You totally should be an Academy voter. You're thoughtful and consistent in your analysis, even when I disagree. Can't wait to see how many you got right!
@@mel4975The Academy creams their jeans whenever black, feminist, or LGBTQ themes are the central focus. I guarantee you if Toni Collette had given the EXACT same performance in "Hereditary" playing a mother whose gay child was a victim of a hate crime or who had to fight against a misogynistic cult she would've gotten a nomination.
Naomi Scott blew me away. I thought her performance absolutely should be recognized. It’s a sin that horror film performances aren’t celebrated. I will never get over Tony Colette - Hereditary and even Florence Pugh -midsommar not being nominated for those performances.
Naomi carried that movie more than the actress who embodied "Rose " in the original...The first film was all over the place...2 is a heavily centered story, eerily dipping between mind and reality
I still say Florence got in for Little Women as a consolatory way of saying “here, you did phenomenally but we can’t nominate horror cause we’re not cool enough” 😂
It's because none of these movies had anything to do with black people being oppressed, gay people being oppressed, or women being oppressed. It's honestly that simple. That's what the academy is obsessed with nowadays. If you want your horror film to get anywhere close to Best Picture it HAS to have a glaring political message like in "Get Out" and "The Substance".
Naomi Scott in Smile 2 is so phenomenal! I think it’s one of the best lead performances in a horror film ever, the same level as Toni Collette in Hereditary.
The Demi Moore mirror scene was heartbreaking. Surrounded with all the horror in this movie it was that moment of self imposed disgust that was the most horrific. Cinema and acting at its finest.
I wholeheartedly agree with you on Naomi Scott. She acted the hell out of that movie. It's probably the best performance in a horror movie since Toni Collette in Hereditary.
Naomi Scott was exceptional in Smile 2. She has joined the all time horror movie performances for me and I guarantee you if she gave that exact same performance in a drama, she would be almost certainly a lock to get nominated for Best Actress.
Absolutely blown away by Naomi Scott!! Genuinely, that level of acting takes an insane amount of skill. Still in shock from her performance. Will be a shame if she doesn’t get even just a nomination!
Thank you for appropriately assessing Bill Skarsgard's performance. Just off degree of difficulty and his character's impact on the film, he should be a far bigger player in this award season.
How is it possible that your preferred nominations are so much better (in my opinion) than what will actually be nominated?! 😅 love this video - great analysis of each performance! Couldn't agree more - especially when it comes to Monica and Naomi ❤
I agree with all of these! I also think Lily Rose Depp and Willa Fitzgerald aren't getting talked about enough for their amazing performances in Nosferatu and Strange Darling respectively, as well as George Mackay's supporting performance in Femme
This is why I watch you--your impeccable taste! When I saw Smile 2, Naomi Scott's performance blew me away. It competes with top performances this year, for sure! Thank you for bringing more attention to her performance.
You know it's a big year for female actresses when Nicole Kidman is in her best acted film of her career and isn't going to even get nominated. 😐 If I was nominating: Nicole Kidman - Babygirl Demi Moore - The Substance Fernanda Torres - I Am Still Here Pamela Anderson - The Last Showgirl Amy Adams - Nightbitch
You know what, Brian? I wouldn't rule out Saoirse Ronan for a nomination at all. Sure, she didn't get in anywhere expect at Bafta but the Academy obviously loves her judging from her past nominations. Also, if the votes are split between Jolie, Kidman, Torres and Anderson, some voters may think ' you know, let's give the nod to Ronan for her amazing job in The Outrun' at the end of the day. And there is the precedent with Javier Bardem from 2011. He only got the Bafta nod and then he was still nominated for the Oscar for Biutiful. So it happens occasionally:) Go, Saoirse!
Ralph Fiennes absolutely should be nominated. I can't take Best Actor seriously without him. Brian is letting his meh reaction to "Conclave" influence him here.
