Russian Winter Offensive Map [w/ Leaked Docs KIA Estimates]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @warmaps78
    @warmaps78  Рік тому +14

    The video includes frontline updates for every day from the period of nearly 6 months - which on this scale shows hardly any movement at all.
    Casualties are based on a recently leaked document that supposedly reveals the number of KIA losses for both sides - for the period until 1st March 2023. The number does not include wounded/POW.
    Sources are in the description.

  • @Moftheg
    @Moftheg Рік тому +118

    Wow it’s like watching a ww1 battle map, only the death count changes

    • @how_to_be_a_Old_legionary44
      @how_to_be_a_Old_legionary44 Рік тому +6

      yeah. cant image how brutal front are... and i hear that russia have brutal logistic problem so this is hell to russia. and ukrane too. but they win i hope!
      edit bdw you are right. this is close to ww1 just mini version!

    • @МилославВихляев
      @МилославВихляев Рік тому

      Не соответствует действительности. Колличество смертей. Пропаганда запада.

    • @extremaduraballanimations
      @extremaduraballanimations Рік тому +1

      LOL jajaja

    • @Mr.Noob1
      @Mr.Noob1 Рік тому +2

      @@how_to_be_a_Old_legionary44 Not really this mini because the frontline length is roughly the length of the western front and this war hasn't had the chance to develop large trench systems yet due to it only lasting a bit more than a year.

    • @universenerdd
      @universenerdd Рік тому

      @@Mr.Noob1 Are you serious? The war has been lasting since 2014, and especially in the donbas, the trenches are already there

  • @georgelyddane8283
    @georgelyddane8283 Рік тому +43

    so many deaths with so little gain. Prayers to all of those affected by this horrible war may God be with you

  • @Szoszta
    @Szoszta Рік тому +36

    Sorry dude, im a huge fan of your work but you shouldt go in this swamp.
    First, the UA KIA is far too low, the russians have currently an avarage of 8 times of the artillery in the field than the ukrainian counterpart. Even the ua minister said tha they went beyond 300k wounded and passed soldier.
    The russian side number is very low too, they currently over 100k dead and wounded give or take.
    The UA KIA is 4,5 or 3,8 to 1 aganist Russians because of the low medicine, field hospital, and the long hours that take to move the evac vehicle to the front and to take it back to the surgeons.
    Russia is suffering this kind of logistical nightmare too, like they are having problems delivering the 152, and 122mm shells to the firing posittions because the drone attacks and constant ambushes on the supply depos from himars.
    This is just the scratch of the surface. Please dont make more of these videos, i dont want to lose faith in you.

    • @bigcat100and2
      @bigcat100and2 Рік тому +6

      arent those kia ratios from the russian forged version of the leaked american documents?

    • @Szoszta
      @Szoszta Рік тому +1

      @@bigcat100and2 I dont know what forged documents, this was a calculation from several experts that studying the war attrition.

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +11

      This is what happens when you want to animate historic battles and use Google Trends to find out what battles people are looking for. Ukraine ends up being unavoidable. I admit adding casualties from a game theme to real life war is bizzare at the very least, but I wouldn't really be thrilled about just moving the lines across the map.
      Also Russian propagandists spew such nonsense that I found myself wanting to counter it, with "our own" nonsense, for what's it worth.

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +6

      @@bigcat100and2 these numbers are supposedly the original ua-cam.com/video/WBLxQn4GRl8/v-deo.html&ab_channel=WillyOAM

    • @Szoszta
      @Szoszta Рік тому

      @@warmaps78 I know, russobots are retarded, sometimes sadly ukrainians too but there are so many misinformations, atleast those shoudnt play this game who has original and quality content. I mean im just a dude that is typing this shit before sleep, the choice is yours i will follow you anyway. Im just trying to signal a warning that you will get swarmed by idiots pretty fast

  • @zitroneneislaktosefrei7464
    @zitroneneislaktosefrei7464 Рік тому +15

    I can't imagine that Ukrainian casualties are so "low". In Bakhmut alone, both sides are losing hundreds of soldiers every day.

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +3

      Given all odds, would you prefer to be the one defending an entrenched position, or the one attacking it?
      However, even UA supporters recently started stating that current losses ratio in Bakhmut are closer to 1:1 (specifically said by Denys Davydov) and that RU are better organized in their attack in the city currently (from an interview with a UA soldier, link of which I can't find).

    • @ИванБогров-ы3у
      @ИванБогров-ы3у Рік тому +3

      ​@@warmaps78 Это полная ложь, потери Украины в 8 раз больше. У них уже десять мобилизаций прошло, в России одна частичная. Так, что завязывай со своими сказками.

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +1

      @@ИванБогров-ы3у I'll dedicate the next video to you

    • @aq.9947
      @aq.9947 Рік тому +6

      @@ИванБогров-ы3у bro got his source from putin 💀💀💀

    • @ДмитрийЛоза-и4н
      @ДмитрийЛоза-и4н Рік тому

      @@ИванБогров-ы3у ахахаха почему не в 80? Чудище, выключай телевизор. В Украине мобилизация не заканчивается: кто по специальности нужен, того призывают, а не рандомных пузатых чмобиков просто гонят на мясо

  • @Pateriyaki_Knees2207
    @Pateriyaki_Knees2207 Рік тому +19

    for a second i thought that the line wasnt moving

    • @yourname7727
      @yourname7727 Рік тому +2

      Так она и не движется

  • @PadaV4
    @PadaV4 Рік тому +2

    We have gone back in time to WW1 trench warfare, casualties go up, frontline stays static.

