Cliff's klein bottles are absolutely worth a buy not merely for their own sake, but for the wonderful included materials and fun things he does with the packaging. The box mine came in is every bit as fun and displayable as the bottles are.
My bottle is on my bookcase and the packaging it came in is on top of the bookcase. I told him that there are 26 dimensions in my reality, but he didn't take the string theory bait. But he did sign the bottle, so I'm still happy, and our email exchanges were fun, too.
When I’m feeling a bit low, which is often these days, I just put on the Cliff Stoll playlist. His energy, excitement, charm, and intellect always puts a smile on my face. Thank you for adding another video.❤️
Oh I love seeing new and exciting cliff stoll klein bottle content. I crocheted a Klein bottle once and the easiest way I could think of doing it was with the window method (5:40) so I can crochet it in one piece. So cool to see the different immersions. Thanks cliff for another interesting video :)
I don't really know much about glass blowing so I can't picture or imagine how this Klein Bottles are made. I would love to see a video showing how they are produced (even if that is probably not going to ve a typical Numberphile video).
@Matthew Morycinski Cliff has shown Numberphile his warehouse in his basement, but in reality, it only appears to be a warehouse in 3-dimensional space.
Search the channel for the other videos with Cliff. There’s one where he shows off his home-made robots, which collect Klein bottles from storage beneath his house for delivery, and talks about the manufacturing process too. Such an amazing character!
Every day that I see a Cliff Stoll update is a truly happy day, just to know that this man is still doing well. Truly one of the greats along with Mr Rogers.
I really love how he excited and passionate he talks about his Klein bottles! I bought one a while back and still have to smile every time I look at it on my shelf. Thank you Brady and thank you Cliff!
Awesome to see another Cliff Stoll video, I really love his personality and passion. As usual I recommend everyone his book "The Cuckoo's Egg: Tracking a Spy Through the Maze of Computer Espionage". Definitely well worth the read Also get a Klein Bottle from him, he also sends a lovely message with them
Mr. Stoll is so passionate about this subject, and that passion permeates to other people, me included. And he makes a quite complex topic into such an interesting discussion. Brady, on his turn, makes the right comments at the exact moments. Such a delightful 10 minutes of life-gaining, well-spent time! Thank you both!
Just saw a collection of Cliff Stoll's Klein bottles in San Francisco airport, terminal D. Also on display are a bunch of historic calculators, including many of Cliff's. Other mathematical displays also. Very cool. I saw the Klein bottles from quite a distance and instantly recognized some of Cliff's unique ones that were previously shown on Numberphile.
Absolutely love Cliff. I bought a Klein Stein from him. The interaction and the additional information he included were brilliantly entertaining alone, not to mention how cool the Stein is!
In another comment, @Massimo pointed out this Cliff Stoll is the one that wrote the book _The Cuckoo's Egg_ . It describes events that happened while he was a Unix System Administrator at a national laboratory. He was a teacher. His first book has a recipe for cookies. So yup, that sounds like a very similar person.
I got one of his Klein bottles for Christmas a couple years ago and it's one of my most prized possessions. I keep it on my desk and it always puts a smile on my face
I really like the analogy that the Klein bottle is to 4 dimensions as the picture is to 3 dimensions... I think this is helping me understand Klein bottles and therefore 4th dimension a little better
The coke bottle approach does a great job of conceptualizing the “pathing” as one travels the manifold, I guess because it preserves the traditional orientation and direction of flow we instinctively think of a bottled drink as having.
I love the Klein bottle videos. That Coke bottle reminds me of the stretched Coke bottles they made down by the seashore when I was a kid and then filled them with layers of colored sand.
I was fortunate enough to see some of the Klein bottles previously featured here in person at the San Francisco International Airport last month. They're in Terminal 2. Neat stuff!
I love this guy! Also, I am not sure which is more "beyond my comprehension", the whole immersion from 4d down to 3d, or the god-tier skill of this Lucas Clarke guy!
I bought a Klein bottle from this guy a little over a decade ago and it has lived in my shelf since. In all those years only one person has known what it is. The moment he recognized it I was so excited.
