Xg along side red velvet both represent how to love and live off black influence music and not copy and paste it ...perfection Different sides but shows the same appreciation
I love all your XG reactions. I usually get annoyed when someone sings along but when you do it, it feels like an extra member of the group. Your sincerity and excitement for XG is shared by me and everyone watching.
from what i could read her lips, i'm pretty sure Chisa in the beginning shouts "お元気ですか? 私 は 元気 です! (ogenkidesuka? watashi wa genkidesu!) which pretty much means "how are you?/are you doing well?, i am doing fine!" which i think is so sweet considering the teaser where they seem to be looking at loved ones or family who are far away, so it's almost as if she's shouting over to them that she is okay and checking in from afar :,) some people have also said it's a homage to the Japanese movie 'Love Letter' (1995) which has a scene like that where the main character shouts those exact words to the mountains after the passing of her husband. Love Letter was also referenced by Twice in What Is Love?, with Jihyo playing this scene at the last chorus, if i'm not mistaken
Listening to the opening verses, is it R&B? Can it be R&B? Then that bass drop on the chorus!! Made my knees weak. YESSS! It's R&B! Damn you Simon! I haven't stopped listening to this song!
XG delivery one my favorites christmas song, yes, they save my christmas with this perfect song. That's the truth, i love this girls. Thank for all support and react, i love your videos so much haha thank youuu
This MV makes me feel watching a movie. Each snow spirits that make snow fall with voices of seven colors separated by the fatal prism of the universe. After different loneliness the seven vioce colors of light like a rainbow gather under the peak and become one pure white light. When the XGs has become one, it has been reborn as unique flower spirits beautifully. They are gather under the winter cherry blossom tree waiting for the coming spring. Finally XGs start to blooming with sparkling flowers in pink, and begin to emit a gentle, fragrant voice among us to cuddle in hope,,,,
Love your reaction and your attitude towards those who aren’t having a good time during the holiday season. This song definitely hit all those spots and tries to make it alright or gives people a sense of hope no matter what anyone is going through. ❤
i literally woke up the exact time xg winter without you was released and listening to it woke me up so quick bc i got up and blast it hard on my speakers, its such a vibe
The way i watch the "shameless" plug all the way waiting for Caitlin to hype me up at the end lmao... i be sitting looking like trash but she makes me feel decent lol... THANK YOU QUEEN
@@ELmayberry no cause i looked crusty as hell after 2 all nighters preparing for my stupid exam (when Caitlin said she hated school... GIRL.. I RELATE)
Bruhhhhh you make meeee feelllzz so soft again waghhh after hear you final thounhtzzz,wahhhhh so when im listeningzz this winter without you againzzz like waghhh i wanna cryzzzz alwayzz
The set is from New Dance. When they’re in their spaceship before they teleport to earth. Loooooveeeee!!!! More like when they’re in the blue and white outfits dancing in the spaceship. 😂
Hi Cait! i am not used to hear balads songs but XG maybe change that lol, beautiful as always! voices on point, the sound always take me to some point in the past i dont know if is just me. Thank you Cait!! congrats again for finish your finals!! i saw it on patreon, take care
XG literally created perfection with this track 10+/10. Flawless from start to finish genuine old skool 90s/early 2000s R&B like only XG can do. So many reactors have shown their goosebumps & even cried reacting to it. This song should 100% be going viral & charting on Billboard easily. Sadly, if Grande, Rodrigo, Swift, etc., released this it would already be #1. XG isn't getting the recognition they so much deserve.
You going IN the on this track also suits the early 2000s R&B swag so much too I very love it😂😂 it's the aggressive body rolling and jigging for mee ❤❤
Yaaaay! Finally 😊 Seeing you getting knocked out by the heavenly vocals was worth every second of the wait 😅❤ Maya's vocal curveball floored me too. XG is the DREAM TEAM indeed. This is already a timeless classic, to be played for years to come. Thanks for the XG love as always.
So the part where they were like crying was because they heard their parents voice saying their name and maya and jurin nearly cried or did cry im not sure but it was sad for me because i cried many times
Thanks for reacting to XG! This song is so beautiful but sad, and I love it. Sometimes you need a good cry and this helps lift your spirits at the same time.
