Great video, you had me expecting you were going chalk with Caleb Williams and Drake Maye but you really threw me for a loop with Kedon Slovis QB2! Keep up the good work!
I watched Caleb a lot when he was a freshman at OU. What I saw was he just looked like football just came natural to him. If I remember correctly, his senior year in HS was wiped out by COVID, and looked like he barely missed a day. And his game vs Texas is one of my favorite memories as a Sooners fan. He’s gonna be really good in the NFL.
Penix lack of pocket presence? Sir, That’s an absurd take. He was great at getting the ball out on time and not taking sacks. How about the game against usc when he threw the td to culp on the move dropping it in a bucket between 2-3 defenders. Polk in the Texas game to set the TD. There’s a highlight reel of these type of plays.
Marcus you have literally the best timing. Abt to head out on a 5 hour road trip. I only had bootleg to listen to but now you’ve given me this. Thanks man
Great evaluations, especially of Bo Nix, who I think would fit really well with the Vikings offense. Nix moves well enough to survive and operate behind MN's average NFL O line. His excellent pre-snap reads and tendency to hit quick passes in defensive soft spots means that JA, JJ and Hock each should get opportunities to get lots of RAC. It would be up to KOC to tell Bo who his first read would be. His B+ passing outside the pocket also bodes well, as does his ability to scramble for first downs. This adds up to a rookie QB that could survive starting on day one. Give him a legit RB1 for play action fakes, and you might just have a very functional system.
@@thestormofwarI like McCarthy more; I think his style would be more similar to kirks (especially if we got a good rb for him to lean on a bit); and I’m worried about KOC’s ability to play call for mobile QB’s after Dobb’s fell off the face of the earth last season (once we were able to actually game-plan for him starting).
penix can extend plays, he’s just gotten away from it due to his injury history. when it comes down to it he can get back to the creative extensions he made in high school, and the flashes of that he showed this year. i think he will be amazing if developed correctly
Watch penix last season, everyone’s basing it off this szn, last year he was making all the underneath reads with good pocket presence not just the deep ball, kid has all the talent in the world, only thing that will hold him back is injuries. Easily the 3rd best qb in the draft
I was initially shocked to hear you say Caleb Williams is the worst QB in the draft, but when you made your point that since the Bears are going draft him, he's going to be a bust, I had to agree. Excellent analysis overall!
Can't wait for your "my guys" segment this year! That Cheifs defense has 3 of my own "My guys" on it from the past couple years. (Mcduffie, Chanel, Bolton)
I feel like everyone overvalued the ability to "create" with Stroud last year and undervalued how good he is throwing from the pocket. Even though Penix isn't as good as Stroud, it's surprising to see people do the same with him this year. Just my opinion, but I think what he can do is much more valuable than what he can't.
That “create” narrative so overrated only qb recently that has won a chip from being “creative” is Mahomes. Stafford Brady nick foles etc. at the end of the day, pocket presence, processing abd throwing under pressure will always remain superior
Stroud created his ass off against one of the best defenses ever in the playoffs against Georgia. He just didn't have to show it that often playing inferior big ten teams, and played to what he was coached.
@@Trashbag095 Stafford is one of the most creative QBs in NFL history what are you talking about? In fact the QB in recent NFL history most similar to Patrick Mahomes, is Matthew Stafford.
@@knightdance8377 Penix has excellent pocket presence. Watching the tape you see him step up, step to the side, avoid a free rusher and make a nice throw really frequently. Sometimes it's bizarre, you watch people analyze tape and come away with completely opposite impressions.
TFG: “I’m not a Penix hater” Also TFG: “he could end up being a worse version of Jacoby Brissett” Those two comments are COMPLETELY mutually exclusive, dude😂
Watched a bit of Jayden Daniels over the last few days and I feel like his arm talent is being a little overrated. Sure he throws an accurate deep ball, but the ball doesn't zip out of his hands like some of the other guys. You don't see him fit the ball into tight windows often either and I feel like part of his hesitation to throw over the middle like you mentioned is because he isn't that confident in his ability to. Imo his arm strength is about on par with Bo Nix and a bit behind McCarthy.
Penix blew my mind, whoever has a great oline and decent receivers he is perfect. For that team he is a gem hiding behind a lot of highly rated QBs. Sorta a Tom Brady upside potential, wrong team he will get crushed and ended.
