Pixar Theory: Why Were Superheroes In The Incredibles Illegal?: Discovering Disney

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @IsaacCarlson
    @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +230

    Hello! Hope you're having a magical day everyone! Just to let you know if you ever like to send me anything my PO Box is:
    PO Box 31
    Manitowoc, WI 54221
    Thanks for checking out the video! You are awesome!

    • @kkcake5771
      @kkcake5771 7 років тому +2

      thanks wotso videos

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      My pleasure Tara!

    • @kkcake5771
      @kkcake5771 7 років тому +2

      you're welcome

    • @bethany8379
      @bethany8379 7 років тому +1

      Can you PLEASE do a Disney prince week like prince Phillip and the prince of beauty. For the first seven princes. Like you do for princess week. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!!!

    • @mrheroprimes
      @mrheroprimes 7 років тому +3

      the start of The Incredibles is also supposed mirror the end of the golden age of superhero comics.
      Syndrome was a defense contractor for the US government who went rogue?
      its pretty clear throughout the movie that Syndrome is a technical genius. He's developed virtually indestructible robots, jet shoes, and matter-freezers (that blue outline thing no idea what it's actually called.) How did he get the funding for all of these weapons, how did he have access to a private island, and how come nobody seemed to care that superheroes were dying all over the place. The answer is pretty simple, the government hired Syndrome to develop weapons for them.
      it starts out like this, Buddy Pine bring the blue prints Omnidroids v.X1 to a meeting to get founding for the Omnidroids project and he brings up brings up a question of what he can use to test it on and one of the government officials suggest using the supers to test the Omnidroids, citing info given to them from different case workers like Rick who had to pay people to keep things quiet, erase memories and relocate the Parrs, so much that it was getting very exhausting and too expensive for the government. so from the government's perspective who cares of a few supers go missing it saves them some tax dollars, and they no longer have to worry about a super can't Quail his or her damn itch to be hero like they were in the early 1950's.
      the project goes smoothly for a couple years until Omnidroid 5 test's when they asked Simon J. Paladino/Gazerbeam to return and he refused, it's possible that it could have been due to the fact that his campaign to get equal rights for supers may have been picking up steam, so syndrome was forced to have him kidnap. But because Simon J. Paladino was kidnapped it ended up in the Metroville Tribune newspaper, the government then turns around and pulls the plug on the Omnidroid project because Simon J. Paladino was a public figure and government did not want to risk the project getting traced back to them.
      heres a link to the Metroville Tribune newspaper ohmy.disney.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Toy-story-of-terror-trivia-Gazerbeam-civilian-name.jpg
      syndrome then creates Operation Kronosto plaing to use the very weapon he was creating for the government against them.
      what further cements my believe that the government was involved in this plot is Dicker's line "We've frozen all of Syndrome's assets. If he even sneezes, we'll be there with a hanky and a pair of handcuffs. " This was literally seconds after mr incredible and his family along with Frozone, defeated Omnidroid v.10. which means that the government was aware that Syndrome had gone rogue with the weapon and use it for his own self interests, and instead of owning up to their involvement, they let the supers take care of the mess, and blamed this massive weapon project on a crazed Lunatic with delusions of grandeur, and wiped their hands off of this potential PR mess by focusing on the return of superheroes.

  • @haremfanatic1014
    @haremfanatic1014 7 років тому +543

    "Despite in everything you've done for them, eventually they'll hate you."-Green goblin, A tech base human to a exceptional insect super.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +57

      Long live that first Spiderman movie.

    • @creed8712
      @creed8712 6 років тому +5

      Harem Fanatic101 his glider didn’t allow him to take and dodge punches from a guy who regularly dodged bullets and stops trains

    • @giggityking6505
      @giggityking6505 6 років тому +8

      Can you imagine that all those supers went to war with the government and used deadly force to reprise the super relocation act?

    • @Eddiemunson20
      @Eddiemunson20 4 роки тому +2

      Such a very exquisite quote from the green goblin

    • @babaluplays4258
      @babaluplays4258 4 роки тому +5

      THINK ABOUT IT HERO!

  • @gianlucacherubini9034
    @gianlucacherubini9034 7 років тому +311

    The real question is how did the government handled other supers rebelling or current villains

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +71

      Maybe they purchased Syndrome's weapons.... wouldn't that be bad. Thanks for watching!

    • @austinreed7343
      @austinreed7343 5 років тому +10

      Gian Luca Cherubini
      The army and cops gained additional powers to destroy the villains for good in the absence of heroes.

    • @staceytetzlaff2822
      @staceytetzlaff2822 4 роки тому +2

      Who knows.

    • @woofwoof9199
      @woofwoof9199 4 роки тому +3

      because they created the supers and they can create more

    • @TheKing-uu7jn
      @TheKing-uu7jn 3 роки тому +2

      @@IsaacCarlson I see what you did there 😏

  • @varvaraellena9764
    @varvaraellena9764 7 років тому +338

    The train accident drove me crazy too what was the court thinking. it was the supers job to protect how was he supposed to know all of that would occur. I think the people on the train were only wanting money because the guy got alll that money it was a chain reaction of people being blind and greedy.

    • @marii_lilmonsta
      @marii_lilmonsta 6 років тому +11

      titanium _ well said

    • @trappersshadow9751
      @trappersshadow9751 6 років тому +9

      titanium _ honestly my thoughts they probably would not see it that way until something so bad happen that they feel regret for disbanding the supers

    • @granmastersword
      @granmastersword 6 років тому +5

      It's either that or they expected the supers to do it better and were mad that they didn't manage to solve the issue perfectly despite being oblivious of the events

    • @giggityking6505
      @giggityking6505 6 років тому +4

      Can you imagine that all those supers went to war with the government and used deadly force to reprise the super relocation act?

