What do Russians think now? 9 months after the start.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лис 2022
- Steal BLACK FRIDAY deal! 85% OFF:
get.atlasvpn.com/1420
1420 is one of a kind in Russia, you can support the channel at the following links:
✨ Patreon: / issafourteentwenty
✨ Paypal: www.paypal.me/daniil1420
PayPal email: issafourteentwenty@gmail.com
PayPal name: Daniil Orain
✨ Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/1420
Cryptocurrencies:
🪙 ETH: 0x1F7402dE513afDB5906a174eF22C7030D19651DF
🪙 BTC: bc1qvns4pkvcs6hzktpcnudvgz5sr06u7phwhej0cg
✉️ Business: hello@1420.today
🧢 1420 clothes and accessories: 1420.clothing
Steal BLACK FRIDAY deal! 85% OFF:
get.atlasvpn.com/1420
I had thought as you interviewed, because in North America they have Sesame Street and the Muppets shows here, turns out the women who produced " Muppets in Moscow" lives in the US now, had been interviewed in The Guardian Muppets in Moscow: The Unexpected Crazy True Story of Making Sesame Street in Russia is out now.
It looks like it's warmer in Moscow than Montana, USA right now, lol!
The EU Crime Syndicate aka IVReich, after 2 years of destructing European life and economy, now is making Europe the most expensive continent in the world! OF course, They are not going to be affected by the enormous crisis(self-imposed by a series of sanctions on Russia) but to avoid responsibility and punishment, They will throw millions under the war slaughter machine! It has come to the point that the societies of European countries have to fight against the European regime, medical terror, and worse censorship that was in communism, for their fundamental human and civil rights. The EU dictatorship dictates actions often at odds with the distinctiveness of each nation in all areas of life. It has nothing to do with democracy but instead with totalitarianism and regime and technocracy. So be careful what You wish for!
What do Chinese think now ? 35 months after the start of special zero Covid operation.
Guys, I want to give you an idea. I'm not sure if you do this already or not, but do you guys also show reaction of people on youtube from europe and america in the comment section to the people of russia?
Example: Aren't you russian have enough land already? Why is your Putin taking other people's country? And killing innocents? something like that.
The people in Ukraine are sitting in the basement with no light, no water, no heating, and in Russia people are wondering why they are not liked in Ukraine and why their relatives in Ukraine are no longer in touch. Maybe something is different than they think? Too bad it's so difficult to talk about it.
That last old hag was mindblowing. She asked why Ukrainian children all hate Russia. Well it might have something to do with Russia shelling Ukraine and taking out their power grid in the middle of winter. Boming child shelters and maternity wards also isn't going to win hearts and minds. Nor is conscripting marauders from the east to rape and pillage.
The Russians have no friends anywhere. Even if they win this stupid, stupid war, they have lost everything.
100,000 dead Russian soldiers SO FAR, 100,000 dead Ukrainian women and children SO FAR, all for Putin-Sauron and his sick mind and ego.
Make no mistake, Russia has lost.
Truth
Yes, it is bad that ukrainian people are suffering right now without light and water. Too bad you didnt see how these ukrainians laughed at Crimean people, sitting without light and water in 2015. Just imagine, they were saying that crimea is occupied by russia, and in the same time they turned off light and water for THEIR people in crimea, people that were occupied by russians, like they said. Laughing at "this is the russian world you voted for, get used to it"
Of course, not all ukrainians are like these mad people, but i cant imagine russian brewery producing dark beer named "ukraine at night". And yes, there was ukrainian dark beer "crimea at night", mocking Crimean people's suffering.
Russian propaganda has idea like "ukrainians are our fraternal people, we need to free them from their nazi government, raised by usa and western countries". Ukrainian propaganda has idea "russians are orcs and subhumans, they are dark people with slave mindset, everyone Who supports Russia deserves their suffering".
Эти люди половину спецоперации сидели со всей важной для проживания инфраструктурой, а вот ДНР и ЛНР до сих пор сидят без неё с 14 года
I am from Kyiv. On Wednesday, I watched a rocket explosion from my office. I am quite a humane and peace-loving person, but I feel hostility and disgust for the Russian government and those who support it. I don't want to have anything to do with it, and personally I would choose to live in hard conditions, but not with these guys. Difficulties harden, and the carelessness of the people in this video and the belief in invincibility makes them weaker.
Hi from the UK.
Here to say there is no acceptable reason for Russia to be invading your country. I recently saw an exhibition of the awful scenes in Mariupol and my first thoughts where how similar they were to the genocide of the Jewish population in Germany. Russia are murdering innocent people. I know it I've seen it. Whatever the deniers say. Stay strong.
Stay strong!
I can understand this. The entrenched stupidity and total indifference to the suffering of the Ukranians in these interviews is striking and infuriating. I sympathize with them as well. Putin has insulated them from the worst of it so far. And I think many of them are clinging to patriotism out of fear of the collapse of the state.
@@bluecheesehasmoldinit I`m from Skandinavia and must say that i hate thugs who attack peaceful people because they want to steal their possessions and are prepared to practice violence and death to get it. May the incredible Ukrainian people find the strength to stand against injustice and defeat the thugs. Slava Ukraini!❤❤
@@H.J.U.49 And what about people of Donbass who was killed by Ukraine? My family friends are from Gorlovka in DPR. I haven't seen you judging Ukraine, when Gorlovka was shelled multiple times and civilians were being killed.
I am from Russia, Saint Petersburg. Many Russians really live in a kind of vacuum. now it has become more clear to me about the things that happen to us, about the state of our mind. At the moment, there is not a single person from my family and friends who would condemn this. Everyone thinks the boss knows what he's doing. I feel like a stranger among my loved ones. Are people really that stupid and cruel? I don't want to believe it. Maybe from the point of view of the Russians it sounds very naive, but I just can't accept it and accept it!!! now all my loved ones have become strangers to me.
Awful too hear this ,stay strong .still there are many people that thinks like u in your country also,I'm so sick of this war watching young men dying for nothing... only for and old mans Logic.
Странно считать, что многие русские живут в вакууме, подверженны пропаганде и именно потому поддерживают СВО. Я считаю, что Вакуум он един для всех. Антимиллитарийцы (или как принято их называть - либералы) запросто могут быть ограничены в своем понимании конфликта и подверженны другой пропаганде.
