I worked at a Jewish Retirement Home that had many survivors, I was 23 yrs old, now at 59 I can say it has remained with me, We need to not let this History be down played. Never Again!
First I will say thank you for having her on your show, but I'm very disappointed with the amount of time you allowed for her to speak! I have seen y'all give others several minutes to spout nonsense but you had an opportunity to hear from an actual survivor of a horrific time & you gave it 6minutes & 17 seconds that is so disrespectful. I hope you actually take the time to bring Lucy back & give her the time & respect she deserves!
Really should have allocated a decent amount of time at least 10 minutes to explore such a complex topic otherwise it looks like you're just having her on because the view wouldn't. At least let her finish her story or work out beforehand how long it would take before she gets into it or take the break before she starts it? Bit disrespectful.
Agree. She obviously wanted to share more of her story but it does seem as if she was just called to confirm that The View had not contacted her. Better even, send Brian Entin to have a lovely interview with her
Lol it’s a main stream media source, ofc they’re gonna do anything to make the other side look bad, hence the constant pressure on asking if the apology sufficed, all these outlets don’t understand the actuality of these survivors, it’s all about their ratings and trying to “cancel” each other.
Stop interrupting and let her speak. You really are no better than Whoopi and the “girls” when bringing her on your show, but not allowing her to tell her story. That was why she reached out to Whoopi in the first place, to educate ignorant people, including you and I about the horrors of her life.
I would love to see her take Whoopi’s spot while she’s on her little break. Holocaust survivors are some of the most amazing, strong people who have ever walked this earth & we need to hear their stories before they are all gone. There are so few left now. I can’t believe she is 88 years old, she doesn’t look a day over 50!!! Also, y’all need to have her back on & do a proper interview. She didn’t even get to speak or tell any of her story & I really wanted to hear it. It was rude to bring her on for such a short period & ask her questions, but not allow her to answer the questions. 😥
Do better! When you have a survivor on your show, allow them to speak! I see right through your finger pointing back at the View for your own ratings benefit.
So true, this was as disrespectful as what Whoopi said, if not more disrespectful by disregarding what she had to say about her feelings of her experience. Very sad.... They all should be ashamed.
Please have Lucy back on the show. Her value as a historian is immeasurable. The world would benefit greatly from more first hand accounts of the survivors of the Holocaust. The burden is not on them to educate us, but for us to listen and learn. Whoopi had no place commenting or inserting her willfully ignorant "opinion". Her apology is not sufficient.
I completely agree with you that this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner, needs to be quickly brought back to NewsNation Now for an interview of proper length. I am the child of Holocaust survivors, and you put it well, that the burden is not on survivors to educate everyone else, but for the rest of us to listen and learn. It's not so hard to listen & learn, either. The only reason I didn't upvote your comment is that, as a lifelong fan of Whoopi Goldberg's wonderful comedy, I don't believe that she was being willfully ignorant. Misinformed, yes, and seeing the unique racism towards European Jews through the lens of American racism towards black people, yes. But Whoopi just did not understand. Like most people who haven't been educated on a particular topic, she wasn't being willfully clueless. Whoopi has demonstrated that she's teachable and willing to learn the true nature of Jewish people's predicament, not just during the Shoah but in the years leading up to it, in which European Jews saw their citizenship rights systematically disappear for their being judged an "inferior race." When people view other people as sub-human, horrors ensue. Both NewsNation Now and The View need to invite Holocaust survivors & educators onto their platforms so that Whoopi's mistake can lead to positive change in the public's understanding of what really happened to all those millions of Jews.
it is So important you come on, unfortunately we have to cut you off mid sentence when you are talking about a pivotal moment in your life and in history
I am so grateful for my high school back in the 80s for teaching us kids about the holocaust.. Whoopies apology was not compassionate whatsoever! She said her apology in a defensive manner because she got corrected...I don't believe she is actually sorry
Although Nazis considered Jews to be a separate race than themselves, it was a little bit more complex than just race. Many other groups were killed; gays, disabled, blacks, Gypsies, and anyone who spoke out against the war, or those accused of hiding any Jews, although the majority of Jews were targeted. Not to mention the experiments Hitler did on his own people. I understand what Whoopi was saying, but I don’t think she explained it very well.
Please, can we get rid of not Whoopi Goldberg and The View entirely ? I have NEVER been enlightened/inspired/ intellectually challenged nor intellectually informed by ANY episode of The View . It is always a bunch of non- intellectual women who bicker .. SO annoying! My dear friend ( who has since passed) always had this on in the background whenever I would come to visit her… It always gave me a headache. Yuck! Whoopi used to be a Comedian 40 years ago… she was somewhat funny back in those days. Today, I find her tiresome, boring and pedantic… please stop.. the show has reached its prime .. it is so outdated…
THAT'S the word for what "happened" to Whoopie-- she became PEDANTIC! That's what made her error sooo very cringe worthy-- she was practically pounding the table insisting to JOY the JEW that she, Whoopie--, knows better. BIG WHOOOOPSIE!
Cutoff so rudely mid story....Cuz they got what they wanted, her take on whoopie, after that the rest didnt matter to them. To them she was just blabbin on. Bet nobody else caught that.
@@p.gizzle5226 We caught that, we did. I love Marni Hughes, but it was painful to hear her cut off the words of this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner. NewsNation Now, give this lady a proper-length interview. She wants to tell us what happened to her, and we, the subscribers, want to hear it!