    • @daylenconn282
      @daylenconn282 6 років тому +2

      I think if he made the argument that they would all be dead if he did not stop the train

  • @WeegeeSlayer123
    @WeegeeSlayer123 7 років тому +668

    Too bad the government in the Incredibles isn't like the government in One Punch Man, who seem to not mind having to rebuild entire cities and deal with mass civilian casualties.

    • @Diagonalstuff
      @Diagonalstuff 7 років тому +51

      WeegeeSlayer the hero association isn’t the government they just have lots of rich financial backers.

    • @WeegeeSlayer123
      @WeegeeSlayer123 7 років тому +37

      RyanB 1228 That's still a lot of death and destruction they have to pay for.

    • @ollypa7062
      @ollypa7062 7 років тому +30

      One punch man Theory.The Hero association have only existed in a few years, the same problem my occur in a couple of seasons.

    • @jyoster6447
      @jyoster6447 7 років тому +24

      Ollypa
      That's something that might be taken into account later on. But, it seems that god-like threats are going to be present regardless. So, let's see where it will take us.

    • @kristinabusch5610
      @kristinabusch5610 7 років тому +3

      WeegeeSlayer lol that's so funny! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ParasolMushroomStudios
    @ParasolMushroomStudios 7 років тому +410

    I think this was more of a commentary on how media can turn anybody against anyone. Edna's line about gods was more of her overly eccentric nature seeing the supers as Majestic beings. But this theory was still very good and I enjoyed it!

    • @Gooberwares
      @Gooberwares 7 років тому +5

      Parasol Mushroom Art I agree it’s the media’s job to bring the intensity to world even if it’s total lies

    • @buki3009
      @buki3009 7 років тому +11

      Parasol Mushroom Art i really think that supers were gods , when edna says that she used to make cloth for gods , she is pointing that ancient statu like an old statu of an old friend who was viewed like a gods , and think of it , how people of the stone age or people from the 4th century would call supers ? , plus edna is seemingly also a super , what is her power ? i think it just being immortal (like she stoped aging around her fourthies )

    • @mr.incredible4754
      @mr.incredible4754 6 років тому +3

      Parasol Mushroom Art I can't believe that Oliver Sansweet didn't want to be saved, because of daily pain when he was committing suicide.

  • @devilovesdevil
    @devilovesdevil 7 років тому +371

    I was so angry at the people in the movie they seemed so selfish

    • @guardianknight5417
      @guardianknight5417 7 років тому +9

      Leila Kaufman hmm probably born with them or either genetic alteration

    • @saphiriathebluedragonknight375
      @saphiriathebluedragonknight375 7 років тому +7

      I think it was Supercalvinebrothers who theorized that they got their powers from the government.

    • @misleynacelus9187
      @misleynacelus9187 6 років тому +7

      Cpn. Beartato yeah who sews people for saving his life

    • @granmastersword
      @granmastersword 6 років тому +9

      Misley Nacelus people who only focused on the damaged caused during their fights without understanding the context of their situations

    • @spiderverse_triohill6510
      @spiderverse_triohill6510 5 років тому +18

      Cpn. Beartato for real Mr.Incredible got sued from a man who WANTED to die, but got in even more trouble for saving countless people on a train who DIDN’T want to die

  • @isaacgraff8288
    @isaacgraff8288 7 років тому +155

    All things considering, it makes some sense that some Supers would go Villain. "Look at everything I did for you and THIS is how you repay me?"
    "And who is going to stop me?"

    • @curtisdavis2891
      @curtisdavis2891 7 років тому +8

      Isaac Graff Kind Of Like Megamind!

    • @isaacgraff8288
      @isaacgraff8288 7 років тому +39

      Another theory, what happened to the villains when the Super Hero Relocation act passed. Their main adversary is taken out of the picture and the public expects them to quit because 'its illegal to use powers'? The bad guys will keep being bad guys and the most successful method of stopping them, has been negated by public opinion.
      Who is going to stop them? The police? If the police were enough I don't see Supers rising to the same they did. Were villains behind the SHR act so they can act uncontested?

    • @FiresideBoomer
      @FiresideBoomer 6 років тому +5

      Isaac Graff
      I think it becomes the batman problem
      Batman captures the Joker, the Joker escapes kills a bunch of people, Batman captures Joker, rinse and forever repeat.
      With supers gone human rely on more conventional methods
      Bomb-voyage would have been met with a swat/special forces team that would have just gunned him down, and suddenly Bomb-Voyage never hurts anyone ever again.
      The big orb of death (the robot thing from the first movie) yeah it stopped gunfire, but what about when the airforce starts just airstriking it.
      Plus the government probably kept tabs on all the supers, and when one looked like they would go rouge, pop they "disappear"

    • @RebelGodessRed90
      @RebelGodessRed90 4 роки тому +2

      Gamma Jack would be the first in line for it. He was already on the borderline with having tyrannical and megalomaniac tendencies. Although, I’m not sure how Syndrome would feel about that, having another supervillain steal his spotlight. It would be a different story if Gamma Jack usurped him and took his island. ❤️

    • @grimmettcleaningservices7003
      @grimmettcleaningservices7003 8 місяців тому

      ​@@isaacgraff8288as I got older, that was one of my questions as well. It's not actually addressed in the movie, as far as I can remember. But it makes absolute sense that there would be some type of rise and villainy, particularly from supervillains running amok because Supers are now illegal. I wouldn't mind a prequel dressing this - who took care of the supervillains that had to still be out there once the supers were made illegal? The government through clandestine means?

  • @yagi6381
    @yagi6381 7 років тому +198

    Same!!!! I don't get the train problem! Like he safe your lives, what were you expected from him? Really, it was the best thing to do, he couldn't let them die, I believe having a few broken bones is so much better then being dead

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +26

      I'm glad someone agrees with me! Thanks for watching!

