These EV Chargers Are Confusing... And It's Not Just Me!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @GruffSillyGoat
    @GruffSillyGoat 14 годин тому +4

    Dave, the chargers in the video (9:32) are compliant with the CPO regulations there are no requirements to display charger availability in an app; rather they are required to collate aggregate reliability statistics and make these available on their website. The only display requirement within the regulations are the _Price Transparency_ ones, which states either displayed on the charger *or* via an app/separate device; as long as the app is accessible without a contract being required to access it. An app can lag or even not display anything if the charger displays the current pricing details on the terminal screen. This is a usability consideration rather than a regulatory one.

  • @timoliver8940
    @timoliver8940 20 годин тому +15

    I use my Electroverse card for Ionity and have never had any money reserved on my account doing it that way.

    • @Un-Apologetic
      @Un-Apologetic 19 годин тому

      Do you find it cheaper as I'm an Octopus customer and I've tried it at a few local chargers and both times the price on the Electroverse app was more expensive than the charger price. Octopus claim upto 15% cheaper ?

    • @reiniernn9071
      @reiniernn9071 19 годин тому +1

      That is because the pay guarantee comes from Electroverse....
      I use my hyundai charge card...also that ios payment once a month.
      Reservation will be used if you pay with any crdit of bamk card.

    • @Sean-uk4tf
      @Sean-uk4tf 3 години тому

      Same with my renault charge pass. I get 46p per kwh. I find ionity really good on the move, but none in my home area. 🐙 Does do cheaper, but you have to check if the charger doesn't have discounts available on their own app first

    • @CW-om2qq
      @CW-om2qq 3 години тому

      It also depends whether your Electroverse account is linked to your credit card or your energy account. If it's a credit card then a pre-auth happens automatically, but it's cleared as soon as the payment is made. That can be rapid, so you don't see any pre-auth.

  • @robinallen7356
    @robinallen7356 15 годин тому +4

    You MISSED one of the best features of the Ionity lights! Down the front of each charger there's a glowing white line. That line shows at a glance how charged each car is. So you can easily see which car has just started charging vs which car is at 90% and about to leave.

    • @mjcamp01
      @mjcamp01 14 годин тому

      Good info, thanks

  • @robinallen7356
    @robinallen7356 15 годин тому +4

    I get that you are saying you are confused, but you are confused by having MORE information. Just imagine they didn't have purple and white lights on the top - then would you be able to figure out which are occupied just by looking at the cars parked in the bays? Even if the lights aren't always showing the correct status, they're a pretty good indication of which bays to aim for, that you can see all the way from the other side of the car park. So even if they aren't perfect all the time (and I agree they do often get stuck) it's still better than not having them.

  • @mjcamp01
    @mjcamp01 14 годин тому +4

    £40 preauth also gives a lot of perspective to the home charging, which most cars would even from empty struggle to get to £7 on a cheap tariff

    • @CW-om2qq
      @CW-om2qq 2 години тому

      But you're not getting DC rapid charging from an expensive charger at peak time when you charge at home on AC.

  • @RichardBacon-h5x
    @RichardBacon-h5x 20 годин тому +6

    One for you to follow up Dave, if FastNed can allow you to register your car and plug and charge like Teslas at Tesla sites, then why can't the other charger companies do the same and avoid all this messing around selecting chargers and payment options. I've registered my MG4 with FastNed and used their plug and charge and it works just fine.

    • @djtaylorutube
      @djtaylorutube 18 годин тому +3

      Because they just don't care and that's the world of disparate charging companies with no affiliation with vehicle manufacturers.
      Manufacturers don't care because charging is an owner problem after purchase.

    • @michaeldawson6309
      @michaeldawson6309 16 годин тому

      Yes this has to be the future plug n play no faffing with apps or convoluted hidden payment methods.