Big yes for Naomi Scott! Wow, what a powerhouse performance. With the exception of the opening scene, she was pretty much in every frame of the movie. But like you said, not only does she have horror bias working against her, but sequel bias. Another similarly intense horror performance that should have been recognized by Oscar a few years back was Samara Weaving in Ready or Not. Both Naomi and Samara had to pitch their performances at an 11 for pretty much the entire runtime of their films...no easy feat.
Here's mine for a few of the top categories: Best supporting actor: Kieran Culkin- A Real Pain Guy Pierce- The Brutalist Harris Dickinson- Babygirl Clarence Maclin- Sing Sing Josh O'Connor- Challengers Best Supporting Actress: Felicity Jones - The Brutalist Monica Barbaro - A Complete Unknown Danielle Deadwyler - The Piano Lesson Ariana Grande -Wicked Carrie Coon (yes! So excited you are talking about this movie, it's in my top 5 and she's my favorite out of three great performances in His Three Daughters). Qualley is my #6 Best Actor: Adrian Brody- The Brutalist Timothee Chalemet- A Complete Unknown Colman Domingo- Sing Sing Daniel Craig- Queer Hugh Grant- Heretic But I'd also love it if one of the two leads from Nickel Boys could show up, they were both phenomenal Best Actress: Demi Moore - The Substance Saoirse Ronan- The Outrun (again, so glad to hear you mention this! This is one of my top 10 films and no one is talking about it. That performance was the movie). Mikey Madison- Anora Nikiya Adams- Bird Nicole Kidman- Babygirl Cynthia Erivo is my #6 Best Picture: The Brutalist A Complete Unknown His Three Daughters Sing Sing Nickel Boys Challengers Wicked Anora A Real Pain Babygirl (The Substance is my #11)
There were so many great lead actress performances in horror this year!! I’m incredibly happy Demi Moore is getting the attention she deserves for the Substance, I agree with you that Naomi Scott was impressive in Smile 2, and I really wish Lily Rose Depp was getting more praise for Nosferatu she was incredible!!
I'm totally with you on Jesse Plemmons for Civil War. He waltzed in and gave an incredibly memorable performance in about 5m. I just didn't see that same impact from Rossellini. It's crazy.
Great video, Brian! I really love all your videos! I think a really fun video for you to do would be your pics for nominations for the Razzi Awards, which i believe come out the day before the Oscar nominations..
Yay! The first comment! Discovered you a couple of months ago and now I watch you religiously!!! Love your videos!! Keep them coming! Justice for Saoirse! Sending thanks and love from the UK!
I’m interested how you made a big stink about Saldaña going supporting when she’s really a co-lead, but have no problem pushing Qualley for supporting when she too is definitely co-lead.
I was about to say that I couldn't agree more, but leaving Torres out of the list for best actress is unacceptable to me. I would easely replace either Kidman or Ronan by her.
I would say that both Babygirl and The Substance are pretty strong on both the premise and the directorial execution of that premise. However, I think that both scripts have some clear flaws (the first suffering from lack of development and the second overstaying its welcome).
My picks as an Academy member Actress: Mikey Madison, Daisy Ridely (Young woman and the sea), Demi Moore, Nicloe Kidman, and Cynthia Erivo Actor: Adrien Brody, Timothée Chalamet, Hugh Grant, Ralph Fiennes, and Sebastian Stan (A different man) Director: Denis Villeneuve, Sean Baker, Brady Corbet, Coralie Fargeat, and James Mangold Original Screenplay: Sean Baker, Brady Corbet, Coralie Fargeat Adapted Screenplay: Peter Straughan, Denis Villeneuve, James Mangold Picture: Anora, The Brutalist, Dune Part 2, A Complete Unknown, The Substance, Conclave, Wicked, The Wild Robot
I just watched “A real pain” and I totally agree that Kieran is the lead actor, even more than Jesse. He’s incredible but he’s not by any means supporting.
