Nalini Singh moderates a discussion on Doordarshan with leaders from all political parties ahead of upcoming Assembly elections in 1995. ARDG/DVC-60/12673
@@Avinashyadav-l1h still our democracy is better than USA.. In USA only two party can participate in election.. We have open minded towards parties .. A new party can replace an old senior party too ..if public decides .. Yes we have problem with our media .. they support whoever sit on power .. so that they can get more and more funding..
@Delphic Tableau Abe tu idhar bhi Gandhi Vadra krra hai. Merk oye smjh ni aata Vadra krte krte 10 saal ho gye hain abhi tak bnda bahar ghumra hai. Zara question ye bhi kr ki Rallies aur promotion ka kharcha jo arabo rupyo me hai wo bjp kidhar se laati hai. kinko faida pahunchati hai jo use arabo k electoral bond kharid kr usko chanda pakda dete hain. Sirf Vadra Gandi nhi, chori bahut door tak fail chuki hai. Aur jahan tak Gandhi ki baat hai, pretty sure this debate is in aftertimes of Bofors Scam. So no, Gandhi family was not so much untouchable still .
You don't need to read a constitution book to understand the correct meanings of parties, opposition & democracy. This video is enough. Today's political scenario has no link with the then founded constitution. Thanks to Prasar Bharati for bringing out this gem & Nalini Singh what a presenter. Respect !!
हरिकिशन सिंह सुरजीत ने कांग्रेस की इतनी खिंचाई की, परन्तु राजेश पायलट ने बहुत ही शालीनता से उनकी आलोचना को सुना और पुरे आदर के साथ उनको जवाब दिया! अति उत्तम!
@@mdakhlakusmani1603 but randi sonia gandhi ne use marva dia kyuki unka congress mein kad bada ho rah tha but wo randi unhe hi cahhti thi jo uske neche reh aur uski sune
Look at 32:54 when that women started speaking, openly criticising Rajesh Pilot in front of the entire audience and other party leaders and look at Mr Pilot’s calm epic reply. These days we cannot imagine such patience from our leaders specially ruling party members
ऐसे debates अभी भी hote h, बस yahi h ki लोग उनको dekhna नहीं चाहते,, वो तो अभी logo ka controversy hua h तो, Doordarshan k purane videos recommendation me aa rhe h
This is the first time that i have seen such type of debate and feel very fortunate as an indian.atal ji pailt ji harkisan ji were the great leaders and also great human beings. Specially Rajesh pailt jis accept their defit in elections in a very calm way is great.
Polite she is NDTV pranoy roy wife complete communist .They where happy until Vajpayee ji because he was soft .They expected same calm in modiji but result was different.
When Atalji said that *Media is fourth pillar of democracy* he meant this type of media *not the current media* houses who runs agenda at prime time for both sides.
@@NoName-ss8pm sale andhanamazi rabish kumar madarchod hai jo sirf anti-hindu and anti-India propaganda karta hai har debate uski hindus and India ke against hoti ahi
What an excellent debate! This is how debates should be conducted. This debate mush have happened in the 1st week of Dec 1994, as Shri N T Rama Rao became AP CM on 12 Dec 1994. Pity to see that many participants on the dais (except Shri Gegong Apang, Mrs Nalini Singh, and Shri Shekhar Gupta) are no more. May their Souls rest in peace.
@@jyotirmayanag9831 exactly but no that won't happen these people are fed propaganda day and night where in rubbishuddin type presstitutes are glorified and the nationalist journalists are ignored
@@tigerpandey7636Bihar.....Mujhe 1995 ka to yaad nhi... Mera janm hi 1991 me hua tha.....But 2004 ya 2005 tak mere shahar Siwan me bmushkil 6 ghante bijli aati thi....
Such sober and nice presentation. DD was pioneer in this. Its a lesson to new generation journalists that shows can be conducted in a most civilized manner and sober way. Thank you DD Archives
Modern day panelists and anchors should be made to see this video. Look at the calmness, composure and grace in the debate. No high decibel shouting yet everyone makes their view point
Wow what a pleasant interview. Humble leaders of the time and No personal accusation . And now level of degradation of tv anchors and politicians. Young generation should certainly admit and admire such sporting interviews and condemn and boycott present style debates and anchors
I am overwhelmed by seeing the gentle nature of the participants. Expecting a debate as peaceful as this from the news channels of current time is beyond expectation.