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 16 годин тому +4

      Plug & Charge is part of the CCS protocol, which is what Tesla use behind the scenes. Other operators are rolling it out but it takes both the car and the charger to support the handshake, the car provides a digital certificate to prove it is who it is and provides details of the payment service to use. Tesla default the payment service to themselves, not sure if the UI allows this to be changed.
      Ionity and Electroverse offer Plug & Charge on a range of vehicles that support it. Other CPOs are considering it as payment roaming is mandated in the new CPO regulations but the CPO's have two years to implement it.
      Fastned, with their Autocharge, do something a little different the car doesn't provide certificates or payment service details just it's VIN in the normal charging session setup data exchange with the charger. They then lookup the saved payment details on their database and charge using this information. This is similar to how apps process payments. The concern is security of this approach as to whether any device becomes available to spoof the VIN details.

    • @RichardBacon-h5x
      @RichardBacon-h5x 14 годин тому

      ​@djtaylorutube thanks that was really interesting 👍

    • @zaranohare1768
      @zaranohare1768 12 годин тому

      I use fastned at haydock and tesla in flint and Trafford centre, no charger anxiety with these, all the rest then I start sweating, I whish they would all get there act together, there's lots of chargers about but we should be able to trust them, also I do try not to use them cos most are priced ridiculously, the cheaper ones mean I can get a free lunch lol 😊

  • @johndoyle4723
    @johndoyle4723 18 годин тому +1

    I have used Ionity plenty of times, always had a good fast but expensive experience. Some Instavolt also have lights on the top.
    Yes, they are all a bit confusing at first.

  • @theyjustwantyourmoney4539
    @theyjustwantyourmoney4539 Годину тому

    I’ve also noticed several times 2 chargers of the same company with the same kilo watt output for the same charging time with a massive difference in price, I mean more than double such that I now know a particular charger that is so expensive that many drivers avoid it and would rather wait for the cheaper one to be vacant.

  • @markrozee
    @markrozee 16 годин тому +2

    I wish the lights were ROYGBIV , just to annoy the Daily Mail🎉

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 16 годин тому

      @@markrozee - That or the colour matches the pink or blue depending upon which coloured new Jag turns up.

    • @rugbygirlsdadg
      @rugbygirlsdadg 45 хвилин тому

      Or LGBTQ (lilac, green, blue, turquoise, quartz grey - struggled with that last one 🙂)

  • @fenegroni
    @fenegroni 20 годин тому

    Good to call out Ionity.👏

  • @MrDAVIDATKIN
    @MrDAVIDATKIN 8 годин тому

    Ionity are definitely a lot easier using the app.Has always worked well for me, only ever come across one that was broken in perhaps 40 charging sesssions, that was at Cullompton.

  • @POVDrivingTour
    @POVDrivingTour 17 годин тому +3

    I use my Mini charging card with an Ionity subscription for £5.49 per month and 33p/kWh (both invoiced monthly). What I've noticed at Cobham Ionity where I charge frequently is a random guy who goes around the chargers and placing the CCS charger correctly back into its charger port, that's when the charger lights change from purple to white. EV drivers usually leave the CCS charging cable midway inside the charger port, you have to push it right in until the charger light changes colour. Or sometimes, the charge didn't stop correctly and the charger needs a reboot for a new charging session.
    Very odd though, you'd think the range would drop in line with December weather. In the past 2 weeks, I've activated preconditioning at 19 degrees in the lowest setting for 10 mins. Even in 50mph wind, the range stayed the same! Departed from my house in West London with 100% SoC / 99 miles and arrived in Dorking, Surrey with 80% SoC / 65 miles. But then I do a lot of hill driving for the next 2 hours and the range is at 50% SoC, meaning I don't need to use a public charger to get home. And when I do arrive home, I've got 30% SoC which is just incredible for this time of year. Tyre pressure set to 2.5 bars all around, driving in sport mode throughout, sometimes 50-70mph where appropriate but mainly 30mph.
    So far this month, I've spent £20 charging at home and have driven 1,250 miles! 7p/kWh overnight charging with Octopus Intelligent. If I desperately need a charge during the day, I use the Tesla superchargers in Box Hill, Surrey at 40p/kWh (usually 20-25kW required, £8-£10).
    Lastly, I've noticed that when preconditioning the car in cool/heat for 10 mins, the rapid acceleration in sport mode is 10x more rapid, actually frighteningly fast, you can certainly feel the car pulling and it doesn't stop until reaching 70mph from 0mph! I'm looking to get a 2nd Mini electric (gen 3) to convert to a JCW LCI2 and do some crazy stuff with it. Maybe tune the battery to make it go even faster or longer, who knows ;)

