I remember when people were arguing with me, a once AUT tester, about how YBA would instantly die once aut dropped, not realising just how buggy it was and going off on 2 sneak peaks.
True, YBA has his bugs and all, but AUT just survived 2-3 days, in the hallowen update they died faster than I thought, from 40k to 20k, they did good and bad decisions, but the game is still good
@@Elpapurandomxd123 yeah, horrible desicions like adding yasuo and yone. i think that's waht caused people to quit aut, since they're extremely overpowered. the devs did a poll on if they were balanced, expecting truth, but most of aut's playerbase being people that want to abuse extremely overpowered specs to in obviously said yes. Yasuo and yone both have a true 70% combo, which led me to quit. It would be fine if it took some skill like mih's combos, but they don't since the moves have huge hitboxes and stun. in my opinion, the combat of the game needs to be reworked, they don't need to make new combat, but at least adding s after having used a move that should not combo extend. i think it's quite evident that the 70% combos are bugs, since they involve attacking after using moves that deal knockback.
@@koenigseggpeta4360 I was playing AUT after halloween update and some yone started attacking me and dude i cant even do anything, stun is so much that i cant even move and it does like my %70 hp. AUT was better before halloween event imo, balance system sucks
@@domseyboi they say that AUT is a balanced gsme where the balance doesn't exists, in YBA you need skills, braincells and is balsnced, having max vitality gived you max life, and everyone can have max life, boxing gives extra, but it still has balance.
I honestly prefer YBA’s combat and pvp system, I love the “build your own playstyle” type of gameplay from YBA, the fact that any stand can be good is refreshing. YBA’s pvp system also feels more rewarding, as fights last way longer, however the largest downside is that when something is unbalanced, its much more noticeable and annoying
Yba is good other than how you get those things i just wish there was a samdbox mode of where people can try make the best build possible because a lot of builds i have to come up in my head but only one didnt work and that was jaw breaker into inhale on star plat but any other ragdoll still works and i still have sp boxing on an alt
@@Henry-dn2xb that’d probably kill the main modes, because imagine if you could just go into sandbox and get whatever for free, would you even play normal yba anymore?
@@free5343 people would play normal yba for arrows and to just talk with others about the game, but you shouldnt be able to just use any stand in sandbox you should probably have to unlock it to test
I think the customisability is one of the reasons I play YBA more than AUT too. I agree with you when you mention things like skill trees, although my favourite feature of YBA is specs, since they add an extra layer to every single build and can potentially transform the way you play a stand if you're using a certain spec. The problem is that AUT doesn't have this kind of system and it never could; once you've seen an ability you've seen all it has to offer. The replay value of YBA is just higher because of the amount of possibilities for builds which is why I keep coming back to YBA and why I think it's the more played game.
Bro we all know the real answer ITS BECAUSE AUT IS BALANCED AND YBA IS A BROKEN STAND ARENA It's more fun when your stand can just one shot any one who needs skills
@@dominicballinger6536 It's quite good for me, they added presents that spawn on map with 0.5% chances but the time idk and from comp sbr you can get present with 10-20%, from 1v1s its 4% from 2v2s 1% but from presents you can get limited specs and cosmetics and they added shinies they look good tho
A universal move in fighting games I don't see most of the time are combo breakers/reflectors. Basically they're used in stun to launch the enemy back, stunning both you and the enemy, resetting the gameplay back to neutral. Maybe AUT can link this combo breaker universal move to the block stamina, because I think it would be super good for the stupid infinite combos in AUT.
or maybe a sparking system like dragon ball fighterZ, when you activate sparking you will knockback and stun the enemy, your regen is increased, you have a slight buff on all attacks, stun decreased slightly, duration is only 10 seconds, and sparking wont be available until you die to a person. In 1v1's it'll be different, sparking buffs is still the same, the things that are changed is that when you use sparking and you die to a person in 1v1's you won't get another sparking for the whole match, sparking will build up each time you die if you're not using it, ex: when you first die, sparking will glow orange and when you die to your last life your sparking will glow red, what that means is that the sparking buffs will be increased whenever it changes colour. thats my suggestion for AUT and send feedback if you think there is something is unbalanced.
This. A lot of people miss the fact that the reason why actual fighting games are playable is because they have defensive options so getting hit by a jab does not spell game over. Good examples include Mortal Kombat breakaways(and the game’s many other defensive options), JoJo EOH combo breaker, and DBFZ sparking(as Kozo mentioned)
@@twohomiesplayingjojogames6748 no, there's a game called Offbeat Journeys, which has a combo breaker function similar to DBFZ or GGR. And I don't think you understand what I was talking about, as KC's time erase move in NTJJG can't be used to bail (from my prior knowledge, tell me if i'm wrong) from combos.
AUT Pros: -Frequent updates -Almost all content is free -Devs post sneak peaks to keep fans entertained Cons: -Lots of bugs every update -Wonky mechanics -Extremely unbalanced abilities upon release YBA Pros: -Decently balanced stands (controversial) -Very well made updates -Very diverse combat Cons: -Updates take eons to come out and no sneak peaks -Extremely toxic community (with the staff being worse at times) -Gamepasses are extremely expensive In conclusion, both games have their pros and cons depending on what type of player you are, and most things people will like while other hate.
there are sneakpeaks. Just go on his patreon. And before you complain about him having a patreon, god forbid a 15 yr old kid wanting income As for gamepasses. Tbh besides there being no spec storage freebie, ion mind gamepasses and what they do for the game. Rest i agree with though.
Probably the best video you could have made, possibly ever for these two. Wholeheartedly agree with the part where uzu should hire others who can do his job with/for him, but yeah, it's never that simple. I really hope it resonates with both dev teams cause what you're saying is extremely important. Good stuff my guy
While I think both games are fine, I feel one of AUT's biggest issues is lack of testing. The rate at which we get AUT updates are nice in comparison to YBA, but the amount of bugs/balancing issues present with each new update is just disheartening and could 100% be improved with more in depth testing of new content. YBA doesnt suffer from this issue in the same way AUT does. YBA's lack of updates, and more specifically, content updates means that there arent many new bugs present to the game. YBA does however fail in the fact that the bugs that do exist often times go unfixed for months, and many of them are detrimental to certain stands (i.e Knives). At the end of the day though I really cant say which is better than the other, and thats mostly down to personal preference.
One thing i have to say is that if the new aut came out the same time as yba/had the same time as yba to make updates and all that, it would be really good, with the speed they do things
Honestly why more people play YBA: It just appeals more to the casual audience while also having a decent complexity for more competitive players. Everyone knows that most people casually play games and not taking everything too seriously. But there are also players who enjoy playing games more seriously and investing time into finding the optimal battle strategy. Funnily enough, the customisation is what makes it fun as well. It allows Casual Players to use whatever they want and it will mostly work while more competitive players can find the ultimate combination of spec and Stand power (Boxing go brrr).
I agree but I feel as if yba just as a really nice community and overall more enjoyable public servers, people are always in one area socializing (near the arcade) and aut is usually just a whole mess with it’s laggy map and boring and crappy rkers.
@Suus can't say much about aut because I haven't played it in a long time but he's basically spot on with yba minus servers with a group of toxic players, and the occasional rking because it's either grind fight or idle in main game And also the server wars that start after a group of people teamed on others too much and now there's more than 4 people that want to see them crumble In aut I'm guessing people just go around attacking others because of quests that require kills or dmg
I feel the difference in YBA and AUT is like Smash Bros. Melee and Ultimate, one is semi competitive and less glitchy, and The other is SUPER buggy but very competitive
That’s why I like yba more then aut. The grinding is hard and long and takes days. I am a hard grinder gamer so I love it when I grind for days just to get one thing, whilst for aut it has less grinding and isn: as hard. You just complete what’s on your screen and that’s it.
To be honest, the only reason that i still play YBA was because of the memories made in the game. Memories of doing sbr with gang members, winning 1v1s, doing 2v2s with other people. Gang wars, farming for a stand and getting hyped when you got the stand that you desired. I played YBA since 2020 and have thought of quitting the game because of the toxicity, exploiters, the ridiculous ammount of farming i have to do, and lack of updates. I have tried not playing YBA again but i just kept on coming back. Even if my gang disbanded, me becoming gangless, without anyone to play yba with, alone, no one to help you fight. In the end, i kept on coming back. It isn't obsession or anything, it's just how much of a thrill YBA has. AUT has the large variery of stands, specs, and movesets sure. Project star had the wits to compete against YBA if only they had more devs and all. TB2 has the varierity of characters, and the special moves the characters have. But they lack updates to keep the hype up. And my conclusion to this is, YBA is almost a masterpiece. And it is hard to stop playing after the things you've experienced in the game. First time getting a rare stand, first time winning sbr, first time winning 1v1s and so on. Sure it has its downsides like exploiters and the group of toxic players there. But after all, why should we stop playing it?
Personally, I think AUT is a really good game with great animations and models, but it's the lack of content that really dries the playtime fast. I originally first joined YBA because I heard about the storyline aspect of it and that was really interesting at the time, but once you beat the storyline 4 times, get TWOH and MIH, and get max prestige, it's time to move on. I agree with what you said about YBA's content + AUT's animations and models could make a really REALLY good and entertaining game to play on the daily. The problem is that in every attempt to make a jojo game better than YBA or even atleast AUT, it fails miserably because of multiple reasons. 1; theres is literally no more unused names for jojo games. Every jojo game says something related to 'bizarre' 'adventure' 'jojo(s)' 'crusader(s)' 'star' 'infinite' 'day' and the list goes on. 2; content gets so dry with these games that people play them, completely max out everything in the span of a week or two and they return to AUT or YBA. Lastly, the playerbase/community is what really controls these games. I guarentee that if literally every single YBA/AUT player complained to the devs that the game is dry and they will quit if no updates are dropped, the devs (if they actually care about their game) will probably work on an update. That's basically it, I don't really play YBA or AUT anymore so yeah that's all.