    • @bigkirbyhj666
      @bigkirbyhj666 7 років тому +10

      Well because if he hadn't interfered with the crime, that situation would not have been created.(Not defending just thinking of the logic behind it.)

    • @ColdNorth0628
      @ColdNorth0628 7 років тому +5

      Herschel Johnson but then the guy would have gotten away with money and would have stolen peoples hard earn cash.

    • @bigkirbyhj666
      @bigkirbyhj666 7 років тому +6

      Like i said I wan't defending the people sueing him, just saying how shallow the thought process is.

    • @yagi6381
      @yagi6381 7 років тому +4

      Herschel Johnson but he is spouse to do that, he needs to stop the bad guys, the thing here is why did people were defending someone who wanted to commit suicied? (Idk know how to write) like really guys what the heck? Or there is a law that says that if you don't want to get save you will not get save?

  • @roxanneruiz9261
    @roxanneruiz9261 7 років тому +214

    The citizens expected so much from the superheroes. They did see them as gods in which any altercating imperfection draw them to a disappointment. And in the same time they low-key feared the supers knowing well they are more powerful than them. I think all of them issues combined is what made them ban the supers. It's a shame that they didn't see past that and just learn how to appreciate them and be able to look outside that box that in the end the supers are just people who make mistakes as any other and can be more relatable than they think..

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому +1

      maybe you should have put this in 2 different comments

    • @roxanneruiz9261
      @roxanneruiz9261 7 років тому +5

      +Lillian PIlgrim Nah it's fine I like it on the way I wrote it 😊

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому +2

      kk girl

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому +2

      also how do you do emojis in the comment

    • @roxanneruiz9261
      @roxanneruiz9261 7 років тому +2

      Lillian PIlgrim Well to me it appears on the keyboard. It's a smiley face on the bottom left or right. (on my phone or tablet)

  • @ld4206
    @ld4206 7 років тому +73

    This whole thing about superheros causing collateral damage, causing injuries and being threatened with registration acts makes me think of Captain America Civil War.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +7

      That's why I had to include the seen with Vision towards the end. It fits so well to what everyone was angry about. Thanks for watching!

  • @jrcsmash2150
    @jrcsmash2150 7 років тому +110

    I honestly don't care if I would get harmed if a super saved my life I would always be grateful to them.

    • @alwaysonyourtail2563
      @alwaysonyourtail2563 7 років тому +4

      a super strong man could break your arm while garbing you for whatever reason(catching, pushing out of danger, Ext) and you might be fine with that but if mister incredible hit a villain with your car you just lost a lot of money. and its not a sure thing that insurgents would cover you car in the side of a skyscraper

    • @jrcsmash2150
      @jrcsmash2150 7 років тому +2

      always on your tail cars are just material things that can be dealt with overtime

    • @xientau9028
      @xientau9028 6 років тому +3

      always on your tail Those would be some very kind insurgents if they did. :D
      [Insurgent] (noun) - a person fighting against a government or invading force; a rebel or revolutionary.

    • @xientau9028
      @xientau9028 6 років тому +1

      Sorry, I just couldn't resist. ;)

    • @oldaccount1143
      @oldaccount1143 6 років тому +1

      That is true. I would be grateful.

  • @ashiraestrada9114
    @ashiraestrada9114 7 років тому +216

    They would've sued Mr. Incredible anyway! If he didn't save the guy trying to do suicide the public would complain, so when he did save the guy he said "You didn't save my life, you ruined my death!" (Funniest quote in movie btw)

    • @antisimptrooper4635
      @antisimptrooper4635 6 років тому +4

      Keoh 8 sad bastard wanted to die

    • @TheMorgueDonator
      @TheMorgueDonator 6 років тому +4

      @Keoh 8 bastard

    • @spencerbowden2979
      @spencerbowden2979 5 років тому +6

      Keoh 8 that guy was obviously out for money.
      If you want to die what good is money going to do you?

    • @RebelGodessRed90
      @RebelGodessRed90 4 роки тому +12

      Yeah, it would’ve been his fault either way he handled that situation.

    • @ceanly7845
      @ceanly7845 4 роки тому +4

      If that was me right after he said that I would have killed him

  • @VidzOnComputer
    @VidzOnComputer 7 років тому +151

    Where there any other super's in other countries?
    How come any super's didn't go rogue and turn into super villains?
    Was every super hero government sanctioned, or where they found and eventually recruited?

    • @Matt-xj8lh
      @Matt-xj8lh 7 років тому +22

      1)Probably not. It was the U.S. governments idea
      2)they possibly could have
      3)it was government sanctioned

    • @darksev.6468
      @darksev.6468 7 років тому +7

      Isn't that essentially what happened with Syndrome tho?

    • @VidzOnComputer
      @VidzOnComputer 7 років тому +9

      Yes exactly it did, Mr Incredible would have had a worthy sidekick by his side instead of a future arch nemesis.
      I see it like with Jedi knights they have the power to chose to use the force for good or evil.

    • @thebookworm8574
      @thebookworm8574 7 років тому +4

      Actually, there's a theory that, just like with Captain America, the governmet and the military used some kind of super serum to everyone that volunteered to be a "soldier", turning them into supers, and that's why there is no super villains, they're *controling* the supers by number and ambitions, so there's only super heroes and not villains

    • @rainynight02
      @rainynight02 6 років тому +2

      SuperCarlinBrothers did a video on this topic, the idea being that the government created Supers.

  • @peachy_peach5684
    @peachy_peach5684 7 років тому +90

    It's either you die or get hurt. The train track lawsuit just doesn't make sense...

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +10

      I'm glad you think so too! Thanks for watching!