I’m the granddaughter of Holocaust survivors who studied and has tutored sociology students. Whoopi is not wrong, actually. Judaism is sociologically defined as an ethnicity. Race is purely based on physical characteristics - and Hitler incorrectly tried to make an entire thing about his Arian race being superior to not only Jews, but others like gay and disabled people. Hitler really ingrained this as being an issue of race and it has stuck. However, it was largely an issue of ethnicity and creed in actuality - Hitler just tried to use physical traits as a way to identify these people. It has since been proven in recent years with empirical sociological studies and documentaries that Hitler’s theories about the Arian race and way of defining people’s ethnicities and other inferiorities (in his point of view) by their physical traits alone was wrong - after all, there were many people from all the countries he targeted who were not Jewish who fit similar descriptions. My grandparents and other relatives who were survivors and have since passed away all saw it just as I described it. People need to use concrete sociological definitions of race (which strictly refers to physical characteristics like skin, hair, and eye color, body type, nose shape, etc.), and ethnicity (which includes country of origin, religion, and other factors) in this sort of discussion and critically examine Hitler’s theories and methods in order to have a meaningful discussion. I’m not saying that public perception is wrong, but Whoopi is using the same types of definitions to draw her perspective. Black racism is clearly just about skin color - it does not typically include religion, creed, etc. and other such factors on the whole. If the black community is attacked as a whole, we call that racism even if individuals in that group may belong to different religions, come from different countries of origin, etc. since that is the singular common attribute between everyone and is likely the sole reason for the bias. If a single individual black man who happens to also be gay happens to get attacked by someone yelling racial and sexual epitaphs, then it is not strictly a case of racism alone - then it is usually referred to as a case of general bias or it being was targeted due to his race and sexual orientation. It would be wrong to only refer to it as a racial attack. When you look at the Holocaust, Hitler incorrectly viewed it as a racial issue because he created his own twisted definitions of what race means rather than using the accepted sociological definitions (which already existed thanks to major sociological theorists). But if we all critically examine what occurred to Jewish and other minorities as a whole, it was not strictly an attack on being white. It mostly was due to the fact that he hated people who were Jewish, gay, and disabled (among other minority groups). He did not attack white people who fit the same physical characteristics as those Jewish, gay, disabled, etc. populations that he labeled as inferior. I’m sorry, but Whoopi is really not wrong. Go back and listen to what she said bearing what I’ve explained in mind. That’s the line of thought that I believe she’s coming from. That’s how most sociological studies have examined the reasons for the Holocaust and why certain groups were targeted by Hitler. Unfortunately, people have been brainwashed by Hitler always talking about his Arian race and only see the Holocaust as a racial issue as a result and/or people are misinformed about the sociological definitions of and differences between race and ethnicity. Even people who went though the Holocaust are often mistaken in their verbiage. I’m not saying public opinion is wrong. It’s just a bit misguided. Whoopi was really not wrong and should not be punished just because she’s educated herself on sociological definitions and issues. I was lucky to have been educated about this from a strictly sociological and empirical point of view, as well as having grandparents who always raised us to understand that their families were targeted for being Jewish. Synagogues were burned, religious objects were taken and destroyed, they had to wear those yellow identifying Jude stars, and they were sent to concentration camps after being identified as Jews. Nobody said they were going to the camps because they were white. Nobody sent the Christian-Polish neighbors across the street who had the same skin tone, dark brown hair/eyes, etc. that many Jews had to concentration camps - if it was strictly a matter of race, Hitler would have sent those people to the camps too. Hitler just tried to warp people’s minds with his made up theories about his superior Arian race - and sadly, his point of view has misguided people to this day including many survivors. Examine the facts critically, use sociologically accepted definitions. You’ll come to see that Whoopi is is not wrong. She deserves to be put back on the show effective immediately and is owed a massive apology by ABC.
@@bittersweet2253 You sound like the misguided one with that response…Reading comprehension is fundamental so try rereading maybe 🤔 you’ll come away with a different perspective..🙂
Hitler took the concept of race to another level. He called the Jews an inferior race, period, and saw them as subhuman. The Holocaust, which killed far more Jews than any other group of people, was indeed about race because Hitler made it about the eradication of the Jewish "race" through The Final Solution, regardless if Jews post-WWII are labeled an ethno-religious group or whatever academia is teaching these days. Take history at its word, and please stop rewriting it.
You should have set aside A LOT more time to allow this woman to say what she wanted to say and express herself and what she went through! Why invite her on if she’s not allowed to say what she wanted to say?!?! This infuriates me!!! She tagged the View bc she wanted to be able to TALK and express what HELL she lived through and educate Idiots that speak out both sides of their mouth!!!! Do better! Your ratings would be BETTER if you allow ppl to talk and express themselves not cut them off when they haven’t even got a full thought out of their mouth yet!
I'm Jewish and highly Holocaust literate, and I don't in any way think that Whoopi is ant-Semitic. I doubt that she'd have the last name Goldberg if she was. Her original comment was awkward. it would be different if she was some kind of rabid hater of Jews, but she's not. I, for one, accept her apology and realize that she spoke a bit out of turn. Sadly, there is a lot of anti-Semitism in the world right now, so perhaps the subject deserves more sensitivity. But Whoopi's not a hater, and she's not ignorant, either. I'm for letting this drop.
@@americasamericas5782 Why isn't it? How Jewish people are different from the rest of the people? Explain your angry all-caps claim! Why racism against a Jewish person is different from racism against a non-Jewish person?
@@scarlettohara910 I could be wrong but I think Whoopi views race through the eyes of American standards. Think of when you check the box on applications. There is no “Jewish” category. So I think Whoopi views Jewish people as white because that’s probably the box they check in America. So I think she doesn’t/didn’t see the racism because she sees Nazi and Jews as white. However, Hitler and the Nazis viewed Jews were an inferior race. So for them it definitely was racial. Some people killed in the holocaust were considered Jewish because they had a Jewish grandparent. So it was definitely racial. For some reason, Whoopi was unaware of this. Some people have to remember that Jewish can be viewed as both religious and race. Perhaps, Whoopi only views it as a religion. That’s just my interpretation of her comment and her apology. I could be wrong 🤷🏾♀️.
