Rana Safvi On The Red Fort-Dalmia Bharat Controversy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @shammi1960
    @shammi1960 6 років тому +9

    मोदी के प्रधान मंत्री बनने के 3 साल बाद पता चला कि पकोड़े बनना, ऑटो चलाना, मिस्त्री, प्लंबर, चाय बेचना, सब्जी का ठेका लगाना पहली बार पता चला कि यह भी सरकारी नौकरी हे

  • @vassets
    @vassets 6 років тому +16

    BJP Rss wants to destroy these monuments....change the history......These dogs must be kicked out in 2019...

  • @ravirana809
    @ravirana809 6 років тому +17

    Iss sarkar main aajad bharat ka sabse jayada bhayanak samey.

  • @ankur02gupta
    @ankur02gupta 6 років тому +14

    so you are saying lal kila is already earning 21 Crores per Year, then what was the need for these dalal govt to sell Lal quila to dalmiya house....dalal government.

  • @mannom303
    @mannom303 6 років тому +5

    आपने तो कह दिया कि लालकिला बहुत बुरी हालत में है पर हमने सुना है साहेब चुनावी भाषण में जो पैसे दिए थे उनका कर्ज साहेब चुका रहे है जिसने भी साहेब की मदद की है उसका कर चुका रहा है
    आपने कहा ₹30 टिकट का भाव है जिसमें यह लीज पर लिया है वह कीमत ज्यादा भी कर सकता है उनको तो फायदा ही चाहिए

  • @shammi1960
    @shammi1960 6 років тому +4

    Three years after Modi became the Prime Minister, it came to know that making pakodas, auto driving, mistry, plumber, selling tea, vegetable contracting first came to know that this is also a government job.

  • @farooquesiwani4132
    @farooquesiwani4132 6 років тому

    लाल किला को डालमिया के हाथों में सौंपना नरेंद्र मोदी की खाम नियत को दर्शाता है

  • @myshorts5632
    @myshorts5632 6 років тому +7

    Soon India on sale BJP as seller and buyer? ???????

  • @itsmesamster
    @itsmesamster 6 років тому +2

    Jitne comments aaye, sb chutiyo ne kiye... Ja k padh lijiye CSR (corporate social responsibility) kya hota h... to aap ko pta chal jayega k jo collection of revenue hai wo sara kuch end me ASI k paas jayega na k Dalmiya group k paas. Dalmiya group is supposed to spend money jo unhe apne CSR me dikhani hoti h. Yahi baki monuments k sath b hona h. Khair useless h yha pe kuch kehna... Log prejudices le k hi aaye h video dekhne aur gaali dene.

  • @tribalvoic
    @tribalvoic 6 років тому +10

    देश अजाद होने पर सबसे पहिला तीरंगा लहेराया ..यह इनको समजना चाहिय

  • @srs918
    @srs918 6 років тому +5

    Brilliant analysis by Rana Safvi ji, conservation of the monument is more important than anything else, as usual the government is treading the path of misguided priorities which shows abject failure of policy.

  • @s.c.biswal2737
    @s.c.biswal2737 6 років тому +8

    Why only lalkila? Why not all heritage places like tajmahal, president house, Parliament etc sales to corporate houses like ambani, adani by present govt including country for better administration?

  • @hotelsuryapalace9988
    @hotelsuryapalace9988 6 років тому +5

    i am agree with the madam ,first priority must be for conservation not for bath rooms .

  • @Ashoke141
    @Ashoke141 6 років тому +3

    Recall that high decibel nasal cacophony: "न तो मैं खाऊंगा, न तो मैं किसीको ( मेरे करीब दोस्तों को छोड़के. ) खाने दूंगा, हा. हा हा. "

  • @tribalvoic
    @tribalvoic 6 років тому +11

    जिसे अठारा करोड मिल रहा है तो सरकार उसके उपर खर्च नही कर सकते है क्या ..
    पराव्हेट तो पराव्हेट ही होता है वो तो आपनी मन मर्जी करेगा

  • @amitotsava
    @amitotsava 6 років тому

    मैडम टिकट ऑनलाइन है... इसलिए मुझे लगता है कि टिकट का पैसा सरकार को ही जायेगा

  • @jun2011jh
    @jun2011jh 6 років тому +1

    Shivaji + Patel statue 6600 crores allocated which if build will destroy eco system on shores.

    • @yunushmehri6218
      @yunushmehri6218 6 років тому

      jameel hasan Rana sad hi Adab beautiful discussion Yunus Makrani

  • @aaishgamerandadventure3197
    @aaishgamerandadventure3197 6 років тому +1

    My friends I been to many places in the world in Europe USA China, Jordan Srilanka Ethiopia and seen different manuments and most of that manuments are preserved by theirs government so why not in India.
    When our PM can spent more then 300 carores in travels why not for taking care of indian heritages.

