If you watch the whole video with an open mind, I can guarantee a few things: 1) You will learn a ton about the differences between operatic singing and other kinds of singing. 2) You will learn a ton about what Rob and Austin's strengths and weaknesses are in their approaches to singing this operatic piece. 3) You will hear an honest analysis from someone that sings opera professionally and is a huge fan of Home Free and both these singers. Keep in mind that in this video, I provide praise for their success with this piece, along with critiques and comparisons, all of which is intended to be both constructive and educational. Much love to these two for taking on a challenging operatic aria, and thanks to all of you for watching.
I'm sad the intellectually honest feel it necessary to provide a disclaimer. Especially when they are in their wheelhouse 😀. I respect your "professional" breakdowns.
I appreciate your unbiased observations…for the untrained ear..it’s mind boggling..especially Rob. When I first heard this..my comment was you can still hear Austin’s souther twang ..subtle…but it’s there….
Rob had two comments about this recording during the premiere. First, do not ever expect them to do at a live show, because it takes a different kind of preparation to sing than the rest of the show. Second, he played the recording for his father at Father's Day, since opera is what his father most enjoys. His father cried to hear his son once again sing what he originally trained for.
Thank you, Peter. As much as I like these two, I fully understand that we should respect those professional opera singers who have honed their crafts for years. While to ordinary people's ears Rob and Austin sound 'perfect', that's not the case to those in the genre. Still, we, as homefries, should be very proud of Rob and Austin. As non-opera singers, based on Peter's (and Maggie's) comments, they seem to do a superb job... Another thing that we should really appreciate them singing Nessun Dorma is that they bring Opera to those who normally do not listen to the genre.
Agreed! I'm a Home Fry, & I absolutely adore both Rob & Austin. I've met both of them in person several times, & they're truly lovely people as well as extremely talented singers. BUT that doesn't mean I automatically think they're perfect at everything they do (nor do they think that). I know nothing about opera, so to my untrained ears it sounds fantastic. But I absolutely understand that to professional opera singers there's probably a lot of small things to improve upon. Opera is a very unique style of singing that requires years of training to perfect. That said, I do think Austin & Rob did a great job considering that they haven't spent years training in that style..
Glad I looked at your extended remarks as the first paragraph seemed rather harsh. Glad I peeked under the dots. I thought you were done. Glad you weren't. Hitting your thumbs up.
I’m a home fry and I love these guys and they are both extremely talented. And I understand that there’s a huge difference between opera and country but not being trained opera singers they did wonderful, absolutely wonderful. Just wondering if you’ve ever tried singing country?
@@carolynyerby361 Yes I actually lived in Nashville for summer and sang country music, and I grew up in the mountains of Virginia so country music has been a big part of my life
Both Austin and Rob studied vocal performance in college. Rob has more training in opera than Austin has, but Rob hasn’t sung opera In 15 years. Austin majored in musical theater, but did some opera in college.
I really appreciate the way you approach this-giving these guys all the credit they deserve for even trying this, and for everything they’re doing well, and showing the respect you have for them as singers, then pointing out where a professional opera singer would handle things differently. Very fair, very constructive and balanced. I also love the way you pick out details to talk about, then go back and let us hear it again (some of us really need the demonstration). You do a great job of making some very abstract thoughts make sense. I’ve said this before-I really wish I’d had a teacher like you when I studied vocal music in college. I might have stuck to it instead of getting discouraged. Even if it isn’t perfect operatic technique, I do love this piece. Austin’s obvious joy and bright tone are really pleasing, and I could listen to Rob sing like this all day. Hope they veer out of their lane more often! Well done, Peter. 👏🏼
Peter, thanks to you, and also to Austin and Rob (and Home Free). One thing you are all doing is increasing our appreciation for music and getting us to try flavors of music we might now try left to our own devices. Kudos to all of you, and thanks for sharing your talents with the rest of us!
It would be interesting to hear your reaction about Dan Vasc's cover of Nessum Dorma. Dan's dad was Italian (Dan speaks italian) and they used to listen to opera together and Dan's mother was an opera singer and Dan has 10+ years of classical training. Dan did this song as a tribute to his dad when he passed away so his version is very emotional. 💖
Peter, we got what we expect from you, a true defining of what we heard, yet affirmation that they have really great voices. You are one that I truly appreciate as you tell it like it is but always so encouraging. You did not come across as negative, but educationally balanced and fair. Quite frankly Rob and Austin brought a large audience to opera experience that hopefully in the long run helped both interest to the opera world and attention to Home Free. Thank you Peter.
They said that they recorded this separately, and when Austin heard Rob he wanted to redo it after they got off tour. Austin wanted to give it everything he had to make sure it was given the respect it deserves.
When Rob and Austin take off their hat and look at each other, reminds me of the glance in the Ring of Fire on the Sing-Off before Tim hits that massive LOW note. Like they are saying, "They have no idea what is coming."
I have been excited and nervous for you to do this. Excited for your analysis, and nervous for my boys…. So thanks for your introduction about your balanced approach.
The versatility of the guys always fascinates me. They are perfect in everything they touch. I don't know how many times I've listened to it - I'm still speechless! Great reaction!
I love Peter's kind, honest, and fair analysis of these two singers. He is critical without being critical. I'm going to find some songs done by Peter Barber.
I took one class on singing, am not a Home Fry, and do not like opera. I am trying to wrap my head around how it is I just spent 45 minutes raptly listening to your commentary and loved it. Damn, you're good.
LOL Dare I say welcome to the Home Free rabbit hole? These guys are an amazing vocal band (there's five of them) and I think you would really enjoy their music.
I think if you don't love opera but enjoyed this you would also love Olimpico by Dimash Kudaibergen. A nice rock approach but operatic approach. Dimash does have a solid bel canto training background though. You can search Dimash Olimpico Arnau. Enjoy.
Ahahaha--you sound a bit like me when I found Peter's channel: a combination of "*What* is this I'm listening to?!?" &, after I finished watching, "Why was that so interesting? I never even knew that ____ existed before, let alone learned about it...." Peter's a great engrossing teacher regardless of what genre of music he's talking about, & I enjoy all sorts of music more because of him. Plus I shocked a music geek friend recently by knowing something, which was all kinds of fun! >;-)
The key is getting us home fries to hear something many never would consider and then possibly get curious...plus it made Robs dad cry in happiness so I'm happy twice
Good job. It's been over 35 years since I was a voice student learning to sing opera. My professor at that time used very subjective terms to try to teach me how to sing and I just didn't get it. I've always needed objective explanations. So I appreciate you going at least a little bit into the physics of singing. I ended up taking a different path and switched to physics. Now I combine the two as a audio engineer. Even in the world of sound reinforcement, I encounter some vocalists who naturally have that "cut" (an emphasis on particular harmonics generated by vocal folds and shapes of resonance cavities) and others I need to use EQ and compression techniques to draw out those harmonics. In opera where you aren't going to have sound reinforcement, the vocalist needs to work to develop those harmonic patterns they don't naturally have. So you are right in saying that there is much about singing opera that isn't natural. There's a very good reason for that.