@@happyalice6306 I only view Judaism as a religion as well. No one explains why, when and how Judaism turned from a religion to a race! Did the same thing happen to Christianity, Islam and Judaism? Are they a race too?
@@scarlettohara910 I think some people view being Hebrew as an ethnicity, not a race. People tend to use ethnicity and race interchangeably but they are mistaken.
GOD BLESS HER. Whoopi should have the decency to talk to this lady, but I doubt she will. HUMANITY ISN’T IN WHOOPI’S DNA. A hater does NOT listen to another’s point of view.
Anyone who would like to hear Mrs. Lipiner tell her story should check out her book titled, ‘Long Journey Home’. There’s also a short interview with her on UA-cam from a radio show/podcast. I thought it was so rude that they cut her off and barely let her speak, ugh.
Whoopi/ The Holocaust wasn't about race Hitler during his speeches/ We are going to make a superior race....... To be fair, I never saw Whoopi as a person who actually reads or cares about history. I honestly didn't know the View was still a thing.
So important she came on but didn't give her much time. You should have blocked out more time for her story. This was poorly done. You look like you were more tryin to expose Whoopie then you were to actually hear her story.
Yes, I agree. What's almost worse than not inviting a Holocaust survivor to share her story, one week after the 77th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, is inviting a survivor to share her story and then literally cutting her off after 5 minutes. I love Marni Hughes, but she didn't even give this survivor a moment to cry about her childhood best friend, Rachel, who was sent as a kid to the gas chambers. Do better, NewsNation Now, and invite this survivor, Lucy Lipiner, back for a proper-length interview. We, the subscribers, want to hear her story!!
This woman deserved a longer time slot. You said “we need to listen to holocaust survivors speak” THEN SPOKE OVER HER. This was not a segment that should have been given a short time
Hello, NewsNation Now, please bring this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner, back on your show, now, for a proper interview of respectful length. It's not just about respect: it's that the horrors of the Holocaust require more than 5 minutes of coverage. I am a first-generation American Jew, and a recent subscriber to your channel because I was impressed by your coverage of Gabby Petito & other missing persons' cases, and I wanted to support your mission. A person going missing or getting murdered is an unimaginable tragedy. The Holocaust was the tragedy of one person's murder multiplied by inconceivable millions, via the staggering barbarism of the Nazis and their collaborators. I am the daughter of Jewish refugees from Poland, who barely made it out of there alive. Holocaust education needs to be standard in school curricula. Anti-semitism didn't die with the more than six million Jewish souls. Instead, it's rising worldwide. Please, NewsNation Now, live up to the fine example you've set in missing persons' coverage and invite this Holocaust survivor back on your show, now, while the Whoopi Goldberg controversy is still a hot topic in the news, for a full-length segment. Don't rely on The View to do the right thing: set an example and do it yourself. Don't just say, "it's important to listen." Actually listen to living survivors. There aren't many left. People are hungry for knowledge & enlightenment. People are also looking for ways to use their empathy: it's the kindheartedness & desire to feel & connect with others that's at the core of human nature. Hearing this woman's story isn't just a vital opportunity for viewers, it's good for business. When you do the right thing, you broadcast your reputation. Please take heed of the comments, here, asking you to be true to your own words, and give us "fact-driven, unbiased coverage" of real history and a real story.
Seems this interview was to piss on Whoopi, interviewer did not LISTEN, she cut her off just wanting to ask about how she felt about whoopis’ comments! She really should of given Lucy more time to talk!
Obviously Whoopi faced racism differently. I do think she should be forgiven. Why do we just want to get rid of someone that simply. Marjorie Taylor Greene is still a Republican in Congress after her terrible comment.
Obviously, you and Whoopi did not educate yourself, I’m not going to because you will not learn… you’ll make an excuse to not accept whatever is correct… your parents should of have to deal with you not other people!
I think Marjorie Taylor Greene is different because she’s a politician, but I also think what Whoopi said isn’t as bad as what some believe it to be. She never denied the holocaust or undermined what happened. I don’t think she fully explained her opinion well enough for people to understand what she was trying to say. I think what Marjorie Greene said was way more offensive.
you guys should of just spoken about whoopie and not bring this wonderful lady out here to talk about her scary life experience and not let her talk or let her finish. ugh!! HOW RUDE!
This lady has a wonderful spirit about her and a kindness..it is wonderful that she wants to sit down and teach the Holocaust to these rediculius women.
Important segment, thank you for picking this up, although the VIEW likely will pass. Hope this has the effect of enticing them rather than letting it sit.
YES!! This is so important. I am so glad a survivor is wanting to talk and share and EDUCATE. Whoopie has a past of doing lots of antisemitic things. Naming a recipe “the Jewish American princess fried chicken” and demeaning the Jewish people in so many stupid ways and I would love to know WHY. Why does she feel the need to KEEP doing this? She has done this over and over for ten years. She doesn’t care she just doesn’t want to be cancelled.
