Thank you for comparisons, Colin. I love the softness of the Byredo formulas but I also experienced a fair amount of fall-out on the first go. Found that I had much less with a natural bristle (or duo fibre) brush than I did with a standard synthetic. My fave Singe Beauty brushes did these formulas no favor but Rephr worked great with a tap-off. Finger application also worked well. Overall, I adore this palette for its versatility, performance, and packaging; I expect it to land in my top 10 for the year.
I haven’t had issues with fallout from any of the palettes but I mostly use natural hair and always tap off so maybe that’s why. I am glad you are also loving it
Freaking love this palette! Didn’t bought it immediately, so expensive but the love for the Remembrance palette, the fact that it is limited edition, the cool tones, the multiple one and done shades, the softness of the colors and not to forget the quality! Perfect for my 54 old oily eyelids😁 Love it!!
I'm not even halfway through the video and appreciate it so much! My makeup budget is much tighter this year. The Nomad Cosmetics Ghost Town Palette is something I've been considering and will be a much more affordable alternative to Mineralscapes (which is admittedly breathtaking). Thank you!!! On the other hand, I'm wondering if I should just save for whatever Isamaya releases next!
Aww yay!! I get that. Mine might be tighter too. I think you’d really enjoy the nomad for a similar vibe but I am happy I have both. So intrigued to e what Isamaya does this year
Something about the new Sigma Cool Neutrals palette very much echoes Mineralscapes to me. Fourteen pans, $52 USD with free shipping via Neiman Marcus. Sigma makes respectable eye shadows, though I'm truly impressed with Byredo's formulas.
@@QueerBones I honestly can't tell how cool or warm it is by most of the photos but the reviews should be coming soon. Curious. Just spotted Angela Bright's review. Cursory look at her footage, yeah, the one end of the palette is definitely not as cool toned as expected.
So pretty!! Especially love that pop of color shadow wing on you!! The finishes/muted tones look so beautiful but I know myself and seeing such a stunning palette covered in my fingerprints would make me want to throw it out a window.
I had to stand up and clap in the middle of the video because i absolutely love how in depth you go with our comparisons thank you sooooooooo much for showing us all of these hands down you are the greatest
Thanks for clarifying between Indie brand shades and this palette. I love my indie palettes. I also love this colour story. So it’s a hard decision to make. Especially with it being so expensive. x
So glad I found you on UA-cam just now. I just love your shade and formula descriptions! Spot on. I love this palette so much, exquisite. I have had ZERO fall out on these at all btw, and I am not sure why Charlotte Holdcroft had such a hard time, especially with the greens, maybe brush choice? Anyway fell in love with these larger Byredo palettes at Remembrance (narrowly missed Flora Kalahari) and are now my favorite formulas just because it is impossible to do a bad look.
Thank you! I think brush choice and tapping off excess make a huge difference and I don't think enough people do. I agree, I think the formula is kinda foolproof
I absolutely love this palette. The Byredo big palette formulas are fantastic. The more muted/desaturated tones in this palette are very special! They are unlike any other palette I have. I thought it might be too cool for me, but it works. I can see this being my favorite fall and winter palette. I’m wearing it a bunch because it’s new, but these tones just feel very fall/winter for me. It’s great for me because Remembrance is a great spring/summer palette. Just like they mixed the warm tones in Remembrance with silvers, I love that they put golds in with these cool tones. It’s such a great pop of contrast! I’ve actually used Mineralscapes with Remembrance too recently. (I am still mad at Past Lisa for passing on Flora Kalahari. It’s my biggest “palette that got away”regret. 😢)
I agree, these are unlike any other formula I have. I heard it's a different than the formula in the stone shaped palettes but I haven't tried them yet. I will definitely use with Remembrance now, can't wait to see how that works! Sorry this took a while to get back to, this week was a lot
I am very impressed by this palette. The application is seamless. Thank you for doing the blue eye shadow. It’s always a tough ask for me. I am really impressed by how muted the colours are. It looks gorgeous on you.
I picked this up and haven’t used it yet but excited to try! One thing I will say, I wish the packaging had more weight to it. It’s pretty light and cheap for the price tag. I wish it was more weighted like the PM motherships.
Love the way you swatched this palette in color stories rather than in order 😅 it really helped to see the nuances of the shades so well ❤ I have this palette along with the previous 2 … can’t wait to play with the new one along with the other two 💃🏻👌🏼🙌 thx so much for this video !
Oohh! I loved the blue as a liner! I haven’t done that yet, but I will now! I love that brush for doing a soft shadow liner. I have been surprised hearing people say there’s a lot of fall out with this palette, but I always tap my brush, too. That must be why I haven’t had lots of fall out with this palette either!