There are three meanings to the word "critic." You hit definitions 1 and 2, but didn't even come close to definition 3. Nice work. Thanks for the elucidation. I had not realized there was such a difference between opera and other forms of singing. critic krĭt′ĭk noun 1. One who forms and expresses judgments of the merits, faults, value, or truth of a matter. 2. One who specializes especially professionally in the evaluation and appreciation of literary or artistic works. 3.One who tends to make harsh or carping judgments; a faultfinder.
I was hoping that you would react to this. It's nice to hear the explanations about the differences in styles and seeing how close they got. Both are really talented and I'm excited that they went out of their wheelhouse to attempt something new. And that they did it well. I do have to say that your "that's a choice" comment cracked me up.
Thank you for this reaction. I found it honest and of a complimentary nature. It's not always understood how very complex singing is. These two guys are amazingly accomplished.
I loved Rob and Austin's performance of this piece. Your explanations of exactly what's going on really help me to appreciate them more. You had me listening to your whole breakdown on regular speed which is truly an accomplishment. It felt like you really enjoyed getting to drill down on their "operatic" performance instead of their usual music. I was actually laughing at a few of your comments and facial expressions - you're very charismatic and entertaining. Loved this one. Peace.
Rob is my favorite in the group because he is a very good whistler...another talent he hasn't used a lot in Home Free. But to hear his operatic chops stand up to professional critique also? That makes me respect him on a whole other level. Thank you for the honest deep dive into this aria. I clung to every word.
Great analysis, thanks. I appreciate your honesty since this is your lane. I've heard Rob did some opera early in his career, so he has a jump on Austin. Both are to be admired for putting their necks out there on the chopping block. We know how the internet can be. Thanks again.
Dear Peter: I have no music formation whatsoever, just a normal guy who loves to hear beauty in songs and I usually react to what moves my heart. What I enjoyed most in the singing of Austin and Rob (of whom I know very little actually) is the sheer joy that came across. I had no idea what they were singing about but it seemed to me that they were singing about a great and abiding love. Then I listened to your analysis and was literally floored. You opened a door to musical analysis I was not aware of and showed me another side of beauty about singing I did not know existed. The precision in your language and your attention to details are wonderful! I could pick out those details in their singing after you would point them out and that led me to go and listen to the same piece by pavaroti and I could immediately tell the difference in the power of his voice. No question about it: he can sing in ways that Rob and Austin couldn't but ... their singing touched my heart, his didn't. It came across as mechanically sound but lacking soul... not something I could clearly explain. You could blame my ignorance in music. In any case, thank you so much for your intelligent comment. I know now a little bit more about singing and opera than I did before watching you.
There are a few recent videos that I was hoping you'd cover, but this was definitely at the top because I knew you would have a ton of insight. If there was ever a video that I'd want you to spend more time with, this was it so I was really glad that you didn't stick to the 30-minute mark. Thanks so much for this!
This was the one aria that would always bring tears to my eyes when Luciano Pavarotti sang it. I got to see Turandot in Florence with Zubin Mehta conducting, so it also brought back fond memories , (I still have the Italian libretto). Your analysis was interesting and spot on Peter. While you'd never expect this good a performance from two country music singers, I agree that Rob's voice was remarkable!
Rob's voice almost brought me to tears on this one - I definitely had the sting in my eyes! As much as I love this aria, up until this was released, no other singer after Pavarotti has pulled that reaction out of me again. Rob did it! (I mean no offense to any other vocalist with this; it's just my own personal emotional reaction to hearing it.)
I respect the honesty and educational information in your analysis. I also appreciate that you give these fellas the props they're due for being brave enough to take this on. There are a handful of you professional singer reactors which likely read to the apprehension these two experienced prior to this debut. But, I feel the constructive criticism couched in mad respect comes through. Looking forward to the next video from them and the next reaction from you. 🙂
I'm a Home Free fan and know nothing about opera so I'm looking forward to your analysis. Thank you for sharing your professional expertise with me! I am thinking this piece is beginning to grow on me the more times I listen and perhaps I can develop an appreciation for opera that I may not have begun otherwise. Cheers to you!
Was waiting for your take. Despite your praise you will no doubt receive reactive comments from the Stans. Enjoyed the performance, enjoyed your analysis and learned a lot. Thanks for allowing us to train our ears with your guidance!
I really hope he doesn't get hate for simply providing an honest analysis as a professional! I adore Austin & Rob, & they did great considering their lack of operatic training. I can (& do) appreciate that they were willing to attempt something way outside their comfort zone & put themselves out there for all of us to hear. But I have no doubt that they're far from pro-level to people with trained ears. Hopefully my fellow Home Fries can also appreciate an honest & professional review. We're a fiercely loyal fan base & very protective of our guys, but we're also reasonable (mostly, LOL).
This was a commendable performance from two talented singers, and it brought emotional responses. I actually saw Pavarotti perform this in Modena when I was twelve. I had never seen so many people weeping in one place before that, and that experience resonated with me all over again during Rob's lead-off. Great review!
I have really enjoyed your commentary. I was waiting for a professional to go into depth explaining the differences in what Rob and Austin usually sing and opera. You were very fair in your assessments and very respectful of their innate talents. Thank you. I enjoyed watching this review very much.
I grew up listening to Jussi Bjoerling singing this (still the greatest tenor ever for me) and you can definitely hear the difference between a "trained" and "untrained " voice. Thanks so much for this in depth and really interesting deconstruction of what those differences are. I can hear it but I never had the background to understand what I was hearing. Mad love and respect to Rob and Austin for doing this.
Not upset with your analysis. To our untrained ears, it sounded beautiful. It had a relatable sound, if that makes sense. "Opera for the common man," if you will. It was fascinating to hear what they did well, and where they lacked. I just admire their fearlessness in attempting an intimidating genre. Great reaction and analysis.
Thank you for this. I accidently stumbled on their version and couldn't believe how many people were saying how "perfect" it was. When you have heard it sung by opera singers (Turandot is one of my favs - I cried my face off!) you can absolutely tell the difference between people "singing" opera and opera singers.
Abbbbbbsolutely! Both these gents did a great job (especially Rob), but there are significant differences compared to people who pursue opera as a career
For us who doesn't listen to opera regularly or have a trained ear it does sound perfect, but I think most people understand it is not as good as if a proffessional operasinger perform this piece, and few people excpect it to be....
As a music educator who works with kids primarily between the ages of 0 - 5, I really appreciated hearing this. I'm an instrumentalist who's had to train her voice a little more as is the nature of working with early childhood music, but most of my work is very basic music theory along with child development and neuroscience. Fascinating stuff, and I really love learning about it, but I miss the deep dives into the more advanced music techniques. I really enjoy your videos and always learn a ton.
I was so excited when I saw you had reacted to this (in fact, I started anticipating your reaction the moment I heard the song). My only sadness came from the fact that I had to wait until I had time to listen to it in one go. I hope no one is offended. I think you did a really great job of pointing out differences without sounding disparaging. I really enjoyed your reaction. Thank you.
Yes, I enjoyed it very much. And textbook evaluation technique - according to management theory - lead with praise, bring in critique, and suggestions for improvement along with positives, as deserved, and end with praise. Thanks.