Since AUT released I had a kinda bad feeling about it. My friends started playing, begging me to try it. Eventually I did, and I had fun for a few weeks. Got most of the stands ingame and it just got boring, so I switched permanently to YBA. I really think that AUT's problem is that it focuses too much on PvP and PvE, and not really on the actual main game.
Well said Eclipse i hope Uzu will get his passion to make yba better again so this game can be better again and i hope aut will get thier lost players back
This is true. The farming system in YBA sucks. I was literally for an hour in my priv and couldn't find a single Rokakaka. I even invited my friend who had item grind hacks and as it turned out, the server had no rokas.😐 Oh, and by the way, Eclipse can you add chapters to your movies? It would be helpful (at least for me)
As a YBA main, when I started playing AUT I was really confused at how easy the combo making was. I mean using YBA hard combo tactics that do a tiny amount of damage absolutely shreds peoples hp in AUT. I was disappointed in the stun on the M1s and got bored of it really quick
M1s doing stuns is literally the nor of any pvp game. I personally think YBA have no stun on m1s is horrible, the only reason Uzu even removed stun from m1s is cus man was too lazy to balance dmg and moves. Also YBA combos aren't rly hard, it's literally just use moves while in AUT it's, use moves + m1. But hey, that's just my opinion, you enjoy what you enjoy.
@@YaBoiAshX Even tho this was 2 days ago, I now like AUT's system after I met a guy who somehow deflected all of my combos. Also I think that irl if someone punched u you wouldnt just be able to punch back in a matter of milliseconds. So yea. I'm an AUT main instead of a YBA main now
One of the most important mechanics in fighting games is a recovery mechanic. Dragon Ball Xenoverse has a mechanic called vanishing, where as long as you have stamina (which hardly regens), you can vanish out of hitstun. If you break someone's stamina, you just get to beat on them. In YBA, this mechanic is Stand barrage typically, with a few exeptions (Six Pistol's Improved Dashes). If someone overuses their defensive mechanic, they get hard punished (DBX has stamina break, Stand Barrage deals huge damage, and can only be stopped by another Stand Barrage or something of the sort.) In AUT, if you fail to block or dodge, you get beaten on...and if you don't get some sort of frame perfect dodge, sometimes the combo even gets looped...no one likes that.
There’s an amazing game called “World Of Stands” It’s currently shut down (although it was openly tested a few days ago) It has: A storyline A level system AMAZING CUTSCENES No jacksh*t Arrow percentage Skins aren’t ridiculously rare Things that AUT could do to literally easily obliterate YBA’s player count: Dungeons and more gamemodes Events and a storyline Exclusive stands and specs for the storyline Multiple storylines (each part) OR a linked massive storyline
new aut messed up hard by basically deleting most of what the game was, get a stand then go on a journey (normally either killing a boss, trading and waiting for it to spawn) and then using the stand. its like how stw was something that took time to get but now its just a chance from a normal arrow
@@toniskangur7519 for me the stw part actually makes sense, like why would you sacrifice your evolved stand (TW) to get the first version of the stand (STW).
Eclipse puts up some rather great points, but simplified, yba has progression that is rewarding, and no matter which stand you have, you can kill another, its gonna take usage of your brain to really think, "Is it worth getting this skill?" in yba the combat system is just so harshly diverse! Meanwhile aut is just a copy paste of the average jojo game but "better" just because of its graphics?
ye, aut is basically your normal jojo game with a few other specs and stands plus better graphics but thats literally it, its like abd but more custom and better graphics
90% of AUT fans just went by the logic "Good graphics/Good vfx = Good game!" When looking at the sneakpeeks before the game was even out, proceeding to claim it was the "YBA Killer." The game then dropped, was buggy and unbalanced as shit and well YBA just sort of sat there unscathed.
@Volt problem is, people are tired of yba and want something better. Yeah YBA is cool but it has some very glaring problems. They hoped AUT would fix it with their game. But it didn’t.
I like YBA for the diversity in builds. Like sure there's the meta, but then there's obscure stuff that's busted together that nobody plays or knows how to fight against. In AUT the stand you get is the stand you get and that's it.
Yba is way more developed than aut but since yba has been having a big lack of updates and new content, a lot of players would rather play aut which is a game that regularly gets updated. I still think yba is the best roblox jojo game tho
I feel like a great way the yba developers could become less bored of developing strictly jojo stuff is creating uncanon jojo things more stuff like kcr
honestly it's just that I like YBA's combo system where it's really quick, you either lose really hard or win really hard, mistakes make you stronger they say
YBA's combat system has three categories: You stomp the opponent, it's a long, drawn-out fight of equal skill and you both sneak picks at each other, but no significant damage is made, or you get completely stomped. There is nothing but that.
If no one remembers, there was a game called Stand Upwrite, and it had skill trees and unique atributes for their stands, the game was also provided with levels, dungeons, along with depth of development. Stand upwrite was very successful due to the fact that your attribute determined your winning or losing. Most people would think that this is a bad thing, but with these unfair power scales, the game shifts from just fighting mindlessly to a more rpg-like and social game. People would log on to chat with friends and do missions, so the thing AUT should be aiming for is something that includes more RPG ASPECTS and a way to make the game more SOCIAL. Roblox players love social games, and some of the top games are games where you basically just chat with a few twists. This, along with stands and abilities could make for a great game that could 100% beat YBA.
I remember playing Stand Upright and it was pretty similar to YBA, but in a different manner. The one thing I didn’t like about the game was the fact that there was the characteristic factor when getting a stand (ex: Divine, Permistic, Brave). Sure, you could get the stand you wanted, but chances are that it’s much weaker than the same stand, but with the rarer characteristic. This made the game a bit unbalanced as this meant that only players that have the same kind of characteristic could only compete with each other, leaving weaker players out of the question to even fight them as they’d get RK’d for who knows how long. Other than that, I enjoyed the game and had a great time with it.
Agreed, stand upright is really fun once you get a very good attribute of a stand, its like dragonball with the powerscaling and stuff but in a jojo game
The reason I play YBA more nowadays is that AUT isn't as wacky and fun as it used to be. Most of the moves I liked didn't even get a balance or nerf, just a straight removal or replaced with something completely different that what they once were. I liked the fact that some stands had a stronger stand jump than others, and that nearly every stand or spec had a traversal move. I dislike the fact that most "rare" or hard to get stands were revoked from every player that obtained the original just to be replaced with a better looking, worse functioning version of what it once was.
i feel like if aut added social elements, such as dungeons mentioned in the polls, 2v2s, gangs, sbr, etc. it'll have a massive boost in their playercount, and if they make the main game map actually playable on low-end edit: yes i know stuff like dungeons & sbr were polls, and had positive results, and that 2v2s are basically confirmed, and that the map is confirmed too, but i was just commenting how it'd MASSIVELY help
Definitely agree. Updates are frequent but all they add that really contributes to gameplay is a new ability. People then try to get this ability and play with it a little bit and then what?
I'm pretty sure they said on the discord server that once they're done with making the map optimised they're gonna focus on the story in some way (they didn't specify it was a quest line or dungeons)
@@FluffyAxel no, i tend to disagree; although aut and stand upright do have some similarities, 2v2s aren't unique, neither is sbr, not really, and gangs were in old aut; overall it'd just be a giant social update, beneficial for all parties
My YBA playtime is definitely up there because of the shiny grinding, and it's understandable that it's dumb to shiny farm. But honestly, shiny farming is an excuse for me as someone who's done almost everything I can in the game to keep on playing sbr, to have fun times and etc with my friends. Even if it's a lot of wasted time, lmao.
if I could wish ONE thing about this I would wish that AUT and YBA would set aside their differences and work together to make the best Jojo and others game ever. all they have to do is see who does something better that way the better person can work on it. BIG BRAIN!
whenever i play aut i feel like im playing some alpha game that needs 2 more years of work put into it for it to be functional and yba feels like it only need 6 months more of work to be functional
Playing with stands on aut feels real basic compared to yba, like the lack of customisation (picking whether you want a move or not and being able to change your keybinds), another thing I like alot is specs cause depending on the spec you pick it can change ur playstyle. Also in my opinion stands feel better in yba. (Mb for waffling)
YBA is winning because its JJBA, its based on one thing instead of 60 different topics. YBA also has less lag, and is genuinely sometimes more enjoyable. AUT has better stand attacks and animations, but is too leggy, and you can't even play AUT on mobile due to the fact that that the new map is too massive and leggy along with the graphics.
The only laggy thing in YBA they need to fix is the fact that killer queens explosions lag the hell out of mobile and crappy pc users (Including myself).
If I’m correct, I believe a while ago AUT was considering a storymode or something similar to YBA so that there was something to do. I think they added this skin system and what not to being a way to be rewarded for completing story quests
Imo the problem is lack of content relating to jojo references. There are more specs than actual jojo related stands Many people dont even care bout specs,half the community dosent even know where it's from. If they add actual stands there is a chance people might look back. Another thing is the map.....(you know) It's just better to make a simple map that isn't huge nor small. Last and final fault imo is the grinding method and the npcs Bosses are way to strong and ignore stun,npcs can m1 in middle of a barrage (sometimes)and the grinding method is just so bad If they fix these faults they can regularly update the game with small updates and get the same mediocre fanbase each time.
actually that makes it more apealing to more players not to only jojo fans more fans the map thing is true but its not about the uncanon stands its more so about the amount of times the updates are worse then the last
AUT is less enjoyable than YBA for me, AUT has alot of abilities but once you get the good ones it kind of loses it's replayability value, it has cool animations, but that doesnt overshadow the combat which is pretty bad if you ask me , most abilities overshadow others alot (like how broly overshadows almost every stand ability) and I think that comes down to lack of proper testing, most if not all attacks have so much stun for no reason at all ( which makes it impossible to escape combos), and the grind is pretty alright (like grinding for shinies), but it can get really bad (like grinding for abilities like tusk) . YBA on the otherhand has alot of replayability, and that comes to the spec + stand combinations you can make in the game (for example anubis + pluck), the animations are good but not as good at AUT's, the combat is alot better (considering that you can parry moves, and actually cancel combos that aren't true, unlike aut where you can't escape combos unless you have a broken spec like broly which gets stun for no reason at all) and the grind is more bearable, but it can get boring at times ( like trying to grind for a skins ).