I watched Charlotte's video since and she did not tap off, they are soft shadows so it definitely matters how much you pick up. I think brush type matters too, but I think more people need to tap off excess product in general to fix a lot of their complaints lol
When you pulled out LE Vega for comparison it finally clicked to why I was so drawn to this one! I think I’ll be passing on this just because I love my Flora Kalahari and it hasn’t seen enough love, and it’s practically summer already in Vegas and I think this palette would shine more in Seattle spring
It's so beautiful! It is definitely giving North Sea or Baltics, but also... pigeons? Love those kind of greys and the old coin green-golds. Packaging is my favourite so far. I have not yet tried Byredo and will not get opportunity to swatch it. What brand's formula of your collection would you say is similar to each formula in this palette? I think I will like the mattes and satins, but I am picky when it goes to thicker metallics.
I feel the satins and metallics are most similar to pat. Even the thicker ones have that creaminess and softness. Not thick like Sydney Grace or anything. Just thicker than the satins. The mattes are very silky. Steven said similar to givenchy but I haven’t tried theirs. I would say the silk of Lisa but less grip and substance or like the YSL I just got but more silky and finely milled.
I’m so glad you swatched the blues & greens together, this is tremendously helpful, thank you! Love these looks, exactly what I missing seeing in other review videos. Now to patiently wait for the restock email from Byredo 🫠
Swatching mine as I watch. I love how dingy all of these shades are.
Thank you for comparisons, Colin. I love the softness of the Byredo formulas but I also experienced a fair amount of fall-out on the first go. Found that I had much less with a natural bristle (or duo fibre) brush than I did with a standard synthetic. My fave Singe Beauty brushes did these formulas no favor but Rephr worked great with a tap-off. Finger application also worked well. Overall, I adore this palette for its versatility, performance, and packaging; I expect it to land in my top 10 for the year.
I haven’t had issues with fallout from any of the palettes but I mostly use natural hair and always tap off so maybe that’s why. I am glad you are also loving it
Freaking love this palette!
Didn’t bought it immediately, so expensive but the love for the Remembrance palette, the fact that it is limited edition, the cool tones, the multiple one and done shades, the softness of the colors and not to forget the quality!
Perfect for my 54 old oily eyelids😁 Love it!!
I love it so much. I haven’t been wearing makeup the last week or so because I’ve been sick but I can’t wait to use it again
@@QueerBones I can imagine! Get Well soon Colin!❤️🩹
Thanks! Hopefully I’ll be back here soon.
Thank you for comparing it to the nomad palette! I loved all the looks!
I hope it was helpful!!
I'm not even halfway through the video and appreciate it so much! My makeup budget is much tighter this year. The Nomad Cosmetics Ghost Town Palette is something I've been considering and will be a much more affordable alternative to Mineralscapes (which is admittedly breathtaking). Thank you!!! On the other hand, I'm wondering if I should just save for whatever Isamaya releases next!
Aww yay!!
I get that. Mine might be tighter too. I think you’d really enjoy the nomad for a similar vibe but I am happy I have both. So intrigued to e what Isamaya does this year
Something about the new Sigma Cool Neutrals palette very much echoes Mineralscapes to me. Fourteen pans, $52 USD with free shipping via Neiman Marcus. Sigma makes respectable eye shadows, though I'm truly impressed with Byredo's formulas.
It doesn’t look very cool to me. Most of the photos look fairly warm
@@QueerBones I honestly can't tell how cool or warm it is by most of the photos but the reviews should be coming soon. Curious.
Just spotted Angela Bright's review. Cursory look at her footage, yeah, the one end of the palette is definitely not as cool toned as expected.
I bought Mineralscapes as well, but had to order from Self Ridges. I love Remembrance so much I couldn’t resist! ❤
I understand that!
I picked this up too and I can’t wait to start playing with it. I loved the sophistication of this set of shadows. Thank you!
Hope you enjoy it!
So pretty!! Especially love that pop of color shadow wing on you!! The finishes/muted tones look so beautiful but I know myself and seeing such a stunning palette covered in my fingerprints would make me want to throw it out a window.
Thank you!
Haha I get that. I don’t mind it because it cleans easily but I can see it driving others crazy
This is sold out, so I guess it wasn’t meant to be for me.
Glad you were able to purchase this. Beautiful colors.
It’s not sold out everywhere and Byredo said they will be restocking it
You can sign up for restock emails on their site too
It’s available at other US retailers & right now at ! You can still grab it !
I had to stand up and clap in the middle of the video because i absolutely love how in depth you go with our comparisons thank you sooooooooo much for showing us all of these hands down you are the greatest
Aww thank you so much!
Thank you so much for the comparisons! It is always extremely helpful and appreciated!
So glad it was helpful!
Thanks for clarifying between Indie brand shades and this palette. I love my indie palettes. I also love this colour story. So it’s a hard decision to make. Especially with it being so expensive. x
It is so expensive. I think worth it for the right person but not universal
So glad I found you on UA-cam just now. I just love your shade and formula descriptions! Spot on. I love this palette so much, exquisite. I have had ZERO fall out on these at all btw, and I am not sure why Charlotte Holdcroft had such a hard time, especially with the greens, maybe brush choice? Anyway fell in love with these larger Byredo palettes at Remembrance (narrowly missed Flora Kalahari) and are now my favorite formulas just because it is impossible to do a bad look.