God bless this woman Lucy and her family. Like she said not all Jewish people are white I'm black and I'm part Jewish, and Cherokee Indian so you see you never know who is a mixed race my heart goes out to all the Holocaust survivors God bless you all
@@jolietia Gee. Is that akin to “All lives matter”? Because yes there is bigotry all around the US, and the world. But in this case, Whoopi Goldberg (who appropriated the name btw)-She tried to reduce the genocide (of a great percentage of the entire, global, Jewish population) into something “petty”. Into some kind of irreverent quarrel, that is meaningless. It doesn’t matter to her, because the killers were white, and to her the Jews (those being killed) were “white”. (Everyone knows that although Jews are technically Caucasian, no one in America considers them “white”. Not really. So this isn’t about “bigotry against everyone”. Your response is demeaning, as well. This, proving the point.
Look up Lucy Jacobs on you tube. She is a family friend and also a Holocaust survivor, she has been interviewed by Steven Spielberg as well. She’s amazing and stills tells her story.
I am so glad Whoopi can learn a life lesson on life. Please Whoopi go away. Thank the lord In heaven this beautiful woman can tell the truth beautiful woman
I still want whoopie to be taken off the View and the View to be taken off the air. The View alway starts trouble and after they are called out then they have their tail between their legs and we have to feel sorry for them when they enjoy pointing finger at everone.
Two weeks is a sick CYOA joke... But honestly, this show really doesn't have much impact. American women are way to smart to watch it for more than entertainment value. I'm so happy they our Nation is beginning to stop being afraid of the delusional far left and right and is grabbing the losers! The worst kind of bigotry and racism is exactly what whoopi's been on for years...
“It is so important that you come on and share your experience …but we are out of time”. Really? That’s all the time you could spare for Lucy and her story? Tisk tisk
Wow they really just tried to meet the requirement to have her on the show but the segment really didn’t give her much chance to tell her story, they just met their quota for race relations and then gave her 20 seconds to tell what happened to everyone in the photograph. Pitiful. They were just trying to get someone to forgive Whoopi on national tv… they didn’t care about her story one bit.
This must be taught in school. Too many people dont understand the holocaust. Its also sad that people dont even know about holocaust in Congo. 10 million people murder by king Leopold because of their ethnicity. Thats just one country. We need to learn more about each other.
yikes. cut her off to tell her how you should listen to her. but since its all about getting that interview first, don’t actually give her the respect and time.
Jewish is a religion, is not a race, a race shares biological characteristics among them, a culture or a religion shares the upbringing, is not the same and I can understand how Whoopie was saying that without wanting to hurt anyone.
Why would anyone think Whoopi is an authority on anything. Because she’s on a talk show? Whoopi thought it was a good idea for her boyfriend to wear blackface!
I have a boycott list of people that I refuse to watch on TV or in movies. As a result of her crass remarks Whoopi Goldberg is added to that list. Jane Fonda, Roseanne Barre, Rosie O'Donnell, Mel Gibson, Bill Cosby, Susan Sarandon. Yes I am only one person but I know I am not the only one that has a boycott list. Some 'entertainers' end their own careers due to not thinking before speaking - for that I am grateful. Words and actions have consequences!!!
I worked at a Jewish Retirement Home that had many survivors, I was 23 yrs old, now at 59 I can say it has remained with me, We need to not let this History be down played. Never Again!
You really should have her back and give more time to her story.
First I will say thank you for having her on your show, but I'm very disappointed with the amount of time you allowed for her to speak! I have seen y'all give others several minutes to spout nonsense but you had an opportunity to hear from an actual survivor of a horrific time & you gave it 6minutes & 17 seconds that is so disrespectful. I hope you actually take the time to bring Lucy back & give her the time & respect she deserves!
Really should have allocated a decent amount of time at least 10 minutes to explore such a complex topic otherwise it looks like you're just having her on because the view wouldn't. At least let her finish her story or work out beforehand how long it would take before she gets into it or take the break before she starts it? Bit disrespectful.
Agree. She obviously wanted to share more of her story but it does seem as if she was just called to confirm that The View had not contacted her. Better even, send Brian Entin to have a lovely interview with her
Lol it’s a main stream media source, ofc they’re gonna do anything to make the other side look bad, hence the constant pressure on asking if the apology sufficed, all these outlets don’t understand the actuality of these survivors, it’s all about their ratings and trying to “cancel” each other.
@@devenshortxd4497 at least they read the comments and brought her back, albeit for a shorter time than what she probably wanted or expected.
well this news network did at least bring her on and read her post....props to them
Please bring this dear lady back. I'd like to hear more about her story.
Stop interrupting and let her speak. You really are no better than Whoopi and the “girls” when bringing her on your show, but not allowing her to tell her story. That was why she reached out to Whoopi in the first place, to educate ignorant people, including you and I about the horrors of her life.
I would love to see her take Whoopi’s spot while she’s on her little break. Holocaust survivors are some of the most amazing, strong people who have ever walked this earth & we need to hear their stories before they are all gone. There are so few left now. I can’t believe she is 88 years old, she doesn’t look a day over 50!!! Also, y’all need to have her back on & do a proper interview. She didn’t even get to speak or tell any of her story & I really wanted to hear it.
It was rude to bring her on for such a short period & ask her questions, but not allow her to answer the questions. 😥
what a great idea!
Do better! When you have a survivor on your show, allow them to speak! I see right through your finger pointing back at the View for your own ratings benefit.
So true, this was as disrespectful as what Whoopi said, if not more disrespectful by disregarding what she had to say about her feelings of her experience. Very sad.... They all should be ashamed.
She's doing what the old bats do on the view, cut off when they talk.
Please may we have more of Lucy’s story, please
Please have Lucy back on the show. Her value as a historian is immeasurable. The world would benefit greatly from more first hand accounts of the survivors of the Holocaust. The burden is not on them to educate us, but for us to listen and learn. Whoopi had no place commenting or inserting her willfully ignorant "opinion". Her apology is not sufficient.