Unbelievable this was the Level of Grace & Maturity of All Including Audience.. Civilised Way of Anchoring Q&A and Mutual Respect for each other and the show .. And Now what a Downfall in All Aspects . 😢😢
The most amazing thing to witness here is the fact that the host had the free will to tighten the screws of the panelists without any fear. Try that today and you will be out of a job!
इसे कहते हैं चर्चा शांत वातावरण में ही प्रगतिशील चर्चा संभव है आज के कई न्यूज चैनल तो कुश्ती के अखाड़े जैसे लगते है सच बोल रहे हो तो चिल्लाने की क्या जरूरत है
@@nash6414corrupted nhi hain abhi bhi, iss liye washing machine mein dhulke party badal nehi sakta. Ruko, pehle usko corruption karne do, ohir bhajpa join kar lega
So pleased to watch the debate in such a polite manner. Importantly all the great leaders of an era are the participants and look the way they speak. Present day's mere spokesperson & news anchors should watch it every morning they wake up.
this is a discussion after the Dec 1994 results of Andhra P, Karnataka assembly elections & not February 1995 elections in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Odisha.. this video truly captures the civility wth which serious political issues of the citizens were discussed in a healthy, democratic manner..
Cant believe what I am seeing here. All the participants are so calm and very respectful of each other and mindful of the language. Even though the participants had differences of opinion, they never traded insults throughout. Its very surprising to see Political debates back then were so quiet. Nalini Singh at her best. With lots of respect.
Today's public can't imagine such a healthy and respectful debate.
Bilkul sahi kaha apne sir
Watch DD news
lol!!
jn those leaders era only ----- kashmiri pandits exodus happend !!
Gathbandhan era 😂😂. Na Teri na meri mili bhagat ki saarkar 😂😂
@@venugopala4865i dont think godiji has done anything for Kashmiri pandits in 10 yrs except for asling votes in their name
This is what democracy should look like. Perfect statesman
Is time democracy me bharat ki 10-15% janta shamil thi
Hindu hijda spotted Indra Gandhi ka samay bhool gya tab democracy tere pichhwade mein ghus gayi thi kya
Booth capturing wala time vo tha..
Aur tum democracy ki baat kar rhe ho..bihar UP me jungle raaj tha
LoL
Bengali ka dimag ghutne me kahe hota hai?
One of the reasons why I loved being a 90's kid.
Yes आँखों देखीं
Godi media ko dikhao
Aankhon Dekhi
@@Avinashyadav-l1h still our democracy is better than USA..
In USA only two party can participate in election..
We have open minded towards parties ..
A new party can replace an old senior party too ..if public decides ..
Yes we have problem with our media .. they support whoever sit on power .. so that they can get more and more funding..
80s kids were way better
After listening to the heated, loud debates these days, this video sounds like a calm music.
WhatsApp University ne logo ke dimag mai bhusa bhar Diya hai. Pahle k leader kitne humble or mature the. I really admire Atal ji.
Ha bilkul nhi toh piche se congress wale aaj kal bhokte hai
I am stunned to see generosity of politicians.
Cannot believe debates can be conducted like this
We can watch type debate in news X TV
@Delphic Tableau Abe tu idhar bhi Gandhi Vadra krra hai. Merk oye smjh ni aata Vadra krte krte 10 saal ho gye hain abhi tak bnda bahar ghumra hai. Zara question ye bhi kr ki Rallies aur promotion ka kharcha jo arabo rupyo me hai wo bjp kidhar se laati hai. kinko faida pahunchati hai jo use arabo k electoral bond kharid kr usko chanda pakda dete hain. Sirf Vadra Gandi nhi, chori bahut door tak fail chuki hai. Aur jahan tak Gandhi ki baat hai, pretty sure this debate is in aftertimes of Bofors Scam. So no, Gandhi family was not so much untouchable still .