Thank you! I think brush choice and tapping off excess make a huge difference and I don't think enough people do. I agree, I think the formula is kinda foolproof
I absolutely love this palette. The Byredo big palette formulas are fantastic. The more muted/desaturated tones in this palette are very special! They are unlike any other palette I have. I thought it might be too cool for me, but it works. I can see this being my favorite fall and winter palette. I’m wearing it a bunch because it’s new, but these tones just feel very fall/winter for me. It’s great for me because Remembrance is a great spring/summer palette.
Just like they mixed the warm tones in Remembrance with silvers, I love that they put golds in with these cool tones. It’s such a great pop of contrast!
I’ve actually used Mineralscapes with Remembrance too recently.
(I am still mad at Past Lisa for passing on Flora Kalahari. It’s my biggest “palette that got away”regret. 😢)
I agree, these are unlike any other formula I have. I heard it's a different than the formula in the stone shaped palettes but I haven't tried them yet.
I will definitely use with Remembrance now, can't wait to see how that works!
Sorry this took a while to get back to, this week was a lot
I am very impressed by this palette. The application is seamless. Thank you for doing the blue eye shadow. It’s always a tough ask for me. I am really impressed by how muted the colours are. It looks gorgeous on you.
Thank you! I am glad you enjoyed it ☺️
I picked this up and haven’t used it yet but excited to try! One thing I will say, I wish the packaging had more weight to it. It’s pretty light and cheap for the price tag. I wish it was more weighted like the PM motherships.
I get that. I don’t mind the weight because I feel it could be too heavy if it was but I understand.
Love the way you swatched this palette in color stories rather than in order 😅 it really helped to see the nuances of the shades so well ❤ I have this palette along with the previous 2 … can’t wait to play with the new one along with the other two 💃🏻👌🏼🙌 thx so much for this video !
I am so glad it was helpful! I hope you love it too!
Oohh! I loved the blue as a liner! I haven’t done that yet, but I will now! I love that brush for doing a soft shadow liner.
I have been surprised hearing people say there’s a lot of fall out with this palette, but I always tap my brush, too. That must be why I haven’t had lots of fall out with this palette either!
I watched Charlotte's video since and she did not tap off, they are soft shadows so it definitely matters how much you pick up. I think brush type matters too, but I think more people need to tap off excess product in general to fix a lot of their complaints lol
Hi! What's on your nails when you swatch the palette? I really like it! Thank you!
It's an old Essie polish, I don't think it's available anymore. It was a geode collection two years ago
When you pulled out LE Vega for comparison it finally clicked to why I was so drawn to this one!
I think I’ll be passing on this just because I love my Flora Kalahari and it hasn’t seen enough love, and it’s practically summer already in Vegas and I think this palette would shine more in Seattle spring
This is definitely made for an environment like Seattle, Sweden or Northern Maine haha
Lovely the dark blue 👌👍🌻
Thank you!!
I wonder if this palette is too desaturated for deeper skin tones. 🤔 I’m olive undertoned medium-tan (toward deep in summer).
I have seen deeper skin tones use it and thought it still worked. I would check out Beauty and Frizz and Alicia Archer’s videos
@@QueerBones will do. Thanks!
Love this palette too
☺️
YAYAYAYAYAYAY!!! 🎉
🥰
miss you hope you are well take care ❤🙋🏼♀️💐
Thank you! Not feeling well but hopefully back soon. Hope you’re doing well
@@QueerBones i’m ok, doing a sleep test for sleep apnea ughhhh you take care i have missed you rest well… 🙏🏻❤️🙋🏼♀️
It's so beautiful! It is definitely giving North Sea or Baltics, but also... pigeons? Love those kind of greys and the old coin green-golds. Packaging is my favourite so far.
I have not yet tried Byredo and will not get opportunity to swatch it. What brand's formula of your collection would you say is similar to each formula in this palette? I think I will like the mattes and satins, but I am picky when it goes to thicker metallics.
Hahaha pigeons
I feel the satins and metallics are most similar to pat. Even the thicker ones have that creaminess and softness. Not thick like Sydney Grace or anything. Just thicker than the satins.
The mattes are very silky. Steven said similar to givenchy but I haven’t tried theirs. I would say the silk of Lisa but less grip and substance or like the YSL I just got but more silky and finely milled.
Another great review, Colin. Thanks for all those comparison swatches.
@QueerBones thank you so much for the info! Haha, I love Sydney Grace mattes but not a fan of their shimmers.
🙋🏼♀️ pretty pallet ❤
I am really happy with it
@@QueerBones it looks super i like it too.. ❤️🥰🙋🏼♀️😊
Swatches begin at 7:22
I put the tag where I did because the context/disclaimer
watching again…. need to write something’s down. 🙋🏼♀️
☺️
I’m so glad you swatched the blues & greens together, this is tremendously helpful, thank you! Love these looks, exactly what I missing seeing in other review videos. Now to patiently wait for the restock email from Byredo 🫠
I’m so glad it was helpful ☺️☺️
Hopefully the restock soon. I’ll post if I notice