क्या Dharmendra-Manmohan Desai Salim-javed की वजह से अलग हुए | क्यु md rafi को भगवान मानते थे मनजी
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- दोस्तो आप सब का स्वागत है हमारे यु ट्यूब चैनल फिल्मी फ्लैशबैक पर. दोस्तो इस चैनल पर आपको मिलेंगे बॉलीवुड खबरे, कुछ चुनिंदा फिल्मों की रोचक जानकारिया, मनोरंजन की खबरे, फिल्म समीक्षाए और बहुत कुछ! तो इसी प्रकार की मनोरंजन से भरी जानकारिया पाने के लिए हमारे चैनल को subscribe करे!
क्या Dharmendra-Manmohan Desai Salim-javed की वजह से अलग हुए | क्यु md rafi को भगवान मानते थे मनजी
In this episode we will talk about a fight between Bollywood film director Manmohan desai with Write duo salim javed and singer kishore kumar
all the information shown in this video are based on the newspaper articles,magazines and different internet websites as wikipedia,imdb,boxoffice india,muvyuz etc if any information is wrong in this video the publisher of this video is not responsible.
Note 1 : "Some contents are used for educational purpose under fair use. Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
Note 2 : 'IF ANY COPYRIGHT OWNER FIND THEIR CONTENT IN MY VIDEO SO PLEASE KINDLY CONTACT ME BEFORE GIVING STRIKE OR DO SOMETHING, EITHER I WILL REMOVE MY VIDEO OR WILL GIVE YOU CREDIT.'
Note 3 : All photos with the videos remain the propertwy of their respectful owners. If any of your photos is featured in my videos and if you want to remove or want credit then kindy contact me through mail which is given in my channel about section. THANK YOU Like, Comcment, Share and Subscribe
#FilmyFlashback
#ManmohanDesai
#SalimJaved
#KishoreKumar
#MDRafi
#Dharmendra
#AmitabhBachchan
#Sholay
#Deewar
#AmarAkbarAnthony
#Zanjeer
डायरेक्टर का अपना स्थान होता है जो फिल्म देखने पर ही मालूम होता है पर संगीतकार और गायक का जादू फिल्म के बाद बरसों बरस चलता है , किशोर दा, रफी साहब मुकेश जी, आदि अपने चाहनेवालों के दिल में बसें है , बसे रहेंगे ,
सलिम जावेद के बारे में सही विचार थे मनमोहन देसाई के,
पर किशोर कुमार की आवाज उनको इरिटेटिंग लगती थी सुनकर हैरानी हुई, जबकि उनकी ही मूवीज मर्द, तूफान, कुली, गंगा जमना सरस्वती बहुत ही इरिटेटिंग मूवीज थी 😜
The great adorer and fan of Rafi sb... Who always have the great regard and respect for Rafi sb
👍👍👍👍
Sb singer ka ek hi baap ....kishore daa
@@AjaySharma-ve6in .....shehanshah ek hi hai... Wo hai Rafi sb.
@@sheikhfayaz1258 yeah .rafi was Shahenshah in female voice and harkat ..😂
@@AjaySharma-ve6in kya zamaana aagaya... Gawayyo ko singer kehte hain...
😃😃😃
@@sheikhfayaz1258 sbse bdaa gawayya to rafi chacha hi the 😂
Manmohan Desai ji ki movies Bohot achchi hain..
Lekin unki movies se kayi guna behter Great Kishore da ke gaye hue geet hain jo ki aaj bhi log sirf Kishore da ki awaaz ki wajah se hi sunte hain unn geeton ko..
Jai Kishore da 🙏
We love Kishore da ❤️
Ek dm sahi dada ka jawab nahi
M.M.D. bevkoof bola jayega... jisko Kishore Da ka awaz achhi nahi lagti thi.
It's is personal choice, people have different choices and tastes, but every golden era singers were evergreen , be it Mukesh, Kishore da , Rafi Sahab, Manna Da etc.
