Who is better civil engineer or architect ?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
  • #civilengineerstraininginstitute #CivilGuruji
    Who is better civil engineer or architect ?
    Join our New UA-cam Channel
    Engineering University UA-cam channel Link : / @civilgurujibhilai
    CALL NOW :- 9111001234
    Last Day Limited Seat Available Hurry UP !!.
    Website :- www.civilguruj...
    Download our Latest Version App:- play.google.co....
    Corporate Training Course:- www.civilguruj....
    GURUJI Ka खजाना :- www.civilguruj....
    About This Video
    In This Video Er. Vijish Shinde, Explaining about Who is better civil engineer or architect ?
    Civil engineers work on a variety of different projects that include planning, building, and maintaining roads, buildings, bridges, and water systems, while architects work primarily with houses, factories, and similar structures. Civil engineers and architects do, however, work together on some projects. They both visit construction sites to ensure work is being completed correctly and in the given time frame. Civil engineers and architects both estimate costs and create plans based on the projected budget. While civil engineers decide on the materials used to ensure a safe structure, architects highlight the design aspect of the project.
    Architect
    Architects design various buildings and structures that include office buildings and houses. They can work on projects as small as rooms in a building to designing the entire building. They must have experience with computer software such as CADD to create scaled drawings to provide plans to workers. Architects must have great creativity and vision to ensure the project looks attractive to clients. They are also responsible for taking care of many parts of the project, so they must be very organized to keep track of all aspects of the architectural development. Architects with extensive experience can advance into higher-level supervisory roles as architectural managers
    Job responsibilities of an architect include:
    Organizing structure specifications
    Estimating budget and time
    Creating drawings and plans
    Presenting plans to clients
    Developing contracts
    Civil Engineer
    Civil engineers are responsible for overseeing and designing roads, bridges, water systems, buildings, and dams, among other structures. Civil engineers spend the majority of their time in an office designing and planning projects, though they do visit construction sites to oversee the work being completed. Civil engineers work with complicated designs where a background in math, as well as skills in problem-solving, can aid in finding solutions to issues that may arise with the development of projects.
    Job responsibilities of a civil engineer include:
    Testing building materials
    Following regulations and considering possible project hazards
    Performing surveying operations
    Supervising maintenance of infrastructures
    Using design programs for projects

КОМЕНТАРІ • 148

  • @iffatjerifa5277
    @iffatjerifa5277 3 роки тому +66

    Stop giving wrong information, I know both have their own importance. But civil engineers have nothing to do with design. A building is designed by Architect and the structural details are designed collaboration with structural engineers and once it’s finalised the set of drawings are handed over to civil Engineers who carry forward the work on site. India 🇮🇳 needs to know this. Jai Hind!

    • @praveenchandran4403
      @praveenchandran4403 3 роки тому +2

      These people don't have any idea about how the field works. We have to sit and explain every time we meet a prospective client about what we do. And this misguidance with all these false information adds so much pain and time wastage for us.

    • @aroy914
      @aroy914 2 роки тому +10

      But architects only construct buildings and nothing else. civil engineers construct every constfuctions like buildings, dams, bridges, roads etc ok. Mind it

    • @praveenchandran4403
      @praveenchandran4403 2 роки тому +2

      @@aroy914 no we don't construct anything. We design everything in coordination with all other experts. All structures need architects, Structural and all other specialized engineers for its design.

    • @KabirP-tw7sh
      @KabirP-tw7sh 2 роки тому

      @@praveenchandran4403 At ArchiDAO we are working to disrupt civil engineers and get Architecture to the mainstream. We have got 2 Metaverse projects, 3d printed cafes ,real estate tokenisation and many more innovative projects DAO is a decentralized organisation on blockchain. Its the future of Architecture😊.

