But now we. You very much like like the other day I was b by you so. You vbbhub8 yby7byby h98g7y7y8h7yb7uvhub7by7b97yb7h8y7 uhhhy 9hbb787 by 79 77yb7777y878u7797y7977:7 7 7 byu by the y8b7 88 090 538 337 b7y b. 77buby
This is the most *OUTSTANDING and ADMIRABLE* channel about astronomy. *THANK YOU VERY MUCH* mister Butler for your hard work and time you spend for our education.
Your videos are so informative and fascinating, Mr. Butler. But my favorite thing about them is that the cadence and tone of your voice relaxes me to the point of falling asleep. Treat that as a compliment.
I have seen COUNTLESS vids, docs, etc. regarding the subject of the Milky Way Galaxy. And I have to say that this video is EASILY BY FAR, The Most In depth, Straight fwd, Easy to understand, video that I have seen..... MAYBE EVER! KEEP UP THE EXCELLENT WORK, and DO NOT LISTEN 2 UNIMPORTANT INTERNET TROLLS!!! 👍🏻👍🏻
All the wars in the world would stop quickly and laugh at each other if they watched this video and realized how insignificant we are in the universe Somali civil war survivor.
Not to mention that if the world is in war and there is a winner and soon after scientists discover that a huge asteroid is heading our way and will erase life on this planet.
I've watched this series so many times, I can quote most of it by heart. My favorite is "It did not wobble"! So much is amazing, I can always come back & enjoy. Here in #10 he mentions work done at my school, Univ.of Wis.
I've seen these videos before, but just watched a few again. Man, they are great. So much knowledge, presented clearly and accessibly, with beautiful images and music. Thank you again, sir.
Thank you for sharing the awesome wonder of our galaxy! We are so privileged to be able to begin our understanding of the universe the way it really is.
I was never able to find information about the center of our galaxy. This is very informative and I appreciate the effort you put into making this. Thanks for the video!
DUMNEZEU este mare , a facut totul perfect. Documetarul este interesant si util pasionatilor de astrofizica. Multumim Einstein, inaintasilor , contemporanilor care au putut pune in lumina acest minunat domeniu si nu in ultimul rand lui David Butler !
Thank you! Finally, a straight forward explanation of the structure and size of the Milky Way and the location of the Solar System in the Orion Spur. Great video.
Thank you David Butler. UA-cam is a great tool or a great waist of time. Your site is a great tool. There is so much pseudoscience on UA-cam It is great to find a site as good as yours.
It's sad how far people have fallen... I don't know what's to blame. I've noticed most of them are American, so it's probably alot to do with the failing education system, but that doesn't explain the pathological distrust, hyper suspicion, and tendancies to beleive in elaborate conspiracies. I've spoken to some of these people and it really is crazy how they explain away anything and everything that goes against their conspiracy with the most bizarre nonsense ... Ive heard them say that Gravity doesn't exist, That the sun's only 3000 miles away "because it has to be for their flat earth model to work" , uh the moon is a hologram, satellites are fake, the space stations fake, all images videos are fake, Antarctica is patrolled by whoever and they turn away anyone who tries to go there... Lol, the tourist etc are paid actors... And there are thousands of these nuts! My own mother is kind of one,. She's a chem trailer... Believes contrails from aircraft are a nefarious chemical spray... You'd think people would grow and shine since the internet gave everyone complete access to the whole of human knowledge, but instead we get this spreading downward spiral into a new anti science paranoid dark age
How can we feel so much when we are so small? Mr Butler I hope a transmission of this work makes it to other civilisations so they can see what we are capable of.
Beautifully narrated with clear explanations, I feel inspired and learned something new that G2 will be sucked in by Sag*A. Your videos are some of the best on the subject of astronomy and I hope you keep producing such content. I am very very disappointed by the comments here and I wish people could develop some critical thinking. Thank you for taking out the time to spread knowledge free of cost for all of us.
Thanks. By the way, G2 did not fall into the black hole. I covered that in an annual update. Also, you might find the 2019 4k update interesting. I added quite a bit on Sag A *.
Mr. Butler these are excellent videos. I recommended them to a high school buddy of mine who now teaches high school herself, and she passed them on to the science teacher who now uses them in his class.
