When A Cynical Director Makes A Christmas Movie...

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 46

  • @hermanhale9258
    @hermanhale9258 15 днів тому +4

    A Christmas note: when Bill is being followed, we see the bald guy near a stop sign where somebody has written CMB beneath the STOP. Somebody else suggested it means Caspar, Melchior and Balthazar, the Three Kings of Catholic tradition and the Nativity story. It could mean something else, but I think this explanation is very funny.

  • @deelak2329
    @deelak2329 15 днів тому +2

    Ah yes, Stanley Kubricks death from "heart.... attack"

  • @cloudbloom
    @cloudbloom 23 дні тому +12

    Man this was great. I love this movie but it's unsettling, I saw it in theaters when it came out and I couldn't stop thinking about it for months afterward. Thanks for the vid I'll give this movie a rewatch asap

    • @wheredyougomatt
      @wheredyougomatt  23 дні тому

      @@cloudbloom thank you mate! I hope you enjoy your rewatch

    • @cloudbloom
      @cloudbloom 23 дні тому

      @wheredyougomatt merry Christmas by the way!

    • @wheredyougomatt
      @wheredyougomatt  22 дні тому +1

      @@cloudbloom Merry Christmas to you as well!

  • @AllboroLCD
    @AllboroLCD 19 днів тому +3

    my good man, the apartment was a FULL SCALE replica of the apartment Stan & his wife lived in before he defected from the US

  • @TakinErEasyHere
    @TakinErEasyHere 18 днів тому +13

    In the original cut of the movie they allow their daughter to be taken by the cult. That's what Kubrick didn't want them to edit out.

    • @ryebread9299
      @ryebread9299 18 днів тому

      Ooooooo

    • @JeffreyStonerVideo
      @JeffreyStonerVideo 18 днів тому +1

      Peculiar, because their daughter is featured prominently in the last scenes.

    • @Eudaimaniac44
      @Eudaimaniac44 18 днів тому +5

      You laugh, but Kubrick's daughter left the family for Scientology about halfway through the filming

    • @Eudaimaniac44
      @Eudaimaniac44 18 днів тому

      ​@@JeffreyStonerVideoword round the campfire is there were 22 minutes missing after SK died.

    • @whiterose3263
      @whiterose3263 16 днів тому

      ​@JeffreyStonerVideo and you can see that while tom and Nicole are talking in that last scene, she is seen in the background possibly leaving with a group of men

  • @riffraffrichard
    @riffraffrichard 16 днів тому +4

    I think it’s powerful that he strips the imagery of any Christian imagery and we only see the modern christmas artifice. It showing the event as a modern capitalist ritual and making parallels with the masked ball. When things operate subconsciously it’s hard to see their sinister and destructive force.

    • @hermanhale9258
      @hermanhale9258 15 днів тому

      Ritual is what happens at Somerton. And those probably are capitalists under the cloaks and the hoods. Lights and wreaths and trees are decorations, which are part of customs and traditions. They aren't shown very impressively in EWS. Mostly look like junk. Any candles you see in EWS could be interpreted as part of a ritual, though.

  • @saturnFIV3
    @saturnFIV3 19 днів тому +2

    Just watched it again a few days ago. More prescient than ever.

  • @ChrisLeRose
    @ChrisLeRose 20 днів тому +3

    Alice's hair in the last scene is SO MESSY. I photograph people for a living, and it must have taken effort to get it to look that frazzled while still somewhat styled. She looks crazy. It really adds to the tone.

    • @hermanhale9258
      @hermanhale9258 17 днів тому +1

      Her hair looks pretty much like it looked in the middle of the night when she had had a nightmare.

    • @ChrisLeRose
      @ChrisLeRose 17 днів тому

      @hermanhale9258 Maybe. If so, that has meaning.

  • @FermatSim
    @FermatSim 21 день тому +1

    There are so few videos about this masterwork by Kubrick, but every single one is thoughtful and well-produced. Thank you for this, Matt!

  • @dgosch90
    @dgosch90 21 день тому

    Incredible channel, keep it up!