*Watch NDTV.* *Only channel now that conducts civilized debate!*
This type debate you can see with ,arnab goswami,sudhir chowdhri,anjana on modi,deepak charities etc
Media in old days was for the elite by the elite.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee...ji ko शत शत प्रणाम.... एक सच्चा नेता....Miss You....sir....
No screaming, no abusing, no flashing of mobiles. This is called sticking to facts and topic at hand. Very fortunate to have grown up in this era !
You don't need to read a constitution book to understand the correct meanings of parties, opposition & democracy. This video is enough. Today's political scenario has no link with the then founded constitution. Thanks to Prasar Bharati for bringing out this gem & Nalini Singh what a presenter. Respect !!
Missing this quality in debates. Just amazed with maturity and sensible conversation by senior leaders.
सैल्यूट...ये परंपरा जारी रहना चाहिए!!!
भाई मेरे, ये परंपरा कब की खतम हो गयी है
Sambit patra
वश क्या बात है इतने बड़े नेता अटल जी राजेश जी एक शाथ ।
आजकल तो 2 टके के नेता tv पर बकचोदी करते है
sahi baat
How humble and peaceful debates used to be!
Thanks doordarshan for letting us know that debates can be in these form also! Else aajkal k debates toh debates Kam nd WWE jyada h!
Doordashan aaj bhi aisa hi aata hai.
RSTV, lstv me bhi aisa discussion hota hai
@@subhrakdutta8009 par dekhta koi nhi qk log ab debate mostly mje lene k lye dekhte h .
randitv us se bhi ghatai hia bhia
आजतक और रिपब्लिक भारत को देखो आज 😢
With this type of dignity, elegance, sincerity, i cannot hate congress, BJP, CPI or all the political parties of those times.
हरिकिशन सिंह सुरजीत ने कांग्रेस की इतनी खिंचाई की, परन्तु राजेश पायलट ने बहुत ही शालीनता से उनकी आलोचना को सुना और पुरे आदर के साथ उनको जवाब दिया! अति उत्तम!
I love rajes pilot ji
@@mdakhlakusmani1603 but randi sonia gandhi ne use marva dia kyuki unka congress mein kad bada ho rah tha but wo randi unhe hi cahhti thi jo uske neche reh aur uski sune
Dono ek hi thali ke chatte bhatte hain
CPI aur CPIM ka kam hi yahi tha. Khud kuchh nahi karneka aur dusro ko kahete rahena tumne ye galat kiya wo galat kiya
@@hbt253 cpi power me aaya hi kab ki woh kuch karenge
Look at 32:54 when that women started speaking, openly criticising Rajesh Pilot in front of the entire audience and other party leaders and look at Mr Pilot’s calm epic reply. These days we cannot imagine such patience from our leaders specially ruling party members
Rightt
Pls show this to current, media and politicians to learn and for good behavior
Kash aese debate wale din wapas aa jai...🥺 #17/04 #2024
ऐसे debates अभी भी hote h, बस yahi h ki लोग उनको dekhna नहीं चाहते,, वो तो अभी logo ka controversy hua h तो, Doordarshan k purane videos recommendation me aa rhe h
One can't imagine this sort of healthy debate by todays prime time anchors , and these clear and straight questions by any media spokes person
Only 90s children know this lady
The Full Fill or
Remember Aankhon Dekhi?
No she still comes as analyst
तो फिर रहिये न बेखबर देखिये काल फिर खास खबर
आंखों देखी......😊😊
@@Roman19926 on DD Metro
Miss that time of conversation and humbleness
This is the first time that i have seen such type of debate and feel very fortunate as an indian.atal ji pailt ji harkisan ji were the great leaders and also great human beings. Specially Rajesh pailt jis accept their defit in elections in a very calm way is great.
What a host or anchor , she is handling in a very polite manner.
That was a generic culture across anchosts and politicians
Ajkal to anchors pagal Hain
Polite she is NDTV pranoy roy wife complete communist .They where happy until Vajpayee ji because he was soft .They expected same calm in modiji but result was different.
She is Nalini Singh. She was one of the most ferocious and fearless journalist India ever saw.
