I'm sure Rockstar kept this technology on the shelves somewhere and are working on it and do more in depth R & D on it to further improve upon it. Hell, they might be working on a new game or at least have a thought of working on a game with this technology and it might be LA Noire 2. I'm hoping it's a new IP.
He was hoping that the slow pace of communication and searching (no internet, no search engines) would mean that he would have been released before the LAPD found out. Interviews with former LAPD say that the records department would usually take hours to days to find information like who owned a car based on a license plate.
This guy is so hammy and full of shit. I love how calm he seems for most of these interrogations. It makes it all the more hilarious when he finally snaps.
Grosvenor McCaffrey would be a broken pedestal if they actually knew him: he was a smug, cruel and arrogant man, plus he never been in combat because he beat a woman to near death in Syracuse after she tried to steal from his wallet. The robbery on itself was not the thing that made him angry(it did but on a secondary level) but that she tried to outsmart him. Grosvenor is not as smart as he thinks he is, choosing communism because it made him feel superior to everyone else, not because of conviction. He is just a small and insecure manchild with delusions of grandeur at heart.
One minute he was calm and collective and charming but as soon as Cole called him out for his criminal record, McCaffrey showed his true colours and confessed what he did.
Even if he didn't actually do it and it was The Werewolf, the sudden angry outburst followed by "she got what it was coming to her" made me go like: "yep, he's the one"
I've seen you guys have a bit of a problem with the first questio. I answered it in my McCaffrey Guide at Mensch's Bar. If you pay attention to the Bar interroagtion you'll see the "Last contact with Victim" question at the end of the guide. Here's the solution: You have to choose "LIE" after that select the "BOOK" as evidence and you should be fine. Hope this helps and please thumbs u so peolpe can see. Greetz CruelTroopOfDoomTV
In my game, I cannot ask McCaffery about the lug wrench; I found it, and it was added to evidence, but the question does not pop up for me, which also means I cannot get his accusation against Tiernan, and therefore cannot get a perfect interrogation against him. :|
did anyone try to leave Rusty behind when on a case investigation? he will then catch Cole up in a few blocks, on the back sit of a police car with sirens on. he gets out of the police car approaches to Phelps and say "do you think it's funny?"
@@MariusBoss11458 Logic doesn't even matter in this case, cause neither of them killed her. Both have large amounts of evidence stacked against them so might as well pin it on the most hated suspect and get good PR.
It was a pain to get this one. The game intentionally confuses you. If mccaffrey did it then it doesnt makes sense for him to leave the evidence there so obvious. No one would be so bold as to try and set up the other guy by incriminating themselves like that. And even if they did they would at least look nervous in some way. He shook the entire thing off like he was 100% innocent, and the game plays dramatic music that all but convinces you to charge tiernan. I reccomend using a walkthrough for this game. They made it b.s. so you would have a reason to play it a second time.
I kinda knew right away Because I had a suspicion tiernan had a few screws lose in his head which is probably how mcaffery made him confused if he did it not
@@joshuahughes5761 When looked at first glance without the information you mentioned, it sounded like he killed Summers at the heat of the moment. Count that with the Syracuse incident and bam, he was the perfect guy to frame.
Look, man, he was excited as all get out. You know how detectives get their jollies off from a perfect interrogation. (Looking at you with a relaxed face, no uneasy facial/eye movements.)
Old post but...You go and speak to Tiernan after McCaffrey accuses him and you're given an option to use the telephone to check his criminal and military record.
+MiyuEmi i love rockstar for putting that in the game. LA Noire was a great game incredibly ahead of its time and any other game company could have just get the huge paycheck relying the game to sell itself with the motioncap and facial expressions. Rockstar just nailed everything in the story, gameplay, mocap and character developement.
i had the same problem. turns out that we missed something in his apartment. The other half of the torn message. That's why it was wrong. Saying you found a torn letter doesn't mean he was there, it just means you found a torn letter.