    • @akashshirsat4661
      @akashshirsat4661 2 роки тому

      Thanks for u r coment

  • @dinirazin5978
    @dinirazin5978 2 роки тому +9

    You missed a lot of points. Architects deals with design than engineers. Engineers works with architects in structural design for complicated structures, high rises etc. Architects do a lot more things what is said in this video. Some of the things are user analysis - to make buildings more user specific based on experiments and studies, activity-space relation, etc. We design buildings with respect to micro climate for achieving ample lighting and ventilation, by learning the wind direction of each location, sun path study, light and shadow study etc. To make more energy efficient spaces. We learn about design and it's psychological impacts on people, kids, physically/mentally challenged like colours and different shapes. We research on materials, we learn about environmental impacts of buildings. We do market study, feasibility study, economic study, footfall analysis, customer acquisition strategies etc. while designing commercial projects and public infrastructure, We do project management, time management, working drawings, sanction drawings, shop drawings. We do lighting, furniture and landscape design. We do urban/rural design and placemeking to improve wellbeing among communities, to improve tourism, to provide more job opportunities. We do more than just buildings, which this comment section is not sufficient for. We basically do things based on research and logical analysis yet nobody hire us.
    Why do you think architecture is a 5 year course and engineering is 4 years?

  • @dhananjayakkp815
    @dhananjayakkp815 Рік тому +8

    Civil engineer =Bones, muscles, Nerves, veins, eyes, nose, mouth every thing as created life by god.
    Architect =beauty technician

  • @animationking199
    @animationking199 Рік тому +4

    Now a days I think civil engineers are doing both site work as well as design work, and after a period of time they become best in both the work.

    • @Civil_Guruji
      @Civil_Guruji  Рік тому +1

      Thank you very much for your Love and Support . I appreciate your expression of support and goodwill. Let us continue to learn and share knowledge together.

  • @ar.kathousanasingha8900
    @ar.kathousanasingha8900 3 роки тому +9

    Good content, regarding civil topics
    But kindly research more on Architecture!
    Thank you

    • @KabirP-tw7sh
      @KabirP-tw7sh 2 роки тому

      At ArchiDAO we are working to disrupt civil engineers and get Architecture to the mainstream. We have got 2 Metaverse projects, 3d printed cafes ,real estate tokenisation and many more innovative projects DAO is a decentralized organisation on blockchain. Its the future of Architecture😊.

    • @dinirazin5978
      @dinirazin5978 2 роки тому

      @@KabirP-tw7sh @K B hey, I'm an Architect based in Kerala. Id like to know more about Metaverse Projects. How do I convert my models into NFTs

  • @amreshpatnaik5105
    @amreshpatnaik5105 2 роки тому +5

    Hey dude u r asking which is better brain or heart? I am an architect and by brother is an civil engineer i am designing,making spaces comfortable for all types of people ( blind, handicapped,etc) whereas my brother looks after the structure and estimation.. both civil and architect make the building from lvl+0.spread some positive vibes.

    • @Shreya-co4mh
      @Shreya-co4mh 2 роки тому

      Hey can you help me ,,, i just completed my 12th and I am thinking of doing b.arch ,,but I don't have any idea ...

    • @kusumaswetha9509
      @kusumaswetha9509 Рік тому

      ​@@Shreya-co4mhare u studying barch now

  • @Design_dhyana
    @Design_dhyana 3 роки тому +9

    Hey dude u know the definition of architecture go and swim in u will know it what exactly it is

  • @w.k8624
    @w.k8624 Рік тому +9

    Civil engineer can do architecture job but architect cannot do civil engineer job.

    • @vkey071110046
      @vkey071110046 11 місяців тому +1

      Hao 1600 sqft me ghar banata hai civil engineer.... aur wahi tak aukat hai....

  • @atulpanday2540
    @atulpanday2540 3 роки тому +7

    sir , please tell who design the beam ,slab, column etc ..how much steel is needed to bear the load ... who mention them in drawing

    • @ArchitectureOpinion
      @ArchitectureOpinion 3 роки тому +4

      Structural Engineer do all this thing by making Structural details like Excavation plan, Slab and beam layout plan, footing layout plan, load calculation etc

    • @akr1880
      @akr1880 2 роки тому

      Structure Engineer.....

    • @w.k8624
      @w.k8624 Рік тому

      Civil engineer (structural design part)

    • @w.k8624
      @w.k8624 Рік тому

      ​@@ArchitectureOpinion Structure engineer, he is civil engineer by training.