@@alphetti4348 Yeah, getting bored of a stand+spec combination? No worries, you can research for builds or standspec combinations that tend to look strong, fun or viable, heck the game has about a total of 38 stands, there are 5 specs and one specless 38 stands x 5 specs = 190 stand comhinations 190-220 stands and specs when combined (220 if we included basic specless stands on their own) This just tells me how wide your choose pool is with YBA if you want to use something else
@@jameslol6743 literally didn't ask, I am talking about the grinding for the stands OVERALL, I also took 3 seconds to make SPTW, but took me ages to get SP
This is a really interesting analysis, and I think that both games have hurt their player count in different ways. AUT's main thing was the new universe update that made things reasonable to get as opposed to the old universe that was winning over YBA because you had to sit in a private server for hours and hours on end to get the things you want like it pretty much is with skins in YBA. YBA's main thing (my opinion, after the update hype dies down) is gonna be the addition of trading given that if someone was grinding for star platinum and they got whitesnake 3 times, they wouldn't have to lose faith in the RNG gods and roka it since they can now just go and trade it for the other stand they wanted as opposed to how things worked before christmas.
My thoughts exactly. AUT's "New Universe" update kinda broke the game in multiple ways, and instead of rewarding grinding and patience, you could go get Star Platinum and suddenly you can fight any stand with a bit of practice. YBA, while VERY similar to this *cough* Aeroshit *cough,* still rewards the committed and the determined who want to get stands like Made in Heaven and The World: Over Heaven, which take a long time to get (excluding trading for them).
For me it might because of the whole "new universe" thing, the upgraid is great, but after the new universe came out most of the the stand/character that we farm for have been erase, even tho its ok for those who's new but it totally not for me
All of the things the made the game fun like Casey, Zenith, Hermit purple and the meme stands like Made in Walmart, Sprite Cranberry, etc. All those things together made the game fun and they ripped it away from us by turning the game heavily based on pvp with most stands being broken, pvp, the whole thing they're going for, isnt fun (LIKE NOCTURNUS DOES INF STUN BECAUSE OF BLEED AND DOES A RIDICULUES AMOUNT OF DAMAGE, or how p//s hasn't gotten a single update but we've had 4 new specs and skins for p//s) Moral of the story, they turned aut into something the community didnt want, pve into pvp. RIP 90% of the stands that made the game fun
Personally like aut more than yba for my own reason but I have to admit yba is currently winning even if this never was a contest. Still don't know what people are doing in yba
I knew yba wouldn’t lose it’s just that a part of me hope it would lose a lot of people playing so the devs pay more attention to the game and have more updates but yba always has 20k and more players in the game no matter what time it is
One of my biggest issues is that YBA actually gives you a reason to get hard to get stands like TWOH because they’re actually strong, but in aut all the end tier stands either suck a lot or are stupidly overpowered while pretty much every arrow and easy to get stand is busted
In yba, you can get so creative with the builds and do what you want, so with specless included, every new stand is multiplied by 6, not to mention skill trees. And, if you experiment with it, you can find a brand new build that's super powerful, and have fun with it. This is proven by my experience with top players. I've fought 3 top players in total, and 2 of them had creative builds that I never even thought of and combo in amazing ways. One had cmoon pluck, and the other had Hermit pluck, and while those sound like ba dideas on paper, they made amazing combos that work incredibly well. That's why yba has more players, the freedom of being able to be creative with your build is what makes yba so cool. P.s. the cmoon pluck user used that cause he could pilot right after crescent slash and confirm uppercut, creating an infinite, and the pluck Hermit would use grapple and use pierce strike while grappling to confirm vine trap. If that isn't proof you can experiment with builds what is?
We currently have 38 solo stands and 5 specs in YBA, they can also be combined uniquely depending on your choices or how you want a meta or casual spec + stand combination Also, you can make up to 190 stand+spec combinations in total (if we include the basic no-spec-non-combined stand like they're just their own, then we'd have like 228 stands in total) while also being able to shift and adjust/modify your build and how you want to make the combination work, which moves you want to sacrifice to make one better, YBA has a HUGE field of what you want to use specifically than just one solo stand like most jojo games
with the "jojo hurts yba" thing, instead of maybe adding canon stands with their canon movesets, they could add less popular canon stands with unique movesets like they did with anubis, or more requiem stands so that they'll have more freedom, the only problem with this is that it takes time to implement, which the yba devs hate.
I think the sad fact of the matter is here is what we're left with. We have a good game with a developer who is resting on his laurels knowing full well there are problems and money will keep flowing even if he doesnt fix them, moderators and staff who treat their community like shit and cant manage at all. Then we have a pretty mediocre jojo game with developers who give a shit (albiet have a bad track record if the stolen asset fiasco is anything to go by), actually want to improve the game, and know that money will only keep flowing if they continue to improve. It honestly feels like the only way yba is gonna get any proper improvement is if a new developer picks it up and actually starts trying because uzu obviously doesnt feel the need to. (which he is a kid and is in school so its not like he doesnt have real life responsibilities, all the more reason to get another developer to handle more consistent updates)
Personally I disagree on AUT being mediocre. It's certainly better than a lot of other Jojo games out there, and the combat is pretty alright. Bugs are fixed pretty consistently, so I wouldn't personally call the game mediocre. That said, I do agree. Even if AUT was mediocre, I'd take it any day over a good game with a bad community and lazy devs. While most people say you should separate the art from the artist, in the case of the developers, knowing the passion they feel (or lack thereof) really makes a difference on the gaming experience.
I prefer yba for the combat system, the movements system, sbr, cosmetics (i know it sounds stupid but it's another reason to play sbr for example) the customisation of your moves, the storyline and the well made npcs. I played a lot of aut when it came out but after grinding some stands i obviously lost interest. And that's a shame because yba has problems that hardly ruin the game (cheaters, bugs, toxic people) and devs aren't even thinking to do something. If yba had the actual aut devs it would be the perfect jojo game.
I would say either reduce the stun time in aut or add a new mechanic where you can only string a combo for sometime before the opponent is flung away. Also add some way to counter stuns or avoid it like increase s in dodges or have some moves that can be used while stunned but they go on cooldown for a longer time
I loved YBA until I played AUT, and then I didn't touch YBA for at least a month, but my issue is one mentioned in the video. I don't have an interest in the "rare" stands that take grinding to do, besides mabye 2 of them. Once I got all the stands/specs I wanted in AUT, and exhausted using them all, I had no need to go back. But I have since then played another alt account on YBA to max prestige again, just to have new builds. The longevity of customisation and prestiges definitely beats the longevity in getting the 6 stands you want and calling it a day.
My opinion on why most people (including me) choose to play YBA and not AUT -The combat sytem of YBA is really good. You dont get punished for other people landing m1s on you -More stand options -More customizations. For example using X stand with X Specs -Trying to find really good combos with different specs and stands -Teams gamemode, Solo game modes - Hard Challenges like getting corpse parts - Trying to wipe sbr servers with X Stand and specs - Team wiping people with friends - A storyline that you have to finish - Forming teams in main game to eliminate the server -Skin system (even tho its bad cuz its based on luckiness, people still like it cause they can flex their stand skins) -Even tho it updates years later the updates are HUGE. (these are my opinions, you are allowed to have ur own so please dont argue)
@@glacialblast2588 the problem with auts shinies is that they're so easy to get they almost have no value, as they're basically all worth the same. This is a huge double edged sword as there's no longer a trading economy and really no reason to collect shinies since they're mostly worth the same, also the purpose of shinies is to be rare. Auts shinies are not rare at all, it's not impressive to have a shiny in aut, they're just skins you buy.
@@glacialblast2588 "a rare skin is in the shop and my daily quest will give me enough, let me just do the quest, buy the skin, equip it, and then just l e a v e!"
I think it really just boils down to YBA being like a Triple A game, while AUT is more like an indie game. One tries to appeal to the people while the other tries to get the most out of their audience. One is objectively better in some regards, but the other is made to make a profit and they succeed.
Man I always log in to yba to just have a fun FFA with random players, sometimes getting ganged , getting others ganged , find new friends, be toxic , not be toxic. U get the idea, yba is probably not dead cause of this, it's the only reason why it's not boring.