Anora was a film I didn't like at all but I can't deny the amazing performances from both Mark Eidelstein and Karren Karagulian and I'm shocked they're not getting as much attention because they were the true stand out performances for me in that film
I think that The Brutalist is remarkable. Definitely best film, best actor, best director and best cinematographer. Some of those scenes - perhaps especially in the marble quarry- are just so hauntingly beautiful ❤
I don't think agree with Eydelstein instead of Borisov. Eydelstein has the flashier performance but he never has to show emotional depth, Borisov shows several kinds of emotions, he looks like the typical henchman but he acts so much with his eyes and with his delivery. I compare his performance to Casey Affleck's in Manchester by the sea, that was very subtle as well.
I wish more awards voters and critics would be like you -- make picks based on what impressed them the most, instead of basing their decisions on they think others would choose. The awards season would be so much more exciting and more films/performances would get a chance to share the wealth, if we could just do away with this mob-thinking mentality.
When I saw “The Substance” in the theater last year, two people walked out when Elizabeth (Demi Moore) was putting her makeup on and off. I guess they must of thought that that scene was ridiculous. I enjoyed the movie overall, and everyone else stayed until the film ended.
Really enjoyed this video! I’m curious if you have an opinion about the use of AI in the brutalist and whether that would hurt its odds at the Oscar’s?
Why not Conclave as Best Adapted Screenplay? Not the most exciting film of the year, but one category where this successful, Oscar-friendly film could be acknowledged.
Yassss you should be! I don’t look forward to the day when I run out of your videos to binge, learning SO much about great cinema through the lens of the Oscars and your analysis! 👏🏼
I don’t always agree with you, but I always appreciate the depth of your analysis and your explanations for your choices. You’ve done the film season of 2024 very proud.
A Real Pain snubbed but not A Complete Unknown is really surprising but I think original screenplay is really passionate for you and it shows by your choices. Monica Barbero was in Top Gun Maverick so she’s slowly coming up but this was another step in the right direction for her.
I never really thought that deep about it but Kieran Culkin probably should be up for lead actor in A Real Pain and not Supporting. But also shouldn't Hugh Grant be a Supporting actor for Heretic
Speaking of horror at the Oscars, I’d like to give my two cents with that. I was glad David Dastmalchian won at Fangoria in 2024 (I voted for him!). In an ideal world, I’d nominate him for a Best Actor in a Leading Role Academy Award because he WAS Jack Delroy in Late Night With the Devil. I couldn’t imagine anyone else in that role. I like old TV and I think he was really believable as a ‘70s talk show host. Not only that, but he consistently nails emotion. It never seems like he’s acting, he’s just there existing in those cinematic worlds. The passion is never lost. Dastmalchian is more known as a character actor in secondary roles, but he absolutely nailed his mainstream leading role in Late Night and gave, in my eyes, what is one of the greatest modern horror performances.
how were you not blown away by Cynthia Erivo in Wicked? I am surprised she isn't getting more love for this performance. ( I do understand maybe people are waiting for part two .. but still)
Was Red Rocket on your Oscar ballot back in 2019 ? That was Sean Bakers last film and I think that film is super underrated. It’s hard not to root for Sean Baker because you can tell he loves what he does and he’s not doing it for fame and none of his films have a big budget or any big actor minus Willem Dafoe in The Florida Project but man does he cast for perfection. He tells these original realistic stories that you can see actually happening and none are boring. He takes simple stories and makes them super entertaining.
My best actress pics would be Naomi Scott smile 2 Cynthia erivo wicked Fernanda Torres im still here Demi Moore the substance Pamela Anderson the last showgirl
I agree about Saoirse Ronan. She is a brilliant actress. I can not believe she has been forgotten. Months ago everyone was talking about her performance. She should have won an Oscar by now.
I don't really get why Paramount did not campaign Naomi Scott in Smile 2, she could've been a dark horse this season, they put all their cards in Gladiator II and not even performing well 😂 but I'm glad she won in the ASTRAs for Best Performance in a Horror/Thriller ❤️
Perhaps they should have named the movie "Smiles"...with the title "Smile 2", that movie was already relegated to the generic horror movie bin on the awards circuit people's minds.