    • @arslanjatt8522
      @arslanjatt8522 Рік тому

      @@w.k8624 bro agr hum koi bulding design krty hy to kya phly structure engineer sy help ly gy

  • @PritiMishra25
    @PritiMishra25 3 роки тому +14

    Architect is the work boss and engineer is a field instructor

    • @subhrajyotinag1721
      @subhrajyotinag1721 3 роки тому +2

      @@PranavMish213 OO BHAI TERA AWKAAT NEHI HAY TO TALK ABOUT AN ARCHITECT

  • @c_326_ruchikasangar8
    @c_326_ruchikasangar8 3 роки тому +4

    Sir, I have already completed diploma in civil engineering..Kya Mai direct second architecture ko apply kr Sakti hoon?? Reply back plzz...

  • @Yog2024
    @Yog2024 11 місяців тому +1

    Thanku for this amazing knowledge 😊

  • @aroy914
    @aroy914 2 роки тому +1

    Architects sirf aur sirf building site mein kam kar sakta hai jab ki civil engineers building site ke alava road, dam, bridges is tarah ke sector mein kam lar sakta hai jahan architects kam nahi kar sakta hai

  • @shreyashddeshpande
    @shreyashddeshpande 3 роки тому +4

    Joor se Taali ek haath se kabhi nahi bajti...so likewise both are very crucial in creating beautiful yet functional spaces for a human to survive in a longer run♥️

    • @shreyashddeshpande
      @shreyashddeshpande 3 роки тому

      @Clay Corey honestly no time dude really really...could u just put Ur perspective here I'll respect it

  • @harshstudy488
    @harshstudy488 Рік тому +3

    Civil engineer is just lakho barbad kia hua thekedar 😂🤣🤣🤣

  • @nandinijaiswal1027
    @nandinijaiswal1027 3 роки тому +13

    Which is best architecture or civil engineer

  • @extramail3485
    @extramail3485 2 роки тому +11

    Architects will always get the credit.

  • @mayurbhatewara4513
    @mayurbhatewara4513 3 роки тому +1

    Please make a video on MEP works in building contruction and role of MEP engineer.

  • @lovebirdnegi
    @lovebirdnegi 3 роки тому

    श्री मान जी,एक बात आप से पूछनी है कि मैने अपने प्लाट पर कंपाउंड ,(9 इंच)4.5 इंच मेरी और 4.5 डीलर की डीपीसी डलवाई थी,कुछ समय बाद मेरे साथ वाले प्लाट पर डीलर ने मकान बना कर सेल कर दिया,और मैने अपने साथ वाले डीलर से डीपीसी का कोई पैसा नही लिया,और मै अब अपना मकान बना रहा हु,मेरा नया पड़ोसी अब अपनी दीवार के पैसे मांग रहा है (ग्राउंड फ्लोर) .अब मुझे क्या करना चाहिए कृपया करके जल्दी से जल्दी बताये.
    धन्यवाद !

  • @rupeshjadhav7439
    @rupeshjadhav7439 4 роки тому +2

    Sir muje apke AutoCAD course join Karna he par apke exicuitive ne batay ki there is no doute session for these courses

  • @sabooraquib
    @sabooraquib 4 роки тому +1

    Sir app update hone k bad discussion option ni hai?

  • @Saurabhkumar_79
    @Saurabhkumar_79 3 місяці тому +1

    Fantastic video

    • @Civil_Guruji
      @Civil_Guruji  3 місяці тому

      Dhanyavad! Saurabh Kumar, hume bahut khushi hui ki Aapko hamara video acha laga, Aise hi hamare sath jude rahiye aur sikhte rahiye!

  • @akashshirsat4661
    @akashshirsat4661 2 роки тому +2

    Civil engineer hi sab khuch kr dega to Architect aur structral engineer chutay hai kay 😂😂😂🤣🤣

  • @PankajChaudhary-Activist
    @PankajChaudhary-Activist Рік тому

    How To Get Rebar Grouting Projects?