Ваше "против войны" не говорит о какой-то просвящености.
Привет из Санкт-Петербурга, неужели друзья тоже поддерживают? Удивительно.
I think some of it is a soviet mentality. I grew up post soviet times, but my parents lived in ussr. Whenever i expressed empathy for someone like children in africa, people in haiti etc etc they would always get annoyed and would say "worry about yourself first, we also have it bad". It's a victim mentality. I think many Russians feel they struggle enough already and don't have space for empathy for other people. Then add to that 20 years of propaganda where they always say "america does that too so why cant we" and justify everything from imperialism to murder because somewhere sometime america did it too... when my father talks about this war, he only talks about usa. He watches russian state tv every day. It's very sad and I feel so angry. I'm not looking forward to Christmas because I think I'll.end up.ruining it by screaming at my whole family. So I undersrand the frustration. My advice is to find likeminded people online so you can feel less alone. It's the only thing that helps me feel sane.
Be strong and continue to have straight moral system. I know is hard to have delusional family, but how i sad, be strong!!!
There was a man in Moscow selling newspapers and every morning a man come and bought a newspaper, watched the first page and throw it into the trash bin, and this was going on for a week before the salesman asked
- what are you doing?
- I'm waiting for an obituary the man replied.
- But the obituaries are not on the front page?
- The obituary I'm waiting for will be there.
we all look forward to that obituary
For the old woman at the end it is inconceivable that russia might be despised for its actions. It seems to be easier to imagine that somehow America has influenced Ukrainians with some mysterious instruments than to see that it is a direct response to the russian aggression.
Nato overthwoed the Ukranian goverment in 2014...
They'll start to say Coronavirus was made by americans to change ADN and hate Russians. But their system is too good that coronavirus didn't affect russia🙃
Yeah that has always amused me, it would be like Nazi's complaining in the 1940's that the world hates them because they have an fear of Germans not because of their actions. The kremlin has literally created a term 'russiophobia' for this... 🤣
@@bordedup546 that and the fact russia blew up their cell phone towers
She sounds like US led a coup in Ukraine to replace its elected president with a pro western and start a civil war against the Donbas 😳
I have worked in post Soviet Union and have Russian and Kazakh family so I understand the indoctrination the old lady spoke of, but the other way around. My Russian daughter-in-law's parents would visit us and they were an engineer and a Professor. Even though they visited us over a fifteen year period and could see how their daughter had thrived and how relaxed things were here. She earned over £350,00 a year and had a fantastic lifestyle flying off here and there almost bi-weekly. Her Russian parents only watched Russian TV and refused to speak English, but my son and children learnt Russian. Even though they saw the wealth of the South East and how their daughter loved the UK and the indoor plumbing, TVs, technology, and how friendly people were to them - they always mistrusted everything they saw with their own eyes. They would insist we were all brainwashed and things were not good here and there huge crime waves, and everywhere was unsafe and there was always going to be a war between the EU, the US and or the UK were all drug addicts, pedophiles or gay. The point is despite everything they could see they still believed what they were told by Russian state TV. They could not comprehend or leave go of their 'Russian Motherland' or what they thought it was.
Ох, как знакомо.
I have a theory in this regard. Those old folks you talk about live depressed lives in a depressed state, they haven't achieved anything in life, they haven't cultured themselves to the levels they could enjoy life above "meat and bread" satisfactions. That WW2 victory is the only thing they were and ever will be proud of - that is the only victory they can personalize as their own. For this reason everything revolves around this theme of victory, Russia almighty, power, everyone envy us, and alike medieval bullshit. Since this is their only satisfaction on self-realization scale, they continue to feed the monster instead of actually developing themselves mentally and morally.
I remember an example of the same closed mind mentality in an old person but in another way round. A friend in Glasgow's dad had been a lifelong Communist and a year before he died he finally went to look at the USSR. He visited quite number of places, was given hospitality and came back announcing proudly that people were much happier there, that he was delighted to have seen confirmed what he'd always believed. Communism would never be overthrown there and its spread to the rest of the world was inevitable. A year after his death the whole Communist edifice crumbled without any sign that many in Russia or the rest of eastern Europe were mourning it. People often believe what they want yo believe and it takes a lot of evidence to get them to rethink anything!
@@olddogoddments675 not sure about the evidence part - I've heard thousands of their people talk and they pick just suitible information and transform it into evidence, disregarding everything else, regardless of how absurd it sounds. Recently I heard a radio episode where some woman was explaining everyone, that Ukrainians have such a good counter attack, because American general Harry Potter has trained them and has shared them his secrects. If this person does not ackowledges such absurdity, there is no place for evidence at all. That Russian zombie level is hard to beat.
In Russia they seem to believe that gay marriage is compulsory and not just optional, no one forces you to do anything
according to Forbes Russia spent 82 billion on the war since February, that's a quarter of the entire russian government budget, and in 2023 it will get only worse for other non war related spending like healthcare schools or infrastructure. It would be interesting to ask russians if it wouldn't have been better if those money were used in improving their country instead of destroying Ukraine.
Such expenses are because of you, so we will blame you (+ your weapons kill our mobilized, rejoice in the "Russian stuffing" as you say, but one day we will take revenge)
@@user-yj5jg8xs2p Nope, such expenses are because you attacked a sovereign country. Period.
@@user-yj5jg8xs2p Attacking a sovereign country and then bitching about killed conscripts and blaming everybody instead of yourselves. Come on ruski bot, try harder.
@@user-yj5jg8xs2p Always the victim, eh? I feel like Russia needs thoroughly deprogramming when this is all over. The world is not against you. What you see now is the result of your government's actions. And you have the government you have because Russian people gave up democracy in order to feel safe. A lesson to us all...
By the end of summer EU countires paid Russia around 103 billion for resources. I guess EU should be designated a "sponsor of a sponsor of terrorism".
Suggestion for the next question:
- "Do you think all the media (TV, Internet) in Denmark, Sweden, Mexico, Canada, Germany, France, Italy, Poland, Japan, South Korea, Belgium etc lie about the war in Ukraine or... the Russian media lies?"