  • @sargfowler9603
    @sargfowler9603 19 годин тому +5

    Why aren't they covered with a roof? Getting out to charge up in the rain/snow isn't fun.

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 9 годин тому

      How owns the car park, who's responsible for putting up the canopies, whose responsibility is it to maintain and insure them, does planning permission exist to cover such? Most sites with canopies are owned/leased and operated by a CPO itself, where the canaopy was part of the planning application, rather than a sub-lease style arrangement within an existing car park.

    • @hansj5846
      @hansj5846 Годину тому +1

      Give it time.
      Just saw a new service station that doesn't sell diesel or petrol.

  • @cassopsnoxdigger614
    @cassopsnoxdigger614 19 годин тому +1

    well done Dave..another very good job...keep it up m8, these must be the first version of IONITY'S chargers... the ionity chargers that i use are simple.

    • @Sean-uk4tf
      @Sean-uk4tf 3 години тому

      I agree. Never seen the central card reader before.

  • @jonfb1683
    @jonfb1683 17 годин тому

    I don’t fancy faffing around with that contactless terminal in the rain! One of the problems with different charging companies is that the process for charging is slightly different. You have to read the instructions to find the correct order of doing things. And different coloured lights or bays for different companies add to the confusion, especially if your colour blind! I would like to see colours and text to make it clear which charges are available and which are out of order. And some covers would be nice!

  • @ByronSipson
    @ByronSipson 14 годин тому +1

    I hope it gets better I went on a road trip from Grimsby to Windermere and needed to charge and what a mere slapping it down with rain dark cold no cover no lighting having to download yet another app get it sorted for gods sake you go to a petrol station your under cover it’s light use your card fill up done !

    • @solentbum
      @solentbum 2 години тому

      When I first started to travel by private car I remember my Dad using a hand wound pump, in the dark and the rain, and that was when ICE cars had been around for over 50 years!. I suggest that EV chargers are at about year 25 .

    • @hansj5846
      @hansj5846 Годину тому

      Just give it time mate. EVs are an afterthought for garages but it'll change very quickly.

  • @reiniernn9071
    @reiniernn9071 19 годин тому +1

    I'm used to ionity chargers (on long trips ) in Germany and Poland.
    Those light up green (available) or blue/purple when in use.
    No light if out of order. Which not often happens.
    I use a rfid card (hyunday) which works with most chargers at my journeys.
    (Ionity is owned by some carmakers from Germany AND hyundai...)
    Never tried if my banccard also would work.
    But I've seen some chargers who have printed symbols about which direct pbankcards they accept.

  • @NckBrktt
    @NckBrktt 19 годин тому +1

    Dave, it's Christmas lighting obviously. The festive season hits EV charging.
    It is becoming so you have to take your tech savvy grandchild with you in case you need to use a public charger.

  • @paulweston1106
    @paulweston1106 18 годин тому +1

    Can't say I've ever noticed the lights on the Ionity chargers. Every time I've used them there has been a queue, so I just pull into a bay when it becomes free and it's my turn. They aren't cheap but I never had any issues using them although I use the Electroverse RFID card. They are fast with my Ioniq 5 though. I have seen the 'remote' card payment terminal cause some confusion though.

  • @rtfazeberdee3519
    @rtfazeberdee3519 4 години тому

    You should get the people responsible for the chargers (all brands) and put their feet to the fire to explain why the app isn't updated in real time and why a plugged in charger that is no longer charging is shown as available etc

    • @hansj5846
      @hansj5846 Годину тому

      Why? There are no legal requirements for them to display real time information.