I must admit that I was both looking forward to and dreading your reaction. As a Home Free super fan I was worried that you were just going to trash them given your background as a professional opera singer. But I was delighted to hear a balanced analysis on both the good aspects and where a professional opera singer would do it better. I learned a lot as with most of your reactions so thank you!
Thanks for the depth and balance in the analysis. Really validated and provided explanation for some of what I heard, but couldn’t articulate. Love you took the time and effort to do it properly and critique from your expertise.
Absolutely loved the intro where you absolute just pulled all that background history and it was clearly off the top of your head. Also, I came here for the constructive criticism. Every other reactor could do the praise, you're the one who could actually do this analysis. I've been looking forward to this analysis since they came out with it.
This is literally the first time my mind has been opened to what opera really is, why its so amazing and so freakin' difficult! Mad props to this video, I could easily listen to you talk about this stuff, your craft, for hours! Days even! Having non-operatic singers try to sing opera did make it more approachable though, so maybe have those as examples every now and then? Awesome video dude! Thanks from Norway! I will now go google if we have any good opera singers in Norway :D
I love that people with an operatic background are no longer as dismissive of other styles of singing as they were when I was younger. Of course there were shortcomings. The Three Tenors struggled with uneven eighths. Let's simply enjoy sharing the talents of those more skilled than ourselves and allow joy to flow from good singing.
I appreciated your analysis. I know Rob was nervous to do this as he had not sung opera for over 15 years. I think they both will appreciate your critique as you were complimentary to both of them and that is a big deal coming from an opera singer. I loved their performance and even though not perfect they have now introduced opera to a whole group of people who would never have listened to it. Bravo to all of you. I personally have never cared much for opera it actually makes me feel jittery. I get so uptight I have to turn it off. Rob an Austin brought me to tears and has given me the idea to try more of it again. I enjoy your voice as well. Just love Tim more :)
I love it when a reactor educates me. I know very little opera but could also hear the difference in so many ways between these wonderful singers. I’m so glad that Austin talked Rob into doing this! They’ve taken a huge chance and have succeeded. I agree with your analysis of both men. Even I can tell the differences in their singing what? singing styles? These were brilliant analysis and examples of what you mean with your commentary. Thank you.
I absolutely loved watching you analyze this song - much more than I originally thought I would. Explaining so many different aspects of the song that those of us that don’t listen to opera very often even noticed. For those that say they don’t “like” opera should still appreciate the amount of time, energy, and effort that goes into perfecting that type of vocal. You were respectful while still being able to critique the song. ❤
I've been waiting for your reaction to this! I knew you would be honest while appreciating their effort. And you confirmed some of the things I was thinking but didn't have the words to express. Thanks!
Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and insights with us. I was looking forward to your reaction to this video since it came out (just as I was waiting for Maggie's reaction).
I was that odd kid in the Southeast who adored opera as a small child. I have heard a ton of different tenors do this aria, but I love the difference this one brings with the twang from Austin while Rob pulls it back to the traditional sound.
I learned a lot and thoroughly enjoyed your taking us through an analysis of this piece. It makes me appreicate what they did and opera itself more generally. Thank you very much.
They did excellent in my opinion knowing that they do not sing opera as a profession and do not have that level of training either. I was thoroughly impressed.
OMG Peter! I become addicted to your analysis, that is whole new world opened to me. After each I listen those pieces again and wow .... I just loove to listen music but no musical education at all. Avi, Tim (just love bass singers) Austin are on my every play list as well as Groban, Buble, Lambert, Phelps, Jonathan Antoine, Bocelli and so many more. Thank you!
O.....m.....g! This is completely fantastic. A lot of operatic talent I never knew they had. Take me to opera church! I love that one of the first full operatic songs that you've did an analysis on is this, it's awesome to hear you critique something that you're so passionate about, I know that you're passionate about all music but in this particular one you're just so comfortable discussing all of the techniques and your face kind of lights up when you talk about it. I appreciate the in-depth critique on this even if it goes over 30 minutes LOL it's awesome to learn so much about it. I will say that I know that some people will think that it sounds like you're bashing their singing because it's not professional but to me I think it's nice to hear how well they're doing and you pointing out their awesome points yet explaining how it would be done in a professional setting so I truly appreciate that part as well. I mean when you're critiquing a video you can't just be all like oh this is totally awesome they've done everything right you have to be able to explain the flip side of that as well especially in a setting that you're a professional in. Amazing analysis as always
When I first listened to this, even with my very limited opera knowledge, I thought the same thing, that while they are both excellent singers and did a great job, Rob was much more operatic. I was very impressed with both, but especially Rob in this case.
Like many others, I've been waiting for you to critique this, and a bit nervous, because of your thorough knowledge and passion about opera. You did a great analysis and reaction. In a way, this was a difficult reaction to do because both Rob & Austin are excellent non-opera singers (with a rabid fan base) singing a completely different, difficult genre. Thanks much.
Thanks for the opera singing clarifications. From my viewpoint, they sounded like a royal treat. Rob was my favorite of the two, Austin's voice had a more nasal quality. My first opera and I was 16 visiting my older sister living in Germany. She sent me on a bus trip of Austria, Switzerland and Italy. In Rome, we went to the ruins of the Roman Baths where they performed Aida. The stage was huge, big enough for 2 horse-drawn chariots. I was mesmerized even without the English translation. I was fluent in Spanish so it wasn't a total loss but still. Flying back to the states, I had a layover in NY so I rented a car and drove up to Connecticut and spent a couple of days with him and his wife. They took me to see Carlos Montoya, the great Flamenco guitarist. It was a great summer. My mother was funny. "Go, do everything that I would have done if I had gone at your age - and you know what I wouldn't have done." It was the trip of a lifetime and history that I learned from books, suddenly became real. I stood on the site where Brutus killed Caesar, and walked through the catacombs where the Christians hid, I walked through the Coliseum. In Florence, the river Arno had flooded and swept away the golden panels by Cellini on the doors to the Basilica, I saw Rodin's The Kiss, the statue of David. Venice with the glass blowers and gondolas. The people of Pompeii preserved in the ashes of the volcano were so small. The world and time became alive in a way that I had never suspected. I had planned to see Aida this winter but I got covid and didn't dare venture out so that and Wicked are still on my list. I did get to see Voctave at Florida State University for their one-night show. I've been blessed.
This was a great analysis video. Like many Home Fries, I was both nervous and excited to hear your opinion. I know many people will have a fit that you didn't see them as doing a perfect rendition. But most of us realize that it's not a realistic idea considering the very specific training it takes to sing opera. And even if you do have the training, just like many things in life, if you don't use it, you lose it. Something that you brought up about mouth positioning with Rob was really interesting. I've often noticed how his mouth is more vertical than spread wide. I thought it was just my imagination. Thank you for taking the time to do a breakdown that those of us who are not opera aficionados could understand.
Have avoided the 45 minute reaction but so glad I finally listened! Not an opera guy but truly enjoyed your analysis and did learn a lot. So after avoiding, thanks for putting the time in.