McCarthy ball of clay? Lol Maybe fair if practically a QB draft truism, but then pointless. A crap way to say unlimited development upsides. Which is what he is saying… When I wrote that I didnt realize he had Penix ahead of McCarthy. McCarthy is an easier fit for teams to build with/around, less fragile. If Penix is like a well polished Tom Brady. McCarthy is the Tom Brady that left school a year early, somewhat unpolished. Since Penix and McCarthy are so far down on everyone’s lists, it helps for evaluatiors to ignore they played well enough to get in the National Championship this year, the potential hiding in plain sight. So far, Penix and McCarthy are the most high profile, hidden gems, ever. Exactly what at least two NFL teams want.
Great stuff. Wish a lot more Washington fans would look up more info and see Jayden is NOT a better option that Drake at #2. I’lll be checking out your other videos. Second to none breakdown brother.
I mean this is about where everyone is putting all these QBs rn. I trust him more than most TV people cause he actually watches film and goes to events to watch prospects play
QBs are a crap shoot. Nobody really knows who will or won’t work out at QB. You watch the film, you say, “this is my best guess”, and you cross your fingers.
@samhensley4934 Or you just follow the herd and say all the same things and never look back. They're all wrong and terrible together. Safety in numbers. Caleb will be just as awesome as Bryce was. Then they'll all be back next year hyping Deion II. Is what it is.
Bo Nix is a one read stare down QB , who was never hit while throwing a TD over 5 years. He has tunnel vision cant process, snd made a living throwing to wide open NFL recievers behind the best blocking line in college. He never turned his head in college.his arm strength is bottom tier.
came to take a look at who might potentially be the pick for the Giants, but honestly feel confident that Daboll will get the most out of any of them to maximize their talents which has me kinda leaning towards the ideal draft night being taking Nabers/Odunze at 6 and then using the 2 seconds or a future pick to get back into the 1st for that 5th year on someone like JJ or Nix. Whoever they take, I dont think there is a single coach I'd want to develop my young QB more than Daboll and Kafka after the job they've done with Jones last year, but the work with DeVito convinced me that whatever they're doing with the QBs is rare. To go from running the WC against the Jets when he first took snaps because you feared what he might do to winning 3 games with him and making people believe he was actually the Giants Purdy (the most insane shit ever to anyone who watched him either at Cuse, Illinois or here) was remarkable. So glad that Kafka was retained because I can't say for sure who is the better of the QB whisperers, but no matter what QB is taken or where, I will convince myself its the start of their fledgling HoF career.
Not sure I understand how Jayden Daniels has a 10 % overall accuracy difference between him and Maye, yet you have Maye with substantially better ratings. At the very least Daniels should have an A+ deep accuracy. I also think his mid range accuracy is at least a B. Otherwise, good job
Shocked to see Taulia so high. I think he will go undrafted, and be a practice squad/UFL guy. Whereas Travis should be a 4th-5th round pick and a solid backup for awhile
On your video in the background, Nix is hitting second and third reads repeatedly. Kind of tough to buy the first read only narrative. It’s also hard to buy your arm strength argument as well when he’s on tape running and hitting a guy in stride at 55 with the flick of a wrist. Good fit for Minnesota like McCarthy. Also on Nix, his ball placement is some of the best I’ve ever seen. He hits guys in stride, back shoulders, and in position for serious yac. Reminds me of Kurt Warner at this. It’s a seriously underestimated trait for the next level.
First of all, just because you look one way first, doesn't mean that guy is your first read. College offenses design look offs when he first read is not in that direction. Second, he didn't say Nix was a first read only guy, he said that he's uniquely good at hitting his first read, there's a difference.
Drake Maye legit holds the ball forever. Idk i see a lot of bust potential. Idk if its the acc cameras but his release looks slow. People say hes herbert but idk hes got the light athlete type movement. But idk i see the Carson Wentz way more thab Justin Herbert.
I like Taulia a lot as a backup QB, I could see him thriving in AZs stretch zone PA WCO. Love to draft him if he’s available in the 6th to compete with Clayton Tune as Kyler Murray’s backup. That might be a bit unfair though because I think Tune will take a huge step forward after a year in this system transitioning from the straight airraid he ran at UH.