- Follow up 1: "Do you know / agree that what is said in the Russian media is completely controlled by the Kremlin?"
- Follow up 2: "Do you believe that in all other countries the media is controlled by their government as much as it is in Russia?"
never seen so stupid suggestionᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ
They literally do think that western MSM is more corrupt than state sanctioned media. Thanks to the orange turd stain 'fake news' became prevalent in the free world. These clowns that support him censor their media habits on his orders... It would have been unthinkable a few decades ago that a free country would have a large percentage willingly self censor, but Trump did love the asinine people for a reason!
Isn't it obvious that the West is remotely controlled from the White House? Why would they be anti Russian i.e. nazis for any other reason? Vova and his dream team (NK, Iran &c) will save the human kind.
Predicted typical reply: "All those countries and all their media are robots controlled by the US. The US points a gun at their heads and hypnotizes them with it. And drugs them. And plants microchips in their ears. I saw all this on TV. You should open up your eyes if you don't want to be a robot, hypnotized, drugged and microchipped by the US." And so on.
Would LOVE this :)
“It’s worthless bravado!” Well said, sir.
Meanwhile in the west that is almost all that fuels them. "SUPPORT THE TROOPS" is another way to say "Shut up and agree, if you don't, then I will question your 'patriotism'".
I wonder: where do these billionaires work that they were not affected by the sanctions? I live in Moscow, I work, I get enough, there is enough money for everything, but even I was affected by sanctions, at least by the fact that all food products began to cost twice as much.
В 2 раза дороже ? Максимум процентов на 10 в Екб. Если вы про газировку и прочую хрень то это не продукты.
If they say they are Not affected... Maybe they are just saying they dont care?
They just say that. Let’s see next year at the next mobilisation, what they think.
@@wederMaxim ну вот например хлеб, который мы обычно покупали, стоил 27 рублей, а сейчас 44. Почти в 2 раза
@@youngblood7191 странно. Вроде Екатеринбург беднее Москвы, но у меня все нормально. Только вот однажды заглянул в отдел газировки и охренел от цен. А хлеб как и раньше по 36.
It's so refreshing when I see a sane, intelligent person. And then... I see the others and I lose hope.
But of course, because there are different people. 🤦♂
The last person is one of those who’ll support anything the government says and does. Scary
Видео вышло 2 минуты назад. Как ? Вы бот ?
@@wederMaxim it’s just because you’re slow and ignorant you can’t watch a video nine mins long.
They all use the same sentences - Zelensky is a coke head clown, and Why did they bomb Donbas for 8 years
I think its impossible to reeducate the elderly Russian population, if Russia will continue with this same mindset soon Russia will be bombed, because that is straight up terrorism and big % of population are on Putins side
@@Rblock777 Old people just have to go, no other solution for Russia.
@@wederMaxim открою тебе секрет. Можно сделать так чтобы как только видео залито приходит сообщение об этом. Можешь попробовать, очень удобно.
It amazes me how flippantly some Russians talk about getting "new territories" yet can't seem to understand that Russia has to take others territory to achieve it.
Russian own territories at 99% don’t work for common Russians. Huge territories full of possibilities. Since that I don’t understand, why do we need any kind of invasion at all.
Russia has the largest landmass on Earth but they still need some more territories to make it "all better" LOL
@@roberttracey9834 I'm Canadian and we have the second largest landmass. Never felt like I needed more elbow room, geographically speaking.
No, they are perfectly aware and want it. Also, all Dugin fascist philosophy is based on russia starting from Lisboa at the west and much southern than they are too.
Amazes me, too, but from what I learned in the last Months it has to do with a century-old pathological Russian fear of being vulnearble as long as its borders are not running along coasts or mountains. (Bonus: they don't mind if the grabbed terrotory has natural resources).
6:26 "Be proud that you did something well, not that you kill somebody" 👏👏👍
Well, one thing that I've had to accept after watching this 1420 channel is that I can't predict the answers based on the person's appearance. 🤷🏼♂️
My hit rate has gone down considerably since the mobilisation and mass exodus. 🤣
You shouldn't judge anything about a person by their appearance.
@@dianajemison105 Predicting answers based on the many facets of appearance is not "judging." There's no need to escalate the matter into a question of character.
@Dr Oscar Foster Correct on the elderly, wrong on the women.
The same swamp as now 😭
Thank you Daniil ❤️ stay safe xxx
The fear inside Russia is deep. I couldn't imagine living in a country where your afraid of your own government. Afraid to say what you really feel on camera.
Fu*k you m*therfucker. We are not afraid of our government. You and your "Putin's dictator" are just freaks
So you would be able to freely speak about the migrants or lgbtq people in the west? Every country has taboos.
You realy get a point there!
yeah, my boss chose to burrow deep in denial and gets angered every time I provoke him with questions about future. not even about war or politics, just future
@@anitapodsudek8041 when did the U.S. and Canada lose it's freedoms.
I have to admit that I laughed a little bit at the old lady at the end saying how Zelenskyy was a beloved clown who performed in Russia but the Americans had twisted him against the Russians. She didn't consider the fact that it was the Russian invasion of his country that turned him against Russia and not anything that the Americans said to him about Russia.
@@Sssssss553 She is very wrong
Yes the americans made the russians bomb them every day and thats why russia are hated over half the world ,thats some thinking there.
well, that's how quickly you forget the coup in 2014... Until then there was zero conflict with Russia
Zelenskyy's performing style IS clownish, and if you've seen a lot of him as an entertainer you might find it hard to imagine him being a serious president. But he does have a law degree and law license and he did build a million-dollar business, and because our access to news is not blocked we see how he is working effectively for Ukraine, both in getting support from allies and keeping his people informed and inspired. The Kremlin likes to show videos of Zelenskyy looking silly, and even supposedly corrupt because of a routine where he plays the piano with his penis and another where he and three others cut up with a spoof of a dance routine by the group Kazaky called LOVE where they dance topless in 6-inch high spike heels. Sometimes I think of him as some happy, buoyant boy I used to know who had to grow up and stop having fun and just be serious all the time and it makes me sad, but everyone knows now, I think, that he was the right man in the right place at the right time, that he stood up to the challenge and did what needed to be done and the history books will name him as a hero in the mold of Sir Winston Churchill, and Putin as a brutal and slimy sociopath.