Grosvenor McCaffrey got pwned with his interrogation. He got what was coming to him, and if he'd known any better, he wouldn't have murdered Evelyn Summers! If he HAD gone into combat, he probably wouldn't have been a repeat offender in the first place! He probably would've been dead from combat had he gone into combat. Phelps went into the service, went into combat, and most importantly, served his country as a serviceman. Now with the LAPD, Cole serves up a mean, hot dish of justice.
What the hell do they keep saying? "I put him down with my saddle?" What the hell does that mean?! I hear it over and over and I never understand what he's saying.
1:45 - Oh, come on! They literally just fucking change the subject when you press accuse! Oh course I have fucking evidence for you wanting to hurt Everyn, you muppet, but that isn't what you said before the prompt. I hate this game.
So when I use the torn letter as evidence to the first question it doesn't work I get a X next to the question smh 🤦♂️ I can't pin this guy the game won't let me it wants me to arrest that tierian dude. Idk what to do other than to arrest tieran for it to progress the story :/
![L.A. Noire: Perfect Interrogation - James Tiernan at Central Station [Secretary Murder Case]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oV-GTbKJSIE/mqdefault.jpg)
![L.A. Noire: Perfect Interrogation - James Tiernan at Central Station [Secretary Murder Case]](/img/tr.png)
![L.A. Noire: Perfect Interrogation - Jessica Hamilton at Central Station [A Fallen Idol Case]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NElxmUF_piM/mqdefault.jpg)
perfect interrogation, unsuccessful walking through doors
Phelps is a talking man, not a walking man.
@@WarPenguinDude He talks what he talks, but he doesn't walk what he walks.
You can tell by the way he used his walk. He's a woman's man. No time to...walk correctly?
Can't win them all.
3:44 I will never forget that. How throughout most of the interrogation a kept a calm demeanor, but then suddenly loses his cool. Great performance.
Eh, Canadian Gamer You again lmao
Eh, Canadian Gamer “AND SHE GOT WHAT WAS COMING TO HER!”
That one sentence alone is more than enough to fully sum up this character.
I think he kept his cool until he got asked about the military service question and he got pissed off.
At least Stuart Ackerman was better than this guy
this guy's narcissistic breakdown and tiernan's like MOVING moving performance made this my favorite case in murder
Perfect interrogation followed by walking into a door.
Smooth, Phelps. Smooth.
Nobody’s perfect. And yes I know I am REALLY late.
@@josephmoffatt4696 indeed
We've all had bad days
3:53 rusty teleporting around the room
Damn, imagine these facial mechanics on next-gen graphics... 😍
This is next gen. I can only imagine full body scan too but apparently LA Noire wasn't succesful enough...
I'm sure Rockstar kept this technology on the shelves somewhere and are working on it and do more in depth R & D on it to further improve upon it. Hell, they might be working on a new game or at least have a thought of working on a game with this technology and it might be LA Noire 2. I'm hoping it's a new IP.
InboundsAlpaca ¥¥88¥💓💓💓
InboundsAlpaca now, you got your wish. La Noire is coming to PS4 and Xbox One in November
And Mass Effect Andromeda is a thing lol.
Who the fuck was McCaffrey trying to fool with his record. The police have access to that
yeah nowdays its obvious, but in the 1940s it wasnt evident
He was hoping that the slow pace of communication and searching (no internet, no search engines) would mean that he would have been released before the LAPD found out.
Interviews with former LAPD say that the records department would usually take hours to days to find information like who owned a car based on a license plate.
@@RamdomView Also helps that he didn’t actually do it, shady past aside, so he has another reason to be confident.
@@matthewriley7826 Bro what he admits to it lmao
@@Andre-uu5xvPlay the game
This guy is so hammy and full of shit. I love how calm he seems for most of these interrogations. It makes it all the more hilarious when he finally snaps.