I could be completely wrong with these comps, but Tyrod Taylor is my comparison for Jodan Travis, and somewhat of an alex smtith/colin kaepernick hybrid for JJ McCarthy
JJ Mccarthy is a 15 year franchise QB , he doesnt have the reps because he didnt need to throw. He ran the offense. Ehat you missed is he has 2 bug time pro throws every game. He also checks every box for a franchise QB
Wouldn’t you consider Penix similar to Stafford, with his arm talent and deep ball ability? I think he’ll be a really good #2 for the rams, considering another team doesn’t draft him as a starter.
There's a lot more context to it than that, but yeah... He ended up QB6 as I learned about his knee problems and it's not like there's anyone from that class to speak of 🤷♂️
The single most important factor for a QB's success in the NFL is quickness at mental processing - understanding and recognizing what is happening on the field. It doesn't matter how gifted he is physically. I don't know if he can process fast enough for NFL speeds. If he can, he's going to be fantastic. If he doesn't, he's not going to do well.
IMO I think the scouts are going to love JJ Mccarthy, I could be wrong but the guy has so much talent that was not realized because Mivhigan was such a run heavy team. I mean there was a game I can't remember, maybe Penn state but they ran an entire half, not one pass. Some people may think thats a bad sign, like they didn't trust him to throw but it was more that they knew they win just by running it down their throats but I believe he will be in the top 4 QBs taken once it's all said and done
Been saying that his entire college career, and it hasn't happened. Love the guy and everything he did for Michigan while he was there, but the writing's on the wall for him.
Caleb doesn’t make fast enough decisions for the NFL in my opinion. He needs to do a ton of work on that. He won’t be able to hold that ball as long in the NFL. The players are simply too fast. How many TD’s and picks the last 5 games or so? Lights up bad defenses, not good against decent defenses.
Small sample size, but that is pretty much spot on. Holding on to the ball. Looked good against bad defenses and really struggling against good defenses about two thirds through his rookie year.
As a bears fan, with how reckless and poorly run the bears have been for all my life (born way after 85) if the bears pass on Caleb and penix falls to Minnesotas lap idk if I’ll still be able to be a fan of the team
I have the #1 overall pick in my dynasty league. Who would you recommend I go with? I’m trying to decide between Marvin Harrison Jr. or Caleb Williams. My league is a 2 QB league. I already have Dak, Kyler Murray, Bryce Young and Stafford. My top receivers are Justin Jefferson, CD Lamb, DJ Moore, Zay Flowers, Calvin Ridley and Jakobi Meyers. Biggest weakness on my roster is RB but I don’t think any are going to be worth taking #1 overall.
Kyler Murray is going to go OFF this next season and will have a huge season next year both in fantasy n reality. In fantasy two other Cardinals you might want to think about drafting is TE Trey McBride who’s developed into an elite top 5 TE and should be even better next year as he will be thee guy from WK1 and is basically a #1 himself. Secondly I think 2nd year WR 6”2/213pd Michael Wilson will have a huge season as a AZs Z #2 WR and will get a lot of work/targets in the red zone. Hes a late 1st early 2nd rd talent who fell to the 3rd because of injuries in college and he’s very good. And then of course Marvin Harrison Ir who they most likely draft lol.
1. Caleb Williams 2. Drake Maye 3. Jayden Daniels 4. Bo Nix 5. Michael Penix Jr. 6. J. J. McCarthy 7. Spencer Rattler 8. Michael Pratt 9. Devin Leary 10. Jordan Travis
Does anyone get the feeling we are falling a little bit too much in love with the "this guys cieling is so high if he can just put it all together" prospects? Now adays the QBs who do the little things well but arentt necessarily the fastest or the flashiest athletes arent as appreciated. Feels like we're overthinking what makes a good QB. I want my QB to be able to escape, versus being able to "run".
Mahomes, Allen, even Herbert...seeing the top qbs in the NFL be guys that there were questions on coming out is going to give teams hope they can find those guys too.
Those are two very similar things. If you can run, you can escape. And yes, it is important in the NFL. Look at Patrick Mahomes, one of the best passers in the NFL, and check how many first downs he has scrambled for. He does it all the time and it's crucial to his team.