Bless you, hon. Know I'm sending you energy for clarity, strength, grace, and knowing all the things. My neurospicy daughter is in the midst of finals and the struggle is real. She sounds like a moaning and wailing banshee most of the time. 😂
Fun fact at 9:53 they are actually seeing their parents and having conversations because it’s been such a long time! Simon put together that little gift for them🥺❤️
This song is absolutely beautiful I have been enjoying the song ever since I've heard it I have I have a bird the yellow bird is in my picture art is my heart and soul and she loves XG and I give her music therapy she loves it so I literally said I put a song on and she immediately started saying that she loves this song instantly
Love your reactions. I agree it's a sad vibe and I'm here for it. The rap and adlibs together? Chef's kiss. 😘 I'll be looking forward to your #XG_UNDEFEATED reaction. 🛸👽♾️🐺🌌
Wonderful reaction. The world has been given such a Beautiful song. ❤ Thanks for supporting XG on your channel. This is XG Enjoy. ❤ Jurin 🦋 Chisa 🌞 Hinata 💠 Harvey 🦄 Juria 🧸 Maya 🐕Cocona 🍄 ALPHAZ 🐺 Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.🎄🎆❤🔥❤🔥
Hi Caitlin. I think this is my first time commenting on your video. XG was on FIRST TAKE and preformed "Shooting Star" and "Winter Without You" Hope you might have some time to check it out😊
i love how everybody's reaction (including mine) after listening to the first 15 seconds of the song is to ask Simon why he playing with us like this as if he is there like 😂 im sure he would laugh if he knew
XG just hasn’t missed yet and I’m SHOOK. XG and Kiss of Life ate this year up. No question. (I’m also hoping for a KIOL album reaction too, but take ur time) This song has been on REEEEPPPEAT since it came out haha
I just subbed to ur Patreon...u are the first content creator i really love...i never use Patreon this is my first time..i love seeing more content there as well
The set is from New Dance, Cocona pops in at the end of the video. The snow set, I can't be sure but it looks similar to the one used in Puppet Show. Takes me back either way, lol.
Grew up listening to TLC, Aaliyah, Brandy, Ashanti, Mary J. And these girls show so much love and respect to R&B. Obsessed with them.
Xg along side red velvet both represent how to love and live off black influence music and not copy and paste it ...perfection
Different sides but shows the same appreciation
@darkstorm08 I love RV too!
Sameee
Except I don't listen to rv
yesss.. same 🥰
Chisa: *hits first note of song*
Caitlin: *soul leaves body* 😂
LIKE DAMN
@@caitlinbensonn 🤣🤣
I love all your XG reactions. I usually get annoyed when someone sings along but when you do it, it feels like an extra member of the group. Your sincerity and excitement for XG is shared by me and everyone watching.
they had no business releasing a Christmas song this good 😭 I’m listening to this no matter what month it is 👉🏻🥴👈🏻
this song is perfect for my christmas playlists
Their stylist had the AUDACITY to bless us with a Hinata fit like this… girl looks like a goddamn Christmas ornament I canNOT 😭😭😭
from what i could read her lips, i'm pretty sure Chisa in the beginning shouts "お元気ですか? 私 は 元気 です! (ogenkidesuka? watashi wa genkidesu!) which pretty much means "how are you?/are you doing well?, i am doing fine!" which i think is so sweet considering the teaser where they seem to be looking at loved ones or family who are far away, so it's almost as if she's shouting over to them that she is okay and checking in from afar :,)
some people have also said it's a homage to the Japanese movie 'Love Letter' (1995) which has a scene like that where the main character shouts those exact words to the mountains after the passing of her husband. Love Letter was also referenced by Twice in What Is Love?, with Jihyo playing this scene at the last chorus, if i'm not mistaken
your correct.. Jihyo referenced Love Letter in the mv when Twice did What is love 😊
Listening to the opening verses, is it R&B? Can it be R&B? Then that bass drop on the chorus!! Made my knees weak. YESSS! It's R&B! Damn you Simon! I haven't stopped listening to this song!
the ad-libs at the end are CRAZY and the fadeout??? yeah this is textbook 90s/early 2000s r&b
New favorite Christmas song! XG killed it all year long.
いつもXGちゃんたちへのリアクションありがとうございます✨ものすごくノリノリで笑、嬉しいです😁ホントに上質なR&Bバラードですよね。この曲そのものも素晴らしいですけど、パフォーマンスしてる時に音楽そのものへの愛を7人からいつも感じます。どこにも嘘がないから、リリックを聴いていても感動がケタ違いに膨らんでいきます😆
Thank you for your reaction💞🎄✨🎁💞
🔥XG 🔥
I did not expect to love this song as much as I do. I didn't know that I needed this. Love your reaction ❤
That set is from New Dance. Congrats on finishing up the school year, enjoy your time off.
Cmon Caitlin you should know by now you can’t do an XG reaction sitting down. lol. Ty for this.