@Dadalux "Fermented mind" 😆
"Never think that war, no matter how necessary, nor how justified, is not a crime." Ernest Hemingway
Yes!!
The guy said “they want to take our land”. I know of no country, not one, that wants to take Russia’s land.
Thing is, Ukraine was always Russian puppet and USA put their puppet in charge so USA actually is taking Russian land, nowadays we dont live in the world where we annex states - we control their economy, culture and make them our slaves without the shackles. Vladimir Putin lost his mind and wants to do it the old way because Russia is losing the Cold war hard.
@@Dark_Voice wow, you certainly have a negative view of the world.
You must live in a box. The smartest and most anti-social of people want to pillage Russia, like the US did to Iraq and many other nations. You have no clue.
@@Jean-Seb it seems like Russia should not have invaded Ukraine, from Belarus. It is a very stupid dictatorship.
@@toma9976 Ukraine invaded the innocent Russian speaking territories of the east and KILLED THEM for 8 YEARS! Who cares what allied country of Russia Russia decides to protect the innocent from? You don't think American weapons didn't have to go through numerous countries to reach the doorsteps of Russia?!
Thanks for continuing to produce these glimpses of what is in the minds of ordinary Russian citizens.✌️
If I get my way, Daniil here will be Putin's replacement. He is young, smart, and very pragmatic. Russians seem to feel being a leader is a very hard job, but when a good man/woman comes along they rise to the task. Danill Orain for president!
@@Matt-nj so far you can only become a russian president is you're older than 35 years old
@@Matt-nj Amen!
Makes me think that i'm unordinary then, because i do not have anything with the minds of those...
lol, I do not advise you to trust any interviews and youtubers from Russia. I am russian citizen and even before the war I had the feeling that 1420 is the kremlin propagandists, whose goal is to show that 80-90% of russians are putinists. In real life, among Russian youth, I do not see lovers of the Russian government at all. Russian propaganda is smarter than it looks
An interesting question would also be what Russian citizens say about the fact that the reasons for the Russian invasion have changed several times since February. First it was said that Russia would never invade Ukraine. Then it was suddenly the urgent denazification and demilitarisation of Ukraine. The Russian side also claimed that they did not want to occupy any territory. Then suddenly it was a war against NATO. Then suddenly referendums were held in the occupied territory (with 35k ballots out of 1.4 million citizens) and Putin let these sham referendums count as justification for the annexation. Then lately it became a fight against the Satanists in Ukraine. At the beginning of the war, Putin also assured that there would be no mobilisation. Suddenly there was. Putin seems to be very flexible in this respect and Russian citizens also seem to have a very bad memory.
They are not there for the truth. Their goal is Ukraine annexation and justification of their wrongdoing by any means necessary.
@@PUARockstar Yes, this applies to the Putin-controlled politicians, but why the citizens accept the incessant lies is somewhat puzzling to me. Are they really such sheep?
У нас не плохая память, все прекрасно всё понимают. Но также все понимают, что власть безнаказанна и будет менять законы, конституцию, обещания так, как им это выгодно в данный момент.
@@jennyJx Хорошо. Тогда будем надеяться, что за Путиным и его друзьями последуют политики получше.
indeed
Thanks for these fantastic videos.
That old lady complaining about other people being indoctrinated. Jaw dropping
Literally the only people I've seen say things like "I only want truth" and "I'm trying to be unbiased" is hardcore Z-types. The most extremely brainwashed people subconsciously project it onto others.
yes scary levels of brainwashed hypocrisy.
She is a typical old russian woman, selfish, indifferent, uneducated and don't mind if other peoples children are sent to die. She just watches state tv, goes to groceries and gossips with other babushkas.
@@nervoeser5828 you perfectly adopted tactics of russian propaganda - not to tell exact lies, but to create doubts. Stick it up into your arse
@@nervoeser5828 I have seen plenty of Russians proudly displaying Nazi symbols . I have encountered Russian football fans/ hooligans with Nazi symbols tattooed on their bodies with no respect for women or people from different backgrounds. They destroy everything and go looking for fights. Chelsea fans ( formley owned by a Russian ) arethr worst fans in England .
You have poisoned many people on my home soil . Far to many for my liking ( a cowards game ) . You have threatened my country with nukes. And threatened to take Ireland out with us ( who haven't done anything to you )
Why should I not want Russia to loose?
6:08 "Be proud that you can give life, not that you take lives." Wise Russian
Thank you Daniil, I love your videos, stay safe🍀
Stay safe Dani and crew.
thank you for still making these. You ask good questions and we get valuable insight into peoples minds. You are awesome.
He seems too biased and sometimes is even rude in how he asks questions or what he is asking. As a person who lives in the USA, you wouldn't believe the types of people and their statements on Russia here. Not everyone is hateful but a good amount of people believe the TV media which is corporations that own them and also owns weapons making companies. People will believe their lies and believe Russians are bad people.
@@Jean-Seb I agree some of the questions are confrontational, but they do a nice mix all and all so it's fine. The grand total makes this excellent reporting from inside the country 👍
Thanks again for your videos ! be strong ! .. it's always very sad to watch your interview .. but this is what 's is going on for real !
great job man....thanks for the insights
remember when the war was all about the us biolabs? i haven’t heard a followup on that story in a while
its satan himself nowdays thats keeping them ukranians from freezing
Russians throw shit at the wall to see what sticks, its about biolabs, Nuclear bomb, dirty bombs, attacking Belarus, protecting Russian speaking people, and my favorite from Russian propogandist is Ukrainians are bombing their own hospitals and schools. Its basically the same playbook republican's in America use which we call whataboutism.
I think we're at.. America bioengineering mosquitoes with deadly disease to kill all Russians. 😂
I remember when the war was all about liberating from Nazis.
I remember when the war was all about NATO expansion.
The guy at 5:11 saying the government has a plan is unbelievable. If the plan was to destroy itself and neighbors then it works perfectly. The agony is coming soon.
had a plan ... it is 9 months since their plan fell apart
Probably has more of a plan the Biden in his demented daily life.
From Finland cheers to those wise people. You are the ones who make that different happen!