    • @peachy_peach5684
      @peachy_peach5684 7 років тому +2

      Wotso Videos
      My pleasure! I enjoyed the video a lot! :D
      Can't wait for the next one!

    • @granmastersword
      @granmastersword 6 років тому +2

      My only guess is that they expected him to handle the situation better. They must have though that as a super he should and must have prevented it from happening

  • @skaweirromeda6787
    @skaweirromeda6787 7 років тому +72

    This is awesome, I really think that the Supers where charged with too much responsability. In the movie you can see that the actual cops were badly trained or just lazy because they relied on the fact that the Supers would always be there to get the job done. So it became an obligation for the Supers to protect the cities and it was too much for them as they where also citizens with their own lives to care about. (Sorry for my broken english, I'm still working on it)

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +11

      Right? Like the Supers were pulling all of the weight so they received all of the blame for no reason. Thanks for watching!

  • @beck3149
    @beck3149 7 років тому +26

    On the train accident i think the public couldnt wrap their heads around how Mr. Incredible couldn't stop buddy.
    They werent there and probably didnt think about the kind of restraint Mr. Incredible needed to stop but not hurt Buddy, or how hectic the scene was.
    It was all just " you let the bad guy get away, and couldn't even stop a child?!"

    • @samuellopez479
      @samuellopez479 2 роки тому +2

      If hindsight was possible, maybe Mr. Incredible could’ve hopped under the track and pushed the train up through the split, then warned the conductor of the damage before running off. Those cops man, so unwilling to do their job after watching the hero rip a tree out to save a cat and hurl the tree between the criminal’s escape route. Godlike was right, these civilians were too reliant and helpless

  • @carolcarlson6125
    @carolcarlson6125 7 років тому +108

    I think the Supers should be appreciated.

  • @theotomeotakuhorrorfan9154
    @theotomeotakuhorrorfan9154 7 років тому +35

    When I first watched this movie when I was a little it left me a bit baffled that the people on the train would have been angry for him saving their lives...
    I literally thought those people were idiots... 😶

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +8

      I just don't know what they thought the alternative option would be if Mr. Incredible didn't intervene. Thanks for watching!

    • @theotomeotakuhorrorfan9154
      @theotomeotakuhorrorfan9154 7 років тому +5

      Wotso Videos EXACTLY!!!! What other option did he have? I knew for a fact that he couldn't throw the bomb anywhere else if it were to harm someone near by so he did the next best thing...
      If I was on the train I would be great ful that I am even alive.

  • @phantom115cw
    @phantom115cw 7 років тому +110

    what happen to Mirage?

  • @overachievernamedmarco1141
    @overachievernamedmarco1141 7 років тому +18

    They really sued him when he saved all their asses, that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard but since they actually did it it’s dumb

    • @GreatMewtwo
      @GreatMewtwo 6 років тому +1

      Marcos A. Murillo Vlogs Yes, but what if--like Mr. Sansweet--some of them neither asked to be saved nor wanted to be saved, and then they sued Supers just to be bags about it?

    • @SeanWheeler100
      @SeanWheeler100 2 місяці тому

      @@GreatMewtwo Mr. Sansweet's case is even worse since it's illegal to commit suicide. How the hell did he manage to sue him for saving him from suicide? Sansweet should have been admitted to the psych ward.

  • @ghostcomet3973
    @ghostcomet3973 3 роки тому +2

    That’s a really good theory which I agreed and I seen this movie so many times. I kinda find that superhero lawsuit was ridiculous. If you think about it, superheroes like Mr. Incredible, Frozone, Elastigirl etc. had so many responsibilities and it seems that the police were lazy and see the supers as gods. If Mr. Incredible didn’t save the train, many people would’ve be killed and he didn’t have a choice. His only choice was to save those people who were in the train that was heading towards a damaged train track. Like Uncle Ben, always says,”With great power comes with great responsibility.” I guess the civilians and government didn’t realized the consequences of it. Also remember in Incredibles 2, after the underminer escaped, the police was blaming on the super AGAIN for the damaged. If they captured the underminer without stopping that giant drill then that entire city hall building (I think) would’ve been destroyed and many countless civilians might get killed.

    • @thinkwithvideos2238
      @thinkwithvideos2238 7 місяців тому

      Also. WTF do the police think they could do against the Underminer!!!? I don't see at all how THEY could've stopped him, so they should be thanking their asses the supers showed up to stop the chaos!!

  • @queendsheena1
    @queendsheena1 7 років тому +7

    Great work Issac. You really dug into the reason behind the 'official reason' very well. Excited for Incredibles 2.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Thank you! I am excited as well! Thanks for watching!

  • @plazasta
    @plazasta 6 років тому +2

    whenever I look at those lawsuits, I remember that, at least today in Canada, they'd be impossible to file in because of the Good Samaritan law. If you don't know what it is, here's a quote from Wikipedia on it: _Good Samaritan laws offer legal protection to people who give reasonable assistance to those who are, or who they believe to be, injured, ill, in peril, or otherwise incapacitated._
    basically, if you save someone's life, they cannot sue you. If firefighters, while helping someone escape a burning building, break the person's leg, that person cannot sue them for injuries. If, by practising CPR on someone with a heart attack, you break their ribs, they cannot sue you because you were helping them.
    In this case, the suicidal guy and the people from the train would not be able to sue Mr Incredible because he was saving their lives.

  • @violetcupcake
    @violetcupcake 7 років тому +12

    I think that the Government in the Incredibles was upset with the super heroes because they weren’t getting exactly what they wanted from them and they also felt in danger being near the supers so that is why they wanted to band them!!!!

    • @violetcupcake
      @violetcupcake 7 років тому +2

      Thanks for putting love on my comments I always appreciate that 😊💜

  • @garavenger2276
    @garavenger2276 6 років тому +4

    "He didn't want to be saved"- Stop it Pixar! Stop it get some help! A lawsuit over getting saved. Wow!