@@sasikumargopinath2939No she is not Prannoy Roy’s wife. She is Nalini Singh.
I was born in 1998 and back then media was like this❤❤, peaceful and no controversial debates😊.
Golden years of Indian democracy. Such a healthy comrade across political parties. Can we imagine the same today!
Ha golden days the democracy. Ke jab aap kashmir me tiranga lekar nahi ja sakte the
Kayka ka democracy? bihar mei mob collector ki hatya karte; bihar ki halat to aaj ke somalia se batthar thi.
@@gaming_with_rannvijaychup andhbhakt
No.. now they are full of hate and love Dynasty over democracy, only wants Modi to dethrone instead of Development
@@gaming_with_rannvijay awar aaj manipur may nahi lehra saktay
90's kids childhood memories. We missing all it 😢😢.golden era time.
It was always a bliss watching Doordarshan those days
Well mannered speakers and disciplined anchor
When Atalji said that *Media is fourth pillar of democracy* he meant this type of media *not the current media* houses who runs agenda at prime time for both sides.
Not Godhi media
@@NoName-ss8pm PIDDI MEDIA
Did you see the name Shekhar Gupta? Now, to you care to repeat the statement?
@@tootsie40 ab yeh bhi leftist agenda chala raha hai
@@NoName-ss8pm sale andhanamazi rabish kumar madarchod hai jo sirf anti-hindu and anti-India propaganda karta hai har debate uski hindus and India ke against hoti ahi
What an era that was ready to listen to be humble to be polite..
Neelam Singh Aunty ...The best Hindi Anchor & Journalist ....( AAP Beeti DD News golden era ✨️)
The most beautiful woman of the times
Nalini singh
She is not Neelam singh she is nalini mam
Nalini Singh, sister of Arun Shourie
@@amithanamshet8526be tere jese log sabki chhat te ho
Itni Shanti 🤗🤗 itni khushi 😀😀 mujhe aajtak nahi hui 😌😌
that's because of aajtak :)
What an excellent debate! This is how debates should be conducted. This debate mush have happened in the 1st week of Dec 1994, as Shri N T Rama Rao became AP CM on 12 Dec 1994. Pity to see that many participants on the dais (except Shri Gegong Apang, Mrs Nalini Singh, and Shri Shekhar Gupta) are no more. May their Souls rest in peace.
What Arnab Goswami did to news anchoring in India is equivalent of what Ekta Kapoor did to Indian TV.
Bro Arnab Goswami is still better..you should blame people like Ravish Kumar for doing anti national propaganda
@@jyotirmayanag9831 exactly but no that won't happen these people are fed propaganda day and night where in rubbishuddin type presstitutes are glorified and the nationalist journalists are ignored
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Exactly 🤣
beta rabish kumar kute ke bare mein kya khayal hai tera
This discussion is so calm and productive. Nowadays you can see only shouting in channel room including channel anchor.
दुर्भाग्यवश उस समय ४ घंटे बिजली आने की वजह टीवी पर बहुत सी चीजें देखने से हम वंचित रह गए
कहाँ की बात कर रहे हो आप?
@@tigerpandey7636Bihar.....Mujhe 1995 ka to yaad nhi... Mera janm hi 1991 me hua tha.....But 2004 ya 2005 tak mere shahar Siwan me bmushkil 6 ghante bijli aati thi....
Scamgress ke achievements. Azadi ke 50 saal tak bijli pani bhi nahi thi 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 great lootere hai scamgressi.
Which place you lived
Siwan me us samay sahabuddin ka ujala tha tho bijli kaise aati@@piyupiyu91
I was 4 years old that time we used to watch DD on Dish in Karachi Pakistan
have u seen saktimaan>
?
@@akashsahu9118 yes I have watched shaktiman but we used to watch more Ainak Wala Jin on PTV
@@talhabinirfanusmani1087 why Pakistan always made story of jins like jakuta jin
I don't know but that was marvelous series of our childhood
Akash Sahu bhai us Samay India me bhi Alif Laila bhi bahut hit hua tha
बहुत अच्छी डिबेट कम डिस्कसन नेता शालीन, पत्रकार निष्पक्ष और माहौल बहुत अच्छा है दर्शकों का ज्ञान, अवेयरनेस शानदार ए लेवल ही कुछ अलग है।
What A Better Way To Watch Nalini Singh After Long Time It's Really More Than Awesome
32:52 look the, way woman reacted and how rajesh pilot handled it...