Good Mic and natural vocals,. I can put David Butler on at night when me and my girlfriend go to sleep and with the black background of the night and David’s low hertz voice = peaceful, osmosis, good night of sleep!!! 🔙🔛🔝🔚
Your series is awesome I have been watching them all , it boggles my mind,I could ask a million questions , thanks to people like you and Carl Sagan, who introduced me to the Cosmos my hunger to know more is never ending
Dear David this is outstanding and still very much relevant ,99% of us who have watched your vids applaud you. Your an absolute steller guy in life there's givers and takers your one of life's givers I've learnt so much from you and passed onto my children the knowledge I got from you ,bless you and I wish you all the best 👍
Totally fascinating ....that humankind is at this point we can try to understand our place in a galaxy , one of countless of such objects , is mind blowing . Even though our earthly notion of space and time seems unable to comprehend these creations and lightyears' distances. It's only physicists who are able to understand a fraction of it . Most of us can only philosophize about it .🤔 🌌
Very interesting indeed! Thank you very much. If I ever travel to the outside of our Milky Way I will bring back a picture. Make sure you are here in approx. 1100 Million years.
I know the thought of seeing the milky way from outside of the disk is a bit of an irrational wish on my part, but I can't stop myself from imagining the overwhelming beauty such a view would bring. It is sad to think that we will not be able to see it. I understand that it would be very similar to the other spirals in the universe, but there is just something about knowing that you're looking at _our own_ little island of stars moving silently through the void.
it will be quite a spectacle but the thing about the feeble minds of humans, we get bored easily. even if the orion clusters is next to the moon, we will get use to it and move on to other things
@@orbitalpunch4711 I've noticed that people definitely take many things for granted, and are no longer amazed by things they see often as well. However there are still people that see the beauty of the universe in even seemingly "ordinary" things.
David Butler, hats off to you good sir. You did a phenomenal job in presenting this information. Your video books are even better than what is available on television (Nova, Mutual of Omaha, and even History Channel). You have gained a subscriber. Keep up the good work.
18:47 "They call it dark matter because it does not interact in any way with the matter and electromagnetic energy we see with our instruments." Then you immediately contradict this by saying "Its only interaction is through gravity." So It DOES INTERACT.
I understand. By particles 'interacting' I mean that there would be some kind of energy exchange if they came into contact. But dark matter would pass right through normal matter without any energy exchange whatsoever. But you are correct in noting that the existence of dark matter in a space, bends the space just like normal matter. That bend will impact all matter that encounters it. It is a sort of interaction. Thanks for you note.
Wow, so crazy big! The voyager part about the photo of the Milky Way, blew my mind! had to go bad to make sure I heard that right! Wow some great videos very informative easy to understand, well done sir!
I really enjoy your videos. Some unsolicited advice, to help improve, is to use a pop filter/pop screen between your mouth and microphone. This will remove the little clicks and smacking sounds and make it more pleasant for listeners. Especially those who listen with headphones/earbuds. Thank you for all of your efforts into producing these fantastic videos.
Hi David I recently commented on a video asking for one about black holes 🕳️ 😊. To my surprise you recently did just that. I was looking for videos on Arendale or the morning star (old galaxy in a gravitational lense picture from Hubble and now Webb). Think a video on Arendale would be very interesting 😊
excellent documentary....I found it extremely informative and easy to follow and understand for an astronomy novice like myself. I will certainly be following you and your other features.
Our Galaxy the Milky way with us is millions of knots away from where it was just a minute ago in space. And all other galaxies are part of a free fall by multiples of the speed of light toward the same direction. Even accelerating it's speed at the closer side to the gravitation that pulls all of them by far greater mass with. You may say that the "Universe is expanding" Einstein defined only what happens to the limit of speed of light within this system, and he is still correct. Nobody can prove that he was wrong. Nobody can prove an absolute greater speed also in the space despite that it is exists. The above mentioned occurence happens approximately by 14 billion years ago, or even much more- I would not bet on a fix numerical definition.
Amazing! I am alive only because of this understanding. I work in a poor country, where the salary is only a 100 bucks. This knowledge is the only thing that keeps me alive, without it I had to suicide myself... and I'm serious about this.