  • @sargentrowell81
    @sargentrowell81 7 років тому +16

    Shouldn't there actually have been more supers? Is it possible that the database of supers was incomplete? We see in the first few minutes of the movie, three of the supers in the database are based out of Municiberg alone. Those being, Mr Incredible, Elastigirl and Frozone. If it took an average of AT LEAST 3 supers to keep peace in cities as large as that, shouldn't there be more supers in the US?

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +5

      I think that is a great point. Maybe that database isn't complete or they just weren't all under the National Supers Agency authority. Thanks for watching!

    • @almondex7831
      @almondex7831 2 роки тому

      @@IsaacCarlson they may have different agencies kinda like mha

    • @shadekerensky3691
      @shadekerensky3691 Рік тому

      @@IsaacCarlson I can also see some supers going under the radar and pulling a Rorshach sorta situation.

  • @anotherfool9278
    @anotherfool9278 6 років тому +2

    Same reason why people hate guns, video games and pretty much anything they can't control. A lot of fear of the unknown, a lot of ignorance and a lot of just hate themselves so they put the blame on easy targets

  • @Goddess.Of.Mischief
    @Goddess.Of.Mischief 7 років тому +8

    They're basically saying that instead of being saved and bruised up a bit by Mr.Incredible they would die on the train. So ungrateful.

  • @vanessanuon3997
    @vanessanuon3997 7 років тому +18

    You should have been his lawyer

  • @Bostonterrierslol
    @Bostonterrierslol 4 роки тому +3

    There’s something called the good samaratain act where rescue workers aren’t considered to be legally viable in the case of injuries or loss of life. Ex. Where a paramedic is unable to save an injured victim due to an external force such as timing or distance or the severity of injuries

    • @SeanWheeler100
      @SeanWheeler100 2 місяці тому

      Exactly. Which is why Mr. Incredible shouldn't have been sued at all.

  • @lizzysummersproductions
    @lizzysummersproductions 7 років тому +78

    This video was amazing! I seriously can't wait for The Incredibles 2!

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      I'm happy you enjoyed it! I am excited too!! Thanks for watching!

  • @DomesticAnimo
    @DomesticAnimo 7 років тому +25

    I was thinking i smell captain america civil war all over this video then you mentioned vision lol. I wont go into a rant or anything but it reminded me of that because it broke apart the avengers, people wanting the superheros to take accountability for all the destruction and death they would unintentionally cause because they were trying to do the right thing :/

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому

      :/

    • @idiocyincorporated7635
      @idiocyincorporated7635 6 років тому +1

      I disliked the plot of Civil War for this (and some other) stupid reason. Like the king of wakanda (not the current one, his dad) blamed the Avengers for the death of the relief workers he sent to the country they were in. NEVER MIND THAT IF THEY WEREN'T THERE THE BAD GUYS WOULD GET AWAY WITH A SUPER VIRUS. Or if SW hadn't have moved the bad guy who blew himself up a bunch of people around the building (including Cap) would most likely have been killed.

  • @heathledgersjoker6262
    @heathledgersjoker6262 7 років тому +25

    Do black cauldron and horned king next.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +2

      Definitely need to cover them at some point! Thanks for watching!

  • @SasuNaruL0vR80
    @SasuNaruL0vR80 4 роки тому +7

    how was Mr. Incredible supposed to know the guy wanted to kill hiself? he was just doing his job as a Super: saving ppl! and the train accident happened because of Buddy; if Buddy hadnt been there Bombvoase wouldnt have placed the bomb on his cape and Mr. Incredible wouldnt have had to try to save a kid. none of tht was Mr. Incredible's fault! so y sue him? :/

  • @linkzellda
    @linkzellda 7 років тому +7

    The public turn against their superheroes? That sound like a DC and Marvel story.

  • @Prittykitty42099
    @Prittykitty42099 6 років тому +3

    I'm glad you brought up buddy. I think buddy is a major reason supers were banned because of his obsession and his inability to follow a simple order. He "helped" bomb voyage get away and blow up the train tracks. If he were never there Mr. incredible would have never had to save the train. Maybe buddy was just born to be bad? (I think so because his father could have been a Villanova who left, which would give the lack of a father. So why not love a figure that does good and is the closest thing he could get to a father...)

  • @manuelgrothe608
    @manuelgrothe608 Рік тому +1

    5:14 and 5:30 Bomb Voyage was a Mime in the streets of Paris before he became a villain

  • @AliceBunny
    @AliceBunny 7 років тому +28

    Your videos are AWESOME :D!

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Thanks so much! I'm happy you enjoy them! Thanks for watching!

  • @flashfrozen7401
    @flashfrozen7401 7 років тому +5

    The citizens acted like children. Feeling entitled to having Supers at their beck and call. However, when Supers began making "human" mistakes, the people forsakened the very same heroes who protected them tirelessly. They gave their entire lives to protecting the civilians and were tossed aside when they didn't live up to the unrealistic expectations of the people. This always upset me because of the petty and selfish nature of the normal humans. Lazily waiting for others to take care of things, then blaming them for inevitable failure.

  • @lindzel5672
    @lindzel5672 7 років тому +2

    Your videos are so thought out, you deserve lots more recognition than you get. *LOVE* your videos❤️

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      Thank you! I'm happy you are passionate about them! Thanks for watching!

  • @coldermusic2729
    @coldermusic2729 7 років тому +5

    another thing that happened for the super's to be banned is that super that died because of the cape and plane, you could say that the plane crashed because of this and a lot of people died.

  • @pedrosaabedra5653
    @pedrosaabedra5653 7 років тому +7

    anyone hope they maybe more heroes that survived Sydrome's droids?