I loved hearing that bit about the boro glass vs. the Coca-Cola glass - I have a lot of admiration for people who are true masters of their craft, especially when it involves working with their own hands on something like this. I can design digital logic circuits quite well, if I do say so myself, but to actually get one in my hands I send money to some company to actually make my circuit boards. So yeah - "hands on artisan-ship" really impresses me.
The best part of this video is that, because video is a 2D medium, we can't prove that Cliff hasn't had radical 3D surgery to make himself into a human Klein Bottle.
This talk about higher dimensions being projected on lower dimensions reminded me of how I wrapped my head around this whole concept. A two dimension plane being projected on a one dimension line will only show the "shadow of the plane, and if you rotate and translate the plane around, that shadow projected on the line changes, giving a better idea of the real shape of the two dimensional plane, on that one dimensional line, while, at the same time, one dimensional "beings" on that line can only "see" (assuming they "see" like we do) in one direction of that line at a time, their perception of their reality being reduced to a point at the same time that they can't "see" behind a point on that line, they need to "get behind" that point to be able to perceive the length of that object. On the same token, two dimensional beings can se the whole one dimensional line all at once, but they can't "see" behind other two dimensional objects, they need to either rotate that object or circle around it to get the whole picture. Then we get to the projection of three dimensional objects on a two dimensional plane, and the same thing happens, on 2D you can only perceive the shadow of the 3D object and need to rotate and translate it in order to perceive different perspectives of the object to be able to grasp it's true shape. And if we go the other way, bringing a 2D object to a 3D world, we can, again, perceive it's entirety all at once, because, like in the 2D world, we can step to a higher dimension and perceive all the lower dimensions at once. And I imagine it would be the same with a 4D object, a three dimension representation would be just a limited projection on our 3D reality, while in a higher dimension our 3D world could be perceived all at once, with nothing hidden behind anything. Rinse and repeat for higher dimensions.
Not gonna lie, if those three alternate versions of the Klein bottles end up being in the shop, I know I'll be buying. Having those babies sitting next to my main would be a sight to behold!
I'm always happy to see another Cliff out there, but I'm curious if it's short for Clifford, or in my opinion, the better option of Clifton? I may be biased.
Coke Bottle is unveiled about 6:44
THANK FOR SAVING MY TIME
Thanks for the note, but I think I speak for a great many of us in saying "we're watching the whole thing anyways."
@@HM-pb9kd you actually lost 6 fabulous Cliff Stoll minutes
@@JaxMerrick absolutely
I clicked because of Cliff Stoll, everything else is irrelevant!
So glad to see this awesome and passionate man again!
His TED talk is awesome.
I thought people like them were crazy, lol!
Me too!
@@x_gosie 'cause they are - and that's why they are so amazing :D
I saw this comment before the ad finished and got super excited
Imagine if Lucas had made the Klein bottle with a Sprite instead of a Coke.
It'd be a soda lime lemon lime soda bottle bottle.
Sounds like an ending gag for Citation Needed.
"It's the Michael Bay and George Takei week away in St Tropez."
@@JaxMerrick "it's Jean-Claude Van Damme's cloned-jaw damned van."
lemon lime soda lime soda bottle klein bottle bottle
r/WordAvalanches
false.
Lucas has found a way to make an iconic object even more iconic- this needs to find its way to some museum of contemporary art.
Or to a science museum.
Shudder to think what it would bring at auction. Maybe a fundraiser for numberphile?
Absolutely. It's like pop art paintings of logos or what photomontage artists do with magazines. This is something that's never been done before.
false.
Cliff's klein bottles are absolutely worth a buy not merely for their own sake, but for the wonderful included materials and fun things he does with the packaging. The box mine came in is every bit as fun and displayable as the bottles are.
packed to the brim with jokes on shipping papers, and personalised texts all over. Imagine getting a handwritten note from Cliff specifically to you.
My bottle is on my bookcase and the packaging it came in is on top of the bookcase. I told him that there are 26 dimensions in my reality, but he didn't take the string theory bait. But he did sign the bottle, so I'm still happy, and our email exchanges were fun, too.
I love the stickers he includes! I wish that design was on a t-shirt, so I could wear it with my Klein bottle hat and möbius scarf.
false.