Pasand apni apni mai sirf Muhammed Rafi Shaheb Ke gane sunti hu agar mai ye kahu ki Mai Muhammed Rafi saheb ke awaz ki diwani hi mai aur kisi ki gane ki awaz nahi sunti Jo Log MUHAMMED RAFI SHAHEB Ke awaz ke diwane hai wo kisi aur ki awaz nahi sun sakte Ye KHASIYAT hai RAFI SHAHEB ME 🌹🌹
Kishore Kumar was legendary singer and far better then Md. Rafi
आप की जानकारी के लिए बता दूं कि खुद किशोर कुमार को रफी साहब ने 6 फिल्मो में अपनी आवाज दी है।
और किशोर कुमार के बड़े भाई अशोक कुमार को भी सात फिल्मो में अपनी आवाज दी है।
Kishore Kumar ji Kumar ji the hai aur always rahege 👍❤️👌👌...aise kayi manmohan Desai aayege aur jaayege ..par Kishore da Jaisa na koi hua hai aur na kabhi koi hoga ...na kabhi koi aaya hai aur na kabhi koi aayega 👍❤️
Kishore da jaisa koi nahi tha na hai na hoga.........
भाई एक बात और जान लो किशोर कुमार खुद अमिताभ बच्चन के लिए एक वक्त पर गाना छोड़ दिया था बाद में अमिताभ बच्चन ने उसे जाकर रिक्वेस्ट किया क्या आप मेरे लिए गीत गाइए तब जाकर उन्होंने शुरू किया. इसलिए अमिताभ बच्चन के लिए कुछ गीत दूसरे गायकों ने भी गाया था. नहीं तो अमिताभ बच्चन की असली आवाज किशोर कुमार थे।
Q
Bilkul Sahi baat hai
रफ़ी साहब जी ने जो भी गीत गाया वो एक्टर पर पूरी तरह से सूट हुआ है चाहे वो दिलीप कुमार हों राजेन्द्र कुमार हों धर्मेन्द्र हों यहाँ तक कि चाहे राजेश खन्ना ही क्यों ना हो। एक बात तो सत्य है कि कोई भी गायक किशोर कुमार तो बन सकता है लेकिन कोई भी गायक मौहम्मद रफ़ी तो क्या मौहम्मद रफ़ी जैसा बनना मुश्किल है।
@@bioscope3122 अपने अपने जगह पर दोनों महान हैं।
@@bioscope3122 अरे बेवकूफ रफी जैसा बहुत लोग थे खुद महेंद्र कपूर रफी जैसा गाते थे इसलिए रफी ने कहा कि हम लोग साथ में नहीं जाएंगे क्योंकि हम लोगों की आवाज बहुत मिलती है. इसके अलावा रफी जैसे स्टाइल वाले गायक बहुत से आए, अनवर, शब्बीर कुमार, मोहम्मद अजीज ऐसे गायक. लेकिन किशोर कुमार जैसा गायक आज तक नहीं हुआ है ना होगा.
I utterly agreed with Manmohan sir ...It's an individual choice no one is 100% perfect ☝️
No matter what Manmohan likes was. Never it mattered never it will be mattered .
मनमोहन देसाई किसी को अपने से ज्यादा टैलेंटेड नहीं समझते थे।
Kishor da jadu ki chadi the. Jiske sath kam karte the. Tag sirf ek hi hota hai superhit desai sahab shayad dada ko jante nahi the apni filmo main geet gavate the ke geeto ki vajah se film hit ho jaya karti thi. Ye jadu tha kishor da tha god gifted personality ko mera salaaam
I never liked movies made by Manmohan Desai after he started to make movies with Amitabh. He did not like Kishore Kumar was his personal matter which was not supposed to be made public. Salim Javed were the first professional script writers of Bollywood and made some blockbusters. They did lift stories and characters from Hollywood and some Bollywood B&W era. They also would make nasty comments on many stalwarts of Hindi cinema. They deserved nasty comments from likes of Manmohan Desai.
Rafi Sahab is God of music.
Ghanta
Manmohan Desai Kishor Kumar ko pasand nahin karte the vah to itne mahan gayak the Manmohan Desai itne acche director production hi the
Manmohan Desai is a legend
Good facts story true 💯💯👍🏻👍🏻🔥🔥🙏🙏🙏
@@FilmyFlashback pls u sound horrible
Aisa nhi hai Manmohan Desai ji ne Rampur ka Lakshman.
Aa gle lgh ja.
Roti.
Dharamveer.
Bhai ho to aisa mein Kishore Kumar ji k gaane record karwaye thhe.
Amar Akbar Anthony. Aur Naseeb mein b Kishore Kumar ji k geet thhe.
Thanks bai sahab aapne bahut acchi batein batai jo koi aam admi nahi janta kaafi jankari wali aapki batrn thee thanks bai ji sat shree akaal
Salim javed ki jodi me yeh jo salim naam ka banda hai yeh aisa banda hai jisne bollywood ke first super star Rajesh khanna ji ka carier barbaad karne me poora jor lagaya
Lol kuch bhi Bakwaas...