  • @izzyhumphrey8727
    @izzyhumphrey8727 7 років тому +26

    This is an amazing video!

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Happy you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching!

  • @overachievernamedmarco1141
    @overachievernamedmarco1141 7 років тому +4

    The citizens and people in the incredibles, basically what they’re doing is being selfish and showing lack of appreciation.

  • @megustaguitarguy
    @megustaguitarguy 7 років тому +4

    With the train thing if they didn't get saved and all died their families would be suing him for not saving them while he was there

  • @caroladrago5447
    @caroladrago5447 7 років тому +1

    The people in the train: Let's see Mr.incredible Me: At least your still alive!!!

  • @sanjaydatta2537
    @sanjaydatta2537 7 років тому +14

    Can you please do another Mulan theory?

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      I actually just watched Mulan and have an idea I really want to share. Not sure when it will be, but could be soon! Thanks for watching!

    • @nicholastosoni707
      @nicholastosoni707 6 років тому

      Yeah, come on! Let's get down to business!
      (...I had to say it.)

  • @TayoEXE
    @TayoEXE 7 років тому

    Clean, thoroughly researched, interesting videos about Disney on UA-cam? Dude, how have I not seen your videos before?

  • @neorenamon
    @neorenamon 7 років тому +4

    I believe that the people blamed superheroes for the damage they caused, intentional or not, because they could. If the damaged was caused by a tornado, hurricane or tidal wave, you can't blame anyone for that (except maybe God). You can only blame a government for a war when they lose, but still there's massive damage on almost all sides. Since heroes were human, they could also be sued, but not if you knew only their public identities. Hence the Registration Act. I have to wonder if any heroes did give up their secret identities in order to comply with the law?

  • @GlamorousTitanic21
    @GlamorousTitanic21 2 роки тому +2

    I’m reminded of the Dark Knight quote.
    “You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”
    - Harvey Dent

  • @BlissfulHues13
    @BlissfulHues13 7 років тому +12

    I love this theory
    It makes sense

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Oh thank you! I'm glad you agree! Thanks for watching!

  • @radcircles9865
    @radcircles9865 5 років тому +1

    Chef Skinner’s Full Story (Discovering Disney)
    Disney Theory: How do arcade characters know they are in a game: Wreck-It-Ralph (Discovering Disney)
    Incredibles: The Deavor’s Full Story (Discovering Disney)

  • @AnnieLavender
    @AnnieLavender 7 років тому +10

    I’m dying for the incredibles 2

  • @predatoralpha4893
    @predatoralpha4893 3 роки тому +1

    Blazestone - A former convict
    So was Ant-Man but he’s still kicking it!
    Dynaguy - Impulsive and reckless
    Yeah, so is the HULK.
    Hypershock - Bad temper and alcohol addiction
    Tell that to Wolverine and Iron Man!!!
    These Supers were not exactly flawless, but doesn’t that kind of make them more relatable…?

  • @gracekim1998
    @gracekim1998 7 років тому +6

    ‘Too late! 15 years too late!’ 😂 sorry I couldn’t resist

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Well said. Thanks for watching!

    • @gracekim1998
      @gracekim1998 7 років тому

      Wotso Videos 😁thanks for replying, I love that joke too much 😂

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому

      :/

    • @gracekim1998
      @gracekim1998 7 років тому +1

      Lillian PIlgrim it’s a line of the movie remember?

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому

      ooooooo ok sorry it has been a while since i have seen this

  • @sabertooth3studioshq838
    @sabertooth3studioshq838 6 років тому +2

    you know i was confused on the train wreck part you see one of my characters bright spark has done the same thing and the public didnt sue her . BESIDES out loud if Mr incredible didnt stop the commuter train insistent lives would been lost.

  • @ravenwilhelm8188
    @ravenwilhelm8188 7 років тому +3

    I love this theory on the Incredibles
    You did an awesome job
    :) :)
    Can't wait to see Incredibles 2

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching!

  • @ash_j_williams
    @ash_j_williams 7 років тому +1

    I noticed you put lots of good work into your amazing videos

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Thank you for noticing! I really appreciate the support! Thanks for watching!

  • @trexnext
    @trexnext 7 років тому +10

    I love these kinds of videos

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      Glad I could make it then!! Thanks for watching!

  • @MinecraftJimmy7951
    @MinecraftJimmy7951 4 роки тому +1

    I don’t understand the train part either, like what was he suppose to do, Pull the spider man train move from Spider-Man 2?

    • @SeanWheeler100
      @SeanWheeler100 2 місяці тому

      How was he supposed to do that without webs?

  • @AnimeFreak4Ever13
    @AnimeFreak4Ever13 7 років тому +9

    Love this video! The Incredibles is a super close tie with Ratatouille for my favorite Pixar movie. If I were a victim of the train accident I wouldn't be mad at the heros. I'd rather have some injuries to myself hopefully not serious ones but rather that than dying by flying off the track end or having a child killed or having an entire police force blown up. In realities like that where people have tremendous powers you have to accept that protection and destruction come at a high cost. It's kinda like the Avengers, they protect you from dangers way beyond your capabilities but you also need to accept that with a risk of danger so extreme it's probably not gonna be easy to handle and there will probably be a lot of collateral damage from the battles. This video made me realize the parallels in Age of Ultron and Civil War to The Incredibles, especially with so many Marvel movies coming out before the sequel. Great job with this one! 💚

  • @hanna6953
    @hanna6953 7 років тому +2

    That’s was awesome Isaac, and I totally agree!! Love you! But can you please do Star Wars?!? I gave you a ton of ideas in a poll like 2 weeks ago. Thanks. ❤️

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      I'm glad you liked it! I think I will discuss Star Wars once The Last Jedi releases on Bluray if I were to do it. Thanks for watching!