  • @barrymurton8988
    @barrymurton8988 18 годин тому

    It just the network updating the app and your phone, there will always be a lag. It all depends on the bandwidth etc!

  • @huwjones5879
    @huwjones5879 20 годин тому +2

    It would be very interesting in situations like these if you were to give the helpline a call to see how they handled things?

    • @hansj5846
      @hansj5846 Годину тому

      Helpline for what? Everything worked although signage was lacking.

  • @MrPindie
    @MrPindie 5 годин тому

    I’ve never managed to get an Ionity charger to work even using the app and the have all my details for payment. They need to make it work like Tesla.

  • @garrycroft4215
    @garrycroft4215 17 годин тому +1

    I used to use this site ones a week with my last car BMWi3s in all my years of charging I can’t answer this question.. the i3 can only charge at 50kW and usually started at 40 something and tailed off as it filled up exactly how you would expect. Not here it would start at 50kW and flatline at 50 kW right up to 90%. Never have I had that at any other charging station.

    • @michaeldawson6309
      @michaeldawson6309 16 годин тому +1

      My i3 charges flat mostly 45kW they are so efficient even when arriving with a cold battery. BMWs seem to charge well.

  • @James-BB70
    @James-BB70 37 хвилин тому

    Do all public chargers have a pre-authorisation charge? I'm new to EV ownership and have only charged at home so far.

  • @mjcamp01
    @mjcamp01 14 годин тому

    You also missed the Red car in bay two for the second half of your video appears to not be changing, had some strange graphics, then the same out of order logo you briefly showed

  • @michaeldawson6309
    @michaeldawson6309 16 годин тому +1

    So what was the procedure at this site to pay by contactless? 1) choose a free charger on the card machine and pay £40 then walk to the charger and 2) Just plug it in?
    Or 1) plug in the free charger 2) walk to card machine to get it to start by paying?
    Not very intuitive are they.

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 15 годин тому +1

      @michaeldawson6309 - the latter, the shared payment terminal works the same as a on charger terminal. You plugin, start a charge session on the charge point, then walk and select the charger on the shared payment terminal and tap the card. If alls well the charging should start shortly afterwards. RFID is still accepted at the charger.

  • @charlesflouvat1829
    @charlesflouvat1829 17 годин тому

    The law says chargers must have contactless, it doesn't say you can't have a cash slot. When was the law passed to refuse payment with the Kings head on it?

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 16 годин тому +4

      That would be the Electronic Money Regulations 2011, and the respective Payment Service Regulations. Coin/cash has been optional for a fair while now, and not limited to chargers (Pay at Pump is the same).

  • @MichaelSmith-us9ch
    @MichaelSmith-us9ch 12 годин тому

    Pre-pay £40 ????? That is NOT Copntactless payment. May not be so bad if they reserve £40 and only charge what is actually used.

  • @stevenbarrett7648
    @stevenbarrett7648 20 годин тому

    Stopped st Cedar Court Hotel at the top of the M606 Bradford to use one of the 18 brand new V4 Tesla chargers, does this make it a giga site?. Phenomenal charging speed, just plug in and that's it!. Look like open to all as they have contactless payment screens which we Tesla driver's don't need.

  • @GeoffreyTrigg
    @GeoffreyTrigg 19 годин тому

    Charging plug not put back correctly won’t put light change through

  • @charlesflouvat1829
    @charlesflouvat1829 17 годин тому

    Could do with a cash slot

    • @djtaylorutube
      @djtaylorutube 13 годин тому +1

      @@charlesflouvat1829 How would that work? I never carry cash, no use to me. Someone would have to come and empty it, requiring constant attention and that would only drive up costs.

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 9 годин тому +1

      Call me suspicious but are you missing some sought of personal revenue stream since contactless became available?