I completely agree with you that this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner, needs to be quickly brought back to NewsNation Now for an interview of proper length. I am the child of Holocaust survivors, and you put it well, that the burden is not on survivors to educate everyone else, but for the rest of us to listen and learn. It's not so hard to listen & learn, either. The only reason I didn't upvote your comment is that, as a lifelong fan of Whoopi Goldberg's wonderful comedy, I don't believe that she was being willfully ignorant. Misinformed, yes, and seeing the unique racism towards European Jews through the lens of American racism towards black people, yes. But Whoopi just did not understand. Like most people who haven't been educated on a particular topic, she wasn't being willfully clueless.
Whoopi has demonstrated that she's teachable and willing to learn the true nature of Jewish people's predicament, not just during the Shoah but in the years leading up to it, in which European Jews saw their citizenship rights systematically disappear for their being judged an "inferior race." When people view other people as sub-human, horrors ensue. Both NewsNation Now and The View need to invite Holocaust survivors & educators onto their platforms so that Whoopi's mistake can lead to positive change in the public's understanding of what really happened to all those millions of Jews.
Thank you! I would love to hear more from Lucy. ❤️❤️❤️
Yes, she’s lovely and has so much to reveal.
it is So important you come on, unfortunately we have to cut you off mid sentence when you are talking about a pivotal moment in your life and in history
Ugh, that was the worst.
It was like, ok we got her take on woopie she's going way back now, " CUT!!" Its all that mattered to them thats why.
I am so grateful for my high school back in the 80s for teaching us kids about the holocaust.. Whoopies apology was not compassionate whatsoever! She said her apology in a defensive manner because she got corrected...I don't believe she is actually sorry
And she did what she does best: hide behind her race and use it as an excuse to be racist.
She herself has a Jewish last name...Goldberg
Yeah she was ordered by ABC to apologize. Not heartfelt
@@msjannd4 Trump was the president in the usa. How racist do you want it
Did you guys see what she said on Colbert that night? Pretty bad.
Crazy how she gets away with those words and just gets two weeks off when the folks on that show try to cancel everyone else. They want it both ways.
Although Nazis considered Jews to be a separate race than themselves, it was a little bit more complex than just race. Many other groups were killed; gays, disabled, blacks, Gypsies, and anyone who spoke out against the war, or those accused of hiding any Jews, although the majority of Jews were targeted. Not to mention the experiments Hitler did on his own people. I understand what Whoopi was saying, but I don’t think she explained it very well.
Please, can we get rid of not Whoopi Goldberg and The View entirely ? I have NEVER been enlightened/inspired/ intellectually challenged nor intellectually informed by ANY episode of The View . It is always a bunch of non- intellectual women who bicker .. SO annoying! My dear friend ( who has since passed) always had this on in the background whenever I would come to visit her… It always gave me a headache. Yuck! Whoopi used to be a Comedian 40 years ago… she was somewhat funny back in those days. Today, I find her tiresome, boring and pedantic… please stop.. the show has reached its prime .. it is so outdated…
THAT'S the word for what "happened" to Whoopie-- she became PEDANTIC! That's what made her error sooo very cringe worthy-- she was practically pounding the table insisting to JOY the JEW that she, Whoopie--, knows better. BIG WHOOOOPSIE!
Let her talk! How are you gonna say it's important for her to talk amd us to all listen while your cutting her off that your out of time. How rude.
Cutoff so rudely mid story....Cuz they got what they wanted, her take on whoopie, after that the rest didnt matter to them. To them she was just blabbin on. Bet nobody else caught that.
@@p.gizzle5226 We caught that, we did. I love Marni Hughes, but it was painful to hear her cut off the words of this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner. NewsNation Now, give this lady a proper-length interview. She wants to tell us what happened to her, and we, the subscribers, want to hear it!
So RUDE to not let her finish!!!! 🤯😤😡🤯😤😡😡😡😡😡
This woman has a good heart ❤️ she will never for get what happened. Her story will be good to hear .
That was not an apology.
Exactly. It seems forced and unsincere. I hope she gets fired. 🙄
So tired of her.
@@lorimiller4301 Same here. She always wants to be right in any argument. It's annoying as AF. 🙄
@@jaguar4120 😁
I’m the granddaughter of Holocaust survivors who studied and has tutored sociology students. Whoopi is not wrong, actually. Judaism is sociologically defined as an ethnicity. Race is purely based on physical characteristics - and Hitler incorrectly tried to make an entire thing about his Arian race being superior to not only Jews, but others like gay and disabled people. Hitler really ingrained this as being an issue of race and it has stuck. However, it was largely an issue of ethnicity and creed in actuality - Hitler just tried to use physical traits as a way to identify these people. It has since been proven in recent years with empirical sociological studies and documentaries that Hitler’s theories about the Arian race and way of defining people’s ethnicities and other inferiorities (in his point of view) by their physical traits alone was wrong - after all, there were many people from all the countries he targeted who were not Jewish who fit similar descriptions.
My grandparents and other relatives who were survivors and have since passed away all saw it just as I described it. People need to use concrete sociological definitions of race (which strictly refers to physical characteristics like skin, hair, and eye color, body type, nose shape, etc.), and ethnicity (which includes country of origin, religion, and other factors) in this sort of discussion and critically examine Hitler’s theories and methods in order to have a meaningful discussion.
I’m not saying that public perception is wrong, but Whoopi is using the same types of definitions to draw her perspective. Black racism is clearly just about skin color - it does not typically include religion, creed, etc. and other such factors on the whole. If the black community is attacked as a whole, we call that racism even if individuals in that group may belong to different religions, come from different countries of origin, etc. since that is the singular common attribute between everyone and is likely the sole reason for the bias. If a single individual black man who happens to also be gay happens to get attacked by someone yelling racial and sexual epitaphs, then it is not strictly a case of racism alone - then it is usually referred to as a case of general bias or it being was targeted due to his race and sexual orientation. It would be wrong to only refer to it as a racial attack.