Brian Brian!! Thank you for recognizing Bill Skarsgard in my favorite movie of the year "Nosferatu." Such an amazing performance. And Naomi Scott!! Why has she not been in the conversation?! She was terrific!
You totally should be an Academy voter. You're thoughtful and consistent in your analysis, even when I disagree. Can't wait to see how many you got right!
Yes!
Thank you for not giving Emilia Perez any attention.
So crazy how many awards it’s won so far
@@mel4975The Academy creams their jeans whenever black, feminist, or LGBTQ themes are the central focus. I guarantee you if Toni Collette had given the EXACT same performance in "Hereditary" playing a mother whose gay child was a victim of a hate crime or who had to fight against a misogynistic cult she would've gotten a nomination.
20:55
best actor
15:35
best supporting actress
2:24 adapted screenp play
5:47 original screenplay
11:13 supporting actor
21:22 best actress
Naomi Scott blew me away. I thought her performance absolutely should be recognized. It’s a sin that horror film performances aren’t celebrated. I will never get over Tony Colette - Hereditary and even Florence Pugh -midsommar not being nominated for those performances.
Naomi carried that movie more than the actress who embodied "Rose " in the original...The first film was all over the place...2 is a heavily centered story, eerily dipping between mind and reality
Toni Collette's omission was a TRAGEDY.
I still say Florence got in for Little Women as a consolatory way of saying “here, you did phenomenally but we can’t nominate horror cause we’re not cool enough” 😂
And Lupita for US!! HOW?
It's because none of these movies had anything to do with black people being oppressed, gay people being oppressed, or women being oppressed. It's honestly that simple. That's what the academy is obsessed with nowadays. If you want your horror film to get anywhere close to Best Picture it HAS to have a glaring political message like in "Get Out" and "The Substance".
Josh O'Connor to me was spectacular in challengers! his evil smirk would've gotten him an Oscar nomination in my book
Absolutely he deserves the nomination.
He deserved nominations for God’s country, and La chimera as well
Hats off to Josh. I'm very impressed with his work.
Naomi Scott in Smile 2 is so phenomenal! I think it’s one of the best lead performances in a horror film ever, the same level as Toni Collette in Hereditary.
Yes
Not even close
I agree. I'd also like to do a shout out to Vera Farmiga for Orphan
@@agungs8564yes it is
Close enough, welcome back Roger Ebert
To who’s Gene Siskel?
My husband asked me yesterday if Brian was the new Roger Ebert!
Can we not do this?
The Demi Moore mirror scene was heartbreaking. Surrounded with all the horror in this movie it was that moment of self imposed disgust that was the most horrific. Cinema and acting at its finest.
Rooting for Demi Moore.
That scene might just win her the Oscar 🏆🎉
I wholeheartedly agree with you on Naomi Scott. She acted the hell out of that movie. It's probably the best performance in a horror movie since Toni Collette in Hereditary.
Yes
Naomi Scott was exceptional in Smile 2. She has joined the all time horror movie performances for me and I guarantee you if she gave that exact same performance in a drama, she would be almost certainly a lock to get nominated for Best Actress.
Plus she did EVERYTHING in that role. A great acting performance and she also sings and dances like a REAL popstar.
Absolutely blown away by Naomi Scott!! Genuinely, that level of acting takes an insane amount of skill. Still in shock from her performance. Will be a shame if she doesn’t get even just a nomination!
i was absolutely blown away by naomi scott
I'm blown away by people overrating such a mid performance in a absolutely ass movie
@MrBarborosa bro u need to drink some voss water and chill tf out
@@MrBarborosa you are a mid existence and nobody is calling you out for it, babe
Maravilloso!
No Emilia Pérez
Yes, The substance!
Yes, The brutalist!
Yes, Colman Domingo!
Yes, Hugh Grant!