I think this is fake news that man did not like Kishore kumar
मनमोहन देसाई सबसे महान निर्देशक।
Please tell us disco dancer 1982 movie unknown facts please please please please
Yeh ek bakwas baat hai, Sachcha jhutha ,Roti,Bhai ho to aisa,Aa gale lag ja, parwarish, Dharm veer,Naseeb, Toofan etc filmo me kishore da ne gaya hain.
Rafi really great singer
Rafi saab all time best isme koi shaq nahi lekin kishor kumar achhe nahi the iska ye matlab nahi. Har ek fankar ka alag andaz hota hai. Kishor kumar ka bhi Behatrin andaz tha. Manmohan desai unko pasand nahi karte the ye. Unki psychology hogi waise ye kisi ke bhi samaz ke bahar hai ki kishor da pasand manmohan ko kyun nahi. Sab kuchh to hai kishor da me fir isme napasandwali kya baat hai ?ye manmohan desai ka igo ho sakta hain. Ye usase achha ,main tumse achha, yahatak thik lekin jab sirf main hi achha to waha igo ka role shuru ho jata hai. Salim javed ko na pasand karne wali kya baat hai? Andaz,hathi mete sathi, zanjeer, yadon ki barat ,andaz,seeta aur geeta, mazboor ,sholay, chacha bhatija sabhi to hit block buster filme hain . aapki filme konsi achhi story ki bani thi. Wahi ghisa pita loss and found formula na usne jara bhi logic. Shukr mano laxmi pyare aur kalyanji anandji ka . nahi to aapke film ko rone ko bhi koi nahi hota. Us time ki public itni samazdar nahi thi isliye chala liya aapko hit gani ki ekmatr vajah se .nahi to aapke film ko koi nahi puchta. Bad me public bhi sayani ho gayi isliye aapke bad me ki filme pahale jaise hit na ho pati sirf coolie ko chhod kar coolie chali lekin wo bachchan saab ki accident ki vajah se. Mard, toofan ganga zamana hit nahi ho sake. Mera yah vishleshan kaisa raha.
Rafi is the wonder boy. Complete singer.
Kyonki vo muslum tha
Yes very true. Rafi Sahab is the singer of the millannium and best male voice of India.
@@vibhasingh9815 true sir
Sab singers ka BAAP Kishore Da hi hai.
@@Kishore_108 rafi sahab ek institute hai kk ek. Student
Man mohen g ki mawet pr kuch roshni dale thanks
Kishore Kumar ki awaaz ko jahan 1970 ke baad popularity mili...waheen kuch log unki awaaz ko besura aur phati awaaz kehte theh...ye wo log theh aur hain...jo sur aur saaz ki baarikiyon ko jaante hain...jo music ke ustaad hain...jo classical music ko pasand karte hain...aur pop music...yodeling pasand nahi karte. Kishore Kumar jab low pitch mein gaate hain to unki awaaz sambhli hui hoti hai...unka aik range thah jismay unhone bahot shaandaar gaane gaaye...lekin all round singer kabhi nahi rahe. Kaka ki Super Stardom ne bhi Kishoreda ki bahoth madad ki.
I think kishore da is best kyu ki un jasha gayaki nahi paiye aaj tak maine yes jab unhone gayaki suruwat ki wo classical song nahi gaate thy but jab unhone popularity hashil kiya tab se unoho ne play back ko serious lena suru kardiya wo sab shik ne lag gage wo sami classical song vhi aashaine gaate tey but jab jo logo kishore ko bura kaha tha wohi log un k sath kam karne k lia aate tay but kishore da un k talent ko respect karte tay but uss inshan ko nahi wo kuch na kuch bol kar bahana bana deete tey😊😊
I think wo all round singer hi tey wo har types k song gaaya hai wo chahai wo romatic ho ya comedy ya sami classical song vhi aashani jaata hai and supar star rajash khana ki wajha se un ko madhad nahi unta rajeshkhan kishore da ki wajhe se supar star bane
Bhai. Aj tak voice mudulation kisi aur singer ka itna behtar nahi raha jo kishor da karte the. Apne toh badi bekar si bat ki yaaar
@@RajatKumar-me1gj Maine ye nahi kha ke Kishoreda voice modulation nahi karte theh, Kishore da bahoth achcheh singer theh but with limitations.