  • @adamnur1883
    @adamnur1883 7 років тому +21

    Hi Issac.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +2

      Hello! Thanks for watching!

    • @adamnur1883
      @adamnur1883 7 років тому +1

      Wotso Videos,you're welcome, how's your day?

  • @Faith_Southers
    @Faith_Southers 7 років тому +1

    Awesome video! I can see you're just as pumped for the sequel as I am :)

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      I definitely am! It's a really fun movie to discuss! Thanks for watching!

  • @danirangel2810
    @danirangel2810 7 років тому +6

    U know if u were in the movie u would be a good defense lawyer for the supers

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Oh thank you!! Thanks for watching!

  • @shanestone9770
    @shanestone9770 3 роки тому +1

    Has anyone else noticed the correlation between the rise, fall, and rebound of supers in The Incredibles and the rise, fall, and rebound of supers in comic books in the real world? Now, the golden age of supers and the supers’ fall from grace seems to take place in the 40s, approximately 1947, 15 years later in 1962 the rest of the story takes place, and by 1963 supers are made legal again, that correlates with how super heroes in comic books enjoyed a golden age in the 40s with characters such as Superman, Batman, and Captain America, but by the 50s their popularity started to decline, and while they were still well loved they were nowhere near as popular as their inception when they were something new that we haven’t seen before, but with a lack of new heroes being created their daring escapades started to get old, but by the 60s, approximately 1962 and 1963, supers made a spectacular comeback with characters such as Iron Man, Hulk, and the Fantastic 4, I think this was an intentional timeline choice by Pixar to connect their film with the golden and silver age of comic book super heroes.

  • @TinaCutri
    @TinaCutri 7 років тому +14

    Wow this video was.... INCREDIBLE!!!
    (there's like 500 comments on this video someone probably already made that joke)

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      I'm happy you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching!

  • @Strawberry.amethyst
    @Strawberry.amethyst 6 років тому +1

    New subscriber.~
    I've just binged watched most of your videos and STILL can't get enough! Most of these theories I actually had a little thought about, but... Wow. Putting it down into a video and explaining much better than I ever could. :'D

  • @pjgray443
    @pjgray443 7 років тому +31

    good job

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      Thanks Baby Groot! Thanks for watching!

  • @dreamyo
    @dreamyo Рік тому

    thank you for this video! you've managed to explain everything so clearly and kept the info short and sweet, which I enjoyed

  • @SezFrancis1
    @SezFrancis1 7 років тому +36

    This is interesting, Issac; I’m unsure to explain the train 🚊 incident either. And way a go, Helen; girl power all the way!!!! ⭐️✨

    • @stagergamer4172
      @stagergamer4172 7 років тому

      you know isaac from school?

    • @HunterStiles651
      @HunterStiles651 7 років тому +1

      stager gamer who says she has to know Isaac personally? It's extremely common for youtubers to make their first names public knowledge.

    • @xientau9028
      @xientau9028 6 років тому +1

      I blame greedy lawyers;
      "Hey check this out guys! If we can sue one super hero... Then we can sue them all for damages and make millions! Quick, get me the names of every person injured during the train incident!"

    • @HunterStiles651
      @HunterStiles651 6 років тому

      Xien Tau Do you really have to go there? The lawyers were just doing their job, representing people who feel they've had injustice done to them in court. It's like getting mad at police officers for arresting people suspected of committing a crime (which sadly, is a thing that happens).

  • @redtalon8947
    @redtalon8947 7 років тому +1

    For the people on the train: Would you rather live with a broken for a little while, or be cripplingly dead. I rest my case.

  • @gaoussoufadiga9913
    @gaoussoufadiga9913 7 років тому +4

    Last time I was this early, Logan Paul was not that much of a jerk

    • @trexnext
      @trexnext 7 років тому

      Mr.savage that doesnt make sense

  • @thedisturbedone5026
    @thedisturbedone5026 6 років тому +2

    I think that under the "good Samaritan Act" both cases should have been thrown out

  • @lulamoore978
    @lulamoore978 7 років тому +9

    Remember gil backstory not to rush you just thought you forgot

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      DEFINITELY DIDN'T FORGET! I just have had a ton of topical topics to cover first! Thanks for watching!

    • @lulubelle8788
      @lulubelle8788 7 років тому

      Looking forward to it as well buddy 😄👋👍

  • @gigifabulous
    @gigifabulous 7 років тому +2

    I feel that for example young supers that have to live under the anti super law would instead of using their powers for good, use them for evil out of pure frustration.

  • @predatoralpha4893
    @predatoralpha4893 3 роки тому +5

    That incident with the train is what still boggles my mind to this day! There was no other safe place to get rid of it of the bomb :
    1. He couldn’t throw it aside where the buildings were
    2. He wasn’t going to throw it down the streets where traffic and citizens were
    3. He couldn’t throw it in the air because of how strong he is, he wouldn’t risk hitting any nearby helicopters
    4. If the blast is big enough to destroy the tracks then what would have happened if Mr. Incredible tried to pull a “Superman” and cup the blast in the palm of his hands…?
    And let me point out two things that could have happened if Mr. Incredible didn’t remove the bomb :
    1. Buddy (Incredi-Boy) would have died if it hadn’t been removed by Mr. Incredible, who would have felt personally responsible for his death
    2. As you said, Buddy would have gone to the police station (WITH THE BOMB ATTACHED TO HIM) and he would have gotten everyone killed

  • @caseyd.9708
    @caseyd.9708 6 років тому

    Your channel is my FAVORITE out of any conspiracy/theory channels

  • @GuardianLords
    @GuardianLords 7 років тому +5

    this dude already looks like incrediboy

  • @reddrago8274
    @reddrago8274 4 роки тому +1

    I cant believe all those people sue him for giving them injuries at the cost of their lives. Nor can I believe a man who nearly committed can win a trial and gain sympathy from the public over the hero.

