What's behind the recent ethnic violence in Ethiopia? | Inside Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 758

  • @benjaminbenjamin8843
    @benjaminbenjamin8843 2 роки тому +7

    95% of trader lose learn to hold. No one goes from broke to rich without market pain. Stop selling and buying on emotion. Buy. Hold. Get through the pain. In 10years you'll do great. Don't buy meme coins.

    • @christianfox4092
      @christianfox4092 2 роки тому

      Wise words You are right thanks I was introduce to Expert Evelyn Vera, we get to see people poor due to ignorance,

    • @rosejudith697
      @rosejudith697 2 роки тому +1

      @@christianfox4092 Wow I know Mrs Expert Evelyn. I met her at a conference in The Dome at America's center Life 2016 where she introduced us her business strategy, she helped me cover my Loans a higher success

    • @kyloleif5257
      @kyloleif5257 2 роки тому

      I also trade with Mrs Expert Evelyn Vera, and I must say she makes money making seem a whole lot easier right now I'm a single parent and I pay the bills comfortably since I met Expert Evelyn she's absolutely amazing and I recommend her the best

    • @alicegrace3766
      @alicegrace3766 2 роки тому

      Oh please, how can someone get to speak with Mrs Evelyn Vera!!??

    • @rosejudith697
      @rosejudith697 2 роки тому +1

      十15045174834🇺🇸

  • @getadane
    @getadane 2 роки тому +29

    Thank you Tewodrose Terefe 🙏🙏🙏. You nailed it the fact well.

  • @warrior5847
    @warrior5847 2 роки тому +21

    My condolences for all who have lost their lives 🙏 💔 having said that the Same has been done in the Northern part of Ethiopia and people didn't denounced it but cheer not knowing they could be next 😢

  • @ezrameko7911
    @ezrameko7911 2 роки тому +23

    Bizuneh seemed to be living in cloud cuckoo land when he said the constitution was working well and had nothing to do with the turmoil Ethiopia had been experiencing for the past 4 years. He is sitting comfortably with the TPLF constitution that introduced the ethnic apartheid system in Ethiopia and the basis of all the troubles in the country for nearly 30 years! He presents himself as an academic but is, clearly, nothing more than a narrow-minded and bigoted ethno-centrist masquerading as a proponent of 'federalism' in its purest sense.

    • @Janhoy723
      @Janhoy723 2 роки тому +2

      @Exra Meko Well said. Bizuneh is in cahoots with Abiy Ahmed.

    • @ezrameko7911
      @ezrameko7911 2 роки тому +1

      @@Janhoy723 I have no reason to believe Abiy is pro the ethnic apartheid system and the basis of its existence, i.e. the present constitution, and therefore in complete opposition to the guy in question. Not sure what made you think he is 'in cahoots' with the PM.

    • @adamwario7167
      @adamwario7167 2 роки тому +3

      In deed the constitution by itself has no problem. All rebels are demanding rights enshrined in the constitution. Disregarding the constitution will lead the county to Balkanize. Theodros’s approach ignites more violence. He said many people are against current constitution, who are these many people? The way forward is reconciliation and granting more autonomy to the regions

    • @ezrameko7911
      @ezrameko7911 2 роки тому +1

      @@adamwario7167 Yes, the constitution has no problem for proponents of ethnic apartheid. The majority of Ethiopians want it to go (majority = those who cast their votes in the general election queuing for hrs to express their democratic rights!) except the section on 'human rights'. No, disregarding will lead to the unity and integrity of the country. Just because a few hundred loud proponents of ethnic apartheid are screaming does not make it a 'significant number'. Reconciliation with terrorists is impossible despite their efforts to impose it by killing innocent civilians. It is inevitable that they will be erased from the face of the earth soon.

    • @adamwario7167
      @adamwario7167 2 роки тому +4

      @@ezrameko7911Do you mean Amhara apartheid? Did you hear Abiy Ahmed reported to parliament 70% of opportunities are monopolized by Amhara and the majority of Ethiopians are marginalized. It’s this marginalization that created dozens of liberation fronts.

  • @isaacmoges3621
    @isaacmoges3621 2 роки тому +14

    Egypt lenders openly said they will destabilize peace and Estability in Ethiopia, so the Great Renaissance dam construction Distrupted and will be slow down or stopped. That's why they support heavily TPLF and OLF Rebels group openly.

    • @wub5669
      @wub5669 2 роки тому +3

      Exactly

    • @user-qy6tu9ip9v
      @user-qy6tu9ip9v 2 роки тому

      The federal government supports ola and olf. Wake up.

    • @user-qy6tu9ip9v
      @user-qy6tu9ip9v 2 роки тому

      @Ana Or they are being killed in other regions because they are surrounded by bloodthirsty primitive savages. Even Tigrayans were being burned in benishangul. I guess those Tigrayans are racist as well. The Amharas being killed in the Oromo region and Benishangul region are literally dirt poor and they're worried about finding their next meal but don't worry buddy. Amharas will start getting rid of Oromos and Gumuz and Amharas will get their revenge.

    • @wub5669
      @wub5669 2 роки тому

      @Ana unfortunately so many brainwashed generations 💔 re-read what u wrote.

  • @mehadiabdo4276
    @mehadiabdo4276 2 роки тому +40

    The Ethiopian people have never voted for ethnic-based federal system. The system has been imposed on the people by Ethnic entrepreneurs.

    • @denbel426
      @denbel426 2 роки тому

      They never voted for any government

    • @vahhidlelissa7653
      @vahhidlelissa7653 2 роки тому +1

      True

    • @ambessaseway5594
      @ambessaseway5594 2 роки тому +1

      There is no exuses for the massacres since Abiy Ahmed came to power

    • @meznehemia
      @meznehemia 2 роки тому +5

      Ethiopian Federalism is not ethnic based. There are 80+ different nations inside 10 states united as one union. If states were drawn purely on ethnic boundaries, shouldn't there be more than 80+ states? States were drawn according to commonalities in language, settlement patterns and consent of the people in each nation during a 4 year long negotiation from 1991-1995. It's unpatriotic to disparage any country's constitution let alone your own.
      Look up Article 46 of the 🇪🇹 FDRE constitution. More sensible than just ethnic boundaries.
      Article 46 States of the Federation
      1. The Federal Democratic Republic shall comprise of States.
      2. States shall be delimited on the basis of the settlement patterns, language, identity and consent of the people concerned.