Grosvenor McCaffrey would be a broken pedestal if they actually knew him: he was a smug, cruel and arrogant man, plus he never been in combat because he beat a woman to near death in Syracuse after she tried to steal from his wallet. The robbery on itself was not the thing that made him angry(it did but on a secondary level) but that she tried to outsmart him.
Grosvenor is not as smart as he thinks he is, choosing communism because it made him feel superior to everyone else, not because of conviction. He is just a small and insecure manchild with delusions of grandeur at heart.
FACTS
Not a comrade.
One minute he was calm and collective and charming but as soon as Cole called him out for his criminal record, McCaffrey showed his true colours and confessed what he did.
Not exactly, sure he had an angry outburst for being revealed as the fraud he is, but never explicitly said he did it.
Even if he didn't actually do it and it was The Werewolf, the sudden angry outburst followed by "she got what it was coming to her" made me go like: "yep, he's the one"
I've seen you guys have a bit of a problem with the first questio. I answered it in my McCaffrey Guide at Mensch's Bar. If you pay attention to the Bar interroagtion you'll see the "Last contact with Victim" question at the end of the guide.
Here's the solution:
You have to choose "LIE" after that select the "BOOK" as evidence and you should be fine.
Hope this helps and please thumbs u so peolpe can see.
Greetz CruelTroopOfDoomTV
Ty bro🙏🙏
In my game, I cannot ask McCaffery about the lug wrench; I found it, and it was added to evidence, but the question does not pop up for me, which also means I cannot get his accusation against Tiernan, and therefore cannot get a perfect interrogation against him. :|
Hurting a woman out of anger is one thing. Convincing an innocent man that he might have done it is f'd up.
True but for all MCaffery knew, Tiernan did do it since he had no idea who else could’ve.
This was the best interrogation in the game.
"And how do you prove that detective?"
*Guides*
Intuition
did anyone try to leave Rusty behind when on a case investigation? he will then catch Cole up in a few blocks, on the back sit of a police car with sirens on. he gets out of the police car approaches to Phelps and say "do you think it's funny?"
1.Lie (Torn letter)
2.Lie (Tiernan's accusation)
3.Lie (McCaffrey's criminal record)
oh
1.lie (book)
For the alibi I put in tiermans alibi
2 is torn letter
Walking into doors is just Phelp's warm up routine before interviewing suspects
4:16 I can’t help, but look how good McCaffrey looks when he’s pissed
At least I arrested the right guy. The minute he said "bitch" I knew he was a criminal
But he didn't kill her.
@@jareddavis9012 you must charge him, or the maximum rating you can get on this case is 3 stars.
@@moonmoon2479 Man who cares about Stars? Logic over stars.
@@MariusBoss11458 Logic doesn't even matter in this case, cause neither of them killed her. Both have large amounts of evidence stacked against them so might as well pin it on the most hated suspect and get good PR.
@@manletchief Plus he looked like he killed her so fuck it.
It was a pain to get this one. The game intentionally confuses you. If mccaffrey did it then it doesnt makes sense for him to leave the evidence there so obvious. No one would be so bold as to try and set up the other guy by incriminating themselves like that. And even if they did they would at least look nervous in some way. He shook the entire thing off like he was 100% innocent, and the game plays dramatic music that all but convinces you to charge tiernan. I reccomend using a walkthrough for this game. They made it b.s. so you would have a reason to play it a second time.
Lmao that music plays for all suspects, and both turn out to be innocent
Some of the interrogations até definetly bs
I kinda knew right away Because I had a suspicion tiernan had a few screws lose in his head which is probably how mcaffery made him confused if he did it not
Killed her because she stole his book haha
J0sh 2k2 he didnt kill her though the black dialhia planted evidence
@@joshuahughes5761 When looked at first glance without the information you mentioned, it sounded like he killed Summers at the heat of the moment. Count that with the Syracuse incident and bam, he was the perfect guy to frame.
@@hammerbro1947 Don’t forget being a commie.