I think between 2000 and 2014 russia had no sanctions at all and the economy was growing fast. Even tho 99.9% of wealth went to the oligarchs and just a drop to the average people
Yeah... What sanctions and hste for Russia do they mean?!?
Like I always scolded my polish grandma. She was super anti-Russia. Mind you not anti-russians per se, but their countries had history.
Well we live in Germany, different horrible history, but we surely turned around.
I always told here its in the past, we have to believe in a peaceful united Europe.
And now? I scolded here angst for Russia and those bas#$% invaded their neighbours. I feel rather foolish and lost. My dream of a peaceful Europe shattered for now.
> between 2000 and 2014 russia had no sanctions
Neither before 2000. Only some (military-related) technology import restrictions during some of the late soviet era.
In contrast, Russia imposed trade sanctions on Ukraine in 2012 (~ $7 billion according to Yanukovych himself)
He thought currency depriciation and other countries growing at a faster rate was sanctions. I don't think he knew what he was talking about.
Until 2007 Russians' real incomes were good (for Russian realities ofc). In 2008, there was a significant reduction of several times, but Russians still didn't lose. Since 2014, Russians have been losing again and again in real terms. Even Komsomolskaya Pravda admitted this has been a dire state for years.
At the end the older lay saying "we have only one clown", maybe not the one she thinks about.
Thanks for the videos my friend! :)
Good video. Keep them coming and be safe.
Thank you for your insights in Russia. It's very interesting.
These videos are priceless for history
@@anitapodsudek8041 Ah, yes, everyone with an English name is from the US. Makes sense. Not like there are any other countries that also have people with English names.
sorry this is happening now in Ukraine . War against independent country.
I've impressive at how respective you are when asking questions. Good job!
He has more videos that you will see after a while he has a slant that is kind of bad. The way he states some questions is really bias and some of the questions are even ridiculing people. Young and ignorant, while looking down on older people who have different experience for disagreeing with him.
i see bias
I think Russian history can be summarized : Then it got worse.
🤣 Ok, now that's hilarious. I hope you don't mind if I borrow that one.
the most famous sentence in the Russian world, pronounced by a minister following the barbaric intervention of security forces during the hostage-taking at the hospital in Budonovsk: "We intervened but it ended as usual"
Worse, and stupider
Solovyev, says it is a honor to die in Ukraine for Mother Russia, but has never served. The Russian Ambassador to the EU said his son will not need to fight in Ukraine because he has a family and has had no military training. Unlike the 100s of thousands family members who were mobilized. To be safe you need to have a seat at “the Russian Imperial court”.
Thank you Daniil & 1420. Excellent interview. And depressingly paranoid in places.
"Be proud that you did something well, not that you kill someone"... Amen. That echoes something my late Father said - he was an RAF bomb aimer in WW2 and he always said that "no matter how necessary or deserved it is, there is *nothing" to be proud about killing someone"
Thanks for those videos. They are very insightful to understand the different mindset.
Well, I should say to "know", instead of "understand"; I can't believe when I heard the last lady referring to others as "non humans".
well fan fact the British ,so as to validate themselves and not feel as guilty, decided to believe blacks were non Humans
Nice work as always, hopefully we don't get a "12 months" episode (while the war's ongoing)...
Chances for the war to end now are slim.
This war will be as long as Putin stays in power and maybe longer unfortunately.
Why not? Those “people” are full of hateful and self destroying, there is nothing to help them at all
Not even a good thing man
"12 months" will be truly horrific in Ukraine, if it isn't already. How will Muscovites be spending their Christmas with their head of the Orthodox Christian church calling for mass extinction a "satanic" race in Ukraine?
Isn't religion a wonderful concept?
You might be the bravest Russian nowdays. Keep it up.
he is
they say Russia has no freedom of speech, looks far better than the west. Talk about Russian perspective these days you will be instantly banned, censored and demonetized.
That would be Zelenskiy (russianspeaking russian jew ethnically from russianspeaking city). He has more courage than 99% of russians.
I'm joking, of course, but not entirely.
@@PUARockstar Of course you're not joking. The average commenter on a pro-UA, anti-RU channel like this literally sees Zelensky as some kind of Marvel superhero combined with the DNA of Gandhi and George Washington, instead of what he actually is: a greedy narcissistic puppet who is all too happy to send waves of men into a meatgrinder while he busies himself with celebrity photo ops.
@@birdick1307 the difference is I know him personally. But no, I don't idolise him, never were
From December 1, it will be forbidden to publish forecasts of the military-political situation. This paragraph is included in the order of the FSB (something like FBR), which lists other information that is inadmissible for publication and distribution, which, if received by foreign sources, can be used against the security of the Russian Federation.
The ban also applies to individuals
Where is this information from? I live in Russia, it's fake
@@shesanicon7411 if you live in russia how you know whats fake and whats not?
@@uxsenebeli because there is no information about it even in Russian media which hate our gov...
@@uxsenebeli there no information about it even in western media
Ah yes. It’s the Americans 😂 as usual. It’s good to have a reliable enemy. I thought the guy who talked about the need to produce things besides kids made a good point. If that happens it will at least be one upside for Russia out of this. Always interesting…thanks!
The problem is - production needs access to capital and technologies.
From which Russia has been cut by sanctions. So, this guy's logic "now when we can't buy Western-made goods it's time to start producing our own" doesn't work in reality.
@@user-sy2jy1si8f ох да Иран то не находился под санкциями 40 лет и не смог построить свое производство
@@user-yj5jg8xs2p Iran doesn’t need to have its production up. Terrorist states like yours have no right to do business with democratic nations. You terrorist countries can all trade with yourselves
@@user-sy2jy1si8f Spot on. Not only components but markets too. It’s costly to tool up for production and not economically viable if your market is small. The only way for self sufficiency is to go back to a planned Soviet economy. That lasted only 70 years when China was poor and they had the eastern bloc to rely on.
@@Gopferteckel actually, Soviet economy never was self-sufficient.
Technologically, it was always dependent on the West
My boyfriend is in kyiv I'm in the US and every time the power goes out the past few weeks and I don't hear from him when he normally will call I get so much anxiety and feel so helpless because I start thinking he's dead
That's so scary... I'm sorry you both have to deal with that.
Send him a starlink and a generator lol
Thank you for your journalism
"journalism"
It's not a real journalism at all....