    • @sadiqomar6679
      @sadiqomar6679 2 роки тому +3

      Has ethiopia ever voted in a free and fair election? 🤔

  • @zedonutube
    @zedonutube 2 роки тому +22

    Thank you Teodros for articulating what is going on in Ethiopia!
    And where did that guy, Bizuneh, come from? He must be living under a rock somewhere. He thinks the constitution is working well, and yet we know it is the source of all the troubles in Ethiopia.

    • @wendwesenadamu1541
      @wendwesenadamu1541 2 роки тому

      Constitution is a paper supposed to be respect by government of a people by the people. Ethiopia has no such government. Ethiopia is ruled by a government that is practically a war lord of Addis Ababa.

  • @Hhhhf344
    @Hhhhf344 2 роки тому +52

    Mr tedros we thank you for sharing the pain and suffering of the Amhara people to the International Community I hope they they take action on the perpetrators for the last 4 years in oromia and benishagul many Amhara are being killed and it's still continues

    • @solomonend8235
      @solomonend8235 2 роки тому +4

      "international community" don't fool your self sir!!!!
      same community don't care about yemen, Libya, Syria, etc.....
      power dynamic...............................

    • @ጨዋታተወዲኡ
      @ጨዋታተወዲኡ 2 роки тому

      stop kissing whites and arabs as$, instead ask GOD. I doubt you talk to God because you seek man's help

  • @kalida2413
    @kalida2413 2 роки тому +10

    No one talked about amhara and tigrey when they mascred the Ogaden state and Oromo

    • @ablove7957
      @ablove7957 2 роки тому

      Your point is?

    • @ጨዋታተወዲኡ
      @ጨዋታተወዲኡ 2 роки тому +1

      @@ablove7957 point is, STOP selective reporting that fits ones agenda, or stop adding fuel to the fire. Al jeira is not going to come and rescue anyone, they are just adding fuel to the fire. AND to YOU the message is , stop wishing arabs to help Ethiopia

    • @A.D.540
      @A.D.540 2 роки тому

      im tigrayan and i always spoke up from somali and oromo not much as i should since their want enough news coming out but i did always support their choice.

  • @yemerewfano5084
    @yemerewfano5084 2 роки тому +14

    Thanks Teddy for being voice for us as always!

  • @lifeinthecountrysidehome
    @lifeinthecountrysidehome 2 роки тому +45

    It's so sad to see our people killing each other. We need to accept each other individual cultures and learn from each other and live in unity and peace for the bettering and development of Africa. If we want Africa to be Great again, we have to stop this nonsensical madness.

    • @focusontruth2184
      @focusontruth2184 2 роки тому

      People are not killing each other the government is killing people

    • @achumatirunew8510
      @achumatirunew8510 2 роки тому

      It’s not killing each other, people are killed by the government that’s the reality. Shame on you trying to hide the reality of government sponsored genocide 🩸🩸🩸

    • @libanali1626
      @libanali1626 2 роки тому +7

      Since when you thought that brilliant idea why not for attrocities committed for thousand years where were you unless you are wicked people who beleived that amhaara is to rule and others to be slaves what does mean to you the idea of amhaara must be respected as holy people.

    • @abadirzulu5249
      @abadirzulu5249 2 роки тому +2

      Amen agree JESUS CHRIST 4 africa

    • @stoptheamharagenocidesopit913
      @stoptheamharagenocidesopit913 2 роки тому +1

      No problem between the people, our issue is the mercenaries foreign appointees. Now it become clear to whom must get cancelled first! The mercenaries on power!!! We Ethiopians will do it soon!!;

  • @Tamking72
    @Tamking72 2 роки тому +13

    0:53 Sir, Don’t be afraid to say, that just last week thousands have died in Ethiopia 💔

  • @zb1567
    @zb1567 2 роки тому +10

    This William guy is biased in a pocket of TPLF we have all his track records and what does he knows about Ethiopia? Why not invite real Amharas as for your information, Amhara are the majority of Ethiopia note: outside the so called ethically demarcated region alone, there are nearly 20 million now when you add the Amhara so called region you have 30 millions making it 60 million in total.

    • @wediofla3230
      @wediofla3230 2 роки тому

      Really?

    • @zeed7938
      @zeed7938 2 роки тому

      Oh ya William works for tplf. He was/is one of the reporters putting out false information about Ethiopia to help tplf. Our Twitter zemecha wAs against people like him. We debunked all their manufactured stories n defeated them. No matter he says about Ethiopia, He should not be trusted

    • @ayubmumad2808
      @ayubmumad2808 2 роки тому

      You are stupid as you Write the comment 1st learn Ethiopian history

    • @tomwie3253
      @tomwie3253 2 роки тому

      ​@@wediofla3230 yes. He is right.

  • @ጠረፍ
    @ጠረፍ 2 роки тому +5

    I feel sorry for a professor teaching politics at the University of Kent lacks a very rudimentary understanding of the problem in his country of origin. One has to be stupid enough to lose a sight of what is happening on the ground.

    • @እዝራ-ኰ4ፀ
      @እዝራ-ኰ4ፀ 2 роки тому +1

      I couldn’t agree more with you but I’m also wandering if’s an intellectual dishonesty or sheer stupidity.

    • @harmonyclarke6808
      @harmonyclarke6808 2 роки тому

      Where do poor people get such guns from, people can't find food but can find guns, don't you guys think your going to die,leave this ethnic rubbish alone and get on with living,the rest of the world is laughing at you.

  • @mucheabere1437
    @mucheabere1437 2 роки тому +22

    Thank you Aljezira for being a voice for the innocent people. 1500 people died and think of how many were wounded. Killers still are very confident to live within the government structure. They are very close to the government. They are supported in ammunition and weapons. The killing of Amhara was their daily task and they will do it in the future for sure.

    • @jahservantgad9042
      @jahservantgad9042 2 роки тому

      So repatriating Oromo leaders from Eritrea was a bad decision by president Abiy?