Cliff: "I'm not going to ask his secrets."
Brady: "It's free real estate."
هذا الرجل خليط بين الخبرة والذكاء و الفكاهة ،،،، كل الاحترام لك من مصر 🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬
This man is mix of intelligent and experience and joking
When I’m feeling a bit low, which is often these days, I just put on the Cliff Stoll playlist. His energy, excitement, charm, and intellect always puts a smile on my face. Thank you for adding another video.❤️
Cliff is one of my favourite contributors to this channel, so I'm always glad to get more videos from him.
Same, he is so happy en enthousiastic
Oh I love seeing new and exciting cliff stoll klein bottle content.
I crocheted a Klein bottle once and the easiest way I could think of doing it was with the window method (5:40) so I can crochet it in one piece. So cool to see the different immersions. Thanks cliff for another interesting video :)
Now, for a real challenge, you should try crocheting it in four dimensions.
false.
always love cliff videos
Was not expecting you to be here .
Former Minecraft mod and Klein bottle enjoyer
He is always so jumpy
I don't really know much about glass blowing so I can't picture or imagine how this Klein Bottles are made. I would love to see a video showing how they are produced (even if that is probably not going to ve a typical Numberphile video).
>(even if that is probably not going to ve a typical Numberphile video).
Sounds like maybe a topic for Objectivity, his other channel.
They already did
@Matthew Morycinski Cliff has shown Numberphile his warehouse in his basement, but in reality, it only appears to be a warehouse in 3-dimensional space.
Search the channel for the other videos with Cliff. There’s one where he shows off his home-made robots, which collect Klein bottles from storage beneath his house for delivery, and talks about the manufacturing process too. Such an amazing character!
??
Every day that I see a Cliff Stoll update is a truly happy day, just to know that this man is still doing well. Truly one of the greats along with Mr Rogers.
Ah Cliff, your enthusiasm always makes me smile
I really love how he excited and passionate he talks about his Klein bottles!
I bought one a while back and still have to smile every time I look at it on my shelf.
Thank you Brady and thank you Cliff!
Awesome to see another Cliff Stoll video, I really love his personality and passion. As usual I recommend everyone his book "The Cuckoo's Egg: Tracking a Spy Through the Maze of Computer Espionage". Definitely well worth the read
Also get a Klein Bottle from him, he also sends a lovely message with them
Mr. Stoll is so passionate about this subject, and that passion permeates to other people, me included. And he makes a quite complex topic into such an interesting discussion. Brady, on his turn, makes the right comments at the exact moments. Such a delightful 10 minutes of life-gaining, well-spent time! Thank you both!
Can't believe it, just unpacked my new printer half an hour ago - and what do I see in the background? Exactly my model! Good choice :-)
I always enjoy Cliff Stoll popping up. I bought some klein bottles from him and the packaging they came in was so very humorous.
Just saw a collection of Cliff Stoll's Klein bottles in San Francisco airport, terminal D. Also on display are a bunch of historic calculators, including many of Cliff's. Other mathematical displays also. Very cool.
I saw the Klein bottles from quite a distance and instantly recognized some of Cliff's unique ones that were previously shown on Numberphile.
Please do more Cliff Stoll!!! I have watched all of his videos at least 3 times, I love him so much
I'm so glad that he could come back to the future.
Came here to comment on how much I love videos with Cliff just to see most of the comments already saying that. There's hope for us after all.
Absolutely love Cliff. I bought a Klein Stein from him. The interaction and the additional information he included were brilliantly entertaining alone, not to mention how cool the Stein is!
Cliff is my favorite Numberphile. He just gets so excited! I love it
He's high on math!
I had a Lenux teacher / Unix teacher in college who was much like this guy. Adorable old nerdy cooks are some of the best people in the world.
In another comment, @Massimo pointed out this Cliff Stoll is the one that wrote the book _The Cuckoo's Egg_ . It describes events that happened while he was a Unix System Administrator at a national laboratory. He was a teacher. His first book has a recipe for cookies.
So yup, that sounds like a very similar person.
My C professor is the same. They actually used to be coworkers
I'm a simple man. I see a Numberphile video with Kline bottles, I click it.
Welcome back Cliff! WE LOVE YOU!