Бирено Коремче bro, you have internet access. your life isn't that bad. :/
7 років тому+2
Бирено Коремче 100 dollars? per week? per day? apparently it's enough that one may afford a computer and have internet connections. how much the average person earns is not what determines his wealth, it's how much things cost vs. what he earns. we like to use the gallon of milk comparison. for instance e figure say, a fellow works as a painter and earns roughly $500-$600 per week, A gallon of milk costs around $3-$4 per gallon.. more or less depending on location. I can tell you that the average American will spend/consume approx $100 per day just normal day to day business.
Just FYI, the second part of the name "Schwarz-schild" is pronounced like "shield", not child. It also translates as 'Black Shield'. Great post, love your channel. Thanks for sharing your knowledge and love of astronomy with us.
Dave I’m loving your videos you are so accurate when it comes to the Milky Way I really look forward to seeing more your videos I can’t get enough of them the music the sound of your voice I find to be oddly satisfying I love you man keep up the good work
If the outer and inner halos are rotating opposite, in view of gravitational lens theory, the light comes into our galaxy is a kind of changed form from it's original. Therefore our understanding of universe is remain question, isn't it? Is this question correct? But thank you for one of the best lectures I inspired.
Mr Butler, I very much enjoy your videos and I am happy that someone with knowledge in this field of study is producing such content for youtube. I think you are good at doing this. Your presentation is pleasant and entertaining to listen to. I think you do a very good job at this.
@@arguemaxdotcom2710 Get into the habit of watching information that makes sense...and not the Main Stream Scientific Bullshit that they have been trying to shove down our kid's throats for a hundred years ! Watch Ben Davidson and the Suspicious Observers and The Thunderbolts Project Electric Universe ....and get the facts that make sense ! Start here with Ben's Daily Update on the Sun's activity... Learn some Real Facts ! ua-cam.com/video/_HHPU9JtRTA/v-deo.html
Hm, 2013. That is 5 years ago and I do hope that you are well and still doing the work which you love. I viewed this segment first and must now search out 1-9. Thank you.
Excelent video. Dr. Butler, could you put English subtitles on the video, it will be very useful for us to understand all you are taking about. Thank you.
On 15th June 2018, a signal was transmitted from the Esa big radio antenna at Cebreros (77km West of Madrid, Spain), in memory of Stephen Hawking, who died on 14 March 2018, and his work on the physics of black holes. The broadcast will travel the 3457 light year distance at the speed of light and will arrive in the year 5475; this will be the first ever human interaction with a black hole. 1A 0620-00 was chosen for this broadcast as it is the closest black hole to Earth.
Thank you David, somehow you capture the scale so much better than anyone else I've seen. The only problem is, It makes me want to show everyone I know.
Thank you, Dr. Butler! Do you agree with recent observations of the Milky Way at 170,000 - 200,000 ly in diameter and ~ 1 trillion solar masses? Our galaxy would seem to be a better "bride" for Andromeda. In 4-4.5 billion years when Andromeda and Milky Way merge tidal interactions will result in the creation of tens of billions of new stars and planets. Not a dark future for our galaxy but a bright new chapter as the giant elliptical Milkomeda is gradually born.
I understand that the numbers for the Milky Way are changing. I usually wait for more time for re-observes and confirmations before I study the new data and publish the news in my annual updates.
Tank you David. I'm very grateful to you for this program. I'm Brazilian, living in Brazil. I spend hour and hours listening you wonderful programs.
I am Brazilian too.
For many years I follow him.
Always ... Great videos
I really enjoyed this and all of your videos. I hope you continue to make more.
But now we. You very much like like the other day I was b by you so. You vbbhub8 yby7byby h98g7y7y8h7yb7uvhub7by7b97yb7h8y7 uhhhy 9hbb787 by 79 77yb7777y878u7797y7977:7 7 7 byu by the y8b7 88 090 538 337 b7y b. 77buby
@@gsxr100100 Your comment made so much sense, halfway thru your comment you had a bit of an aneurism.
This is the most *OUTSTANDING and ADMIRABLE* channel about astronomy. *THANK YOU VERY MUCH* mister Butler for your hard work and time you spend for our education.
The music + your voice = so peaceful that it’s like listening to a bedtime story to make you sleep
The best voice i have ever heard.
Every single word melts into my mind.
Your videos are so informative and fascinating, Mr. Butler. But my favorite thing about them is that the cadence and tone of your voice relaxes me to the point of falling asleep. Treat that as a compliment.