Thank you for appropriately assessing Bill Skarsgard's performance. Just off degree of difficulty and his character's impact on the film, he should be a far bigger player in this award season.
100
Finally! Someone recognized Naomi Scottʼs unnerving performance!
God I hope Demi gets nominated it would wipe away some huge mistakes that the academy did in the past. Fingers freaking crossed
Fernanda Torres is the best actress of 2024
😂😂
@ 🥴🤪 What’s funny? Talking yeast infection. 😆
@@Heroliesinyou shut up bitch
i totally agree... these gay snubs actresses in foreign language films
We don't need to put people down to lift Fernanda up!😊
How is it possible that your preferred nominations are so much better (in my opinion) than what will actually be nominated?! 😅 love this video - great analysis of each performance! Couldn't agree more - especially when it comes to Monica and Naomi ❤
I absolutely agree with Naomi Scott. She is nominated for a Saturn award an Astra Award. Gosh what a performance.
Josh O'Connor has been so snubbed in this award season. He was fantastic in both Challengers and La Chimera.
I agree with all of these! I also think Lily Rose Depp and Willa Fitzgerald aren't getting talked about enough for their amazing performances in Nosferatu and Strange Darling respectively, as well as George Mackay's supporting performance in Femme
I thing Fernanda Torres in I'm Still Here, the best and most sofisticated female performance in this year
i would also argue that lily rose depp's performance in nosferatu was award worthy as well. she really blew me away
Bill Skarsgard's phenomenal performance in NOSFERATU deserves an Oscar nomination.
he was phenomenal
This is why I watch you--your impeccable taste! When I saw Smile 2, Naomi Scott's performance blew me away. It competes with top performances this year, for sure! Thank you for bringing more attention to her performance.
Jesse Plemons 1000% deserves an nomination for Civil War. His performance transformed a good movie into a great movie. Truly chilling.
You know it's a big year for female actresses when Nicole Kidman is in her best acted film of her career and isn't going to even get nominated. 😐
If I was nominating:
Nicole Kidman - Babygirl
Demi Moore - The Substance
Fernanda Torres - I Am Still Here
Pamela Anderson - The Last Showgirl
Amy Adams - Nightbitch
No Mikey Madison or Marianne Jean-Baptiste ?
I’d go with Demi, Nicole, Marianne, Fernanda and Pamela
Anderson only
@@erwan3204Put those two lists together….Perfect.
So there needs to be seven nominees for Best Actress
You know what, Brian? I wouldn't rule out Saoirse Ronan for a nomination at all. Sure, she didn't get in anywhere expect at Bafta but the Academy obviously loves her judging from her past nominations. Also, if the votes are split between Jolie, Kidman, Torres and Anderson, some voters may think ' you know, let's give the nod to Ronan for her amazing job in The Outrun' at the end of the day. And there is the precedent with Javier Bardem from 2011. He only got the Bafta nod and then he was still nominated for the Oscar for Biutiful. So it happens occasionally:) Go, Saoirse!
Great picks, but Ralph Fiennes should absolutely be nominated as best actor. His performance is so subtle, powerful and meaningful.
Yes! I truly hope he's gonna win.
Ralph Fiennes absolutely should be nominated. I can't take Best Actor seriously without him. Brian is letting his meh reaction to "Conclave" influence him here.
Ralph is the best actor of the others
1:10 I'm Still Here for Adapted Screenplay
Big yes for Naomi Scott! Wow, what a powerhouse performance. With the exception of the opening scene, she was pretty much in every frame of the movie. But like you said, not only does she have horror bias working against her, but sequel bias. Another similarly intense horror performance that should have been recognized by Oscar a few years back was Samara Weaving in Ready or Not. Both Naomi and Samara had to pitch their performances at an 11 for pretty much the entire runtime of their films...no easy feat.
I absolutely agree about mark from Anora. I don’t understand why he hasn’t gotten any recognition, he was so magnetic
2024 was such a great year for female performances and characters
just saw the room next door, both leading actresses were amazing
This is how it should be. No Emilia Pérez anywhere
One Dominican, One Mexican and a trans woman?!!! Scary!!!!