    • @safiyasahle8478
      @safiyasahle8478 2 роки тому

      1500 you must be idiot

    • @anonymoussynonyms6183
      @anonymoussynonyms6183 2 роки тому

      ENATOTEN LEBDACHEW YE EGYPT TELALKI BE ZEFN ENA BEWORKT MYFERS HGR YELM NEGERK ABICHU KKKKKKKKKKKK KOMECHEW

    • @biniam2301
      @biniam2301 2 роки тому

      😂

  • @EyobAbyssinia
    @EyobAbyssinia 2 роки тому +16

    Thank you so much, Tewodros being a voice for the voiceless
    ኢትዮጵያ ታሸንፋለች ሞት ለባንዳዎች❗️❗️❗️

  • @endaleabera9742
    @endaleabera9742 2 роки тому +2

    The government has 0 political gain from the amara people death. But u guys have and u r looking for the gain Ethiopian are going to hate u once the people start to have clue about politics. Taking advantage on 1 year old baby death is stupid

  • @akitman1785
    @akitman1785 2 роки тому +6

    It is ethical cleansing , the dead people reached 1600 as per the source from the victims village.This is done by govt backed terrorist because the village leader
    speak clearly how he received direction for massacre.

  • @joeGuizan
    @joeGuizan 2 роки тому +11

    In the process of negotiation, proper representation of the ethnic groups and parties will offer a path forward.🎉🎉🎉🎉

    • @jojo-yc5bp
      @jojo-yc5bp 2 роки тому +1

      ethnic representation
      and ethni genocide r not the same thing

    • @rasta6713
      @rasta6713 Рік тому

      Yup! Reconciliation and amending, and moving on!

  • @NewTechOfficial2321
    @NewTechOfficial2321 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks Aljezera for your repor, now in Ethiopia is going on Government sponsored Genocide on Amhara civilians and more than 5000 Civilian Amhara's massacred in a single week , the main acter of this genocide is Abiy Ahmed government , the first responsibility of the government is to protect violence but after Abiy Ahmed came to power so many thousand's of civilian Amharas have been killed ,

  • @leweyehu_yirsaw
    @leweyehu_yirsaw 2 роки тому +47

    Thank you Mr Tewodros for being a voice for the innocent Amhara people killed in Oromia.

    • @kylesmith8128
      @kylesmith8128 2 роки тому +1

      Psy-ops is not your calling....

    • @gherieg.1091
      @gherieg.1091 2 роки тому

      Amharas ... collectively and individually pray to God. And support each other everywhere and in every way you can.
      This is a scourge that’s coming at all Christians in Ethiopia from the Marxist ghouls from Eritrea. They’re persecuting Christians in Eritrea, too.
      We’re in the end times. These are part of the endtime Antichrist movement, the 666.
      Even if you don’t believe me on that ... you’re a deeply Christian people. You do well to turn to God.
      Jesus is Lord. God bless you.

    • @gherieg.1091
      @gherieg.1091 2 роки тому

      @@kylesmith8128
      What do psyops have to do with what he said, sir ?

    • @tomwie3253
      @tomwie3253 2 роки тому +1

      ​@@kylesmith8128 leave from here. Killer.

  • @addisalemberihunmelese2859
    @addisalemberihunmelese2859 2 роки тому +15

    What a sad and painfully thing to see a genocide story of my country that I love. May God help us.

    • @abadirzulu5249
      @abadirzulu5249 2 роки тому +1

      Other forces don't want Ethiopia moving forward I love abasinia those are my brothers n sisters.

    • @leoracicaneda3895
      @leoracicaneda3895 2 роки тому +1

      😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢🇧🇷🇮🇱🙏

    • @abadirzulu5249
      @abadirzulu5249 2 роки тому

      Amen 🙏

  • @tadwmichael
    @tadwmichael 2 роки тому +3

    The problem is ethnic federalism which created factions for killing Amharas people . Why the constitution especially article 39 and regions should not be divided by race . That is the main core problem!
    Ethiopia 🇪🇹 for all Ethiopians!
    God bless Ethiopia 🇪🇹 with pace and humanity for all!

  • @marthamengistu7882
    @marthamengistu7882 2 роки тому +26

    Mr Tedrose thank you for being the voice for voiceless Amara victims in Oromoia region .Thia violence has been going on for a long time and the international press should stand with the innocent victims of poor Amara farmers and their children including the infants.

  • @abagudakershu9599
    @abagudakershu9599 2 роки тому +4

    What Mr. Tewdross said is proved to be true. This has been confirmed 2 day ago by Dr. Angassa an Oromo Member of parliament.

  • @hilinateshome9302
    @hilinateshome9302 2 роки тому +23

    Mr.Tewdros Terefe Thank You a voice for the innocent Amhara People of Killed in Oromia .
    STOPE AMHARA GENOCIDE

  • @selamlimena7902
    @selamlimena7902 2 роки тому +2

    Oromuma and OLF is the Killer Genocider 👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾

  • @adamseid5447
    @adamseid5447 2 роки тому +9

    As An Amhara born and grew up in Wollegga this is not Ethnic Violence . It is a terrorist Group killing innocent Amharas to gain political benefit. Oromos in the area don't support it.

    • @denbel426
      @denbel426 2 роки тому

      Why did you leave your state and want another state

    • @adamseid5447
      @adamseid5447 2 роки тому +2

      @@denbel426 I didn't left my state . I just went back to my ancestors land.

    • @ambessaseway5594
      @ambessaseway5594 2 роки тому

      Killing Tigrayans by Fano in Western Tigray is also a Terrorist Group

    • @adamseid5447
      @adamseid5447 2 роки тому

      @@ambessaseway5594 Talking about this fiction all the time will not change the reality on the ground. A fiction will always be A fiction (unreal). indeed Western Tigré by it self is a fiction created by TPLF terrorists. The real name of the area is wolkait Tegede. And It will never ever back to Tigrés. You know that .

    • @ambessaseway5594
      @ambessaseway5594 2 роки тому

      @@adamseid5447 So Amhara killing is also fiction you are destroying Ethiopia in the name of Amhara Extremist

  • @alemaywld6120
    @alemaywld6120 2 роки тому +4

    Thank you Mr. Theodros for clarification of the truth what's happening on the ground.

  • @Freedom-ix9sw
    @Freedom-ix9sw 2 роки тому +3

    The constitution is the main problem which doesnot give minority right in the regional states.

  • @jaarsawalaabu4393
    @jaarsawalaabu4393 2 роки тому +8

    There is strong evidence from local administrators & survivors that the Tole massacre was conducted by government officials the same way they conducted the Karayu massacre.