I agree. And I would redo the whole story using alt account to not waste something dumb. So far I really needed a freaking a spec store for idk a year? I keep need to sell my items and killin boss I wasted over 100,000 money I'm sure since got 5 alt acc in YBA. And I agree what eclipse says. Damn my pain of wasting my time redo grinding
While yes aut has had so many bugs and just plain unbalanced stands, they fix them as fast as they can and seeing that yba is basically muuuucchhhh older i think it's meh to critique aut on it. I would love to see how aut would look like if it had as much time as yba
another great part of the skill tree is it allows relatively bad stands to become really good when you unlock specific skills, like likes look at it like this, beach boy can go from borderline useless to a beast if you practice with him and unlock points to use on him. This is amplified with specs and character upgrades and all
Ima be honest with you guys, the reason why yba is so good or lasting right now, because it has more content or things to do than aut, like grinding levels, making builds with specs, fighting people, all this has it going for yba, aut has none of this besides fighting people and even then its not that much fun because yba keeps it random, as in you can see a the hand pluck and it somehow works, its the randomness that yba has that you dont know what you are to expect next, maybe some stands like twoh are presictable because they always run boxing because hamon or pluck doesnt work to well with twoh. But my point still stands, aut does have its good stuff, like graphics specs/stands, good effects, new ways to grind, decent ish bossfights(tho need to work better because they have no stun) and bigger map, but it lacks any early content besides auto grinding stands like stories or level grinding or skill tree making,( i love skill trees and yba nailed it with not being able to unlock everything) as well as every stand is almost different on how there moves work, what yba doesnt have going for it is animation which is lame, every single rage/awakening uses the same animation, and rage bars yell the same RAAAAA, atleast they got voicelines back, anyways, i feel like they both have there ups and down but yba has more going for it
True, main problem would be even if you get 200+ ping, you'd struggle and your stand delays every move, but if you do have below 200 you're gonna have some fun
The thing that annoyes me the most in yba is that we get an update every 2-3 months and when we get an update it includes like 4 codes, a bug fix out of 10 bugs and that updates doesnt really include much content
As always the things you say are true and make sense but sadly a big problem whit yba is that some people's are scared of doing pvp because they are scared of getting laughed at or being trash talked and that's very sad because yba combat is fun
I playing yba now too because it has more stands than aut and aut just has the same moves like you doing the same things but on the yba there is hamon,boxing,pluck,spin 2v2 gamemode and sbr gamemode the combat of yba is good too and it has a skill tree
like you kinda said yourself eclipse the m1s in aut just have too much stun and yba have almost none so you have to use moves to start a combo instead of just m1s and thats why i like yba more
Honestly, even know AUT has “unique” stands, they kinda feel like carbon copies of each other. They either do something like TS, Have generally SP or TW strength or just are a LITERAL copy of SP or TW with just an edgy design. I think YBA is a lot more fun because the abilities are actually different from each other- and although there is cheese stands, there’s a much less drastic difference between what’s trash and what’s good, It’s the opposite for AUT. I feel even if a stand is trash in YBA you can still make the most of it, and if you’re skilled, slap top tier stands.
@@vnmememan8657 the lack of updates could easily push yba into the deeper side of roblox, meaning less new players, meaning the game would die eventually
Eclipse I’ve always wanted to make a JoJo game and I’ve been looking at a bunch of different games and jotting down notes about what makes those games good, I’m thinking about doing development as a career and I genuinely believe I can probably dethrone Yba, however ur probably gonna have to wait quite a few years 😅, I’m just mainly worried about people hating on me to “copying” but I will make all my assets myself and stuff.
To me, it's just because AUT’s combat feels so floaty, and clunky. Attacks while having stun, have little to no oomph and combat is such a slog. You described it perfectly, it feels like footsies. To me it's even less satisfying than games like A A with similar combat mechanics because at least the combat there is more responsive and "felt".
Also another big problem in AUT is it's TS Basically, whenever somebody activates TS, the players that are affected by it can see what the TS user is doing, the user isn't stuck in the same position they were in from the pov of the people. Seeing the TS user move from X to X is an irritating thing, because then you'd know what they're doing or where they're going. Implementing a mechanic where you can't see or know what the TS user is doing/going would be really great and realistic
Honestly I feel like the reason I keep on going back to YBA is because of it just has more playibility than AUT, even thought updates take several months and no sneak peaks are given to the community. AUT’s problem lies in how easy it is; there’s no story mode, no real grind you have to do for anything or at least no grind that compares to trying to obtain mih or twoh in YBA. Not saying that YBA is perfect in fact both games have serious problems that need addressing especially YBA with uzu too blinded by money and having lost all passion for the community. In conclusion although the way YBA keeps its player count is usually by people wasting days grinding for a stand and people doing stupidly hard quests, it works YBA has more players because it’s so grindy and AUT isn’t grindy enough
The reason is because when you play AUT it starts with only you on the server if you press the servers below it says 1 of 1 aloud Meaning it's only the Lobby. Meanwhile in YBA it transports you to the Main Game itself
For me I just started yba first and got far in it and didn’t want to go start a new game so I just stayed and started helping my friends who are new to the game
bruh i wrote everything about how I prefer yba over aut and how I think the problems in yba could potentially be fixed,and then my youtube crashes,erasing everything
I remember when people were arguing with me, a once AUT tester, about how YBA would instantly die once aut dropped, not realising just how buggy it was and going off on 2 sneak peaks.
True, YBA has his bugs and all, but AUT just survived 2-3 days, in the hallowen update they died faster than I thought, from 40k to 20k, they did good and bad decisions, but the game is still good
Bro some child was saying that YBA is so trash and hoped that AUT will kill it , it didnt age well
@@Elpapurandomxd123 yeah, horrible desicions like adding yasuo and yone. i think that's waht caused people to quit aut, since they're extremely overpowered. the devs did a poll on if they were balanced, expecting truth, but most of aut's playerbase being people that want to abuse extremely overpowered specs to in obviously said yes. Yasuo and yone both have a true 70% combo, which led me to quit. It would be fine if it took some skill like mih's combos, but they don't since the moves have huge hitboxes and stun. in my opinion, the combat of the game needs to be reworked, they don't need to make new combat, but at least adding s after having used a move that should not combo extend. i think it's quite evident that the 70% combos are bugs, since they involve attacking after using moves that deal knockback.
@@koenigseggpeta4360 I was playing AUT after halloween update and some yone started attacking me and dude i cant even do anything, stun is so much that i cant even move and it does like my %70 hp. AUT was better before halloween event imo, balance system sucks
@@domseyboi they say that AUT is a balanced gsme where the balance doesn't exists, in YBA you need skills, braincells and is balsnced, having max vitality gived you max life, and everyone can have max life, boxing gives extra, but it still has balance.
I honestly prefer YBA’s combat and pvp system, I love the “build your own playstyle” type of gameplay from YBA, the fact that any stand can be good is refreshing. YBA’s pvp system also feels more rewarding, as fights last way longer, however the largest downside is that when something is unbalanced, its much more noticeable and annoying
Yba is good other than how you get those things i just wish there was a samdbox mode of where people can try make the best build possible because a lot of builds i have to come up in my head but only one didnt work and that was jaw breaker into inhale on star plat but any other ragdoll still works and i still have sp boxing on an alt
@@Henry-dn2xb that’d probably kill the main modes, because imagine if you could just go into sandbox and get whatever for free, would you even play normal yba anymore?
ABA still better
@@stew8685 to each their own, i just think yba has a more immersive pvp system, hell, even gang wars can be fun (im talking like 8v3s)
@@free5343 people would play normal yba for arrows and to just talk with others about the game, but you shouldnt be able to just use any stand in sandbox you should probably have to unlock it to test
its simple, yba doesn’t have a ridiculous amount of stun on every single attack
Bro, literally every single move on AUT has a stun , Hell they might even add stun to WASD
Yet it also has ridiculous stun for some things
i kinda like it this way beacuse in this way laggy players can actually do combos
@@somo4227 m1s still aren't a reliable option for Brazilians and pretty much everyone who's not close to a server.
As an anubis pluck user, I actually have to disagree with you.
I think the customisability is one of the reasons I play YBA more than AUT too. I agree with you when you mention things like skill trees, although my favourite feature of YBA is specs, since they add an extra layer to every single build and can potentially transform the way you play a stand if you're using a certain spec. The problem is that AUT doesn't have this kind of system and it never could; once you've seen an ability you've seen all it has to offer. The replay value of YBA is just higher because of the amount of possibilities for builds which is why I keep coming back to YBA and why I think it's the more played game.
Hey, is the yba Christmas update good? My pc won't play yba and I gotta sort that out
Bro we all know the real answer ITS BECAUSE AUT IS BALANCED AND YBA IS A BROKEN STAND ARENA
It's more fun when your stand can just one shot any one who needs skills
@@dominicballinger6536 It's quite good for me, they added presents that spawn on map with 0.5% chances but the time idk and from comp sbr you can get present with 10-20%, from 1v1s its 4% from 2v2s 1% but from presents you can get limited specs and cosmetics and they added shinies they look good tho
@@ДимаБелоцерковец-о5р hm, well okay. Thx! (Still not touching sbr tho lol)
@@hossammlaiha7889 aut is not balanced you can run with any stand that has ts with very little counter to it
A universal move in fighting games I don't see most of the time are combo breakers/reflectors. Basically they're used in stun to launch the enemy back, stunning both you and the enemy, resetting the gameplay back to neutral. Maybe AUT can link this combo breaker universal move to the block stamina, because I think it would be super good for the stupid infinite combos in AUT.
or maybe a sparking system like dragon ball fighterZ, when you activate sparking you will knockback and stun the enemy, your regen is increased, you have a slight buff on all attacks, stun decreased slightly, duration is only 10 seconds, and sparking wont be available until you die to a person.
In 1v1's it'll be different, sparking buffs is still the same, the things that are changed is that when you use sparking and you die to a person in 1v1's you won't get another sparking for the whole match, sparking will build up each time you die if you're not using it, ex: when you first die, sparking will glow orange and when you die to your last life your sparking will glow red, what that means is that the sparking buffs will be increased whenever it changes colour.
thats my suggestion for AUT and send feedback if you think there is something is unbalanced.
This. A lot of people miss the fact that the reason why actual fighting games are playable is because they have defensive options so getting hit by a jab does not spell game over. Good examples include Mortal Kombat breakaways(and the game’s many other defensive options), JoJo EOH combo breaker, and DBFZ sparking(as Kozo mentioned)
they could assign the move to block + heavy punch
N the jojo game has one combo breaker, and it’s King Crimson’s Time Erase. That’s literally all there is on roblox
@@twohomiesplayingjojogames6748 no, there's a game called Offbeat Journeys, which has a combo breaker function similar to DBFZ or GGR. And I don't think you understand what I was talking about, as KC's time erase move in NTJJG can't be used to bail (from my prior knowledge, tell me if i'm wrong) from combos.