  • @cliffh.3279
    @cliffh.3279 Рік тому +18

    “Russian offensive” *lines don’t move*

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +5

      Stalin wouldn't be proud of the offshoot of USSR

    • @Coleusse
      @Coleusse Рік тому

      Yeah seems about right

  • @ИванМашаЕфремовы

    Всё врут

  • @AmIAPacifist
    @AmIAPacifist Рік тому +1

    10/12, most of the songs were pretty easy to guess but Puppe and P*ssy are two songs that I haven't listened to as much as the others and so wasn't able to guess

  • @wolfsturm8896
    @wolfsturm8896 Рік тому +13

    Кто верит в эти цифры? Если даже подумать логически, Россия превосходит в воздухе и выпускает за день в 3 раза больше артиллерийских снарядов. Она в априори не может иметь потери в 3 раза больше

    • @ded-v-vannoy
      @ded-v-vannoy Рік тому +1

      Тут радоваться нужно, если такие циферки в их секретных документах, значит наша контр-разведка работает отлично.

    • @kilowhiskey7973
      @kilowhiskey7973 Рік тому +3

      I believe it. It’s basic logic really. Especially when you pay attention to Russian rotations and U.S. lethal aid.
      Russia is sooo superior to Ukraine and still hasn’t sent a single SU-57. The Russian Federation isn’t flying a lot at this point. Hell, it was like every day on Reddit I would see Russian helicopters and aircraft shot down by the Ukrainians with U.S. weapon systems.
      Also. The point of the HIMAARS package the U.S. sent to Ukraine was to strike Russian artillery positions the moment they would begin firing… and they would do so with pinpoint accuracy.
      I’ve seen a lot more Ukrainian drone usage compared to their adversaries. I could be wrong but I think Ukraines drone operations are more significant in numbers.
      Also. The Ukrainians simply have better gear. From having REAL armor inserts down to the quality of tires on their vehicles. They sound small in scope, but it’s things that have caused more and more Russian fatalities over the course of the war. Ukrainians have amazing gear. They are getting issued the same gear the Russians troops are literally purchasing with their own money… and the preferred equipment in question is American.
      Russian troops want Oakley/Mechanix brand of gloves. I’ve seen the Gucci’d RU troops wear good U.S. and U.K. boot brands. They want Crye/Dri-Fire styled outfits as well. They want multicam. They want the U.S.’s high speed ballistic helmets. Etc etc. They want the good gear that makes them look like a U.S. operator with an AK.
      The Ukrainians are being GIVEN this stuff…

    • @kilowhiskey7973
      @kilowhiskey7973 Рік тому +2

      The numbers are believable because Russia has an extremely poor chain-of-command system that places it’s soldiers in danger because they can’t communicate properly and that’s a large issue coming from the Russians on the ground there.
      History also shows that Russia isn’t all that great at handling casualties. It’s definitely casualty numb in conflicts. Even recent history shows that.

    • @ded-v-vannoy
      @ded-v-vannoy Рік тому

      @@kilowhiskey7973 have you read your own country's secret report? Read it. You'll find a lot of interesting things there. From: the supply of weapons is completely recognized as a failure, to the point that Ukrainians will not be able to defend, let alone attack.

    • @warmaps78
      @warmaps78  Рік тому +6

      ​@@kilowhiskey7973 I'd wager a bet that even the armchair storm troopers from the comments would still prefer to be the ones in the bunker, then the ones charging the bunker. Especially if the bunker is a city.

  • @Phantogram2
    @Phantogram2 Рік тому

    Compared to this, Ukraine's counter-offensive looks very succesful

  • @kindaryekindar8982
    @kindaryekindar8982 Рік тому

    Меня всегда удивляют такие гении, которым всё и вся докладываю и о потерях и тд...

  • @fazilmemmedov2035
    @fazilmemmedov2035 Рік тому +4

    🇦🇿❤️🇺🇦🤗

  • @westEast6476
    @westEast6476 Рік тому +5

    Полный бред

  • @smpipes4103
    @smpipes4103 Рік тому +1

    Madness

  • @Владислав-л4ы7ъ

    При таком соотношении потерь Россиия бы уже давно проиграла.У Украины почти всю войну было превосходство в живой силе.

  • @МИХАИЛБОРОВСКИЙ-и2х

    These casualties must have been reported by Zelensky)))

  • @Podilian_H8H8L
    @Podilian_H8H8L Рік тому

    So rUSSIEN take three villages in winter (fact)

  • @williamparis5303
    @williamparis5303 Рік тому +1

    Sad war is never good

  • @Cl4rkU
    @Cl4rkU 25 днів тому

    Ww2 ahh offensive

  • @herberteduardoperezurquizo5417

    Malditos políticos que no luchan sus guerras , solo mueren inocentes

  • @Frieren_cute_vai_o
    @Frieren_cute_vai_o Рік тому

    i think 2027 russia and ukraine will sign a peace deal and ukraine need to give russia donestk crimea mariupon to join NATO

  • @Пророк11
    @Пророк11 Рік тому +3

    Автор искажает правду, у Украины матерь в 10 раз больше, а у России в 5 раз меньше!

    • @PashaHR21
      @PashaHR21 Рік тому

      😂😂😂🐖🇷🇺

    • @Danput
      @Danput 11 місяців тому

      Откуда такие цифры?)

  • @eVisyaschev
    @eVisyaschev Рік тому +3

    На кого это рассчитано?

  • @TANKWarMapping
    @TANKWarMapping Рік тому

    RIN eighter russian or ukraine

  • @albertososa4080
    @albertososa4080 Рік тому

    Parece falso

  • @naksur2298
    @naksur2298 Рік тому +2

    за этот период только на одном из 6ти направлений под бахмутом всу теряли от 300 до 500 человек ежедневно, получается около 50к, только на одном из направлений за эти 4 месяца

    • @hiki9351
      @hiki9351 Рік тому

      300 єжеднєвно, в Украине такой армии нету