4:04 they are singing live. 1:43 chiquita and 1:50 Pharita are raw vocals. and they sound exactly like the stage. Pharita's raw high note is impressive.
Note that there is the part with Pharita that made you suspect that she was just lip-synching, but it is clear that he is actually singing, it would have been nice to comment, because clearly you were wrong. From the quality of the performance, I'm pretty sure this is what was used in the clip. And yes, there is probably some processing in the studio, at a minimum to remove background noise, but hardly anything more.
😂😂😂@@Vr_shyq.. cool...you know what,the content to their vlogs,is to react what they are hear,...the problem t is, before you react,you have to know,the subject you are reacting to.....most especially YG....That BLACK PINK,came from....😊😊😊..
The thing is that you guys make confused is that because all this things YG make it's all have a big production. Yes it is all live but all of that recording pass by the process of studio stuff and production thing before they released the videos. All are live they got the same vocals colors of the studio version and that is confusing many people cuz it has a very high production. Knowing YGE for years they are the company who prioritize live singing and that's the edge of the compyfor many years. The problem today is they make things so high quality that its over shadow the vocals and make you confused if it's real or not.
7:21 That's why they made a distinction between the "Special Stage" and the "Live Stage" version that they put up on YT. The special stage is more like their pseudo-music-show promotion, and therefore the production (audio and visual) were processed or polished. On the other hand, the "live stage" is their effort to bring a live presentation in their desired environment, which means the audio is recorded as it is but with the sound system and equipment optimized to their liking which leads to multiple takes or records of that live performance before the final outcome. That is just my belief tho.
They definitely sang live, but there's definitely some minor post production stuff going on. The problem is they're so good that some minor post productions are enough to make them sound very close to the recorded version.
That’s how I feel. I know they sang live. But then ruin it with the editing. The first concert they do is going to be scary. I’m sure they will pull it off. They have the skills. But holy shit that has to be scary.
YG released this bts video right on time to answer yr questions from your last reaction. Lol😂 I know you don't react bts video much, but thanks for your support !!!!!
I think this song, this 6 members version, Babymonster can't sing without backtracking because it was designed to let artist sing only main lyrics plus some harmonies, and left some small details be part of backtrack music. For example; at Rora's first sweet part "you lift my feet off of the ground", the higher harmony voices are pre-recorded along with piano sound. If we carefully listening, it's always there in every versions and there was no sign of any member sing along in both live performances. Anyway, my personal opinion, I believe the 'special stage' and the 'live stage', Babymonster sang live to make these videos for us. They did their best honestly, no matter what YG producers would do for any post-production. I valued their dedication rather than doubted their talents.
Why do you guys still insist that it is recorded. Very strange. If they can have one live stage, why won't they get the girls to sing live again in the other special stage. You meant they get the girls to lipsync for their other live stage. Does that even make sense? Why not apply MR Removed yourself for all past and future videos and you can hear live from all girl/boy groups less the music (removed).
Thai people has long name and surname. So parents give nickname for them since birth. Canny for chiquita, Prae for Pharita, so behind camera they call each other like that. Lisa real nickname is Pokpak , i guess closed friend and family stiil call lisa like that.
what crazy is, sometimes you can't identify, because they sound the same when they are singing live, it is like they eat a CD, that's how good they are.
I mean common...4:07 to 4:17 you said "that sounds live" but it was clearly captioned as "with soundtrack for movement check"..if you listen to that carefully you can clearly hear the audio got vocals on it.... the one that is LIVE,they put a LIVE caption on it. And their vocals in this one are very into-your-face and you can hear the audio playing and the voices are not together. This is what in there SPECIAL STAGE..You can clearly hear their live vocals on the special stage video..common listen to that again cause for me its very clear
As I said in your previous reaction, They recorded it LIVE without taking more than one take (obviously cos it's live and you can't say it's live if you take retakes) with "very minimal" post production, like removing eco and increasing vocal audio than instrumental audio, removing unwanted voices... I still don't think that the post production involved "adjusting vocals" of BM members, BM vocals are so good that I really don't think they need any adjustments.