Are there any offenses in the NFL that have a RPO one read concept? I don't think any offensive coordinator has a primary receiver and 2 or 3 decoy routes, the coaches want the QB to look at 1 if covered go to 2 if covered go to 3 if covered scramble. That isn't Nix he is read the first option if covered checkdown or run that is why his time to throw is 2.49 seconds, that is a testament of his inability to look for the other routes.
Great video, you had me expecting you were going chalk with Caleb Williams and Drake Maye but you really threw me for a loop with Kedon Slovis QB2! Keep up the good work!
Especially with Sam Hartman at QB1
@001Khy why would it be funny? Sam Hartman and his handsome beard is a very serious prospect.
I was more surprised Marvin Harrison Jr was #1 QB
@001Khyyes
He just wants the be different
Having Spencer Rattler as qb 3 was certainly a surprise but I see the vision
*QB7
QB7
@@MyMarkjoeQB17*
Rattler's analysis was literally "boys will be boys" lmao
*QB1
I was really surprised that JJ McCarthy ended up as QB 1 for you, but he certainly brings winning experience to whoever drafts him
😂
lol I haven’t watched the video yet this feels like trolling 😂
Or I’m in for a shocking revelation
Why did I believe this
In my opinion bringing “winning experience” does little to nothing.
I watched Caleb a lot when he was a freshman at OU. What I saw was he just looked like football just came natural to him. If I remember correctly, his senior year in HS was wiped out by COVID, and looked like he barely missed a day. And his game vs Texas is one of my favorite memories as a Sooners fan. He’s gonna be really good in the NFL.
Penix lack of pocket presence? Sir, That’s an absurd take. He was great at getting the ball out on time and not taking sacks. How about the game against usc when he threw the td to culp on the move dropping it in a bucket between 2-3 defenders. Polk in the Texas game to set the TD. There’s a highlight reel of these type of plays.
Gotta admit Caleb’s highlights are insane
Insanely unimpressive, indeed. Small, slow, never throws on time. Whoa! Such a superstar! 😂
@@FantasySportsZen justin fields is trash
Yeah I just wish he didn’t have the personality of a 16yr old girl
@@FantasySportsZen so you watched him play and that’s what you came up with for an evaluation? don’t talk sports anymore
@@phene-449 he’s not trash
It’s the bears tf do you expect ?
So wild how Trevor Lawrence is being used as a comp now for a prospect, feels like just yesterday watching that top 10 video of that QB class lol
Hahah crazy isn’t it
Then he still comes in second. Just nuts.
the nfl is a coaching
@@itscebby8882 personally think williams will be the worst out the bunch
Marcus you have literally the best timing. Abt to head out on a 5 hour road trip. I only had bootleg to listen to but now you’ve given me this. Thanks man
My opinion has arrived folks ❗️❗️❗️
I agree.
After what he said about stroud I’m a little more cautious
This guy misses on so many players lol. Watch Bengal for real analysis
@@AustinBreheverybody misses on players genius. Bengal would tell you this guy does good work.
@@AustinBreh no one in the world does not miss on players lol
Great video as always Marcus. One thing. Can you include ages in your evaluation graphics?
Agree
im leaving for the army soon so wont be able to watch the draft this year but im always excited when marcus uploads these kinds of videos
Thank you for your service!!!
Bro I hope your team wins next year superbowl 🫡
Hooah, good luck dude
Best of Luck Bro! One of The finest!
Don't get captured.
lets gooo, these are some of my favorite videos out there
YOOOO YOURE A TFG FAN TOOO??
love the rebuilds bro 🔥
Love the rebuilds bro, It’d be cool if you used the TFG roster for one of your rebuilds…
Hey bwandon 🥲
The guy I trust most in player evaluations. Thanks for the hard work you do TFG!
Great evaluations, especially of Bo Nix, who I think would fit really well with the Vikings offense. Nix moves well enough to survive and operate behind MN's average NFL O line. His excellent pre-snap reads and tendency to hit quick passes in defensive soft spots means that JA, JJ and Hock each should get opportunities to get lots of RAC. It would be up to KOC to tell Bo who his first read would be. His B+ passing outside the pocket also bodes well, as does his ability to scramble for first downs. This adds up to a rookie QB that could survive starting on day one. Give him a legit RB1 for play action fakes, and you might just have a very functional system.
I think he or McCarthy could work for the Vikes.
