You're dead wrong. Each of them recorded a perfect 10. So... combined, they achieved the impossibly rare, illustriously coveted: 20/10. i mean how dare you 😉
I’ve introduced this to everyone I care about since finding this early in quarantine, on another user’s page. I’m 55, divorced a few years, father of 3 adult kids - basically, I don’t think I’m the target demographic of Noah…or Phoebe. But that’s what happens when you create one of the moving performances I’ve heard in 5 1/2 decades - your genius transcends any target demographic. The fact that The Sound can be as powerful played at any tempo, with any instrumentation, and even coming out of a song like The Killer - puts it in the league of the perfect songs that are equally flexible. And those harmonies with Abby. Damn. Thank you for this. I saw Phoebe at Forest Hills summer of 2022, and wanted a second night to see Noah last month when he came to NYC. But I will see him. Get the VIP ticket. And hopefully thank him. This is perfection.
I am a single 66 year woman and love this performance more than I can say. I’ve tried to introduce others to it also. Sometimes people have to discover in their own way. One of the most beautiful songs I know.
I've easily watched this 100 times, Noah. It was one of the first things I got to see after discovering your work. Which was when I saw your incredibly moving live cover of Tiny Changes right after Scott died. Thank you for that, btw. I don't know if you look at comments. But I always wanted to ask you about that black eye. Talk about a "poetic moment". And so appropo, lyrically speaking, for a duet of The Sound. If this was the totality of everything you and Phoebe ever did, it would still be one of the most timeless, beautiful moments in all of the arts. Everyone is heading to the grave in their own time. It must be quite a comfort to leave something this special behind. ❤
This never loses any emotion no matter how many times I watch it. Looking for some European tour dates for 2024. Please come back to Dublin again! 🇮🇪 ❤️
This was just, wow. I feel like my heart and soul just got ripped open, layed bare, then stitched back together, in the best way. Brilliant by everyone involved!
How beautiful is this 🌹harmony with the great creator. Love always wins it’s worth the fight 💫💛💙❤️ family water is life 🙏🌹🙏🎶🎶🎶🎶🌟 never forget who are. Aho
Ever since you first uploaded it those many years ago i find myself singing it out of the blue when cleaning or drawing or just letting my mind blank, its the first thing that comes to my mind when im not thinking. Really beutiful arrangement! ❤
Brilliant collaboration… Two of the most important songwriters and performers…..Poetry, relevant social imagery…..and significant cultural influencers….
Such a beautiful performance!! This is up at the top of the list of impactful performances. I can feel the weight of every note and lyric in a deeply meaningful sense. The melodies, and harmonies, and simplicity, and empathy pack a punch in this one.
I saw him in concert a few years ago and I swear it was someone else. It was all like Dance music 😂 I don’t regret for a second, I can say I saw him - but not the mood I was expecting with all the slow soulful songs I fell in love with. I could see that would be depressing to only play those songs but maybe one or two? Lol
I used to play with Noah a bit when I was in the Seattle jazz scene. He's not a fighter. He got sucker punched at a bar a couple days before this was recorded, pretty messed up scenario honestly.
@@NelsonHoppI watch this all the time and have always wondered what the story was, sometimes wondered if it was some sort of prop thing, sad to hear the real story, and personally glad he’s not a fighter
This is unrelated (I can't say anything better than everyone already has. This mashup entrances me. It gets inside me and it's also on the top of my 'anxiety attack' playlist to calm me down.) BUT. I'm always curious if 1979 is a reference to the song by Smashing Pumpkins, or to an older family member.
Me too. Definitely healing from any angle. I've never felt this before. I just found him 3 songs ago. God pointed him out and his tenderness is like nothing from this world.
The most beautiful 8 minutes of human existence ever recorded.
One of the best recordings ever made, 10/10 for sure
You're dead wrong. Each of them recorded a perfect 10. So... combined, they achieved the impossibly rare, illustriously coveted: 20/10.
i mean how dare you 😉
@@carpeimodiem I mean, of course! How could I be so stupid!😂
@@carpeimodiem 30/10! Don’t forget Abby! 😊
@@lgin10315 haha my bad... 30/10
I’ve introduced this to everyone I care about since finding this early in quarantine, on another user’s page. I’m 55, divorced a few years, father of 3 adult kids - basically, I don’t think I’m the target demographic of Noah…or Phoebe. But that’s what happens when you create one of the moving performances I’ve heard in 5 1/2 decades - your genius transcends any target demographic. The fact that The Sound can be as powerful played at any tempo, with any instrumentation, and even coming out of a song like The Killer - puts it in the league of the perfect songs that are equally flexible. And those harmonies with Abby. Damn. Thank you for this. I saw Phoebe at Forest Hills summer of 2022, and wanted a second night to see Noah last month when he came to NYC. But I will see him. Get the VIP ticket. And hopefully thank him. This is perfection.
I’m 63 widowed and am just now finding out about this phenomenon , omg I’m blown away
Welcome to the club. ❤ His live shows are almost spiritual.
I am a single 66 year woman and love this performance more than I can say. I’ve tried to introduce others to it also. Sometimes people have to discover in their own way. One of the most beautiful songs I know.
Thank you! Beautiful
It,s so wonderfull. It comes like a wave in the silence . So peacefull.