  • @hotelsuryapalace9988
    @hotelsuryapalace9988 6 років тому +3

    Dalmia group is a business house , if he is so worried about the condition of Lal QUILA, they should donate the money according to their love for lal quila to govt for its conservation and all ,as people say this govt is very honest , Dalmias might have full faith on modi govt.

  • @varundesai1044
    @varundesai1044 6 років тому +6

    great expert advise on the matter. bjp n present govts failure to bear expense of its monument. transparency lacking in this matter

  • @ashirwadgrcharoonrashid3907
    @ashirwadgrcharoonrashid3907 6 років тому +4

    Bahut good tafsira

  • @ashrafkhanket7198
    @ashrafkhanket7198 6 років тому

    Achai discuss hai wazahat bhi durust hai.
    Mohtarma Hyderabad ki rehne wali lag larahi hain urdu ka lehja Dakni hai.
    Waise bahut izafa huwa hamare bhi ilm my shukriya.

  • @imamqureshi499
    @imamqureshi499 6 років тому

    افریں۔۔بہت ہی بہترین بات چیت تھی۔اسی طرح تاریخ کے مسائل پر گفتگو کر تے ہیں۔اور لوگوں کو صحیح جانکاری دیں۔رانا صفوی جی آپ تاریخ نویسی پر پروگرام بنائے مہربانی ھوگی۔شکریہ

  • @subodhjain5277
    @subodhjain5277 6 років тому

    There are many other ways to protect and conserve and maintain these monuments. The govt. could have hired experts on contract basis for each monument and the conserving, maintaining and facilities work , specialists workmen could be hired and work could have been done with their help.This would have provided several thousand people with employment that may light up several homes.

  • @Hindian_voice
    @Hindian_voice 5 років тому +1

    Sabd nahi hai bjp or rss k liye merd pass.. Ye sabse bade dushman hindus n Hindustan k he hai..

  • @मरियमहाशमी
    @मरियमहाशमी 6 років тому +12

    Aadab Rana Sahiba, Bahut Dino Baad,, Bahut Accha Laga..Shukriya Zururi Malumat k liye.. 2014 tak toh govt maintain kar rhi thi? abb Hindu Muslim karne Me Govt busy h?

  • @jaimoolnivasijai8560
    @jaimoolnivasijai8560 6 років тому +1

    the wire good thought media

  • @NeerajKumar-ff2qr
    @NeerajKumar-ff2qr 6 років тому +5

    Government officials need to do a good work otherwise these properties will be given to private companies for maintenance

  • @kamalunawane1105
    @kamalunawane1105 6 років тому +2

    सर बहुत दिनोके बाद दिखाई दिए . द वायरके कुछ प्रोग्राम नही देखे तो कुछ खोया ऐसे,लगाता है.

  • @Hindian_voice
    @Hindian_voice 5 років тому

    Conservation, restoration and maintenance

  • @tribalvoic
    @tribalvoic 6 років тому +5

    सही बात बोलना चाहिय सर इन्होने

  • @mrvashist9568
    @mrvashist9568 6 років тому

    1.She is saying these monuments need maintenance.Now govt. Is doing this then what's wrong in that??
    2.She her self saying there is no man power for these monuments,no bathrooms,No handicap friendly but this group will provide all these amenities.. Isn't it great?
    3.That's a old building as she said almost 400years old..can you or anybody else's take guarantee for the same??
    4.Condition of red fort is degrading day by day.it need help.. Kindly let this govt. do their work for the same because previous govt.never paid heed to the condition of these monuments they were too busy in giving subsidies and looting this country.
    5.They will spend 5 crore from their end i.e from CSR
    6.They are adopting it for maintenance and "development". You understand DEVELOPMENT right?? Development includes restoration and conservation too.
    7.They will collect the money from tickets and obviously will give it to the govt.
    8. She has no authentic source for her stats then how the hell she can assume things by her own??
    9.She has no information about the agreement and she is raising question over it...
    10.She is going to write a book over it. Kindly do research first then raise questions.

  • @nitishchidanand2966
    @nitishchidanand2966 6 років тому

    Tukde tukde gang wah👍

  • @amira..a1440
    @amira..a1440 6 років тому +10

    Bahot khoob

  • @mahbubarTalukdar
    @mahbubarTalukdar 6 років тому

    If it is done as it is done in the way it is done in the West, then that’s different story. In the West many archaeological sites or park etc sometime given to big companies who spend their own money as public service to take care of those places or improve it -- this is done mostly for efficiency. Please tell me nobody will steal but money will be put in Lal qillah. Lots depend on honesty or evilness.

  • @malikbhai6047
    @malikbhai6047 6 років тому

    Yeh captilism wali sarkar hai... Or congress bi Shayed Yahi Karti Aaj Jis tarha se RTO toying service ko corporates ke hawale kiya gaya hai os main sarkar ne public ka Kya fida kiya hai...jahan Hum 250/= bhar ke tow wheeler ko leke aate thy wahi Hum ko Abhi 420/= Dena padhta hai 4w ko 400/= Dena hota tha Aaj 640/= Dena padhta hai AAM public ko lota jaraha hai or Kuch nahi.... Ab kya Pata lalkila pe bi tickets ka rate bhade ga parking ka rate bhade ga....sab chor bazari hai or Kuch nahi jo kahi awaz uthata hai oska muh band Kardiya jata hai....... 🙏🙌

  • @mokshamalhotra2332
    @mokshamalhotra2332 6 років тому

    Too many Ads.. The wire has Become "Ad Wire"..