  • @layac4373
    @layac4373 2 роки тому +2

    The Kings of the earth are going to pay dearly for their crimes against Humanity 🙏🏼🔥 Abba Father protect these beautiful people from the from these evil humans who we know have an agenda to carry out these crimes 🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @bedelludesta5508
    @bedelludesta5508 2 роки тому +1

    Make no mistake that, it is the government of Oromo region which is coordinating the genocide against Amara, according to a member of the parliament Mr Angasa

  • @mahdiali2695
    @mahdiali2695 2 роки тому +1

    12 millions somalis are equal to 13 million ahmaara.. 18 million other amaara are not amaara ..jaziira working for the west so they can keep there license

  • @fekerachenafe6438
    @fekerachenafe6438 2 роки тому +1

    Teodros do you realy saying OLA and the government works together? Ethiopian government should question you to presented your fact. You get the nerve to accused Ethiopia government jyst to save TPLF. Theodore wr know your background , believe me you are not defending TPLF

  • @ሽሮእወዳለሁ
    @ሽሮእወዳለሁ 2 роки тому +11

    Davison seems particularly uninformed about the intricacies of Ethiopia's ethnic history and the workings of Abiy's government for a person who specializes in the area.

  • @maetebtesfamariam4072
    @maetebtesfamariam4072 2 роки тому +1

    the victims are not amhara ethnic society. Its Oromo and Tigrian residents who have been murdered for political purposes

  • @abbaa8712
    @abbaa8712 2 роки тому +1

    Do not forget amharas are killed raped and evicted 1.2 million tigrayans from Western Tigray.

  • @mikem6459
    @mikem6459 2 роки тому +1

    William don't try to water down the atrocities committed in Tigray by a multiple of aggressors including Amharas, Ethiopian and Eritrean forces and other foreign forces. What you suggest will not solve any problem. What is needed is independent investigation of all atrocities and ensure accountability.

  • @Somaaliman
    @Somaaliman 2 роки тому +2

    Ethiopia is in a big mess. MAY ALLAH HELP the poor people.

  • @abebemandefro291
    @abebemandefro291 2 роки тому +1

    The report has undermined the number; it is not, by all means 200, but it is over 1,500.

  • @badasslifestylee
    @badasslifestylee 2 роки тому +4

    "attacks on innocent civilians and destruction of livelihoods by illegal and irregular forces is unacceptable" ok, so if the government forces do it is all good right? Hahahahaha

  • @laylaali5977
    @laylaali5977 2 роки тому +1

    Very sad people killing their own people we have the same thing in Somalia.

  • @legessedinka1945
    @legessedinka1945 2 роки тому +1

    Mr. Tewdreos is a very biased man always talking with no evidence .

  • @ye5331
    @ye5331 2 роки тому +1

    lol, just ask the Ethiopian guys...the white guy isn't needed

  • @wediofla3230
    @wediofla3230 2 роки тому +3

    Tedros,
    Where is fano? You guys claimed it is the saviour of Ethiopia. 😃
    All Fanos do is kill innocent Tigrayans and Oromos .

    • @wediofla3230
      @wediofla3230 2 роки тому

      @Samuel Maru Really?? We all know what they did in Western Tigray. Now they are being hunted down by terriorsts abiy and demekech Meknonnen and Eritrian troops.

    • @user-qy6tu9ip9v
      @user-qy6tu9ip9v 2 роки тому +2

      @@wediofla3230 Eritrea is doing the opposite of what you're saying. Eritrea has trained over 80k Fanos since Fano took back welkait and humera. It's only Abiys troops that are hunting down Fanos in Gojjam and so far Abiys troops have been taking losses. Tplf and Sudans military also recently carried out an attack on Fano in West Gondar and Sudans military and TDF sustained heavy casualties. Cope

    • @wediofla3230
      @wediofla3230 2 роки тому

      @@user-qy6tu9ip9v What an insider you are.

  • @henokyared4352
    @henokyared4352 2 роки тому +7

    Thank you for your coverage

  • @tsedalebelete1516
    @tsedalebelete1516 2 роки тому +1

    who is behind? cia, moozad, egypt, esayeyas (Eriteria)

  • @yada7630
    @yada7630 2 роки тому +4

    It needs to address other extinct ethnic cleansing & genocidal killings in oromia & other regions for the past three decades, bedeno, arba gugu, arsi, benshangul, maykadra......... All these killings didn't get even a single coverage in the mainstream media.

  • @lolal1ola
    @lolal1ola 2 роки тому +1

    Why is this racist colonialist always presented as an expert on Ethiopian issues???

  • @ethiopianqueen2445
    @ethiopianqueen2445 2 роки тому +1

    This is a very sad genocide. Everyone is dying, but ecspecially the innocent women and children. May God help us all.

  • @misgantesfaw8944
    @misgantesfaw8944 2 роки тому +12

    Aljezira English Thank you for covering the news of Amhara Genocide in Oromiya region .

  • @tormundgaint1022
    @tormundgaint1022 2 роки тому +3

    Im not even Oromo, but Amhara people should stay in their region instead of moving to Oromia and the Somali region.

    • @eyob4794
      @eyob4794 2 роки тому

      They’ve been in oromia for centuries

    • @tormundgaint1022
      @tormundgaint1022 2 роки тому

      @@eyob4794 Then they should leave just to be safe..

    • @eyob4794
      @eyob4794 2 роки тому

      @@tormundgaint1022 they’re safe in Addis & always will be

  • @amirmohammed2964
    @amirmohammed2964 2 роки тому +1

    OLA is not a criminal group. it's a legitimate Military group to free Oromo People from tyranny

  • @bulakochebo7636
    @bulakochebo7636 2 роки тому +4

    America and west devised ethnic federalism in Ethiopia, brought ethnically intoxicated TPLF to power and made Eritrea an independent country. the root cause of the problems in Ethiopia are the west and America.

    • @thegunners4045
      @thegunners4045 2 роки тому

      U shouldn’t mention Eritrea 🇪🇷. Eritrea was never 👎 part of Ethiopia 🇪🇹. All this mess caused by tplf . Coz they were minority nd wanted to stay in power .