  • @mehul_0073
    @mehul_0073 4 роки тому +1

    Sir mene package buy kiya he.par video or pdf kese download kare

  • @harshstudy488
    @harshstudy488 Рік тому +1

    This guy is totally saying crap 😂
    This happens when you don't get a good job and parents constantly ask you to do something you start doing this bulls*it

  • @scaryminati5528
    @scaryminati5528 4 роки тому +3

    Civil engineering ke bad architecturing karana possible hai Kya sir

    • @ArchitectureOpinion
      @ArchitectureOpinion 3 роки тому +3

      No, for architecture you have to do B.Arch course. and for Civil Engineering you have to do B.Tech course. both are different in terms of course. But if you love designing and creating the space and having good knowledge of the Functional part of the planning then you can simply make an Architectural Drawings and sign it (signature) from an Architect. You just have to pay less amount for signature. means Design is yours and signed by an Architect. (Its the best alternative way if you want to design a building)

    • @scaryminati5528
      @scaryminati5528 3 роки тому +1

      @@ArchitectureOpinion ok sir thank you 🙏

    • @scaryminati5528
      @scaryminati5528 3 роки тому

      @Tiger A IAS Aspirant IIA Kya hai sir college hai ya fir Kya hai samajha nahi thoda explain kijiye na please 🙏🙏

    • @scaryminati5528
      @scaryminati5528 3 роки тому

      @Tiger A IAS Aspirant ye based on 12th hota hoga na firr engineering matter nahi karti hai isame sahi hai na

    • @scaryminati5528
      @scaryminati5528 3 роки тому

      @Tiger A IAS Aspirant accha

  • @vkey071110046
    @vkey071110046 11 місяців тому

    Gajab ppt banaya civil इंजीनियर ne...Civil is about execution, Structural is about building strength design & Architecture is about designing creating spaces... ek dusre ke ga**d me mat ghuso.. jiska jo kaam hai vo kripya kar k kare.....and btw koi batayega konse civil engineer ne ya structural engineer ne koi iconic buildind banaye ho..

  • @injamulhaque9641
    @injamulhaque9641 2 роки тому

    ek baat me kahu to architech ka kaam buautiful design banana and civil engineer ka kaam hai us design ko real me execution kar na with safety,
    Am I right?

  • @Rockybhai-ku6fd
    @Rockybhai-ku6fd 3 роки тому +3

    Can I pursue m.arch in abroad after bachelor in civil engineering?

    • @Hemraj_2468
      @Hemraj_2468 3 роки тому

      but first you clear Nata exam or jeet2

    • @Hemraj_2468
      @Hemraj_2468 3 роки тому

      no civil engineer only architecture

  • @namioraon830
    @namioraon830 5 місяців тому +1

    Sir mera Diploma Architect branch hi to civil ka form bhar sake hi ya nhi

  • @sandesh9879
    @sandesh9879 3 роки тому +2

    Research krle Bhai architecture pe pehle 🙄

  • @chetanayalangde4758
    @chetanayalangde4758 Рік тому

    the part told by you of architect deals with is way wrong and lesss please revise and contact an architect to undersand the function of an architect

  • @medarirajeev6426
    @medarirajeev6426 2 роки тому

    Sir I'm applying for pgecet. In m-tech which is better civil engineering or architecture and planing.

  • @namioraon830
    @namioraon830 5 місяців тому

    Good afternoon sir ,sir Architect branch ka civil ka form bhar sake hi ya nhi

  • @mehedihasan-yb5ws
    @mehedihasan-yb5ws 3 роки тому

    Sir, iss nam pein ko e UA-cam channel nehi hein

  • @hetaljangid1975
    @hetaljangid1975 2 роки тому +1

    I'll choose architect

  • @satishdahit686
    @satishdahit686 11 місяців тому

    Architecture engineering me structureal design hota hai ki nahi

  • @dushyantkumarsahu5939
    @dushyantkumarsahu5939 Місяць тому

    Thanks sir👏

  • @omkaringle5587
    @omkaringle5587 2 роки тому +1

    Engineering bolo na bhai engeering kya hota hai 🙄

  • @dchandrashekhar4680
    @dchandrashekhar4680 4 роки тому +1

    Sir kaha hai link

  • @mdshamimakhtar7402
    @mdshamimakhtar7402 3 роки тому

    Sir polytechnic m civil branch achcha hai ya dusra

  • @vasuachary
    @vasuachary Рік тому

    you don't have knowledge about architect. try to research deeply .