When you look at the Holocaust, Hitler incorrectly viewed it as a racial issue because he created his own twisted definitions of what race means rather than using the accepted sociological definitions (which already existed thanks to major sociological theorists). But if we all critically examine what occurred to Jewish and other minorities as a whole, it was not strictly an attack on being white. It mostly was due to the fact that he hated people who were Jewish, gay, and disabled (among other minority groups). He did not attack white people who fit the same physical characteristics as those Jewish, gay, disabled, etc. populations that he labeled as inferior.
I’m sorry, but Whoopi is really not wrong. Go back and listen to what she said bearing what I’ve explained in mind. That’s the line of thought that I believe she’s coming from. That’s how most sociological studies have examined the reasons for the Holocaust and why certain groups were targeted by Hitler. Unfortunately, people have been brainwashed by Hitler always talking about his Arian race and only see the Holocaust as a racial issue as a result and/or people are misinformed about the sociological definitions of and differences between race and ethnicity. Even people who went though the Holocaust are often mistaken in their verbiage.
I’m not saying public opinion is wrong. It’s just a bit misguided. Whoopi was really not wrong and should not be punished just because she’s educated herself on sociological definitions and issues. I was lucky to have been educated about this from a strictly sociological and empirical point of view, as well as having grandparents who always raised us to understand that their families were targeted for being Jewish. Synagogues were burned, religious objects were taken and destroyed, they had to wear those yellow identifying Jude stars, and they were sent to concentration camps after being identified as Jews. Nobody said they were going to the camps because they were white. Nobody sent the Christian-Polish neighbors across the street who had the same skin tone, dark brown hair/eyes, etc. that many Jews had to concentration camps - if it was strictly a matter of race, Hitler would have sent those people to the camps too. Hitler just tried to warp people’s minds with his made up theories about his superior Arian race - and sadly, his point of view has misguided people to this day including many survivors. Examine the facts critically, use sociologically accepted definitions. You’ll come to see that Whoopi is is not wrong. She deserves to be put back on the show effective immediately and is owed a massive apology by ABC.
You really think people are going to buy your BS?
@@bittersweet2253 You sound like the misguided one with that response…Reading comprehension is fundamental so try rereading maybe 🤔 you’ll come away with a different perspective..🙂
Hitler took the concept of race to another level. He called the Jews an inferior race, period, and saw them as subhuman. The Holocaust, which killed far more Jews than any other group of people, was indeed about race because Hitler made it about the eradication of the Jewish "race" through The Final Solution, regardless if Jews post-WWII are labeled an ethno-religious group or whatever academia is teaching these days. Take history at its word, and please stop rewriting it.
You should have set aside A LOT more time to allow this woman to say what she wanted to say and express herself and what she went through! Why invite her on if she’s not allowed to say what she wanted to say?!?! This infuriates me!!! She tagged the View bc she wanted to be able to TALK and express what HELL she lived through and educate Idiots that speak out both sides of their mouth!!!! Do better! Your ratings would be BETTER if you allow ppl to talk and express themselves not cut them off when they haven’t even got a full thought out of their mouth yet!
Ugh why ask such and important question only to cut her off.
Lucy, you are a Brave woman. Thank you for your voice.
Old Whoopie better read some history! The NAZIS did not like Blacks any better than the Jews. Not My personal view,but, it's something to think about!
Exactly!
I want to hear her story!! Please let her come over and tell her story.
Holocaust survivor? How old is this lady?! EDIT: holy she's 88! Looks great too!
Bring her back on and let her talk. Thank you for bringing if her is on but bring her back!
I'm Jewish and highly Holocaust literate, and I don't in any way think that Whoopi is ant-Semitic. I doubt that she'd have the last name Goldberg if she was. Her original comment was awkward. it would be different if she was some kind of rabid hater of Jews, but she's not. I, for one, accept her apology and realize that she spoke a bit out of turn. Sadly, there is a lot of anti-Semitism in the world right now, so perhaps the subject deserves more sensitivity. But Whoopi's not a hater, and she's not ignorant, either. I'm for letting this drop.
I agree but there are topics that need to be known before speaking.
RACISM AGAINST THE JEWISH PEOPLE IS NOT COMPARABLE TO OTHER CULTURES
@@americasamericas5782 Why isn't it? How Jewish people are different from the rest of the people? Explain your angry all-caps claim! Why racism against a Jewish person is different from racism against a non-Jewish person?
@@scarlettohara910 I could be wrong but I think Whoopi views race through the eyes of American standards. Think of when you check the box on applications. There is no “Jewish” category. So I think Whoopi views Jewish people as white because that’s probably the box they check in America. So I think she doesn’t/didn’t see the racism because she sees Nazi and Jews as white. However, Hitler and the Nazis viewed Jews were an inferior race. So for them it definitely was racial. Some people killed in the holocaust were considered Jewish because they had a Jewish grandparent. So it was definitely racial. For some reason, Whoopi was unaware of this. Some people have to remember that Jewish can be viewed as both religious and race. Perhaps, Whoopi only views it as a religion. That’s just my interpretation of her comment and her apology. I could be wrong 🤷🏾♀️.
@@happyalice6306 I only view Judaism as a religion as well. No one explains why, when and how Judaism turned from a religion to a race! Did the same thing happen to Christianity, Islam and Judaism? Are they a race too?