"i don't know how many ears does he have. I can extrapolate "
That man is the legend
Cliff cliffing about Klein-Bottles is just what you need
0:08 Only Cliff Stoll would take a selfie the old-school way
I would SO love to get to spend a day with Cliff and just ask him questions. He's a gem.
I got one of his Klein bottles for Christmas a couple years ago and it's one of my most prized possessions. I keep it on my desk and it always puts a smile on my face
I appreciate that Cliff Stoll appreciates the workmanship and material differences, even as he delights in the topography.
I see Klein bottle in the title and I can sense it has Cliff in it, so I click.
He actually made the neck of the bottle at the bottom if I see right. That's a really nice detail.
Saw "Klein Bottle" and knew *exactly* who this was going to feature. Love me some good Clifford Stoll content.
just got done with my last a level maths mock and come home to a new cliff video, couldnt ask for more :D
I love how you can tell who is going to present the video based on what topic!
Cliff we love you! Finally video with you ❤
I really like the analogy that the Klein bottle is to 4 dimensions as the picture is to 3 dimensions... I think this is helping me understand Klein bottles and therefore 4th dimension a little better
This man is by far my favorite thing on Numberphile
Stoll is my hero! Yet another fine video added to the Stoll playlist! TY Numberphile!
With the way the world has been the past few years, I am immensely glad to see that Cliff is still safe. That man is one of my heroes.
YES!! Cliff is hands down my favorite numberphile guest!
Love seeing Cliff again!
I came here with the speed of light.
Impossible!
You can't be particle ( human ) 🙂
I see klein bottle in the title, I drop what I'm doing and start the video. This man brings such joy to the world around him
@@skmishra1685 it was a metaphor 🙂🙃
It is always a pleasure to watch Cliff Stoll talk about Klein bottles so passionately.
I love that there is a ramanujan picture in the background
Cliff Stoll and his enthusiasm is such a treasure
The coke bottle approach does a great job of conceptualizing the “pathing” as one travels the manifold, I guess because it preserves the traditional orientation and direction of flow we instinctively think of a bottled drink as having.
I love the Klein bottle videos. That Coke bottle reminds me of the stretched Coke bottles they made down by the seashore when I was a kid and then filled them with layers of colored sand.
I can't understand what he is talking about but I love his energy
It is such a joy to see Cliff Stoll again, hot damn!
I was fortunate enough to see some of the Klein bottles previously featured here in person at the San Francisco International Airport last month. They're in Terminal 2. Neat stuff!
This guy is fully passionate in what he is doing, I enjoy that
A person can't have enough of Klein Bottles and Numberphile videos with Cliff
"theres some things i dont want to know" one of the smartest people in the world, telling you ignorance is bliss and secrets are to be respected.
He appreciates the magic :)
I love this guy! Also, I am not sure which is more "beyond my comprehension", the whole immersion from 4d down to 3d, or the god-tier skill of this Lucas Clarke guy!
Cola and maths, this is where I shine - Always lovely to see Mr. Stoll as well!
I bought a Klein bottle from this guy a little over a decade ago and it has lived in my shelf since. In all those years only one person has known what it is. The moment he recognized it I was so excited.
OK this pushed me over the edge. I went and ordered one from Cliff. His website is worth visiting.
did you order a klein bottle, or a klein bottle 'puzzle'? :P
The website is a treat. Needs to get saved on the way back machine as a pick me up for 20 years from now
Numberphile: *uploads a video on klein bottles*
Subscibers: I have been summoned.
Everything is great about this video but my favourite part is ... getting to see Cliff's office!
I'm a simple man. If I see any mention of Cliff or Klein bottles (in the hopes that Cliff is in it) in the video title, I watch.
idk why but there's something just so fantastic about his walls being covered in famous mathematicians
Cliff's explanation at the start of the video really helped me understand what a klein bottle actually represents.
hes so passionate about Klein bottles and im here for every second of that
I wish we could preserve Cliff Stole in a Klein Bottle forever, he's a treasure to this world.
I'm imagining another video now: "Hi, I'm Simon Whistler, and today we're talking about That Time Coca-Cola Tried To Sell Coke In A Klein Bottle..."