@@thestormofwarI like McCarthy more; I think his style would be more similar to kirks (especially if we got a good rb for him to lean on a bit); and I’m worried about KOC’s ability to play call for mobile QB’s after Dobb’s fell off the face of the earth last season (once we were able to actually game-plan for him starting).
Jayden Daniels to me just seems like Justin Fields at Ohio State minus 20 pounds
Jayden has a much better fundamental skills as a QB Justin is a elite athlete that’s all.
Well Jayden has shown improvement at least.
Glad to see this content is back. Your 2023 draft class put me on a lot of guys I didn't know like Laporta and tank dell. Lets goooo!
I love this specific series of videos you make bro!
Just remember this is the guy that had Justin Herbert as the qb6
I think JJ is being slept on. His arm talent is underrated as is his poise and accuracy.
Props sir. This is always some of your best content.
Your Procomp for tauli should be “gunslinger without a gun”
Love the videos Marcus, keep it up!
Nerfslinger
Doesn't that mean he'd die?
Not sure how Taulia is ahead of Joe Milton or even Sam Hartman lmao
Cowboy with a slingshot
I’ve been waiting for this! As a Vikings fan, I’m sure we are gonna pick one of these guys up. Should be fun!
Hopefully Bo Nix
@@beatlesandoasis6631 High floor low ceiling, JJ seems like he could be a lot better.
Loved the video. That Caleb kid at QB 7 feels a bit high but you know what, you're the expert!
babe i have to cancel our plans tfg just dropped a classic
I am excited. I have been waiting for these videos to start.
Dats my dawg ! Been waiting on your top 10s for each position, thanks for the upload gang
penix can extend plays, he’s just gotten away from it due to his injury history. when it comes down to it he can get back to the creative extensions he made in high school, and the flashes of that he showed this year. i think he will be amazing if developed correctly
He’s the best in this class
@@davidwillis8623 Agreed, the injuries are the issue.
@@pugilist102 he may be one of those “when healthy” guys
No better channel to follow for draft season, so excited for the content this year with so many fun players!
Watch penix last season, everyone’s basing it off this szn, last year he was making all the underneath reads with good pocket presence not just the deep ball, kid has all the talent in the world, only thing that will hold him back is injuries. Easily the 3rd best qb in the draft
Agreed I'm going Williams, Daniels, Penix, Maye, McCarthy, Nix, Rattler.
Really enjoyed your outlook
Tulane student here don’t sleep on micheal pratt, man made a ton of big throws i could totally see him being a top tier backup
I am hyped for all your rankings. Your my favorite guide through the draft season.
I was initially shocked to hear you say Caleb Williams is the worst QB in the draft, but when you made your point that since the Bears are going draft him, he's going to be a bust, I had to agree. Excellent analysis overall!
Can't wait for your "my guys" segment this year! That Cheifs defense has 3 of my own "My guys" on it from the past couple years. (Mcduffie, Chanel, Bolton)
I feel like everyone overvalued the ability to "create" with Stroud last year and undervalued how good he is throwing from the pocket. Even though Penix isn't as good as Stroud, it's surprising to see people do the same with him this year. Just my opinion, but I think what he can do is much more valuable than what he can't.
Im more worried about his pocket presence tbh
That “create” narrative so overrated only qb recently that has won a chip from being “creative” is Mahomes. Stafford Brady nick foles etc. at the end of the day, pocket presence, processing abd throwing under pressure will always remain superior
Stroud created his ass off against one of the best defenses ever in the playoffs against Georgia. He just didn't have to show it that often playing inferior big ten teams, and played to what he was coached.
@@Trashbag095 Stafford is one of the most creative QBs in NFL history what are you talking about? In fact the QB in recent NFL history most similar to Patrick Mahomes, is Matthew Stafford.
@@knightdance8377 Penix has excellent pocket presence. Watching the tape you see him step up, step to the side, avoid a free rusher and make a nice throw really frequently. Sometimes it's bizarre, you watch people analyze tape and come away with completely opposite impressions.
TFG: “I’m not a Penix hater”
Also TFG: “he could end up being a worse version of Jacoby Brissett”
Those two comments are COMPLETELY mutually exclusive, dude😂
You break down tape better than any vid on the 2024 Draft that I've yet seen, good work!
This is where I come for good opinions that are well researched and not presented for shock value. Just great content.