Excellent breakdown. I enjoyed learning about the different techniques used for the different styles of singing. It's something I have heard in listening to the different genres but never understood why it sounds the way it does. Thank you for a wonderful video and I look forward to seeing more!
As soon as I saw this, my first thought was, oh man, I can't wait to watch Peter's video on this. You were very informative, and I enjoyed this entire analysis.
Ty for doing this, I've been waiting to see how a opera performer would break this down. I have definitely learned a lot from this as this introduced me to hearing opera for the first time tbh. Now I want to hear more.
A video that Introduces a listener to opera and results in that listener wanting to hear more…that is a huge compliment. I think Rob and Austin would be pleased. 😊
I was absolutely amazed at how well they did. I heard Rob was nervous about singing this since it had been 15 years from the last time he sang opera. Austin had to really do some talking and then when he heard how good Rob sounded, he went back and re-recorded his own soundtrack. To me that is high praise from Austin to Rob. I agree neither of them sound like they were doing this full time, but they did themselves and Home Free proud. Way to go guys and I'm glad you agree they did well for non-professionals. Thank you for your analysis.
Now THAT is a great idea!! You should contact Rob about a collaboration!! I'd LOVE to see that! If I were to compare Rob's performance on this aria with the great tenors around me as a voice major, Rob would shine. The open vowels and warmth of tone were gorgeous.
You my Patreon friend blow my musical brain with your vocal analysis. I completely agree when you explain it regarding their sounds for operatic vs musical theatre singing. You open my eyes to the language, the vowel shapes, drop jaw, brighter sounds, and I could go on and on. I would like to see you review David Phelps when he does the same aria. Again, he is not an opera singer, but a country gospel singer who is incredible in his own right as a tenor, again with quite the low range as well. I have always thought it was a great version. Having YOU an opera singer evaluate it would mean so much to this vocalist. Brava!! AND David does his live. Typos? Sorry it’s late and I’ve been reading scores for hours.
@@PeterBarber If you have never heard him before, check out non operatic pieces as well. This doesn’t give him the full justice he deserves. I’d probably go for O Holy Night since it’s well known and he knocks it out of the park.
Peter. Just stumbled across your channel. I like the way you were able to point out the differences without being condescending to the singers. As someone who can’t carry a tune in a bucket, I can hear the differences. Genre training is a huge difference. You took that into account. I have personally heard opera singers try to sing country or classical songs. It’s good, but not spot on. But, still enjoyable. Terrific video.
Your analysis is what I’ve been looking forward to listening to. Thank you for the education. I enjoyed Rob and Austin’s singing without the analysis but, your thoughts taught me more.
Really enjoyed your analysis and approach. I've seen in other contexts, musical experts tear apart performances of other performers and it amounts to "hey! look at me! I know a lot!" You really showed that when you clarify what you're doing and why, so that people can learn about the singing techniques used, that you can do that while still giving the performers the respect that they deserve for making the effort. I'm a chamber singer. I don't have the benefit of the type of experience and training that you have. You taught me some things here that I appreciate. Further, you were kind to both Rob and Austin who are crazy-talented people stretching themselves here. Appreciate your humble, but still straight forward approach. You hit just the right balance and I know now why some other efforts by others at times have hit me wrong when that balance is not there. Keep up the good work. You're one of the best reactors and analysts on UA-cam.
Appreciate the fact that you reacted to this objectively. Unlike a certain so called expert who said that he saw Pavarotti in person singing this and these two were nothing like him. Who is ? The title says " Two COUNTRY SINGERS trying to sing opera.
This is the best, most informative "analysis" pieces I have seen by anyone! I think a person HAS to be very interested in the science and mechanics of vocal performance to "like" this level of detail. Outstanding Review! Thank you! (edited to remove 'one of' and shorten to 'the best')
I am a giant Home Free fan and I was a little scared to hear what you had to say. But this all made perfect sense to me. I found it very interesting. I was not surprised to hear that this type of music is more suited to Rob than Austin given their training. That seemed sort of obvious to me, but now I have some idea why. I thought your criticisms were still polite and not meant to be mean or "I could do this so much better than you". More like a teacher might tell you in a lesson. Been on the receiving end and you feel better about criticism if it's constructive. Thanks for the education!
Austin spent his years in college (on a music scholarship) trying to nullify his Georgia accent - when he joined Home Free they told him to stop trying. Rob is from Minnesota.
Great analysis. Austin's clarity always sounds brilliant and Rob's voice gives me chills. It was wonderful hearing your technical review. Kind, respectful, and informative!
I really loved your response to this. I just discovered their performance and Rob utterly blew me away, especially considering how different he sounds here than in his “normal” voice. But I really wanted some analysis from someone who really understands opera, and you nailed it. I personally would love to see more videos like this where you explain a bit about the different techniques in a classical piece. I’d love to see reactions to Andrea Bocelli, Pavarotti, Jonathan Antoine, Josh Groban, etc. I’d love to get your take on how these individual styles vary, some are obviously more classical than others. This is coming from someone who knows very little about opera. I think it’s so technical and different from what most people listen to, it can be very difficult to listen to and appreciate what you’re hearing without some guidance.
first time watching your analysis. I know exactly zero about vocal technique, but I am super impressed with your knowledge and the way you presented your analysis made it easy to understand what was happening. Thank you! Subscribed.
Thank you, I learned a lot. Some of your observations were in the back of my mind even though I've never had any operatic training. They must have had big nerves to attempt and do as well as they did. Makes me appreciate them more.
I found your in-depth analysis fascinating, and the best of all reactions (even if almost 45 minutes in length - lol.) Thank you for your due diligence.
If you watch the whole video with an open mind, I can guarantee a few things: 1) You will learn a ton about the differences between operatic singing and other kinds of singing. 2) You will learn a ton about what Rob and Austin's strengths and weaknesses are in their approaches to singing this operatic piece. 3) You will hear an honest analysis from someone that sings opera professionally and is a huge fan of Home Free and both these singers. Keep in mind that in this video, I provide praise for their success with this piece, along with critiques and comparisons, all of which is intended to be both constructive and educational. Much love to these two for taking on a challenging operatic aria, and thanks to all of you for watching.
Plz react on Dimash new song.....The story of one sky.... that video should get an Oscar.... 🥲you would cry after watching... what a powerful message
I'm sad the intellectually honest feel it necessary to provide a disclaimer. Especially when they are in their wheelhouse 😀. I respect your "professional" breakdowns.
@@ericreed4535 i say something wrong🥺.. I'm a little boy....i dont understand what are you saying 😅
@@Dinofelis999 I replied to Peter, not you little guy 😀. Have a wonderful life and love yourself 👍. Eat your veggies 😉.
I appreciate your unbiased observations…for the untrained ear..it’s mind boggling..especially Rob. When I first heard this..my comment was you can still hear Austin’s souther twang ..subtle…but it’s there….
Rob had two comments about this recording during the premiere. First, do not ever expect them to do at a live show, because it takes a different kind of preparation to sing than the rest of the show. Second, he played the recording for his father at Father's Day, since opera is what his father most enjoys. His father cried to hear his son once again sing what he originally trained for.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
Thank you, Peter. As much as I like these two, I fully understand that we should respect those professional opera singers who have honed their crafts for years. While to ordinary people's ears Rob and Austin sound 'perfect', that's not the case to those in the genre.