@@ateeqrahman2792 limitation ki bat hi nahi hai bro. Bat tab hoti hai jab ek hi jaise geet gaye jaye but dada ne har tarah ka geet alag andaz se gaya hai. Agar apne dada ke comedy song sune hai toh sad sunke dekho motivation song sunke dekho. Ruk jana nahi . jo rah chuni tune . gaadi bula rahi hai . aree ohh re . ye suno zara. Soft voice geet suno high pich geet suno low base geet suno pata lag jayega kya range kishor da ki. Aur vaise bhi dada ko samkhna itna asaan nahi hai bhia god gifted aise hi hote hai. Yaha log ajkal bjagwaan ko nahi mante dada toh phir ek legend singer hai
He was the weekest person who could not fight and ended his life. Pl don't show any thing about this person who could not fight with problems.
Sholay script was approved by GP Sippy and not Ramesh Sippy !! And when GP Sippy approved it ..it was still an idea and not a script !
स्टोरी सुना रहे हो या कोई कविता सुना रहे हो
MANDOHAN MESAI KOI ACHCHA DIRECTOR NAHI THA. VO COMEDY SCENE KO SERIOUS SCENE DIKHANE ME HOSHIYAR THEI
किशोर कुमार के सामने कोई नही है
Manmohan ki aukat ni...thi ki KISHORE kumar bina vo hit ho sakey...agar KISHORE da ni gayey...to manhon ki ghatiya film kp koun dekhta..haaa..
Kishor Kumar ne to coolie aur mard film ke ek bhi gane nahi gaye the magar dono hi filme blockbuster thi aur gane bhi hit the.
@@UmeshUKRShonaa to fir zanab kishoreda ne sharbi ki ganey ho ya namak halal ke ganey..gakar kisey supwrhit kiya..zabki coolie or mard ke ganey hit hue...coolie or mard ke ganey ki koi aukat hi kaya..sharabi or namakhalal ke samney..or coolie to amitabh ke injury se zayda hit thi..or fir ANUMALIK ne sahensha ka ek gana ANDHERI RATO me KISHORE da se gavaya zab ki KISHORE da se amitabh ne compromise kiya...puri baat zaan lizie
@@subratbhowmick8301 zanab sharabi aur namakhalal prakash Mehra ki Film hai manmohan Desai ki nahi hai aur mai khud kishore da bahut bada fan hu magar aapne jo kaha manmohan ki kya aukat us bat per maine pratikriya di apni. Aur Shahenshah film ke music director Amar Utpal hai Anu Malik nahi hai aur director Tinu Anand hai na ki manmohan Desai.
@@UmeshUKRShonaa bhi yeha..manmohansingh ki bahut gappu film ki baat hui..tumney coolie or mard ki baad kahi..to NASTIKbhi super hit thi..vaha shabbir ne ni KISHORE ne gaya tha..asal me..dusrey log manmohan ko KISHORE da safalta ki guarentee hi bolkar ..manmohan hamesha kam paisa wala gayak khoztey they...ek gana ...jai jai shiv shankar ..usmey kishoreda ne bech me gaya tha..bazao..zamke bazao...paisa pura diya hi..ye asal me manmohan ke liye hi gaya they KISHORE da..or zanab AAP KISHORE fan ni hi..ye mai zaan gaya hu....bhi ...duaro ko gadha mat samjho...
@@subratbhowmick8301 har director aur producers ki apni pasand hoti hai fir chahe vo manmohan Desai ho ya Raj Kapoor ho ya b r chopra. Ab raj Kapoor ki khud ki pasand Mukesh ji the aur B R chopra ki pehli pasand mahendra kapoor ji the to kya ye dono kishore kumar se bura gate the ya inke koi gane hit hi nahi hue. B R chopra ki to lagbhag sabhi filmo ke gane mahendra kapoor ne hi gaye hai aur vo filme bhi hit hui hai aur gane bhi.
In dono Charlie ke sath koi aatmsaman wala.....
Very good decision
Love you man aapne bilkul sahi kaha
I like the name Charlie,
They came to film industry to destroy others career
They tried to destroy Rajesh Khanna fully though he is a thorough natural actor ...duck to water unlike those who work hard for one scene...like amir khan
If you are right, then is there any alternate of Sholay / Don / Trishul / Zanjeer / Naam / Arjun /Betaab.These movies are still hits on any platforms. Even Late Mr. Desai was a proven Charlie with Toofan / Ganga Jamuna Saraswati.