Awesome video!!! Love this idea and great picks as well!
Conclave should be in best adapted screen play
Naomy Scott was amazing on Smile, did not she was that a great at acting, very raw and beautiful performance
'Conclave' for best adapted screenplay.
Absolutely!!! One of the best films I’ve seen in many years.
Here's mine for a few of the top categories:
Best supporting actor:
Kieran Culkin- A Real Pain
Guy Pierce- The Brutalist
Harris Dickinson- Babygirl
Clarence Maclin- Sing Sing
Josh O'Connor- Challengers
Best Supporting Actress:
Felicity Jones - The Brutalist
Monica Barbaro - A Complete Unknown
Danielle Deadwyler - The Piano Lesson
Ariana Grande -Wicked
Carrie Coon (yes! So excited you are talking about this movie, it's in my top 5 and she's my favorite out of three great performances in His Three Daughters).
Qualley is my #6
Best Actor:
Adrian Brody- The Brutalist
Timothee Chalemet- A Complete Unknown
Colman Domingo- Sing Sing
Daniel Craig- Queer
Hugh Grant- Heretic
But I'd also love it if one of the two leads from Nickel Boys could show up, they were both phenomenal
Best Actress:
Demi Moore - The Substance
Saoirse Ronan- The Outrun (again, so glad to hear you mention this! This is one of my top 10 films and no one is talking about it. That performance was the movie).
Mikey Madison- Anora
Nikiya Adams- Bird
Nicole Kidman- Babygirl
Cynthia Erivo is my #6
Best Picture:
The Brutalist
A Complete Unknown
His Three Daughters
Sing Sing
Nickel Boys
Challengers
Wicked
Anora
A Real Pain
Babygirl
(The Substance is my #11)
There were so many great lead actress performances in horror this year!! I’m incredibly happy Demi Moore is getting the attention she deserves for the Substance, I agree with you that Naomi Scott was impressive in Smile 2, and I really wish Lily Rose Depp was getting more praise for Nosferatu she was incredible!!
I'm totally with you on Jesse Plemmons for Civil War. He waltzed in and gave an incredibly memorable performance in about 5m. I just didn't see that same impact from Rossellini. It's crazy.
Great video, Brian!
I really love all your videos!
I think a really fun video for you to do would be your pics for nominations for the Razzi Awards, which i believe come out the day before the Oscar nominations..
Just love your list ❤ Nicole Kidman and Saoirse Ranon are my favorite performances by the way
Conclave was not my favorite movie of the year, but I gotta say omitting Fiennes from the best actor category is a crime.
so glad to hear a fellow film fan addressing your personal faves instead of what the awards industry say
Yay! The first comment! Discovered you a couple of months ago and now I watch you religiously!!!
Love your videos!! Keep them coming! Justice for Saoirse!
Sending thanks and love from the UK!
I’m interested how you made a big stink about Saldaña going supporting when she’s really a co-lead, but have no problem pushing Qualley for supporting when she too is definitely co-lead.
I don’t know why people aren’t considering Angelina Jolie in Maria. I thought she was amazing and most definitely Oscar worthy in that film.
I was about to say that I couldn't agree more, but leaving Torres out of the list for best actress is unacceptable to me. I would easely replace either Kidman or Ronan by her.
I would say that both Babygirl and The Substance are pretty strong on both the premise and the directorial execution of that premise. However, I think that both scripts have some clear flaws (the first suffering from lack of development and the second overstaying its welcome).