  • @eramanverma9007
    @eramanverma9007 3 роки тому

    Sir polytechnic civil engineering ke baad architecture ka course kitne din ka hota hai

  • @abhishekpal1804
    @abhishekpal1804 Рік тому

    Thank you sir ji

  • @nirmalasubedi4978
    @nirmalasubedi4978 3 роки тому +1

    Sir bachelors civil engineering pe karkar masters architecture me possible hain na USA or Europe mein toh?

  • @vinayakpraveen2980
    @vinayakpraveen2980 3 роки тому

    Civil designs a building.... just stop giving false info

  • @mdmoin8536
    @mdmoin8536 2 роки тому

    Engiring ny baba engineering bolo

  • @rk2710
    @rk2710 3 роки тому

    Dip. Arch can apply b. Tech ?

  • @Ar_Rahman_M.k
    @Ar_Rahman_M.k 3 роки тому +1

    Nice sir

  • @Shree123mk
    @Shree123mk Рік тому

    Zhatu tum architect jesa design nhi bna skte

  • @ShankarYadav-yt9ny
    @ShankarYadav-yt9ny 3 роки тому

    Thanks

  • @yuvirajput9205
    @yuvirajput9205 3 роки тому +2

    Sir kya civil engineering diploma ke baad B Arch kr skte h kya

    • @Civil_Guruji
      @Civil_Guruji  3 роки тому

      Yuvi aapne 12th complete kiya hai then aap B Arch kar sakte hai after diploma.

    • @karthikks5621
      @karthikks5621 3 роки тому +1

      Wrong information.. Personl can do B-Arch after getting diploma in civil engineering.. No need of 12th..

    • @w.k8624
      @w.k8624 Рік тому

      ​@@Civil_Guruji ku feku giri karte ho.

  • @ashishmahatau2382
    @ashishmahatau2382 3 роки тому

    Nice video sir...
    Please tell me civil or architect मे सब्से ज्यादा mathematics किस्मे होति हे?

  • @shahrukhkhan5774
    @shahrukhkhan5774 2 роки тому

    My vote only architect ko

  • @raselmolla779
    @raselmolla779 3 роки тому

    Thank you

  • @er.siddharthnayansingh6387
    @er.siddharthnayansingh6387 3 роки тому

    Sir, I am doing b.tec from Civil engineering. Sir mai iske bad architecture kaise ban sakta hu

    • @shivanshgarg8697
      @shivanshgarg8697 3 роки тому +1

      You can't

    • @shivanshgarg8697
      @shivanshgarg8697 3 роки тому +1

      You have to do 5yrs course for architecture..

    • @atizazahsan3201
      @atizazahsan3201 3 роки тому

      @Tiger A IAS Aspirant hlw

    • @w.k8624
      @w.k8624 Рік тому

      If you work in building design for 2 years and get institute of engineer membership, you can get architect licence.

  • @shakeeljamil6059
    @shakeeljamil6059 2 роки тому

    Nice

  • @tania907
    @tania907 3 роки тому +1

    Sir can do Architecturing after 12th Medical science ??
    Sir plz tell its important ..

    • @xdd236
      @xdd236 3 роки тому

      First prepare for the entrance exam called NATA to be eligible for doing that.

    • @TK-kt6pp
      @TK-kt6pp 3 роки тому

      You need to have mathematics as well

    • @saptadeep1503
      @saptadeep1503 3 роки тому

      Prepare for jee mains paper 2, if u get good marks, u will be eligible for better government colleges

    • @monikasingh.5981
      @monikasingh.5981 3 роки тому

      @@xdd236 you also need PCM.

    • @monikasingh.5981
      @monikasingh.5981 3 роки тому

      @@saptadeep1503 how much percentage we need.

  • @videoforkid
    @videoforkid Рік тому

    Mc

  • @dchandrashekhar4680
    @dchandrashekhar4680 4 роки тому +3

    Oooye

  • @daydreamdinesh7201
    @daydreamdinesh7201 3 роки тому

    Paid video

  • @dchandrashekhar4680
    @dchandrashekhar4680 4 роки тому +1

    Sir

  • @TheLastview1
    @TheLastview1 2 роки тому

    Farji

  • @amarjot8423
    @amarjot8423 3 роки тому

    *Injuring

  • @asimdas5716
    @asimdas5716 Рік тому +1

    Thank u sir.

  • @AaBb-pe1zf
    @AaBb-pe1zf 2 роки тому

    thanks