to asa,you can say its already its live why?because it MV her pronunciation for pushing me in. I is hard pronounce, but in live her I is soft like "en" . you can rewind if you hear it clearly
Hey guys, I'm sorry if I was hard on you in your last video. I understand what you mean and I want to her the same thing but I just don't think that will happen until all 7 are together and have more songs under their belts . Perhaps we will get a "true" live performance after their mini album drops. I'm hopeful. BTW, midnight April 1st is actually 7am in Los Angeles on March 31st. Adjust for your time zone. Thanks for your reaction. Bob
What you see in this sounds nothing like what they put out. 100% they are singing live. But it’s not what we got in the video. It’s heavily edited. Just compare this to the original vid. Same as them. I love babymonster. We all know they can sing. But if you want to say something is live make it 100% live. No editing.
@@chrisdef15Nobody.... Absolutely Nobody nowadays do the "Special Stage" completely LIVE WITHOUT EDITING so expecting this ONLY from BM is unfair, but yes They recorded it live with "very minimal" post production like removing eco and increasing vocal audio than instrumentals... They didn't "took multiple takes" while recording so you can't say it wasn't LIVE
Of course, music video audio is a studio version lmao. What the heck are you guys saying??? It's live singing. Period. You guys sound like trying so hard to find a flaw and seems can't accept that Babymonster sounds so good whether it's live or not.
@watchingSundays at 07:30 you said. And of course, it recorded live because it is not live streaming?? I hope that before you guys try so hard to prove whether they are singing live or not, they are from YG. No lipsync rule. You guys should have known that if you guys are kpop fans. And just please enjoy the music without trying so hard to be a critic.
@@acidpainter111 I think this song, this 6 members version, Babymonster can't sing without backtracking because it was designed to let artist sing only main lyrics plus some harmonies, and left some small details be part of backtrack music. For example at Rora's first sweet part "you lift my feet off of the ground", the higher harmony voices are pre-recorded along with piano sound. If we carefully listening, noticing, it's always there in every versions. Anyway, my personal opinion, I believe the 'special stage' and the 'live stage', Babymonster sang live to make these videos for us. They did their best honestly, no matter what YG producers would do for any post-production. I valued their dedication rather than doubted their talents.
the special stage was lip synced. The live stage version wasn't, but the vocals were overproduced. end of discussion. The key proof is the body language, people, dont act dumb.
4:04 they are singing live. 1:43 chiquita and 1:50 Pharita are raw vocals. and they sound exactly like the stage. Pharita's raw high note is impressive.
Note that there is the part with Pharita that made you suspect that she was just lip-synching, but it is clear that he is actually singing, it would have been nice to comment, because clearly you were wrong. From the quality of the performance, I'm pretty sure this is what was used in the clip. And yes, there is probably some processing in the studio, at a minimum to remove background noise, but hardly anything more.
Babymonster members are vocal top tier to the point they always get accuse of lip sync
Can't wait to see them on shows being like "First Take" 😱
@@WatchingSundaysfirst take they use auto tune 💀
@@WatchingSundays why so u can say theyre not singing live?..
@@cool_wth_nthg Girl can't accept the fact 😂
😂😂😂@@Vr_shyq.. cool...you know what,the content to their vlogs,is to react what they are hear,...the problem t is, before you react,you have to know,the subject you are reacting to.....most especially YG....That BLACK PINK,came from....😊😊😊..
The thing is that you guys make confused is that because all this things YG make it's all have a big production. Yes it is all live but all of that recording pass by the process of studio stuff and production thing before they released the videos. All are live they got the same vocals colors of the studio version and that is confusing many people cuz it has a very high production. Knowing YGE for years they are the company who prioritize live singing and that's the edge of the compyfor many years. The problem today is they make things so high quality that its over shadow the vocals and make you confused if it's real or not.