AUT
Pros:
-Frequent updates
-Almost all content is free
-Devs post sneak peaks to keep fans entertained
Cons:
-Lots of bugs every update
-Wonky mechanics
-Extremely unbalanced abilities upon release
YBA
Pros:
-Decently balanced stands (controversial)
-Very well made updates
-Very diverse combat
Cons:
-Updates take eons to come out and no sneak peaks
-Extremely toxic community (with the staff being worse at times)
-Gamepasses are extremely expensive
In conclusion, both games have their pros and cons depending on what type of player you are, and most things people will like while other hate.
eons XD
This is like the best comment about both games I’ve seen so far
How is the YBA staff toxic? Idk anything about the staff or how the act so someone pls explain
there are sneakpeaks. Just go on his patreon. And before you complain about him having a patreon, god forbid a 15 yr old kid wanting income
As for gamepasses. Tbh besides there being no spec storage freebie, ion mind gamepasses and what they do for the game.
Rest i agree with though.
well made update isn't a skin and and lucky arrow lol? yba is mainly better just the combat is just so fun the rest it goes to aut
Probably the best video you could have made, possibly ever for these two. Wholeheartedly agree with the part where uzu should hire others who can do his job with/for him, but yeah, it's never that simple. I really hope it resonates with both dev teams cause what you're saying is extremely important. Good stuff my guy
While I think both games are fine, I feel one of AUT's biggest issues is lack of testing. The rate at which we get AUT updates are nice in comparison to YBA, but the amount of bugs/balancing issues present with each new update is just disheartening and could 100% be improved with more in depth testing of new content. YBA doesnt suffer from this issue in the same way AUT does. YBA's lack of updates, and more specifically, content updates means that there arent many new bugs present to the game. YBA does however fail in the fact that the bugs that do exist often times go unfixed for months, and many of them are detrimental to certain stands (i.e Knives). At the end of the day though I really cant say which is better than the other, and thats mostly down to personal preference.
One thing i have to say is that if the new aut came out the same time as yba/had the same time as yba to make updates and all that, it would be really good, with the speed they do things
Keep in mind, AUT is the game that came out with the Halloween Update around Thanks Giving time and still does updates quicker than YBA lmfao
@@NotTsurugi yea but with those updates, they come out unpolished and buggy
@@NotTsurugi still losing ezezezrzezrzrzrz
@@godlikebeing...1584 Yba community in a nutshell lol
Honestly why more people play YBA: It just appeals more to the casual audience while also having a decent complexity for more competitive players. Everyone knows that most people casually play games and not taking everything too seriously. But there are also players who enjoy playing games more seriously and investing time into finding the optimal battle strategy.
Funnily enough, the customisation is what makes it fun as well. It allows Casual Players to use whatever they want and it will mostly work while more competitive players can find the ultimate combination of spec and Stand power (Boxing go brrr).
I agree but I feel as if yba just as a really nice community and overall more enjoyable public servers, people are always in one area socializing (near the arcade) and aut is usually just a whole mess with it’s laggy map and boring and crappy rkers.
@@mikeehrmantraut8622 wait i thought its the other way around.
@@suus1027 Yesn't.
@Suus can't say much about aut because I haven't played it in a long time but he's basically spot on with yba minus servers with a group of toxic players, and the occasional rking because it's either grind fight or idle in main game
And also the server wars that start after a group of people teamed on others too much and now there's more than 4 people that want to see them crumble
In aut I'm guessing people just go around attacking others because of quests that require kills or dmg
YBA rlly sucks, too little updates. It stinks. This vid is so wrong.
I feel the difference in YBA and AUT is like Smash Bros. Melee and Ultimate, one is semi competitive and less glitchy, and The other is SUPER buggy but very competitive
That’s why I like yba more then aut. The grinding is hard and long and takes days. I am a hard grinder gamer so I love it when I grind for days just to get one thing, whilst for aut it has less grinding and isn: as hard. You just complete what’s on your screen and that’s it.
@@purplefartjuice701 did you see grinding in old aut? never again.
@@swolzer what
@@purplefartjuice701 what
@@purplefartjuice701 grinding in old aut took atleast 12 hours to get a good stand
I would like to see YBA add a daily quest which could give you items such as arrows, rokakakas, rib cages, etc. Maybe some in-game money as well.
In game money already exists but yba would be more fun with that
Old man in sewers gives some exp for coins..
@@truesight5652 sounds like a scam tbh
the mail man better make a return
There actually used to be a mailman quest which is daily
To be honest, the only reason that i still play YBA was because of the memories made in the game. Memories of doing sbr with gang members, winning 1v1s, doing 2v2s with other people. Gang wars, farming for a stand and getting hyped when you got the stand that you desired. I played YBA since 2020 and have thought of quitting the game because of the toxicity, exploiters, the ridiculous ammount of farming i have to do, and lack of updates. I have tried not playing YBA again but i just kept on coming back. Even if my gang disbanded, me becoming gangless, without anyone to play yba with, alone, no one to help you fight. In the end, i kept on coming back. It isn't obsession or anything, it's just how much of a thrill YBA has. AUT has the large variery of stands, specs, and movesets sure. Project star had the wits to compete against YBA if only they had more devs and all. TB2 has the varierity of characters, and the special moves the characters have. But they lack updates to keep the hype up. And my conclusion to this is, YBA is almost a masterpiece. And it is hard to stop playing after the things you've experienced in the game. First time getting a rare stand, first time winning sbr, first time winning 1v1s and so on. Sure it has its downsides like exploiters and the group of toxic players there. But after all, why should we stop playing it?
gang wars and rking/rkers make the game fun like imagine if no one fought in main game
@@obamaprism9458 some bozos want to implement "no pvp main game" before 💀
Exactly gang wars is so fun in the game especially when everyone calls their own gangs on the server and it's just a fun war
Well said my brotha
@@obamaprism9458 if no one fought in main game it would be impossible to get items bruh
Personally, I think AUT is a really good game with great animations and models, but it's the lack of content that really dries the playtime fast. I originally first joined YBA because I heard about the storyline aspect of it and that was really interesting at the time, but once you beat the storyline 4 times, get TWOH and MIH, and get max prestige, it's time to move on. I agree with what you said about YBA's content + AUT's animations and models could make a really REALLY good and entertaining game to play on the daily. The problem is that in every attempt to make a jojo game better than YBA or even atleast AUT, it fails miserably because of multiple reasons. 1; theres is literally no more unused names for jojo games. Every jojo game says something related to 'bizarre' 'adventure' 'jojo(s)' 'crusader(s)' 'star' 'infinite' 'day' and the list goes on. 2; content gets so dry with these games that people play them, completely max out everything in the span of a week or two and they return to AUT or YBA. Lastly, the playerbase/community is what really controls these games. I guarentee that if literally every single YBA/AUT player complained to the devs that the game is dry and they will quit if no updates are dropped, the devs (if they actually care about their game) will probably work on an update. That's basically it, I don't really play YBA or AUT anymore so yeah that's all.
i dearly wish and hope they do like a collab
@@Flip634 then dont tf 💀
Since AUT released I had a kinda bad feeling about it. My friends started playing, begging me to try it. Eventually I did, and I had fun for a few weeks. Got most of the stands ingame and it just got boring, so I switched permanently to YBA. I really think that AUT's problem is that it focuses too much on PvP and PvE, and not really on the actual main game.
Y e p
Yba doesn't have anything either...
@@Vazuzzu it has more then aut
Well said Eclipse i hope Uzu will get his passion to make yba better again so this game can be better again and i hope aut will get thier lost players back
The players who played aut were mostly yba players who went back to yba
@@Bawrhsaia So true lmao
I only quit aut because the servers were so laggy and the low gfx mode makes me even laggier thats why i quitted aut
This is true. The farming system in YBA sucks. I was literally for an hour in my priv and couldn't find a single Rokakaka. I even invited my friend who had item grind hacks and as it turned out, the server had no rokas.😐
Oh, and by the way, Eclipse can you add chapters to your movies? It would be helpful (at least for me)
I realized I forgot just slightly after uploading the video and added them immediately, sorry about that.
No problem my dude
@um uh I know privs have lower spawnrates but c'mon, 1 hour and no rokas?
@@falkosos skill issue
honestly thats skill issue
Me and my friends used to play AUT a lot, but once the map updated there was way too many things to load, and the game became basically unplayable.
As a YBA main, when I started playing AUT I was really confused at how easy the combo making was. I mean using YBA hard combo tactics that do a tiny amount of damage absolutely shreds peoples hp in AUT. I was disappointed in the stun on the M1s and got bored of it really quick
M1s doing stuns is literally the nor of any pvp game.
I personally think YBA have no stun on m1s is horrible, the only reason Uzu even removed stun from m1s is cus man was too lazy to balance dmg and moves.
Also YBA combos aren't rly hard, it's literally just use moves while in AUT it's, use moves + m1.
But hey, that's just my opinion, you enjoy what you enjoy.
@@YaBoiAshX Even tho this was 2 days ago, I now like AUT's system after I met a guy who somehow deflected all of my combos. Also I think that irl if someone punched u you wouldnt just be able to punch back in a matter of milliseconds. So yea. I'm an AUT main instead of a YBA main now
@@diobrando8217 ngl I was exited for nothing for the Christmas update it’s shit at and kcr is now immortal so there’s that
@@SplaterYT yea
The tutorial is way clearer and YBA isn't so clear on how to play
One of the most important mechanics in fighting games is a recovery mechanic.
Dragon Ball Xenoverse has a mechanic called vanishing, where as long as you have stamina (which hardly regens), you can vanish out of hitstun. If you break someone's stamina, you just get to beat on them.
In YBA, this mechanic is Stand barrage typically, with a few exeptions (Six Pistol's Improved Dashes). If someone overuses their defensive mechanic, they get hard punished (DBX has stamina break, Stand Barrage deals huge damage, and can only be stopped by another Stand Barrage or something of the sort.)
In AUT, if you fail to block or dodge, you get beaten on...and if you don't get some sort of frame perfect dodge, sometimes the combo even gets looped...no one likes that.