Lol 1402 still existing in Russia may be the best commercial for a working VPN ever.
The war costs each one of them at least half of their income and wealth. Down to their grandchildren. They cannot see it clearly now, just like you cannot see the earth is round.
But the loss is and will be there.
1:32 “we only know how to make kids” 😂😂
Not even that...
Russia fertility rate is low.
And mr p wants women to have 10 children! I wonder why?
Looking at their demographics, they don't even know how to do that. Russia will be Muslim majority by the middle of this century, like Western Europe.
@@chefchaudard3580 Therefore, they "make" new Russian citizens from residents of conquered lands and even kidnap young children to raise them as Russians.
That's why they're stealing Ukrainian children
Russia has 11% of world's territory but poor living conditions. The fix to that problem is "new land, new money". This guy lives on Mars.
Hey there ! Question suggestion for your fellow muscovites: do they follow the news about the protests in Iran
and do they consider the protesters brave ?
Keep up the good work brother
Российская верхушка хватается за любую возможность удержать власть,извините, пересраться со всем миром, убить СОТНИ ТЫСЯЧ людей, потерять МИЛЛИОНЫ трудоспособных граждан, в страхе бежавших из страны, разрушить экономику,потерять тысячи единиц военной техники, у меня нет слов, чтобы описать тот ужас и шок от осознания, сколько зла кучка лысеющих стариков принесла миру. Нет ничего ценнее человеческой жизни, эта война стёрла всякие моральные принципы , обесчеловечила людей, которых мы считали близкими и родными.
Мне 20 лет, я была слишком юна, чтобы даже отдать свой голос на выборах 2018года , уже тогда было очевидно, что мы идём в никуда.
Это просто смешно! Минобороны Шойгу не служил, Минобразования и года в школе не проработали, нет большей напасти, чем идиоты, дорвавшиеся до власти!
В паспорте 20 лет, а в голове...
Так измени это в лучшую сторону. Всё в твоих руках
Everyone was feeling very opinionated on this day! Great work as ever. I feel for the grey hoodie guy, he seems like he has a firm grasp on reality - it must be a strange and surreal experience to feel like a lone voice of sanity. Hopefully he has some like-minded friends.
The way that guy gulped at 2:46 when asked about the future of his country. Telling body language
I noticed that when you start developing a conversation with people from the point closer to them (and safer), they eventually open up more.
Not starting with war or political questions, but rather on personal life, views on the future. In most cases, they will turn the conversation towards those things themselves.
If they begin to talk about how great Putin is, ask them who do they see as the next president (reminding that Putin will not stay forever - he's not getting any younger). If nobody - that's an interesting thought for them.
If they turn the Ukraine talk towards "historical Russian lands", ask them whether they visited Crimea (before or after 2014), do they have relatives in/from Ukraine.
If they start talking about "victory", try asking whether they think new territories will require a lot of expenditure and how that will affect their economics. Whether they would prefer a peaceful solution, do they think Ukrainian people are at fault or their bad government (and which of their presidents was the worst Yanukovich, Yushchenko, Poroshenko, Zelensky - the government has changed multiple times during Putin's rule).
The accession of new territories to Russia is inevitable, so we must treat this as a fait accompli. Yes, now these territories will require an investment of money, but in the future all this will pay off in full. After all, these are the richest in fossil territories. In principle, these fossils are enough to support themselves. And it is important that now incomes go not into the pockets of Ukrainian oligarchs, and not Russians, but for the benefit of the inhabitants. As for the future president of Russia, no one will be able to answer, because so far there is no worthy contender capable of replacing Putin. We hope that it will appear closer to the elections. But most likely he will be from the military elite. Regarding Crimea, we can say that the main fear of the Crimeans is that they are afraid to return to Ukraine again. Which is not surprising.
@@danascully6670 Pretty sure average Crimeans were fine with life inside of Ukraine prior to 2014. Everything went to shit afterwards and not because of Ukraine in itself, but because of the division between people with Russian and Ukrainian ancestors and roots. After the illegal anexation, Ukraine cut out the water supply to it, they had severe droughts and the remaining population (mostly Russians, as any normal Ukrainian would flee) got even more "anti-Ukraine". I wouldn't necessarily put all of the blame on Russian, but I'd say it's at least 90% the fault of Russia's government. As far as I can tell, the reason for the anexation of Crimea in particular was a strategic one, as Russia wanted to secure the deep sea port of Sevastopol. It was under Russia's control, but a pro-european government could have resulted in this deal getting revoked. It wasn't "we want to keep our Russian compatriots safe". Same goes for Donbas. It's a strategic rich part of Ukraine. BP and Shell were drilling there and allegedly found lots of natural gas reserves in the area, which could potentially make Russia's gas exports almost obsolete and unnecessary. Obviously Putin couldn't let that happen. At the end of the day he remains "a master strategist".
@@danascully6670 Russia is rich in resources. It does't need Ukraine
@@deniivanov strategic goals are certainly present. But they are more related to security. And as for the Crimea, everything was by mutual agreement. Mutual security again. Now there would be NATO bases, not the Black Sea Fleet. Did the Crimeans need these bases? probably the best option was lost for them. At least that's how they write.
@@PG-wz7by This is imperialism, nothing more. Prior to the invasion the EU was Russia largest trading partner by far... Had Nord Stream 2 come on board then Russia would have avoided import taxes transiting Ukraine and even the deposits found in Ukraine would have taken decades to develop and deploy and likely by then wouldn't be worthwhile given the shift from fossil fuels.
edit: the EU was their largest trading partner even after their invasion of Ukraine in 2014!
The war has now become an end unto itself, the reasons for the war constantly change because there was never a good reason for it to begin with. Now for Russia it needs to be won, for no reason other than to win it, therefore there is no concept of what victory actually looks like because the war has no objective.
Thanks!
"Be proud that you did something well, not that you kill somebody. Be proud that you can give life, not that you take lives." Everyone should live by those words. Thank you for all your efforts, Daniil.
One of them got it right about Russia: nothing changes.
“Everything is exactly the same as before… but we do miss our son”
I don't know how you keep going, man. But I love you.