Still, we, as homefries, should be very proud of Rob and Austin. As non-opera singers, based on Peter's (and Maggie's) comments, they seem to do a superb job...
Another thing that we should really appreciate them singing Nessun Dorma is that they bring Opera to those who normally do not listen to the genre.
Agreed! I'm a Home Fry, & I absolutely adore both Rob & Austin. I've met both of them in person several times, & they're truly lovely people as well as extremely talented singers. BUT that doesn't mean I automatically think they're perfect at everything they do (nor do they think that). I know nothing about opera, so to my untrained ears it sounds fantastic. But I absolutely understand that to professional opera singers there's probably a lot of small things to improve upon. Opera is a very unique style of singing that requires years of training to perfect. That said, I do think Austin & Rob did a great job considering that they haven't spent years training in that style..
They really did an amazing job! Mad respect to both of them
Glad I looked at your extended remarks as the first paragraph seemed rather harsh. Glad I peeked under the dots. I thought you were done. Glad you weren't. Hitting your thumbs up.
I’m a home fry and I love these guys and they are both extremely talented. And I understand that there’s a huge difference between opera and country but not being trained opera singers they did wonderful, absolutely wonderful. Just wondering if you’ve ever tried singing country?
@@carolynyerby361 Yes I actually lived in Nashville for summer and sang country music, and I grew up in the mountains of Virginia so country music has been a big part of my life
Props to them for introducing their audience to opera. Austin was 100% expected but Rob was 200% amazing.
Both Austin and Rob studied vocal performance in college. Rob has more training in opera than Austin has, but Rob hasn’t sung opera In 15 years. Austin majored in musical theater, but did some opera in college.
I'm assuming they hired opera coaches in the making of this video. So they did what they could with what they had.
I really appreciate the way you approach this-giving these guys all the credit they deserve for even trying this, and for everything they’re doing well, and showing the respect you have for them as singers, then pointing out where a professional opera singer would handle things differently. Very fair, very constructive and balanced. I also love the way you pick out details to talk about, then go back and let us hear it again (some of us really need the demonstration). You do a great job of making some very abstract thoughts make sense. I’ve said this before-I really wish I’d had a teacher like you when I studied vocal music in college. I might have stuck to it instead of getting discouraged.
Even if it isn’t perfect operatic technique, I do love this piece. Austin’s obvious joy and bright tone are really pleasing, and I could listen to Rob sing like this all day. Hope they veer out of their lane more often!
Well done, Peter. 👏🏼
Peter, thanks to you, and also to Austin and Rob (and Home Free). One thing you are all doing is increasing our appreciation for music and getting us to try flavors of music we might now try left to our own devices. Kudos to all of you, and thanks for sharing your talents with the rest of us!
It would be interesting to hear your reaction about Dan Vasc's cover of Nessum Dorma.
Dan's dad was Italian (Dan speaks italian) and they used to listen to opera together and Dan's mother was an opera singer and Dan has 10+ years of classical training. Dan did this song as a tribute to his dad when he passed away so his version is very emotional. 💖
I don't think there's a reactor more qualified to react and analyze this than you.
Peter, we got what we expect from you, a true defining of what we heard, yet affirmation that they have really great voices. You are one that I truly appreciate as you tell it like it is but always so encouraging. You did not come across as negative, but educationally balanced and fair. Quite frankly Rob and Austin brought a large audience to opera experience that hopefully in the long run helped both interest to the opera world and attention to Home Free. Thank you Peter.
They said that they recorded this separately, and when Austin heard Rob he wanted to redo it after they got off tour. Austin wanted to give it everything he had to make sure it was given the respect it deserves.
When Rob and Austin take off their hat and look at each other, reminds me of the glance in the Ring of Fire on the Sing-Off before Tim hits that massive LOW note. Like they are saying, "They have no idea what is coming."
The point of dropping the hats (and the change of clothing) is a very clear signal that this will NOT be country.
I have been excited and nervous for you to do this. Excited for your analysis, and nervous for my boys…. So thanks for your introduction about your balanced approach.
The versatility of the guys always fascinates me. They are perfect in everything they touch. I don't know how many times I've listened to it - I'm still speechless! Great reaction!
I love Peter's kind, honest, and fair analysis of these two singers. He is critical without being critical. I'm going to find some songs done by Peter Barber.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
I took one class on singing, am not a Home Fry, and do not like opera. I am trying to wrap my head around how it is I just spent 45 minutes raptly listening to your commentary and loved it. Damn, you're good.
LOL Dare I say welcome to the Home Free rabbit hole? These guys are an amazing vocal band (there's five of them) and I think you would really enjoy their music.
I think if you don't love opera but enjoyed this you would also love Olimpico by Dimash Kudaibergen. A nice rock approach but operatic approach. Dimash does have a solid bel canto training background though. You can search Dimash Olimpico Arnau. Enjoy.
Ahahaha--you sound a bit like me when I found Peter's channel: a combination of "*What* is this I'm listening to?!?" &, after I finished watching, "Why was that so interesting? I never even knew that ____ existed before, let alone learned about it...." Peter's a great engrossing teacher regardless of what genre of music he's talking about, & I enjoy all sorts of music more because of him. Plus I shocked a music geek friend recently by knowing something, which was all kinds of fun! >;-)
The key is getting us home fries to hear something many never would consider and then possibly get curious...plus it made Robs dad cry in happiness so I'm happy twice
Good job. It's been over 35 years since I was a voice student learning to sing opera. My professor at that time used very subjective terms to try to teach me how to sing and I just didn't get it. I've always needed objective explanations. So I appreciate you going at least a little bit into the physics of singing. I ended up taking a different path and switched to physics. Now I combine the two as a audio engineer. Even in the world of sound reinforcement, I encounter some vocalists who naturally have that "cut" (an emphasis on particular harmonics generated by vocal folds and shapes of resonance cavities) and others I need to use EQ and compression techniques to draw out those harmonics. In opera where you aren't going to have sound reinforcement, the vocalist needs to work to develop those harmonic patterns they don't naturally have. So you are right in saying that there is much about singing opera that isn't natural. There's a very good reason for that.
There are three meanings to the word "critic." You hit definitions 1 and 2, but didn't even come close to definition 3. Nice work. Thanks for the elucidation. I had not realized there was such a difference between opera and other forms of singing.
critic
krĭt′ĭk
noun
1. One who forms and expresses judgments of the merits, faults, value, or truth of a matter.
2. One who specializes especially professionally in the evaluation and appreciation of literary or artistic works.
3.One who tends to make harsh or carping judgments; a faultfinder.
I was hoping that you would react to this. It's nice to hear the explanations about the differences in styles and seeing how close they got. Both are really talented and I'm excited that they went out of their wheelhouse to attempt something new. And that they did it well. I do have to say that your "that's a choice" comment cracked me up.
Thank you for this reaction. I found it honest and of a complimentary nature. It's not always understood how very complex singing is. These two guys are amazingly accomplished.