I have seen COUNTLESS vids, docs, etc. regarding the subject of the Milky Way Galaxy. And I have to say that this video is EASILY BY FAR, The Most In depth, Straight fwd, Easy to understand, video that I have seen..... MAYBE EVER! KEEP UP THE EXCELLENT WORK, and DO NOT LISTEN 2 UNIMPORTANT INTERNET TROLLS!!! 👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks.
yes .
Fantastic presentation in pictures, words, and music, thank you
All the wars in the world would stop quickly and laugh at each other if they watched this video and realized how insignificant we are in the universe
Somali civil war survivor.
Not to mention that if the world is in war and there is a winner and soon after scientists discover that a huge asteroid is heading our way and will erase life on this planet.
Yes my friend
I've watched this series so many times, I can quote most of it by heart. My favorite is "It did not wobble"! So much is amazing, I can always come back & enjoy. Here in #10 he mentions work done at my school, Univ.of Wis.
Looks like I'm hooked in until the end of this series. This really helps grasp ideas on how our universe is constructed and how it works.
I've seen these videos before, but just watched a few again. Man, they are great. So much knowledge, presented clearly and accessibly, with beautiful images and music. Thank you again, sir.
Thank you for sharing the awesome wonder of our galaxy! We are so privileged to be able to begin our understanding of the universe the way it really is.
I was never able to find information about the center of our galaxy. This is very informative and I appreciate the effort you put into making this. Thanks for the video!
Nice video.....simplifying and packing tonnes of scientific studies in just 20 minutes....!
Brilliant...
Mind-blowing!! Our galaxy is amazing 😀 Beautifully written and presented, thank you so much.
Very useful information given in this video.. thanks sir
DUMNEZEU este mare , a facut totul perfect. Documetarul este interesant si util pasionatilor de astrofizica. Multumim Einstein, inaintasilor , contemporanilor care au putut pune in lumina acest minunat domeniu si nu in ultimul rand lui David Butler !
Mr Butler thank you so much for you video's. I realy enjoy you explaining stuff about the universe. THANK YOU
Thank you! Finally, a straight forward explanation of the structure and size of the Milky Way and the location of the Solar System in the Orion Spur. Great video.
Thank you David Butler. UA-cam is a great tool or a great waist of time. Your site is a great tool. There is so much pseudoscience on UA-cam It is great to find a site as good as yours.
It's sad how far people have fallen... I don't know what's to blame. I've noticed most of them are American, so it's probably alot to do with the failing education system, but that doesn't explain the pathological distrust, hyper suspicion, and tendancies to beleive in elaborate conspiracies. I've spoken to some of these people and it really is crazy how they explain away anything and everything that goes against their conspiracy with the most bizarre nonsense ... Ive heard them say that Gravity doesn't exist, That the sun's only 3000 miles away "because it has to be for their flat earth model to work" , uh the moon is a hologram, satellites are fake, the space stations fake, all images videos are fake, Antarctica is patrolled by whoever and they turn away anyone who tries to go there... Lol, the tourist etc are paid actors... And there are thousands of these nuts! My own mother is kind of one,. She's a chem trailer... Believes contrails from aircraft are a nefarious chemical spray...
You'd think people would grow and shine since the internet gave everyone complete access to the whole of human knowledge, but instead we get this spreading downward spiral into a new anti science paranoid dark age
Anthony Romeo yes indeed....i encourage the youth to use YT as an educational tool, they'll enjoy it and appreciate it alot more
These are great videos! I'm glad I came across this channel. I have learned a lot more, and I could listen to David Butler talk all day!
How can we feel so much when we are so small? Mr Butler I hope a transmission of this work makes it to other civilisations so they can see what we are capable of.
Indeed ! 😎
WHY do this kind of videos don´t go viral man? your videos are just awesome David,thanks for charing your knowledge
Beautifully narrated with clear explanations, I feel inspired and learned something new that G2 will be sucked in by Sag*A. Your videos are some of the best on the subject of astronomy and I hope you keep producing such content.
I am very very disappointed by the comments here and I wish people could develop some critical thinking.
Thank you for taking out the time to spread knowledge free of cost for all of us.
Thanks. By the way, G2 did not fall into the black hole. I covered that in an annual update. Also, you might find the 2019 4k update interesting. I added quite a bit on Sag A *.