    • @bulakochebo7636
      @bulakochebo7636 2 роки тому

      @@thegunners4045 ok, but we can argue on that

  • @zerataw
    @zerataw 2 роки тому +2

    Today report the massacre number is increasing to 1600 people

  • @robayohannes5331
    @robayohannes5331 2 роки тому +4

    Roughly 2 years ago, about 200 Amharas were killed in Wollaga and it was blamed on TPLF using its long arm to destabilize the government. It was used as part of the reason to wage war on Tigray. It resulted in approximately 500,000 deaths and incalculable property damage. With the Tigray war subsiding, another 200 or so Amharas are killed and this time, it is being used to wage war against the OLA. My message to Amharas is - when do we stop and ask for independent investigation? When do we hold the actual criminals accountable? Do we wait until another 500,000 people are dead? The investigation will happen! If you have not noticed - the UN has approved and investigative team to investigate the Tigray war crimes. I am confident this one too, will be investigated. It will not help any of the dead or the ones that are going to die as a result of the war, if we investigate after the fact. Please stand with all the groups that are asking for independent investigation. Reserve your judgements till after that.

  • @karenkane2922
    @karenkane2922 2 роки тому +4

    It's sad and sickening knowing my brothers and sisters are killing each others over ethnicity when their are bigger problems to fight we need to respect and preserve our tribal diversity with love,one Africa ,one people and one love will carry us through united state of Africa, not war against each others,we need to start talking about unity between different tribes. One Africa. Outsiders are laughing and saying here we go again. we need to stop this madness.

    • @samizewdu2309
      @samizewdu2309 2 роки тому +1

      Thank you for your toughts but they are not killing each other... the Amhara people are getting killed by mass everyday in oromia state

    • @ebsamohamed5845
      @ebsamohamed5845 Рік тому

      We need to stop this madness just to stop others laughing at as really? This just like amhara claiming they were the corner done for decolonization of Africa when every one knows haile selassie was spying for the great powers at the same time

  • @Nade863
    @Nade863 2 роки тому +3

    Abiy’s Oromo prosperity Party is a cause for all Amhara genocide by supporting OLA for the sake of Oromo homogeneous region creation!

  • @rasfele1
    @rasfele1 2 роки тому +1

    It’s astonishing to see William as an expert on Ethiopia 🇪🇹 he barely knows Ethiopia.

  • @bigloaf7982
    @bigloaf7982 2 роки тому +2

    Ethiopia was never colonized so at least europeans cant be blamed for the troubles and misfortunes of Ethiopians .

    • @bigloaf7982
      @bigloaf7982 2 роки тому +1

      @Samuel Maru Europeans have not been allies to each other.
      They hated each other and made war .
      Look what Russia doing to its closest cousin Ukraine .

  • @AFROKUSHTIC
    @AFROKUSHTIC 2 роки тому +2

    Al jazeera We could send you live recorded videos killing Of oromo civilian by amhara in amhara regions

    • @lail111
      @lail111 2 роки тому

      @@showfaya2367 You are not victims you have been the aggressors in the region for centuries.

  • @shahzaibmajeed1068
    @shahzaibmajeed1068 2 роки тому

    Surat No. 21 Ayat NO. 18
    بلکہ ہم تو حق بات کو باطل پر کھینچ مارتے ہیں ، جو اس کا سر توڑ ڈالتا ہے ، اور وہ ایک دم ملیا میٹ ہوجاتا ہے ۔ ( ٨ ) اور جو باتیں تم بنا رہے ہو ، ان کی وجہ سے خرابی تمہاری ہی ہے ۔
    Surat No. 21 Ayat NO. 18
    Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe.

  • @thematteroftime4486
    @thematteroftime4486 2 роки тому +1

    Abiy is a killer not OLF . OLF asked independent investigators find out the truth. Abiy is a killer.

  • @zchataabba6490
    @zchataabba6490 2 роки тому +1

    May the souls of all my African family members in Ethiopia find peaceful rest. AMEN. William Davidson, Senior Ethiopia Analyst sitting in Kenya??? Al Jazeera PLEASE..... let ALL the contributors BE Ethiopian ONLY.

  • @nebeethd9251
    @nebeethd9251 2 роки тому +13

    The attacks against Amhara|s has continued for decades. Oromo and Tigray nationalists visualize their imagined empire at the demise of Amhara. They grew with hate narrative. They are waging continuous Genocide against Amhara civilians. In the latest attack in Oromia region of Ethiopia, at least 1500 Amhara civilians including children and women are slaughtered by Oromo liberation army terrorist forces who are supported by the state government. The world should stand with Amharas to save lives.
    Thank you Aljazeera for being voice for the voiceless Amhara.

    • @lail111
      @lail111 2 роки тому +3

      You did that to the oromos for centuries what goes around comes around.

    • @rigbeqi
      @rigbeqi 2 роки тому +1

      @@lail111 That's a lie. No single amhara in government ever killed a single oromo. Dont mention Dergue or the kings, none of them were representative of Amharas.

    • @user-qy6tu9ip9v
      @user-qy6tu9ip9v 2 роки тому +1

      @@lail111 Oromos have a history of being expansionists and at the same time crying like they are victims. Don't cry when Amharas begin retaliating.

    • @LoveSoldierJames
      @LoveSoldierJames 2 роки тому +1

      @@lail111 Shall your great grandchildren be rightly held accountable for your wrongs then?

    • @lail111
      @lail111 2 роки тому

      @@rigbeqi Why not mention the kings?

  • @mayabelay6114
    @mayabelay6114 2 роки тому +1

    This is not the first incident amara had have been killed murdered in benshangule ,oromia. Deliberately murdering women children OLF authorities slaughtered them all .the world should know oromia region in Ethiopia is the worst place for human being . Even during primitive society no such murderers like Oromo authorities and oromia young man become soldiers to murder amara children women and man.

  • @theycallmeflipper4515
    @theycallmeflipper4515 2 роки тому +7

    The war in Ethiopia is far worse than that of Ukraine

    • @waliali7915
      @waliali7915 2 роки тому

      I don’t think so Al-47 vs missiles

  • @Captainhumanity22
    @Captainhumanity22 2 роки тому +12

    Thank you Tedros as always for your insights. The international community need to step up and stop Amhara genocide in Ethiopia.

  • @turegnassefa5140
    @turegnassefa5140 2 роки тому +7

    What a foolish comment by Bizuneh. How do u think they forget the date of birth of a 1 month old infant?