Pretty chalk top 5, but I really like how detailed you are in your technical analysis of the players
I think bo is solidly a first round qb- amazing video as always was looking forward to this!!! This class is amazing
Was waiting for this!
Watched a bit of Jayden Daniels over the last few days and I feel like his arm talent is being a little overrated. Sure he throws an accurate deep ball, but the ball doesn't zip out of his hands like some of the other guys. You don't see him fit the ball into tight windows often either and I feel like part of his hesitation to throw over the middle like you mentioned is because he isn't that confident in his ability to. Imo his arm strength is about on par with Bo Nix and a bit behind McCarthy.
Penix blew my mind, whoever has a great oline and decent receivers he is perfect. For that team he is a gem hiding behind a lot of highly rated QBs. Sorta a Tom Brady upside potential, wrong team he will get crushed and ended.
McCarthy ball of clay?
Lol Maybe fair if practically a QB draft truism, but then pointless.
A crap way to say unlimited development upsides.
Which is what he is saying…
When I wrote that I didnt realize he had Penix ahead of McCarthy.
McCarthy is an easier fit for teams to build with/around, less fragile.
If Penix is like a well polished Tom Brady.
McCarthy is the Tom Brady that left school a year early, somewhat unpolished.
Since Penix and McCarthy are so far down on everyone’s lists, it helps for evaluatiors to ignore they played well enough to get in the National Championship this year, the potential hiding in plain sight.
So far, Penix and McCarthy are the most high profile, hidden gems, ever.
Exactly what at least two NFL teams want.
Great stuff. Wish a lot more Washington fans would look up more info and see Jayden is NOT a better option that Drake at #2. I’lll be checking out your other videos. Second to none breakdown brother.
I love TFG. I love his draft videos. I trust his analysis in a lot of ways. But, his QB prospect evaluations I trust the least of everything he does.
That's fine, but I am curious who you do trust for QB evaluations?
I mean this is about where everyone is putting all these QBs rn. I trust him more than most TV people cause he actually watches film and goes to events to watch prospects play
@@ThatFranchiseGuy Idt you'll ever live down that Justin Herbert evaluation 😂
QBs are a crap shoot. Nobody really knows who will or won’t work out at QB. You watch the film, you say, “this is my best guess”, and you cross your fingers.
@samhensley4934 Or you just follow the herd and say all the same things and never look back. They're all wrong and terrible together. Safety in numbers.
Caleb will be just as awesome as Bryce was. Then they'll all be back next year hyping Deion II. Is what it is.
Pratt reminds me of an athletic Mullens from the Vikings
Babe wake up, TFG dropped some more draft content ‼️
Bo Nix is a one read stare down QB , who was never hit while throwing a TD over 5 years. He has tunnel vision cant process, snd made a living throwing to wide open NFL recievers behind the best blocking line in college. He never turned his head in college.his arm strength is bottom tier.
It’s certainly a hot take having Phil Jurkovec as your QB1 but I think that’s spot on
Phil the Thrill Baby!
Lmao trash 🗑️
came to take a look at who might potentially be the pick for the Giants, but honestly feel confident that Daboll will get the most out of any of them to maximize their talents which has me kinda leaning towards the ideal draft night being taking Nabers/Odunze at 6 and then using the 2 seconds or a future pick to get back into the 1st for that 5th year on someone like JJ or Nix. Whoever they take, I dont think there is a single coach I'd want to develop my young QB more than Daboll and Kafka after the job they've done with Jones last year, but the work with DeVito convinced me that whatever they're doing with the QBs is rare. To go from running the WC against the Jets when he first took snaps because you feared what he might do to winning 3 games with him and making people believe he was actually the Giants Purdy (the most insane shit ever to anyone who watched him either at Cuse, Illinois or here) was remarkable. So glad that Kafka was retained because I can't say for sure who is the better of the QB whisperers, but no matter what QB is taken or where, I will convince myself its the start of their fledgling HoF career.
good to have this series back
Nice flow on the Daniels review
Not sure I understand how Jayden Daniels has a 10 % overall accuracy difference between him and Maye, yet you have Maye with substantially better ratings. At the very least Daniels should have an A+ deep accuracy. I also think his mid range accuracy is at least a B. Otherwise, good job
Yeees was so happy when I saw you put this video out!!
Great analysis
Jayden Daniels looks like tyrod forsure!!
I’ve been waiting on this, can’t wait!!!