I loved Rob and Austin's performance of this piece. Your explanations of exactly what's going on really help me to appreciate them more. You had me listening to your whole breakdown on regular speed which is truly an accomplishment. It felt like you really enjoyed getting to drill down on their "operatic" performance instead of their usual music. I was actually laughing at a few of your comments and facial expressions - you're very charismatic and entertaining. Loved this one. Peace.
Rob is my favorite in the group because he is a very good whistler...another talent he hasn't used a lot in Home Free. But to hear his operatic chops stand up to professional critique also? That makes me respect him on a whole other level. Thank you for the honest deep dive into this aria. I clung to every word.
Been waiting for your assessment. Glad you shared this with us.
Great analysis, thanks. I appreciate your honesty since this is your lane. I've heard Rob did some opera early in his career, so he has a jump on Austin. Both are to be admired for putting their necks out there on the chopping block. We know how the internet can be. Thanks again.
Dear Peter: I have no music formation whatsoever, just a normal guy who loves to hear beauty in songs and I usually react to what moves my heart. What I enjoyed most in the singing of Austin and Rob (of whom I know very little actually) is the sheer joy that came across. I had no idea what they were singing about but it seemed to me that they were singing about a great and abiding love.
Then I listened to your analysis and was literally floored. You opened a door to musical analysis I was not aware of and showed me another side of beauty about singing I did not know existed. The precision in your language and your attention to details are wonderful! I could pick out those details in their singing after you would point them out and that led me to go and listen to the same piece by pavaroti and I could immediately tell the difference in the power of his voice. No question about it: he can sing in ways that Rob and Austin couldn't but ... their singing touched my heart, his didn't. It came across as mechanically sound but lacking soul... not something I could clearly explain. You could blame my ignorance in music. In any case, thank you so much for your intelligent comment. I know now a little bit more about singing and opera than I did before watching you.
There are a few recent videos that I was hoping you'd cover, but this was definitely at the top because I knew you would have a ton of insight. If there was ever a video that I'd want you to spend more time with, this was it so I was really glad that you didn't stick to the 30-minute mark. Thanks so much for this!
This was the one aria that would always bring tears to my eyes when Luciano Pavarotti sang it. I got to see Turandot in Florence with Zubin Mehta conducting, so it also brought back fond memories , (I still have the Italian libretto). Your analysis was interesting and spot on Peter. While you'd never expect this good a performance from two country music singers, I agree that Rob's voice was remarkable!
Rob's voice almost brought me to tears on this one - I definitely had the sting in my eyes! As much as I love this aria, up until this was released, no other singer after Pavarotti has pulled that reaction out of me again. Rob did it! (I mean no offense to any other vocalist with this; it's just my own personal emotional reaction to hearing it.)
Rob must sing more opera! He’s amazing.
I respect the honesty and educational information in your analysis. I also appreciate that you give these fellas the props they're due for being brave enough to take this on. There are a handful of you professional singer reactors which likely read to the apprehension these two experienced prior to this debut. But, I feel the constructive criticism couched in mad respect comes through. Looking forward to the next video from them and the next reaction from you. 🙂
I'm a Home Free fan and know nothing about opera so I'm looking forward to your analysis. Thank you for sharing your professional expertise with me! I am thinking this piece is beginning to grow on me the more times I listen and perhaps I can develop an appreciation for opera that I may not have begun otherwise. Cheers to you!
Was waiting for your take. Despite your praise you will no doubt receive reactive comments from the Stans. Enjoyed the performance, enjoyed your analysis and learned a lot. Thanks for allowing us to train our ears with your guidance!
I really hope he doesn't get hate for simply providing an honest analysis as a professional! I adore Austin & Rob, & they did great considering their lack of operatic training. I can (& do) appreciate that they were willing to attempt something way outside their comfort zone & put themselves out there for all of us to hear. But I have no doubt that they're far from pro-level to people with trained ears. Hopefully my fellow Home Fries can also appreciate an honest & professional review. We're a fiercely loyal fan base & very protective of our guys, but we're also reasonable (mostly, LOL).
@@JustGettinBy1321 Well said!
What is a "Stans"? I've never heard that term and I've no idea what that means?
@@teresacartwright5406 Over-obsessed and fanatical fans... ;)
I learned more about vocal performances in this reaction than I have in the hundreds I've watched before. Thank you.
This was a commendable performance from two talented singers, and it brought emotional responses. I actually saw Pavarotti perform this in Modena when I was twelve. I had never seen so many people weeping in one place before that, and that experience resonated with me all over again during Rob's lead-off. Great review!
I have really enjoyed your commentary. I was waiting for a professional to go into depth explaining the differences in what Rob and Austin usually sing and opera. You were very fair in your assessments and very respectful of their innate talents. Thank you. I enjoyed watching this review very much.
I grew up listening to Jussi Bjoerling singing this (still the greatest tenor ever for me) and you can definitely hear the difference between a "trained" and "untrained " voice. Thanks so much for this in depth and really interesting deconstruction of what those differences are. I can hear it but I never had the background to understand what I was hearing. Mad love and respect to Rob and Austin for doing this.
Not upset with your analysis. To our untrained ears, it sounded beautiful. It had a relatable sound, if that makes sense. "Opera for the common man," if you will. It was fascinating to hear what they did well, and where they lacked. I just admire their fearlessness in attempting an intimidating genre. Great reaction and analysis.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
Thank you for this. I accidently stumbled on their version and couldn't believe how many people were saying how "perfect" it was. When you have heard it sung by opera singers (Turandot is one of my favs - I cried my face off!) you can absolutely tell the difference between people "singing" opera and opera singers.
Abbbbbbsolutely! Both these gents did a great job (especially Rob), but there are significant differences compared to people who pursue opera as a career
For us who doesn't listen to opera regularly or have a trained ear it does sound perfect, but I think most people understand it is not as good as if a proffessional operasinger perform this piece, and few people excpect it to be....
As a music educator who works with kids primarily between the ages of 0 - 5, I really appreciated hearing this. I'm an instrumentalist who's had to train her voice a little more as is the nature of working with early childhood music, but most of my work is very basic music theory along with child development and neuroscience. Fascinating stuff, and I really love learning about it, but I miss the deep dives into the more advanced music techniques. I really enjoy your videos and always learn a ton.
Thank you for your reaction and adding your beautiful voice when clarifying the
points you were making. Be well.
I was so excited when I saw you had reacted to this (in fact, I started anticipating your reaction the moment I heard the song). My only sadness came from the fact that I had to wait until I had time to listen to it in one go. I hope no one is offended. I think you did a really great job of pointing out differences without sounding disparaging. I really enjoyed your reaction. Thank you.
Like many others I was hoping you would review this recording/video. It's everything I hoped your analysis would be, Thank you!!!
Truly appreciate your detailed review of this performance. You sure helped me hear what I didn't know before.
Yes, I enjoyed it very much. And textbook evaluation technique - according to management theory - lead with praise, bring in critique, and suggestions for improvement along with positives, as deserved, and end with praise. Thanks.
I must admit that I was both looking forward to and dreading your reaction. As a Home Free super fan I was worried that you were just going to trash them given your background as a professional opera singer. But I was delighted to hear a balanced analysis on both the good aspects and where a professional opera singer would do it better. I learned a lot as with most of your reactions so thank you!