    • @tomwie3253
      @tomwie3253 2 роки тому +1

      that ist also my thought. He was trying to defend His "freedom fighters " so bad

    • @negusofminjar8290
      @negusofminjar8290 2 роки тому

      brainless gala lie lie

  • @Freedom-ix9sw
    @Freedom-ix9sw 2 роки тому +2

    Oromo is not the largest community. It is the largest kilil. Amhara is the largest community.

  • @EdwardLawrence-12345
    @EdwardLawrence-12345 2 роки тому +14

    Maybe yes! 🤔
    "A resident of Tole said I swear in the name of Allah” and added that“the administrator of the Tole locality or village Mr. Nigatu Ummeta, said he had organized and undertaken massacre of Amara..."

  • @seble.......160
    @seble.......160 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you Tewodrose for being the voice of innocent people.

  • @abrehamgetenet2908
    @abrehamgetenet2908 2 роки тому +3

    Thank you Al Jazeera for being the voice of those innocent Amhara innocent peoples.

    • @saraawoke8901
      @saraawoke8901 2 роки тому

      Thank you al jazeera for being tha voice of those innocent AMHARA INNOCENT PEOPLES THANK YOU🙏🙏🙏

  • @abuabdillahabdullah4232
    @abuabdillahabdullah4232 2 роки тому +5

    The next Yugoslavia is loading

    • @desalegnsendek830
      @desalegnsendek830 2 роки тому

      your expectation is totally unacceptable and you have to understand our country that it had survived much greater challenges more than this.

  • @gabigebreal7620
    @gabigebreal7620 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks Teodros Tirfe the TRUE ETHIOPIAN SON.
    💚💛❤🙏

  • @zerataw
    @zerataw 2 роки тому +10

    It is not incident , it is genocide on Amhara Ethic .

  • @solomonshiferaw9600
    @solomonshiferaw9600 2 роки тому +3

    It should be known to all that Abiy Ahmed brought in OLA from Eritrea deserts ,well armed them and conducted a series of horrific massacres on innocent Amhara ethnic members in Oromia region,Ethiopia since 2018 !

    • @ጸሎተ
      @ጸሎተ 2 роки тому

      Very true he brought OlA to kill Amhara this government is working with OlA

    • @solomonshiferaw9600
      @solomonshiferaw9600 2 роки тому

      @@ጸሎተ He is a cold blooded genocider.

  • @shimelisshiferaw1312
    @shimelisshiferaw1312 2 роки тому +1

    Dear Bizuneh, How could you say the constitution do not have a problem, the multi-ethnic nation or from two different parents were ignored while we exist

  • @chalewabebe6631
    @chalewabebe6631 2 роки тому +8

    Thank you Tewodros!!

  • @ethiozegba7532
    @ethiozegba7532 2 роки тому +1

    Tplf cancer of Ethiopia.

  • @jalitolassa7809
    @jalitolassa7809 2 роки тому +1

    Bizuneh was speaking responsibly. the same goes with William. as for tewodros this is what i say. how did this discussion evolved into constitutional change??? what if the whole problem is about a power struggle to scrap the constitution?? the state formation process in Ethiopia, like anywhere else is one of violence. that is one and half century ago. what is different about Ethiopia is that, it has produced unequal relations which has to seem much change and the likes of Tewodros are adamantly none progressive. they actually seek reversals into the initial conditions of the violent state formation. such start created hegemonic relations that has Ethnic, linguistic, cultural, economic, political implications, more than tilted. The 1995 constitution is wrongly labelled as Ethnic, which raises the question what is not Ethnic in Ethiopian context. just simply dividing the political spectrum as Ethnic vs Unionist is a semantics imperialism that emboldens the rhetoric of the the hegemonic true Ethicists. It is a second best solution to self Administration rights of the nations that the 1995 constitution was promulgated. second best solutions are often more complications because more should have been done in the first place to create an equal and inclusive governance. Rather opportunism, power balance relations and unconstitutional governance besides being inadequate as in all second best solutions brought the change in 2018. it is/was not Ethnic at all.
    for people whos say the 1995 constitution was Ethnic, it begs the question as opposed to what? let them ask themselves a million times "as opposed to what?" some of the panelists here was lamenting about the government for allowing the exiled OLF to enter to Ethiopia. why is he lamenting about that? isnot it all exiled politicians including Amhara based that were given political "pardon" and allowed in? But in case he forgot, the change that happened at 2018 was largely brought by the qeerroo movement which is psychologically, socially, culturally, politically and in every sense aligned with constitutionalism and OLF itself. of course, since the change they have successfully alienated even qeerroo and campaigned for the closure of the political land scape to close for all Ethiopians except for their ethnic group. they have made all the rest out of the ballot box!!! they have controlled the media, mobilized and influenced the regime to that effect. it is not difficult for any journalist to clarify this!
    His group of exiled politicians were also allowed to enter. "amnesty" was given to every politician. when they enter they started to define what change meant and what to exclude to ever appear on the ballot. they started to define change meant to scrap every progressive change the country has witnessed in the last 50 years. these group of politicians curse the last 50 years because of what? for the down fall of the last feudal system the world seen? why are them the only ones to lament? as this is the narrative that won the heart of the regime in Addis, be it Benishngul or Oromo or Tigray or for that matter the majority of Ethiopians were to be excluded from participating in elections not because people were not to vote for them but the same politicians that complain OLF from Oromia, ONLF from Ethiopian Somalia or all the other 80 plus politicians from the nations have to be banned except from theirs and run a mock election. before the war in Tigray, the Amhara regional state was in war largely with its Qimant and Oromo nations. Amhara regional government was also waging war in Benishangul Gumz Region, still has presence there, with Tigray region and still has presence there, some incidents of irregular forces entering into the region of Oromia and doing some operations. The Oromia state was in war with its own Oromo constituencies that were deemed to have differences with the vision of change that the current regime is trying to sell ........
    Unfortunate for Ethiopia, the regime in Addis doesn't seem to have an understanding of structural matters or seem to have the wrong understanding of appeasing the never ending demands of the hegemonic group that it actual speaks in their tongue and its political framing is a replica theirs thus far. the tongue spoken by the power in Addis and how Addis seen change in the last 4 years happen to give hope for he hegemonic group to further their demands into totally taking Ethiopia back to its "inglorious past", their own domination under the name of Unity - unity under the confederates of the past U.S. They first alienated the regime from its base with their tactical support and adventurous moves, keep giving that support when it does their work - often more than they could ever dream of themselves and withdraw when they are unsatisfied. to be honest, the regime can satisfy them at its own final demise... that is exactly their game and the regime seems to be entangled in to that scheme. so far there is that feeding each other. like consider one of the panelists proposing constitutional change before even investigating the incidents and holding the perpetrators of such heinous crimes accountable. how did someone from across the Atlantic did the investigation to make such a sweeping generalization of who the perpetrators are and who is to be whipped and ultimately put forward as a solution what governance mode people all over Ethiopia need to have in order to avert such problems from ever happening again? ? how? even for the regime, he did not throw it under the bus. he put the condition to whip itself up and come to a solution that he as a person from another constituency proposes!!! what does it say about politicking in general and how the person is concerned about finding the true perpetrators of the heinous crimes and holding those accountable? were we all born yesterday? from here on, you will find mobilizations that seek the same to put pressure towards constitutional change hoping that it works. but it only will turn too be terrible experiments risking a lot that may end up shocking the world. there is too much to say but......
    justice to the victims now and before!!! civilians should not be used for political conspiracies. that is heinous crime and that is a sin. it has to be denounced by all!!!! most of all it has to be investigated. justice cannot be made without knowing the true perpetrators of the crimes.