There’s an amazing game called “World Of Stands”
It’s currently shut down (although it was openly tested a few days ago)
It has:
A storyline
A level system
AMAZING CUTSCENES
No jacksh*t Arrow percentage
Skins aren’t ridiculously rare
Things that AUT could do to literally easily obliterate YBA’s player count:
Dungeons and more gamemodes
Events and a storyline
Exclusive stands and specs for the storyline
Multiple storylines (each part) OR a linked massive storyline
I see the potential of WOS. I hope the devs uee that potential for a great game.
Hope they reduce the amount of moves with cutscenes. Istg, when somebody’s is comboing me, is a whole movie.
Bruford in WOS literally has flame breathing
trash pvp and graphics and trash map
WOS opens on weekends.
when I played aut for the first time, I thought it was very strange and bad that the stands already came to their full potential.
new aut messed up hard by basically deleting most of what the game was, get a stand then go on a journey (normally either killing a boss, trading and waiting for it to spawn) and then using the stand. its like how stw was something that took time to get but now its just a chance from a normal arrow
@@toniskangur7519 for me the stw part actually makes sense, like why would you sacrifice your evolved stand (TW) to get the first version of the stand (STW).
Eclipse puts up some rather great points, but simplified, yba has progression that is rewarding, and no matter which stand you have, you can kill another, its gonna take usage of your brain to really think, "Is it worth getting this skill?" in yba the combat system is just so harshly diverse! Meanwhile aut is just a copy paste of the average jojo game but "better" just because of its graphics?
And it has stun
it just has a barebone combat system thats iffy asf
ye, aut is basically your normal jojo game with a few other specs and stands plus better graphics but thats literally it, its like abd but more custom and better graphics
90% of AUT fans just went by the logic "Good graphics/Good vfx = Good game!" When looking at the sneakpeeks before the game was even out, proceeding to claim it was the "YBA Killer." The game then dropped, was buggy and unbalanced as shit and well YBA just sort of sat there unscathed.
@Volt problem is, people are tired of yba and want something better.
Yeah YBA is cool but it has some very glaring problems.
They hoped AUT would fix it with their game. But it didn’t.
so is someone else does not listen to eclipse and just watching the pvp in the background?
Tried the 1v1 in AUT recently as a new player and eclipse is true about the land m1 and half of your health is gone.
YBA combat is more like a chess.
Sptw players in AUT belike : m1m1mm1m1m1 barrage m1m11m1mm11m1mm1m
Yba Sptw players Belike : funni ts and beatdown
@@regularshitposter2601 well yea it’s ts and then M1 M1 M1 m1
I like YBA for the diversity in builds. Like sure there's the meta, but then there's obscure stuff that's busted together that nobody plays or knows how to fight against. In AUT the stand you get is the stand you get and that's it.
That’s true one of the reasons I prefer yba pvp
It’s just every time you come across a 6p and a vampire boxing you think about your life choices
@@cocopuffs8646 wait till you meet a sc vamp and he life drains you both in game and real life
me with spin anubis knowing its trash "my goals are beyond your understanding"
@@muhammadmuqhrizz1631 ahah inf combo go BRRRR
"M1s don't have stun"
Anubis: so anyway i started stunning
RHCP with electrify: lemme hop in
mih with double accel
Sp boxing: hello there
Yba is way more developed than aut but since yba has been having a big lack of updates and new content, a lot of players would rather play aut which is a game that regularly gets updated. I still think yba is the best roblox jojo game tho
i don't like the YBA skil tree and how some specs work,but it s alright
Honestly the only reason I don’t like yba is the community
Yba still has more players
@@Matt_364 Same
@@Matt_364 i like the game , but holy the community is a dumpster fire
aut players was 120k+ after nu, but after information about "stolen assets from YBA", aut now has a 5k-10k.
In YBA you can change your keybinds, block doesn't have a cooldown, and it feels much more smoother.
I like how you used Star Platinum in AUT then in YBA both in 1v1's to show their differences and their combat systems
meet the man who is impossible to disagree with
Hes possible to disagree with but the stans for him just don't think he ever misses even when he says things that are blatantly silly
Hes a yba player he obv would prefer yba
@@llerioo2885 did you even watch the video?
@@koenigseggpeta4360 i bet he didnt
@@koenigseggpeta4360 People will still disagree
I feel like a great way the yba developers could become less bored of developing strictly jojo stuff is creating uncanon jojo things more stuff like kcr
Yeah, that would create more variety, like Shindo Life
@@greenman784 yeah a great shindo example of a uncanon bloodline is satori rengoku
Uzu did say he's gonna add a requiem to every stand
@@TheTophatGuy lol 6pr is just an AR 15
@@TheTophatGuy when?
honestly it's just that I like YBA's combo system where it's really quick, you either lose really hard or win really hard, mistakes make you stronger they say
YBA's combat system has three categories: You stomp the opponent, it's a long, drawn-out fight of equal skill and you both sneak picks at each other, but no significant damage is made, or you get completely stomped. There is nothing but that.
@@lordpumpkinhead265 this apply to every fighting games though.
If no one remembers, there was a game called Stand Upwrite, and it had skill trees and unique atributes for their stands, the game was also provided with levels, dungeons, along with depth of development. Stand upwrite was very successful due to the fact that your attribute determined your winning or losing. Most people would think that this is a bad thing, but with these unfair power scales, the game shifts from just fighting mindlessly to a more rpg-like and social game. People would log on to chat with friends and do missions, so the thing AUT should be aiming for is something that includes more RPG ASPECTS and a way to make the game more SOCIAL. Roblox players love social games, and some of the top games are games where you basically just chat with a few twists. This, along with stands and abilities could make for a great game that could 100% beat YBA.
I remember playing Stand Upright and it was pretty similar to YBA, but in a different manner. The one thing I didn’t like about the game was the fact that there was the characteristic factor when getting a stand (ex: Divine, Permistic, Brave). Sure, you could get the stand you wanted, but chances are that it’s much weaker than the same stand, but with the rarer characteristic. This made the game a bit unbalanced as this meant that only players that have the same kind of characteristic could only compete with each other, leaving weaker players out of the question to even fight them as they’d get RK’d for who knows how long. Other than that, I enjoyed the game and had a great time with it.
Agreed, stand upright is really fun once you get a very good attribute of a stand, its like dragonball with the powerscaling and stuff but in a jojo game
@@colonfist I agree with you there, man. What you said is pretty much a nutshell of the game as a whole lol
Stand upright was basically YBA but even worse balancing but better community
That’s basically project star
The reason I play YBA more nowadays is that AUT isn't as wacky and fun as it used to be. Most of the moves I liked didn't even get a balance or nerf, just a straight removal or replaced with something completely different that what they once were. I liked the fact that some stands had a stronger stand jump than others, and that nearly every stand or spec had a traversal move. I dislike the fact that most "rare" or hard to get stands were revoked from every player that obtained the original just to be replaced with a better looking, worse functioning version of what it once was.
This happened when AUT first released (old AUT). It had 50k when it released then died to like a couple thousand players. Rare stands were too op
And that's why I commit rage quit
i feel like if aut added social elements, such as dungeons mentioned in the polls, 2v2s, gangs, sbr, etc. it'll have a massive boost in their playercount, and if they make the main game map actually playable on low-end
edit: yes i know stuff like dungeons & sbr were polls, and had positive results, and that 2v2s are basically confirmed, and that the map is confirmed too, but i was just commenting how it'd MASSIVELY help
they are going to rework the map soo it kool
Definitely agree. Updates are frequent but all they add that really contributes to gameplay is a new ability. People then try to get this ability and play with it a little bit and then what?
I'm pretty sure they said on the discord server that once they're done with making the map optimised they're gonna focus on the story in some way (they didn't specify it was a quest line or dungeons)
That would be like a copy of stand upright except for 2v2 gangs and sbr
@@FluffyAxel no, i tend to disagree; although aut and stand upright do have some similarities, 2v2s aren't unique, neither is sbr, not really, and gangs were in old aut; overall it'd just be a giant social update, beneficial for all parties
My YBA playtime is definitely up there because of the shiny grinding, and it's understandable that it's dumb to shiny farm. But honestly, shiny farming is an excuse for me as someone who's done almost everything I can in the game to keep on playing sbr, to have fun times and etc with my friends. Even if it's a lot of wasted time, lmao.
touch some grass jajajaj ezezez3zezezezez
🙈🙈🙈🙈🙊🙊🙊🙊🙉🙉🙉🙉
if I could wish ONE thing about this I would wish that AUT and YBA would set aside their differences and work together to make the best Jojo and others game ever. all they have to do is see who does something better that way the better person can work on it. BIG BRAIN!
whenever i play aut i feel like im playing some alpha game that needs 2 more years of work put into it for it to be functional and yba feels like it only need 6 months more of work to be functional
Playing with stands on aut feels real basic compared to yba, like the lack of customisation (picking whether you want a move or not and being able to change your keybinds), another thing I like alot is specs cause depending on the spec you pick it can change ur playstyle. Also in my opinion stands feel better in yba. (Mb for waffling)
YBA is winning because its JJBA, its based on one thing instead of 60 different topics. YBA also has less lag, and is genuinely sometimes more enjoyable. AUT has better stand attacks and animations, but is too leggy, and you can't even play AUT on mobile due to the fact that that the new map is too massive and leggy along with the graphics.
delayed*
But yba mobile isn’t great too, when I play mobile on yba I just get bugged
You cant really play YBA on mobile either. High particle stands crash me all the time.
Yeah, I used to play in main game aut, but now with the new map it lags and everyone is all over the map and u can’t find anyone
The only laggy thing in YBA they need to fix is the fact that killer queens explosions lag the hell out of mobile and crappy pc users (Including myself).
If I’m correct, I believe a while ago AUT was considering a storymode or something similar to YBA so that there was something to do. I think they added this skin system and what not to being a way to be rewarded for completing story quests
12:15 is SOO relatable, for some reason I've used over 150 arrows to try and get star platinum in YBA and didn't get it ONCE.
oof i got star plat and k.c
Imo the problem is lack of content relating to jojo references.