@@scarlettohara910 I think some people view being Hebrew as an ethnicity, not a race. People tend to use ethnicity and race interchangeably but they are mistaken.
NOT LONG ENOUGH. SHE SPRAKS SLOWLY, PRODUCERS SHOULD HAVE ALLOTTED AT LEAST 10 MIN TO HER.
SUPPORTING YOU LUCY!!!
GOD BLESS HER. Whoopi should have the decency to talk to this lady, but I doubt she will. HUMANITY ISN’T IN WHOOPI’S DNA. A hater does NOT listen to another’s point of view.
Anyone who would like to hear Mrs. Lipiner tell her story should check out her book titled, ‘Long Journey Home’. There’s also a short interview with her on UA-cam from a radio show/podcast. I thought it was so rude that they cut her off and barely let her speak, ugh.
Whoopi/ The Holocaust wasn't about race
Hitler during his speeches/ We are going to make a superior race.......
To be fair, I never saw Whoopi as a person who actually reads or cares about history.
I honestly didn't know the View was still a thing.
I wanted to hear more 😔 😪 poor thing give her time
It’s a teachable opportunity. Don’t think The View will see it that way
So important she came on but didn't give her much time. You should have blocked out more time for her story. This was poorly done. You look like you were more tryin to expose Whoopie then you were to actually hear her story.
Yes, I agree. What's almost worse than not inviting a Holocaust survivor to share her story, one week after the 77th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, is inviting a survivor to share her story and then literally cutting her off after 5 minutes. I love Marni Hughes, but she didn't even give this survivor a moment to cry about her childhood best friend, Rachel, who was sent as a kid to the gas chambers. Do better, NewsNation Now, and invite this survivor, Lucy Lipiner, back for a proper-length interview. We, the subscribers, want to hear her story!!
What I didn't like about this interview was you didn't let the lady finish her words in the end. ✡ ❤
This woman deserved a longer time slot. You said “we need to listen to holocaust survivors speak” THEN SPOKE OVER HER. This was not a segment that should have been given a short time
Hello, NewsNation Now, please bring this Holocaust survivor, Lucy Lipiner, back on your show, now, for a proper interview of respectful length. It's not just about respect: it's that the horrors of the Holocaust require more than 5 minutes of coverage. I am a first-generation American Jew, and a recent subscriber to your channel because I was impressed by your coverage of Gabby Petito & other missing persons' cases, and I wanted to support your mission. A person going missing or getting murdered is an unimaginable tragedy. The Holocaust was the tragedy of one person's murder multiplied by inconceivable millions, via the staggering barbarism of the Nazis and their collaborators.
I am the daughter of Jewish refugees from Poland, who barely made it out of there alive. Holocaust education needs to be standard in school curricula. Anti-semitism didn't die with the more than six million Jewish souls. Instead, it's rising worldwide. Please, NewsNation Now, live up to the fine example you've set in missing persons' coverage and invite this Holocaust survivor back on your show, now, while the Whoopi Goldberg controversy is still a hot topic in the news, for a full-length segment. Don't rely on The View to do the right thing: set an example and do it yourself.
Don't just say, "it's important to listen." Actually listen to living survivors. There aren't many left. People are hungry for knowledge & enlightenment. People are also looking for ways to use their empathy: it's the kindheartedness & desire to feel & connect with others that's at the core of human nature. Hearing this woman's story isn't just a vital opportunity for viewers, it's good for business. When you do the right thing, you broadcast your reputation. Please take heed of the comments, here, asking you to be true to your own words, and give us "fact-driven, unbiased coverage" of real history and a real story.
Usually love your show, did not like how she was cut off. She was invited to speak.
God Bless
✨Lucy Lipiner✨ & Keep her
❤
Wow Whoopi... she's just sorry she got called out & suspended... shit like that stops the all mighty paycheck for the spoiled lifestyle $$$
Yup. I hope she gets fired. 🙄
Wow, she doesn't look anywhere near 88!! What a beautiful woman. ❤️
So articulately well said Lucy! I stand with you Lucy! I just wish I could’ve heard more of you Lucy❤️
I don't understand why you're always out of time. Baffling
I hate when they do that.
cancel culture Karma
This woman does not look 88 ! What? !
Seems this interview was to piss on Whoopi, interviewer did not LISTEN, she cut her off just wanting to ask about how she felt about whoopis’ comments! She really should of given Lucy more time to talk!
The view is a nothing show take it off the air
Obviously Whoopi faced racism differently. I do think she should be forgiven. Why do we just want to get rid of someone that simply. Marjorie Taylor Greene is still a Republican in Congress after her terrible comment.
Obviously, you and Whoopi did not educate yourself, I’m not going to because you will not learn… you’ll make an excuse to not accept whatever is correct… your parents should of have to deal with you not other people!
I think Marjorie Taylor Greene is different because she’s a politician, but I also think what Whoopi said isn’t as bad as what some believe it to be. She never denied the holocaust or undermined what happened. I don’t think she fully explained her opinion well enough for people to understand what she was trying to say. I think what Marjorie Greene said was way more offensive.
Yeah and MTG is hideous.
you guys should of just spoken about whoopie and not bring this wonderful lady out here to talk about her scary life experience and not let her talk or let her finish. ugh!! HOW RUDE!
Lucy is the only person I want to hear. She is so sweet and humble. Two virtues Whoopi and the rest of the Hags on the view are unfamiliar with
This lady has a wonderful spirit about her and a kindness..it is wonderful that she wants to sit down and teach the Holocaust to these rediculius women.
Important segment, thank you for picking this up, although the VIEW likely will pass. Hope this has the effect of enticing them rather than letting it sit.