6:30 that man is speaking the truth there
i believe you found some very brave people in this interview and i respect their thoughts that any war is a pointless task and to be proud of what you do that is good.
these people i wish well and if only all Governments had this ideals it would be a much more peaceful world
I always watch your videos, and I'm always disturbed by them. Please keep up the good work. What you do is very important! (And risky.)🇺🇸
We have one clown 🤡 ohhh not us, but them. Term "Freudian slip" 😂😂😂
Клоун у нас один...
Ой, не у нас, а у них.
Прям оговорка по Фрейду
Poison clown. Next gig: floating belly up in the Mockba River when the inevitable Ceaucescu moment finally comes.
@@mikerodent3164 It will be a massive celebration across the world when pootin get ceaucescu'd. In Ukraine especially.
I've made the same comment about 8 months ago. The sanctions take time to sink in, the experts said about 12-18 months before you'll see the effects. You're now 9 months in from the first sanctions. The effects are coming....
Im with you.
But sanctions don't only affect individuals (like rising prices, nonavailability of western products etc), but it will more n more affect the state russia: nearly isolated in world community, loss of high income by selling oil/gas, foreig currencies drop, loss of tech western know how etc.
Not a bright future for tsar Putins russia...
Also people seem to expect Russia ro completely collapse.
The first objective was to make war as costly as possible for the Russian state and to ensure it couldn't buy new weapons or advanced parts to build more.
Now, there are only two counties that sell weapons to Russia: Iran and North Korea.
Even China, the so called ally of Russia doesn't.
Those samé expert said theyr economy Is falling few months ago
@@MrMajsterixx sure thing Ivan LMFAO
That's true. Sanctions are slow poison, not a sword.
"New territorys, new money." It is like listening a thief bragging.
he wouldnt call himself a thief, he just takes whats there .. like garbage collector of sorts
Also the fact that 'new territories' actually means less money/more spending 🙄
Indeed. And they are stealing not just Ukrainian territorities, but ukrainian people to, doing a genocide. We can't allow any of that.
great work!
That old last lady... My god.
Interesting, looks like their day to day life wasn't affected that much. I bet those French supermarket stores make huge profits. It's unfortunate that EU doesn't ban all exports except for bread. We had 9months to prepare business for this and we did nothing.
The majority of those people don’t use expensive gadgets and do not have even a small thought to go travel. I am affected by sanctions, just because I like to travel (it’s very expensive now and some destinations are unavailable), used to shop in European and US online-stores (shipping and payment issues), and have two hobbies that are 90% connected with import (snowboarding and road/gravel cycling). Can’t use Apple-pay, that made me several times return home to get my wallet, cuz I used to take only phone to my local food-stores. Moreover I see how sanctions affecting healthcare (since I work there), now all the “hi-tech” equipment is 3 to 4 times more expensive, some of already existing stuff is out of order (lack of spare parts) and my income decreased by 20-30%. But I also clearly and with pain understand that my “struggles” are nothin in comparison with Ukrainians. And yes, it seems like the majority of old and poor people in Russia believe, that the shit that is happening is some kind of a justice and is good for all Russian people (like “make Russia great again”).
@@Maks4e "Make Russia Great Again" - the more retarded version of "MAGA". At least "MAGA" had some actual points to promote. What do we have? Gas, oil and former military glory, even though our military has been robbed to its underwear in the past ten years and lacks financing.
But seriously, it's gotta suck. Lack of quality health care, inability to travel properly, limited foreign import and trade in general, decreasing work opportunities, etc. etc...
Best wishes from a Finn with Russian ancestry. Let's hope this whole thing gets resolved in as civil of a manner as possible. In the meantime I'll just sit on a snowy hill with my bucket of popcorn and watch the shit show progress.
@@DansuB4nsu03 have lots of Niirala stamps in my passport, btw. The last time I was crossing Mordor border in October, Finnish customs-officer asked me if I understand that I will not have an opportunity to return in the nearest future.. And wished me a good luck.
Yep, now the main and only our pride is “former military glory” as far as I can see…
But I decided to stay and watch the “show” from the “closest point”. I’m a patriot, if you will. But a patriot «по Шевчуку», not “Z-patriot”.
Another interesting piece ! I found it heartening that Russians are talking about the conditions they live in.
It would be really interresting if you would do a video asking Russians about the similarities of the regime rethoric of Hitlers germany and Putins Russia. Because there are a lot, especially when it comes to the things they say to justify the "special operation"
Modern Russia is an inheritor state of the USSR, one that is trying to infuse the USSR with much older history from the Romanov Empire and even from the Eurasian Golden Horde. There's no actual overlap or ideological similarity with the Thirdreich here, and people who talk non-stop about Hitler comparisons usually have no real grasp on history and political theory
Forbes estimates Russia has spent $82 billion on war with Ukraine since Feb. 24. Maybe ask people if they think the money could have been used better elsewhere.
@Dr Oscar Foster Europe is not even a party to the conflict, but spends billions to support Ukraine. Russia is a party to the conflict, what is your logic
How much money did the US && EU spent on war in ukraine?
We spent more than this in the west and never got a vote on it. I know that money could have helped me and many others. Ask better questions. What is America doing an ocean away in a political crisis that isn't at all theirs?
@@Jean-Seb so you want Russia expands to Europe, eventually this would mean US is also kaput.
Please interview Russians about their thoughts on the recent protests in China against the government. I feel like there are a lot of parallels and I wonder if it makes them reflect on their own situation. Thank you and keep up the good work
I am russian. And I even haven't heard of that. So the same the others
I'm surprised you still here 😐
Thanks for this🙏
They really don't understand that Russia is done for decades to come. Now everyting seems to be fine but in the future it will get worse, to develope high tech industrie takes time. You need a special machine to produce chips and Russia ca't purchase this because it's made in Europe.
Europe doesnt make anything anymore...
@@command_unit7792 Yes you are right, no cars no planes, there’s not ASML . Total Europe on a collapse, freezing to death and hungry. How can I survive 😩
@@command_unit7792 🤣🤡
Oh, poor Russia, what a pity that Kazakhstan does not sell us "super-complicated" chips machines, and China 2 the world economy imposed sanctions on us and does not trade😭😭😭how will we live
@@user-yj5jg8xs2p you are not very bright you know what happens when a product goes to more hands ?? it gets more expensive .. enjoy that :)
That last old lady couldn't really imagine why Ukrainian youngsters would hate Russia? When Russia is starting taking Ukrainian land in 2014, threatens it and now let the bombs rain over Ukraine. She thinks people like being bombed? And fter what happened to Mariupol, and all other horrific things that war involves. Amazing.