There are more specs than actual jojo related stands
Many people dont even care bout specs,half the community dosent even know where it's from. If they add actual stands there is a chance people might look back.
Another thing is the map.....(you know)
It's just better to make a simple map that isn't huge nor small.
Last and final fault imo is the grinding method and the npcs
Bosses are way to strong and ignore stun,npcs can m1 in middle of a barrage (sometimes)and the grinding method is just so bad
If they fix these faults they can regularly update the game with small updates and get the same mediocre fanbase each time.
actually that makes it more apealing to more players not to only jojo fans more fans the map thing is true but its not about the uncanon stands its more so about the amount of times the updates are worse then the last
AUT is less enjoyable than YBA for me, AUT has alot of abilities but once you get the good ones it kind of loses it's replayability value, it has cool animations, but that doesnt overshadow the combat which is pretty bad if you ask me , most abilities overshadow others alot (like how broly overshadows almost every stand ability) and I think that comes down to lack of proper testing, most if not all attacks have so much stun for no reason at all ( which makes it impossible to escape combos), and the grind is pretty alright (like grinding for shinies), but it can get really bad (like grinding for abilities like tusk) . YBA on the otherhand has alot of replayability, and that comes to the spec + stand combinations you can make in the game (for example anubis + pluck), the animations are good but not as good at AUT's, the combat is alot better (considering that you can parry moves, and actually cancel combos that aren't true, unlike aut where you can't escape combos unless you have a broken spec like broly which gets stun for no reason at all) and the grind is more bearable, but it can get boring at times ( like trying to grind for a skins ).
@@alphetti4348 Yeah, getting bored of a stand+spec combination? No worries, you can research for builds or standspec combinations that tend to look strong, fun or viable, heck the game has about a total of 38 stands, there are 5 specs and one specless
38 stands x 5 specs = 190 stand comhinations
190-220 stands and specs when combined (220 if we included basic specless stands on their own)
This just tells me how wide your choose pool is with YBA if you want to use something else
If AUT added a story mode I dont know what I would do with my life
I bet they will do that tbh
sup missings
i hear that they adding it
but no idea what is reward for playing story mode
@@IV_II if that's true then it's like they are copying from yba at some point
As someone who has every evolution stand on Yba, I can assure grinding takes Weeks
Bro it took me a day to get twoh
skill issue
@@jameslol6743 literally didn't ask, I am talking about the grinding for the stands OVERALL, I also took 3 seconds to make SPTW, but took me ages to get SP
@@yeatme5509 dies from repetitive "joke"*
@@SpacatoTT yeah no, i ALSO didnt ask how long it took you to get sp 😎
This is a really interesting analysis, and I think that both games have hurt their player count in different ways. AUT's main thing was the new universe update that made things reasonable to get as opposed to the old universe that was winning over YBA because you had to sit in a private server for hours and hours on end to get the things you want like it pretty much is with skins in YBA. YBA's main thing (my opinion, after the update hype dies down) is gonna be the addition of trading given that if someone was grinding for star platinum and they got whitesnake 3 times, they wouldn't have to lose faith in the RNG gods and roka it since they can now just go and trade it for the other stand they wanted as opposed to how things worked before christmas.
My thoughts exactly. AUT's "New Universe" update kinda broke the game in multiple ways, and instead of rewarding grinding and patience, you could go get Star Platinum and suddenly you can fight any stand with a bit of practice. YBA, while VERY similar to this *cough* Aeroshit *cough,* still rewards the committed and the determined who want to get stands like Made in Heaven and The World: Over Heaven, which take a long time to get (excluding trading for them).
For me it might because of the whole "new universe" thing, the upgraid is great, but after the new universe came out most of the the stand/character that we farm for have been erase, even tho its ok for those who's new but it totally not for me
All of the things the made the game fun like Casey, Zenith, Hermit purple and the meme stands like Made in Walmart, Sprite Cranberry, etc. All those things together made the game fun and they ripped it away from us by turning the game heavily based on pvp with most stands being broken, pvp, the whole thing they're going for, isnt fun (LIKE NOCTURNUS DOES INF STUN BECAUSE OF BLEED AND DOES A RIDICULUES AMOUNT OF DAMAGE, or how p//s hasn't gotten a single update but we've had 4 new specs and skins for p//s)
Moral of the story, they turned aut into something the community didnt want, pve into pvp. RIP 90% of the stands that made the game fun
in my head when he said the one m1 and your dead aba was just the first thought i had
Personally like aut more than yba for my own reason but I have to admit yba is currently winning even if this never was a contest. Still don't know what people are doing in yba
playstyle customization, win hard or lose hard, its like everything has thrill
ofc it dies, but later on regens like on node 3
The thing i do is go with random stands and specs to see if its good like bb hamon or ph spin etc
Also being able to meme in main game, like commiting robbery with 4 6pistols
I knew yba wouldn’t lose it’s just that a part of me hope it would lose a lot of people playing so the devs pay more attention to the game and have more updates but yba always has 20k and more players in the game no matter what time it is
In 01:15, those are AUT's players that are in the main menu, NOT actually in the game. Just to let you know
One of my biggest issues is that YBA actually gives you a reason to get hard to get stands like TWOH because they’re actually strong, but in aut all the end tier stands either suck a lot or are stupidly overpowered while pretty much every arrow and easy to get stand is busted
The main thing I like about AUT is the variety of stands and specs like they just added yasuo and yone and those were really fun
Did you mean?: Really unfair
In yba, you can get so creative with the builds and do what you want, so with specless included, every new stand is multiplied by 6, not to mention skill trees. And, if you experiment with it, you can find a brand new build that's super powerful, and have fun with it. This is proven by my experience with top players. I've fought 3 top players in total, and 2 of them had creative builds that I never even thought of and combo in amazing ways. One had cmoon pluck, and the other had Hermit pluck, and while those sound like ba dideas on paper, they made amazing combos that work incredibly well. That's why yba has more players, the freedom of being able to be creative with your build is what makes yba so cool.
P.s. the cmoon pluck user used that cause he could pilot right after crescent slash and confirm uppercut, creating an infinite, and the pluck Hermit would use grapple and use pierce strike while grappling to confirm vine trap. If that isn't proof you can experiment with builds what is?
We currently have 38 solo stands and 5 specs in YBA, they can also be combined uniquely depending on your choices or how you want a meta or casual spec + stand combination
Also, you can make up to 190 stand+spec combinations in total (if we include the basic no-spec-non-combined stand like they're just their own, then we'd have like 228 stands in total) while also being able to shift and adjust/modify your build and how you want to make the combination work, which moves you want to sacrifice to make one better, YBA has a HUGE field of what you want to use specifically than just one solo stand like most jojo games
To me, the less lag and the parry mechanism really makes me love yeah more than aut.
*yeah*
@@obamaprism9458 the blocking feels wonky in aut. Cooldown feels weird, x key feels weird, and keybinds for the base person in aut is just weird.
Yeah
@@snoote533 i said yeah because u misspelled yba
@@obamaprism9458
I hate autocorrect and deserve to be rked.
I rememeber aut fans saying aut will kill yba, boy did that age well...
homie did this like 5 days after he got tester for aut 💀
with the "jojo hurts yba" thing, instead of maybe adding canon stands with their canon movesets, they could add less popular canon stands with unique movesets like they did with anubis, or more requiem stands so that they'll have more freedom, the only problem with this is that it takes time to implement, which the yba devs hate.
They dod that with RHCP and nobody uses it. Just stick to making popular ones so they get some use
@@sonicslayer0161 that’s just because it’s weak as hell
There are currently some polls to buff it
@@Rock-vk9ei RHCP is actually a very strong stand if you know what you're doing.
@@ancientwarrior3482 you can technically say that with any stand
@@weirdcarpetthing97 that’s why yba is good
I think the sad fact of the matter is here is what we're left with.
We have a good game with a developer who is resting on his laurels knowing full well there are problems and money will keep flowing even if he doesnt fix them, moderators and staff who treat their community like shit and cant manage at all.
Then we have a pretty mediocre jojo game with developers who give a shit (albiet have a bad track record if the stolen asset fiasco is anything to go by), actually want to improve the game, and know that money will only keep flowing if they continue to improve.
It honestly feels like the only way yba is gonna get any proper improvement is if a new developer picks it up and actually starts trying because uzu obviously doesnt feel the need to. (which he is a kid and is in school so its not like he doesnt have real life responsibilities, all the more reason to get another developer to handle more consistent updates)
Personally I disagree on AUT being mediocre. It's certainly better than a lot of other Jojo games out there, and the combat is pretty alright. Bugs are fixed pretty consistently, so I wouldn't personally call the game mediocre.
That said, I do agree. Even if AUT was mediocre, I'd take it any day over a good game with a bad community and lazy devs. While most people say you should separate the art from the artist, in the case of the developers, knowing the passion they feel (or lack thereof) really makes a difference on the gaming experience.
Uzu might have school but he's 18 he's not a kid but he still has responsibilities
he isnt 18, hes like 15.
@@whoopingmuffin9700 Proof?
@@bonafidebruhmoment5440 well, its been about a year and a half since the discord post where it was mentioned he turned 14.
I prefer yba for the combat system, the movements system, sbr, cosmetics (i know it sounds stupid but it's another reason to play sbr for example) the customisation of your moves, the storyline and the well made npcs. I played a lot of aut when it came out but after grinding some stands i obviously lost interest. And that's a shame because yba has problems that hardly ruin the game (cheaters, bugs, toxic people) and devs aren't even thinking to do something. If yba had the actual aut devs it would be the perfect jojo game.
I would say either reduce the stun time in aut or add a new mechanic where you can only string a combo for sometime before the opponent is flung away. Also add some way to counter stuns or avoid it like increase s in dodges or have some moves that can be used while stunned but they go on cooldown for a longer time
they should add a universal combo breaker that stuns both players and uses all your block stamina
I loved YBA until I played AUT, and then I didn't touch YBA for at least a month, but my issue is one mentioned in the video. I don't have an interest in the "rare" stands that take grinding to do, besides mabye 2 of them. Once I got all the stands/specs I wanted in AUT, and exhausted using them all, I had no need to go back. But I have since then played another alt account on YBA to max prestige again, just to have new builds. The longevity of customisation and prestiges definitely beats the longevity in getting the 6 stands you want and calling it a day.