Amjad Khan ke pichhe pd gye the dono
Aur rahi baat jin filmo ka naam aap Gina rahe ho to dhyan se history check kijye hr director ne inke mutabik samjhota kiya hai aur latest example hai dabang jisme inke sahabjade they jo Abhinav ne direct ki thi fir inhe lga ki are hm hi direct kr lenge to sab ki sab pit gyi aur Sholay ko chod aur dusri filmo ne cult history nhi rachi aur ek baat hathi mere sathi film ke dauran Rajesh kh anna ne inhe intjar krawaunga aur nakhre dikhyae fir ye unhe down market ke liye amtibh ko le aaye actually baat ye hai silver screen pr hr koi chmkana aur raja ki kursi chata hai to ye ldai chlati rahegi aur rahisahi kasar wahan pr dusre kaam krne wale puri kr dete hai isliye kon sahi kon glat I know bt I don't know.
Toofan ek badi flop thi
Vinod ji, why we should use our brain to prove who is right and wrong. This is film industry or any corporate office, everywhere people are pulling each other. This is common practice. Now , we will close this matter and respect each other openion as I don't know who is Salim Javed and who was Late Manmohan Desai. So good to hear you and God bless you 👍👍🙏
Sir ji I am so sorry if I hurt you and with warm regards avoid all matters good night .
Manmohan Desai ne kabhi bhi Kishoreda ki aawaaz ke baare mein koi galat baat nahin ki...
Jo zinda nahin hain unke baare mein kuchh bhi chhaap dete ho
Tumhen kuchh nahin maloom hai chacha bhatija se pahle dharmveer film banaa chuke hain Salim Javed
Kishore dada
मनमोहन देसाई के फिल्म में स्टोरी वगैरे नहीं होती थी बस एक formula रहता था, एक मां के बच्चे बिछड जाते थे, बिच में मसाला भरा जाता था और बाद में बिछडे हुए बच्चे मिल जाते थे, बकवास स्टोरी, सिर्फ गाणे अच्छे रहते थे
Kishor da was great singer no doubt
But
Bahot se logon ne kishor da ko besura bhi kaha hai,,,,,
Shankar jaikishan
Op nayyar
Madan mohan
Naushad
Ne ekka dukka gaane hi gawaye hain,,,
Do your research Mr, Kishore sang more than 100 songs for SJ and around 45 songs for OP Nayyar
@@sidharthrathee2003 please tell me sj 100 song of kishor da
manmohan desai rafi sahab ko bhagwan mante the
Bachchan.ek.khudgarz.insane.hai
kk was greatest singer.
Monmhoan desai ek chutia admi thaa
Rafi sab no 1
موسیقی کو سمجنے والے صرف رفیع صاحب کو ہی ٹاپ پر سمجتے ہین
Army officer nhi oye police officer bol juth mat bol
@@FilmyFlashback is par koi video ya saboot?? Writer ki kalam se??
@@FilmyFlashback aap ne menson kyun nhi kiya yeh ki pehle army officer ki story thi baad me kisi karn badlna pda?? Btao pls
@@FilmyFlashback any way failate rho juth 😀😀
@@FilmyFlashback video aap ne bnaya ha mere paas saboot kyun gunge bhai ji aap pesh karo na
This man sounds like GAY n only gays will like his voice
Tumhare baap gay the? O my God! To phir kiski aulaad hai tu? 🤣🤣🤣
No 1 singer
?
Rafi sahab is the no 1 singer
No one take his place
मनमोहन देसाई एक नंबर का झंड इंसान था.भले ही उसने अच्छी फिल्में बनाई हो लेकिन इंसान अच्छा नहीं था. किशोर कुमार को कितनों ने दबाने की कोशिश किया लेकिन दबा नहीं सके किशोर कुमार जैसा कोई नहीं है वह बॉलीवुड के सर्वश्रेष्ठ गायक हैं। हालांकि सभी बातें सही नहीं है कुछ तो मनगढ़ंत कहानियां है बस के मनमोहन देसाई किशोर कुमार को पसंद नहीं करते थे.
Right kangeresi Sanjay hath dho ke kishor da ke pichhe pad gaye they 1975me fir bhi kishor da (abhash Kumar ganguli) ji nahi jhhuke
Manmohan desai ek c grade film maker the.Sob chori Kiya hua bandel film tha uska. Woh keya Kishore Kumar ke awaz ko pasand nehi karega...woh toh Kishore Kumar ke gaana sunne tak ke liye bhi layak nehi tha.Woh film maker ke naam pe kalank tha.khali raddi, bandel or ek stereotype film aapna pura jindegi banate raha.Aur tum log bhi yaar Kishore Kumar ji ke saath kis kiska naam le late ho.Shame on you.