Good stuff
8:39 Damn I love your humour man 😁
The old woman at the end, 'everyone in the whole world had been indoctrinated and brainwashed except you my dear 😂 🧽🧠🚿
Haha, it will be huge plot twist if it is true, right?
@@homuneko5070 yeah, could you imagine it 🤔 a bit matrixy 🧐
I just find it hard to trust the opinions of a group of people that are being terrified into submission by their government. It's hard to be completely honest in front of a camera when they know that they could be imprisoned at the slightest provocation. Regardless, this is good work. It's important to record the vox populi even under the influence of an autocrat.
I dont think that they are faking anything. They really are dumb as rocks non chalant idiots. Or oscar worthy actors. One of these two
It's as if the russians would rather live on their knees than die on their feet. Whereas, Ukrainians want to live on their feet, and not die on their knees.
@Mister Dude I'm not here to read between the lines. I can make inferences and assumptions and speculate all day, but that doesn't give me a real idea of what is actually happening in a place I don't understand. The best way to get that is to hear honest reports from people living there. I'll take what I can get and make my inferences just like you, but it's not a substitute for what might otherwise be considered reliable information from people living a more free society.
Like I said, I still appreciate that the reporter is documenting them, even if they're unreliable.
I think eyes tell it all. You can clearly see in such videos who sustain from comments out of fear, and who really believes all this shit. Sadly, most of them speak and believe from their hearts.
@@disky01 _"reliable information from people living a more free society"_ You are absolutely correct.
People really have confidence in the government. It's amazing.
Man, you have balls. Congrats for your bravery, be careful.
Санкции "не задели" людей которым уже плевать на высокую инфляцию просто потому что они привыкли
А насчет товаров корпорации слишком жадны, заявив об уходе многие нашли лазейки чтобы продолжать продажи в России
@Dadalux What? I am not in denial, I know it's going to shit, I am just saying that people think they are not affected by the sanctions because they are used to high inflation and things like coca cola found it's way to the russian market
During the period after 1991 until 2014 there were not sanctions on Russia as far as I know. The West wasn't trying to prevent Russia from trading and expanding its influence but neither was it helping. It seems like Russians feel like the country has not been as successful as it should be because of the West standing in its way.
Even more, a couple of years ago a number of EU officials (some from Germany) lobbied to remove the sanctions (those not so many) against Russia.
Another example: that Orban prick never stopped to promote Kremlin's agenda. He recently wore a scarf with "great Hungary" having within borders parts of neighbouring countries (including Ukraine). And went away with it.
The issue with democracy is that is too tolerant to any a**hole that use it against itself. Putin did that successfully, manipulating democracy at his will, and now we are at the edge of a general war. For the unconcealed satisfaction of hard working trolls in the comment section.
Russia have sanctions from 1917
Jackson-Vanik amendment
@@Chaldon-hl6yk That was before 1991. In any case now the West has imposed huge sanctions because it wants to choke Russia’s economy to death, just like Nazi Germany.
@@Chaldon-hl6yk ahhh yes, the not wanting to trade with commies is a proof of sanctions on RUSSIA, that was a hard one to dig out, you know that USSR tried to build a self-sustained state? maybe they wasn't in open trade relationships either? hmmm
Loved that "Same swamp" comment. How true.
At least Russia fights in self-defense, unlike the west who inserts itself in everyones business.
@@Jean-Seb Sorry Jean, but you are an IDIOT! Just how does invading another country constitute defense? You REALLY need to go look that word up. ONLY a damned Ruskie could come up with something that stupid.
As Ukrainian, I would better live in stoneage conditions (which I experienced too across latest 3 days, without electricity, water, heating, internet, credit cards, vital shops just for food) than to accept russian fascist occupiers. To hell with them and their regome. Glory to Ukrainian people. The truth is on our side, and to accept what these murdereds, genociders, rapists etc. do - is unacceptable. And giving them territories, living people behind to russians on them is a crime for eternity. Total liberation of Ukraine should be the answer. Especially since russia understands only the force, the can't be reasoned or dealt with, the world is starting to understand that now, but still has some way ahead to full comprehension. Борітесь - поборете! Нам Бог помагає! За нами правда, за намит слава. І воля святая! Ми незламні
Нам с юга Украины Россия ближе чем ваша западенщина. А началось все с вашего Ющенкооооо
go back to 2014 the source of the conflict .You are young and naive .
@@confidential6073 Sure, right. So why has that 'source' changed about nineteen times now since the invasion began? It is not him that is naive. The source was that Russia took a large part of Ukrainian land. Tell me, what would you do if another country did that to Russia? That was rhetorical, because we've seen the answer. Find the switch that activates your brain, and flip it.
@@confidential6073 The source was FSB Igor Girkin and his fascist invaders.
Thank you for showing the world that there are normal nice Russian people that are also victims in this terrible war.they need to come to senses and become a prosperous country living in peace (,mostly) with the rest of the world
I see how you are careful with your questions, still I'm amazed you've evaded detention. I admire your bravery young man, it defies most people's opinion of your generation as being apathetic or completely detached. You bring more truth to the mentality of Russia than any western media could possibly do, a true journalist, bravo.
Those people who don't even look at you when asking a question 🙄
05:44 Preach brother! 😀
The fella @1:18 is spot on. Highly intelligent human understands that we must be healthy enough as a nation to stand on our own two feet as much as possible.
I watch most of your videos and I so often get a feeling that Russia today is a horrific realization of "the Lord of Flies". It's horrible how indifferent people are to what's happening
Absolutely. That "Lord of the Flies" mentality has been the source for Russian thinkers, philosophers and writers for generations. "Kotlovan" by Andreo Platonov gives the perfect picture too, but I am not sure if it was translated into other languages.
@@olgasitovenko1281 I’ve checked, it’s available in Polish, added to my to read list. Thanks!
@@easytiger197903 you are welcome😁😁😁.
Combined with 1984.