He didn't kill her, though. It was actually a bartender, when they foun dat out they release MacCaffrey.
Oh hey you play a noire aswell!!!
Do you like Roy from this game?
Underboss from the Marina Family Yes do you?
+UnCaged Mayhem He's racist!
Underboss from the Marina Family good
I knew it was McCaffrey right from the beginning because of his smug attitude.
It wasn’t but he’s an asshole
This was a DAMN good case. I restarted 3 times
R.I.P ‘Issac Clarke’ and ‘CommanderOutlaw’.
one of my favorite characters
How so?
@@itsblitz4437 probably because McCaffery challenges Phelps. You know when someone is so unlikable you have to appreciate it
Look, man, he was excited as all get out. You know how detectives get their jollies off from a perfect interrogation.
(Looking at you with a relaxed face, no uneasy facial/eye movements.)
I'd like to see one of the suspects from this game in the sequel and have Cole say, "Ahh...so we meet again."
But he's dead.
We all know... about the girl ... THAT GIRL WAS READY TO GRAAWWWL -this is america - lets change the subject. = This is germany
I know dat 1. It's from YTP, btw McCaffrey looks kinda hot, lol.
I WANT MAH BESBOL!!!
I just gotta keep my mouth shut and watch u run circles, around Jewish people.
I like your ass!
You're lying Morgan!
Crazy how Garrett Mason was the true murderer behind all the homicides and framed all the suspects that were supposedly the killers
When you get the right answers on this game there's some scary music that plays
I wish they kept McCaffrey kept his calm demeanor throughout this interrogation. Would’ve made it 100x harder
Victor Nguyen I think making him break was the best part, dropping his facade
how do you get his crimal record in your notebook ? i seem not to have it
Old post but...You go and speak to Tiernan after McCaffrey accuses him and you're given an option to use the telephone to check his criminal and military record.
+MiyuEmi i love rockstar for putting that in the game. LA Noire was a great game incredibly ahead of its time and any other game company could have just get the huge paycheck relying the game to sell itself with the motioncap and facial expressions. Rockstar just nailed everything in the story, gameplay, mocap and character developement.
I wish they had this for ps4
John Berroa They're remastering it for Xbox One and PS4, it will be released on November 14th. I cannot wait!
Kyle Heenan Same!
Kyle Heenan
Awesome! I might buy it and play it again but this time.. I'm gonna do it serious and get all of the achievements in one go ;)
That’s awesome news! Thanks for the heads up!
I wish they would have put online co op for LA Noire where someone plays your partner and you both can solve the case together
One of my favorite cases because of the acting.... and because McCaffrey is so cute. 😘❤
He is idiot
Markeisha Pope Honestly he is handsome I tell you what.
I knew he's the suspect I want to arrest him so bad but I failed. Two times. Now I got you. Lol. Thanks man.
Oh my God thank you, this case was frustrating me so fucking much
Same took me 2 hours to finish that interrogation
This game has a tendency of not giving the option for questions even when finding the clues
God I loved this game.
McAffrey is a monster.
I thought it was tiernan because I did the arson mission and a few others and it always seemed like the guy with the loudest voice was the killer
1:58 Holy Shit isaac clarke is online!
You didn't show the first question and that's the one I needed the most
I love this channel
i had the same problem. turns out that we missed something in his apartment. The other half of the torn message. That's why it was wrong. Saying you found a torn letter doesn't mean he was there, it just means you found a torn letter.
thanks it helped me a lot i spent two hours trying
Why dose McCaffrey remind me of Quagmire from Family Guy?
Man i put the kid in the cell and didn't put this guy ....
I just made a big mistake
2:39 Nice...
Poor ben shapiro
thanks this vid was a great help
this wasnt the silk stocking murder case. evelyn summers was killed in the studio secretary case...
2:40 is the perfect part
I put the letter answer and it didn't work me 🙄 maybe it is different on PC?