@@howfarawayisit Voyager 1 ( @16:04) was lunched in 1977 not 1975.... there is one dislike from me...
Mr. Butler these are excellent videos. I recommended them to a high school buddy of mine who now teaches high school herself, and she passed them on to the science teacher who now uses them in his class.
That was very informative and captivating.
Thanks mr.Butler,tomorrow i bring you a apple pie.
Thanks David for this incredible work.
It is amazing what you have done.
Greetings from Brazil.
By far the best of 50 milkyway galaxy videos. One thumbs up is all I can give unfortunately.
Love your channel. I can’t get enough of it. Please keep them coming. Thanks.
this video answered many questions I had. bravoooo! for the the teacher!
Good Mic and natural vocals,.
I can put David Butler on at night when me and my girlfriend go to sleep and with the black background of the night and David’s low hertz voice = peaceful, osmosis, good night of sleep!!! 🔙🔛🔝🔚
space, life and classical music somehow suit perfectly together....very interesting
This is an outstanding collection of videos. Who knew learning science could be so beautiful. Thank you!
Your series is awesome I have been watching them all , it boggles my mind,I could ask a million questions , thanks to people like you and Carl Sagan, who introduced me to the Cosmos my hunger to know more is never ending
Dear David this is outstanding and still very much relevant ,99% of us who have watched your vids applaud you. Your an absolute steller guy in life there's givers and takers your one of life's givers I've learnt so much from you and passed onto my children the knowledge I got from you ,bless you and I wish you all the best 👍
Here ! Here ! 😁
Totally fascinating ....that humankind is at this point we can try to understand our place in a galaxy , one of countless of such objects , is mind blowing . Even though our earthly notion of space and time seems unable to comprehend these creations and lightyears' distances.
It's only physicists who are able to understand a fraction of it . Most of us can only philosophize about it .🤔 🌌
Stunningly beautiful. Amazingly interesting...much appreciation for your sharing with us Dr. Butler💥
Mind boggling...this video just put everything into perspective 😯😯
Thank you very much for this wonderful and informative video.
How far??? The Milk Way is right here ..... ALL AROUND ME, close to us, around the earth !!!
I love your channel so much. Excellent, easy to understand delivery.
Great work and very informative. Thank you
What a magnificent channel! Absolutely brilliant and outstanding!👍🏻👍🏻😀😀 thank you Sir for uploading this content.
love your videos! infinite thanks!!!!!!!!!!!
What a fabulous set of videos!
Thank you so much for your videos! No unwanted bullshit, just clear digestible information, love it. Great choice of music as well.
Thank you for this marvellous series!
Very interesting indeed! Thank you very much.
If I ever travel to the outside of our Milky Way I will bring back a picture. Make sure you are here in approx. 1100 Million years.
I know the thought of seeing the milky way from outside of the disk is a bit of an irrational wish on my part, but I can't stop myself from imagining the overwhelming beauty such a view would bring. It is sad to think that we will not be able to see it. I understand that it would be very similar to the other spirals in the universe, but there is just something about knowing that you're looking at _our own_ little island of stars moving silently through the void.
it will be quite a spectacle but the thing about the feeble minds of humans, we get bored easily. even if the orion clusters is next to the moon, we will get use to it and move on to other things
@@orbitalpunch4711 I've noticed that people definitely take many things for granted, and are no longer amazed by things they see often as well. However there are still people that see the beauty of the universe in even seemingly "ordinary" things.
cosmos sci
I couldn’t agree more mate
David Butler, hats off to you good sir. You did a phenomenal job in presenting this information. Your video books are even better than what is available on television (Nova, Mutual of Omaha, and even History Channel). You have gained a subscriber. Keep up the good work.
18:47 "They call it dark matter because it does not interact in any way with the matter and electromagnetic energy we see with our instruments." Then you immediately contradict this by saying "Its only interaction is through gravity." So It DOES INTERACT.
I understand. By particles 'interacting' I mean that there would be some kind of energy exchange if they came into contact. But dark matter would pass right through normal matter without any energy exchange whatsoever. But you are correct in noting that the existence of dark matter in a space, bends the space just like normal matter. That bend will impact all matter that encounters it. It is a sort of interaction. Thanks for you note.