7:21 That's why they made a distinction between the "Special Stage" and the "Live Stage" version that they put up on YT. The special stage is more like their pseudo-music-show promotion, and therefore the production (audio and visual) were processed or polished. On the other hand, the "live stage" is their effort to bring a live presentation in their desired environment, which means the audio is recorded as it is but with the sound system and equipment optimized to their liking which leads to multiple takes or records of that live performance before the final outcome.
That is just my belief tho.
Omg thankyouuu for always spprting them 🫶🏻🥹
Their live vocals are insane
Also visuals
😱😱😱
I really hope they appear on "It's Live" Chanel, because they don't promote on music shows, and I really want to see them perform on stage ❤❤
Yaaas‼️‼️ 💯
Likewise, I wish they showcase on "it's Live "
They definitely sang live, but there's definitely some minor post production stuff going on. The problem is they're so good that some minor post productions are enough to make them sound very close to the recorded version.
That’s how I feel. I know they sang live. But then ruin it with the editing.
The first concert they do is going to be scary. I’m sure they will pull it off. They have the skills. But holy shit that has to be scary.
YG released this bts video right on time to answer yr questions from your last reaction. Lol😂
I know you don't react bts video much, but thanks for your support !!!!!
Our pleasure!
I think this song, this 6 members version, Babymonster can't sing without backtracking because it was designed to let artist sing only main lyrics plus some harmonies, and left some small details be part of backtrack music. For example; at Rora's first sweet part "you lift my feet off of the ground", the higher harmony voices are pre-recorded along with piano sound. If we carefully listening, it's always there in every versions and there was no sign of any member sing along in both live performances.
Anyway, my personal opinion, I believe the 'special stage' and the 'live stage', Babymonster sang live to make these videos for us. They did their best honestly, no matter what YG producers would do for any post-production. I valued their dedication rather than doubted their talents.
Why do you guys still insist that it is recorded. Very strange. If they can have one live stage, why won't they get the girls to sing live again in the other special stage. You meant they get the girls to lipsync for their other live stage. Does that even make sense?
Why not apply MR Removed yourself for all past and future videos and you can hear live from all girl/boy groups less the music (removed).
Thai people has long name and surname. So parents give nickname for them since birth. Canny for chiquita, Prae for Pharita, so behind camera they call each other like that. Lisa real nickname is Pokpak , i guess closed friend and family stiil call lisa like that.
Ahyeon’s spot is right there in the middle. I feel like it’ll be rora, ruka, chiquita, ahyeon, pharita, rami, asa.
chiquita so cutee wow
We all know they can sing. It's just most of the time, post production adds so much effects hence making it sound like a backtrack.
They just sound really good. They're not lip syncing
Yes !!
They're Soo good!!
If yg says its live then its live..THAT COMPANY HATES LIPSYNC😂
what crazy is, sometimes you can't identify, because they sound the same when they are singing live, it is like they eat a CD, that's how good they are.
watch the MR video. it's their live vocal. there is no backtrack.
CHIQUITA Perfect and really sweet voice.
I mean common...4:07 to 4:17 you said "that sounds live" but it was clearly captioned as "with soundtrack for movement check"..if you listen to that carefully you can clearly hear the audio got vocals on it....
the one that is LIVE,they put a LIVE caption on it. And their vocals in this one are very into-your-face and you can hear the audio playing and the voices are not together. This is what in there SPECIAL STAGE..You can clearly hear their live vocals on the special stage video..common listen to that again cause for me its very clear
As I said in your previous reaction, They recorded it LIVE without taking more than one take (obviously cos it's live and you can't say it's live if you take retakes) with "very minimal" post production, like removing eco and increasing vocal audio than instrumental audio, removing unwanted voices... I still don't think that the post production involved "adjusting vocals" of BM members, BM vocals are so good that I really don't think they need any adjustments.
I feel like if you react to their other behind the sense you guys would be able to hear the vocals from them.