I love how they tried alot of genres this year and killed every single one of them
They're so talented
The behind the scenes of this mv made me sob, I hope you watch it
"Winter Without You" is that song that makes you wanna pick up your hairbrush and just start singing and vibing like XG..Timeless Masterpiece! 🐺
this is such a nostalgic take 😭😭
ooh.. those were the times 😊
your reaction on xg is always on top! hope u will react to kiss of life's born to be xx album, all songs are bops, love yah caitlin!
Same!
XG delivery one my favorites christmas song, yes, they save my christmas with this perfect song. That's the truth, i love this girls. Thank for all support and react, i love your videos so much haha thank youuu
XG ❤
XG LETS GOOOOOO!🙌💯💪🏽🎉🔥🙌🫡🎄
Simply perfection.
XG - WINTER WITHOUT YOU MV | Behind The Scenes. watch this video so you can see why they cried 😭😭
This MV makes me feel watching a movie.
Each snow spirits that make snow fall with voices of seven colors separated by the fatal prism of the universe.
After different loneliness the seven vioce colors of light like a rainbow gather under the peak and become one pure white light.
When the XGs has become one, it has been reborn as unique flower spirits beautifully. They are gather under the winter cherry blossom tree waiting for the coming spring.
Finally XGs start to blooming with sparkling flowers in pink, and begin to emit a gentle, fragrant voice among us to cuddle in hope,,,,
Love your reaction and your attitude towards those who aren’t having a good time during the holiday season. This song definitely hit all those spots and tries to make it alright or gives people a sense of hope no matter what anyone is going through. ❤
i literally woke up the exact time xg winter without you was released and listening to it woke me up so quick bc i got up and blast it hard on my speakers, its such a vibe
XGンのリアクションありがとうございます。MAYAが輝いてました。
I followed your journey from "Tippy toes" to "winter without you" ☺️ can really relate to all your reactions ❤
why do i also feel like im praising the Lord when i vibe to this song? 😂 its the "Joyful raise your voice" part
Jurin coming in with the TLC's Left Eye flow has me dead
XGの音楽を心から楽しんで聴いてくれてとても嬉しい。reactionもとても観ていて気持ちいいです😊ありがとうございます🎉
how can xg kill every kind of music look at that beat.they really the meta now in gg 🤘
The way i watch the "shameless" plug all the way waiting for Caitlin to hype me up at the end lmao... i be sitting looking like trash but she makes me feel decent lol... THANK YOU QUEEN
I love you so much 😭 - THANK YOU! 💕
right.. 😮Caitlin was flirting with me, saying that I look good when I know I was looking a bit bummy 😂
@@ELmayberry no cause i looked crusty as hell after 2 all nighters preparing for my stupid exam (when Caitlin said she hated school... GIRL.. I RELATE)
XG 🔥🔥🐺🎄
Bruhhhhh you make meeee feelllzz so soft again waghhh after hear you final thounhtzzz,wahhhhh so when im listeningzz this winter without you againzzz like waghhh i wanna cryzzzz alwayzz
The set is from New Dance. When they’re in their spaceship before they teleport to earth. Loooooveeeee!!!! More like when they’re in the blue and white outfits dancing in the spaceship. 😂
this is the best reaciton i've seen to this song... seeing someone vibe so much with this rnb throwback makes my heart warm
xg❤
あなたのリアクション大好き！！
見てて楽しくなりました🫶🫶
Hi Cait! i am not used to hear balads songs but XG maybe change that lol, beautiful as always! voices on point, the sound always take me to some point in the past i dont know if is just me. Thank you Cait!! congrats again for finish your finals!! i saw it on patreon, take care
when maya brought out the gospel yoooo
They literally was giving me Mariah carey vibe
The bridge part always gets me 😤😭
XG literally created perfection with this track 10+/10. Flawless from start to finish genuine old skool 90s/early 2000s R&B like only XG can do. So many reactors have shown their goosebumps & even cried reacting to it. This song should 100% be going viral & charting on Billboard easily. Sadly, if Grande, Rodrigo, Swift, etc., released this it would already be #1. XG isn't getting the recognition they so much deserve.
lol Caitlin was flabbergasted by the vocals!
When I heard this, I thought this may be a Christmas song Caitlin likes. 😊
You going IN the on this track also suits the early 2000s R&B swag so much too I very love it😂😂 it's the aggressive body rolling and jigging for mee ❤❤
I was so exited to see u react !!!!
Yaaaay! Finally 😊
Seeing you getting knocked out by the heavenly vocals was worth every second of the wait 😅❤
Maya's vocal curveball floored me too. XG is the DREAM TEAM indeed. This is already a timeless classic, to be played for years to come.
Thanks for the XG love as always.
So the part where they were like crying was because they heard their parents voice saying their name and maya and jurin nearly cried or did cry im not sure but it was sad for me because i cried many times
Thanks for reacting to XG!