एहसान फरामोशो की कोई कमी नहीं फिल्म इंडस्ट्री में भी।फिल्म रोटी,सच्चा झूठा,रामपुर का लक्ष्मण, आगले लग जा, परवरिश,अमर अकबर एंथनी जैसी कितनी ही फिल्मों में किशोर दा की आवाज का जी भर कर इस्तेमाल करने के बाद खाई थाली में छेद कर ही दिया मन्नु ने।
Manmohan desai ki Sacha jutha aa gale lag jaa roti sare gaane jo kishoreda ne gaaye the woh hit hue jab ke unhi ki film mard coolie ganga jamuna sarswati ke gaane utne hit nahi hue manji was proudi director the
Bilkul sahi theh Manmohan D....Rafi Sahab jaise awaaz aaj tak aayi hee nahi is dharti pe.....Naushad bhi nahi gavate theh Kishore Da se.....Op Nayyar Lata G se nahi gavate theh.....Actually, ek lobby uthi thee Rafi Sahab ke against.....jisme Chopra, Asha, RD, Rajesh Khanna, Bappi, Salil Chowdhury, Anil Biswas, Kalyan G Anand G ye sab theh, but acha hua Manmohan D khade rahe Rafi Sahab ke saath
Bhai sahib man desai ko pahali kaamyabi Sacha jhootha film se mili aur usme kishoreda ke sare gaane superhit hue the uske baad unki aa gale lag jaa movie bahut hi dil ke karib thi is film ke bhi saare gaane kishoreda ne gaaye the jo super hit hue par manji ahsaan faramosh insaan the barhaal kishoreda ka coolie mard me kishoreda ko naa leke unko.hi loss tha rahi baat music director naushad aur o p nayyar ki to Yeh baat sab ko pata hai ke na naushad aur na hi o p nayyar ko 70 ke baad film mili kishoreda is supreme forever.
@@nitindhruva Kishore Da great theh no doubt but btaye aap kitne Music directors ke liye kaam kiya jisme major RD, bappi aur Kalyan Anand theh....but Rafi Sahab ke saath aisa kuch nahi thaa unhone har ek music director ke saath kaam kiya...Aur Jaise kKishore Da shuru mei koi gaane nahi deta thaa waise he Naushad aur OP Nayyar ko kaam.nahi mila...Chain se humko kabhi aap ne jine na dia Asha Got best playback...Asha fooled Nayyar, jab RD aaya to Nayyar ko kinare laga dia...baat kadwi hai but sachi hain...Aur Naushad jaisa director nahi aaya aur Rafi Sahab jaisa gayak.nahi aaya aur na aayega
Manmohan Desai was not a bad director he was a entertainer he had given so many super hit films script wise Chacha bhatija has a better story then Amar Akbar Anthony , parwarish and dharam veer and Salim JAVID was at their peak at that time may be their must be some creative differences between Manmohan and Salim JAVID but I don’t believe that Desai didn’t like Kishore kumar although Desai was hardcore Rafi fan .
Bandar Kya Jane Adarak Ka Swad...!!
Manmohan Desai was a great Rafi Fan and favoured him!
सचमे किशोर इरिटेटिंग था.
MD is a clown for kishore
Loss was Manmohan Desai 's not kishore kumar
मनमोहन देसाई को भले किशोर कुमार पसंद हो या न हो लेकिन उन्हें अपनी फिल्में हिट कराने के लिए किशोर कुमार का सहारा लेना ही पड़ा जो उनकी मजबूरी और समझदारी दोनों को दर्शाता है, हां किशोर कुमार की महानता थी कि उन्होंने मनमोहन देसाई को मना नहीं किया नहीं तो किशोर दा कैसे मूडी थे हम सब जानते हैं
हा पूरा पगलेट था 😂😂
@@asifaghadi2282
जो अपनें काम के लिये पागल था
इसलिये वो नं वन गायक थे इसलिये किशोर दा जैसा गायक न कोई हुआ था न होगा
😀
वो पगलेट (महान)था लेकिन मोहम्मद रफी ज्यादा पगलेट(महान) था,पगले🥳🥳
बहुत आत्मसम्मानी थे देसाईजी। अमिताभ के संघर्ष के दिनों में उन्हें कहा था कि अपनी लम्बी टांगें कटवाकर आना तब अपनी फिल्म में लूंगा, अमिताभ के सुपर स्टार बन जाने के बाद उन्हीं लम्बी टांगों वाले को उन्हीं की शर्तों पर अमर अकबर अन्थोनी के लिए साइन किया और ज़िंदगी भर अपनी फिल्मों में हीरो का रोल देते रहे।
Kishore Kumar was great singer
No compare between Kishore Kumar and their opponents.