  • @saleemhashmi4131
    @saleemhashmi4131 6 років тому

    Why not this monument should be given to unemployed youth organization to maintain . In this way government can create many jobs for youths , instead of increasing crony capitalists .

  • @user-vp6dx6bp5j
    @user-vp6dx6bp5j 6 років тому

    Ye rss backed bjp ki ek aur chaal hai choro ki tarah... Sabse pehle dalmia ka fayda hoga, Monument conserve hoga k nahi not sure but ye tomar ki haveli zaroor bana denge aur guides bhi yahi bataenge aney wale tourists ko... Kyuki bjp desh hit mey kuch accha soch hi nahi sakti

  • @MohammedMohammed-bj7oj
    @MohammedMohammed-bj7oj 6 років тому

    so an rsslinked group dalmia would look after mughal monuments.

  • @kbslinen8755
    @kbslinen8755 10 місяців тому

    Lal kila agar shahajahan ne banaya hota hoh jama masjid aur lal kila donon ki Disha aik hoti kiblay Makka ki ore
    Aur kila ke sab taraf hindu aabadi sab bare bazar bhi usi taraf
    Yeh vishvashniy nahin lagta
    AAP dalmiya ko koste raho lal gadh ka Satya nikal kar bahir ayega

  • @Buddying_youtuber786
    @Buddying_youtuber786 6 років тому

    Its such a irony where world heritage site and more than that its a national monument from where tricolor is unfurled since independence. Every country respects thier monument of national importance. America doesnt lease Statue of liberty, Paris effil tower, but in India thousand of crores sent publicity statues, etc but cant have money for maintenance of most imp structures. where is all the revenue from tourists is going. It clearly shows thier knowledge, insidious agenda and respect for India.

  • @zakirhussainazad4489
    @zakirhussainazad4489 6 років тому

    Voter's jab appna vote bach daata oss ka bad acha ho y bura janta ko koee haaq nah ban ta
    JAYCEE KAR NE WAY CEE BHARNI

  • @sks_1994
    @sks_1994 6 років тому +4

    Finally government took a good step to keep our monuments clean and attractive ...we have been seeing railways and other government offices suffering from bad management especially toilets...

    • @srs918
      @srs918 6 років тому +1

      Manohar Vajpayee If government cannot preserve its national heritage, they should also hire the corporates to govern the country as well since government is incapable to deliver the basics. These iconic heritage sites give a hefty amount of money to the government which the government cannot make good use of. What a pity!!!!

  • @sunilkhadilkar7161
    @sunilkhadilkar7161 6 років тому

    to my knowledge , not only red fort but many other monuments were given to corporates for maintainance. So why are you discussing only Red Fort?. just because it is mogul (muslim) monument?

  • @vinodbajaj8076
    @vinodbajaj8076 6 років тому +5

    I thinking Why some one Alpsankyaka majority are still not opposed. Second- Why some Muslim Big party are not claimed that red fort They can do All care of Red fort. Jai hind

    • @aaishgamerandadventure3197
      @aaishgamerandadventure3197 6 років тому +1

      Vinod Bajaj this is not belong to only Muslims, this is Indian pride for all indian so we all must make objection on this lease.
      But don’t worry time will change

  • @sushmasharma1555
    @sushmasharma1555 6 років тому

    vo private group bharat ka nahi hai kya, criticism karne se pahle historical monuments ki halat dekh lo. government agencies ki halat kya hame pata nahi agar private group paisa de deta hai to kya bura hai khud kuch karo mat bas har cheez ko criticise karo.

  • @debasishtripathy8004
    @debasishtripathy8004 6 років тому +1

    Please say something about #rape in madarsa
    # Justice for geeta

    • @aaishgamerandadventure3197
      @aaishgamerandadventure3197 6 років тому

      Debasish Tripathy yes we all are bored by temples rapes and yogi babas rapes stories so bring something new.😜😜

  • @tribalvoic
    @tribalvoic 6 років тому

    बकावस कर रहे हो

  • @muzafarahmadbutt9260
    @muzafarahmadbutt9260 6 років тому +9

    Shame on bjp

    • @shammi1960
      @shammi1960 6 років тому +2

      muzafar Butt केवल मोदी भागतो के लिए, झूठ से झूठ ही छिपता है सच नहीं मित्रों

    • @anandad4965
      @anandad4965 6 років тому +1

      muzafar Butt
      Why shame on BJP....?????

  • @sameersameet3988
    @sameersameet3988 6 років тому

    Bohut khoob