    • @enathagertube4619
      @enathagertube4619 2 роки тому

      You must be joking, the constitution is the only problem

    • @abulyft4502
      @abulyft4502 2 роки тому

      Thank for brief de facto in that country. The so called Amhara elite group want to orchestrate the same game that there ancestors did by killing innocent Muslim people to use as double sword but they never succeed.

    • @jalitolassa7809
      @jalitolassa7809 2 роки тому

      @@enathagertube4619 the constitution cannot and wont shoot and kill. dirty politicking does. you must know that simple fact and then come to talk of your point,

  • @Avaricumstudios
    @Avaricumstudios 2 роки тому +6

    I sometimes don't understand Ethiopia....it has existed as a unified entity than most African countries but somehow it seems to suffer most from ethnic divisions

    • @sevenscounty409
      @sevenscounty409 2 роки тому +2

      Ethiopia is the result of occupation of indigious african tribal lands by the othordox church which affiliates with its western allies in the catholic church ( france, germany, italia & most catholics in the EU) in order to subjugate, colonise and christianize a majority muslim land and using ethnicity to hold the country together. This ethnic glue is a very weak binding agent and really an exercise in futility. So the other way is to dismantle the whole venture and let the big ethnic groups unbolt and created their own countries, Oromia for the oromos, Amhara for the amharas, Tigres should join fellow tigres in Eretria, Somalis should join their mother land somalia and the rest in western ethiopia which is mostly nilotic can join their brothers in south sudan. End of story

    • @user-qy6tu9ip9v
      @user-qy6tu9ip9v 2 роки тому

      @@sevenscounty409 Majority muslim land? You're kidding. I agree with Somalis leaving.

    • @derekmahari8184
      @derekmahari8184 2 роки тому

      @@sevenscounty409 delusional. get some antipsychotic meds because this is utterly delusional

    • @PushStartMedia
      @PushStartMedia 2 роки тому +3

      @@sevenscounty409 well that’s the most western book narrative of the facts if any. At various junctures of Ethiopias history dating back to Axum and the Adal empires, there has been expansions and war where the Adulites wiped out their Christian counterparts and vice versa where the Axumites expanded their territories and kingdoms. Through it all the various ethnic groups have coexisted, and the majority of Ethiopians by in large are Christian and Muslim, literally half. There are also verified historical accounts that had it not been for the Oromo expansion to the north and west of the nation there may have been an Adulite dominance back in the 16th century. The ottoman influence, to expand religious based expansion, and British and other European (namely Italian) influence into the culture and political ideologies that predated the 20th century can be recognized as factors that brought about political division by ethnic/tribal affiliation. And since the period of Zemene mesafint after the fall of Axum Ethiopians while not equal under the feudal system we’re not unequal based on ethnicity, but by the nobility and common folks like else where in the world during these eras. It is not unique to Ethiopia and it is baseless to push total responsibility on the Orthodox Church or Christian expansion. If religious oppression existed why is half of the Ethiopian population muslim? The real change in political structures came after the Marxist, Leninist socialization of Ethiopian youth in the 60s and 70s as part of the greater work of dividing the country for conquest and the conflicts that ensued from the late 70s thru the 90s can also be largely attributed to fall outs from the Cold War when the world was fighting an ideological battle. So no ethnic federalism was not created to preserve Ethiopia, it is the very ingredient to the demise of many and application of false narratives that vilify certain people against others. We must acknowledge that this interference and the political influence of indoctrinated elites from various groups but more specifically the 3 dominant (Amhara, Oromo and Tigrayans) are still the ones most discussed. The others in the over 80 ethnic communities are small in number and this their plight against, one, some or all of the dominant cultures is rarely even discussed. The TPLF who were the victors of the socialist liberation movements completely switched gears and embedded into their communist structures an ethno-linguistic system that virtually calls out the Amharas as the enemy of their ethnic group. This political group created and institutionalized its doctrine into the fabric of the politics over 3 decades and took full advantage of the power structure by applying the same western born colonial process of divide and conquer due to the fact that they (Tigrayans) were a smaller (6%) of the population. That said it neither stayed true to its cause of liberating Tigryans or providing social justice, as it converted into a capitalist autocracy that created a vast economic imbalance, rewarded corruption, empowered division by enthroning one group and dethroning another, creating minority populations that natively lived in lands and territories now designated as belonging to one ethnic group and communities in these newly created ethnical federal regions of all ethnic groups were systematically oppressed, displaced and or killed. Amharas suffered greatly during TPLF specifically in places like Welkait which was annexed into Tigray and followed a process of ethnic cleansing that spanned decades, disallowed use of native language and wiped out males specifically as your ethnic identity is classified by fathers identity. Entire generations were wiped out in these areas leaving behind only those who lived through these changes to tell the stories of what was done to the people. The OLA-OnegShene-OLF are all linked to the Oromo Prosperity party and have been linked to multiple atrocities committed against ethnic Amharas. The OLA has also publicly declared its alliegiance with the TPLF, who as stated also had an agenda for wiping out Amharas as their main enemies. It is the very constitution that was inspired by these doctrines that has been maintained after the “change”. While the leaders names and faces have changed, the system of oppression has been preserved, the federal government is applying the same TPLF like suppression of voices, mass arrests, human rights violations etc in the name of order. The TPLF has caused massive destruction and propaganda to vilify Amharas, falsify their plight to that of the Tigrayan people who were also largely forgotten and also oppressed by the same fascist system then ethnically charged by waging a war and calling it defense, attacking Afars and Amharas while playing victim and all the while bringing pain and suffering to the people of Tigray who never deserved any of the wrath brought on by the TPLF and their associates. The OLA allegiance with TPLF is a fact, both groups have been the attackers of Amharas in various regions and the GoE’s inability to secure and protect ethnic Amharas but moreover it’s lack of recognition or empathy to the pain and suffering of these constituents is what has made Ethiopians lose faith in its intent. On hand hand it has not insistently addressed the ethnic apartheid system, it has been silent on many incidents against Amharas and been vocal about unity and sidelining of “extremists” and “tribalism” while it’s the very tribal ideology that it is now taking advantage of for political power grabs. Systemic change, justice for the wrongs committed at the highest level and candid discussions and negotiations of future policies and processes to implement would be the start. Of bringing about real change, not the few chapter brought in 2018 that reads much like the old chapter of EPRDF.