  • @DB25k
    @DB25k 20 годин тому +2

    Brilliant video dave ,great to see you in the front line giving us the legend of the ionity light meaning. Is the ionity reboot screen using Linux code. I can see some /media/ mounted drive definitions. 😊

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 8 годин тому +1

      The logo indicates it's an ABB charger unit inside. The boot output certainly suggests possibly Linux is involved (eth0 eth1 etc.) although hard to tell these days as embedded systems/RTOS's return similar boot logs and use similar naming conventions.

  • @junehanzawa5165
    @junehanzawa5165 12 годин тому

    I hope all this contactless payment stuff is ONLY for those that don't want to use and app? But for majority, who don't mind an app, it's still possible to use the app? All this credit card stuff seems like going backwards to the 20th century. Why not just use plug and charge like Tesla has for over a decade?
    Others are joining the 21st century in America going the plug and charge route, and Norway has used it forever now.

    • @CW-om2qq
      @CW-om2qq 2 години тому

      Wait until your somewhere remote, it's cold and wet, and you need yet another app - but your phone's network isn't supported in that region. Apps are generally, poor, unreliable, and far too many if them. Credit card (or Google Pay, or Apple pay if you want your life to be on your easily snatched phone) has got to be better than all this.

  • @terrymackenzie6784
    @terrymackenzie6784 20 годин тому +3

    Do you plug in first and then pay or pay first then plug in I never worked it out but then discovered Tesla open to all that doesn't seem to mind so don't bother with anything else now

    • @Joe-lb8qn
      @Joe-lb8qn 19 годин тому +1

      AFAICS the charger manufacturers and operators conspired together to each pick one unique permutation order of pre paying, plugging in, selecting a socket type, choosing a payment method and selecting a charger.
      Get three cherries in a row and you win a free charge.

    • @robinbennett5994
      @robinbennett5994 19 годин тому +2

      It doesn't usually matter when you plug in, as none of them seem smart enough to notice which plug you used.

    • @michaeldawson6309
      @michaeldawson6309 16 годин тому +1

      @@Joe-lb8qn Bit like the early days of VHS recording. Bit of machine programming needed :-)

  • @johniooi3954
    @johniooi3954 18 годин тому

    4 Avaiable? Thats the one with the car connected & no longer charging...

  • @AndyJHiscock
    @AndyJHiscock 19 годин тому

    I was suprised Tesla chargers have an exception from the compliance regulations - Other CPOs had to modify theirs, anyone know why Tesla gets a free pass?

    • @djtaylorutube
      @djtaylorutube 18 годин тому +1

      Would you prefer they went back to Tesla only? That's an option.

    • @keithdenton8386
      @keithdenton8386 18 годин тому +2

      @@djtaylorutube Yes Yes please Tesla only.

    • @djtaylorutube
      @djtaylorutube 18 годин тому

      @keithdenton8386 😁

    • @GruffSillyGoat
      @GruffSillyGoat 14 годин тому

      The possibly didn't get a pass the regulations state the 1 year implemenation date starts from when the CPO opens up their network; which can be done by site by site. It would have been within Tesla's gift to reclass a V2/3 open-to-all charger site as Tesla-only before the 24/11/24 deadline date then subsequently re-open the site just before the deadline date (or even afterwards) to start the 1 year implementaiton clock ticking again. V4 chargers are compliant with the regulations.
      A similar 1 year implementation duration would apply after the deadline date if Tesla open up a V2.V3 charger site that has only ever been Tesla-only; it's only new build open-to-all sites that must adhere to the CPO regulations from the day they open.
      Tesla can use this mechanism as they operate three seperate networks in the UK - Tesla desitnation chargers (under 8kw, all exempted within the regulations), Tesla only superchargers (fall outside the regulations) and Tesla open to all superchargers (must adhear to the regulations but with varying implementation deadlines).