Hoping this re-upload is a sign of a new collaboration…I would give ANYTHING
Amazing song and arrangement - 🥰
I've easily watched this 100 times, Noah. It was one of the first things I got to see after discovering your work. Which was when I saw your incredibly moving live cover of Tiny Changes right after Scott died. Thank you for that, btw. I don't know if you look at comments. But I always wanted to ask you about that black eye. Talk about a "poetic moment". And so appropo, lyrically speaking, for a duet of The Sound.
If this was the totality of everything you and Phoebe ever did, it would still be one of the most timeless, beautiful moments in all of the arts.
Everyone is heading to the grave in their own time. It must be quite a comfort to leave something this special behind.
❤
One of the most important pieces of music I’ve ever listened to. Thank you Noah!
This never loses any emotion no matter how many times I watch it. Looking for some European tour dates for 2024. Please come back to Dublin again! 🇮🇪 ❤️
How is Phoebe so radiant 😭
Bone chillingly, transformative. Absolutely beautiful. Thank you 🙏
It’s so good, I’ll never tire of it
This was just, wow. I feel like my heart and soul just got ripped open, layed bare, then stitched back together, in the best way. Brilliant by everyone involved!
This song beaks open my soul
People should sing more and rejoice in the now. Thank you for the beautiful now and here. ❤
this is my favorite thank you for posting this noah. thank you for your music, keep going.
So much tenderness here. I love these harmonies (and the beautiful piano!). 🙏💗🎶
This is resplendent.
One of my absolute favorites! I did an instrumental cover of this for my wedding processional!
I bet that was awesome. What are the chords?
One of my all time favorites
How beautiful is this 🌹harmony with the great creator. Love always wins it’s worth the fight 💫💛💙❤️
family water is life 🙏🌹🙏🎶🎶🎶🎶🌟 never forget who are. Aho
This never gets old! You guys always amaze me. I'm a White Noise girl! ❤
Love it
What a gem.
Oh man, still one of my favorites of all time, thank you for uploading again ❤
Brilliantly written and beautifully done
Ever since you first uploaded it those many years ago i find myself singing it out of the blue when cleaning or drawing or just letting my mind blank, its the first thing that comes to my mind when im not thinking. Really beutiful arrangement! ❤
This beautiful music edifies the soul😊
This is probably one of the most beautiful songs ever written
Brilliant collaboration…
Two of the most important songwriters and performers…..Poetry, relevant social imagery…..and significant cultural influencers….
Auf der Suche nach dem besonderen.. ich habe es gefunden! Großartig!!!
Excellent!!😊
So much soul ❤️
The best! Love this video. It's a part of my mental archive of favorite performances and collabs of all time.
Such a beautiful performance!! This is up at the top of the list of impactful performances. I can feel the weight of every note and lyric in a deeply meaningful sense. The melodies, and harmonies, and simplicity, and empathy pack a punch in this one.
still one of my favorites of all time
I saw him in concert a few years ago and I swear it was someone else. It was all like Dance music 😂 I don’t regret for a second, I can say I saw him - but not the mood I was expecting with all the slow soulful songs I fell in love with. I could see that would be depressing to only play those songs but maybe one or two? Lol
Great job my friends! Hope you all three are doing well!
This is amazing
I love it ❤
2:24 This harmony makes me so emotional
Amazing… 🙏🔥❤
This is beautiful. ❤❤❤
EU TE AMO, NOAH GUNDERSEN.
Incredible
Looks like Noah ain’t scared to throw them hands either. Good on it!
I used to play with Noah a bit when I was in the Seattle jazz scene. He's not a fighter. He got sucker punched at a bar a couple days before this was recorded, pretty messed up scenario honestly.
@@NelsonHopp TY
@@NelsonHoppI watch this all the time and have always wondered what the story was, sometimes wondered if it was some sort of prop thing, sad to hear the real story, and personally glad he’s not a fighter
Coisa linda. Abraços do Brasil 🇧🇷
Killer sound, wow.
Abby gundersen. What a dreamboat.
Beautiful 🎼🫶🏻🌞
Wow, wow, wow….. Thank you
This is unrelated (I can't say anything better than everyone already has. This mashup entrances me. It gets inside me and it's also on the top of my 'anxiety attack' playlist to calm me down.) BUT. I'm always curious if 1979 is a reference to the song by Smashing Pumpkins, or to an older family member.
Me too. Definitely healing from any angle. I've never felt this before. I just found him 3 songs ago. God pointed him out and his tenderness is like nothing from this world.
❤
wow
Re-upload?
Fancy meeting you here
@@willbutler728 lol howdy homie
Hmm I think it never was on his channel, but only on Dead Ocean's.
I'm speechless and I'm a tough critic.
brilliant genial
Lyrics....Just wow,
Outstanding. Simply gorgeous. Thank you 🙏
❤
Chills..only songs of the highest truth give these chills
I hate that I just had to miss the Fort Worth/Dallas show. 😕
Im unsure how to feel at this moment....
this is my roman empire
So, you telling me, that this guy goes from shaved head to shoulder long hair within a month? What the hell man
This is a re-upload of an old video. :)
!
Please someone do a lesson on this for piano😂
🍗
What happened to your face Noah? I hope that you are ok.....