WO DIN BHI KYA DIN THE ❤❤
It's unbelievable ....how sophisticated they are conducting debate even after wining & loosing election 😍🥰🤩😘 I m just amazed
Rajesh Pilot was Pure Gold.
Clean, Professional, intelligent & honest man.
If Sachin Pilot was leading Congress, I would have voted for Congress.
Me too
Nalini Singh has been killing it... fearless women and asking straight pointed questions... these men don't even realize they're been ridiculed...
Very true. Nalini Singh had that command
True
🔥
A great quality of anchoring, questions, politeness while talking and such a healthy discussion.
my all time favorite anchor, always proud of you!
So good to see humble and calm people like Rajesh Pilot ji and Jaswant Singh ji Jasol
With how much love, ethics, smoothness and simplicity the conversation is happning.
Such sober and nice presentation. DD was pioneer in this. Its a lesson to new generation journalists that shows can be conducted in a most civilized manner and sober way. Thank you DD Archives
Nalini Singh used to be very beautiful at the time of my childhood.
She still is!
Ankho dekhi, aaj tak ke liye ithna hi intzar kijiye kal thak!
Esi debates avhi ithihas pe reh gayi... Such a beautiful and respectful debates ❤ miss you Sri Santosh mohan ji(mpofsilchar)
Modern day panelists and anchors should be made to see this video. Look at the calmness, composure and grace in the debate. No high decibel shouting yet everyone makes their view point
Agreed😊
Exactly
rabbish kumar ko sheekna chahiye ke unbaised debate hoti kya hia
@@garrykamboj8084 phir chutiyapa likha yahan par.
Wow what a pleasant interview. Humble leaders of the time and No personal accusation . And now level of degradation of tv anchors and politicians.
Young generation should certainly admit and admire such sporting interviews and condemn and boycott present style debates and anchors
What a debate so peace and tranquility
Soothing and disciplined😊
@@luckylian6860
Just because Muslims were never called out for their crimes then ☺️
@@reconquistahinduism346 ye suar sulle gahtia uar neech hai hamesa hatred falate hia ye suar sulle
@@reconquistahinduism346 han han chutiye, padhai kiya kar
@@reconquistahinduism346 yeah crimes are always done by Congress guys or Muslims right ☺️
This is actual press true journalism and the leaders debating with full honour
Kitni tehzeeb sach mai salute karta hun including everyone ruling party or opposition party and the anchor of prasar bharti.
I am overwhelmed by seeing the gentle nature of the participants. Expecting a debate as peaceful as this from the news channels of current time is beyond expectation.
Unbelievable this was the Level of Grace & Maturity of All Including Audience.. Civilised Way of Anchoring Q&A and Mutual Respect for each other and the show .. And Now what a Downfall in All Aspects . 😢😢
Debates can be like this I never thought earlier. Touched
राजेश पायलट एक साफ सुथरा नेता को दुर्भाग्य से गायब कर दिया इस इंटरव्यू में अटल जी सबसे शांत बैठे रहे और इस चुनाव में अच्छा रिजल्ट उनका ही रहा था😂
2 of my fav leaders atalji & rajesh pilot
The most amazing thing to witness here is the fact that the host had the free will to tighten the screws of the panelists without any fear.
Try that today and you will be out of a job!
Debates on DD news is still better than pvt news channels.
No fighting no shouting just a decent discussion, I wish if we could have seen this in today's scenario of news channels
इसे कहते हैं चर्चा
शांत वातावरण में ही प्रगतिशील चर्चा संभव है
आज के कई न्यूज चैनल तो कुश्ती के अखाड़े जैसे लगते है
सच बोल रहे हो तो चिल्लाने की क्या जरूरत है
इतना बड़ा पैनल! वो भी इतने बड़े कदावर नेताओं का! अत्यंत अद्धभुत!