  • @hamilton_lamstrash2879
    @hamilton_lamstrash2879 7 років тому +18

    Just shows how stupid and awful us humans are. 😂😂 Turn against the people saving us as soon as we see some dollar signs or taste a little bit of fear.

  • @HallowsNGallows
    @HallowsNGallows 7 років тому +2

    There was another incident, were a super hero was sucked into a plane engine and the playing crashed. They don't say it crashed but a bird could crash a plane by being sucked in, led alone a human! Edna mode said it...

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      I remember that but since they never said it crashed I totally forgot about that. Good point! Thanks for watching!

  • @jodiejustice9264
    @jodiejustice9264 7 років тому +3

    Do a lion king video on who’s vitani father is

  • @reese9633
    @reese9633 7 років тому +2

    Another great video Isaac

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Happy you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching!

  • @dinseyfanandmore6803
    @dinseyfanandmore6803 7 років тому +3

    hi Wotso Videos i was wondering if you can please do a theory video about what happened to bomb voyage in The Incredibles because last time we saw him he got away because buddy aka syndrome

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      Honestly Bomb Voyage and Mirage are the characters I am most curious about! Thanks for watching!

  • @ellerj641
    @ellerj641 4 роки тому

    If you think about it, there was most likely a time where supers didn't exist. Then they started showing up and started doing hero work without asking the public what they wanted. It ends up growing to the point where there's supers everywhere and then supervillains because they see the challenge and want in on the fun (or having to adapt to be able to do a crime with superpowered people running around). Out of fear and fascination for these beings, people began to revere them as gods. But this led to completely unrealistic expectations. Gods are supposed to be able to do anything and ALWAYS save the people even if it had bad consequences. So, for the train scene, the people expected Mr. Incredible to somehow magically get rid of the bomb and nobody gets hurt. That didn't happen. Then when the suicide jumper sues Mr. Incredible and actually wins, the people begin to realize either one of two things: there is a way to stop/slow down the gods and let them know they don't want them, and that the gods are the cause for so many problems like the supervillains and civilian injuries. Or second, people realize that they are not gods but people who are horribly flawed and have too much power on their hands. They need to be taken down and sent away so the people can finally feel safe again. Either way, the supers go away, the supervillains go away and crime and injuries are drastically dropped. So, whether Mr. Incredible was able to stop the bomb or not, he is still guilty and responsible for the damage in the civilians eyes because, if he never existed, the whole train accident would have never happened.

  • @user-dk7yx1xr5x
    @user-dk7yx1xr5x 7 років тому +3

    How about a story behind Deasmorelda from hunchback of naltra dame

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      I'm planning on doing that one soon! Thanks for watching!

  • @EChacon
    @EChacon 7 років тому +1

    Awesome job Isaac, it's very interesting how you pointed out that even though the Supers have helped out many civilians they do have their own flaws just like we do.
    Can't wait for Incredibles 2 to come out.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Thank you so much! Me too! Thanks for watching!

  • @calebmedley6906
    @calebmedley6906 7 років тому +3

    I'm Really Excited and Amazed For The Incredibles 2 and A Wrinkle In Time!😂

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Both should be awesome! I am also excited for Black Panther! Thanks for watching!

  • @esthercornwell6351
    @esthercornwell6351 6 років тому

    ok first: this is an amazing video Isaac, you did a great job!
    secondly: the Super Relocation Act forces super heros to go underground, but what about the heros that don't have super powers?

  • @connorplisga3718
    @connorplisga3718 7 років тому +8

    DO SHAN YU’S FULL STORY

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому

      Just watched Mulan yesterday! I love that movie! Thanks for watching!

  • @justjuan9521
    @justjuan9521 7 років тому +2

    I have never seen this topic being touched,nice theory

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      Happy I could share it! Thanks for watching!

  • @inactivechannel3866
    @inactivechannel3866 7 років тому +9

    N O C A P E S

  • @radcircles9865
    @radcircles9865 5 років тому +1

    In my opinion, the public was being very selfish. If they FEARED supers, and wanted them out, why didn’t that occur in other superhero media. My example goes to Superman, who, in the Injustice Storyline, becomes a dictator to the world. Why didn’t those people stop him earlier. As, at that point, they had to rely on heroes to save them

  • @calindastrayhorn
    @calindastrayhorn 7 років тому +9

    Hey Wotso!

  • @holyforce000
    @holyforce000 7 років тому +1

    The Supers were there for a reason; placing unrealistic expectations on others will inevitably lead to failure and tragedy, the only thing that should be expected that they give their best, both as a Super and as a human.

  • @lilbean5840
    @lilbean5840 7 років тому +13

    omg there os gonna be an incredibles 2 !?!

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +3

      Yup!! You know it! June of this year! Thanks for watching!

    • @gracekim1998
      @gracekim1998 7 років тому +1

      Lillian PIlgrim yes, young one😁

    • @markdarc0448
      @markdarc0448 7 років тому +1

      Lillian PIlgrim ur just now finding out

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому

      Ok :/

    • @lilbean5840
      @lilbean5840 7 років тому

      slightly dramatic :/

  • @SharpDesign
    @SharpDesign 7 років тому

    Your videos always get me thinking. Makes me wanna rewatch even if there wasn't a sequel coming.

    • @IsaacCarlson
      @IsaacCarlson  7 років тому +1

      I feel the same way! I had a lot of fun pouring through the movie again. Thanks for watching!

  • @isabelametz473
    @isabelametz473 7 років тому +9

    DO SOME ON GREEK MYTHS OR PERCY JACKSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!