Interesting choices! Good job
My picks as an Academy member
Actress: Mikey Madison, Daisy Ridely (Young woman and the sea), Demi Moore, Nicloe Kidman, and Cynthia Erivo
Actor: Adrien Brody, Timothée Chalamet, Hugh Grant, Ralph Fiennes, and Sebastian Stan (A different man)
Director: Denis Villeneuve, Sean Baker, Brady Corbet, Coralie Fargeat, and James Mangold
Original Screenplay: Sean Baker, Brady Corbet, Coralie Fargeat
Adapted Screenplay: Peter Straughan, Denis Villeneuve, James Mangold
Picture: Anora, The Brutalist, Dune Part 2, A Complete Unknown, The Substance, Conclave, Wicked, The Wild Robot
Naomi Scott: HELL YES!!! She so deserves more recognition for that performance.
Denis getting absolutely snubbed here too..
I just watched “A real pain” and I totally agree that Kieran is the lead actor, even more than Jesse. He’s incredible but he’s not by any means supporting.
Thank you. So good to hear. I would love to hear your thoughts on the detailed "whys" of what makes a good screenplay.
Anora was a film I didn't like at all but I can't deny the amazing performances from both Mark Eidelstein and Karren Karagulian and I'm shocked they're not getting as much attention because they were the true stand out performances for me in that film
I did love Naomi Scott but it's baffling to me that Lily-Rose Depp is being left off all best actress lists this season 😥
I think that The Brutalist is remarkable. Definitely best film, best actor, best director and best cinematographer. Some of those scenes - perhaps especially in the marble quarry- are just so hauntingly beautiful ❤
I don't think agree with Eydelstein instead of Borisov. Eydelstein has the flashier performance but he never has to show emotional depth, Borisov shows several kinds of emotions, he looks like the typical henchman but he acts so much with his eyes and with his delivery. I compare his performance to Casey Affleck's in Manchester by the sea, that was very subtle as well.
Exactly. It's much easier to do what Eydelstein does than pull off the internal emotional performance of Borisov.
Strongly agree.
I wish more awards voters and critics would be like you -- make picks based on what impressed them the most, instead of basing their decisions on they think others would choose. The awards season would be so much more exciting and more films/performances would get a chance to share the wealth, if we could just do away with this mob-thinking mentality.
When I saw “The Substance” in the theater last year, two people walked out when Elizabeth (Demi Moore) was putting her makeup on and off. I guess they must of thought that that scene was ridiculous. I enjoyed the movie overall, and everyone else stayed until the film ended.
were they older? the scene may have hit too close to home and pushed them over the edge. maybe they left to avoid having a nervous breakdown?
I would love for you to do a most anticipated films coming out in 2025 vid. I’m very curious to see your picks. ❤
Really enjoyed this video! I’m curious if you have an opinion about the use of AI in the brutalist and whether that would hurt its odds at the Oscar’s?
Why not Conclave as Best Adapted Screenplay? Not the most exciting film of the year, but one category where this successful, Oscar-friendly film could be acknowledged.
Great list although id take Edward Norton as Pete Seeger for best supporting actor!
kudos for the shout out for Naomi Scott. Horror always gets overlooked. sigh
Yassss you should be! I don’t look forward to the day when I run out of your videos to binge, learning SO much about great cinema through the lens of the Oscars and your analysis! 👏🏼
I don’t always agree with you, but I always appreciate the depth of your analysis and your explanations for your choices. You’ve done the film season of 2024 very proud.
Sebastian Stan in A Different Man is leaps and bounds better than most of your picks for lead Actor.
I completely agree with you, Bill Skarsgård in Nosferatu was so damn good. The things he did with his voice, phenomenal.
I prefer your picks than the ones showing at awards season. Love your love toward babygirl and challengers.
Yes to Josh O’Connor! He should’ve been nominated for God’s Own Country.
How on earth does Edward Norton not get a nod as Pete Seeger?
Yeah. How? Ed gave the best performance in "A Complete Unknown." He sank into being Pete Seeger.
yes yes yes on naomi scott!!
Civil War has been severely overlooked,esp the performances of the whole cast but Spaney and Plemons especially.
sorry but you saying ‘the wild robotS’ when it’s ‘the wild robot’ drove me a little crazy LOL
So creative, love the idea of this video!