  • @oakmobb
    @oakmobb 18 днів тому

    My favorite Christmas movie

    • @sunnyb7228
      @sunnyb7228 15 днів тому +1

      I prefer "It's a Wonderful Life"

    • @CarlFredrik-uo1cu
      @CarlFredrik-uo1cu 14 днів тому

      Greatest alternative Christmas movies:
      Die Hard
      Rocky
      Rocky IV
      First Blood
      Lethal Weapon
      Batman Returns
      Eyes Wide Shut

  • @H00D00
    @H00D00 9 днів тому

    not kidnapped more like sells ;)

  • @KRobinson-ko1ne
    @KRobinson-ko1ne 20 днів тому +3

    He was not a saint
    I hate how he treated Shelly Duvall on the set of The Shining
    Nevertheless I’d be lying if I said he wasn’t brilliant; it’s become popular to reflect on films like Clockwork Orange and lambast it but I just can’t buy it. It’s one of the greatest movies ever made and it handles its message/perfectly and plays off of one’s empathy, even for a monster like Alex DeLarge

    • @davidlean1060
      @davidlean1060 19 днів тому

      In return for putting up with a great director for a year, Duvall's fantastic performance will live on now she has passed. A small price to pay I think.

  • @Alanx_ai
    @Alanx_ai 20 днів тому +2

    It's the tone and matsery of foreboding mystery that creates a feeling unlike any film before or since, as only Kubrick could have made. That's what the best for of art do: invite interpretation. Yet the film feels incomplete at times, intentionally off kilter and rough and Cruise's performance is ctually pretty bad at times. Was this intended? it doesn't matter. With the 1% gaining more and more wealth each day, the movie has become as prescient as ever. I don't agree with your analysis this being a christmas movie, the setting is not quite a plot point, that revisionism is a matter of opinion.
    One more thought: there's a conspirancy theory suggesting the film has a plot-point ithat casts the film's ending in another light. False. Those figures do not appear. Furthermore, Jan Harlan the films' executive producer nails the editing rumors to rest: ua-cam.com/video/YWxJqaIFi3w/v-deo.htmlsi=0AVitXihDQhyauJm

    • @hermanhale9258
      @hermanhale9258 17 днів тому

      Jan Harlan is Mr. Ullman. The movie is a Halloween carnival movie, not a Christmas movie.

  • @cloudbloom
    @cloudbloom 23 дні тому +1

    🎅🎅🎅

  • @SillyWillyFan47
    @SillyWillyFan47 20 днів тому

    Good observation. Where is Christmas present & absent?
    I think you are onto something with Saturnalia.
    Apparently, roles were often reversed, servants being waited upon my masters of the house. Inverted rules. Permissiveness & promiscuity even. There was also an element of scape-goating. The sins of the village were somehow attached to a goat, that was taken out of town and stoned to death or otherwise sacrificed, thereby releasing the people from their sins or peccadilloes.

    • @juiyenisswag
      @juiyenisswag 20 днів тому

      The Christmas lights are always present in those scenes of sexual desire, often even framing the characters entirely. For Example the kiss at the girls flat, or at the first party in the beginning of the movie. Also the two girls there want to "go where the rainbow ends" which for me is similar to those kind of rainbow coloured Christmas lights as well.

    • @hermanhale9258
      @hermanhale9258 17 днів тому

      The scape goat wasn't in Saturnalia. The Greeks had a holiday with a scape goat, but I forget what it was called or what time of year.

  • @hermanhale9258
    @hermanhale9258 17 днів тому

    Most people would say Kubrick's movies are boring, not interesting. And not at all real. They only become interesting when you get hooked and think Kubrick is sending coded messages or you start rewriting the script to make everything you see happening on screen not what really happened.

    • @hayorge27
      @hayorge27 16 днів тому +1

      Never have I ever heard anyone say any Kubrick film is boring, you really shouldn't make generalizations and slander just because you personally don't enjoy an artist's work.

    • @chaosmos24
      @chaosmos24 15 днів тому

      Most people today might say that because most people today have no attention span as a result of rotting their brains on Tiktok videos.

    • @davidlean1060
      @davidlean1060 15 днів тому

      @@chaosmos24 what do you mean people have lost their atten..oh look, a cat!

    • @hermanhale9258
      @hermanhale9258 15 днів тому

      @@chaosmos24 No, seriously. "I saw it. Boring." probably was the most common review he ever got.

    • @chaosmos24
      @chaosmos24 14 днів тому

      @hermanhale9258 Most people probably find Dostoyevsky novels boring. That doesn't mean they aren't interesting or high art.