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
I can't believe how much i learn when i watch your reaction videos. Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
Thanks for the depth and balance in the analysis. Really validated and provided explanation for some of what I heard, but couldn’t articulate. Love you took the time and effort to do it properly and critique from your expertise.
Absolutely loved the intro where you absolute just pulled all that background history and it was clearly off the top of your head. Also, I came here for the constructive criticism. Every other reactor could do the praise, you're the one who could actually do this analysis. I've been looking forward to this analysis since they came out with it.
This is literally the first time my mind has been opened to what opera really is, why its so amazing and so freakin' difficult! Mad props to this video, I could easily listen to you talk about this stuff, your craft, for hours! Days even! Having non-operatic singers try to sing opera did make it more approachable though, so maybe have those as examples every now and then?
Awesome video dude! Thanks from Norway! I will now go google if we have any good opera singers in Norway :D
I love that people with an operatic background are no longer as dismissive of other styles of singing as they were when I was younger. Of course there were shortcomings. The Three Tenors struggled with uneven eighths. Let's simply enjoy sharing the talents of those more skilled than ourselves and allow joy to flow from good singing.
Wow, as an Italian, I’m well impressed by your Italian, you’re really good! And thank you for explaining things so clearly as always 😊
I appreciated your analysis. I know Rob was nervous to do this as he had not sung opera for over 15 years. I think they both will appreciate your critique as you were complimentary to both of them and that is a big deal coming from an opera singer. I loved their performance and even though not perfect they have now introduced opera to a whole group of people who would never have listened to it. Bravo to all of you. I personally have never cared much for opera it actually makes me feel jittery. I get so uptight I have to turn it off. Rob an Austin brought me to tears and has given me the idea to try more of it again. I enjoy your voice as well. Just love Tim more :)
I love it when a reactor educates me. I know very little opera but could also hear the difference in so many ways between these wonderful singers. I’m so glad that Austin talked Rob into doing this! They’ve taken a huge chance and have succeeded. I agree with your analysis of both men. Even I can tell the differences in their singing what? singing styles? These were brilliant analysis and examples of what you mean with your commentary. Thank you.
I absolutely loved watching you analyze this song - much more than I originally thought I would. Explaining so many different aspects of the song that those of us that don’t listen to opera very often even noticed. For those that say they don’t “like” opera should still appreciate the amount of time, energy, and effort that goes into perfecting that type of vocal. You were respectful while still being able to critique the song. ❤
I don’t know all the technical ins and outs of this performance, but it brought tears to my eyes. They did their job. ❤️
Thanks!
I've been waiting for your reaction to this! I knew you would be honest while appreciating their effort. And you confirmed some of the things I was thinking but didn't have the words to express. Thanks!
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and insights with us. I was looking forward to your reaction to this video since it came out (just as I was waiting for Maggie's reaction).
I was that odd kid in the Southeast who adored opera as a small child. I have heard a ton of different tenors do this aria, but I love the difference this one brings with the twang from Austin while Rob pulls it back to the traditional sound.
I learned a lot and thoroughly enjoyed your taking us through an analysis of this piece. It makes me appreicate what they did and opera itself more generally. Thank you very much.
They did excellent in my opinion knowing that they do not sing opera as a profession and do not have that level of training either. I was thoroughly impressed.
OMG Peter! I become addicted to your analysis, that is whole new world opened to me. After each I listen those pieces again and wow .... I just loove to listen music but no musical education at all. Avi, Tim (just love bass singers) Austin are on my every play list as well as Groban, Buble, Lambert, Phelps, Jonathan Antoine, Bocelli and so many more. Thank you!
I've been waiting for an opera expert to analyze this video. Thank you.
Very much appreciated this. I heard thoughtfully precise critical observations, not criticizing. And plenty of acknowledgement :~)
O.....m.....g!
This is completely fantastic.
A lot of operatic talent I never knew they had.
Take me to opera church! I love that one of the first full operatic songs that you've did an analysis on is this, it's awesome to hear you critique something that you're so passionate about, I know that you're passionate about all music but in this particular one you're just so comfortable discussing all of the techniques and your face kind of lights up when you talk about it. I appreciate the in-depth critique on this even if it goes over 30 minutes LOL it's awesome to learn so much about it.
I will say that I know that some people will think that it sounds like you're bashing their singing because it's not professional but to me I think it's nice to hear how well they're doing and you pointing out their awesome points yet explaining how it would be done in a professional setting so I truly appreciate that part as well. I mean when you're critiquing a video you can't just be all like oh this is totally awesome they've done everything right you have to be able to explain the flip side of that as well especially in a setting that you're a professional in. Amazing analysis as always
I’ve been looking forward to your reaction and analysis.
I was waiting for this exact video the moment their video dropped. I'm so glad that you broke it down the way that you did!
Thanks so much for reacting to this one Peter, I was looking forward to hearing what you thought about it as a professional opera singer!
When I first listened to this, even with my very limited opera knowledge, I thought the same thing, that while they are both excellent singers and did a great job, Rob was much more operatic. I was very impressed with both, but especially Rob in this case.
Like many others, I've been waiting for you to critique this, and a bit nervous, because of your thorough knowledge and passion about opera. You did a great analysis and reaction. In a way, this was a difficult reaction to do because both Rob & Austin are excellent non-opera singers (with a rabid fan base) singing a completely different, difficult genre. Thanks much.
I learned so much in this video about opera that I never knew. Thank you for your professional critique of two wonderful singers.
Thanks for the opera singing clarifications. From my viewpoint, they sounded like a royal treat. Rob was my favorite of the two, Austin's voice had a more nasal quality. My first opera and I was 16 visiting my older sister living in Germany. She sent me on a bus trip of Austria, Switzerland and Italy. In Rome, we went to the ruins of the Roman Baths where they performed Aida. The stage was huge, big enough for 2 horse-drawn chariots. I was mesmerized even without the English translation. I was fluent in Spanish so it wasn't a total loss but still. Flying back to the states, I had a layover in NY so I rented a car and drove up to Connecticut and spent a couple of days with him and his wife. They took me to see Carlos Montoya, the great Flamenco guitarist. It was a great summer. My mother was funny. "Go, do everything that I would have done if I had gone at your age - and you know what I wouldn't have done." It was the trip of a lifetime and history that I learned from books, suddenly became real. I stood on the site where Brutus killed Caesar, and walked through the catacombs where the Christians hid, I walked through the Coliseum. In Florence, the river Arno had flooded and swept away the golden panels by Cellini on the doors to the Basilica, I saw Rodin's The Kiss, the statue of David. Venice with the glass blowers and gondolas. The people of Pompeii preserved in the ashes of the volcano were so small. The world and time became alive in a way that I had never suspected. I had planned to see Aida this winter but I got covid and didn't dare venture out so that and Wicked are still on my list. I did get to see Voctave at Florida State University for their one-night show. I've been blessed.
