiet nice town.
Star City of the South 😂😂
What city is a nice quiet city ¿😮😂 not Roanoke 😂¿ not Norfolk 😂¿ not Richmond 😂🤣
I saw a documentary about this last summer. The evidence points towards the settlement relocating further up into the bay. There is an island with a similar name to Croatoan according to local tribes and the theory is that the clue to where they relocated was marked wrong since the map they used was upside down. Archeologists have found evidence of a settlement further into the bay and are convinced that this is what remains after the Roanoke settlement. I find it all very confusing the be honest.
Best Answer 💯
Or.....they violated the natives and it went sideways.......
@@LOCKHIMUP2024 could most definitely have happened too. From the very beginning of the settlement one of them killed a native, which hardly is the best way to impress people when moving into someone else’s neighborhood 😂
@@LOCKHIMUP2024The natives could have came in at night and killed them in their sleep which would be why their was no trace. Or they could have gone andvlived with the Natives thinking White wasn't coming back.
I'm pretty sure they did like DNA testing on the descendants of the tribe and found that they have matches with those of the original English settlers
How does that solve anything ?
@@MikeyMooks it pretty much confirms that they either
A were captured or assimilated into the tribe willingly
@@youngorochino it doesn't lmfao unless you can prove it was one of the people who went missing
I mean honestly, it just shows that the descendants of the tribe had any english people. Which probably is the case with almost every tribe.
This isn't really showing us any indication, that it was those english settlers specificaly.
It could be literally anyone, as I doubt we've got ANY native tribes left, that don't have any genetic variance in terms of settlers from Europe
@@youngorochior the natives interbred with the countless other english colonists that game after them 💀
Do DNA on family members left behind in England and try to find decendants here.
Good idea but who’s gonna pay for all those DNA test which are insanely expensive
@@juanelorriaga2840Wasn't that like +350 years ago 😂??
They left with Croatian sailers!
Finally someone said this.
@@AfroAsiaticLanguages yes sir!
Croatoan is a native tribe
I have heard that the tribe was named after the Croats that sailed there! Interesting
Bigfoot ate them all.
Pretty sure every school in America is forced to teach this to their pupils.
No
And the uk
I taught it last month to my 8th graders.
@@austinh953 That’s quite exuberant. Thank you for continuing this American tradition in which we can enlighten our youth in to better understand our culture.
Nope first time I ever heard about it was an episode of Supernatural way back in season 1
Im a Native American in Rob Co NC. They have now put out paperwork saying that our Tribe, The Lumbee Tribe of NC is the possible decendants of the colony mixing with the Croatians.
What if the carving on the tree was already there before even the settlers came there ? But nobody noticed till they came back
Maybe but it wouldn't have been written by Natives and I doubt anyone else would have.
Aliens got them
Dude took three years to return
I'm surprised you didn't even bring up the Dare Stone!!??
It says what happened!!
Except when he returned he saw lots of young native Americans that had blond hair and blue eyes. They intergreted Instead of starving over a cold winter
3 cold winters.
what an epic prank
This makes me appreciate Supernatural even more.
I remember that episode too 😄
The zombies.
“Supernatural occurrences”
Hah I see what you did there.
Oh i thought you were gunna tell me what happened lol
I remember the “In Search Of” episode what got me into what happened to them and also…..come on Leonard Nimoy hosted it!.Great show
People with Grey eyes , this is a important subject with this occurrence.. but still doesn't explain where they went or what happened . No bodies not a single shred of evidence was left behind. Still intriguing today.
Background bgm name?
They obviously integrated with Native Americans nearby- whether by choice or force (or both). The only other possibility would've been mass drowning, which is highly unlikely.
That's a pretty big statement to say that it's the "only other possibility"
There's literally infinite ammount of possibilities.
Spanish / French ship coming along and taking them, them settling somewhere else by themselfes, fear of attack of natives and fleeing, supersticion leading to that decision, etc. etc.
There's literally an inifinite number of possibilities
Wdym by force?
@@ThatGuy-rdokidnapped, at bow point maybe? Or at least threats of violence.
But a load of white people left behind in a new foreign land? Quite frankly, anything could have happened to them.
Interesting. Similar to a series titled "FROM"
it's just a big lie. they didn't vanished they just spread those informations to make a spooky legend. just like inkas and mayas
CRO? Cristiano Ronaldo?
Croatoan was also the name of the local tribe.
I'm tellin' ya. It was aliens.
Jamestown is kinda suspicious hmm🤔🤓🧐
Why do non of these say act of nature? Maybe they went to the island during an El Niño year and got hit with a hurricane
😢😢😢😢😢😢
BLM = Better Living motivation
The Checquy would like to know your location
Their mutants X-Men is real if you opinion doesn’t validate mine I don’t want it-
It were jorgan windcaller I knew it...!
Er maybe calico jack...?
Take yer PICKaxen you a questing...!?!?
wer the f did they go 🤔🏞️🌅🌲
Slaughtered and their bodies scattered throughout the land.
Naw they weren't slaughtered they never found any kind of bones or anything.
@@insanemind5321 They may have been captured and eaten, Cannibalism and Anthropofagy were fairly common in many native bands...
Fairies talked them into moving to their fairy dimension (or kidnapped them), where they were made slaves and / or eaten.
@@joaoantunes4548not many tribes but yes some tribes did it.
@@joaoantunes4548no they weren't common
Food for natives😅
Hurricane
Clearly what happened is that some spooky HP Lovecraft stuff when down. They all went to the bottom on the sea to live with Dagon as fish people. Croatan was probably the minion of Dagon that recruited them.
eaten
I'm not sure what you mean when you say "no sign of relocation"
Thiers one glaring plot hole in that theory...... Theirs nobody their! That's literally what relocation is, if somebody is on one place then another...... they have relocated.
As for what happened the logical explanation is they ran out of resources such as food, as stated the lead was on a supply run via ship..... so it's most likely scenario that they relocated. (Only conspiracy nuts would say "no sign of relocation" despite the literal meaning of it being aparrent)
Education wasn't common practice so spelling wasn't good I'm surprised letter where even formed by settlers.
Most brutal way.... they where killed by natives while sleeping and relocated, the notices took back the land and carved up, but it's most likely the former than the latter.
Kids that did not understand:😱😱😱🫢🫢😔🤔🤔
Dogmen