Bharat Ratna kishor kumar ke samne manmohan Desai jatu bhi nahi hai
Agar Desai ko kishor kumar itne napasand the to apni filmo ki commercial value badane ke liye kyu kishor kumar se gavate the.
may be this one fake news,KK sung more numbers than Md Rafi fr Manmohan Desai
Pehle to tum apne voice theek karo
@@FilmyFlashback Spelling galat likha matlab yeh nahi aap apni awaaz aur bolne kaa dosh naa sweekaro. Jo videos dekhne aate unka hak hai ki information ke alawa bolne ka tarika bhi dhang ka hona chahiye. Views aur likes to chahiye naa?
Man mohan desai murkh tha isliye kishore daa ko irritating kaha
Kishore da se jalte the ye log bhai wo sbse bade supar star the ek singer ho kr bhi log apni puri puri film rok dete the unka tym ni milta tha to song recording ke liye
Kishorda no doubt great singer the unhone bade acche gane gaye he ab manmohan desai ko uski voice kyu irritating lagi ye unki choice thi public ki nahi
Sir man mohan desai great director and Rafi Sahab great singer
Hum bhi manmohan desai jaise ghise pite type ke director ko pasand nahi karte
तुम्हारी पसंद या ना पसंद कोई मायने नहीं रखता। एक गुमनाम मनुष्य किया कर सकता है।
@@ghulamhassan6914 ek gumnam aadmi bahut kuch kar sakta hai jo abhi dikh raha hai drugiwood ka bahiskar ho raha hai
Muhammad rafi saheb & Manmohan desai great legend excellent combination 😍😍😍
Obviously RAFI sahab was better singer
Rafi Sahab Vishwa Ratan hain industry ne aaj tak aisa insaan nahi dekha nahi paya aur na aise hone wala hai
Mohammad Rafi sahab King of singing and manmohan Desai experimental director
Md Rafi was ordinary singer hving faminine voice and mnmohan desai was a 3rd grade director .
Film 🎥 SACHCHA JHUTHA....& ROTI....written by SALIM - JAWED
Some people like to give credit to salim javed without checking facts.
Kishore Da without any doubt is greatest singer and Manmohan Desai must have his own personal reasons for disliking him. It does not make any sense though. No Doubt Mohd Rafi Sahb was great but Kishore Da is no less.
Manmohan Desai dil ka raja aadmi tha.....very few people achieve the success he got yet he remained down to earth.
Salim-Javed n Kishoreda are legends too.....this looks like a fake story.
It's too much to believe. Everyone mentioned in this video is great in his own right. It's unfair differentiate between singers as they have their own and unique style.
Looks fake 🤣
Manmohan Desai ek average director the unhone kuchh bhi alag nahi kiya apne carrier mein. Ek hi ghise pite fomule pe (lost n found) filmein banayi . Unse behtar uss daur mein Raj Kapoor, Vijay Anand, Yash Chopra, Prakash Mehra, Hrishikesh Mukherjee, Gulzar aur Basu Chatterjee in directors ne acchi aur yaadgar filmein banayi aur yeh safal bhi thi. Aur Kishore aur kisise bhi inn directors ko koi bhi parhej nahi tha. Yeh sabhi Manmohan Desai se behtareen directors the.
Ekdam sahi baat
Manoj kumar ji ka naam kyu bhul.gaye unse behtar to koi bhi director kar nahi paaya 👍
Manmohan desai ki filme jyadar ek hi theme lost n found per chali thi…us daur me actually hero ka daur tha So pehle rajeshkhanna chalte the fir Amitabh chale..meinRamesh sippy ko unse jyada accha director manta hun
Nice
Ramesh shippy ki kayde se do hi badi super hit film hain, seeta aur geeta aur shole baki flop ya average filmen hain, manmohan desai ke paas to hit super hit filmon ki lambi line hai kam se kam 15 ya usse bhi jyada filmen unki hit super hit hain
Bahut pasand aaye aapne sab sach bola
प्रकाश मेहरा और मन जी फिल्मों के गानों में जमीन आसमान का अंतर था
मुकद्दर का सिकंदर लावारिश शराबी नमक हराम की म्यूजिक ऑल टाइम हिट सॉन्ग था
मन जी की अमर एंथोनी के अलावा किसी भी film का म्यूजिक मुझे खास नही लगा
With respect to all. Manmohan Desai was such a director, jisne Anhoni ko Honi bana ke dikhaya aur hum dekhte reh gaye.