  • @Un-Apologetic
    @Un-Apologetic 20 годин тому +2

    Thanks again Dave for highlighting these eye-wateringly expensive, ridiculously unreliable chargers and APPs.
    I thank my lucky stars that I've got a diesel and a PHEV that I charge at home.
    For mass EV adoption it has to cheaper than the alternative and more convenient than the alternative.
    So far it's light years away from that.

    • @tangoadvance8393
      @tangoadvance8393 20 годин тому +1

      Have a day off you Luddite, there is nothing complicated about using an app. I used IONITY the other day. Seamless charge and got 260kwh speed. 43p per kWh.

    • @crm114.
      @crm114. 19 годин тому +4

      Looking at the SMMT data, diesel cars don’t look light years away from extinction.

    • @Un-Apologetic
      @Un-Apologetic 19 годин тому

      @crm114. You're probably right. I think diesel and petrol cars probably have only 30-40 years left.
      Diesel vans and HGV will be worldwide for an indefinite time.

    • @crm114.
      @crm114. 19 годин тому

      @@Un-ApologeticI’m hopeful that batteries will take over the bigger stuff as well. Time will tell.

    • @Nearly-Insane
      @Nearly-Insane 19 годин тому +3

      ​@crm114. I run class 1 lorries, and there is no infrastructure for Hgv charging at all in the UK. Germany has the most Hgv chargers, but most you have to drop the trailer to charge, which isn't practical. Vans unless something big happens very soon with battery range EV vans will be discontinued within 12 months I think. Most only have a range of upto 150 miles empty. Put a load in it, then roof rack and ladders and most things van drivers use and you're lucky to get 60 miles out of one.

  • @peterking2794
    @peterking2794 17 годин тому

    I've never had that problem with a petrol pump! 😀

    • @michaeldawson6309
      @michaeldawson6309 16 годин тому

      I was at a Pay at pump (ICE) recently and tried to pay with my phone wallet. ... Nope can't do that need a physical card to pre pay. So there all crap.

    • @rugbygirlsdadg
      @rugbygirlsdadg 36 хвилин тому

      ​@@michaeldawson6309and pay at pump in some cases, takes a prepayment.

  • @stum8374
    @stum8374 12 годин тому

    When i pay cash for my diesel i dont need to pre-approved 😂😂😂😂 if you dont die in an ev your in debt 😂

    • @briankavanagh7191
      @briankavanagh7191 12 годин тому +1

      some Petrol/diesel pay at pump terminals (UK) take between £99-£120 pre- authorisation charge.

  • @ComeJesusChrist
    @ComeJesusChrist 18 годин тому

    Most of these videos are about the ‘nightmare’ (not my words, but Dave’s) and daily inconvenience of EV charging, the high cost of public charging, occasionally entertaining some hopes and aspirations about the future state of affairs getting better, while the ‘EV haters’ are fairly regularly referenced, even in video titles.
    Meanwhile, these chargers are on trading estates that many of us never want to visit, they are usually without a roof and they all look so soulless, charmless and depressing. They can put as many colours and stickers on the industrial boxes, these locations are car parks and back ends to trading or industrial estates where none of you would want to be otherwise.

    • @ComeJesusChrist
      @ComeJesusChrist 12 годин тому

      David must have discovered the shadow banning or hiding feature.

  • @GibGeeks
    @GibGeeks 19 годин тому +3

    Why are you such a tesla fanboy Dave when they are crap as well as their questionable owner, do you give unbiased reporting about non Tesla services? I use IONITY and dont have any issues ever. I have a subscription with Ionity to get a reduction which makes it easier and totaly un necessary to drive anywhere near Tesla charing points!

    • @davetakesiton
      @davetakesiton  19 годин тому +7

      A Tesla EV became the best selling car in the whole world in 2023 and when I charge at a supercharger I pay less than half what Ionity charges. Nuff said?

    • @stevelongden7368
      @stevelongden7368 19 годин тому +4

      @@davetakesitonDon’t listen to the nutjobs Dave, just glad he stays away from the Superchargers 😂

    • @davidilm3752
      @davidilm3752 6 годин тому

      Another Elon hater by any chance?😂