    • @mohammedmamo6177
      @mohammedmamo6177 2 роки тому

      Even Kenya will suffer the same case since kikuyus want to rule other tribes

  • @blossoming224
    @blossoming224 2 роки тому +8

    Thank you Aljezera for the reliable information!
    Keep your voice for the atrocities and state sponsored killings of innocent Amhara civilians!

  • @boson8
    @boson8 2 роки тому +2

    As opposed to the rest of Eth people who are mostly domicile, peaceful, harmonious, inclusive, humble, ....

    • @boson8
      @boson8 2 роки тому

      @Samuel Maru Thanks for the comliment Galla. But then, u read the name of the commentator and concluded that she/he is a galla. Even then, inclusion might be what is lacking from any party that thinks it knows all. The arrogant ones who are messing up the world. The civilizers, the pioneers, the blessed ones, the heroes, the shrewd manipulators, the self-righteous megalomaniacs.

  • @abulyft4502
    @abulyft4502 2 роки тому +3

    I really appreciate William for through understanding of inside in Ethiopia.

  • @ራስንመቻል
    @ራስንመቻል 2 роки тому +14

    Q: What's behind the recent ethnic violence?
    A: EGYPT
    Q: Since when?
    A: Since over 10 years ago, after the start of construction of GERD (Manage to topple TPLF/EPRDF)
    Q: What month does this happen?
    A: It always happened in June and July (the filling period for the Dam)

    • @Avaricumstudios
      @Avaricumstudios 2 роки тому +7

      Maybe if you took responsibility for internal divisions instead of looking for a for a foreign entity to blame you would be in a much better position

    • @ራስንመቻል
      @ራስንመቻል 2 роки тому +3

      @@Avaricumstudios Lol i blamed the responsible, Its the truth!! swallow it!.

    • @ሽሮእወዳለሁ
      @ሽሮእወዳለሁ 2 роки тому +3

      If that's what you took away from the discussion, I have a bridge to sell you.

    • @ራስንመቻል
      @ራስንመቻል 2 роки тому

      @@ሽሮእወዳለሁ I didn't watch the discussion.

    • @ሽሮእወዳለሁ
      @ሽሮእወዳለሁ 2 роки тому +1

      @@ራስንመቻል Then why are you commenting here?

  • @natez401
    @natez401 2 роки тому +5

    Devidson talks in line with his pay check from TpLf😝😂

  • @amanwehib8367
    @amanwehib8367 2 роки тому +1

    The number of buried is over 1500. Over a thousand tukul homes were also burned while some of the residents were inside.

  • @abdirahmanwarsama1228
    @abdirahmanwarsama1228 2 роки тому +2

    All this problems was caused by amhara dominating. Assimilate and grab land for the last century. Each regions should govern itself. Amhara want the old system. And that is a dream. No going back to amhara dominance. Amhara should go back to their region

  • @kareemkalisari
    @kareemkalisari 2 роки тому +8

    Each of us has a role to play in protecting our planet 🌎🌍🌏

  • @dd51199
    @dd51199 2 роки тому +5

    Aby Ahmed himself did the massacre.He has said several times that he wants to clear oromia from the Amhara ethnicity.

  • @IcyanzuTvRw
    @IcyanzuTvRw 2 роки тому

    Difficult for me to understand how people need to destroy their country ..no place to run now

  • @naolm2n260
    @naolm2n260 2 роки тому +6

    William I appreciate your unbiased judgement and hope more people in my county are like you

  • @zenachrema3525
    @zenachrema3525 2 роки тому +2

    This is fact Amahara genocide

  • @godana
    @godana 2 роки тому

    With all due respects, I object to the statistical misinformation about the size of Amhara population. No citation has even been given. Until the census done by the notorious Amhara hating regime of Meles Zenawi, Amharas have been the largest ethnic population in Ethiopia. Abiy's regime continued on the ethnic based givernance representing Oromo extremists. Both genicidal regimes worked hard to change the demography inside Ethiopia to misrepresent Amharas as second in population.

  • @dawitmengiste6561
    @dawitmengiste6561 2 роки тому

    Stop Amhara genocide in oromiya States sponsored like rewanda stop genocide in amhara genocide

  • @godana
    @godana 2 роки тому

    It is outrageous for Buzuneh and William not to explicitely condemn the cruelty of Oromo extremists in killing not only 1-month old victims but also unborn ones of pregnant wimen. It is not political issue, but humanitarian one for the Oromo extremists and Abiy's regime to recognize and respect human rights. They can negotiate in a civilized way their concerns but they shouldn't kill innocent Amhara children like chickens so as to achieve their political ambhitions. Who else in the world behead innocent civilians and feed on human flesh to meet political goals? Oromo officials are cimmitting the worsr crime on humanities in Ethiopia.

  • @abagudakershu9599
    @abagudakershu9599 2 роки тому

    Is this Tewodrose the brother of Dr. Tewodros of the WHO of the UN member of TPLF. Is the TPLF constitution working fine? Realy sad.

  • @mahdiali2695
    @mahdiali2695 2 роки тому

    excuse me amara are only 13 million.. amara regional gov might be 30 million but amaara only 13 million.. who gave you this numbers.. 70 of otopiya are muzlims