Manmohan Desai utni bade director nehi tha jitni bade kalakar Kishore Kumar hua karta tha. Aaj bhi agar dus aadmi se un donoki baare mein puchha jaye, dus mein se saat Manmohan Ji ko pehchan hi nehi kar payenge, aur dusri tadap Kishore Kumar aaj ka generation ki insaan ka dil mein chhayen hue hai.
Bhai aap glat comparison kar rhe hain, kisi Singer ya kisi Actor ki popularity ka muqabala kisi director se nhi ho skta kyunki director ko film me na koi dekhta hai na sunta hai, aur jise dekha suna jata hai log use hi jyada pahchanenge
director ek penting bnane wale artist ki trah hai, log khubsurat penting ko dekh kar penting ki hi sabse pahle tareef karenge use kisne bnaya hai uspar baad me dhyan jayega uska naam pta ho bhi jaye to bhi wo naam wo bhul jayega lekin penting ki khubsurati nahi bhulega, usi trah logon ko achhi film gaane actor singer yaad rahte hain lekin inhe bnane wale film director music director ye kam hi logon ko yaad rahte hain, kam se kam aam sunne dekhne wale to bilkul bhi nhi jante honge inhe
Kishore Da playback singing ke paise Jyada lete The Isliye
@@prakashkandwal8824 ghalat hai aapki soochana
Bengalis generally supposed to be intelligent and baised to Bengalis . You are one of the rest Bangali Babu ...
sub kum budhhi ke log
Good video
Manmohan Desai ki galti thi k woh kishor da ki aawaaz ko pahechan na sake
Aapko nahi lagtaa aap kuchh jyaadaa hi naatkiy tariqe se bol rahe hai.
Who is Manmohan desai?
Reality is he liked or not he had to use Kishorda and his song became so popular - his liking for rafisaab didn’t made dent to kishorda’s popularity also Kishorda doesn’t wanted to sing for Manmohan n for Amitabh and he got away with it as he was legend and even today Amar akbar anthoney songs are immortal
Dhanyavaad jankari k liye achha hai
Ye.to.sach.he.mo.rafi.ji.ne.ziyada.gaane.man.kifilmo.gaae.ek.vajah.laxmi.pyare.bhi.hain
Good anylisis done, ऐक बात हैं, के फिल्म बनाना कोई asan काम नही हैं, उसमे लाखो /करोडो रुपये lag जाते हैं, पैसा तो Producer/director का lagtay उसमे MMD जैसे आदमी को हर किसी कि बात हजम नही होती थी
Manmohan desai ko aj koi kutta bhi nhi puchta aur kishore daa aane wale 1000 saal tk no 1 rehenge .
Monmohon Desai is genius and Kishore Kumar is Gem if we look statistics then Kishore Kumar is ahead from Mr Desai because Kishore Da is Producer, Director, Singer, Composer, Actor.
Apke Hissab se Md. Rafi sahab se koi bhi gaana nahi gawana chahiye tha??
Monmohan Desai may not like the all time great singer Kishore da, the general public of India very much like to listen to Kishore da's voice and even after 34 years of his death Kishore da is still immortal through his god gifted golden voice and mesmerizing as well as heart touching songs. History has proved many times that Kishore da has been the most popular and the greatest singer and there is no doubt about it. Also, inspite of being an untrained singer Kishore da became the most acceptable voice from the 70's till his death in 1987 and for his long term success as a play back singer he commercially defeated all the then trained singers. So it is meaning less to try to thwart his glory and greatness which is still dazzling in the hearts and minds of crores of Indians. Thank you.
मेरे प्रिय गायक और अभिनेता किशोर कुमार हैं और मैं रफी के केवल भजन पसंद करता हूं एक दो फिल्मी गीत बस।
Kishore kumar was a moody singer with tantrums.. desai had a huge ego with the success he had. He refused to cast dhrmendra after chacha bhatija as he couldn’t do amar akbar anthony vk s role. Just to irritate kishoe kumar in a fit of anger he told kk that he only had him sing as he was a star singer but otherwise his voice was irritating. He hated his biggest hit aaa termed it a trash that was a box office blockbuster… but his all time fav was aa gale lag jaa which wasnt a big big hit .He was so proud of it…. It had kishore all the way … best music of all the desai films…and i am a rafi fan like desai.