Wow, so crazy big! The voyager part about the photo of the Milky Way, blew my mind! had to go bad to make sure I heard that right! Wow some great videos very informative easy to understand, well done sir!
“1,500 years after Copernicus put the sun at the centre of our solar system?” 😳 I think 1,000 years too many 🤔🌝!
A really great video. Very useful and informative. Superior narration, sir.
Ah yes, the four infinity stones: Soul, Heart, Rosetta, and Crab
Thanks for this wonderful pictures
I really enjoy your videos. Some unsolicited advice, to help improve, is to use a pop filter/pop screen between your mouth and microphone. This will remove the little clicks and smacking sounds and make it more pleasant for listeners. Especially those who listen with headphones/earbuds. Thank you for all of your efforts into producing these fantastic videos.
I'll give it a try. Thanks.
Perfect soundtrack, captivating video, thanks for sharing!
Why does this narrator have such a sleep inducing voice...its 10am watchin this n i wanna go to sleep
Hypnotic!
Same thing happened to me even though the subject matter is interesting. I had to fight my eyelids from closing..................
Hi David I recently commented on a video asking for one about black holes 🕳️ 😊. To my surprise you recently did just that.
I was looking for videos on Arendale or the morning star (old galaxy in a gravitational lense picture from Hubble and now Webb).
Think a video on Arendale would be very interesting 😊
Beethoven's 9th, 3rd movement. perfect.
A great presentation! Thank you.
Bravo. Standing ovation.
Very interesting and gives me a bird's eye view (aerial etc) of the Milky way and where we located relative to the rest of the Galaxy. Thanks
My head spun when you said that Orion spur is 2,000 ly deep. And I thought Mariana trench was messy..
excellent documentary....I found it extremely informative and easy to follow and understand for an astronomy novice like myself. I will certainly be following you and your other features.
The Beethoven soundtrack is good
Thanks for your hard work,love this channel.
We're only as smart as you are,the smarter you get.The smarter we get.
Thanks.
Our Galaxy the Milky way with us is millions of knots away from where it was just a minute ago in space.
And all other galaxies are part of a free fall by multiples of the speed of light toward the same direction.
Even accelerating it's speed at the closer side to the gravitation that pulls all of them by far greater mass with. You may say that the "Universe is expanding" Einstein defined only what happens to the limit of speed of light within this system, and he is still correct.
Nobody can prove that he was wrong. Nobody can prove an absolute greater speed also in the space despite that it is exists.
The above mentioned occurence happens approximately by 14 billion years ago, or even much more- I would not bet on a fix numerical definition.
Excellent sir . Thank you
Psalm 148 the heavens declare your majesty
irishbreakfast one must think what really created everything, no?
angel fiery petals nice to see your doing your homework😁
@@333STONE this is one of my most favorite videos. 🙌💕
@irishbreakfast sorry (on the journey as well in search for truth in fascinating mysteries)
Not knowing why a black hole makes an accretion disk is like a character of a book becoming self-aware, but not knowing it existed in a book.
Amazing! I am alive only because of this understanding. I work in a poor country, where the salary is only a 100 bucks. This knowledge is the only thing that keeps me alive, without it I had to suicide myself... and I'm serious about this.
Бирено Коремче have hope time always change u will shine like a star.
Не го правя, на живо има толкова много, за да живее. Научете колкото можете. никога не спирай да се учиш.
Бирено Коремче bro, you have internet access. your life isn't that bad. :/
Бирено Коремче 100 dollars? per week? per day?
apparently it's enough that one may afford a computer and have internet connections.
how much the average person earns is not what determines his wealth, it's how much things cost vs. what he earns. we like to use the gallon of milk comparison. for instance e figure say, a fellow works as a painter and earns roughly $500-$600 per week, A gallon of milk costs around $3-$4 per gallon.. more or less depending on location.
I can tell you that the average American will spend/consume approx $100 per day just normal day to day business.
Бирено Коремче GOD BLESS U
Just FYI, the second part of the name "Schwarz-schild" is pronounced like "shield", not child. It also translates as 'Black Shield'.
Great post, love your channel. Thanks for sharing your knowledge and love of astronomy with us.
Thanks for the correct pronunciation.
Dave I’m loving your videos you are so accurate when it comes to the Milky Way I really look forward to seeing more your videos I can’t get enough of them the music the sound of your voice I find to be oddly satisfying I love you man keep up the good work
Fantastic presentation.
love your voice. very soothing.