Shocked to see Taulia so high. I think he will go undrafted, and be a practice squad/UFL guy. Whereas Travis should be a 4th-5th round pick and a solid backup for awhile
Bo nix is heavily slept on
On your video in the background, Nix is hitting second and third reads repeatedly. Kind of tough to buy the first read only narrative. It’s also hard to buy your arm strength argument as well when he’s on tape running and hitting a guy in stride at 55 with the flick of a wrist. Good fit for Minnesota like McCarthy.
Also on Nix, his ball placement is some of the best I’ve ever seen. He hits guys in stride, back shoulders, and in position for serious yac. Reminds me of Kurt Warner at this. It’s a seriously underestimated trait for the next level.
First of all, just because you look one way first, doesn't mean that guy is your first read. College offenses design look offs when he first read is not in that direction. Second, he didn't say Nix was a first read only guy, he said that he's uniquely good at hitting his first read, there's a difference.
Ruining my sleep schedule to watch this, great work as always marcus
Drake Maye legit holds the ball forever. Idk i see a lot of bust potential. Idk if its the acc cameras but his release looks slow. People say hes herbert but idk hes got the light athlete type movement. But idk i see the Carson Wentz way more thab Justin Herbert.
Babe wake up TFG dropped a rankings video
Anyone else just not sold on Maye? Admittedly my analysis is baded off highlight tapes, i just dont see it.
Maye is more of a Philip Rivers
He reminds me of Kenny Pickett
I like Taulia a lot as a backup QB, I could see him thriving in AZs stretch zone PA WCO. Love to draft him if he’s available in the 6th to compete with Clayton Tune as Kyler Murray’s backup.
That might be a bit unfair though because I think Tune will take a huge step forward after a year in this system transitioning from the straight airraid he ran at UH.
Love seeing Spencer’s bounce back
I could be completely wrong with these comps, but Tyrod Taylor is my comparison for Jodan Travis, and somewhat of an alex smtith/colin kaepernick hybrid for JJ McCarthy
Didn’t know Ben Gulbranson was declaring, but QB4 is not as hot a take as a lot of people think!
Great video, enjoyed the information and break downs. Thank you.
Can’t wait for the 10 WRs, TFG is one of the best evaluators of the WR position out there
JJ Mccarthy is a 15 year franchise QB , he doesnt have the reps because he didnt need to throw. He ran the offense. Ehat you missed is he has 2 bug time pro throws every game. He also checks every box for a franchise QB
Wouldn’t you consider Penix similar to Stafford, with his arm talent and deep ball ability?
I think he’ll be a really good #2 for the rams, considering another team doesn’t draft him as a starter.
id say more like bradford.
Nice job. Thank you.
I'll never forget you had Carson Strong as your Qb1 and then he went undrafted 😂
There's a lot more context to it than that, but yeah...
He ended up QB6 as I learned about his knee problems and it's not like there's anyone from that class to speak of 🤷♂️
@ThatFranchiseGuy Your definitely not wrong, it's just funny in hindsight
I dont know how I missed this, I have notifications on
i like pratt. 4 year starter and who saw a single Tulane game till he was on the scene...he helped make them relevant.
Thank you for my person draft analysis that I will be sharing with my friends and passionately arguing
personal
Michael Pratt at QB3 is interesting
Good analysis and video man. I got a sub for you
The single most important factor for a QB's success in the NFL is quickness at mental processing - understanding and recognizing what is happening on the field. It doesn't matter how gifted he is physically. I don't know if he can process fast enough for NFL speeds. If he can, he's going to be fantastic. If he doesn't, he's not going to do well.
Agreed. Two words: Zach Wilson.
IMO I think the scouts are going to love JJ Mccarthy, I could be wrong but the guy has so much talent that was not realized because Mivhigan was such a run heavy team. I mean there was a game I can't remember, maybe Penn state but they ran an entire half, not one pass. Some people may think thats a bad sign, like they didn't trust him to throw but it was more that they knew they win just by running it down their throats but I believe he will be in the top 4 QBs taken once it's all said and done
Michael Penix in Atlanta would be scary
Joe Milton could be amazing if he develops well
QB Milton is rated as the top ten in other quarterback rankings. He will be drafted!
Been saying that his entire college career, and it hasn't happened.