This was a great analysis video. Like many Home Fries, I was both nervous and excited to hear your opinion. I know many people will have a fit that you didn't see them as doing a perfect rendition. But most of us realize that it's not a realistic idea considering the very specific training it takes to sing opera. And even if you do have the training, just like many things in life, if you don't use it, you lose it. Something that you brought up about mouth positioning with Rob was really interesting. I've often noticed how his mouth is more vertical than spread wide. I thought it was just my imagination. Thank you for taking the time to do a breakdown that those of us who are not opera aficionados could understand.
Have avoided the 45 minute reaction but so glad I finally listened! Not an opera guy but truly enjoyed your analysis and did learn a lot. So after avoiding, thanks for putting the time in.
Excellent breakdown. I enjoyed learning about the different techniques used for the different styles of singing. It's something I have heard in listening to the different genres but never understood why it sounds the way it does. Thank you for a wonderful video and I look forward to seeing more!
As soon as I saw this, my first thought was, oh man, I can't wait to watch Peter's video on this. You were very informative, and I enjoyed this entire analysis.
Ty for doing this, I've been waiting to see how a opera performer would break this down. I have definitely learned a lot from this as this introduced me to hearing opera for the first time tbh. Now I want to hear more.
A video that Introduces a listener to opera and results in that listener wanting to hear more…that is a huge compliment. I think Rob and Austin would be pleased. 😊
I was absolutely amazed at how well they did. I heard Rob was nervous about singing this since it had been 15 years from the last time he sang opera. Austin had to really do some talking and then when he heard how good Rob sounded, he went back and re-recorded his own soundtrack. To me that is high praise from Austin to Rob. I agree neither of them sound like they were doing this full time, but they did themselves and Home Free proud. Way to go guys and I'm glad you agree they did well for non-professionals. Thank you for your analysis.
Thanks so much for the education. :-) I enjoyed the whole 45 minutes.
Now THAT is a great idea!! You should contact Rob about a collaboration!! I'd LOVE to see that! If I were to compare Rob's performance on this aria with the great tenors around me as a voice major, Rob would shine. The open vowels and warmth of tone were gorgeous.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
I was waiting for an actual Opera singer to review this!!
You my Patreon friend blow my musical brain with your vocal analysis. I completely agree when you explain it regarding their sounds for operatic vs musical theatre singing. You open my eyes to the language, the vowel shapes, drop jaw, brighter sounds, and I could go on and on. I would like to see you review David Phelps when he does the same aria. Again, he is not an opera singer, but a country gospel singer who is incredible in his own right as a tenor, again with quite the low range as well. I have always thought it was a great version. Having YOU an opera singer evaluate it would mean so much to this vocalist. Brava!! AND David does his live. Typos? Sorry it’s late and I’ve been reading scores for hours.
I'm so glad you're both enjoying my analysis and learning a lot -- that is my entire goal with these videos. I'll check out David Phelps!
@@PeterBarber If you have never heard him before, check out non operatic pieces as well. This doesn’t give him the full justice he deserves. I’d probably go for O Holy Night since it’s well known and he knocks it out of the park.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
This was a great analysis!
Thank you so much Peter! That was exactly the analysis I've been looking for on this video!
Peter. Just stumbled across your channel. I like the way you were able to point out the differences without being condescending to the singers. As someone who can’t carry a tune in a bucket, I can hear the differences. Genre training is a huge difference. You took that into account. I have personally heard opera singers try to sing country or classical songs. It’s good, but not spot on. But, still enjoyable. Terrific video.
Your analysis is what I’ve been looking forward to listening to. Thank you for the education. I enjoyed Rob and Austin’s singing without the analysis but, your thoughts taught me more.
This is the exact kind of analysis I was hoping for. You never disappoint!
Really enjoyed your analysis and approach. I've seen in other contexts, musical experts tear apart performances of other performers and it amounts to "hey! look at me! I know a lot!"
You really showed that when you clarify what you're doing and why, so that people can learn about the singing techniques used, that you can do that while still giving the performers the respect that they deserve for making the effort.
I'm a chamber singer. I don't have the benefit of the type of experience and training that you have. You taught me some things here that I appreciate. Further, you were kind to both Rob and Austin who are crazy-talented people stretching themselves here.
Appreciate your humble, but still straight forward approach. You hit just the right balance and I know now why some other efforts by others at times have hit me wrong when that balance is not there.
Keep up the good work. You're one of the best reactors and analysts on UA-cam.
I really appreciate this comment! Glad you enjoyed my analysis
Appreciate the fact that you reacted to this objectively. Unlike a certain so called expert who said that he saw Pavarotti in person singing this and these two were nothing like him. Who is ? The title says " Two COUNTRY SINGERS trying to sing opera.
Hello beautiful, how're you doing today.?
You clearly were really enjoying yourself and it's infectious. A far better type of infection than many going around recently. :P
This is the best, most informative "analysis" pieces I have seen by anyone! I think a person HAS to be very interested in the science and mechanics of vocal performance to "like" this level of detail. Outstanding Review! Thank you! (edited to remove 'one of' and shorten to 'the best')
I am a giant Home Free fan and I was a little scared to hear what you had to say. But this all made perfect sense to me. I found it very interesting. I was not surprised to hear that this type of music is more suited to Rob than Austin given their training. That seemed sort of obvious to me, but now I have some idea why. I thought your criticisms were still polite and not meant to be mean or "I could do this so much better than you". More like a teacher might tell you in a lesson. Been on the receiving end and you feel better about criticism if it's constructive. Thanks for the education!
Man, I learned so much about opera from this video. Will I ever be able to sing opera? Of course not, but it's always good to know stuff.
Austin spent his years in college (on a music scholarship) trying to nullify his Georgia accent - when he joined Home Free they told him to stop trying. Rob is from Minnesota.
Great analysis. Austin's clarity always sounds brilliant and Rob's voice gives me chills. It was wonderful hearing your technical review. Kind, respectful, and informative!
Peter always teaches more about Opera than I thought I wanted to know ☺
I really loved your response to this. I just discovered their performance and Rob utterly blew me away, especially considering how different he sounds here than in his “normal” voice.
But I really wanted some analysis from someone who really understands opera, and you nailed it. I personally would love to see more videos like this where you explain a bit about the different techniques in a classical piece. I’d love to see reactions to Andrea Bocelli, Pavarotti, Jonathan Antoine, Josh Groban, etc. I’d love to get your take on how these individual styles vary, some are obviously more classical than others.
This is coming from someone who knows very little about opera. I think it’s so technical and different from what most people listen to, it can be very difficult to listen to and appreciate what you’re hearing without some guidance.
And Rob has a chameleon-like voice. He can change the sound/timbre of his voice depending on the genre he sings--extremely versatile, he is.
Awesome analysis, different than other videos since you are also a producer....bravissimo! we will definitely play this at our Club.
first time watching your analysis. I know exactly zero about vocal technique, but I am super impressed with your knowledge and the way you presented your analysis made it easy to understand what was happening. Thank you! Subscribed.
Thank you, I learned a lot. Some of your observations were in the back of my mind even though I've never had any operatic training. They must have had big nerves to attempt and do as well as they did. Makes me appreciate them more.
I found your in-depth analysis fascinating, and the best of all reactions (even if almost 45 minutes in length - lol.) Thank you for your due diligence.