The comments are going off 😭 we know BAEMON can sing
3:54 the mic so dope, i want one😂
Right? I want my own!!!
see, you judge them on that live.but yes its live vocal.babymonsters the true vocalists 👏🫵
YG doesn't want to leave the MV feel in his live singing. so people think they are lip syncing
Yg artist they are not using too much auto tune thats why studio ver and live ver like the same
to asa,you can say its already its live why?because it MV her pronunciation for pushing me in. I is hard pronounce, but in live her I is soft like "en" . you can rewind if you hear it clearly
Theyve been sounding like that fools lol
Sir, you are too obsessed with raw stuff whatever that is, Man!!
Hey guys, I'm sorry if I was hard on you in your last video. I understand what you mean and I want to her the same thing but I just don't think that will happen until all 7 are together and have more songs under their belts . Perhaps we will get a "true" live performance after their mini album drops. I'm hopeful. BTW, midnight April 1st is actually 7am in Los Angeles on March 31st. Adjust for your time zone. Thanks for your reaction. Bob
All good!! Can't wait for their I guess Debut?? 🤣🤣🤣😱😱😱
@@WatchingSundays 🙂lol me too.
Is it live now? Or not?
All performances are absolutely 100% live without any kind of post-production.
BabyMonster does NOT need it......
They definitely recorded it live.
What you see in this sounds nothing like what they put out. 100% they are singing live. But it’s not what we got in the video. It’s heavily edited. Just compare this to the original vid.
Same as them. I love babymonster. We all know they can sing. But if you want to say something is live make it 100% live. No editing.
@@chrisdef15 🤦♀
A very well articulated argument. Good job.
@@chrisdef15Nobody.... Absolutely Nobody nowadays do the "Special Stage" completely LIVE WITHOUT EDITING so expecting this ONLY from BM is unfair, but yes They recorded it live with "very minimal" post production like removing eco and increasing vocal audio than instrumentals... They didn't "took multiple takes" while recording so you can't say it wasn't LIVE
Both of you say its amazing,but, you're opinion, doesn't feel the same...lmao😂😂😂
Of course, music video audio is a studio version lmao. What the heck are you guys saying??? It's live singing. Period.
You guys sound like trying so hard to find a flaw and seems can't accept that Babymonster sounds so good whether it's live or not.
Pay attention to what we're saying 🤣 This was definitely recorded live. Is it a live performance? No. We will love and support them no matter what.
@watchingSundays at 07:30 you said. And of course, it recorded live because it is not live streaming?? I hope that before you guys try so hard to prove whether they are singing live or not, they are from YG. No lipsync rule. You guys should have known that if you guys are kpop fans. And just please enjoy the music without trying so hard to be a critic.
@@acidpainter111 " YG does a lot of lipsync" 🤣🤣You have no idea what you're talking about...🤦♀
@@Koe_Haru 🤣👏👍
@@acidpainter111 I think this song, this 6 members version, Babymonster can't sing without backtracking because it was designed to let artist sing only main lyrics plus some harmonies, and left some small details be part of backtrack music. For example at Rora's first sweet part "you lift my feet off of the ground", the higher harmony voices are pre-recorded along with piano sound. If we carefully listening, noticing, it's always there in every versions.
Anyway, my personal opinion, I believe the 'special stage' and the 'live stage', Babymonster sang live to make these videos for us. They did their best honestly, no matter what YG producers would do for any post-production. I valued their dedication rather than doubted their talents.
🤍💖
You guys are truly deaf. Music video for Special Stage is exactly the same as the making of the Special Stage.
Rora playing piano???oww..why they didn't show that
Deaf for sure. It is the same. No backtrack. It is live adlibs and Rami harmonising in support. Deaf deaf. You guys are irritating.
Reaction nmixx JYPN performance.. their pradebut content.
the special stage was lip synced. The live stage version wasn't, but the vocals were overproduced. end of discussion. The key proof is the body language, people, dont act dumb.
NEXT REACTION GFRIEND!!!
are you a filipino?