Love the guy and everything he did for Michigan while he was there, but the writing's on the wall for him.
Bruh did you watch him at the senior bowl? Dude needs a lot of development to even be serviceable.
Only watched 4 minutes so far and I love the format. Subscribing as long as you respect Maye later on😂
10 - Jordan Travis
9 - Taulia Tagovailoa
8 - Micheal Pratt
7 - Spencer Rattler
6 - JJ McCarthy
5 - Micheal Penix Jr
4 - Bo Nix
3 - Jayden Daniels
2 - Drake Maye
1 - Caleb Williams
side note for mcCarthy, he was playing against maryland very banged up and coaches has said he was barely able to go
Caleb doesn’t make fast enough decisions for the NFL in my opinion. He needs to do a ton of work on that. He won’t be able to hold that ball as long in the NFL. The players are simply too fast.
How many TD’s and picks the last 5 games or so? Lights up bad defenses, not good against decent defenses.
Small sample size, but that is pretty much spot on. Holding on to the ball. Looked good against bad defenses and really struggling against good defenses about two thirds through his rookie year.
Great video
It would be really cool if Nix goes to Denver because then the AFC west would have both the Oregon QBs who wear number 10 in the same division
As a bears fan, with how reckless and poorly run the bears have been for all my life (born way after 85) if the bears pass on Caleb and penix falls to Minnesotas lap idk if I’ll still be able to be a fan of the team
I have the #1 overall pick in my dynasty league. Who would you recommend I go with? I’m trying to decide between Marvin Harrison Jr. or Caleb Williams. My league is a 2 QB league. I already have Dak, Kyler Murray, Bryce Young and Stafford. My top receivers are Justin Jefferson, CD Lamb, DJ Moore, Zay Flowers, Calvin Ridley and Jakobi Meyers. Biggest weakness on my roster is RB but I don’t think any are going to be worth taking #1 overall.
2 QB league I feel like Caleb should be a no brainer, just saying
Kyler Murray is going to go OFF this next season and will have a huge season next year both in fantasy n reality.
In fantasy two other Cardinals you might want to think about drafting is TE Trey McBride who’s developed into an elite top 5 TE and should be even better next year as he will be thee guy from WK1 and is basically a #1 himself. Secondly I think 2nd year WR 6”2/213pd Michael Wilson will have a huge season as a AZs Z #2 WR and will get a lot of work/targets in the red zone. Hes a late 1st early 2nd rd talent who fell to the 3rd because of injuries in college and he’s very good. And then of course Marvin Harrison Ir who they most likely draft lol.
1. Caleb Williams
2. Drake Maye
3. Jayden Daniels
4. Bo Nix
5. Michael Penix Jr.
6. J. J. McCarthy
7. Spencer Rattler
8. Michael Pratt
9. Devin Leary
10. Jordan Travis
Sounds like JJ would be good if he could sit for a while. I’m glad we have Hendon. He was my favorite QB from last year’s draft.
Does anyone get the feeling we are falling a little bit too much in love with the "this guys cieling is so high if he can just put it all together" prospects?
Now adays the QBs who do the little things well but arentt necessarily the fastest or the flashiest athletes arent as appreciated.
Feels like we're overthinking what makes a good QB. I want my QB to be able to escape, versus being able to "run".
Mahomes, Allen, even Herbert...seeing the top qbs in the NFL be guys that there were questions on coming out is going to give teams hope they can find those guys too.
Those are two very similar things. If you can run, you can escape. And yes, it is important in the NFL. Look at Patrick Mahomes, one of the best passers in the NFL, and check how many first downs he has scrambled for. He does it all the time and it's crucial to his team.
HYPED. It's officially draft season
Crazy you had Devin Leary QB1. Definitely a sleeper, i commend your courage to be different.
John Rhys Plumlee at 4? A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one
My opinion on the 2024 qbs has arrived
Penix was only sacked like 14 times all year.
Are there any offenses in the NFL that have a RPO one read concept? I don't think any offensive coordinator has a primary receiver and 2 or 3 decoy routes, the coaches want the QB to look at 1 if covered go to 2 if covered go to 3 if covered scramble. That isn't Nix he is read the first option if covered checkdown or run that is why his time to throw is 2.49 seconds, that is a testament of his inability to look for the other routes.
(Eagles)
Didnt know you worked for PFF. Thats cool