Like Father, like Son - the legacy of clean, clear, and cogent talk #Pilot
Clearly he is in wrong party , Chota Bheem doesn’t value him .
@@nash6414corrupted nhi hain abhi bhi, iss liye washing machine mein dhulke party badal nehi sakta. Ruko, pehle usko corruption karne do, ohir bhajpa join kar lega
My God
Atal ji and Pilot sahab on debate
Wow
Aaj kal toh chillam chilli hoti News debate mein
Very good debate... I think best leader in the debate is Sh. RAJESH PILOT. 👍
I also think that
Swargiya Shri Bajpai ji
This is called a discussion ..where no one is shouting..no screaming...less bias media....something to learn ...from ...hope today's media is watching
Aajkal media wale WHO WHO WHO WHO chilla rahe hai
jakr ye gyan ndtvv ko khao jo sirf anti-India and anti-hindu propaganda karta hia aur kcuh nai
@@garrykamboj8084 tumhare jaise chutiyon ki wajah se hi india ki ye haalat hai aaj
Hello? This is state media. It is supposed to be like this - humble, polite, educated and unbiased.
So pleased to watch the debate in such a polite manner. Importantly all the great leaders of an era are the participants and look the way they speak. Present day's mere spokesperson & news anchors should watch it every morning they wake up.
This is what we call healthy politics.... We need this again to achieve what potential actually our country has...
What an amazing discussion! Proud to see our leader late Santosh Mohan Dev for being straight to the point. Good old days ❤
Rajesh Pilot was such a gentleman 😢
Watching this in 2024, can't believe, like this debate
पासवान तब भी मौसम वैज्ञानिक थे आज भी वही है😂😂
😂
😂😂😂
😁😁
आज तो है ही नही
Ab to cale gye paswan duniya se pass ho gye
What a serene and composure filled discussion! Shelhar is probably the only black sheep!
Man! world was so different back then.
No Breaking News , No BGM & An honest Anchor ❤
I want this kind of debate from all the political parties...I hope it will come back soon.
What a gentlemanly discussion.
This is the media - Doordarshan being the State owned TV, the anchor stands firm on her autonomy.
SUPER EXCELLENT FANTASTIC DISCUSSION DEBATE ON ELECTIONS...AND SEEING THESE POLITICIANS IS LIKE WE WERE BLESSED TO HAVE THEM...
India missing those professionals educated leaders.
Rajesh ji ko dekh ke achha laga. I heard about him in my childhood but he left us soon❤
Sachin Pilot is all class. Humble and down to earth.
this is a discussion after the Dec 1994 results of Andhra P, Karnataka assembly elections & not February 1995 elections in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Odisha..
this video truly captures the civility wth which serious political issues of the citizens were discussed in a healthy, democratic manner..
Watching it in 2024 I find the panel discussion so decent that no speaker is overlapping another speaker!
Debate should be like this 👍 Today when I open tv and any news channels showing debate I changes channels…. It’s toxic
look at the respect towards each other
It makes me sick how far we done fell
- Bunk Moreland
My respect to India's politics of those era.
Isse dekh ke democracy aur discussion pe bharosa badhta hai...
Now CPI is irrelevant. Congress is reduced. And BJP is stronger than ever
mahabharat me 1 voice thi jiska naam SAMAY tha aur SAMAY ka Chakrra jab ghumta hai to Rank RAJA aur RAJA Rank ban jata hai . . . . .
Bilkul sahi kaha@@salvadordali6835
Now AAP has joined the league
Will be reversed this year. “..but you cant fool all the people, all of the time”
My heart melting on her sophisticated voice
Bajapi ji 🙏😍 jese humble leader kabhi nahi ayenge dubara desh me 😢
Cant believe what I am seeing here. All the participants are so calm and very respectful of each other and mindful of the language. Even though the participants had differences of opinion, they never traded insults throughout. Its very surprising to see Political debates back then were so quiet. Nalini Singh at her best. With lots of respect.
what a time it was the golden age of indian economy and polity.
the man with no haters.missed u rajesh pilot ji.u were a ture gem of country
Congress is very unlucky that they lost Rajesh pilot so early
OLD IS GOLD.......💞💞💞