I clicked the moment I saw Klein Bottle on the title cause I knew it was a Cliff Stoll video. Love this guy.
What a joy, thank you Cliff and Brady!
You’re the only reason I don’t give up on math.
It’s always fun to watch Cliff Stoll 😌
For anyone unfarmilliar with this man Cliff Stoll, read the Cuckoo's Egg or the documentary The KGB, the Computer, and Me. This guy is awsome.
We have an in-depth interview with Cliff here: ua-cam.com/video/lxdcBD4ppF0/v-deo.html
Your enthusiasm is so contagious!
I love it! 😁
I loved hearing that bit about the boro glass vs. the Coca-Cola glass - I have a lot of admiration for people who are true masters of their craft, especially when it involves working with their own hands on something like this. I can design digital logic circuits quite well, if I do say so myself, but to actually get one in my hands I send money to some company to actually make my circuit boards. So yeah - "hands on artisan-ship" really impresses me.
I’ve no interest in glasswork but this man’s enthusiasm is so captivating.
I truly love this guy.
God bless this gentleman.
Upvoted the moment I saw Cliff! Glad to see him again!
Cliff is the bomb. So glad to see him again.
I'm convinced Cliff Stoll is one of the greatest people to ever grace this planet
The best part of this video is that, because video is a 2D medium, we can't prove that Cliff hasn't had radical 3D surgery to make himself into a human Klein Bottle.
Oh my goddd yess!!! Lol I always get superrrr excited whenever i see "klein bottle" on numberphile because i know it's gonna be cliff stoll :DDDD
I love Cliff's wall of fame (Donald Coxeter prominent, and rightly so).
Cliff makes my day every time I watch him
His interest is so genuine and he’s so interesting to watch
Watching him talk about Klein bottle always cheers me up.
siiiií, al fin otro video de Cliff Stoll!!!
gracias Brady
Wait, I was JUST watching the Cliff Stoll playlist over the last day. How did you know that I would like to hear more from Mr Stoll? HOW?
I think Cliff sent me that same photo before he mailed off a bottle I ordered from him. He's one of the coolest people on the planet.
Getting a video with Cliff really made my day.
This video answered a lot of questions I’ve had about Klein bottles for a very long time
Finally some cliff videos!😍
Been waiting ages for a new one!😤🤣
I love Cliff and his enthusiasm
This talk about higher dimensions being projected on lower dimensions reminded me of how I wrapped my head around this whole concept.
A two dimension plane being projected on a one dimension line will only show the "shadow of the plane, and if you rotate and translate the plane around, that shadow projected on the line changes, giving a better idea of the real shape of the two dimensional plane, on that one dimensional line, while, at the same time, one dimensional "beings" on that line can only "see" (assuming they "see" like we do) in one direction of that line at a time, their perception of their reality being reduced to a point at the same time that they can't "see" behind a point on that line, they need to "get behind" that point to be able to perceive the length of that object.
On the same token, two dimensional beings can se the whole one dimensional line all at once, but they can't "see" behind other two dimensional objects, they need to either rotate that object or circle around it to get the whole picture.
Then we get to the projection of three dimensional objects on a two dimensional plane, and the same thing happens, on 2D you can only perceive the shadow of the 3D object and need to rotate and translate it in order to perceive different perspectives of the object to be able to grasp it's true shape.
And if we go the other way, bringing a 2D object to a 3D world, we can, again, perceive it's entirety all at once, because, like in the 2D world, we can step to a higher dimension and perceive all the lower dimensions at once.
And I imagine it would be the same with a 4D object, a three dimension representation would be just a limited projection on our 3D reality, while in a higher dimension our 3D world could be perceived all at once, with nothing hidden behind anything.
Rinse and repeat for higher dimensions.
Not gonna lie, if those three alternate versions of the Klein bottles end up being in the shop, I know I'll be buying. Having those babies sitting next to my main would be a sight to behold!
CLIFF STOLL LET'S GOOOOO I COULD LISTEN TO THIS MAN TALK ABOUT ANYTHING FOR HOURS
I'm always happy to see another Cliff out there, but I'm curious if it's short for Clifford, or in my opinion, the better option of Clifton? I may be biased.