Not every landing is a greaser - especially in the Piper Comanche - Bouncy Bounce at Gulf Shore KJKA

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
  • Hold it off! Good illustration of what happens when you land flat and nose wheel first. A bit of bounce, bounce, baby until the laminar flow wing decides it's done. If the bounce had been any higher or there was strong side drift and prompt go-around would be warranted!
    About the aircraft: 1959 Piper Comanche with 250hp Lycoming engine and 3 blade McCauley propeller.
    How we make these videos (affiliate links):
    - GoPro Hero12 Cameras (amzn.to/45Wj1Kr)
    - Nflightcam Audio Cable (amzn.to/4615t05)
    - MyPilotPro Swivel Mount (amzn.to/4bD1cRy)
    - MyPilotPro Airplane Mount (amzn.to/45XHzmi)
    - Neewer ND Filters (amzn.to/3XYKs4q)
    - 512GB U3 MicroSD (amzn.to/3XXHPQ5)

КОМЕНТАРІ • 24

  • @Krisandnatdex
    @Krisandnatdex 3 місяці тому

    I started using only 2 notches of flaps landing my Comanche. 85MPH over the fence and sets on the ground much better. With 3 notches I need to be much slower for it to flare properly to not risk the nosewheel touching first. Only 2 notches was a game changer for me! Love the Comanche and love your videos, thanks for sharing!

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  3 місяці тому +1

      Thanks! Love the Comanche too! After making this video my father also suggested trying 2/3rds flaps for most landings and as you said a much easier to get a good flare and not a huge impact on roll out. Adjusting full flap speed based on landing weight has also helped a lot.

  • @MrSmddmd
    @MrSmddmd Місяць тому +1

    Love the video, nice when someone is willing to take the time and post. Comanche is nice plane, my favorite actually. I try and make every landing my best, No flap, some or all, it's the same, hold it off about 2 inches until it is stalling, yoke and trim full aft (about) and suddenly you are on the ground.

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  Місяць тому

      Thanks. The Comanche is a challenging one to land consistently

    • @MrSmddmd
      @MrSmddmd Місяць тому +1

      @@planeplaces I know, own a PA30, over 20 yrs, instruct in them

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  Місяць тому

      @@MrSmddmd would love to fly a pa30 some time

    • @MrSmddmd
      @MrSmddmd Місяць тому

      @@planeplaces VAY anytime

    • @MrSmddmd
      @MrSmddmd Місяць тому

      @@planeplaces www.youtube.com/@MrSmddmd

  • @denniscarleton
    @denniscarleton 3 місяці тому +1

    Looks like all of my landings in the Comanche.

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  3 місяці тому

      They've been getting better! Most of the time ... Great airplane.

  • @go737
    @go737 2 місяці тому

    You touched high energy,low speed needed

  • @BritsAbroadTravelCruise
    @BritsAbroadTravelCruise 7 місяців тому +1

    These videos are so watchable. Its our new favourite thing and really glad we discovered your channel.
    We've hit your subscribe button and will be back to enjoy more flights and travel with Dee & Vee 👍

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  7 місяців тому +1

      Thank you so much 🤗

  • @MIKETEIXEIRA
    @MIKETEIXEIRA 6 місяців тому

    Is the camera making mains look like they are cambered in ?

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  6 місяців тому

      Yes, it's a bit of a camera effect

  • @DragonTheGuy_official
    @DragonTheGuy_official 8 місяців тому +1

    A littel bit bouncy landing

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  8 місяців тому

      Yes, hence the title. The nose wheel touches down first which is the main cause and something you try to avoid

    • @DragonTheGuy_official
      @DragonTheGuy_official 8 місяців тому +1

      @@planeplaces maybe u could flare more before u land just a suggetsion

    • @stevel4997
      @stevel4997 8 місяців тому

      @@DragonTheGuy_official He's obviously a newbie.

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  8 місяців тому

      To the Comanche yes

  • @michaelheely
    @michaelheely 5 місяців тому +1

    i am not an expert but i wonder why you drop one stage of flaps short before the threshold. i would do this way earlier and more flaps so i have a constant steady approach and not changing stuff before touchdown. felt a bit like a speedy landing and i wonder why since every knot too much at landing raises the risk of damage and crash. but a nice video and informative as i fly the 250s in flight simulation.

    • @planeplaces
      @planeplaces  4 місяці тому +1

      It's very typical in light planes to have 3 flap settings and add 1/3 at a time on downwind, base, and final. Perhaps counter-intuitively, this allows for a progressive decelleration at a fairly constant power setting and 3 degree glide slope. Comanche 1.3 VSO reference speed for full flap final is 83mph. It was a bit fast at 50' but touchdown was at 70mph. The main issue with this landing was the nose wheel touching first. Being slow in a landing is much more dangerous than being a bit fast - you can always bleed speed in the flair given sufficient runway available. Airspeed gives you margin against wind gusts and a loss of power - as does waiting to add full flaps (and drag) until the landing is fairly assured.

    • @ra2186
      @ra2186 3 місяці тому

      Agreed. Didn't really give the plane any time to settle in the new config.

    • @michaelheely
      @michaelheely 3 місяці тому

      @@planeplaces totally agree with being to slow is way more dangerous. For myself I found it better to have everything setup before threshold and not change the flight behaviour (changing flaps) short before touchdown. But again I talk about flightsim and not real world :) thx for answering :)