Cant wait for the YBA and AUT stans to go to war over this video
I'll grab the popcorn
@@UltimateQuartz you have some?
My opinion on why most people (including me) choose to play YBA and not AUT
-The combat sytem of YBA is really good. You dont get punished for other people landing m1s on you
-More stand options
-More customizations. For example using X stand with X Specs
-Trying to find really good combos with different specs and stands
-Teams gamemode, Solo game modes
- Hard Challenges like getting corpse parts
- Trying to wipe sbr servers with X Stand and specs
- Team wiping people with friends
- A storyline that you have to finish
- Forming teams in main game to eliminate the server
-Skin system (even tho its bad cuz its based on luckiness, people still like it cause they can flex their stand skins)
-Even tho it updates years later the updates are HUGE.
(these are my opinions, you are allowed to have ur own so please dont argue)
Well now AUT has a skin system, and it's WAY better than YBA's
@SkullX 991 how? You can reliably get any skin you want by playing and getting essence.
@SkullX 991 how so
@@glacialblast2588 the problem with auts shinies is that they're so easy to get they almost have no value, as they're basically all worth the same. This is a huge double edged sword as there's no longer a trading economy and really no reason to collect shinies since they're mostly worth the same, also the purpose of shinies is to be rare. Auts shinies are not rare at all, it's not impressive to have a shiny in aut, they're just skins you buy.
@@glacialblast2588 "a rare skin is in the shop and my daily quest will give me enough, let me just do the quest, buy the skin, equip it, and then just l e a v e!"
I think it really just boils down to YBA being like a Triple A game, while AUT is more like an indie game. One tries to appeal to the people while the other tries to get the most out of their audience. One is objectively better in some regards, but the other is made to make a profit and they succeed.
YBA wasn't made for profit
@@larryyasmin7128 YBA really out here making you pay for stand storage tho
Man I always log in to yba to just have a fun FFA with random players, sometimes getting ganged , getting others ganged , find new friends, be toxic , not be toxic. U get the idea, yba is probably not dead cause of this, it's the only reason why it's not boring.
I agree. And I would redo the whole story using alt account to not waste something dumb. So far I really needed a freaking a spec store for idk a year? I keep need to sell my items and killin boss I wasted over 100,000 money I'm sure since got 5 alt acc in YBA.
And I agree what eclipse says. Damn my pain of wasting my time redo grinding
Yba: want a stand? Farm for it then get everything OTHER than that stand.
Aut: Want this? Ok here take it
While yes aut has had so many bugs and just plain unbalanced stands, they fix them as fast as they can and seeing that yba is basically muuuucchhhh older i think it's meh to critique aut on it. I would love to see how aut would look like if it had as much time as yba
YBA doesn't have 300 damages combos that only require a barrage to get
I have a 268 dmg yeah combo lol
EXACTLY
Twau* sry autocorrect
@@leroydhunter8134 ok I use twau now tell your combo
yeah they have one shot TS combos :)
remember, it took 2 updates to fix yba knives
another great part of the skill tree is it allows relatively bad stands to become really good when you unlock specific skills, like likes look at it like this, beach boy can go from borderline useless to a beast if you practice with him and unlock points to use on him. This is amplified with specs and character upgrades and all
Ima be honest with you guys, the reason why yba is so good or lasting right now, because it has more content or things to do than aut, like grinding levels, making builds with specs, fighting people, all this has it going for yba, aut has none of this besides fighting people and even then its not that much fun because yba keeps it random, as in you can see a the hand pluck and it somehow works, its the randomness that yba has that you dont know what you are to expect next, maybe some stands like twoh are presictable because they always run boxing because hamon or pluck doesnt work to well with twoh. But my point still stands, aut does have its good stuff, like graphics specs/stands, good effects, new ways to grind, decent ish bossfights(tho need to work better because they have no stun) and bigger map, but it lacks any early content besides auto grinding stands like stories or level grinding or skill tree making,( i love skill trees and yba nailed it with not being able to unlock everything) as well as every stand is almost different on how there moves work, what yba doesnt have going for it is animation which is lame, every single rage/awakening uses the same animation, and rage bars yell the same RAAAAA, atleast they got voicelines back, anyways, i feel like they both have there ups and down but yba has more going for it
Completly agree with this based man.
Facts, YBA is much more fun that AUT rn.
Always has been
yba is preferred for its combat system , it is just smoother in general and everyone got used to it
True, main problem would be even if you get 200+ ping, you'd struggle and your stand delays every move, but if you do have below 200 you're gonna have some fun
@@colonfist fax
@@colonfist I know I'm 4 months late but may I ask for your pfp sauce?
@@justinjunkatigbak4576 patchouli from touhou
@@colonfist Oh Thanks dude or gal.
Edit: Imma sub to you for providing the sauce real quick.
The thing that annoyes me the most in yba is that we get an update every 2-3 months and when we get an update it includes like 4 codes, a bug fix out of 10 bugs and that updates doesnt really include much content
As always the things you say are true and make sense but sadly a big problem whit yba is that some people's are scared of doing pvp because they are scared of getting laughed at or being trash talked and that's very sad because yba combat is fun
I playing yba now too because it has more stands than aut and aut just has the same moves like you doing the same things but on the yba there is hamon,boxing,pluck,spin 2v2 gamemode and sbr gamemode the combat of yba is good too and it has a skill tree
And the pvp in aut is not so good to me like why is there stun in almost every single move
@@Yama-v1 yeah the good thing in aut is only the bd's
like you kinda said yourself eclipse the m1s in aut just have too much stun and yba have almost none so you have to use moves to start a combo instead of just m1s and thats why i like yba more
this did not age well
you need to make a YBA review on the new most OP weapon, stop sign.
Thank you, AUT just made a poll about combat its most definitely because of this video to thank you so much for helping make AUT better!
Honestly, even know AUT has “unique” stands, they kinda feel like carbon copies of each other.
They either do something like TS, Have generally SP or TW strength or just are a LITERAL copy of SP or TW with just an edgy design.
I think YBA is a lot more fun because the abilities are actually different from each other- and although there is cheese stands, there’s a much less drastic difference between what’s trash and what’s good, It’s the opposite for AUT.
I feel even if a stand is trash in YBA you can still make the most of it, and if you’re skilled, slap top tier stands.
I had a stroke reading that.
@@Me-lt2tb How so? Pretty sure what I said makes grammatical sense….
They are both going to be overshadowed by new jojo games such as world of stands
what games
Oh please. NOTHING will EVER overshadow yba, no matter how good
@@vnmememan8657 the lack of updates could easily push yba into the deeper side of roblox, meaning less new players, meaning the game would die eventually
@@vnmememan8657 ahem. Stand Upright. One of the most anticipated Jojo games after AUT.
@@vnmememan8657 ABD literally shat on YBA and then got shat on by AUT because the AUT devs made AUT from a modded ABD game into an independent game
Eclipse I’ve always wanted to make a JoJo game and I’ve been looking at a bunch of different games and jotting down notes about what makes those games good, I’m thinking about doing development as a career and I genuinely believe I can probably dethrone Yba, however ur probably gonna have to wait quite a few years 😅, I’m just mainly worried about people hating on me to “copying” but I will make all my assets myself and stuff.
Eclipse are you intending on playing deepwoken?
1 year later well, that aged well
Man have I been waiting for this!Thanks for constantly shooting out content, Eclipse!
1 thing that keeps me playing yba than aut its of the mobile system its so organized in yba than in aut if you are a mobile player
To me, it's just because AUT’s combat feels so floaty, and clunky. Attacks while having stun, have little to no oomph and combat is such a slog.
You described it perfectly, it feels like footsies. To me it's even less satisfying than games like A A with similar combat mechanics because at least the combat there is more responsive and "felt".
Also another big problem in AUT is it's TS
Basically, whenever somebody activates TS, the players that are affected by it can see what the TS user is doing, the user isn't stuck in the same position they were in from the pov of the people.
Seeing the TS user move from X to X is an irritating thing, because then you'd know what they're doing or where they're going.
Implementing a mechanic where you can't see or know what the TS user is doing/going would be really great and realistic
Dont forget BE ABLE TO BLOCK TS LIKE NOTHING
This didn’t age quite so well
this is why the old AUT was more fun then the new one
instead of getting half healed combo'd by yone/yauso/umbra
Yeah instead of getting half of ur hp gone u just get 1 shotted
@@negacatn254 i mean old AUT u still get one shotted but it was more fun
Yes, and waiting for severals hours for a cursed orb was more fun
Oh wait it's still the case
Honestly I feel like the reason I keep on going back to YBA is because of it just has more playibility than AUT, even thought updates take several months and no sneak peaks are given to the community. AUT’s problem lies in how easy it is; there’s no story mode, no real grind you have to do for anything or at least no grind that compares to trying to obtain mih or twoh in YBA. Not saying that YBA is perfect in fact both games have serious problems that need addressing especially YBA with uzu too blinded by money and having lost all passion for the community. In conclusion although the way YBA keeps its player count is usually by people wasting days grinding for a stand and people doing stupidly hard quests, it works YBA has more players because it’s so grindy and AUT isn’t grindy enough
The reason is because when you play AUT it starts with only you on the server if you press the servers below it says 1 of 1 aloud
Meaning it's only the Lobby.
Meanwhile in YBA it transports you to the Main Game itself
For me I just started yba first and got far in it and didn’t want to go start a new game so I just stayed and started helping my friends who are new to the game
bruh i wrote everything about how I prefer yba over aut and how I think the problems in yba could potentially be fixed,and then my youtube crashes,erasing everything
I like the story line in Yba while in aut you get a stand you want and your done