This song is so beautiful but sad, and I love it. Sometimes you need a good cry and this helps lift your spirits at the same time.
*Starts shouting* "I'm bouta praise" 😭🤣🤣 Caitlin you got me cryyying
amamos a XG
Hinata went off and Maya omGOD!
gracias por reaccionar ❤❤❤
Bless you, hon. Know I'm sending you energy for clarity, strength, grace, and knowing all the things. My neurospicy daughter is in the midst of finals and the struggle is real. She sounds like a moaning and wailing banshee most of the time. 😂
待ってました🐺
I’ve loved all of their songs, but this is their lane and I kinda hope they stay in it, like this is the sound for them
I absolutely LOVE when you slowly put your chair down so you can stand and vibe lol it gets me everytime lollll
Yess the set is the space ship that they were in in New Dance m/v !!
Fun fact at 9:53 they are actually seeing their parents and having conversations because it’s been such a long time! Simon put together that little gift for them🥺❤️
This song is absolutely beautiful I have been enjoying the song ever since I've heard it I have I have a bird the yellow bird is in my picture art is my heart and soul and she loves XG and I give her music therapy she loves it so I literally said I put a song on and she immediately started saying that she loves this song instantly
Yo 😂. The hard body roll took me out lol. Love this song tho. They added the Motown breakdown 🙌🏾😂
شخص ما لينشر ردة فعلها لانها الافضل دائما 😂😂❤💅🏼
Love your reactions. I agree it's a sad vibe and I'm here for it. The rap and adlibs together? Chef's kiss. 😘 I'll be looking forward to your #XG_UNDEFEATED reaction. 🛸👽♾️🐺🌌
Winter Song 2023🥇📀🎄🎅🏻
👽🧬🐺❄️
XG - World Tour 2024🌏🐺🌍🐺🌎
Your reactions to XG are my absolute FAVORITE! ❄️
My queens!!
This is one of their BEST songs. No boring parts and omg that outro is everythingggg ❤
Wonderful reaction. The world has been given such a Beautiful song. ❤
Thanks for supporting XG on your channel. This is XG Enjoy. ❤
Jurin 🦋 Chisa 🌞 Hinata 💠 Harvey 🦄 Juria 🧸 Maya 🐕Cocona 🍄
ALPHAZ 🐺
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.🎄🎆❤🔥❤🔥
XG be droppin' sad song but makes me smile listening to it.
This is how I remember Christmas used to be growing up. R&B Xmas. It’s warm and happy,sad all of the feels
Its even better on the first take
Hi Caitlin. I think this is my first time commenting on your video. XG was on FIRST TAKE and preformed "Shooting Star" and "Winter Without You"
Hope you might have some time to check it out😊
Hope you have a good break! Happy holidays! 🐺
Sadly enjoying 🥲❤️🩹
i love how everybody's reaction (including mine) after listening to the first 15 seconds of the song is to ask Simon why he playing with us like this as if he is there like 😂 im sure he would laugh if he knew
automatic like for being a hinata bias 🥰
Love your reaction soooo much ❤ XG’s harmony is so dang good ~ I really love old school R&B style
Only caitlin can bodyroll to an emotional ballad😭😆😆
“I’m tryna vibe and praise the lord DONT make me cry” HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Love this song so much i watched it over hundred times already
I feel you on hating school! I’m in nursing school and let me to you…I’m dying!🫠 Enjoy that break girl❤
Hehe, thank you for reacting!
You should also probably react to kiss of life born to be xx album!
XG just hasn’t missed yet and I’m SHOOK. XG and Kiss of Life ate this year up. No question. (I’m also hoping for a KIOL album reaction too, but take ur time) This song has been on REEEEPPPEAT since it came out haha
I just subbed to ur Patreon...u are the first content creator i really love...i never use Patreon this is my first time..i love seeing more content there as well
🎄🌸SAKURA
It looked like a cherry tree.
♾️🤍❄️🙏
"I'm about to praise the Lord" T.T
been waiting for this! thanks caitlin!!!
this song is perfect
This song made me want to break up with my bf so I could regret it and bop properly to the sadness. 😢
Music so good it makes you do dumb shit.
School is something you do to get somewhere better. Hated school, so happy I have the skills/certification it got me. Crying is totally reasonable!
🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🎄
lmaooo this song is so good you needed a praise break
funny how mariah carey has been real quiet ever since this song dropped
Okayyyy lemme buy XG album as in right now. Does this song included on their latest album??
The set is from New Dance, Cocona pops in at the end of the video. The snow set, I can't be sure but it looks similar to the one used in Puppet Show. Takes me back either way, lol.
I know you on simon lists of people to watch reacting to 😂