You need to find the other half of the note in mcaffes apartment
McCaffery is unironically pretty based
To a mentally ill person he is
Goddamn this game is good.
He is too proudy
@Bloodywolf19900 When you see the words, "SPOILER ALERT", you're supposed to stop reading.
Grosvenor McCaffrey got pwned with his interrogation. He got what was coming to him, and if he'd known any better, he wouldn't have murdered Evelyn Summers! If he HAD gone into combat, he probably wouldn't have been a repeat offender in the first place! He probably would've been dead from combat had he gone into combat. Phelps went into the service, went into combat, and most importantly, served his country as a serviceman. Now with the LAPD, Cole serves up a mean, hot dish of justice.
+Kurtis Saar - Spoiler alert:
He didn't kill Evelyn. That was the work of the Black Dahlia killer.
@@KurtisC93 Spoilers:
But they got no one. It's a ghost.
What the hell do they keep saying? "I put him down with my saddle?" What the hell does that mean?! I hear it over and over and I never understand what he's saying.
Easiest interrogation IMO
why dosen't this video start at the first question? it starts on the second and skips the first.
GODDAMMIT. I'd already seen the line underneath before I saw the Spoiler Alert.
Hottest dude in all the game
There is a glitch where the phone won't pop up sometimes
@DG7412 check my guide where i interroagte him at mensch's bar there i asked him already this question. Hope this helps Greetz CTD TV
@Kaweebo uh, that's going to be kind of difficult seeing as how {SPOILER ALERT} Cole dies at the end of the game.
Only for them all to be released, due by learning Garrett Mason is the real killer.
im thinking it wasnt mccafery right now at this point, that it was tiernan
Sound, man I finally got it
Sir Isaac Clarke is online oh god where are the necromorphs
He looks like Robbie Williams
flyvid so true . and treinan looks like Olly Murs
In having a glitch on the first question in answering right but the game says I got it wrong and yes I did find both pieces of the letter
Mr Isaac Clarke is online xD
You literally skipped the first question
How do you get the 'Military Service' option? I did exactly what you did but I don't have it :/
how do u get the access to tire iron question for McCaffrey?? i examined the tire iron in his room...
This didn’t help with the switch version
1:45 - Oh, come on! They literally just fucking change the subject when you press accuse! Oh course I have fucking evidence for you wanting to hurt Everyn, you muppet, but that isn't what you said before the prompt. I hate this game.
I guess blue line flag doesn't like this good choices.
I swear Mcaffrey's voice sounds similar to another character.
Thanks lol was stuck for a whole year...
You get dishonorable discharge for beating up a thief that tries to steal from you?
TheSm1thers beating up =/= nearly killing
Yes, if you beat a woman civilian almost to death you will be dishonorably discharged.
You're a real slimeball.
Ryan Denziloe You're allowed to shoot people that break into your home, why can't you at least hit someone that tries to steal something from you?
@@colzbroeffectboss4619 But he was not at home, but at a military company in a foreign country, so he had no right to lynch against local civilians.
Who can tell me the correct answers for the interrogation for the Nintendo switch version
What's your intro music?
Shutterbugg by Big Boi
Why the hell does it tell me that the half of the letter was wrong although in this video its correct? It dosen't make any f*cking sense at all.
Bro you already answered the first one
Childhood favourite game ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
So when I use the torn letter as evidence to the first question it doesn't work I get a X next to the question smh 🤦♂️ I can't pin this guy the game won't let me it wants me to arrest that tierian dude. Idk what to do other than to arrest tieran for it to progress the story :/
why wont it let me charge mccaffrey?
Where do you get the clue that he was in the war?
whats the first answer , please?
Nice intro
How are you playing on a 360?
Can some one tell me how you get the to ask about his military service because i cant find it
thanks man
whats the first question answer please?
What's that song called, in the beginning
LOL i love your intro!!!
wtf the telephone icon dosent come up on mine