I thought Scott was phenomenal in Smile 2
A Real Pain snubbed but not A Complete Unknown is really surprising but I think original screenplay is really passionate for you and it shows by your choices.
Monica Barbero was in Top Gun Maverick so she’s slowly coming up but this was another step in the right direction for her.
I never really thought that deep about it but Kieran Culkin probably should be up for lead actor in A Real Pain and not Supporting. But also shouldn't Hugh Grant be a Supporting actor for Heretic
Speaking of horror at the Oscars, I’d like to give my two cents with that. I was glad David Dastmalchian won at Fangoria in 2024 (I voted for him!). In an ideal world, I’d nominate him for a Best Actor in a Leading Role Academy Award because he WAS Jack Delroy in Late Night With the Devil. I couldn’t imagine anyone else in that role. I like old TV and I think he was really believable as a ‘70s talk show host. Not only that, but he consistently nails emotion. It never seems like he’s acting, he’s just there existing in those cinematic worlds. The passion is never lost. Dastmalchian is more known as a character actor in secondary roles, but he absolutely nailed his mainstream leading role in Late Night and gave, in my eyes, what is one of the greatest modern horror performances.
WHAT?!
Now Brian I really really enjoy your vids man but Ignoring Denzel Washington, Ralph Fiennes, Karla Sofia Gascon AND ZOE SALDAÑA(!) is insane
I wouldn't have included Denzel
He pretty much played his Training Day character
I think after BAFTA noms, Sing Sing is getting a little bit pushed back into the conversation. I’m confident it will be in the 10 for picture.
@@LoganPritchett-se5ny I hope so. I loved that movie. It's in my top 5.
The much needed rerelease will boost public awareness/chatter
Oscar's rarely do the right thing
how were you not blown away by Cynthia Erivo in Wicked? I am surprised she isn't getting more love for this performance. ( I do understand maybe people are waiting for part two .. but still)
For me, she was just ok,
Fun fact: the screenplay from I'm Still Here was adapted from a book written by the son of the family being portrayed
Was Red Rocket on your Oscar ballot back in 2019 ? That was Sean Bakers last film and I think that film is super underrated. It’s hard not to root for Sean Baker because you can tell he loves what he does and he’s not doing it for fame and none of his films have a big budget or any big actor minus Willem Dafoe in The Florida Project but man does he cast for perfection. He tells these original realistic stories that you can see actually happening and none are boring. He takes simple stories and makes them super entertaining.
My best actress pics would be
Naomi Scott smile 2
Cynthia erivo wicked
Fernanda Torres im still here
Demi Moore the substance
Pamela Anderson the last showgirl
I agree about Saoirse Ronan. She is a brilliant actress. I can not believe she has been forgotten. Months ago everyone was talking about her performance. She should have won an Oscar by now.
I definitely pick Demi Moore& Glen Powell for Hit Man but the movie I’d really like to see nominated is Don’t Move and Aubrey Asbele as best actress
Smile 2💜 The Substance ❤️ Wicked 🩷💚 Hard Truths 🖤The Outrun🩵
These supporting actor picks are so spot on.
I watched A Real Pain and I think it is great movie! Like you, I think that Kieran McKulkins performance is Oscar worthy!
To me Josh O’ Conner is in a leading role but he did do great
Doing Challengers justice here!!!
I don't really get why Paramount did not campaign Naomi Scott in Smile 2, she could've been a dark horse this season, they put all their cards in Gladiator II and not even performing well 😂 but I'm glad she won in the ASTRAs for Best Performance in a Horror/Thriller ❤️
Perhaps they should have named the movie "Smiles"...with the title "Smile 2", that movie was already relegated to the generic horror movie bin on the awards circuit people's minds.
Hugh Grant is on another level in Heretic
Brian Brian!! Thank you for recognizing Bill Skarsgard in my favorite movie of the year "Nosferatu." Such an amazing performance. And Naomi Scott!! Why has she not been in the conversation?! She was terrific!