Can you read this:
www.mlivo.com/quran-kuranandsciencebymlivomustafa.pdf
Maybe it changes something in your life !
Awesome video dear Sir, thank you.
He's voice is so relaxing
Fantastic! My mind is totally boggled.
good use of Beethoven
If the outer and inner halos are rotating opposite, in view of gravitational lens theory, the light comes into our galaxy is a kind of changed form from it's original. Therefore our understanding of universe is remain question, isn't it? Is this question correct? But thank you for one of the best lectures I inspired.
Mr Butler, I very much enjoy your videos and I am happy that someone with knowledge in this field of study is producing such content for youtube. I think you are good at doing this. Your presentation is pleasant and entertaining to listen to. I think you do a very good job at this.
and complete bullshit !
@@Snailmailtrucker how is that?
@@arguemaxdotcom2710
Get into the habit of watching information that makes sense...and not the Main Stream Scientific Bullshit that they have been trying to shove down our kid's throats for a hundred years !
Watch Ben Davidson and the Suspicious Observers and The Thunderbolts Project Electric Universe ....and get the facts that make sense !
Start here with Ben's Daily Update on the Sun's activity... Learn some Real Facts !
ua-cam.com/video/_HHPU9JtRTA/v-deo.html
@@Snailmailtrucker are you a flat earther?
@@arguemaxdotcom2710
Can you read..... Einstein ?
Hm, 2013. That is 5 years ago and I do hope that you are well and still doing the work which you love. I viewed this segment first and must now search out 1-9. Thank you.
11:20 whuuuuut 10,000,000 stars orbiting the galactic center within 1 light year radius???? wow
Excelent video. Dr. Butler, could you put English subtitles on the video, it will be very useful for us to understand all you are taking about. Thank you.
The next best thing to subtitles is the video's document. Download it and have it available to read while you watch the video.
The galaxy is much too beautiful for that name.
I agree!
I've come to love your videos, which I just recently discovered. Thank you so much for making this awesome and inspiring content available.
I got curious: why would someone give thumbs down for such a great video? Would they be terraplanists?
That's a flat earther
Because they're ignorant morons
@@djmikealba let's be optimistic. May be they just prefer rock over classic music.
@@dimassilva6822 You're a better man than me.
@@djmikealba Just easier live this way.
How did i not find this channel sooner? Excellent!
How far away ? We're in it. It's right here.
What i was thinking, but these days ya gotta take it with a grain of salt.
Yeah, you're right. Like saying how far away am I...from me. hehehe
Freedom Storm -- It’s the name of the series you know
for a butler , you make VERY GOOD videos !! Enjoyed watching it
On 15th June 2018, a signal was transmitted from the Esa big radio antenna at Cebreros (77km West of Madrid, Spain), in memory of Stephen Hawking, who died on 14 March 2018, and his work on the physics of black holes. The broadcast will travel the 3457 light year distance at the speed of light and will arrive in the year 5475; this will be the first ever human interaction with a black hole. 1A 0620-00 was chosen for this broadcast as it is the closest black hole to Earth.
Thank you Jerry Li. We owe Stepnen Hawking at least that much.
Thanks, I'm glad somebody read that
send another in 2 years wi6h scramjet 15-20 mach.
Bill Monlux - how long to the nearest star?
Just started watching your collection of videos. Amazing!
Love from Bangladesh
Thank you David, somehow you capture the scale so much better than anyone else I've seen. The only problem is, It makes me want to show everyone I know.
i loveee 💖❤⭐🚀🌌🌎🪐 YOUR JOB yo awesome
Great video with sublime music from Beethoven's Ninth.
Thank you, Dr. Butler! Do you agree with recent observations of the Milky Way at 170,000 - 200,000 ly in diameter and ~ 1 trillion solar masses? Our galaxy would seem to be a better "bride" for Andromeda. In 4-4.5 billion years when Andromeda and Milky Way merge tidal interactions will result in the creation of tens of billions of new stars and planets. Not a dark future for our galaxy but a bright new chapter as the giant elliptical Milkomeda is gradually born.
I understand that the numbers for the Milky Way are changing. I usually wait for more time for re-observes and confirmations before I study the new data and publish the news in my annual updates.