YES!! This is so important. I am so glad a survivor is wanting to talk and share and EDUCATE. Whoopie has a past of doing lots of antisemitic things. Naming a recipe “the Jewish American princess fried chicken” and demeaning the Jewish people in so many stupid ways and I would love to know WHY. Why does she feel the need to KEEP doing this? She has done this over and over for ten years. She doesn’t care she just doesn’t want to be cancelled.
God bless this woman Lucy and her family. Like she said not all Jewish people are white I'm black and I'm part Jewish, and Cherokee Indian so you see you never know who is a mixed race my heart goes out to all the Holocaust survivors God bless you all
Whoopi doesn't care she is ridiculous and quite frankly I've been so tired of her and have been 30 of my 52 years
goldberg is horrible loud mean hateful
Please have Lucy Lipiner back!!! Whoopie got all the coverage : (
Thank you Lucy for your bravery
get rid of Whoopi
The View ought to have a Holocaust survivor on, yes. They also should address black bigotry against Jewish people.
It's bigotry all around amongst everyone. I think conversations defintely need to be heard over accusations.
@@jolietia Gee. Is that akin to “All lives matter”? Because yes there is bigotry all around the US, and the world. But in this case, Whoopi Goldberg (who appropriated the name btw)-She tried to reduce the genocide (of a great percentage of the entire, global, Jewish population) into something “petty”. Into some kind of irreverent quarrel, that is meaningless. It doesn’t matter to her, because the killers were white, and to her the Jews (those being killed) were “white”. (Everyone knows that although Jews are technically Caucasian, no one in America considers them “white”. Not really. So this isn’t about “bigotry against everyone”. Your response is demeaning, as well. This, proving the point.
Yeah I was shocked when I watched Whoopi.I am glad she apologized,.I just hope she really gets it!!
Too bad we get told to just forget about slavery... It was so long ago.
Lame of you to cut this lady off... smh...
I'd love this lovely gracious lady to go on The View.
This woman is a sweet and beautiful woman from the heart,please have her back on the show.
woo hoo!! cancel that witch show for good!!
Look up Lucy Jacobs on you tube. She is a family friend and also a Holocaust survivor, she has been interviewed by Steven Spielberg as well. She’s amazing and stills tells her story.
They should let her talk!
Why would Whoopi make such a thoughtless, ignorant statement??
She did not say that it was about white people fighting white people.. she said i5 was not about race, it was about man's inhumanity to other man...
OMG you cut her off? For what?
I am so glad Whoopi can learn a life lesson on life. Please Whoopi go away. Thank the lord In heaven this beautiful woman can tell the truth beautiful woman
She’s out of time but then she just keeps talking and not letting the guest speak
I completely agree with you Lucy. Shame you ran out of time. Couldn’t you have brought her back you quickly ended her important message
I still want whoopie to be taken off the View and the View to be taken off the air. The View alway starts trouble and after they are called out then they have their tail between their legs and we have to feel sorry for them when they enjoy pointing finger at everone.
Two weeks is a sick CYOA joke... But honestly, this show really doesn't have much impact.
American women are way to smart to watch it for more than entertainment value.
I'm so happy they our Nation is beginning to stop being afraid of the delusional far left and right and is grabbing the losers!
The worst kind of bigotry and racism is exactly what whoopi's been on for years...
“It is so important that you come on and share your experience …but we are out of time”. Really? That’s all the time you could spare for Lucy and her story? Tisk tisk
Wow. She looks amazing
Words don’t explain this event well enough.
Does Jewish Joy have an opinion on Whoopi being an anti-Semite?
Wow they really just tried to meet the requirement to have her on the show but the segment really didn’t give her much chance to tell her story, they just met their quota for race relations and then gave her 20 seconds to tell what happened to everyone in the photograph. Pitiful. They were just trying to get someone to forgive Whoopi on national tv… they didn’t care about her story one bit.
This must be taught in school. Too many people dont understand the holocaust. Its also sad that people dont even know about holocaust in Congo. 10 million people murder by king Leopold because of their ethnicity. Thats just one country. We need to learn more about each other.
I want here this lady about her story /Hope her life got better
I think we need another movie about the holocaust. Forget Native Americans and other races that have had act of genocide committed against them
She should take Whoopi place. I hope she gets fired. 🙄
She is pretty much done even if she is suspended for 2 1/2 minutes.
That's what they all say
Time to leave Woopi
yikes. cut her off to tell her how you should listen to her. but since its all about getting that interview first, don’t actually give her the respect and time.
I honestly don't think what she said was so bad It was Inhumane Shes beautiful thus woman for 88
Jewish is a religion, is not a race, a race shares biological characteristics among them, a culture or a religion shares the upbringing, is not the same and I can understand how Whoopie was saying that without wanting to hurt anyone.
It's also a heritage.
Give her time to talk
I’m done ✅ can’t even listen to her talk
NewsNation Now, please heed the comments.
Why would anyone think Whoopi is an authority on anything. Because she’s on a talk show? Whoopi thought it was a good idea for her boyfriend to wear blackface!
The kicker in this...Goldberg is a long time convert to the Jewish faith.
I have a boycott list of people that I refuse to watch on TV or in movies. As a result of her crass remarks Whoopi Goldberg is added to that list. Jane Fonda, Roseanne Barre, Rosie O'Donnell, Mel Gibson, Bill Cosby, Susan Sarandon. Yes I am only one person but I know I am not the only one that has a boycott list. Some 'entertainers' end their own careers due to not thinking before speaking - for that I am grateful. Words and actions have consequences!!!
Pregunta señora whoopi,entonces la esclvitud aqui en USA 🇺🇸 NO FUE POR RAZA??????